Humbug (Aboriginal)

Last updated

In Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, humbug is a slang term referring to making unreasonable or excessive demands from one's family or other connections. [1] [2]

Contents

While resource-sharing is a common cultural practice among Aboriginal communities, "humbugging" has a negative connotation and is distinct from the traditions of sharing and strong sense of community Aboriginal culture is based upon. Examples of humbugging can range from family arguments and stress related to family obligations to abuse and theft. [3] Not responding to the requests or demands of humbugging can result in assault and payback violence. [1]

Humbugging stems from a variety of factors, including the socioeconomic context and cultural context of Aboriginal communities. [3] It is also closely associated with elder abuse, in particular with financial elder abuse as a prevalent examples of how humbugging occurs. The issue of humbugging has been explored in community legal centres, banks and financial institutions as well as in government inquiries.

Etymology

In broader English, the word "humbug" refers to something or someone that is dishonest or misleading and behaviour, writing or talk that is intentionally deceiving. [4] [5] For example, in Charles Dickens' 1843 novella A Christmas Carol , the main character Ebenezer Scrooge exclaims "Bah! Humbug!" to express his displeasure. [6]

However, in Australian Aboriginal English, "humbug" is used in a general manner to refer to irritating or pestering someone. While there is not one specific or accepted universal definition of humbug, [7] it can also be understood as making unreasonable demands from one's family or other connections in a troublesome and aggravating way. The term can also refer to demands that are repetitive and often accompanied by threats or abuse if the demands are not met. [8]

Background

The causes of humbugging are multifaceted and may include the socioeconomic and cultural context of Aboriginal communities. The cultural norms of resource-sharing and shared wealth put financial stability at an increased risk of abuse. [8] While resource-sharing may be a positive act of support in normal instances, it can also lead to increased financial stress. Especially from elderly Aboriginal people, coercion into unlawfully assisting others through family ties or connections may put them at risk of financial elder abuse. [8]

Demand sharing, also referred to as community obligation, is a large part of Aboriginal communities and is characterized by strong ties to kinship and obligations. [9] In Indigenous culture, sharing is based upon a strong sense of community and service that has been traditional and is an act that sustains social relations within the community. [7] Further, it is one based upon reciprocity and mutual generosity. [10] However, the introduction of Western money systems into this traditional conception of sharing has only come about relatively recently. Due to this, the sharing of money becomes an adapted version of traditional resource sharing, where its used as a gesture to show support and care for one's family and broader community. As these two economic perspectives of Western capitalism and traditional sharing and obligations are fundamentally different, the incompatibilities within the systems may lead to phenomena such as humbugging arising. Humbugging is a reflection of traditional Aboriginal cultural practices, however, may also lead to the exploitation of kinship needs and resource-sharing that is commonly valued in Indigenous culture, especially for the older generation. [7]

Further, as the definition of humbugging is unclear and there is no one consensus meaning, what some communities may see as acceptable humbugging is instead more serious incidents of harassment. [9] For instance, in one study, participants regarded financial support in the form of giving others cash and paying for their goods and services as a cultural norm. [9] Thus, the study reports that more insights are needed to better represent how Aboriginal communities understand wealth, demand sharing and their financial situation. [9]

Barriers that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples face include, but are not limited to, a lack of access and knowledge about traditional financial services and products, distrust for available financial services and the existing financial services being too costly. [9] Due to the expectations and cultural context of resource-sharing, culturally specific forms of financial abuse may arise. [9] Thus, there is emphasis on the need to create financial products that are aligned in culture and value to traditional practices of kinship relations and demand sharing. This may include financial services and institutes investing in increasing financial literacy within Aboriginal communities, more accessible explanations in plain language English and an alignment of cultural perspective when communicating financial advice to Indigenous audiences. [9]

Family humbug is also identified as a main source of concern for Aboriginal communities' family worries. [3] In a survey investigating Aboriginal family support and mental health, family arguments about money, food, drugs and strained family relations were identified as a key tension. [3] One approach to mitigating family arguments and humbug has been motivational counselling, which provides a holistic stance to addressing worries and is able to be culturally adapted. [3] This method has proven successful, however is largely dependent on familial support surrounding the individual. [3]

