Boy with a Basket of Fruit

Last updated
Boy with a Basket of Fruit
Boy with a Basket of Fruit-Caravaggio (1593).jpg
Artist Caravaggio
Yearc. 1593
MediumOil on canvas
Dimensions70 cm× 67 cm(28 in× 26 in)
Location Galleria Borghese, Rome

Boy with a Basket of Fruit is an oil on canvas painting generally ascribed to Italian Baroque master Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, created c. 1593. It is held in the Galleria Borghese, in Rome.

Contents

Background

The painting dates from the time when Caravaggio, newly arrived in Rome from his native Milan, was making his way in the competitive Roman art world. The model was his friend and companion, the Sicilian painter Mario Minniti, at about 16 years old. The work was in the collection of Giuseppe Cesari, the Cavaliere d'Arpino, seized by Cardinal Scipione Borghese in 1607, and may therefore date to the period when Caravaggio worked for d'Arpino "painting flowers and fruits" in his workshop; but it may date from a slightly later period when Caravaggio and Minniti had left Cavalier d'Arpino's workshop (January 1594) to make their own way selling paintings through the dealer Costantino. Certainly it cannot predate 1593, the year Minniti arrived in Rome. It is believed to predate more complex works from the same period (also featuring Minniti as a model) such as The Fortune Teller and the Cardsharps (both 1594), the latter of which brought Caravaggio to the attention of his first important patron, Cardinal Francesco Maria Del Monte. Vittorio Sgarbi notes certain Murillesque portraiture qualities in the painting that could easily point to other painters in the Arpino workshop. [1]

Iconography

Art writers noted several elements of the painting as dominant, either visually or thematically. Moir, for example, notes the key role that the contrast between light and shadow plays in the composition: a window placed high on the left allows a ray of light to penetrate the room, illuminating, as it slides over the wall, the boy, the lush fruit basket, the shirt sleeve, the sensual bare shoulder, and the languid face, while the shadow, the dark mark, is provided by the hair and the projection of the basket's shadow on the wall. [2] As he writes, "the result is an emphasis on the tangibility of objects in the delicately veiled space, which confirms the visual illusion and at the same time the authenticity of the episode, which is no longer a creation of the painter's imagination but a transcription of his experience". [3] The artwork's essential theme is therefore the showing of the tactile experience of "natural things." According to Gregori, "the artwork's subject is exactly that which appears to the viewer's eye: a young seller, with a basket, full of fruit mixed with still fresh leaves, the truth of which is exalted by the marvelous brilliance of the colors". [4]

According to Bologna, Caravaggio takes all of nature—flowers, fruits, figures—as "the object of his brush," performing a wholly advanced operation: that of direct observation, the same that new scientists like Galileo "were conducting on the manifestations and structure of the natural world". [5] Hermann Fiore believes that the artist also kept in mind the Latin tradition of xenia, gifts in the form of fruits and vegetables that in Roman aristocratic houses were offered to guests. [6] Fiore stipulates that that the young man may be a contemporary personification of the god Vertumnus. [7]

Influences and context

Still life in Rome, at the time of Caravaggio's activity, grafted onto Northern European and Lombard experiences; the first significant Roman painting of the kind was Vegetables, Fruits and Flowers, attributed to the so-called Master of Hartford. It is dated to more or less post-1593 and also comes from the seizure of paintings made from Cavalier d'Arpino. Due to this provenance, some have wanted to associate this work with Caravaggio, but as diagnostic radiographic surveys have shown, it seems to be entirely foreign to him. [8] The X-rays reveal many reworkings and corrections on the drawing, a technique entirely foreign to Caravaggio.

Vincenzo Campi's The Fruit and Vegetable Seller, one of Caravaggio's potential influences. Fruit and Vegetable Seller.jpg
Vincenzo Campi's The Fruit and Vegetable Seller, one of Caravaggio's potential influences.

