Israeli torture in the occupied territories

Last updated

Israeli torture in the occupied territories refers to the use of torture and systematic degrading practices on Palestinians detained by Israeli forces in both the West Bank and Gaza Strip. The practice, routine for decades, was eventually reviewed by the Supreme Court of Israel in 1999, which found that "coercive interrogation" of Palestinians had been widespread, and deemed it unlawful, though permissible in certain cases. [1] Torture is also practiced by the Palestinian authorities in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. [2]

Contents

Background

According to Lisa Hajjar (2005) and Dr. Rachel Stroumsa, the director of the Public Committee Against Torture in Israel, torture has been an abiding characteristic of Israeli methods of interrogation of Palestinians. [3] [4] Though formally banned by the High Court in 1999, legalized exceptions, authorized by the Attorney General of Israel, persist. [lower-alpha 1] According to Addameer, Israeli physicians are also complicit in interrogations involving torture. [6] [lower-alpha 2]

In 1987, Israel became the only country in the world where torture was considered legal. [8] [9] [10] The Supreme Court made another ruling in 1999 that curtailed the use of torture, [11] but controversially allowed a necessity defense for agents of the state accused of torture. [12] In 2018 another decision loosened the criteria for torture being excused and further enabled the institutionalization of torture. [13] [14]

During the early occupation years

Reports of torture as a means of extracting confessions arguably began early in the occupation, on evidence for the first decade. [15] In June 1977 the Sunday Times claimed torture was used against the Arab population of the occupied territories. [16] In early 1978 an employee of the US Consulate in East Jerusalem, Alexandra Johnson, [lower-alpha 3] sent two cables detailing evidence Israeli authorities were systematically using torture on West Bank suspects in Nablus, Ramallah, Hebron and the Russian compound of Jerusalem. Early reports indicated detainees were stripped naked and subject for long periods to cold showers or cold air ventilation. [18] People were hung from meat hooks in Hebron and Ramallah. [19] She concluded torture was applied at three rising levels of maltreatment, (a) level one: daily beatings with fists and sticks; (b) level two: alternate immersions of the victim in hot and cold water, beating of genitals and interrogation about twice daily over several hours; (c) level three: rotating teams of interrogators working on a nude person under detention by applying electrical devices, high frequency sonic noise, refrigeration, prolonged hanging by the hands or feet, and inserting objects into their penises or rectums. This last level was used on those who refused at earlier levels to denounce other Palestinians. [20] At the time, Israel described these allegations as "fantastic horror stories." In private, however, Prime Minister Menachem Begin ordered a curtailing of the use of violent interrogation techniques, after which the allegations of torture decreased for the next several years. The hiatus on torture ended in the early 1980s. [21]

78% of a sample of 40 detainees in 1985 said they had been sexually molested, and 67% stated they had been humiliated on religious grounds. [22] Former inmates of the secret detention centre Camp 1391, whose existence is not even officially acknowledged, claim sexual harassment, even rape, forms part of the interrogation techniques. [23] The first important study was conducted by the first Palestinian NGO, al-Haq, in 1986, [24] which focused on practices at the Al Fara'a Detention Centre.

During the First Intifada and onwards

Other techniques include shabeh , a practice 76% of the Israel public (1998) thought a form of torture, but only 27% opposed its use against Palestinians. [25] Methods vary. For example, it may consist of being forced to sit on a very small chair, with a hood over one's head, and forced to listen loud musc. It could, as with one woman, last up to 10 days, night and day; [26] also included among torture techniques was the beating of the bare soles of detainees' feet ( falaqa ), or subjecting them, while deprived of sleep, to endless lectures on themes like: "All Arabs are Bedouin, and Bedouin are Saudis, so Palestinians should go back to Saudi Arabia, where they came from. You don't belong here." [27] [lower-alpha 4] Blindfolding is used so that the suspect can never anticipate when he is to be struck. [5] In the First Intifada, other than prolonged beatings, people, including children, could be smeared with vomit or urine, be confined in a "coffin", be suspended by the wrists; be denied food and water or access to toilets, or be threatened to have their sisters, wives or mothers raped. [29] Methods, including torture, practiced also on Palestinian children were reported to persist with Amnesty International stating in 2018 that though over 1,000 complaints have been filed regarding these practices since 2001, "no criminal investigations were opened." [30] [lower-alpha 5]