There are also long-standing systemic and structural issues that lead to the prominence of humbugging. This includes the extensive and severe financial stress Indigenous households experience compared to their non-Indigenous counterparts. [10] Overall, in addressing Indigenous exclusion in the long-term, incremental and sustained structural reform is needed. [11]

Elder abuse

The concept of humbugging is closely associated with elder abuse, due to humbugging prominently occurring from the younger generation towards the older generation. [7] Financial abuse refers to domestic and family violence of an individual using money to gain authority or control of another in their relationship, for example, a partner, child or other family member. [8]

In a 2020 survey from across the Kimberley, more than half of the respondents believed that "most elders are being humbugged or abused frequently". [8] Due to the low financial literacy within Aboriginal elderly people, financial elder abuse may take form through the misuse of their individual pension allowances, carers allowances and other welfare payments. Vehicles of abuse also can include Centrepay, technology such as ATMs where theft can occur when an older person entrusts a family member to use the ATM on their behalf, and the lack of accessibility or digital literacy for online banking. [8]

For instance, one example that the Kimberley Community Legal Services recounts describes the circumstances of humbugging surrounding an elder suffering from undiagnosed dementia. [8] One of their family members claimed Carers Allowance without the knowledge of any other family members, and the elder's online banking was created by the family member so that they were in control of the elder's finances. [8] While the elder was not provided any care or necessities, the family member profited from their allowance and pension, spending the money on items such as drugs, alcohol and clothing. [8]

Most of the survey participants report that humbugging is a very big issue and happens frequently, while a substantial minority report that it happens to some elders and needs to be better addressed. A small minority do not regard it as an issue. Humbugging Statistics.png
Most of the survey participants report that humbugging is a very big issue and happens frequently, while a substantial minority report that it happens to some elders and needs to be better addressed. A small minority do not regard it as an issue.
Online survey findings answering "In your experience, if an Elder is suffering financial abuse, who is it mainly coming from?" [8]
AnswersResponses
Their children or grandchildren92.68%
Their spouse or partner34.15%
Other relatives68.29%
Friends or acquaintances31.71%
Services providers or businesses19.51%

Context and use

Government and advocacy

The Western Australia Select Committee into Elder Abuse submitted an inquiry into financial elder abuse, in particular focusing on the issue of humbugging. [1] The inquiry and response addressed the role of the Commonwealth Government and State Government, as well as appropriate authorities such as Police, Child Protection and Family Support regarding humbugging. [1]

The Commonwealth Government has taken action in various ways, including strategies such as compulsory and voluntary income management, and Cashless Debit Cards. [10] However, there still remains several limitations at the state level. Due to the necessity for definitions of family violence from the Restraining Orders Act 7997 (WA) or if instances of humbugging do not meet the World Health Organization's definition of elder abuse, then the instances are not an issue that engages State Government strategies. [1]

Further, even though such prevention strategies are being implemented, they are not always the most effective. A small-scale study focusing on income management in the Northern Territory found that many people had difficulty in understanding and using the BasicsCard, similar to a Cashless Debit Card, and felt that it did not aid them financially or alter their spending habits. [1] While a significant minority in the survey reported that it did help them reduce humbugging, this cannot be generalized to the overall population. [1] Overall, income management is reported to be able to provide a certain level of harm minimization which reduces, but cannot eliminate financial harassment and humbugging. [1]

Advocacy and community support has also been important in addressing humbugging, given that it has a broad definition that do not fit one specific crime or violation. The Kimberley Community Legal Services is a significant example of an independent, non-profit organization that provides free legal and financial counselling to disadvantaged peoples across the Kimberley region. [12] In 2020, they released a survey and report on financial elder abuse and humbugging. [8]

Banks and financial institutions

There have been multiple initiatives by banks and financial institutes to address humbugging. These include reports on the topics of financial resilience and equity, as well as the general socioeconomic context of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, to give further insight into humbugging. Both the Commonwealth Bank and National Australia Bank have partnered with academic or research organizations to release such reports. [9] [7]

A comparison between where people receive $2000 a week from. The total Indigenous sample size was 244, weighted to be representative of the Australian Indigenous population aged 18+. The total sample size was 1,685, weighted to be representative of the Australian population aged 18+. FinancialComparison.png
A comparison between where people receive $2000 a week from. The total Indigenous sample size was 244, weighted to be representative of the Australian Indigenous population aged 18+. The total sample size was 1,685, weighted to be representative of the Australian population aged 18+.