Other painters at the time, such as the Campi brothers or Carracci (in the latter's case, his "butcher shops" in particular) adopted a merely figurative interest for fruits and vegetables, usually in the context of depicting farmer's markets. The distinctiveness of Caravaggio's work is that he focusses his attention on the human figure associated with the displayed nature, looking with great realistic attention at individual objects and their tactile experience: consider the compactness of the apples, the roundness of the moist grape berries, the soft fleshiness of the figs, and how these features are complimented by the presentation of the titular seller. [9]

Giovanni Ambrogio Figino, Metal Plate with Peaches and Vine Leaves Giovanni Ambrogio Figino - Metal Plate with Peaches and Vine Leaves - WGA7879.jpg
Giovanni Ambrogio Figino, Metal Plate with Peaches and Vine Leaves

During his time at the workshop of Peterzano in Milan, Caravaggio would certainly have had the opportunity to see and study the works of the Cremonese Campi brothers, who show, in more than one painting, the presence of the abundance of nature in the fruit and vegetable market; for example, in Vincenzo Campi's Fruit and Vegetable Seller of 1580. [10] In the work, we see two characters: one female—the fruit seller—and one male, a helper. In front of them, an abundance of vegetables and both fresh and dried fruit. The painting has a dual function: on one hand, it shows the abundance and richness of the market, also with realistic attention; on the other, however, an erotic meaning is evident: the woman has a split pumpkin in her lap, while the man holds in his hand a bunch of leeks, which raise associations of virility. The male subject inserts a finger into his ear, which was a gesture with a sexual meaning. To complete the interpretation, in the background we can see a man on a tree who throws fruits into the lap of the woman below. It is an explicit sexual allegory in which gestures, images, and fruits have an erotic value, understandable to the audience of the time. A different use of horticultural motifs, however, has been achieved by Giovanni Ambrogio Figino in his Metal Plate with Peaches and Vine Leaves, datable to the late 1500s; similarly, the fruit presented on the painting is used to construct an allegory, but of a non-erotic quality. Rather, Figino explores theme of Vanitas, where next to vine leaves that are yellowing, the peaches seem to remain eternally ripe, maintaining a consistency that defies time and competes with the harder, indestructible material of the metal tray. Erotic symbolism and vanitas are thus already explored in these early examples of still life.

Caravaggio's Basket of Fruit. In this painting, the typical vanitas motifs of decay and passage of time are explored more explicitly than in the Boy with a Basket, through the presence of maggot holes, spots of fungus, and decay. Basket of Fruit-Caravaggio (c.1595).jpg
Caravaggio's Basket of Fruit. In this painting, the typical vanitas motifs of decay and passage of time are explored more explicitly than in the Boy with a Basket, through the presence of maggot holes, spots of fungus, and decay.

These themses can inform our reading Caravaggio's work. At first sight, he seems to be distinctly less interested the passage of time and vanitas in the Boy with a Basket of Fruit than in his other, more expressly vanitas-oriented works, such as the Basket of Fruit. Still, it could be said that the theme of decay in the Boy is explored through the reality of the objects themselves, rather than by employing expressly figurative elements, such as a skull or rotting fruit. [11] Indeed, analysts have noticed that the fruits in the boy's basket bear disorders and imperfections; the sombre atmosphere and harsh lighting underlines the fleeting youthfulness of the subject.

The erotic motifs are not foreign to the Boy with a Basket either: the young man has a languid and feminine expression, his mouth half-open, red lips, his face tilted to the left, flushed cheeks, the shoulder bare and exposed. A homoerotic reading leads to the assertion that the boy is not offering the fruit but himself; [12] the abundance and goodness of the fruits make a pendant with the erotic goodness expressed by the young man. And in this sense, the basket held close to the chest could be a symbolic indication of lust. The basket is one of the attributes of the faun and alludes to lust, like the girdle of Venus, all symbolic cryptograms of Eros. [13] But here too, the sign of time, of transience, is equally present: the fruits offered as gifts (and in this sense the young man himself) are transient, destined to end, like the yellowing leaf that bends down outside the basket.