Human rights organizations have reported specifically on the torture of minors by Israel. During the Human Rights Watch reported in 2002 that over 300 Palestinian minors had been tortured through beating, deprivation of sleep and dousing with freezing water. Israeli human rights group B'Tselem reported similarly in 2001 that Palestinian minors had their heads covered and subject to severe beatings and other abuse. B'Tselem concluded that these reports were "not isolated cases or uncommon conduct by certain police officers, but methods of torture adopted at the police station." Upon filing complaints with Israeli officials, B'Tselem reports that "the authorities have made no serious effort to address the root of the problem. Similarly, they have made no attempt to prosecute the violent police officers." [32] [33]

One major case, in which 20 men from Beita and Huwara were taken from their homes, gagged and bound hand and foot and then had their limbs broken with clubs, eventually reached the Israeli Supreme Court. [lower-alpha 6] [35] In 2017, the alleged torture of Fawzi al-Junaidi, a 16 year old Palestinian boy, in Israeli detention drew media spotlight. [36] A roadside bomb in 2019 leading to the death of an Israeli girl triggered a manhunt by the Shin Bet where up to 50 Palestinians were rounded up and reportedly subjected to some form of torture. [37] 3 of the alleged suspects were hospitalised, one of them with kidney failure and 11 broken ribs while another was "nearly unrecognisable to his wife when he was wheeled into a courtroom". [38]

Such torture is not thought to be very effective. A West Bank member of Hamas gave evidence under torture implicating himself and that organization in the 2014 kidnapping and murder of Israeli teenagers. The extorted confession turned out to be false. [5] Recourse to Israeli courts to obtain recompense and rehabilitation for the psychological damage caused by being tortured are rarely conceded and are exceptional. Financial settlements were given for cases in the 1980s and 1990s, but only if the victim underwrote a clause which absolved the state of Israeli of declaring that the plaintiff had been a victim of torture. [39]

During the Israel–Hamas war

On November 8, Amnesty International reported on cases of torture and degrading treatment by Israeli authorities, which it described as "horrifying", "gruesome", and "a particularly chilling public display of torture and humiliation of Palestinian detainees." [40] In relation to the recent spike in detentions, Amnesty's Secretary General, Agnès Callamard, noted that "arbitrary detention and torture and other ill-treatment are war crimes when committed against protected persons in an occupied territory." [41]

On December 3, the United Nations Human Rights Office in the occupied Palestinian territories called for an investigation into allegations of torture. [42] In a statement, the Office said: "The massive rise in number of Palestinians arrested and detained, the number of reports of ill-treatment and humiliation suffered by those in custody, and the reported failure to adhere to basic due process raise serious questions about Israel's compliance with international humanitarian law and international human rights law." [42] On 19 January, the Human Rights Office stated they had interviewed detainees who "described being beaten, humiliated, subjected to ill-treatment, and to what may amount to torture... consistent with reports our Office has been gathering of the detention of Palestinians on a broad scale." [43] In March 2024, a UNRWA report reported "countless" instances of torture documented in Israeli prisons, including beatings and sexual assault. [44] [45]

The Public Committee Against Torture in Israel (PCATI) stated that there was a "lot of evidence of cases of violence and cruel and humiliating treatment by prison guards", and called for an investigation into the deaths of detainees in Israeli custody. [46] PCATI stated they had documented nine clear instances of torture, including sexual violence. [47] On January 3, 2024, Human Rights Watch reported that Palestinian workers from Gaza detained in Israel since October 7 had been photographed naked, attacked by dogs, and dragged faced down in the gravel. [48] In a report on allegations of torture in Israeli prisons, Euro-Med Monitor stated prisoners were being treated like animals. [49] The Wall Street Journal found detainees underwent psychological and physical abuse, including beatings during interrogations. [50] Doctors reported humiliation, beatings, and being forced to kneel for hours. [51] Adalah reported, "We’re seeing really widespread and systemic use of many, many tools in order to inflict torture and ill-treatment on Palestinians". [52]