In one such report released by the National Australia Bank in partnership with the University of New South Wales, researchers found significant economic inequality between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people in Australia. [7] This is evidenced by a survey showing that only 1 in 10 Indigenous Australians are financially secure and almost half (48.8%) as experiencing severe or high financial stress. [7] This is in comparison to only 11% of the general population experiencing the same severe or high financial stress. [7] Thus, Indigenous people are represented in much higher proportions within Australians dealing with financial stress and insecurity.

In media

Humbugging in music and pop culture can be found in Warumpi Band's 1996 album titled Too Much Humbug. [13] They were an Australian Aboriginal rock band founded in the Northern Territory. [14] One of their tracks from Too Much Humbug, “Stompin’ Ground”, was nominated for “Best Indigenous Release” in the 1997 ARIA Awards. [15]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Torres Strait Islanders</span> Ethnic group of Australia

Torres Strait Islanders are the Indigenous Melanesian people of the Torres Strait Islands, which are part of the state of Queensland, Australia. Ethnically distinct from the Aboriginal peoples of the rest of Australia, they are often grouped with them as Indigenous Australians. Today there are many more Torres Strait Islander people living in mainland Australia than on the Islands.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Meriam people</span>

Melanesian Meriam people are an Indigenous Australian group of Torres Strait Islander people who are united by a common language, strong ties of kinship and live as skilled hunter–fisher–gatherers in family groups or clans on a number of inner eastern Torres Strait Islands including Mer or Murray Island, Ugar or Stephen Island and Erub or Darnley Island. The Meriam people are perhaps best known for their involvement in the High Court of Australia's Mabo decision which fundamentally changed land law in Australia - recognising native title.

Warumpi Band were an Australian country and Aboriginal rock group which formed in the outback settlement of Papunya, Northern Territory, in 1980. The original line-up was George Burarrwanga on vocals and didgeridoo, Gordon Butcher Tjapanangka on drums, his brother Sammy Butcher Tjapanangka on guitar and bass guitar, and Neil Murray on rhythm guitar and backing vocals. Their songs are in English, Luritja and Gumatj. Their key singles are "Jailanguru Pakarnu" (1983), "Blackfella/Whitefella" (1985), "Sit Down Money" (1986), "My Island Home" (1987) and "No Fear" (1987). The group released three albums, Big Name, No Blankets (1985), Go Bush! (1987) and Too Much Humbug (1996). From late 1987 to mid-1995 the group rarely performed as Murray focused on his solo career. In early 1995, Christine Anu, issued a cover version of "My Island Home". Warumpi Band regrouped before disbanding in 2000. Burarrwanga died on 10 June 2007 of lung cancer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies</span> Australian research institute for Indigenous studies

The Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies (AIATSIS), established as the Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies (AIAS) in 1964, is an independent Australian Government statutory authority. It is a collecting, publishing and research institute and is considered to be Australia's premier resource for information about the cultures and societies of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. The institute is a leader in ethical research and the handling of culturally sensitive material and holds in its collections many unique and irreplaceable items of cultural, historical and spiritual significance. The collection at AIATSIS has been built through over 50 years of research and engagement with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities and is now a source of language and culture revitalisation, native title research and family and community history. AIATSIS is located on Acton Peninsula in Canberra, Australian Capital Territory.