These interpretations suggest that Caravaggio does not wholly depart from the Renaissance allegorical tradition: rather, he goes beyond it, investigating with concrete scrupulousness the forms inherent in nature. He shows their richness and extracts meaning through srupulously observing, and realistically representing the physical world.

Horticulturalist analysis

At one level the painting is a genre piece designed to demonstrate the artist's ability to depict everything from the skin of the boy to the skin of a peach, from the folds of the robe to the weave of the basket. The fruit is especially exquisite, and Professor Jules Janick of the Department of Horticulture and Landscape Architecture at Purdue University, Indiana, has analysed them from a horticulturalist's perspective: [14]

The basket ... contains a great many fruits, all in nearly perfect condition and including a bi-colored peach with a bright red blush; four clusters of grapes — two black, one red, and one "white;" a ripe pomegranate split open, disgorging its red seeds; four figs, two of them dead-ripe, black ones, both split and two light-colored; two medlars; three apples—two red, one blushed and the other striped, and one yellow with a russet basin and a scar; two branches with small pears, one of them with five yellow ones with a bright red cheek and the other, half-hidden, with small yellow, blushed fruits. There are also leaves showing various disorders: a prominent virescent grape leaf with fungal spots and another with a white insect egg mass resembling that of the oblique banded leaf roller (Choristoneura rosaceana), and peach leaves with various spots.

The analysis indicates that Caravaggio is being realistic. By capturing only what was in the fruit basket, he idealizes neither their ripeness nor their arrangement—yet almost miraculously, we are still drawn in to look at it, for the viewer it is very much a beautiful and exquisite subject.

Pop culture

The painting was an inspiration for and is referenced by the 2019 album Girl with Basket of Fruit by American experimental band Xiu Xiu. [15]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Caravaggio</span> Italian painter (1571–1610)

Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, known mononymously as Caravaggio, was an Italian painter active in Rome for most of his artistic life. During the final four years of his life, he moved between Naples, Malta, and Sicily until his death. His paintings have been characterized by art critics as combining a realistic observation of the human state, both physical and emotional, with a dramatic use of lighting, which had a formative influence on Baroque painting.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peach</span> Type of fruit tree, or its fruit

The peach is a deciduous tree first domesticated and cultivated in Zhejiang province of Eastern China. It bears edible juicy fruits with various characteristics, most called peaches and others, nectarines.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Frans Snyders</span> Flemish painter (1579–1657)

Frans Snyders or Frans Snijders was a Flemish painter of animals, hunting scenes, market scenes, and still lifes. A versatile artist, his works depict all sorts of foods, utensils, and tableware and wide assortment of animals. He was one of the earliest specialist animaliers and he is credited with initiating a wide variety of new still-life and animal subjects in Antwerp. His hunting scenes and still lifes engage the viewer with their dramatic and dynamic effects. He was a regular collaborator with leading Antwerp painters such as Peter Paul Rubens, Anthony van Dyck, Jacob Jordaens, and Abraham Janssens.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Still life</span> Type of painting

A still life is a work of art depicting mostly inanimate subject matter, typically commonplace objects which are either natural or human-made.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Caravaggisti</span> Artists who were stylistic followers of the late 16th-century Italian Baroque painter Caravaggio

The Caravaggisti were stylistic followers of the late 16th-century Italian Baroque painter Caravaggio. His influence on the new Baroque style that eventually emerged from Mannerism was profound. Caravaggio never established a workshop as most other painters did, and thus had no school to spread his techniques. Nor did he ever set out his underlying philosophical approach to art, the psychological realism which can only be deduced from his surviving work. But it can be seen directly or indirectly in the work of Rubens, Jusepe de Ribera, Bernini, and Rembrandt. Famous while he lived, Caravaggio himself was forgotten almost immediately after his death. Many of his paintings were re-ascribed to his followers, such as The Taking of Christ, which was attributed to the Dutch painter Gerrit van Honthorst until 1990.

