Death of Zara Qairina Mahathir

Last updated

Death of Zara Qairina Mahathir
Date16 July 2025 (2025-07-16)
LocationTun Datu Mustapha Islamic National Secondary School, Papar District, Sabah, Malaysia
CauseDisputed, believed to be based on bullying elements
BurialKampung Kalamauh Mesapol, Sipitang District

In the early morning of 16 July 2025, Zara Qairina binti Mahathir, a form one student of Tun Datu Mustapha Islamic National Secondary School in Papar, Sabah, died after falling from the third floor of her school dormitory. Popular speculation claims that Zara was a victim of bullying at her school, but the manner of her death is disputed.

Contents

Background of the incident

At approximately 3 am on 16 July 2025, Zara Qairina was found unconscious near a drain at the girls' dormitory of Tun Datu Mustapha Islamic National Secondary School, where she studied, with no witnesses to the incident, although most of the other students were still awake. She was then sent to Queen Elizabeth Hospital the next morning, where she was put on life support due to a coma with severe injuries, including broken arms and legs. However, the next day, the hospital decided to stop her life support due to lack of brain function. She was later buried at her residence in Kampung Kalamauh Mesapol, Sipitang District. [1]

Investigations

A police report was first obtained in the morning shortly after Zara was found unconscious. The idea that bullying was involved began to be discussed on social media shortly after her death. [2] On Sunday, police received a report from the next of kin at Papar district police headquarters regarding allegations that the principal wanted to prevent the initial reporting of Zara's death, as well as an official letter to the school demanding an explanation about her death. [1] Regarding the principal, former school principal Rosnih Nasir, who is accused of being the wife of Deputy Minister of Higher Education Mustapha Sakmud, denied any connection to the incident, citing that she was only the principal from March to November of the previous year before retiring. [3] [4]

On 30 July, a post went viral on the Internet claiming that Zara's death was orchestrated by a group of bullies at her school, allegedly known as the "VVIP kids", including three students, nicknamed 'Kak Wana', 'Kak Dedeng' and 'Tomboi'. [2] [5] Various parties, including the victim's heirs, the police and the Sabah government, denied the allegations of the celebrity's involvement. [6] [7] [8]

Throughout the investigation process, as of early August, 60 people appeared as witnesses to assist the police investigation. [9] On 3 August, the victim's mother, Noraidah Lamat, filed another police report on suspicion of finding bruises on the body while preparing the body for burial, with her lawyer calling for the body to be exhumed so that a post-mortem could be conducted following the discovery. [10] The lawyers for the representatives also claimed that the police did not take the Zara clothes for forensic investigation purposes, thus contradicting normal practice in criminal investigations. [11]

On 8 August 2025, the Attorney General of Malaysia ordered that Zara Qairina's grave be exhumed so that an autopsy could be conducted to identify the main cause of Zara Qairina's death. [12] The exhumation process of the grave was carried out on 9 August 2025 and the cemetery area was tightly controlled by the police so that no untoward incident occurred. [13] In addition, the media was also seen at the location to cover it. People were also seen crowding the location of Zara Qairina's grave. [14] Prime Minister of Malaysia Anwar Ibrahim guaranteed that the investigation would be conducted transparently and fairly, and that no one would escape punishment if they were truly involved in the death of Zara Qairina. [15]

Forensic pathologist of Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Jessie Hiu, told the inquest that it was unlikely that Zara's death was caused by accidental falling or by being pushed from a standing position. [16] She also said that the hospital's chemistry department did not detect any drugs in Zara's liver based on the toxicology results. [17] However, according to the Coroner's Court of Kota Kinabalu, laboratory tests detected the presence of the anti-seizure drug, Phenytoin in Zara's kidney tissue. [18]

Trial and procedures

On 20 August 2025, five teenage girls were charged in the Kota Kinabalu Children's Court with bullying of Zara Qairina Mahathir. The accused, all minors, were charged under Section 507C(1) of the Penal Code with making threatening or insulting communications towards Zara, an offence carrying a penalty of up to one year’s imprisonment, a fine, or both. All five pleaded not guilty before Judge Elsie Primus and were released on bail of RM5,000 (US$1,200) each. A gag order was imposed under the Child Act 2001 to protect their identities. [19]

