Fragment of a Crucifixion

Last updated

Fragment of a Crucifixion
Fragment of a Crucifixion.jpg
Artist Francis Bacon
Year1950
TypeOil and cotton wool on canvas [1]
Dimensions140 cm× 108.5 cm(55 in× 42.7 in)
Location Stedelijk Van Abbemuseum, Eindhoven

Fragment of a Crucifixion is an unfinished 1950 painting by the Irish-born figurative painter Francis Bacon. It shows two animals engaged in an existential struggle; the upper figure, which may be a dog or a cat, crouches over a chimera and is at the point of kill. It stoops on the horizontal beam of a T-shaped structure, which may signify Christ's cross. The painting contains thinly sketched passer-by figures, who appear as if oblivious to the central drama.

Contents

Typical of Bacon's work, the painting is drawn from a wide variety of sources, including the screaming mouth of the nurse in Sergei Eisenstein's 1925 film Battleship Potemkin and iconography from both the Crucifixion of Jesus and the descent from the cross. The chimera's despair forms the centrepiece of the work; its agony can be compared to Bacon's later works focusing on the motif of an open mouth.

Although the title has religious connotations, Bacon's personal outlook was bleak; as an atheist, he did not believe in either divine intervention nor an afterlife. As such, the work seems to represent a nihilistic and hopeless view of the human condition. He later dismissed the painting, considering it too literal and explicit. He abandoned the theme of the crucifixion for the following 12 years, not returning to it until the more loosely based, but equally bleak, triptych Three Studies for a Crucifixion . The painting is housed in the Stedelijk Van Abbemuseum in Eindhoven, Netherlands.

Description

The upper creature may be a dog or a cat. Blood pours out of its mouth onto the head and body of its prey, a chimera rendered as owl-like with human facial characteristics. The prey unsuccessfully struggles to flee from its captor. The lower figure's human aspect is most notable in the details of its mouth and genitalia. [2] Both figures are positioned in the centre foreground of the canvas, and are each mutilated and covered in blood, their physical discomfort contrasted against the flat, neutral background typical of Bacon's paintings. The figures exhibit many elements found in his early work, noticeably the expressive broad strokes set against the tightness of the flat, nondescript background. [3] The link with the biblical Crucifixion is made through the raised arms of the lower creature, and the T-shaped cross. [4]

The canvas is almost entirely stripped of colour. The T-shaped cross is dark blue; the two figures are painted in a mixture of white and black hues, the white tones dominating. Over half of the work is unpainted, essentially bare canvas. According to the theologian and curator Friedhelm Mennekes, the viewer's attention is thus solely focused "on the figure in agony on the cross, or more precisely: on the mouth, gaping and distorted in its cry". [5] The body of the chimera, or hybrid bird, [6] is rendered with light paint, and from it hang narrow red streams of paint, indicating the drips and spatter of blood. Bacon uses pentimenti to emphasise the hopelessness of the animal's death throes. [3]

The painting contains the same white angular rails as the mid-grounds of his 1949 Head II , Head VI , and Study for Portrait of the same year. In this panel, the rails are positioned just below the area where the horizontal and vertical bars of the cross intersect. The rail begins with a diagonal line which intersects the chimera at what appears to be the creature's shoulder. [3] The horizontal angular geometrical shape is sketched in white and grey in the mid-ground, and represents an early form of a spatial device Bacon was to develop and perfect during the 1950s, when it effectively became a cage used to frame the anguished figures portrayed in Bacon's foregrounds. In the mid-ground, the artist has sketched a street scene, which features walking stick figures and cars. [7] The pedestrians appear oblivious to the slaughter before them. [3] [8] [9]

Imagery and sources

The bleakness of the painting is informed by the artist's harsh nihilism and existentialist view of life. Bacon was raised as a Christian, but according to his friend and biographer Michael Peppiatt, when he found he could no longer believe he was "extremely disappointed and furious, and anybody with a scrap of religious belief ... he would go for them". Peppiatt makes the observation of Bacon that "if somebody has that intensity, it's almost a faith in and of itself". [10]

