German balanced budget amendment

Last updated

Germany's balanced budget amendment ( German : Schuldenbremse), also referred to as Germany's debt brake, is a fiscal rule enacted in 2009. The law, which is in Article 109, paragraph 3 and Article 115 of the Basic Law, Germany's constitution, is designed to restrict structural budget deficits at the federal level and limit the issuance of government debt. The rule restricts annual structural deficits to 0.35% of GDP. [1]

Contents

The debt brake is controversial among economists. It is supported by a German strand of economics, ordoliberalism, while other economists have challenged the rule. [2] [3]

History

The amendment was enacted because the nation's debt-to-GDP ratio exceeded the 60% threshold fixed in the Maastricht Treaty, primarily a result of the heavy payments to reconstruct former communist Eastern Germany after reunification and a loss of tax revenue during the Great Recession. The law required a change to the constitution and in 2009, it was approved with a two-thirds majority both by the Bundestag and the Bundesrat, under the Grand coalition of the First Merkel cabinet. [4] At the federal level, the law limited the budget deficit to 0.35% of the GDP beginning in 2016 and German states that approved the law were prohibited from taking on debt after 2020. [5] Three states, Berlin, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern and Schleswig-Holstein, did not establish the law in their constitutions. [6] In the years prior to the Covid pandemic, the law helped reduce Germany's debt to 59.5% of GDP. [7] The balanced budget amendment is not absolute and allows the country to exceed the borrowing limits during a national emergency or a recession.

The amendment was suspended in 2020 to allow the country to deal with the costs of the COVID-19 pandemic in Germany and was set to come back into force in 2023. [7] [8] [9]

Although the mechanism was successful in its stated goal, reducing government borrowing, it was criticized by left-of-center parties including the Social Democrats and the Greens, which suggested that the law limited necessary government investment. During the 2021 German federal election campaign, the Greens proposed reforming the rule to allow spending on infrastructure, healthcare and education. [10] In 2022, the government, led by Chancellor Olaf Scholz, succeeded in obtaining the two-thirds majority necessary to amend the debt ceiling to allow Germany to establish a 100 billion euro defense fund that would not be subject to the restrictions. The change was spurred by the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine. [11]

In December 2021, via an amendment to the original budget for 2021, [12] the ruling traffic light coalition reallocated €60 billion of unused funds intended to combat the COVID-19 pandemic to its Climate and Transformation Fund  [ de ] (KTF) for climate and green industry projects. On November 15, 2023, the Federal Constitutional Court, having been prompted by the opposition CDU/CSU conservative alliance, ruled this maneuver to be unconstitutional. The ruling prompted a discussion about whether the amendment in its current form would still be appropriate, with even some conservatives calling for a reform to raise the relatively weak level of investment, compared to European neighbors, which had prevailed for several years. [4] On November 27, the cabinet agreed to extend the lifting of the amendment to 2023. [9]

Discourse

The German debt brake has been both lauded and criticized by economists and policymakers alike. Critics argue that the debt brake constraines the government's ability to respond flexibly to economic downturns. Moreover, some contend that the strict austerity measures enforced by the debt brake hinderes long-term growth prospects by causing underinvesting in infrastructure, education, and innovation.

The German Council of Economic Experts (GCEE)

The German Council of Economic Experts (GCEE) has advocated for a pragmatic reform aimed at enhancing the flexibility of fiscal policy while safeguarding debt sustainability. Firstly, they propose spreading the process of returning the structural deficit to its regular limit over multiple years following the application of the exception clause. Secondly, they suggest that the annual limit for the structural deficit should be contingent upon the level of debt. If the debt falls below a specified threshold, a higher structural deficit would be permissible. Lastly, the experts recommend methodological changes in estimating potential output, a crucial part of calculating the structural deficit. [13]

Discourse among German economists

The debt brake has been controversial since its introduction. [2] At that time numerous German economists spoke out against the introduction of the debt brake in a public letter. [14] German professors remain divided about this issue. A recent report from the Ifo Institut in Munich shows that 48% of economics professors oppose a reform of the debt brake, 44% support a reform, and 6% want to abolish it all together. 2% of economists are undecided. [15]

Positions of Germany´s major parties

The Schuldenbremse, or debt brake, has been a pivotal point of contention among major German political parties, displaying diverse economic perspectives on fiscal policy. The positions of these parties regarding the debt brake demonstrate their differing priorities, concerns, and approaches to managing public finances.

