December 2010 Israeli rabbi letter controversy

Last updated

The December 2010 Israeli rabbi letter controversy was a scandal that erupted surrounding the appearance of two open letters, signed by a number of Israeli rabbis, that were discriminatory towards non-Jews in Israel. Although the letters sparked considerable outrage, evoking condemnation from prominent Israeli and American Jews and others, a poll showed that 44 percent of Israeli society supported the letters' messages. [1]

Contents

Letters

Rabbis' letter

The rabbis' letter was a psak din (religious ruling) signed by an estimated 50 rabbis, that urged Israeli landowners not to rent apartments to Arabs, or any other non-Jews. [2] The letter was initiated by the chief rabbi of Safed, Shmuel Eliyahu. [3] On January 2, 2011, Eliyahu was summoned to an Israeli police interrogation on suspicion of incitement to racism, which is a crime in Israel, [4] but he refused to answer the summons. [2] [5]

Many of the rabbis who signed the letter were municipal rabbis, state employees in charge of religious services, who receive salaries paid for by the taxpayer. Among the signers were rabbis from Rishon LeZion, Ramat HaSharon, Herzliya, Kfar Saba and Holon (suburbs of Tel Aviv); from Jerusalem; and from other towns and settlements. [6]

According to a poll conducted by the Harry S. Truman Institute for the Advancement of Peace at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, a narrow plurality of Jewish Israelis were opposed to the rabbis' call not to rent to Arabs: 48 percent opposed the statement, and 44 percent supported it. [7] [8] [9]

Rebbetzins' letter

The second letter was released on December 28, 2010, by the Lehava organization. It was signed by at least 27 rebbetzins (rabbis' wives). It urged young Jewish women to not date Arabs, and to not work at locations where non-Jews might be present. [7]

Response

Opposition

Politicians and activists

  • Benjamin Netanyahu, Prime Minister of Israel, and leader of the Likud party: On December 7, 2010, Netanyahu condemned the letter in a speech before the International Bible Contest for adults in Jerusalem. He stated: "How would we feel if we were told not to sell an apartment to Jews? We would protest, and we protest now when it is said of our neighbors"; and: "Such things cannot be said - not about Jews, and not about Arabs. They cannot be said in any democratic country, and especially not in a Jewish and democratic one. The state of Israel rejects these sayings." [10]
  • Ehud Barak, Deputy Prime Minister, Defense Minister, and leader of the Labor party: Barak stated that, "The rabbis' letters is part of a racist tidal wave threatening to sweep Israeli society into dark and dangerous zones. The Labor Party under my authority is working to draw all of Israel's citizens together, in the spirit of the Declaration of Independence." [11]
  • Reuven Rivlin, Knesset Speaker (Likud): Rivlin said to Haaretz in an interview that, "In my opinion, their statement shames the Jewish people... I see this general statement as an embarrassment to the Jewish people, and another nail in the coffin of Israeli democracy. Let me make this absolutely clear: I believe these people do the most damage to the state of Israel." He continued: "Israel can justify its faith in itself as a Jewish state only if it wields its democratic powers totally and unreservedly. This moral right will be taken from us if we prove to the world that, when it comes to democracy, we deny anything which does not suit us from a Jewish point of view." He also urged the attorney general to determine whether the letter constitutes the crime of incitement.
  • Avishay Braverman, Minorities Affairs Minister: Braverman had called for Eliyahu's ouster as early as November 18, 2010. [12] On December 12, 2010, Braverman threatened to push for his party, Labor, to quit the coalition, stating that, "There is a hatred of foreigners. The nation is turning into Iran following the rabbis' letter." [13]
  • The Association for Civil Rights in Israel demanded that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu condemn the letter (which he later did), and take disciplinary action against state-employed signatories of the letter, saying in a statement that "Rabbis who are civil servants have an obligation to the entire public, including Israel's Arab citizens. It is unthinkable that they would use their public status to promote racism and incitement." [14]