The painting has been linked both thematically and in its formal construction to Bacon's 1956 work Owls , and to preparatory sketches only brought to the art market in the late 1990s. [11] The art critic Armin Zweite traces the origin of the lower figure to a photograph of an owl that Bacon found in a book on birds in motion; Bacon has replaced the bird's beak with a wide open human mouth. [12]

Open mouth

Still from Sergei Eisenstein's 1925 silent film Battleship Potemkin. Bacon called the image a catalyst for his work, and incorporated the shape of the mouth when painting the chimera. Eisenstein Potemkin 2.jpg
Still from Sergei Eisenstein's 1925 silent film Battleship Potemkin . Bacon called the image a catalyst for his work, and incorporated the shape of the mouth when painting the chimera.

Screaming mouths appear in many of Bacon's works from the late 1940s to the early 1950s. The motif was developed from sources including medical textbooks, [7] and images of the nurse in the Odessa Steps sequence in Sergei Eisenstein's 1925 silent film Battleship Potemkin . [13] Bacon kept a close-up still of the screaming nurse, at the moment when she has been shot in the eye. He referred to the still in paintings throughout his career. [13] [14]

Bacon tended to draw images in series, and the Odessa nurse become an obsessive motif for him. According to Peppiatt, "it would be no exaggeration to say that, if one could really explain the origins and implications of this scream, one would be far closer to understanding the whole art of Francis Bacon". [15] Gilles Deleuze wrote that, in Bacon's screams, "the entire body escapes through the mouth". [7]

Crucifixion

Matthias Grunewald, Isenheim Altarpiece (centre panel), c. 1512-16. Unterlinden Museum, Colmar, Alsace Mathis Gothart Grunewald 022.jpg
Matthias Grünewald, Isenheim Altarpiece (centre panel), c. 1512–16. Unterlinden Museum, Colmar, Alsace

The panel is one of a number of Bacon's treatments of the biblical crucifixion scene. [7] He also incorporates Greek legend, notably the tale of Aeschylus and the Eumenides—or Furies—found in the Oresteia , suggested by the broad wings of the chimera. Bacon's imagery became less extreme and more imbued with pathos as he got older, and fewer of his canvases contain the sensational imagery that made him famous in the mid-1940s. He admitted that, "When I was younger, I needed extreme subject-matter. Now I don't." [16] According to John Russell, Bacon found it more effective to reflect violence in his brush strokes and colourisation, rather than "in the thing portrayed". [16]

The title refers to Christian iconography of the Passion of Jesus. [12] Crucifixion scenes appear from Bacon's earliest works, [14] and appeared frequently throughout his career. Russell writes that, to Bacon, the crucifixion was a "generic name for an environment in which bodily harm is done to one or more persons and one or more other persons gather to watch". [17]

The painting was commissioned by Eric Hall, Bacon's patron and, later, his lover, [18] who in 1933 commissioned three crucifixion paintings. [19] Bacon drew influence from the old masters Grünewald, Diego Velázquez and Rembrandt, [14] as well as Picasso's late 1920s and early 1930s biomorphs. [20] [21] Bacon said that he thought of the crucifixion as a "magnificent armature on which you can hang all types of feeling and sensation". [22]

Peter Paul Rubens, Descent from the Cross (centre panel), 1612-1614 Peter Paul Rubens - The Descent from the Cross (Antwerp Cathedral)., c. 1613.jpg
Peter Paul Rubens, Descent from the Cross (centre panel), 1612–1614

Elements of the canvas refer to Grünewald's c. 1512–16 Isenheim Altarpiece and Peter Paul Rubens's c. 1612–14 Descent from the Cross . [24] According to the art critic Hugh Davies, the open mouth of the victim and the predator leaning over the cross link the painting to Rubens' Descent. The mouth in Rubens' painting is loosely opened, but in Bacon's it is taut. The main figure's legs are folded out of view and the figure's left arm is passive in Rubens' painting, but in the Bacon's painting the chimera's legs and arms are in violent motion, seemingly wildly flailing up and down. [24]