The Attorney-General's Chambers stated that the charge relates specifically to bullying and is not linked to Zara's death, which remains the subject of a separate inquest. The inquest, scheduled to begin on 3 September 2025, was ordered after public outcry over the initial police investigation, which had closed the case without a post-mortem examination. [20]

Responses

Saifuddin Abdullah, Member of Parliament for Indera Mahkota, brought the issue of Zara's death to the Malaysian Parliament, where he called for questions about the manner of Zara's death, the alleged attempt to cover up the case and influence the investigation to be answered immediately. [21] Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim insisted on the parties involved to conduct the investigation transparently, including discussing with Inspector-General of Police Mohd Khalid Ismail and Home Minister Saifuddin Nasution Ismail, to expedite the investigation. [22] The Education Ministry also urged the public to not gather in front of or boycotting the school. [23]

Former Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad expressed hope that the case of Zara Qairina could be resolved based on the "rule of law". He said that if this principle was not upheld, the situation would descend into chaos. [24]

The case caused nationwide outrage with many people demanded justice for her death and anti bullying reforms. [25] In response, several rallies and protests have occurred all over the country, including in Kedah, [26] Kelantan, [27] Kuala Lumpur, [28] Labuan, [29] Malacca, [30] Pahang, [31] Perak, [32] and Sabah. [33] [34]

Analysis

One analyst argued that public sentiment currently hinges on whether authorities demonstrate transparency and accountability in handling the case. Associate Professor Dr. Syahruddin Awang Ahmad of Universiti Malaysia Sabah told the New Straits Times that due to perceived lapses, such as the lack of an initial autopsy, the public have already eroded trust in the government and police, and he warned that failure to address these concerns could significantly impact the credibility of the current administration in voters' eyes. [35]

