Frequency compensation

Last updated November 28, 2024

In electronics engineering, frequency compensation is a technique used in amplifiers, and especially in amplifiers employing negative feedback. It usually has two primary goals: To avoid the unintentional creation of positive feedback, which will cause the amplifier to oscillate, and to control overshoot and ringing in the amplifier's step response. It is also used extensively to improve the bandwidth of single pole systems.

Explanation

Most amplifiers use negative feedback to trade gain for other desirable properties, such as decreased distortion, improved noise reduction or increased invariance to variation of parameters such as temperature. Ideally, the phase characteristic of an amplifier's frequency response would be linear; however, device limitations make this goal physically unattainable. More particularly, capacitances within the amplifier's gain stages cause the output signal to lag behind the input signal by up to 90° for each pole they create.^[a] If the sum of these phase lags reaches 180°, the output signal will be the negative of the input signal. Feeding back any portion of this output signal to the inverting (negative) input when the gain of the amplifier is sufficient will cause the amplifier to oscillate. This is because the feedback signal will reinforce the input signal. That is, the feedback is then positive rather than negative.

Frequency compensation is implemented to avoid this result.

Another goal of frequency compensation is to control the step response of an amplifier circuit as shown in Figure 1. For example, if a step in voltage is input to a voltage amplifier, ideally a step in output voltage would occur. However, the output is not ideal because of the frequency response of the amplifier, and ringing occurs. Several figures of merit to describe the adequacy of step response are in common use. One is the rise time of the output, which ideally would be short. A second is the time for the output to lock into its final value, which again should be short. The success in reaching this lock-in at final value is described by overshoot (how far the response exceeds final value) and settling time (how long the output swings back and forth about its final value). These various measures of the step response usually conflict with one another, requiring optimization methods.

Frequency compensation is implemented to optimize step response, one method being pole splitting.A

Use in operational amplifiers

Because operational amplifiers are so ubiquitous and are designed to be used with feedback, the following discussion will be limited to frequency compensation of these devices.

It should be expected that the outputs of even the simplest operational amplifiers will have at least two poles. A consequence of this is that at some critical frequency, the phase of the amplifier's output = −180° compared to the phase of its input signal. The amplifier will oscillate if it has a gain of one or more at this critical frequency. This is because (a) the feedback is implemented through the use of an inverting input that adds an additional −180° to the output phase making the total phase shift −360° and (b) the gain is sufficient to induce oscillation.

A more precise statement of this is the following: An operational amplifier will oscillate at the frequency at which its open loop gain equals its closed loop gain if, at that frequency,

The open loop gain of the amplifier is ≥ 1 and
The difference between the phase of the open loop signal and phase response of the network creating the closed loop output = −180°. Mathematically: $\Phi _{OL}-\Phi _{CLnet}=-180^{\circ }$

Practice

Frequency compensation is implemented by modifying the gain and phase characteristics of the amplifier's open loop output or of its feedback network, or both, in such a way as to avoid the conditions leading to oscillation. This is usually done by the internal or external use of resistance-capacitance networks.

Dominant-pole compensation

The method most commonly used is called dominant-pole compensation, which is a form of lag compensation. It is an external compensation technique and is used for relatively low closed loop gain. A pole placed at an appropriate low frequency in the open-loop response reduces the gain of the amplifier to one (0 dB) for a frequency at or just below the location of the next highest frequency pole. The lowest frequency pole is called the dominant pole because it dominates the effect of all of the higher frequency poles. The result is that the difference between the open loop output phase and the phase response of a feedback network having no reactive elements never falls below −180° while the amplifier has a gain of one or more, ensuring stability.

Dominant-pole compensation can be implemented for general purpose operational amplifiers by adding an integrating capacitance to the stage that provides the bulk of the amplifier's gain. This capacitor creates a pole that is set at a frequency low enough to reduce the gain to one (0 dB) at or just below the frequency where the pole next highest in frequency is located. The result is a phase margin of ≈ 45°, depending on the proximity of still higher poles.^[b] This margin is sufficient to prevent oscillation in the most commonly used feedback configurations. In addition, dominant-pole compensation allows control of overshoot and ringing in the amplifier step response, which can be a more demanding requirement than the simple need for stability.