CDU/CSU

The conservative parties, CDU/CSU have historically been a strong advocate of the debt brake. They view it as a necessary tool for maintaining fiscal discipline and ensuring the long-term sustainability of public finances. For the CDU/CSU, the debt brake represents a commitment to responsible governance, as it limits the accumulation of government debt and promotes balanced budgets. They argue that reducing government borrowing fosters economic stability, encourages private sector investment, and ultimately strengthens Germany's position within the European Union. Moreover, the CDU/CSU emphasises the importance of honouring budgetary commitments to future generations, framing the debt brake as a mechanism to safeguard their interests. [16]

At the start of 2024 a debate has sparked within the CDU about a reform of the debt brake. Especially. some Ministerpräsidenten have recently advocated for a reform. [17]

FDP

The Free Democratic Party (FDP) generally supports the debt brake. However, with some reservations. While the FDP acknowledges the importance of fiscal responsibility, it advocates for a more flexible interpretation of the debt brake to accommodate economic fluctuations and crises. The party emphasizes the need to strike a balance between debt reduction and strategic investments in areas such as infrastructure, education, and innovation. Also, the FDP advocates for structural reforms aimed at enhancing Germany's economic competitiveness and productivity, viewing them as essential for achieving sustainable budgetary outcomes in the long run. [18] [16]

SPD

The Social Democratic Party (SPD) has a nuanced relationship with the debt brake. While the SPD initially supported its implementation, the party has since become divided over its effectiveness and implications. Some rather conservative factions within the SPD remain supportive of the debt brake, arguing that it promotes fiscal discipline and credibility in financial markets. However, other more left-leaning parts of the party criticize its firm framework and argue that it negatively influences the government's ability to respond effectively to economic downturns or invest in green technologies and welfare programs. These critics advocate for reforms to make the debt brake more flexible. [19] [20]

Bündnis 90/Die Grünen

Bündnis 90/Die Grünen has also expressed mixed views on the debt brake. While the party recognizes the importance of sustainable fiscal policy, it raises concerns about the social and environmental implications of austerity measures enforced by the debt brake. Bündnis 90/Die Grünen emphasizes the need for investments in renewable energy and climate adaptation to address the looming threat of climate change. They argue that prioritising debt reduction over these priorities neglects crucial long-term investments in sustainability and economic growth. [21] [22]

Die Linke

The Left Party (Die Linke) opposes the debt brake altogether, viewing it as a neoliberal austerity measure that undermines social welfare and intensifies inequality. Die Linke advocates for alternative approaches to fiscal policy that prioritize public investment, wealth redistribution, and social justice. They argue that austerity measures enforced by the debt brake disproportionately impact marginalised communities and slow down efforts to achieve inclusive and sustainable economic development. [23] [24]

AFD

The right-wing party AFD (Alternative für Deutschland) is in favor of the debt-brake. [25]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Social Democratic Party of Germany</span> Centre-left political party in Germany

The Social Democratic Party of Germany is a centre-left social democratic political party in Germany. It is one of the major parties of contemporary Germany.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Deficit spending</span> Spending in excess of revenue

Within the budgetary process, deficit spending is the amount by which spending exceeds revenue over a particular period of time, also called simply deficit, or budget deficit, the opposite of budget surplus. The term may be applied to the budget of a government, private company, or individual. A central point of controversy in economics, government deficit spending was first identified as a necessary economic tool by John Maynard Keynes in the wake of the Great Depression.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Government budget balance</span> Difference between revenues and spending

The government budget balance, also referred to as the general government balance, public budget balance, or public fiscal balance, is the difference between government revenues and spending. For a government that uses accrual accounting the budget balance is calculated using only spending on current operations, with expenditure on new capital assets excluded. A positive balance is called a government budget surplus, and a negative balance is a government budget deficit. A government budget presents the government's proposed revenues and spending for a financial year.