Cage

Horizontal frames often featured in Bacon's 1950s and 1960s paintings. The motif may have been borrowed from the sculptor Alberto Giacometti, who Bacon greatly admired and often corresponded with. [25] Giacometti had employed the device in The Nose (1947) and The Cage (1950). [9] Bacon's use of frames has suggested imprisonment to many commentators. [26] [27] Writing on their use in Fragment, Zweite mentions that the diagonal lines transform the cross into a guillotine. [3]

Reputation

The religious imagery belies Bacon's atheist and nihilistic outlook. [28] The painting contains no hope for redemption. [7] Friedhelm Mennekes writes that in the victim's scream, "there is not even a lament of being forsaken by God. A god does not emerge for the figure jerking in mortal anguish in the painting". [5] Sharpe identifies the tiny oblivious stick-figure passersby as the element that mostly removes the work from "a straightforward recapitulation of ancient religious iconography and into postwar modernity". [7]

Bacon was self-critical, and often destroyed or disowned his own work, including pieces held in high regard by critics and buyers. He came to dislike Fragment of a Crucifixion, viewing it as too simplistic and explicit, [29] in the words of Russell, "too near the conventions of narrative-painting". [16] [30] This was an issue with which Bacon struggled throughout his career: he aimed to create imagery that would be instantly recognisable, immediate and directly involving for the viewer, while also staying loyal to his creed of producing "non-illustrative painting". [7]

Bacon returned to the crucifixion theme in his 1962 Three Studies for a Crucifixion . [5] That depiction is a more oblique and less literal utilisation of the iconography of the biblical scene, [31] but a more direct invocation of imagery of the slaughterhouse and slabs of meat. [29]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Francis Bacon (artist)</span> Irish figurative painter (1909–1992)

Francis Bacon was an Irish-born British figurative painter known for his raw, unsettling imagery. Focusing on the human form, his subjects included crucifixions, portraits of popes, self-portraits, and portraits of close friends, with abstracted figures sometimes isolated in geometrical structures. Rejecting various classifications of his work, Bacon said he strove to render "the brutality of fact." He built up a reputation as one of the giants of contemporary art with his unique style.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Influences on Francis Bacon</span>

The painter Francis Bacon was largely self-taught as an artist. As well as other visual artists, Bacon drew inspiration from the poems of T. S. Eliot, Ezra Pound and Yeats, the plays of Aeschylus, Sophocles and Shakespeare; Proust and Joyce's Ulysses.

<i>Three Studies for Figures at the Base of a Crucifixion</i> 1944 triptych by Francis Bacon

Three Studies for Figures at the Base of a Crucifixion is a 1944 triptych painted by the Irish-born British artist Francis Bacon. The canvasses are based on the Eumenides—or Furies—of Aeschylus's Oresteia, and depict three writhing anthropomorphic creatures set against a flat burnt orange background. It was executed in oil paint and pastel on Sundeala fibre board and completed within two weeks. The triptych summarises themes explored in Bacon's previous work, including his examination of Picasso's biomorphs and his interpretations of the Crucifixion and the Greek Furies. Bacon did not realise his original intention to paint a large crucifixion scene and place the figures at the foot of the cross.

<i>Portrait of Innocent X</i> Oil painting by Spanish painter Diego Velázquez

Portrait of Pope Innocent X is an oil on canvas portrait by the Spanish painter Diego Velázquez, executed during a trip to Italy around 1650. Many artists and art critics consider it the finest portrait ever created. It is housed in the Galleria Doria Pamphilj in Rome. A smaller version is held by the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, and a study is on display at Apsley House in London. The painting is noted for its realism as an unflinching portrait of a highly intelligent, shrewd, and aging man. He is dressed in linen vestments, and the quality of the work is evident in the rich reds of his upper clothing, head-dress, and the hanging curtains.