See also

References

  1. 1 2 "'Tak sangka itu tempatnya hela nafas terakhir.' Kronologi Zara Qairina terjatuh tingkat 3, video kongsi kelebihan tinggal di asrama runtun hati" ['Unbelievable that was the place where she took her last breath.' Chronology of Zara Qairina falling from the 3rd floor, video shares the benefits of living in a dormitory, causing netizens to be heartbroken]. SinarPlus (in Malay). 28 July 2025. Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  2. 1 2 Ang, May Vin (31 July 2025). "Chronology Of Events In The Death Of 13-Year-Old Zara Qairina At Sabah School Dorm". SAYS. Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  3. "Mustapha denies link between wife, student's death". Daily Express. 31 July 2025. Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  4. Hazzwan, Iqmal (29 July 2025). ""Saya Tak Terbabit, Sudah Bersara Ketika Insiden Berlaku" – Bekas Pengetua Sekolah" ["I Was Not Involved, I Had Retired When the Incident Occurred" – Former School Principal]. SAYS (in Malay). Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  5. "Kes Zara Qairina: 'Kak Wana, Kak Dedeng dan Tomboi' masih bersekolah di situ, tiada kaitan VIP". Sinar Harian (in Malay). 2 August 2025. Retrieved 27 August 2025.
  6. "Istana Seri Kinabalu denies viral claim linking Sabah Governor's family to Form One student's death in Papar". Malay Mail. 31 July 2025. Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  7. "Police say 'no evidence' linking minister's child to Form One Sabahan Zara Qairina's fatal fall". Malay Mail. 2 August 2025. Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  8. "Mother denies VIP link in daughter's death". The Borneo Post. 2 August 2025. Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  9. "3 schoolmates among 60 quizzed over Zara Qairina's death". FMT. 2 August 2025. Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  10. "Mother files new police report over bruising on Zara Qairina's body". The Borneo Post. 3 August 2025. Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  11. "Police failed to forensic-test Zara's clothes - lawyers". The Borneo Post. 3 August 2025. Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  12. Azmi, Hadi (8 August 2025). "Malaysia orders Zara's body to be exhumed amid protests over student's death". South China Morning Post. Retrieved 25 August 2025.
  13. "Exhumation of Zara Qairina's body completed". Sinar Daily. 9 August 2025. Retrieved 25 August 2025.
  14. "Crowd Gathers To Witness Exhumation Of Zara Qairina's Body Despite Heavy Rain". Bernama . 9 August 2025.
  15. "Zara Qairina Case: Transparent Probe, No One To Be Protected – PM Anwar". Bernama. 9 August 2025.
  16. Chan, Julia (4 September 2025). "Doctor says Zara Qairina died from fall, but stops short of calling it suicide". Malay Mail. Retrieved 5 September 2025.
  17. "Zara Qairina's death not likely from accidental fall or push, says forensic pathologist". Free Malaysia Today. 3 September 2025. Retrieved 5 September 2025.
  18. Yunus, Arfa (3 September 2025). "Anti-seizure drug detected in Zara Qairina's kidney tissue". The Star. Retrieved 5 September 2025.
  19. "Sabah student's death over alleged bullying: 5 teenage girls plead not guilty to verbally abusing Zara Qairina". CNA . 20 August 2025.
  20. Sipalan, Joseph (20 August 2025). "5 Malaysian teenagers, accused of bullying Zara, plead not guilty". South China Morning Post . Retrieved 25 August 2025.
  21. Wan Rou, Chia (30 July 2025). "'Pastikan keadilan, ketelusan kes Zara', tegas Ahli Parlimen PN" ['Ensure justice, transparency in Zara case', PN MP stresses]. FMT (in Malay). Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  22. "Anwar tekankan siasatan telus kes kematian Zara Qairina" [Anwar stresses transparent investigation into Zara Qairina's death]. The Sun (in Malay). 3 August 2025. Retrieved 4 August 2025.
  23. Harun, Nazdy (11 August 2025). "Ministry: Don't gather in front of or boycott Zara Qairina's school". New Straits Times . Retrieved 25 August 2025.
  24. "Dr Mahathir gesa kes Zara Qairina diselesaikan berdasar 'rule of law'". Astro Awani (in Malay). 16 August 2025.
  25. Chan, Julia (16 August 2025). "Papar schoolgirl Zara Qairina's death ignites nationwide outcry for justice and anti-bullying reform". Malay Mail. Retrieved 5 September 2025.
  26. "Tears, prayers, and protest: 6,000 rally for Zara Qairina in Alor Setar". The Star. 22 August 2025.
  27. Aiman, Rafiqin (16 August 2025). "Ribuan Rakyat Kelantan Berhimpun Tuntut Keadilan Terhadap Zara Qairina dan Wan Ahmad Faris". Malaysia Gazette. Retrieved 5 September 2025.
  28. Muhamad, Hasimi (16 August 2025). "Hampir 500 sertai himpunan 'Justice for Zara' di ibu negara". Astro Awani (in Malay). Retrieved 5 September 2025.
  29. "Over 3,000 take part in 'Justice for Zara' rally". The Star. 11 August 2025.
  30. Ali, Amran (17 August 2025). "Lebih 10,000 sertai himpunan 'Justice For Zara Qairina' di Melaka". Utusan Malaysia (in Malay). Retrieved 5 September 2025.
  31. Awang, Asrol (21 August 2025). "Lebih 5,000 berhimpun demi solidariti 'Justice For Zara Qairina' di Pahang". Harian Metro (in Malay). Retrieved 5 September 2025.
  32. Bidin, Ain Safre (17 August 2025). "6,000 sertai himpunan solidariti Zara Qairina di Teluk Intan". Utusan Malaysia. Retrieved 5 September 2025.
  33. "Hundreds gather in Sabah to demand justice for Zara Qairina". Free Malaysia Today. 8 August 2025.
  34. Chong, Rebecca (8 August 2025). "Thousands rally in Sandakan, Tawau demanding justice for Zara". The Star. Retrieved 5 September 2025.
  35. Miwil, Olivia (11 August 2025). "'Zara Qairina case could shake Sabah election'". New Straits Times. Retrieved 25 August 2025.