The Junge Union Deutschlands or JU is the joint youth organisation of the CDU/CSU coalition in Germany. Membership is limited to individuals between 14 and 35 years of age.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Austerity</span> Economic policies intended to reduce government budget deficits

In economic policy, austerity is a set of political-economic policies that aim to reduce government budget deficits through spending cuts, tax increases, or a combination of both. There are three primary types of austerity measures: higher taxes to fund spending, raising taxes while cutting spending, and lower taxes and lower government spending. Austerity measures are often used by governments that find it difficult to borrow or meet their existing obligations to pay back loans. The measures are meant to reduce the budget deficit by bringing government revenues closer to expenditures. Proponents of these measures state that this reduces the amount of borrowing required and may also demonstrate a government's fiscal discipline to creditors and credit rating agencies and make borrowing easier and cheaper as a result.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stability and Growth Pact</span> Main European Union fiscal agreement

The Stability and Growth Pact (SGP) is an agreement, among all the 27 member states of the European Union (EU), to facilitate and maintain the stability of the Economic and Monetary Union (EMU). Based primarily on Articles 121 and 126 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, it consists of fiscal monitoring of member states by the European Commission and the Council of the European Union, and the issuing of a yearly Country-Specific Recommendation for fiscal policy actions to ensure a full compliance with the SGP also in the medium-term. If a member state breaches the SGP's outlined maximum limit for government deficit and debt, the surveillance and request for corrective action will intensify through the declaration of an Excessive Deficit Procedure (EDP); and if these corrective actions continue to remain absent after multiple warnings, a member state of the eurozone can ultimately also be issued economic sanctions. The pact was outlined by a European Council resolution in June 1997, and two Council regulations in July 1997. The first regulation "on the strengthening of the surveillance of budgetary positions and the surveillance and coordination of economic policies", known as the "preventive arm", entered into force 1 July 1998. The second regulation "on speeding up and clarifying the implementation of the excessive deficit procedure", sometimes referred to as the "dissuasive arm" but commonly known as the "corrective arm", entered into force 1 January 1999.

A balanced budget amendment is a constitutional rule requiring that a state cannot spend more than its income. It requires a balance between the projected receipts and expenditures of the government.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wolfgang Schäuble</span> German politician (1942–2023)

Wolfgang Schäuble was a German politician whose political career spanned more than five decades. A member of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU), he was the longest-serving member of any democratic German parliament. Schäuble served as the 13th president of the Bundestag from 2017 to 2021.

The Golden Rule is a guideline for the operation of fiscal policy. The Golden Rule states that over the economic cycle, the Government will borrow only to invest and not to fund current spending. In layman's terms this means that on average over the ups and downs of an economic cycle the government should only borrow to pay for investment that benefits future generations. Day-to-day spending that benefits today's taxpayers should be paid for with today's taxes, not with leveraged investment. Therefore, over the cycle the current budget must balance or be brought into surplus.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Balanced budget</span> Financial plan where revenues equal expenses

A balanced budget is a budget in which revenues are equal to expenditures. Thus, neither a budget deficit nor a budget surplus exists. More generally, it is a budget that has no budget deficit, but could possibly have a budget surplus. A cyclically balanced budget is a budget that is not necessarily balanced year-to-year but is balanced over the economic cycle, running a surplus in boom years and running a deficit in lean years, with these offsetting over time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United States federal budget</span> Budget of the U.S. federal government