<i>Triptych, May–June 1973</i> 1973 painting by Francis Bacon

Triptych, May–June 1973 is a triptych completed in 1973 by the Irish-born artist Francis Bacon (1909–1992). The oil-on-canvas was painted in memory of Bacon's lover George Dyer, who committed suicide on the eve of the artist's retrospective at Paris's Grand Palais on 24 October 1971. The triptych is a portrait of the moments before Dyer's death from an overdose of pills in their hotel room. Bacon was haunted and preoccupied by Dyer's loss for the remaining years of his life and painted many works based on both the actual suicide and the events of its aftermath. He admitted to friends that he never fully recovered, describing the 1973 triptych as an exorcism of his feelings of loss and guilt.

<i>Study after Velázquezs Portrait of Pope Innocent X</i> 1953 painting by Francis Bacon

Study after Velázquez's Portrait of Pope Innocent X is a 1953 painting by the artist Francis Bacon. The work shows a distorted version of the Portrait of Innocent X painted by Spanish artist Diego Velázquez in 1650. The work is one of the first in a series of around 50 variants of the Velázquez painting which Bacon executed throughout the 1950s and early 1960s. The paintings are widely regarded as highly successful modern re-interpretations of a classic of the western canon of visual art.

<i>Crucifixion</i> (Francis Bacon, 1965) 1965 painting by Francis Bacon

Crucifixion is a 1965 triptych painted by the Irish-born artist Francis Bacon. Across each of the three panels, the work shows three forms of violent death.

<i>Study for a Self-Portrait—Triptych, 1985–86</i> Painting by Francis Bacon

Study for a Self-Portrait—Triptych, 1985–86 is a triptych painted between 1985 and 1986 by the Irish-born English artist Francis Bacon. It is a brutally honest examination of the effect of age and time on the human body and spirit, and was painted in the aftermath of the deaths of many of his close friends. It is Bacon's only full-length self-portrait, and was described by art critic David Sylvester as "grand, stark, ascetic".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Triptychs by Francis Bacon</span> Series of paintings made between 1944 and 1986

The Irish-born artist Francis Bacon (1909–1992) painted 28 known triptychs between 1944 and 1986. He began to work in the format in the mid-1940s with a number of smaller scale formats before graduating in 1962 to large examples. He followed the larger style for 30 years, although he painted a number of smaller scale triptychs of friend's heads, and after the death of his former lover George Dyer in 1971, the three Black Triptychs.

<i>Head VI</i> Painting by Francis Bacon

Head VI is an oil-on-canvas painting by Irish-born figurative artist Francis Bacon, the last of six panels making up his "1949 Head" series. It shows a bust view of a single figure, modeled on Diego Velázquez's Portrait of Innocent X. Bacon applies forceful, expressive brush strokes, and places the figure within a glass cage structure, behind curtain-like drapery. This gives the effect of a man trapped and suffocated by his surroundings, screaming into an airless void. But with an inverted pathos is derived from the ambiguity of the pope's horrifying expression—whose distorted face either screams of untethered hatred towards the viewer or pleads for help from the glass cage—the question of what he is screaming about is left to the audience.

<i>Portrait of Isabel Rawsthorne Standing in a Street in Soho</i> 1967 painting by Francis Bacon

Portrait of Isabel Rawsthorne Standing in a Street in Soho is a 1967 oil-on-canvas painting by the Irish-born English figurative artist Francis Bacon, housed in the Neue Nationalgalerie, Berlin. Described by art critic John Russell as one of Bacon's finest works, it depicts Isabel Rawsthorne, the painter, designer and occasional model for artists such as André Derain, Alberto Giacometti and Picasso.

<i>Triptych–August 1972</i> Triptych by Francis Bacon

Triptych–August 1972 is a large oil-on-canvas triptych by the British artist Francis Bacon (1909–1992). It was painted in memory of Bacon's lover George Dyer who committed suicide on 24 October 1971, the eve of the artist's retrospective at Paris's Grand Palais, then the highest honour Bacon had received.