Australian Aboriginal English is a cover term used for the complex, rule-governed varieties of English used by a large section of the Indigenous Australian population as a result of colonization. It is made up of a number of varieties which developed differently in different parts of Australia, and grammar and pronunciation differs from that of standard Australian English, along a continuum. Some of its words have also been adopted into standard or colloquial Australian English.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">George Rrurrambu Burarrwanga</span> Aboriginal Australian musician

George Rrurrambu Burarrwanga, known in life as George Rrurrambu and George Djilangya, was known as the frontman of Warumpi Band, an Aboriginal rock band.

Yuendumu is a town in the Northern Territory of Australia, 293 km (182 mi) northwest of Alice Springs on the Tanami Road, within the Central Desert Region local government area. It ranks as one of the larger remote communities in central Australia, and has a thriving community of Aboriginal artists. It is home to Pintubi Anmatjere Warlpiri (PAW) Media, which produced the TV series Bush Mechanics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aboriginal Australians</span> First Nations peoples of the Australian continent

Aboriginal Australians are the various First Nations peoples of the Australian mainland and many of its islands, such as the peoples of Tasmania, Fraser Island, Hinchinbrook Island, the Tiwi Islands, and Groote Eylandt, but excluding the ethnically distinct Torres Strait Islands. The term Indigenous Australians refers to Aboriginal Australians and Torres Strait Islanders collectively.

Traditional knowledge (TK), indigenous knowledge (IK) and local knowledge generally refer to knowledge systems embedded in the cultural traditions of regional, indigenous, or local communities. According to the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) and the United Nations (UN), traditional knowledge and traditional cultural expressions (TCE) are both types of indigenous knowledge.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Elcho Island</span> Island of the Northern Territory, Australia

Elcho Island, known to its traditional owners as Galiwin'ku (Galiwinku) is an island off the coast of Arnhem Land, in the Northern Territory of Australia. It is located at the southern end of the Wessel Islands group located in the East Arnhem Region. Galiwin'ku is also the name of the settlement where the island's largest community lives. Elcho Island formed part of the traditional lands of the Yan-nhaŋu, according to Norman Tindale. According to J. C. Jennison, the Aboriginal inhabitants were the Dhuwal, who called themselves the Kokalango Mala (mala=clan.)

Indigenous Australians are people with familial heritage from, and membership in, the ethnic groups that lived in areas within the Australian continent before British colonisation. They consist of two distinct groups: the Aboriginal peoples of the Australian mainland and Tasmania, and the Torres Strait Islander peoples from the seas between Queensland and Papua New Guinea. The term Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples or the person's specific cultural group, is often preferred, though the terms First Nations of Australia, First Peoples of Australia and First Australians are also increasingly common; 812,728 people self-identified as being of Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander origin in the 2021 Australian Census, representing 3.2% of the total population of Australia. Of these Indigenous Australians, 91.4% identified as Aboriginal; 4.2% identified as Torres Strait Islander; while 4.4% identified with both groups. Since 1995, the Australian Aboriginal flag and the Torres Strait Islander flag have been official flags of Australia.

Indigenous intellectual property is a term used in national and international forums to describe intellectual property that is "collectively owned" by various Indigenous peoples, and by extension, their legal rights to protect specific such property. This property includes cultural knowledge of their groups and many aspects of their cultural heritage and knowledge, including that held in oral history. In Australia, the term Indigenous cultural and intellectual property, abbreviated as ICIP, is commonly used.

Indigenous Australian customary law refers to the legal systems and practices uniquely belonging to Indigenous Australians of Australia, that is, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people.

Indigenous Australians are both convicted of crimes and imprisoned at a disproportionately higher rate in Australia, as well as being over-represented as victims of crime. As of September 2019, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander prisoners represented 28% of the total adult prisoner population, while accounting for 2% of the general adult population. Various explanations have been given for this over-representation, both historical and more recent. Federal and state governments and Indigenous groups have responded with various analyses, programs and measures.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nyigina</span>

The Nyikina people are an Aboriginal Australian people of the Kimberley region of Western Australia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bunuba language</span> Aboriginal language of Australia