Religious organizations

  • Rabbi Aharon Lichtenstein, dean of Yeshivat Har Etzion, and a major Religious Zionist rabbinical figure: [15] Lichtenstein wrote a lengthy and erudite letter of opposition. [16]
  • Rabbis Yosef Shalom Eliashiv and Aharon Leib Shteinman, the leading Ashkenazic Haredi rabbis in Israel: Eliashiv and Steinman strongly condemned the edict. [17]
  • U.S. rabbis: Numerous American rabbis also condemned the letter. An online petition for rabbis posted by the New Israel Fund on December 10, 2010, had nearly 1000 rabbis as signatories by December 16. [18] The petition stated that "Am Yisrael (The Jewish People) know(s) the sting of discrimination, and we still bear the scars of hatred. When those who represent the official rabbinic leadership of the State of Israel express such positions, we are distressed by this Chillul HaShem (desecration of God's name)....Statements like these do great damage to our efforts to encourage people to love and support Israel. They communicate to our congregants that Israel does not share their values, and they promote feelings of alienation and distancing." Notable American rabbis who signed the petition included Conservative Rabbi Julie Schonfeld, executive vice president of the Conservative Rabbinical Assembly; Reform Rabbi David Saperstein, the director of the Religious Action Center of the Union for Reform Judaism); and Orthodox Rabbis Avi Weiss, the leader of the Hebrew Institute of Riverdale, and Marc Angel. Signatories included members of all major American Jewish denominations. A separate condemnation was issued by the Orthodox Rabbinical Council of America. [19]
  • Israeli Masorti rabbis: Roughly 50 Masorti rabbis signed a counter-letter allowing Jews to rent to non-Jews, while 40 female Israeli Reform rabbis representing the Israel Movement for Progressive Judaism issued a counter-letter proclaiming "professional and social contacts" between Jews and non-Jews to be positive, and that "Jews who are confident in their Jewish identity do not have to fear contact with people from other nations," a statement also supported by the council's 50 male Reform rabbis [20] The Reform rabbis also argued that the rebbetzins' attitude toward Israeli girls was "condescending", portrayed them as "weak", and perpetuated male chauvinism. Their counter-letter encouraged Israelis not to listen to "hate-mongers and fanatics". [21]

Others

  • A response letter was directed to the Israeli government by various Israeli academicians and artisans, criticizing the lax approach by the government to racial and religious incitement by rabbis, and calling for the prosecution of the original letter's signatories for incitement to racism. Among the signatories to the response letter were former politician Shulamit Aloni, author Yoram Kaniuk, sculptor Dani Karavan, and politicians Zehava Gal-On and Naomi Hazan. [22]
  • Holocaust survivors condemned the letter. Noah Flug, the chairman of the International Association of Holocaust Survivors, stated that, "As someone who suffered as a Jew and underwent the Holocaust, I remember the Nazis throwing Jews out of their apartments and city centres in order to create ghettos. I remember how they wrote on benches that no Jews were allowed, and, of course, it was prohibited to sell or rent to Jews. We thought that in our country, this wouldn't happen." [23]
  • Public opinion: When a poll was conducted of Jewish Israelis' reaction to the letters denouncing those who rent or sell homes to non-Jews, 48 per cent of Israeli Jews opposed the rabbis' call, while 44 per cent supported it. [1]

Support

Related Research Articles

Neturei Karta Haredi Jewish religious group that opposes Zionism

Neturei Karta is a religious group of Haredi Jews, formally created in Jerusalem, then in Mandatory Palestine, in 1938, splitting off from Agudas Yisrael. Neturei Karta opposes Zionism and calls for a "peaceful dismantling" of the State of Israel, in the belief that Jews are forbidden to have their own state until the coming of the Jewish Messiah and that the state of Israel is a rebellion against God. While the Neturei Karta describe themselves as true traditional Jews, the more secular US-based Jewish Anti-Defamation League has described them as "the farthest fringes of Judaism".

Shas is a Haredi religious political party in Israel. Founded in 1984 under the leadership of Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, a former Israeli Sephardi chief rabbi, who remained its spiritual leader until his death in October 2013, it primarily represents the interests of Sephardic and Mizrahi Haredi Jews. The party works to end prejudice and discrimination against the Sephardic and Mizrahi community, and highlights economic issues and social justice.

Ovadia Yosef Talmudic scholar, posek and Sephardi Chief Rabbi of Israel from 1973 to 1983

Ovadia Yosef was an Iraqi-born Talmudic scholar, a posek, the Sephardi Chief Rabbi of Israel from 1973 to 1983, and a founder and long-time spiritual leader of Israel's ultra-Orthodox Shas party. Yosef's responsa were highly regarded within Haredi circles, particularly among Mizrahi communities, among whom he was regarded as "the most important living halakhic authority". He was however condemned for making numerous offensive statements about his opponents which made him a controversial figure in his later years.

Mordechai Eliyahu Israeli rabbi, posek, and spiritual leader (1929–2010)

Mordechai Tzemach Eliyahu, was an Israeli rabbi, posek, and spiritual leader.

Reuven Rivlin President of Israel

Reuven "Ruvi" Rivlin is an Israeli politician and lawyer who served as the tenth president of Israel between 2014 and 2021. He is a member of the Likud party. Rivlin was Minister of Communications from 2001 to 2003, and subsequently served as Speaker of the Knesset from 2003 to 2006 and 2009 to 2013. On 10 June 2014, he was elected President of Israel. His term ended on 7 July 2021.