<i>Portrait of George Dyer and Lucian Freud</i> 1967 painting by Francis Bacon

Portrait of George Dyer and Lucian Freud was a 1967 oil-on-canvas painting by the Irish-born artist Francis Bacon, which he destroyed before it left his studio, though it was photographed and is highly regarded by art critics. Bacon was a ruthless self critic, and often abandoned paintings mid-work, or slashed finished canvases; something he often later regretted.

<i>Head I</i> Painting by Francis Bacon

Head I is a relatively small oil and tempera on hardboard painting by the Irish-born British figurative artist Francis Bacon. Completed in 1948, it is the first in a series of six heads, the remainder of which were painted the following year in preparation for a November 1949 exhibition at the Hanover Gallery in London. Like the others in the series, it shows a screaming figure alone in a room, and focuses on the open mouth. The work shows a skull which has disintegrated on itself and is largely a formless blob of flesh. The entire upper half has disappeared, leaving only the jaw, mouth and teeth and one ear still intact. It is the first of Bacon's paintings to feature gold background railings or bars; later to become a prominent feature of his 1950s work, especially in the papal portraits where they would often appear as enclosing or cages around the figures. It is not known what influences were behind the image; most likely they were multiple – press or war photography, and critic Denis Farr detects the influence of Matthias Grünewald.

<i>Head II</i> Painting by Francis Bacon

Head II is an oil and tempera on hardboard painting by the Irish-born British figurative artist Francis Bacon. Completed in 1948, it is the second in a series of six heads, painted from the winter of 1948 in preparation for a November 1949 exhibition at the Hanover Gallery, London.

<i>Three Studies for a Crucifixion</i> Painting by Francis Bacon

Three Studies for a Crucifixion is a 1962 triptych oil painting by Francis Bacon. It was completed in March 1962 and comprises three separate canvases, each measuring 198.1 by 144.8 centimetres. The work is held by the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum in New York.

<i>Head III</i> 1949 painting by Francis Bacon

Head III is an oil painting by Francis Bacon, one of series of works made in 1949 for his first one-man exhibition at the Hanover Gallery, in London. As with the other six paintings in the series, it focuses on the disembodied head of male figure, who looks out with a penetrating gaze, but is fixed against an isolating, flat, nondescript background, while also enfolded by hazy horizontal foreground curtain-like folds which seems to function like a surrounding cage.

<i>Head V</i> 1949 painting by Francis Bacon

Head V is a 1949 painting by Irish-born British artist Francis Bacon, one of series of works made in 1949 for his first one-man exhibition at the Hanover Gallery, in London. It measures 82 by 66 centimetres and is held in a private collection. The painting is part of a series of six works from the late 1940s depicting heads. Like Head II, the work depicts a distorted head in a space in a space shrouded with vertical bands interpreted as curtains, with several safety pins in the curtains.

<i>Blood on the Floor</i> (painting) 1986 painting by Francis Bacon

Blood on the Floor is a 1986 oil-on-canvas panel painting by the British artist Francis Bacon. The panel shows a violent splash of blood, formed from drips of paint, on a bare canvas coloured floor, which may be a wooden plank, or diving board, against a harsh, flat, orange background. The foreground contains two suspended light bulbs, one white, one molten yellow, and a light switch.

<i>Version No. 2 of Lying Figure with Hypodermic Syringe</i> 1968 painting by Francis Bacon

Version No. 2 of Lying Figure with Hypodermic Syringe is a 1968 oil-on-canvas painting by the Irish-born, English artist Francis Bacon. It is the second of two similarly titled paintings based on nude photographs of his close friend Henrietta Moraes, who is shown in a reclining position on a bed, themselves part of a wider series of collapsed figures on beds that began with the 1963 triptych Lying Figure. This later version is widely considered the more successful of the two panels.