This compensation method is described below: Let $A$ be the uncompensated transfer function of op amp in open-loop configuration which is given by:

$A(s)=A_{OL}\cdot {\frac {1}{1+{\frac {s}{\omega _{1}}}}}\cdot {\frac {1}{1+{\frac {s}{\omega _{2}}}}}\cdot {\frac {1}{1+{\frac {s}{\omega _{3}}}}}=A_{OL}\cdot {\frac {\omega _{1}\omega _{2}\omega _{3}}{(s+\omega 1)(s+\omega _{2})(s+\omega _{3})}}$

where $A_{OL}$ is the open-loop gain of the Op-Amp and $\omega _{1}$ , $\omega _{2}$ , and $\omega _{3}$ are the angular frequencies at which the gain function $A(s)$ rolls off by -20dB, -40dB, and -60dB respectively.

Thus, for compensation, introduce a dominant pole by adding an RC network in series with the Op-Amp as shown in the figure.

The Transfer function of the compensated open loop Op-Amp circuit is given by:

       where f_d < f₁ < f₂ < f₃

The compensation capacitance C is chosen such that f_d < f₁. Hence, the frequency response of a dominant pole compensated open loop Op-Amp circuit shows uniform gain roll off from f_d and becomes 0 at f₁ as shown in the graph.

The advantages of dominant pole compensation are: 1. It is simple and effective. 2. Noise immunity is improved since noise frequency components outside the bandwidth are eliminated.

Though simple and effective, this kind of conservative dominant pole compensation has two drawbacks:

It reduces the bandwidth of the amplifier, thereby reducing available open loop gain at higher frequencies. This, in turn, reduces the amount of feedback available for distortion correction, etc. at higher frequencies.
It reduces the amplifier's slew rate. This reduction results from the time it takes the finite current driving the compensated stage to charge the compensating capacitor. The result is the inability of the amplifier to reproduce high amplitude, rapidly changing signals accurately.

Often, the implementation of dominant-pole compensation results in the phenomenon of Pole splitting . This results in the lowest frequency pole of the uncompensated amplifier "moving" to an even lower frequency to become the dominant pole, and the higher-frequency pole of the uncompensated amplifier "moving" to a higher frequency. To overcome these disadvantages, pole zero compensation is used.

Other methods

Some other compensation methods are: lead compensation, lead–lag compensation and feed-forward compensation.

Lead compensation. Whereas dominant pole compensation places or moves poles in the open loop response, lead compensation places a zero^[c] in the open loop response to cancel one of the existing poles.

Lead–lag compensation places both a zero and a pole in the open loop response, with the pole usually being at an open loop gain of less than one.

Feed-forward or Miller compensation uses a capacitor to bypass a stage in the amplifier at high frequencies, thereby eliminating the pole that stage creates.

The purpose of these three methods is to allow greater open loop bandwidth while still maintaining amplifier closed loop stability. They are often used to compensate high gain, wide bandwidth amplifiers.

Footnotes

↑ In this context, a pole is the point in a frequency response curve where the amplitude decreases by 3db due to an integrating resistance and capacitive reactance. Ultimately, each pole will result in a phase lag of up to 90°, i.e., the output signal will lag behind the input signal by 90° at this point. For the mathematical concept of a pole, see, Pole (complex analysis).
↑ The dominant pole produces a phase shift approximating −90° from approx. 10 times the pole frequency to a frequency a factor of ten below the next higher pole position. The next higher pole, in turn, adds another −45° for a frequency at its location for a total of −135° (neglecting the still higher poles).
↑ In this context, a zero is the point in a frequency response curve where the amplitude increases by 3db due to a differentiating resistance and capacitive reactance. Ultimately, each zero will result in a phase lead of 90°, i.e., the phase of the output signal will be 90° ahead of the phase of the input signal at this point. For the mathematical concept of a zero, see, Zero (complex analysis).

Related Research Articles

An operational amplifier is a DC-coupled electronic voltage amplifier with a differential input, a (usually) single-ended output, and an extremely high gain. Its name comes from its original use of performing mathematical operations in analog computers.

