Feminine essence concept of transsexuality

Last updated

In Blanchard's transsexualism typology, Blanchard uses the concept of feminine essence theory to refer to what he describes as a proposal that trans women are females trapped in male bodies; according to Blanchard, the feminine essence idea has been described under several names, and there is no authoritative, widely accepted definition. [1] The term has also been used by sexologist J. Michael Bailey; in a review of Bailey's book The Man Who Would Be Queen, which discusses Blanchard's theories, Alice Dreger described it as the feminine essence narrative. [2]

Contents

Bailey also discusses the concept in a paper titled "What many transgender activists don't want you to know: And why you should know it anyway", where he says that "the predominant cultural understanding of male-to-female transsexualism is that all male-to-female (MtF) transsexuals are, essentially, women trapped in men's bodies"; rejecting the idea, Bailey describes it as "damaging to science and to many transsexuals." [3] Bailey also says that the idea is associated with, but separate from the brainsex theory of transsexualism, which is a belief about a neurodevelopmental cause of transsexualism. [3]

Blanchard's Description

In 2008, Ray Blanchard presented the idea in the form of a theory in a commentary entitled "Deconstructing the Feminine Essence Narrative" in which he lists what he considers to be "the central tenets of the feminine essence theory", and then refutes each of these tenets: [1]

  1. Male-to-female transsexuals are, in some literal sense and not just in a figurative sense, women inside men's bodies.
  2. There is only one type of woman, therefore there can be only one type of (true) male-to-female transsexual.
  3. Apparent differences among male-to-female transsexuals are relatively superficial and irrelevant to the basic unity of the transsexual syndrome.
  4. Male-to-female transsexuals have no unique, behavioral or psychological characteristics that are absent in typical men and women.

Blanchard considers the term to be inconsistent with his research findings, having reported finding that there are two, and not one, types of male-to-female transsexual and that they differ with regard to their sexual interests, whether they were overtly gender atypical in childhood, how easily they pass as female, the ages at which they decide to transition to female, birth order, and their physical height and weight. [4] He also says he has found that the groups differ in how well they respond to sex reassignment and how likely they are to regret having transitioned. [5]

Bailey's Description

In his book The Man Who Would Be Queen , a book on Blanchard's theories, sexologist J. Michael Bailey characterizes these statements as a prototypical example of the feminine essence narrative: "Since I can remember, I have always felt as if I were a member of the other sex. I have felt like a freak with this body and detest my penis. I must get sex reassignment surgery (a "sex change operation") in order to match my external body with my internal mind." [2]

In a paper titled "What many transgender activists don't want you to know: And why you should know it anyway", Bailey says that one of the predictions based on the feminine essence theory is that male-to-female transsexuals would possess female rather than male brain anatomy. [3]

See also

Related Research Articles

Gender identity is the personal sense of one's own gender. Gender identity can correlate with a person's assigned sex or can differ from it. In most individuals, the various biological determinants of sex are congruent, and consistent with the individual's gender identity. Gender expression typically reflects a person's gender identity, but this is not always the case. While a person may express behaviors, attitudes, and appearances consistent with a particular gender role, such expression may not necessarily reflect their gender identity. The term gender identity was coined by psychiatry professor Robert J. Stoller in 1964 and popularized by the controversial psychologist John Money.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Money</span> New Zealand psychologist and sexologist (1921–2006)

John William Money was a New Zealand American psychologist, sexologist and professor at Johns Hopkins University known for his research on human sexual behavior and gender. Believing that gender identity was malleable within the first two years of life, Money advocated for the surgical "normalization" of the genitalia of intersex infants.

The following outline is provided as an overview of and topical guide to transgender topics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">J. Michael Bailey</span> American psychologist (born 1957)

John Michael Bailey is an American psychologist, behavioral geneticist, and professor at Northwestern University best known for his work on the etiology of sexual orientation and paraphilia. He maintains that male sexual orientation is most likely established in utero.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard Green (sexologist)</span> American psychiatrist and sexologist (1936–2019)

Richard Green was an American-British sexologist, psychiatrist, lawyer, and author known for his research on homosexuality and transsexualism, specifically gender identity disorder in children. He is known for his behaviorism experiment in which he attempted to prevent male homosexuality and transsexuality by extinguishing feminine behavior in young boys. He later came to favor biological explanations for male homosexuality.

<i>The Man Who Would Be Queen</i> 2003 book by J. Michael Bailey

The Man Who Would Be Queen: The Science of Gender-Bending and Transsexualism is a 2003 book by the American psychologist J. Michael Bailey, published by Joseph Henry Press.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Androphilia and gynephilia</span> Sexual orientation to men or women

Androphilia and gynephilia are terms used in behavioral science to describe sexual orientation, as an alternative to a gender binary homosexual and heterosexual conceptualization. Androphilia describes sexual attraction to men and/or masculinity; gynephilia describes the sexual attraction to women and/or femininity. Ambiphilia describes the combination of both androphilia and gynephilia in a given individual, or bisexuality.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ray Blanchard</span> American-Canadian sexologist

Ray Milton Blanchard is an American-Canadian sexologist who researches pedophilia, sexual orientation and gender identity. He has found that men with more older brothers are more likely to be gay than men with fewer older brothers, a phenomenon he attributes to the reaction of the mother's immune system to male fetuses. Blanchard has also published research studies on phallometry and several paraphilias, including autoerotic asphyxia. Blanchard also proposed a typology of transsexualism.

