| School | Location | Religious order | Founded | Closed | Ref |
|---|
| Ascension School | Halethorpe | – | 1913 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| Bishop John Neumann School | Baltimore | – | 1974 | 2004 | [3] |
| Blessed Sacrament School | Baltimore | – | – | 1972 | [4] |
| Father Charles Hall Catholic School | Baltimore | Franciscan Sisters of Philadelphia | 1973 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| Holy Angels Catholic School | Baltimore | – | 2012 | 2017 | [5] |
| Holy Cross School | Baltimore | Sisters of Christian Charity | 1855 | 1972 | [6] |
| Holy Family School | Randallstown | – | 1876 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| Holy Rosary Elementary School | Baltimore | Felician Sisters | 1890s | 1997 | [7] |
| Holy Spirit School | Baltimore | – | – | 2004 | [3] |
| John Paul Regional Catholic School | Baltimore | – | – | 2017 | [8] |
| Most Precious Blood School | Baltimore | – | 1960 | 1988 | [9] |
| Mother Mary Lange Catholic School | Baltimore | Oblate Sisters of Providence | 2005 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| Our Lady of Fatima School | Baltimore | – | 1951 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| Our Lady of Good Counsel School | Baltimore | School Sisters of Notre Dame | 1929 | 1972 | [10] |
| Our Lady of Pompeii School | Baltimore | – | – | 2001 | [1] [2] |
| Our Lady of Victory School | Arbutus | Sisters of Notre Dame de Namur | 1957 | 2021 | [11] |
| Sacred Heart of Mary School | Baltimore | – | 1925 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| Shrine of the Little Flower School | Bel Air | – | 1926 | 2005 | [2] |
| Shrine of the Sacred Heart School | Baltimore | Sisters of Mercy | 1867 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| St. Agnes School | Catonsville | – | 1865 | 2025 | [12] |
| St. Alphonsus School | Baltimore | – | 1847 | 2002 | [13] |
| St. Ambrose Catholic School | Baltimore | – | 1926 | 2012 | [14] |
| St. Anthony of Padua School | Baltimore | – | 1884 | 2005 | [2] |
| St. Bernadine School | Baltimore | Sisters, Servants of the Immaculate Heart of Mary | 1928 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| St. Clare School | Essex | – | 1956 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| St. Dominic School | Baltimore | – | 1906 | 2005 | [2] |
| St. Joseph School | Taneytown | School Sisters of Notre Dame | – | 1972 | [4] |
| St. Katharine School | Baltimore | – | 1902 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| St. Mary, Star of the Sea School | Baltimore | Sisters of St. Joseph | 1877 | 1972 | [15] |
| St. Pius X School | Rodgers Forge | – | – | 2021 | [16] |
| St. Rose of Lima School | Baltimore | – | 1914 | 2010 | [1] [2] |
| St. Thomas Aquinas School | Baltimore | – | – | 2017 | [17] |
| St. Wenceslaus School | Baltimore | School Sisters of Notre Dame | 1879 | – | [18] |
| St. William of York School | Baltimore | Holy Union Sisters | 1950 | 2010 | [1] [2] |