References

Notes

  1. Peppiatt (2006), 92
  2. Sylvester (2000), 40
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Zweite (2006), 114
  4. Van Alphen, (1992), 91
  5. 1 2 3 Mennekes, Friedhelm. "Francis Bacon: The Dynamic Reality of The Crucifixion". artandreligion.de. Retrieved 1 May 2017. Archived by the Wayback Machine.
  6. Gale, Matthew. "Three Studies for Figures at the Base of a Crucifixion". Tate. Retrieved 25 February 2017
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Sharpe, Gemma. "Fragment of a Crucifixion Archived 12 June 2021 at the Wayback Machine ". Haus der Kunst, 2016. Retrieved 1 May 2017
  8. Rothenstein, John. "Francis Bacon: Exhibition Cath." Tate, 23 May – 1 July 1962
  9. 1 2 Sylvester (2000), 36
  10. Barker, Oliver. Francis Bacon, 'Untitled (Pope)', in conversation with Michael Peppiatt . London: Sotheby's, 23 October 2012. Retrieved 12 August 2017
  11. Gale, Matthew. "Two Owls, No. 2 circa 1957–61". Tate, February 1999. Retrieved 26 February 2017
  12. 1 2 Zweite (2006), 85
  13. 1 2 Davies; Yard (1986), 18
  14. 1 2 3 Sylvester (2000), 13
  15. Peppiatt (2006), 24
  16. 1 2 3 Russell (1979), 76
  17. Russell (1978), 113
  18. Conrad, Peter. "The power and the passion". The Guardian , 10 August 2008. Retrieved 1 May 2017
  19. Davies; Yard (1986), 12
  20. Baldassari (2005), 140–144
  21. Zweite (2006), 30
  22. Schmied (1996), 78
  23. Alley (1964), 28
  24. 1 2 Adams (1997), 179
  25. Sylvester (1987), 8–9
  26. Sylvester (2000), 37
  27. Farr et al. (1999), 60
  28. Davies; Yard (1986), 404
  29. 1 2 Deleuze (2005), 19
  30. Schmied (1996), 75
  31. Brintnall (2011), 146

Sources

  • Adams, James Luther & Yates, Wilson & Warren, Robert. The Grotesque in Art and Literature. Grand Rapids, MI: William B Eerdmans Publishing, 1997. ISBN   0-8028-4267-4
  • Alley, Ronald & Alley, John. Francis Bacon. London: Thames & Hudson, 1964. OCLC   59432483
  • Baldassari, Anne. Bacon and Picasso. Paris: Flammarion, 2005. ISBN   2-08-030486-0
  • Brintnall, Kent. Ecce Homo: The Male-Body-in-Pain as Redemptive Figure. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press Books, 2011. ISBN   978-0-2260-7470-2
  • Davies, Hugh; Yard, Sally. Francis Bacon. New York: Cross River Press, 1986. ISBN   0-89659-447-5
  • Deleuze, Gilles. Francis Bacon: The Logic of Sensation. London: Continuum International, 2005. ISBN   0-8264-7930-8
  • Farr, Dennis; Peppiatt, Michael; Yard, Sally. Francis Bacon: A Retrospective. New York: Harry N Abrams, 1999. ISBN   0-8109-2925-2
  • Peppiatt, Michael. Francis Bacon in the 1950s. Yale, CT: Yale University Press, 2006. ISBN   0-300-12192-X
  • Russell, John. Francis Bacon. London: Thames & Hudson, 1979. ISBN   0-500-20271-0
  • Schmied, Wieland. Francis Bacon: Commitment and Conflict. Munich: Prestel, 1996. ISBN   3-7913-1664-8
  • Sylvester, David. Looking Back at Francis Bacon. London: Thames and Hudson, 2000. ISBN   0-500-01994-0
  • Sylvester, David. "Giacometti and Bacon". London Review of Books , volume 9 No. 6, 19 March 1987
  • Van Alphen, Ernst. Francis Bacon and the Loss of Self. Chicago: Reaktion Books, 1992. ISBN   0-948462-34-5
  • Zweite, Armin. The Violence of the Real. London: Thames and Hudson, 2006. ISBN   0-500-09335-0