A Defence for Children International report included the testimony of an incarcerated child who stated, "Around 18 children were severely beaten, screaming in pain. I saw police dogs attacking them, bleeding from the mouth and head." [53] The United Nations human rights office reported some detainees were released wearing only diapers. [54] Addameer reported that prisoners remained blindfolded and handcuffed during their detention and people were being killed in the military camps. [55] In March 2024, the UN stated that Israel had detained and tortured its employees in Gaza to extract forced confessions. [56] [57]

See also

Notes

  1. "subsequent regulations issued by the then-Attorney General Elyakim Rubinstein said interrogators who nevertheless used torture would not stand trial if they could demonstrate that it was 'immediately necessary to save his own or another person's life, freedom, person or property from a concrete danger of serious harm', and that 'there was no other way to do so.' The regulations stipulated, however, that only very senior officials could permit the use of these methods, and that any interrogator who used them must keep a detailed record of the number of blows, the painful positions and all other so-called special means used. In addition, the attorney general must be informed after every use of such methods." [5]
  2. ‘the majority of torture practices are preceded by medical examinations of detainees to green-light torture.’ [7]
  3. She was dismissed from her position shortly afterwards, despite recognition of the excellence of her work as an analyst, on the ostensible grounds she did not get on well with her colleagues. [17]
  4. Speaking of completing course work for becoming an intelligence officer, one former member of Unit 8100 said it ended with a full dress performance of pretending to be Palestinians, with the students shouting: "Enough with Palestine, we want to relocate to Australia!" [28]
  5. One case, where a Palestinian woman was forced to undergo two successive vaginal and anal probes during a single night raid conducted by the IDF under Shin Bet instructions, may prove an exception. Her protest was ignored, she spent two years in prison for minor offenses, and was then re-imprisoned for "nationalist" activities, and finally fled abroad due to trauma and shame. Only the persistence of an Israeli woman attorney Jana Mudzgurishvilly, in the Mivtan unit that closed all the other 1,000 cases, brought her complaint to the attention of the Justice Department, which has yet to decide what steps to take. [31]
  6. The description is that of the Supreme Court judge Moshe Bejski, who had survived the Holocaust as one of those on Oskar Schindler's list. [34]