A phase-locked loop or phase lock loop (PLL) is a control system that generates an output signal whose phase is fixed relative to the phase of an input signal. Keeping the input and output phase in lockstep also implies keeping the input and output frequencies the same, thus a phase-locked loop can also track an input frequency. And by incorporating a frequency divider, a PLL can generate a stable frequency that is a multiple of the input frequency.

In electrical engineering and control theory, a Bode plot is a graph of the frequency response of a system. It is usually a combination of a Bode magnitude plot, expressing the magnitude of the frequency response, and a Bode phase plot, expressing the phase shift.

A negative-feedback amplifier is an electronic amplifier that subtracts a fraction of its output from its input, so that negative feedback opposes the original signal. The applied negative feedback can improve its performance and reduces sensitivity to parameter variations due to manufacturing or environment. Because of these advantages, many amplifiers and control systems use negative feedback.

A resistor–capacitor circuit, or RC filter or RC network, is an electric circuit composed of resistors and capacitors. It may be driven by a voltage or current source and these will produce different responses. A first order RC circuit is composed of one resistor and one capacitor and is the simplest type of RC circuit.

In electronics, a common-emitter amplifier is one of three basic single-stage bipolar-junction-transistor (BJT) amplifier topologies, typically used as a voltage amplifier. It offers high current gain, medium input resistance and a high output resistance. The output of a common emitter amplifier is inverted; i.e. for a sine wave input signal, the output signal is 180 degrees out of phase with respect to the input.

The step response of a system in a given initial state consists of the time evolution of its outputs when its control inputs are Heaviside step functions. In electronic engineering and control theory, step response is the time behaviour of the outputs of a general system when its inputs change from zero to one in a very short time. The concept can be extended to the abstract mathematical notion of a dynamical system using an evolution parameter.

In electronics, a common-source amplifier is one of three basic single-stage field-effect transistor (FET) amplifier topologies, typically used as a voltage or transconductance amplifier. The easiest way to tell if a FET is common source, common drain, or common gate is to examine where the signal enters and leaves. The remaining terminal is what is known as "common". In this example, the signal enters the gate, and exits the drain. The only terminal remaining is the source. This is a common-source FET circuit. The analogous bipolar junction transistor circuit may be viewed as a transconductance amplifier or as a voltage amplifier.. As a transconductance amplifier, the input voltage is seen as modulating the current going to the load. As a voltage amplifier, input voltage modulates the current flowing through the FET, changing the voltage across the output resistance according to Ohm's law. However, the FET device's output resistance typically is not high enough for a reasonable transconductance amplifier, nor low enough for a decent voltage amplifier. As seen below in the formula, the voltage gain depends on the load resistance, so it cannot be applied to drive low-resistance devices, such as a speaker. Another major drawback is the amplifier's limited high-frequency response. Therefore, in practice the output often is routed through either a voltage follower, or a current follower, to obtain more favorable output and frequency characteristics. The CS–CG combination is called a cascode amplifier.

This article illustrates some typical operational amplifier applications. A non-ideal operational amplifier's equivalent circuit has a finite input impedance, a non-zero output impedance, and a finite gain. A real op-amp has a number of non-ideal features as shown in the diagram, but here a simplified schematic notation is used, many details such as device selection and power supply connections are not shown. Operational amplifiers are optimised for use with negative feedback, and this article discusses only negative-feedback applications. When positive feedback is required, a comparator is usually more appropriate. See Comparator applications for further information.

The gain–bandwidth product for an amplifier is a figure of merit calculated by multiplying the amplifier's bandwidth and the gain at which the bandwidth is measured.

In electronics, the Miller effect accounts for the increase in the equivalent input capacitance of an inverting voltage amplifier due to amplification of the effect of capacitance between the amplifier's input and output terminals, and is given by

A lead–lag compensator is a component in a control system that improves an undesirable frequency response in a feedback and control system. It is a fundamental building block in classical control theory.

Parasitic capacitance or stray capacitance is the unavoidable and usually unwanted capacitance that exists between the parts of an electronic component or circuit simply because of their proximity to each other. When two electrical conductors at different voltages are close together, the electric field between them causes electric charge to be stored on them; this effect is capacitance.

