Outer Critics Circle Award for Best Actor in a Musical

Last updated
Outer Critics Circle Award for
Best Lead Actor in a Musical
Awarded forBest Lead Actor in a Musical
Location New York City
Presented by Outer Critics Circle
StatusRetired
Website OuterCriticsCircle.org

The Outer Critics Circle Award for Best Actor in a Musical was an annual award given to the best actor in a musical on Broadway or Off-Broadway, as determined by Outer Critics Circle. The award was renamed Outstanding Actor in a Musical beginning in 1999.

Contents

The award was preceded by an award for Best Performance, but the newly gendered award for musical performance was first given out the 1987–1988 season through the season. The award was retired in 2022 and replaced by gender-neutral performance categories. [1]

Awards winners

1980s

  indicates the winner.
YearActorWorkRoleRef.
1988
Michael Crawford The Phantom of the Opera Phantom [2]
1989
Jason Alexander Jerome Robbins' Broadway Narrator [3]

1990s

YearActorWorkRoleRef.
1990
Michael Jeter Grand Hotel Otto Kringelein [4]
James Naughton City of Angels Stone
Rene Auberjonois Buddy Fidler/Irwin S. Irving
Jonathan Hadary Gypsy Herbie
Bob Gunton Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street Sweeney Todd
1991
Jonathan Pryce Miss Saigon The Engineer [5]
Paul Hipp Buddy Buddy Holly
Evan Pappas I Can Get It for You Wholesale Bogen
Mandy Patinkin The Secret Garden Lord Archibald Craven
1992
Nathan Lane Guys and Dolls Nathan Detroit [6]
Harry Groener Crazy for You Bobby Child
Spiro Malas The Most Happy Fella Tony Esposito
Keith Carradine The Will Rogers Follies Will Rogers
1993
Martin Short The Goodbye Girl Nathan Detroit [7]
Mike Burstyn Ain't Broadway GrandMike Todd
Gregory Hines Jelly's Last Jam Jelly Roll Morton
Michael Cerveris The Who's Tommy Tommy
1994
Boyd Gaines She Loves Me Georg Nowack [8]
1995
Matthew Broderick How to Succeed in Business without Really Trying J. Pierrepont Finch [9]
1996
Nathan Lane A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum Prologus/Pseudolus [10]
1997
Robert Cuccioli Jekyll & Hyde Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde [11]
James Naughton Chicago Billy Flynn
Gregory Harrison Steel Pier Mick Hamilton
Sam Harris The Life Jojo
1998
Alan Cumming Cabaret Emcee [12]
John Cameron Mitchell Hedwig and the Angry Inch Hedwig
Brian Stokes Mitchell Ragtime Coalhouse Walker Jr.
Douglas Sills The Scarlet Pimpernel Sir Percy Blakeney
1999
Martin Short Little Me The Men of Belle's Life [13]
Jeremy Kushnier Footloose Ren McCormack
Tom Wopat Annie Get Your Gun Frank Butler
Brent Carver Parade Leo Frank

2000s

YearActorWorkRoleRef.
2000
Brian Stokes Mitchell Kiss Me, Kate Fred Graham/Petruchio [14]
James Carpinello Saturday Night Fever Tony
Craig Bierko The Music Man Prof. Harold Hill
Taye Diggs The Wild Party Mr. Black
2001
Nathan Lane The Producers Max Bialystock [15]
Michael Cumpsty 42nd Street Julian Marsh
Patrick Wilson The Full Monty Jerry Lukowski
Matthew Broderick The Producers Leopold "Leo" Bloom
2002
John Lithgow Sweet Smell of Success J.J. Hunsecker [16]
John Cullum Urinetown Caldwell B. Cladwell
Brian d'Arcy James Sweet Smell of Success Sidney Falcone
Hunter Foster Urinetown Bobby Strong
2003
Antonio Banderas Nine Guido Contini [17]
Harvey Fierstein Hairspray Edna Turnblad
Roger Rees A Man of No Importance Alfie Byrne
Brian Stokes Mitchell Man of La Mancha Don Quixote/Miguel de Cervantes
Jason Petty Hank Williams: Lost Highway Hank Williams
2004
Hugh Jackman The Boy From Oz Peter Allen [18]
Alfred Molina Fiddler on the Roof Tevye
Euan Morton Taboo George
Gregg Edelman Wonderful Town Robert Baker
Hunter Foster Little Shop of Horrors Seymour Krelborn
2005
Norbert Leo Butz Dirty Rotten Scoundrels Freddy Benson [19]
Denis O'Hare Sweet Charity Oscar Lindquist
Tim Curry Spamalot King Arthur
Raúl Esparza Chitty Chitty Bang Bang Caractacus Potts
Cheyenne Jackson All Shook Up Chad
2006
John Lloyd Young Jersey Boys Frankie Valli [20]
Michael Cerveris Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street Sweeney Todd
Harry Connick, Jr. The Pajama Game Sid Sorokin
Hugh Panaro Lestat Lestat
2007
Raúl Esparza Company Bobby [21]
Michael Cerveris LoveMusik Kurt Weill
David Hyde Pierce Curtains Lieutenant Frank Cioffi
Gavin Lee Mary Poppins Bert
2008
Paulo Szot South Pacific Emile de Becque [22]
Boyd Gaines Gypsy Herbie
Roger Bart Young Frankenstein Dr. Frederick Frankenstein
Daniel Evans Sunday in the Park with George George/Georges
2009
Brian d'Arcy James Shrek the Musical Shrek [23]
James Barbour A Tale of Two Cities Sydney Carton
Josh Grisetti Enter LaughingDavid Kolowitz
Matt Cavenaugh West Side Story Tony
David Pittu What's That Smell: The Music of Jacob SterlingJacob Sterling