Citations

  1. Clarke 2013, pp. 100, 102–103.
  2. HRW 2018.
  3. Aharony 2018.
  4. Hajjar 2005, p. 195.
  5. 1 2 3 Levinson 2017.
  6. Kathuria 2024.
  7. Addameer 2022, p. 97.
  8. "Torture by the GSS". B'Tselem. 1999. Archived from the original on 15 November 2002. Retrieved 28 June 2024.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
  9. "Israel: Torture still used systematically as Israel presents its report to the Committee Against Torture" (PDF). Amnesty International . 15 May 1998. Retrieved 28 June 2024.
  10. "It's now (even more) official: torture is legal in Israel". OMCT . 21 March 2019. Retrieved 28 June 2024.
  11. Ballas, Irit (August 2020). "Fracturing the "Exception": The Legal Sanctioning of Violent Interrogation Methods in Israel since 1987". Law & Social Inquiry. 45 (3): 818–838. doi: 10.1017/lsi.2020.11 .
  12. Ben-Natan, Smadar (9 June 2019). "Revise Your Syllabi: Israeli Supreme Court Upholds Authorization for Torture and Ill-Treatment". Journal of International Humanitarian Legal Studies. 10 (1): 41–57. doi:10.1163/18781527-01001008. ISSN   1878-1373.
  13. Schiemann, John Wilson (30 October 2019). "Institutionalizing torture in Israel: The Firas Tbeish decision. A commentary by John W. Schiemann, PhD". Torture. 29 (2): 103–107. doi: 10.7146/torture.v29i2.116127 . PMID   31670709.
  14. Ben-Natan, Smadar (9 June 2019). "Revise Your Syllabi: Israeli Supreme Court Upholds Authorization for Torture and Ill-Treatment". Journal of International Humanitarian Legal Studies. 10 (1): 41–57. doi:10.1163/18781527-01001008.
  15. Bishara 1979, p. 22.
  16. Bishara 1979, pp. 7–8.
  17. Bishara 1979, p. 11.
  18. Punamäki 1988, p. 82.
  19. Bishara 1979, pp. 21–22.
  20. Bishara 1979, p. 20.
  21. Hoffman, Valerie J. (28 February 2019). Making the New Middle East: Politics, Culture, and Human Rights. Syracuse University Press. pp. 247–248. ISBN   978-0-8156-5457-5.
  22. Punamäki 1988, pp. 86–87.
  23. Peak & Everett 2015, p. 306.
  24. Allen 2013, p. 46.
  25. Montell 2000, p. 108.
  26. Montell 2000, p. 106.
  27. Hajjar 2005, p. 197.
  28. The Guardian & 12 Sep 2014.
  29. Graff 2015, p. 174.
  30. AI 2018b, p. 209.
  31. Breiner & Berger 2018.
  32. B'Tselem, Torture of Palestinian Minors in the Gush Etzion Police Station (Jerusalem, 2001)
  33. "Israel, the Occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip, and Palestinian Authority Territories" in Human Rights Watch World Report 2002 (New York)"
  34. Conroy 2001, pp. 48ff., 59.
  35. Graff 2015, pp. 173–174.
  36. "'Bruised and denied care': Fawzi al-Junaidi out on bail". Al Jazeera. Archived from the original on 8 April 2018. Retrieved 19 September 2020.
  37. "Israel Accused of Torturing Palestinians After Fatal Bombing". VOA. 10 February 2020. Archived from the original on 12 February 2020. Retrieved 19 September 2020.
  38. "Bitten at genitals by security dog, 11 broken ribs and unrecognisable face: The cruel face of Israeli torture". The New Indian Express. 10 February 2020. Retrieved 19 September 2020.
  39. Weishut 2015, p. 72.
  40. "Israel/OPT: Horrifying cases of torture and degrading treatment of Palestinian detainees amid spike in arbitrary arrests". Amnesty International. 8 November 2023. Retrieved 9 November 2023.
  41. "Israel/ OPT: Deal to release hostages and prisoners must pave way for further releases and a sustained ceasefire". Amnesty International. 22 November 2023. Retrieved 24 November 2023.
  42. 1 2 "UN rights office 'seriously concerned' about Israel's increased arrest of Palestinians". Reuters. 1 December 2023. Archived from the original on 2 December 2023. Retrieved 4 December 2023.
  43. "UN official describes meeting released Palestinian detainees on Gaza trip". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 20 January 2024.
  44. Borger, Julian (5 March 2024). "Palestinians 'beaten and sexually assaulted' at Israeli detention centres, UN report claims". The Guardian. Retrieved 18 March 2024.
  45. Speakman Cordall, Simon; Pedrosa, Veronica. "Not just the UNRWA report: Countless accounts of Israeli torture in Gaza". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 16 March 2024.
  46. "Israeli rights group says evidence of violence against Palestinian prisoners increasing". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 2 January 2024.
  47. "Rights advocates denounce 'systemic abuse' in Israeli prisons". France24. 16 March 2024. Retrieved 19 March 2024.
  48. "Israel: Gaza Workers Held Incommunicado for Weeks". Human Rights Watch. 3 January 2024. Retrieved 4 January 2024.
  49. "In Israeli army camps, Gazan detainees subjected to torture and degrading treatment". Euro-Med Human Rights Monitor. Retrieved 8 January 2024.
  50. AbdulKarim, Fatima; Rasmussen, Sune Engel; Peled, Anat. "Palestinians Describe Beatings, Stress Positions, Other Alleged Abuses in Israeli Detention". WSJ. Retrieved 16 March 2024.
  51. Cuddy, Alice (12 March 2024). "Gaza medics tell BBC that Israeli troops beat and humiliated them after hospital raid". BBC. Retrieved 18 March 2024.
  52. Sedghi, Amy (16 March 2024). "Rights advocates denounce 'systemic abuse' in Israeli prisons". The Guardian. Retrieved 20 March 2024.
  53. "Palestinian child detained without charge attacked by Israeli military dog". Defense for Children International. Retrieved 14 January 2024.
  54. Abdulrahim, Raja (23 January 2024). "Stripped, Beaten or Vanished: Israel's Treatment of Gaza Detainees Raises Alarm". The New York Times. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  55. "Israel deliberately spread shocking images of blindfolded Palestinian prisoners: Lawyer". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 31 January 2024.
  56. "UN Agency For Palestinians Says Israel Authorities Tortured Detained Staff". Barron's. Agence France Presse. Retrieved 6 March 2024.
  57. Diamond, Jeremy (4 March 2024). "UN agency accuses Israel of detaining, coercing staffers into false confessions about ties to Hamas". CNN. Retrieved 6 March 2024.