The United States budget comprises the spending and revenues of the U.S. federal government. The budget is the financial representation of the priorities of the government, reflecting historical debates and competing economic philosophies. The government primarily spends on healthcare, retirement, and defense programs. The non-partisan Congressional Budget Office provides extensive analysis of the budget and its economic effects. CBO estimated in February 2024 that Federal debt held by the public is projected to rise from 99 percent of GDP in 2024 to 116 percent in 2034 and would continue to grow if current laws generally remained unchanged. Over that period, the growth of interest costs and mandatory spending outpaces the growth of revenues and the economy, driving up debt. Those factors persist beyond 2034, pushing federal debt higher still, to 172 percent of GDP in 2054.

In American political theory, fiscal conservatism or economic conservatism is a political and economic philosophy regarding fiscal policy and fiscal responsibility with an ideological basis in capitalism, individualism, limited government, and laissez-faire economics. Fiscal conservatives advocate tax cuts, reduced government spending, free markets, deregulation, privatization, free trade, and minimal government debt. Fiscal conservatism follows the same philosophical outlook as classical liberalism. This concept is derived from economic liberalism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Romania and the euro</span> Overview of the relationship between Romania and the Euro

Romania's national currency is the leu. After Romania joined the European Union (EU) in 2007, the country became required to replace the leu with the euro once it meets all four euro convergence criteria, as stated in article 140 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. As of 2023, the only currency on the market is the leu and the euro is not yet used in shops. The Romanian leu is not part of the European Exchange Rate Mechanism, although Romanian authorities are working to prepare the changeover to the euro. To achieve the currency changeover, Romania must undergo at least two years of stability within the limits of the convergence criteria.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Axel Fischer</span> German politician

Axel Eduard Fischer is a German politician. He is a member of the CDU and has been a member of the German parliament from 1998 to October 2021, representing Karlsruhe-Land since 2002.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gerda Hasselfeldt</span> German politician

Gerda Hasselfeldt is a German politician of the Christian Social Union (CSU) who served as deputy chairperson of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group and chairwoman of the Bundestag group of CSU parliamentarians. Following her departure from active politics, she became President of the German Red Cross in 2018.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Deficit reduction in the United States</span> Economic policy debate

Deficit reduction in the United States refers to taxation, spending, and economic policy debates and proposals designed to reduce the federal government budget deficit. Government agencies including the Government Accountability Office (GAO), Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), and the U.S. Treasury Department have reported that the federal government is facing a series of important long-run financing challenges, mainly driven by an aging population, rising healthcare costs per person, and rising interest payments on the national debt.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">European Fiscal Compact</span> Intergovernmental treaty

The Treaty on Stability, Coordination and Governance in the Economic and Monetary Union; also referred to as TSCG, or more plainly the Fiscal Stability Treaty is an intergovernmental treaty introduced as a new stricter version of the Stability and Growth Pact, signed on 2 March 2012 by all member states of the European Union (EU), except the Czech Republic and the United Kingdom. The treaty entered into force on 1 January 2013 for the 16 states which completed ratification prior to this date. As of 3 April 2019, it had been ratified and entered into force for all 25 signatories plus Croatia, which acceded to the EU in July 2013, and the Czech Republic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Eckhardt Rehberg</span> German politician

Eckhardt Rehberg is a German politician of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) who served as a member of the Bundestag from the state of Mecklenburg-Vorpommern from 2005 until 2021.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Parlamentarische Linke</span> Political party in Germany

The Parlamentarische Linke is a platform within the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD)'s Bundestag group. As of 2022, 96 of the group's 206 members belong to the Parliamentary Left, making it the largest of the three extant platforms in the SPD group, alongside the Seeheimer Kreis and Berlin Network. The Parliamentary Left represents social democratic positions within the party.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Steffen Kampeter</span> German politician and lobbyist

Steffen Kampeter is a German politician (CDU) and lobbyist. He was a member of the German Bundestag from 1990 to 2016 and Parliamentary State Secretary to the Federal Minister of Finance from 2009 to 2015. Since July 2016, Kampeter has been managing director of the Confederation of German Employers' Associations (BDA).