2010s

YearActorWorkRoleRef.
2010
Douglas Hodge La Cage aux Folles Albin [24]
Nathan Lane The Addams Family Gomez Addams
Brandon Victor Dixon The Scottsboro Boys Haywood Patterson
Sean Hayes Promises, Promises Chuck Baxter
Chad Kimball Memphis Huey Calhoun
2011
Josh Gad The Book of Mormon Elder Cunningham [25]
Daniel Radcliffe How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying J. Pierrepont Finch
Aaron Tveit Catch Me If You Can Frank Abagnale, Jr.
Norbert Leo Butz Carl Hanratty
Tony Sheldon Priscilla Queen of the Desert Bernadette
2012
Danny Burstein Follies Buddy Plummer [26]
Jeremy Jordan Newsies Jack Kelly
Raúl Esparza Leap of Faith Jonas Nightingale
Steve Kazee Once Guy
Norm Lewis The Gershwins' Porgy and Bess Porgy
2013
Billy Porter Kinky Boots Lola [27]
Matthew James Thomas Pippin Pippin
Bertie Carvel Matilda Miss Trunchbull
Santino Fontana Rodgers + Hammerstein's Cinderella Topher
Rob McClure Chaplin Charlie Chaplin
2014
Jefferson Mays A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder The D'Ysquith Family [28]
Neil Patrick Harris Hedwig and the Angry Inch Hedwig
Michael Cerveris Fun Home Bruce Bechdel
Bryce Pinkham A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder Montague D'Ysquith Navarro
Andy Karl Rocky Rocky Balboa
2015
Robert Fairchild An American in Paris Jerry Mulligan [29]
Peter Gallagher On the Twentieth Century Oscar Jaffee
Christian Borle Something Rotten! William Shakespeare
Tony Yazbeck On the Town Gabey
Brian d'Arcy James Something Rotten! Nick Bottom
2016
Danny Burstein Fiddler on the Roof Tevye [30]
Robert CreightonCagney James Cagney
Alex Brightman School of Rock Dewey Finn
Ben Platt Dear Evan Hansen Evan Hansen
Benjamin Walker American Psycho Patrick Bateman
2017
Andy Karl Groundhog Day Phil Connors [31]
David Hyde Pierce Hello, Dolly! Horace Vandergelder
Christian Borle Falsettos Marvin
Nick Cordero A Bronx Tale Sonny
Tony Shalhoub The Band's Visit Tewfiq
2018
Ethan Slater SpongeBob SquarePants SpongeBob SquarPants [32]
Conor Ryan Desperate Measures Johnny Blood
Harry Hadden-Paton My Fair Lady Professor Henry Higgins
Joshua Henry Carousel Billy Bigelow
2019
Santino Fontana Tootsie Michael Dorsey / Dorothy Michaels [33]
Damon Daunno Oklahoma! Curly McLain
Steven Skybell Fiddler on the Roof in Yiddish Tevye
Reeve Carney Hadestown Orpheus
Brooks Ashmanskas The Prom Barry Glickman

2020s

YearActorWorkRoleRef.
2020 (Hon.) Larry Owens A Strange Loop Usher [34]
Adam Kantor Darling GrenadineHarry
Jonathan Groff Little Shop of Horrors Seymour Krelborn
Aaron Tveit Moulin Rouge! Christian
Joshua Henry The Wrong ManDuran
Isaac Powell West Side Story Tony

Multiple wins

3 wins
2 wins

Multiple nominations

4 nominations
3 nominations
2 nominations

References

  1. Andrew Gans (January 24, 2023). "Dates Set for 2023 Outer Critics Circle Awards; Gender Removed From Acting Categories". Playbill.
  2. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1988". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  3. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1989". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  4. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1990". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  5. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1991". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  6. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1992". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  7. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1993". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  8. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1994". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  9. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1995". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  10. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1996". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  11. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1997". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  12. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1998". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  13. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 1999". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  14. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2000". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  15. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2000-2001". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  16. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2001-2002". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  17. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2002-2003". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  18. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2003-2004". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  19. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2004-2005". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  20. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2005-2006". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  21. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2006-2007". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  22. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2007-2008". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  23. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2008-2009". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  24. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2009-2010". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  25. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2010-2011". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  26. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2011-2012". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  27. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2012-2013". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  28. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2013-2014". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  29. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2014-2015". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  30. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2015-2016". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  31. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2016-2017". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  32. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2017-2018". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  33. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2018-2019". AboutTheArtists. Retrieved August 23, 2025.
  34. "Outer Critics Circle Awards 2020". BroadwayWorld. Retrieved August 23, 2025.