Sources

Further reading

Related Research Articles

Hooding is the placing of a hood over the entire head of a prisoner. Hooding is widely considered to be a form of torture; one legal scholar considers the hooding of prisoners to be a violation of international law, specifically the Third and Fourth Geneva Conventions, which demand that persons under custody or physical control of enemy forces be treated humanely. Hooding can be dangerous to a prisoner's health and safety. It is considered to be an act of torture when its primary purpose is sensory deprivation during interrogation; it causes "disorientation, isolation, and dread." According to the International Committee of the Red Cross, hooding is used to prevent a person from seeing, to disorient them, to make them anxious, to preserve their torturer's anonymity, and to prevent the person from breathing freely.

This article describes the use of torture since the adoption of the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), which prohibited it. Torture is prohibited by international law and is illegal in most countries. However, it is still used by many governments.

Ghost detainee is a term used in the executive branch of the United States government to designate a person held in a detention center, whose identity has been hidden by keeping them unregistered and therefore anonymous. Such uses arose as the Bush administration initiated the War on Terror following the 9/11 attacks of 2001 in the United States. As documented in the 2004 Taguba Report, it was used in the same manner by United States officials and contractors of the Joint Interrogation and Debriefing Center at the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq in 2003–2004.

Torture in Bahrain refers to the violation of Bahrain's obligations as a state party to the United Nations Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment and other international treaties and disregard for the prohibition of torture enshrined in Bahraini law.

Administrative detention is arrest and detention of individuals by the state without trial. A number of jurisdictions claim that it is done for security reasons. Many countries claim to use administrative detention as a means to combat terrorism or rebellion, to control illegal immigration, or to otherwise protect the ruling regime.

International human rights organizations, along with the United Nations, and the United States Department of State, have reported human rights violations committed by the State of Israel, particularly against minority groups. These reports include violations of the rights of Palestinians, both inside and outside Israel as well as other groups in Israel.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Camp 1391</span> Israeli secret prison camp

Camp 1391, also referred to as Unit 1391 or Facility 1391, is an Israel Defense Forces prison camp in northern Israel for "high-risk" prisoners. It is run by Unit 504. The existence of the prison was unknown to the public before 2003, and most information about it remains classified, although the Supreme Court of Israel ordered the release of some information about the jail.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Khalida Jarrar</span> Palestinian politician

Khalida Jarrar is a Palestinian politician. She is a member of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) and the Palestinian Legislative Council (PLC). She was elected to the PLC in January 2006 as one of the PFLP's three deputies and has continued to serve as an elected representative ever since. She is also the Palestinian representative on the Council of Europe and is currently head of the Prisoners Committee of the PLC. She played a major role in Palestine's application to join the International Criminal Court.