Chaim Kanievsky Haredi rabbi and leader in Israel (1928–2022)

Shmaryahu Yosef Chaim Kanievsky was an Israeli Haredi rabbi and posek. He was a leading authority in Haredi Jewish society on legal and ethical practice. Known as the "Prince of Torah", much of his prominence came through Torah education and advice about Jewish law.

The Tal Committee was an Israeli public committee appointed on 22 August 1999 which dealt with the special exemption from mandatory military service in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) given to Israeli ultra-Orthodox Jews which had been the status quo from the time of Ben Gurion, as well as extending mandatory military service to Israeli-Arabs. The committee was appointed by Prime Minister Ehud Barak and was initially headed by former Supreme Court Justice Tzvi Tal. The committee was later headed by Yohanan Plesner before its official dissolution on 2 July 2012, two days before submitting its report, hence the term Plesner Committee.

Eliyahu Bakshi-Doron Israeli rabbi

Eliyahu Bakshi-Doron was an Israeli rabbi who served as Rishon LeZion from 1993 to 2003. Prior to that he served as Sephardi Chief Rabbi of Bat Yam and Sephardi Chief Rabbi of Haifa.

Shlomo Aviner Israeli Orthodox rabbi, born in France

Rabbi Shlomo Chaim Hacohen Aviner is an Israeli Orthodox rabbi, born in France. He is the rosh yeshiva of the Ateret Yerushalayim yeshiva in Jerusalem, and the rabbi of the Israeli settlement Bet El. He is considered one of the spiritual leaders of the Religious Zionist movement.

Mordechai Elon Israeli Religious Zionist rabbi

Mordechai (Moti) Elon is an Israeli Religious Zionist rabbi. He has headed several Orthodox Jewish social organizations and institutions, most notably as Rosh Yeshiva of Yeshivat HaKotel in the Jewish Quarter of Jerusalem from 2002 to 2006. He has also hosted television and radio shows.

Tuba-Zangariyye Local council

Tuba-Zangariyye or Tuba az-Zanghariyya is a Bedouin town in the Northern District of Israel. Located in the Korazim Plateau, it achieved local council status in 1988. It was formed by the merger of two villages, Tuba and az-Zangariyye. Populated by the Bedouin tribe of El Heib, Tuba is situated near Kfar Hanassi, overlooking the Jordan River, and sits 250 meters above sea level. In 2019 it had a population of 6,776.

Shmuel Eliyahu

Shmuel Eliyahu is an Israeli Orthodox rabbi. He is the Chief Rabbi of Safed and a member of the Chief Rabbinate Council.

Dov Lior Israeli Orthodox rabbi (born 1933)

Rabbi Dov Lior is an Israeli Orthodox rabbi, who served as the Chief Rabbi of Hebron and Kiryat Arba in the southern West Bank until late 2014. He is also the rosh yeshiva of the Kiryat Arba Hesder Yeshiva, and also heads the "Council of Rabbis of Judea and Samaria".

Yitzhak Yosef Sephardi Chief Rabbi of Israel

Yitzhak Yosef is the Sephardi Chief Rabbi of Israel, the rosh yeshiva of Yeshivat Hazon Ovadia, and the author of a set of books on halakha called Yalkut Yosef.

Racism in Israel encompasses all forms and manifestations of racism experienced in Israel, irrespective of the colour or creed of the perpetrator and victim, or their citizenship, residency, or visitor status.

Lehava Jewish far-right organization in Israel

Lehava is a far-right and Jewish supremacist organization based in Israel that strictly opposes Jewish assimilation, objecting to most personal relationships between Jews and non-Jews. It is opposed to the Christian presence in Israel. It has an anti-miscegenation focus, denouncing marriages between Jews and non-Jews forbidden by Orthodox Jewish law.

Price tag attack policy Attacks and acts of vandalism committed by Jewish fundamentalist Israeli settler youths

The price tag attack policy, also sometimes referred to as "mutual responsibility", is the name originally given to the attacks and acts of vandalism committed primarily in the occupied West Bank by Israeli Jewish fundamentalist settler youths against Palestinian Arabs, left-wing Israeli Jews, Israeli Arabs, Christians, and Israeli security forces. The youths officially claim that the acts are committed to "exact a price from local Palestinians or from the Israeli security forces for any action taken against their settlement enterprise".

Bentzi Gopstein

Ben-Zion "Bentzi" Gophstein is a political activist affiliated with the radical right in Israel, a student of Meir Kahane, and founder and director of Lehava, an Israeli Jewish anti-assimilation organization. He was a member of the Council of Kiryat Arba, 2010-2013. In November 2019, he was indicted on charges of incitement to terrorism, violence and racism.