<i>Young Sick Bacchus</i> Painting by Caravaggio

The Young Sick Bacchus, also known as the Sick Bacchus or the Self-Portrait as Bacchus, is an early self-portrait by the Baroque artist Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio, dated between 1593 and 1594. It now hangs in the Galleria Borghese in Rome. According to Caravaggio's first biographer, Giovanni Baglione, it was a cabinet piece painted by the artist using a mirror.

<i>The Lute Player</i> (Caravaggio) Painting by Caravaggio

The Lute Player is a composition by the Italian Baroque master Caravaggio. It used to exist in two versions, one in the Wildenstein Collection and another in the Hermitage Museum, St. Petersburg. A third version, which was kept for 275 years at Badminton House, Gloucestershire, came to light in 2001, and which today is understood to be the original version. The Hermitage and the Badminton House versions were exhibited together in 2020 at the Galleria Borghese.

<i>Boy Peeling Fruit</i> Painting by Caravaggio

Boy Peeling Fruit is a painting by the Italian Baroque master Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio (1571–1610) painted circa 1592–1593.

<i>Still Life with Fruit</i> (Caravaggio) Painting by Caravaggio

Still Life with Fruit on a Stone Ledge is a painting attributed to the Italian Baroque master Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio (1571–1610).

<i>Boy Bitten by a Lizard</i> Painting by Caravaggio, c. 1595

Boy Bitten by a Lizard is a painting by the Italian Baroque painter Caravaggio. It exists in two versions, both believed to be authentic works of Caravaggio, one in the Fondazione Roberto Longhi in Florence, the other in the National Gallery, London.

<i>The Cardsharps</i> Painting by Caravaggio

The Cardsharps is a painting by the Italian Baroque artist Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio. The original is generally agreed to be the work acquired by the Kimbell Art Museum in 1987, although Caravaggio may have painted more than one version.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mario Minniti</span> Italian painter

Mario Minniti was an Italian Baroque painter active in Sicily after 1606.

<i>Bacchus</i> (Caravaggio) Painting by Caravaggio

Bacchus is an oil painting by Italian Baroque master Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio (1571–1610) commissioned by Cardinal Del Monte. The painting shows a youthful Bacchus reclining in classical fashion with grapes and vine leaves in his hair, fingering the drawstring of his loosely draped robe. On a stone table in front of him is a bowl of fruit and a large carafe of red wine. He holds out a shallow goblet of the same wine, inviting the viewer to join him. The painting is currently held in the Uffizi Gallery in Florence.

<i>Basket of Fruit</i> (Caravaggio) Painting by Caravaggio

Basket of Fruit (c.1599) is a still life painting by the Italian Baroque master Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio (1571–1610), which hangs in the Biblioteca Ambrosiana, Milan.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Adriaen van Utrecht</span> Flemish painter (1599–1652)

Adriaen van Utrecht was a Flemish painter known mainly for his sumptuous banquet still lifes, game and fruit still lifes, fruit garlands, market and kitchen scenes and depictions of live poultry in farmyards. His paintings, especially the hunting and game pieces, show the influence of Frans Snyders. The two artists are considered the main inventors of the genre of the pronkstillevens, i.e. still lifes that emphasized abundance by depicting a diversity of objects, fruits, flowers and dead game, often together with living people and animals. Van Utrecht also painted a number of flower still lifes. He was a regular collaborator with leading Antwerp painters who had been pupils or assistants of Peter Paul Rubens, such as Jacob Jordaens, David Teniers the Younger, Erasmus Quellinus II, Gerard Seghers, Theodoor Rombouts, Abraham van Diepenbeeck and Thomas Willeboirts Bosschaert.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fede Galizia</span> Italian artist (c. 1578–c. 1630)

