The British Malayan headhunting scandal of 1952 was a political scandal involving senior British politicians, military leaders, and activists, including prime minister Winston Churchill, communist publisher J.R. Campbell, general Gerald Templer, and colonial secretary Oliver Lyttelton.
The scandal was sparked by the Daily Worker's publication of photographs depicting British soldiers fighting in the Malayan Emergency posing with the severed head of suspected anti-colonial guerrillas belonging to the Malayan National Liberation Army (MNLA). [1] The images were published in the Daily Worker under the supervision of communist activist J.R. Campbell as the paper's editor. [2]
The decapitation of suspected MNLA members was subsequently found to have been a common and widespread practice by British troops in Malaya that had been sanctioned by Gerald Templer. It was also found that the British military had hired over 1,000 mercenaries from Iban headhunting tribes in Borneo to fight in Malaya with the promise they could keep the scalps of the people they killed. [3]
The British government and military initially denied that the Daily Worker's first headhunting photograph was genuine. The Daily Worker responded by publishing another photograph of the same incident and multiple eyewitness testimonies from British soldiers who witnessed British and Commonwealth troops collecting the heads and scalps of their enemies as trophies. Later they published a number of new headhunting photographs. This led to the British government's foreign secretary Oliver Lyttelton to openly confess in the House of Commons that the Daily Worker's headhunting photographed were genuine. [4]
The issue of the photographs were raised in the House of Commons multiple times, until the 21 May 1952 when the British government declared that no British troops would be punished. [5] Privately commenting on the Daily Worker photographs, the Colonial Office noted that "there is no doubt that under international law a similar case in wartime would be a war crime". [6] [7]
In response to the scandal, Prime Minister Winston Churchill (serving his second term 1951-1955) and his cabinet agreed to order British forces to stop the practice of decapitating guerrillas in Malaya. Churchill's order was widely ignored by British troops who continued to decapitate corpses. [3]
On the 21 May 1952, headhunting by British forces and their allies in Malaya was mentioned in parliament for a final time. In the House of Commons, Labour Party MP Michael Stewart asked the Minister of State for Colonial Affairs, Henry Hopkinson, if the British government intended to punish soldiers posing for photographs with decapitated human heads. Hopkinson confirmed that none of the British soldiers would be punished, claiming that said soldiers had never explicitly been forbidden from mutilating corpses. [8]
The scandal was largely ignored by British newspaper, with some historians pointing out that the Daily Worker was the only British newspaper to republish the decapitation photographs. [9]
The scandal received attention in many foreign publications. The Soviet newspaper Pravda , and the Soviet English language journal New Times, both acknowledged and commented on the headhunting scandal. Many Chinese outlets also acknoweldged British headhunting in Malaya following the Daily Worker articles, including the Shangai edition of Ta Kung Pao, the English language publication China Monthly Review, and the New China News Agency. [10]
Once it was announced that the British government had ordered British soldiers to hault the practice of headhunting, the practice was briefly mentioned in The Washington Post . The American communist newspaper the Daily Worker (not to be confused with the British newspaper of the same name which sparked the headhunting scandal), was the only newspaper in America to denounce the British military's use of headhunting in Malaya, comparing such atrocities to ones committed by the Nazis. In the weeks following the Daily Worker's leaking of headhunting images, the practice of headhunting by British troops was briefly mentioned in small print in Singapore and Malaya, in publications such as The Straits Times , Singapore Standard, and the Singapore Free Press . [11]
During the scandal, many British trade unions publicly condemned the British military and their practice of headhunting in Malaya, comparing the British military's actions to atrocities committed by the Nazis during WWII. Workers of the Thomas-Housten factory in Willesden circulated a petition denouncing British headhunting in Malaya. Similar denounciations of headhunting and other atrocities committed by the British military in Malaya came from Shoreditch Trades Council, workers at Ambrose Shardlow and Co, unionised workers in Gateshead, Southend-on-Sea, London's docklands, and branches of the Electrical Trades Union and Union of Shop, Distributive and Allied Workers. [12]
The scandal motivated trade unionist Betty Tebbs and her husband to leave the labour party and join the Communist Party of Great Britain. [12] The trade unionist, Arthur Clegg, also wrote in the Daily Worker of his disgust at the British military's practice of headhunting in Malaya, and compared anti-colonial guerrillas in Malaya to the Tolpuddle Martyrs. [13]
On the 9 June 1952, ten British military veterans gatecrashed the annual shareholders meeting of Dunlop Rubber to protest against British military atrocities in Malaya. Dunlop's board of directors were present, as well as the company director Clive Baillieu. They threw copies of the Daily Worker headhunting photographs across the room and unfurlled anti-war posters. [14]
The timeline was as follows: [15]
April 1952
May 1952
Karl Hack, a history professor and expert on the Malayan Emergency, wrote several pages on the scandal for his work The Malayan Emergency: Revolution and Counterinsurgency at the End of Empire. [16]
Erik Linstrum, a history professor and expert on media in the British Empire, used the Daily Worker headhunting scandal as a case study in his research into British media and Britain's post-WWII counterinsurgencies. [17]
Simon Harrison, a University of Ulster professor of Anthropology, approached the scandal from an anthropological viewpoint in his book Dark Trophies. [18]
Wen-Qing Ngoei, a history professor whose research focuses on anti-communism in Asia, attributed the practice of headhunting to racism and Lyttleton's public relations spin among other factors as successfully "drowning popular aversion to beheading communists with yellow faces" [19]
In 2023 a history of the scandal was published titled Head Hunters in the Malayan Emergency: The Atrocity and Cover-up. [3]
The Malayan Emergency, also known as the Anti–British National Liberation War, (1948–1960) was a guerrilla war fought in Malaya between communist pro-independence fighters of the Malayan National Liberation Army (MNLA) and the military forces of the Federation of Malaya and Commonwealth. The communists fought to win independence for Malaya from the British Empire and to establish a communist state, while the Malayan Federation and Commonwealth forces fought to combat communism and protect British economic and colonial interests. The term "Emergency" was used by the British to characterise the conflict in order to avoid referring to it as a war, because London-based insurers would not pay out in instances of civil wars.