Shimon Baadani

Shimon Baadani, also spelled Shimon Ba'adani, is a leading Sephardi rabbi and rosh kollel in Israel. He is the co-founder and dean of Kollel Torah V'Chaim in Bnei Brak, and serves as president of dozens of Torah institutions. He is also a senior leader of the Shas political party and a member of that party's Moetzet Chachmei HaTorah rabbinical leadership council.

Bezalel Smotrich Israeli politician

Bezalel Yoel Smotrich is an Israeli lawyer and politician. The leader of the Religious Zionist Party, he previously served as a Knesset member for Yamina. He is the co-founder of the NGO Regavim, an organization that monitors and pursues legal action in the Israeli court system against constructions undertaken by Palestinians, Bedouins, and other Arabs in Israel and the West Bank without Israeli permits.

References

  1. 1 2 Mark Weiss (29 December 2010). "Rabbis' wives call on Jews not to date Arabs". The Telegraph .
  2. 1 2 Marcy Oster (3 January 2011). "Safed rabbi refuses police summons over anti-Arab letter". Jewish Telegraphic Agency.
  3. ↑ Kobi Nahshoni (3 January 2011). "Druckman: It's a rabbi's duty to voice opinions". Ynetnews.
  4. 1 2 Kobi Nahshoni (2 January 2011). "Safed rabbi interrogated on incitement charges". Ynetnews.
  5. ↑ Kobi Nahshoni (31 December 2010). "Safed Rabbi fails to answer investigation summons". Ynetnews.
  6. ↑ noam (7 December 2010). "50 Israeli Rabbis issue ruling forbidding renting of homes to Arabs". Promised Land.
  7. 1 2 Levinson, Chaim. (2010-11-19) "Rabbis' wives urge Israeli women: Stay away from Arab men" Haaretz . Retrieved on 2011-01-06.
  8. ↑ "Rebbetzins: Women, stay away from Arab men". The Jerusalem Post . 28 December 2010. Retrieved 2011-01-06.
  9. ↑ Asaf Shtull-Trauring (28 December 2010). "Report: 44% of Israeli Jews Support Rabbis' Edict Forbidding Rentals to Arabs in Safed". Haaretz. Retrieved 2011-01-06.
  10. ↑ Barak Ravid; Chaim Levinson (7 December 2010). "Netanyahu Slams Top Rabbis' Call to Forbid Renting Homes to Arabs". Haaretz.
  11. ↑ Attila Somfalvi (29 December 2010). "Barak: Rabbis', wives' letters part of racist tidal wave". Ynetnews.
  12. ↑ Jonah Mandel (18 November 2010). "Braverman calls to oust Safed rabbi for racial incitement". The Jerusalem Post .
  13. ↑ Attila Somfalvi (22 December 2010). "Minister Braverman threatens to quit, says Israel turning into Iran". Ynetnews.
  14. ↑ Sherwood, Harriet (December 7, 2010). "Dozens of Israeli rabbis back call to forbid sale of property to Arabs". The Guardian . London.
  15. ↑ Jeffrey Goldberg (14 December 2010). "A Bit of Good News on the Don't-Sell-to-the Arabs Controversy". The Atlantic .
  16. ↑ Rabbi Aharon Lichtenstein (14 December 2010). "Rabbi Aharon Lichtenstein's Response to the Letter Banning Sale of Homes to Gentiles in Israel". Kol HaRav - Rabbinic Voices.
  17. ↑ Yair Ettinger; Tomer Zarchin (10 December 2010). "Leading Rabbi Denounces Colleagues' Edict Against Renting Homes to non-Jews". Haaretz .
  18. ↑ Naomi Paiss (16 December 2010). "Nearly 1000 of World's Rabbis Urge Israeli Colleagues to Reject Racist Religious Ruling" (Press release). New Israel Fund.
  19. ↑ Josh Nathan-Kazis (15 December 2010). "U.S. Rabbis Offer Rare Rebuke of Israeli Edict". The Forward .
  20. ↑ Marcy Oster (30 December 2010). "Female Israeli Reform rabbis speak out in favor of contact with Arabs". Jewish Telegraphic Agency.
  21. ↑ Nashoni, Kobi (December 30, 2010). "Women Reform rabbis: Stop the hatred". Israel Jewish Scene. Retrieved December 31, 2010.
  22. ↑ Yair Altman (2 January 2011). "Intellectuals: Firing racist rabbis not enough". Ynetnews.
  23. ↑ Blomfield, Adrian (December 31, 2010). "Holocaust survivors warn of stirrings of neo-fascism". The Daily Telegraph . London.
  24. ↑ Gil Ronen (12 December 2010). "Bill Would Grant Rabbis Immunity Regarding Freedom of Speech". Arutz Sheva.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.