Fede Galizia, better known as Galizia, was an Italian painter of still-lifes, portraits, and religious pictures. She is especially noted as a painter of still-lifes of fruit, a genre in which she was one of the earliest practitioners in European art. She is perhaps not as well known as other female artists, such as Angelica Kauffman and Élisabeth Vigée Le Brun, because she did not have access to court-oriented or aristocratic social circles, nor had she sought the particular patronage of political rulers and noblemen.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bartolomeo Cavarozzi</span> Italian painter

Bartolomeo Cavarozzi (1587–1625), occasionally referred to as Bartolomeo Crescenzi, was an Italian caravaggisti painter of the Baroque period. Cavarozzi's work began receiving increased admiration and appreciation from art historians in the last few decades of the 20th century, emerging as one of the more distinct and original followers of Caravaggio. He received training from Giovanni Battista Crescenzi in Rome and later traveled to Spain alongside his master for a few years where he achieved some renown and was significant in spreading "Caravaggism" to Spain before returning to Italy. His surviving works are predominantly Biblical subjects and still-life paintings, although older references note he "was esteemed a good painter especially of portraits".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joris van Son</span> Flemish painter (1623–1667)

Joris van Son or Georg van Son was a Flemish still life painter who worked in a number of sub-genres but is principally known for his still lifes of fruit. He also painted flowers, banquets, vanitas still lifes and pronkstillevens. He is known to have painted fish still lifes representing the Four Elements, and also collaborated with figure artists on 'garland paintings', which typically represent a devotional image framed by a fruit or flower garland.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Italian Baroque art</span> Italian art movement

Italian Baroque art was a very prominent part of the Baroque art in painting, sculpture and other media, made in a period extending from the end of the sixteenth to the mid eighteenth centuries. The movement began in Italy, and despite later currents in the directions of classicism, the Rococo, Italy remained a stronghold throughout the period, with many Italian artists taking Baroque style to other parts of Europe. Italian Baroque architecture is not covered.

References

  1. Vittorio Sgarbi "Caravaggio", in FMR#9, 1985
  2. A. Moir, Caravaggio, New York, 1982, p. 64.
  3. A. Moir, op. cit., p. 64.
  4. M. Gregori, Caravaggio in AA.VV. Caravaggio e il suo tempo, Exhibition Catalogue New York, 1985, pp. 197-353 (p.211).
  5. Ferdinando Bologna, op. cit., p. 294.
  6. K. Hermann Fiore, Caravaggio e la quadreria del Cavalier D'Arpino, in AA.VV. La luce nella pittura Lombarda, Milan, 2000, p.27
  7. Ibid, p. 68.
  8. Anna Coliva, Le origini della natura morta a Roma, in AA. VV:, Le origini della natura morta in Italia. Caravaggio e il maestro di Hatford, Roma, 2016, Introductory Essay, pp. 1-2.
  9. R. Vodret, Caravaggio e Roma, Silvana, Milan, 2010, p. 24.
  10. AA.VV. Gli occhi di Caravaggio. La formazione, edited by Vittorio Sgarbi, Exhibition Catalogue Milan, 2011.
  11. F. Bologna, op. cit., pp. 288-89.
  12. This is the thesis of Posner, cited in Rossella Vodret, Caravaggio in Rome, cit., p. 24. D. Posner, Caravaggio's homo-erotic early works, "Art Quarterly", 1971, pp. 301-324.
  13. Maurizio Marini, op. cit., p. 373.
  14. Janick, Jules (n.d.). "Caravaggio's Fruit". Archived from the original on 2003-08-22. Retrieved 2019-03-27.
  15. "Demons, Caravaggio, and Feminism: Xiu Xiu on 'Girl with Basket of Fruit', PopMatters". www.popmatters.com. 2019-02-27. Retrieved 2024-11-15.