Headhunting is the practice of hunting a human and collecting the severed head after killing the victim, although sometimes more portable body parts are taken instead as trophies. Headhunting was practiced in historic times in parts of Europe, East Asia, Oceania, Southeast Asia, South Asia, Mesoamerica, South America, West Africa, and Central Africa.
Robert Michael Maitland Stewart, Baron Stewart of Fulham, was a British Labour Party politician, life peer and Fabian Socialist who was a Member of Parliament for 34 years, and served twice as Foreign Secretary in the first cabinet of Harold Wilson.
The Sunday People is a British tabloid Sunday newspaper. It was founded as The People on 16 October 1881.
The Batang Kali massacre was the killing of 24 unarmed male civilians in Batang Kali by the British Army's Scots Guards on 12 December 1948. The massacre took place in Batang Kali, Malaya during the Malayan Emergency, a communist insurgency involving the British Commonwealth and communist guerrillas belonging to the Malayan National Liberation Army (MNLA). British author Christopher Hale described the massacre as "Britain's My Lai" in his book titled Massacre in Malaya: Exposing Britain's My Lai.
Field Marshal Sir Gerald Walter Robert Templer, was a senior British Army officer. He fought in both the world wars and took part against the Arab Resistance in Palestine. As Chief of the Imperial General Staff, the professional head of the British Army between 1955 and 1958, Templer was Prime Minister Anthony Eden's chief military adviser during the Suez Crisis. He is also credited as a founder of the United Kingdom's National Army Museum.
Randall Carline Swingler MM was an English poet, writing extensively in the 1930s in the communist interest.
Malcolm John MacDonald was a British politician and diplomat. He was initially a Labour Member of Parliament (MP), but in 1931 followed his father Ramsay MacDonald in breaking with the party and joining the National Government. He was consequently expelled from the Labour Party. He was a government minister during the Second World War and was later Governor of Kenya.
The Ibans or Sea Dayaks are an Austronesian ethnic group indigenous to northwestern Borneo. The Ibans are also known as Sea Dayaks and the title Dayak was given by the British and the Dutch to various ethnic groups in Borneo island.
Jenny Eclair is an English comedian, novelist, and actress, best known for her roles in Grumpy Old Women between 2004 and 2007 and in Loose Women in 2011 and 2012.
Charles Neal Ascherson is a Scottish journalist and writer. In his youth he fought for the British in the Malayan Emergency. He has been described by Radio Prague as "one of Britain's leading experts on central and eastern Europe". Ascherson is the author of several books on the history of Poland and Ukraine. His work has appeared in The Guardian and The New York Review of Books.
40 Commando RM is a battalion-sized formation of the British Royal Marines and subordinate unit within UK Commando Force, the principal Commando formation, under the Operational Command of Commander in Chief Fleet. Their barracks are at Norton Manor Camp, Norton Fitzwarren near Taunton in Somerset.
Henry Lennox D'Aubigne Hopkinson, 1st Baron Colyton, KCVO PC, was a British diplomat and Conservative politician.
Stanley Stephen Awbery was a British trade unionist and Labour Party politician who served as the Member of Parliament (MP) for Bristol Central from 1945 to 1964.
Clive Latham Baillieu, 1st Baron Baillieu, KBE, CMG was an Australian-British businessman, public servant, and rower.
Arthur Creech Jones was a British trade union official and politician. Originally a civil servant, his imprisonment as a conscientious objector during the First World War forced him to change careers. He was elected to Parliament in 1935 and developed a reputation for interest in colonial matters, gaining the nickname "unofficial member of the Kikuyu at Westminster". He served in the Colonial Office in the Labour government of 1945–1950. After losing his seat in the 1950 general election he was involved in writing and lecturing about British colonies, before returning to Parliament in 1954. Initially, he was known as Arthur Jones, but throughout his time in politics he invariably used his middle name.
The Working Class Movement Library (WCML) is a collection of English language books, periodicals, pamphlets, archives and artefacts, relating to the development of the political and cultural institutions of the working class created by the Industrial Revolution, in Salford, Greater Manchester, England.
Lau Yew, born Liu Chang-biao, was a prominent member of the Malayan Communist Party. He was a member of the Malayan Peoples Anti-Japanese Army (MPAJA)'s Central Military Committee during World War II.
Nepalese-British relations are the foreign relations between the Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Relations between the UK and Nepal have historically been friendly and there have been close links between the two royal families, until monarchy was abolished in Nepal. The UK is highly regarded in Nepal as a result of historical ties, development assistance and long-term support in the struggle for democracy in Nepal.
Alias Chin Peng: My Side of History (2003) is the auto-biography of Malaysian communist leader Chin Peng, the former leader of the Malayan Communist Party who led the Malayan resistance against Japan during World War II, the resistance against the British occupation of Malaya during the Malayan Emergency, and later led communist forces during the Communist insurgency in Malaysia (1968–1989).