References

  1. ↑ "Germany's debt brake and the art of fantasy budgeting". The Economist. 2024. ISSN   0013-0613.
  2. 1 2 "Meet the Economist Leading Germany's Battle Against Debt". Bloomberg.com. 2024-07-13.
  3. ↑ "What is Germany's debt brake?". DW. 2023.
  4. 1 2 Rinke, Andreas; Marsh, Sarah (2023-11-26). "Germany's budget crisis spurs calls to change its borrowing limits". Reuters . Retrieved 2023-11-26.
  5. ↑ "Germany's debt brake: surveillance by the Stability Council" (PDF). Bundesbank. April 2019. Retrieved 2022-06-18.
  6. ↑ "Schuldenbremse erhält Verfassungsrang". Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung (in German). 2009-06-12.
  7. 1 2 "The end of the German debt brake?" . Economist Intelligence Unit. 2021-03-01.
  8. ↑ "Olaf Scholz plots a way round Germany's debt rules" . Financial Times. 2021-12-06.
  9. 1 2 "Germany's cabinet agrees to lift debt brake again for 2023". Deutsche Welle . 2023-11-27. Retrieved 2023-11-27.
  10. ↑ "Germany's Greens clash with finance minister over return to debt brake". Reuters. 2021-05-12.
  11. ↑ "Germany approves €100bn fund to modernise its armed forces". Financial Times. 2022-06-03.
  12. ↑ Martinez, Maria; Kraemer, Christian (2023-11-15). "German court deals 60 billion euro budget blow to Scholz government". Reuters . Retrieved 2023-11-28.
  13. ↑ "The German debt brake: the merits and limitations of fiscal rules". economic-research.bnpparibas.com. Retrieved 2024-04-28.
  14. ↑ Öchsner, Thomas (2010-05-17). "Der Protest der Professoren". Süddeutsche.de (in German). Retrieved 2024-04-28.
  15. ↑ "Die deutsche Schuldenbremse – Stabilitätsanker oder Investitionsblocker? | Fakten | ifo Institut". www.ifo.de (in German). 2023-12-08. Retrieved 2024-04-28.
  16. 1 2 Hausding, Götz. "Deutscher Bundestag - Fraktionen positionieren sich zu Schuldenbremse und Investitionen". Deutscher Bundestag (in German). Retrieved 2024-04-29.
  17. ↑ "CDU-geführte Bundesländer streben Reform der Schuldenbremse an • Table.Briefings". Table.Media (in German). 2024-04-21. Retrieved 2024-04-29.
  18. ↑ "Schuldenbremse Einhalten Und Investitionen Stärken". 29 April 2024.
  19. ↑ Rödle, Moritz. "Fraktionstreffen: Wie die SPD die Schuldenbremse reformieren will". tagesschau.de (in German). Retrieved 2024-04-29.
  20. ↑ "Neue Regeln für die Schuldenbremse". 29 April 2024.
  21. ↑ "Handelsblatt". www.handelsblatt.com. Retrieved 2024-04-29.
  22. ↑ ""Wir wollen die Schuldenbremse durch eine Investitionsregel ergänzen"". BÜNDNIS 90/DIE GRÜNEN (in German). Retrieved 2024-04-29.
  23. ↑ MWO. "Die Linke fordert Reform der Schuldenbremse". Deutscher Bundestag (in German). Retrieved 2024-04-29.
  24. ↑ "Investitionswende statt Schuldenbremse". Die Linke (in German). 2024-03-20. Retrieved 2024-04-29.
  25. ↑ Hausding, Götz. "Deutscher Bundestag - AfD-Vorstoß zur Einhaltung der Schuldenbremse stößt auf Widerspruch". Deutscher Bundestag (in German). Retrieved 2024-04-29.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.