Bunuba is an Australian Aboriginal language spoken by some 41 older Bunuba adults, most of whom live in Junjuwa, an Aboriginal community in Fitzroy Crossing in Western Australia. Bunuba is not related to the Pama-Nyungan language family that spans the majority of Australia; however, it is a relative of Guniyandi. Both are subgroups of the Bunuban language family. Bunuba consists of two dialects, 'light' and 'heavy' Bunuba.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Indigenous health in Australia</span> Medical condition

Indigenous health in Australia examines health and wellbeing indicators of Indigenous Australians compared with the rest of the population. Statistics indicate that Aboriginal Australians and Torres Strait Islanders are much less healthy than other Australians. Various government strategies have been put into place to try to remediate the problem; there has been some improvement in several areas, but statistics between Indigenous Australians and the rest of the Australian population still show unacceptable levels of difference.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">June Oscar</span>

June Oscar is an Australian Aboriginal woman of Bunuba descent, Indigenous rights activist, community health and welfare worker, film and theatre ,and since 2017 and as of February 2022 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Commissioner.

<i>Mabo: Life of an Island Man</i> 1997 film by Trevor Graham

Mabo: Life of an Island Man is a 1997 Australian documentary film on the life of Indigenous Australian land rights campaigner Eddie Koiki Mabo.

Aboriginal Australian identity, sometimes known as Aboriginality, is the perception of oneself as Aboriginal Australian, or the recognition by others of that identity. Aboriginal Australians are one of two Indigenous Australian groups of peoples, the other being Torres Strait Islanders. There has also been discussion about the use of "Indigenous" vs "Aboriginal", or more specific group names, such as Murri or Noongar (demonyms), Kaurna or Yolngu, based on language, or a clan name. Usually preference of the person(s) in question is used, if known.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Government of Western Australia, Department of Communities. (2018). Inquiry into Elder Abuse – Humbugging.
  2. ↑ Fay H. Johnston, Susan P. Jacups, Amy J. Vickery and David M. J. S. Bowman "Ecohealth and Aboriginal Testimony of the Nexus Between Human Health and Place" EcoHealth 4, 489–499, 2007DOI: 10.1007/s10393-007-0142-0
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Nagel, T. & Thompson, C. (2010) The central role of Aboriginal families in motivational counselling: family support and family ‘humbug‘. Australian Indigenous HealthBulletin 10 (1).
  4. ↑ Humbug. (2021). Retrieved 21 December 2021, from https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/humbug.
  5. ↑ Humbug. (2021). Retrieved 21 December 2021, from https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/humbug.
  6. ↑ Dickens, Charles (1843). A Christmas Carol.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Weier, M., Dolan, K., Powell, A., Muir, K., Young, A. (2019) Money Stories: Financial Resilience among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians 2019 . Centre for Social Impact (CSI) – UNSW Sydney, for National Australia Bank.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Kimberley Community Legal Services. (2020). No More Humbug: Reducing Aboriginal Financial Elder Abuse in Kimberley . Kimberley Community Legal Services.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Gendered Violence Research Network. (2021). Understanding Economic and Financial Abuse in First Nations Communities .
  10. 1 2 3 Breunig, R., Hasan, S., & Hunter, B. (2017). Financial Stress and Indigenous Australians. SSRN Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3092565
  11. ↑ Westbury, N. & Dillon, M. C. (2019). Overcoming Indigenous exclusion: very hard, plenty humbug (Policy Insights Paper 1/2019). Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research, Australian National University, Canberra. doi: 10.25911/5cff8369abd6d
  12. ↑ Who We Are – Kimberley Community Legal Services. Kimberley Community Legal Services. (2021). Retrieved 21 December 2021, from https://www.kcls.org.au/who-we-are.
  13. ↑ Warumpi Band – Too Much Humbug. CAAMA Music. (2021). Retrieved 21 December 2021, from https://www.caamamusic.com.au/product/warumpi-band-too-much-humbug/
  14. ↑ Warumpi Band. Discogs. (2021). Retrieved 21 December 2021, from https://www.discogs.com/artist/552302-Warumpi-Band
  15. ↑ ARIA Awards Past Winners. (2022). Retrieved 11 January 2022. from https://www.aria.com.au/awards/past-winners/1997
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.