American-Canadian sexologist Ray Blanchard proposed a psychological typology of gender dysphoria, transsexualism, and fetishistic transvestism in a series of academic papers through the 1980s and 1990s. Building on the work of earlier researchers, including his colleague Kurt Freund, Blanchard categorized trans women into two groups: homosexual transsexuals who are attracted exclusively to men and are feminine in both behavior and appearance; and autogynephilic transsexuals who experience sexual arousal at the idea of having a female body (autogynephilia). Blanchard and his supporters argue that the typology explains differences between the two groups in childhood gender nonconformity, sexual orientation, history of sexual fetishism, and age of transition.

Gender incongruence is the state of having a gender identity that does not correspond to one's sex assigned at birth. This is experienced by people who identify as transgender or transsexual, and often results in gender dysphoria. The causes of gender incongruence have been studied for decades.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transgender sexuality</span> Sexuality of transgender people

Sexuality in transgender individuals encompasses all the issues of sexuality of other groups, including establishing a sexual identity, learning to deal with one's sexual needs, and finding a partner, but may be complicated by issues of gender dysphoria, side effects of surgery, physiological and emotional effects of hormone replacement therapy, psychological aspects of expressing sexuality after medical transition, or social aspects of expressing their gender.

The classification of transsexual and gender non-conforming people into distinct groups has been attempted since the mid-1960s.

David Oliver Cauldwell was a prolific and pioneering sexologist, who coined the term transsexual as used in its current definition. Many of his monographs on sex, psychology, or health were published by Emanuel Haldeman-Julius in such forms as Big Blue Books. He was the editor of Sexology magazine's question and answer department. Cauldwell and Harry Benjamin were "two early and important American voices on transsexuality".

Ira Basil Pauly is an American psychiatrist who was an All American college football player at UCLA, and is known for his influential work on transsexualism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Transsexual</span> People experiencing a gender identity inconsistent with their assigned sex

Transsexual people experience a gender identity that is inconsistent with their assigned sex, and desire to permanently transition to the sex or gender with which they identify, usually seeking medical assistance to help them align their body with their identified sex or gender.

Erotic target location error (ETLE) is a hypothesized dimension for paraphilias, defined by having a sexual preference or strong sexual interest in features that are somewhere other than on one's sexual partners. When one's sexual arousal is based on imagining oneself in another physical form (such as an animal, an infant, or an amputee) the erotic target is said to be one's self, or erotic target identity inversion (ETII).

Anne Alexandra Lawrence is an American psychologist, sexologist, and former anesthesiologist who has published extensively on gender incongruence. Anne transitioned male to female in her 40s.

"The Empire Strikes Back: A Posttranssexual Manifesto" is a 1987 essay written by Sandy Stone. Stone's essay is considered to be the founding text of transgender studies in academia, with other critical transgender works emerging after it. The essay examines how transgender women have historically been viewed, studied, and treated by the western medical establishment.

<i>The Transsexual Phenomenon</i>

The Transsexual Phenomenon is a medical textbook published by American endocrinologist and sexologist Harry Benjamin in 1966 with The Julian Press. The text is notable for its examination of transsexualism not as a psychological issue, but rather as a somatic disorder that should be treated through medicine. Benjamin argues that transvestism and transsexuality are a spectrum of conditions, requiring different treatments that ranged from hormone replacement therapy to surgical intervention.

<i>Transsexualism and Sex Reassignment</i> Book on transgenderism

Transsexualism and Sex Reassignment is a book on gender dysphoria which was edited by sexologists Richard Green and John Money and was published by Johns Hopkins University Press in 1969. It was the first medical textbook to be published on transgender people. The book contained a chapter on hormone replacement therapy written by Christian Hamburger and included an appendix with additional treatment suggestions and guidelines by Harry Benjamin.

References

  1. 1 2 Blanchard R (June 2008). "Deconstructing the feminine essence narrative". Arch Sex Behav. 37 (3): 434–8, discussion 505–10. doi:10.1007/s10508-008-9328-y. PMID   18431630. S2CID   43303779.
  2. 1 2 Dreger AD (June 2008). "The Controversy Surrounding The Man Who Would Be Queen: A Case History of the Politics of Science, Identity, and Sex in the Internet Age". Arch Sex Behav. 37 (3): 366–421. doi:10.1007/s10508-007-9301-1. PMC   3170124 . PMID   18431641.
  3. 1 2 3 Bailey J. M.; Triea K. (2007). "What many transgender activists don't want you to know: And why you should know it anyway". Perspectives in Biology and Medicine. 50 (4): 521–534. doi:10.1353/pbm.2007.0041. PMID   17951886. S2CID   40120167.
  4. Blanchard, R., & Steiner, B. W. (1990). Clinical management of gender identity disorders in children and adults. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press. ISBN   0-88048-187-0
  5. Blanchard R.; Steiner B. W.; Clemmensen L. H.; Dickey R. (1989). "Prediction of regrets in postoperative transsexuals". Canadian Journal of Psychiatry. 34 (1): 43–45. doi:10.1177/070674378903400111. PMID   2924248. S2CID   23436826.