The future of Palestinian prisoners detained by Israel in the context of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict is considered central to progress in the Israeli–Palestinian peace process. Cases of prison sentences include the charges of terrorism or being a member of an "illegal terrorist organization", such as Hamas or prior to the Oslo Accords the Palestine Liberation Organization, but according to some accounts also by political activism such as raising a Palestinian flag.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Landau Commission</span>

The Landau Commission was a three-man Commission set up by the Israeli Government in 1987 following a long-running scandal over the deaths of two Palestinian prisoners in custody and the wrongful conviction of a Circassian IDF officer. The Commission, headed by former Supreme Court Justice Moshe Landau, found that the GSS interrogators routinely used physical force during the interrogation of prisoners and then committed perjury at subsequent trials. In its conclusion, approved by Cabinet in November 1987, it lay down guidelines for the use of a "moderate measure of physical pressure". The details of the recommended methods were described in the classified appendix to the report. In 1994 the UN Committee Against Torture stated: "The Landau Commission Report, permitting as it does 'moderate physical pressure' as a lawful mode of interrogation, is completely unacceptable to this Committee."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ktzi'ot Prison</span> Gulag or Political Concentration Center for Jewish and Arab dissidents in Israel

Ktzi'ot Prison is an Israeli detention facility located in the Negev desert 45 miles (72 km) south-west of Beersheba. It is Israel's largest detention facility in terms of land area, encompassing 400,000 m2.

Khader Adnan Mohammad Musa was a Palestinian activist and prisoner in Israel who died after an 87-day hunger strike in protest of his detention without trial. By the time of his death, he had been arrested 12 times by Israel. He became prominent as a figure after a 66-day hunger strike in 2011 that led to a mass hunger strike among Palestinian prisoners and his ultimate release.

The Al-Moskobiya, Moscobiyeh, Muscovite or Moscovia Detention Centre is an Israeli detention and interrogation facility and prison in the Russian Compound of West Jerusalem. The center is used to interrogate Palestinian detainees and prisoners from a variety of age groups, including children. The Palestinian NGO Addameer has alleged that harsh methods of torture are used there.

Torture in the State of Palestine refers to the use of torture and systematic degrading practices on civilians detained by Palestinian forces in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. As of 2018, Amnesty reported that LGBT people were subjected to arbitrary arrest and ill-treatment.

Addameer, officially Addameer Prisoner Support and Human Rights Association, is a Palestinian NGO based in Ramallah.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mass detentions in the Israel–Hamas war</span> Arrest and detention of Palestinians since October 2023

Since the outbreak of the Israel–Hamas war on October 7, 2023, Israel has carried out mass arrests and detentions of Palestinians. Thousands have been arrested in the Israeli-occupied Palestinian territories and in Israel, based on alleged militant activity, offensive social media postings, or arbitrarily.

The 2023 Israel–Hamas war led to an intensive interrogation program by Israeli intelligence agencies, particularly Israel's domestic security agency, Shin Bet and IDF's Unit 504, targeting captured "Hamas militants". Following the sudden attack on 7 October, which killed more than 1,100 Israelis, alleged militants were captured in Israel. Israel has claimed that the interrogation of the suspects revealed significant insights into the group's strategies, ideologies, and operational methods that played a crucial role in Israel's military response and in shaping the global understanding of the conflict.

During the ongoing Israel–Hamas war, Israeli male and female soldiers, guards as well as medical staff have reportedly committed wartime sexual violence against Palestinian children, women and men; including rape, gang-rape, sexualized torture and mutilation. In February UN experts cited at least two cases of Palestinian women being raped by male Israeli soldiers. Palestinian boys and men have also been raped and subjected to torture, and in some cases the torture has led to the victim's death.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Torture during the Israel–Hamas war</span>

During the Israel–Hamas war, Israel has systematically tortured Palestinians detained in its prison system. This torture has been reported by the United Nations, Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, as well as Israeli nonprofit human rights organizations such as Physicians for Human Rights Israel and B'Tselem.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sde Teiman detention camp</span> Israeli military base detaining Palestinians

Sde Teiman is an Israeli military base located in the Negev desert near the border with the Gaza Strip. During the Israel–Hamas war, its use as a detention camp doubled and gained international attention for its systemic human rights violations against its Palestinian detainees from the strip.