An all-pass filter is a signal processing filter that passes all frequencies equally in gain, but changes the phase relationship among various frequencies. Most types of filter reduce the amplitude of the signal applied to it for some values of frequency, whereas the all-pass filter allows all frequencies through without changes in level.

In electronics, a differentiator is a circuit that outputs a signal approximately proportional to the rate of change of its input signal. Because the derivative of a sinusoid is another sinusoid whose amplitude is multiplied by its frequency, a true differentiator that works across all frequencies can't be realized. Real circuits such as a 1^st-order high-pass filter are able to approximate differentiation at lower frequencies by limiting the gain above its cutoff frequency. An active differentiator includes an amplifier, while a passive differentiator is made only of resistors, capacitors and inductors.

In electronic amplifiers, the phase margin (PM) is the difference between the phase lag $φ$ and -180°, for an amplifier's output signal at zero dB gain - i.e. unity gain, or that the output signal has the same amplitude as the input.

A fully differential amplifier (FDA) is a DC-coupled high-gain electronic voltage amplifier with differential inputs and differential outputs. In its ordinary usage, the output of the FDA is controlled by two feedback paths which, because of the amplifier's high gain, almost completely determine the output voltage for any given input.

Pole splitting is a phenomenon exploited in some forms of frequency compensation used in an electronic amplifier. When a capacitor is introduced between the input and output sides of the amplifier with the intention of moving the pole lowest in frequency to lower frequencies, pole splitting causes the pole next in frequency to move to a higher frequency. This pole movement increases the stability of the amplifier and improves its step response at the cost of decreased speed.

In electronics, a transimpedance amplifier (TIA) is a current to voltage converter, almost exclusively implemented with one or more operational amplifiers. The TIA can be used to amplify the current output of Geiger–Müller tubes, photo multiplier tubes, accelerometers, photo detectors and other types of sensors to a usable voltage. Current to voltage converters are used with sensors that have a current response that is more linear than the voltage response. This is the case with photodiodes where it is not uncommon for the current response to have better than 1% nonlinearity over a wide range of light input. The transimpedance amplifier presents a low impedance to the photodiode and isolates it from the output voltage of the operational amplifier. In its simplest form a transimpedance amplifier has just a large valued feedback resistor, R_f. The gain of the amplifier is set by this resistor and because the amplifier is in an inverting configuration, has a value of -R_f. There are several different configurations of transimpedance amplifiers, each suited to a particular application. The one factor they all have in common is the requirement to convert the low-level current of a sensor to a voltage. The gain, bandwidth, as well as current and voltage offsets change with different types of sensors, requiring different configurations of transimpedance amplifiers.

CMOS amplifiers are ubiquitous analog circuits used in computers, audio systems, smartphones, cameras, telecommunication systems, biomedical circuits, and many other systems. Their performance impacts the overall specifications of the systems. They take their name from the use of MOSFETs as opposite to bipolar junction transistors (BJTs). MOSFETs are simpler to fabricate and therefore less expensive than BJT amplifiers, still providing a sufficiently high transconductance to allow the design of very high performance circuits. In high performance CMOS amplifier circuits, transistors are not only used to amplify the signal but are also used as active loads to achieve higher gain and output swing in comparison with resistive loads.

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[1] In this context, a pole is the point in a frequency response curve where the amplitude decreases by 3db due to an integrating resistance and capacitive reactance. Ultimately, each pole will result in a phase lag of up to 90°, i.e., the output signal will lag behind the input signal by 90° at this point. For the mathematical concept of a pole, see, Pole (complex analysis).

[2] The dominant pole produces a phase shift approximating −90° from approx. 10 times the pole frequency to a frequency a factor of ten below the next higher pole position. The next higher pole, in turn, adds another −45° for a frequency at its location for a total of −135° (neglecting the still higher poles).

[3] In this context, a zero is the point in a frequency response curve where the amplitude increases by 3db due to a differentiating resistance and capacitive reactance. Ultimately, each zero will result in a phase lead of 90°, i.e., the phase of the output signal will be 90° ahead of the phase of the input signal at this point. For the mathematical concept of a zero, see, Zero (complex analysis).

[a]

[b]

[c]