Pennsylvania College Cases

Last updated

Trustees of Jefferson College in Canonsburg v. Washington and Jefferson College
Seal of the United States Supreme Court.svg
Decided December 1, 1871
Full case nameTrustees of Jefferson College in Canonsburg v. Washington and Jefferson College
Citations80 U.S. 190 ( more )
13 Wall. 190; 20 L. Ed. 550; 1871 U.S. LEXIS 1330;
Court membership
Chief Justice
Salmon P. Chase
Associate Justices
Samuel Nelson  · Nathan Clifford
Noah H. Swayne  · Samuel F. Miller
David Davis  · Stephen J. Field
William Strong  · Joseph P. Bradley
Case opinion
MajorityClifford, joined by unanimous
Jefferson College 1830 EDITED.jpg
The main buildings at Jefferson College in Canonsburg, Pennsylvania as they appeared ca. 1850
Old Main 1850.jpg
Old Main and McMillan Hall at Washington College in Washington, Pennsylvania as they appeared ca. 1850.
These buildings would be part of the unified Washington & Jefferson College; Old Main would later be adorned with two spires to symbolize the union.

The Pennsylvania College Cases, also known as Trustees of Jefferson College in Canonsburg v. Washington and Jefferson College, was a United States Supreme Court case that was decided in 1871. [1] Justice Nathan Clifford wrote the opinion, ruling in favor of Washington & Jefferson College. [1]

Contents

In 1865, two colleges in Washington County, Pennsylvania, Jefferson College in Canonsburg and Washington College in Washington merged to form Washington & Jefferson College, which maintained two campuses, one in each of the towns. [2]

That arrangement failed, and in 1869, the trustees voted to consolidate the two campuses in Washington. [3]

Shortly thereafter, a number of Canonsburg residents and dissident trustees of Jefferson College sued, claiming that the consolidation was unconstitutional. [1] They argued that the original 1802 charter for Jefferson College had been illegally usurped in the process. [1] Specifically, they argued that the provision in the Jefferson College Charter that it "shall not be altered or alterable by any ordinance or law of the said trustees, nor in any other manner than by an act of the legislature of the Commonwealth" prohibited such a move. [4] Their lawsuit went to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. It ruled, on January 3, 1870, that the consolidation had been done in a legal manner. [1] [5] The Jefferson College partisans appealed to the United States Supreme Court, saying that the consolidation had been contrary to the United States Constitution. [1] The court ruled otherwise, and upheld the consolidation in a December 1871 opinion written by Justice Nathan Clifford. [1] [6]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Livingston Lowes</span>

John Livingston Lowes was an American scholar and critic of English literature, specializing in Samuel Taylor Coleridge and Geoffrey Chaucer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas McKean Thompson McKennan</span> American politician

Thomas McKean Thompson McKennan was a 19th-century politician and lawyer who served briefly as United States Secretary of the Interior under President Millard Fillmore.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jacob Lindley</span> American academic administrator

Jacob Lindley was the first president of Ohio University, between 1809 and 1822.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Andrew Wylie (college president)</span>

Andrew Wylie was an American academic and theologian, who was president of Jefferson College (1811–1816) and Washington College (1816–1828) before becoming the first president of Indiana University (1829–1851).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Matthew Brown (college president)</span>

Matthew Brown was a prominent Presbyterian minister and president of Washington College and Jefferson College. Next to John McMillan, Brown was the most important figure to education in Western Pennsylvania.

John Watson was the first principal and president of and professor of moral philosophy at Jefferson College.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David Elliott (college president)</span>

David Elliott was the third president of Washington College from 1830 to 1831.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John McMillan (missionary)</span>

John McMillan was a prominent Presbyterian minister and missionary in Western Pennsylvania when that area was part of the American Frontier. He founded the first school west of the Allegheny Mountains, which is now known as John McMillan's Log School. He is one of the founders of Washington & Jefferson College.

Thaddeus Dod was a prominent Presbyterian minister in Western Pennsylvania. He is one of the founders of Washington & Jefferson College.

Joseph Smith (1736–1792) was a prominent Presbyterian minister in Western Pennsylvania. He is one of the founders of Washington & Jefferson College.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joseph Ruggles Wilson</span> American theologian and father of Woodrow Wilson (1822–1903)

Joseph Ruggles Wilson Sr. was a prominent Presbyterian theologian and father of President Woodrow Wilson, Nashville Banner editor Joseph Ruggles Wilson Jr., and Anne E. Wilson Howe. In 1861, as pastor of First Presbyterian Church in Augusta, Georgia, he organized the General Assembly of the newly formed Presbyterian Church in the United States, known as the Southern Presbyterian Church, and served as its clerk for 37 years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Clark Family Library</span>

The Clark Family Library, formerly U. Grant Miller Library is the academic library for Washington & Jefferson College, located in Washington, Pennsylvania. The library traces its origins back to a donation from Benjamin Franklin in 1789. The Archives and Special Collections contain significant holdings of historical papers dating to the college's founding. The Walker Room contains the personal library of prominent industrialist John Walker, complete with all of his library's fixtures and furniture, installed exactly how it had been during Walker's life.

Literary societies at Washington & Jefferson College played an important role in its academics and student life, especially during the 18th and 19th century. Washington & Jefferson College is a private liberal arts college in Washington, Pennsylvania, which is located in the Pittsburgh metropolitan area. The college traces its origin to three log cabin colleges in Washington County, Pennsylvania established by three frontier clergymen in the 1780s: John McMillan, Thaddeus Dod, and Joseph Smith. These early schools eventually grew into two competing colleges, with Jefferson College in Canonsburg, Pennsylvania being chartered in 1802 and Washington College being chartered in 1806. These two schools merged in 1865 to form Washington & Jefferson College.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of Washington & Jefferson College</span>

The history of Washington & Jefferson College begins with three log cabin colleges established by three frontier clergymen in the 1780s: John McMillan, Thaddeus Dod, and Joseph Smith. The three men, all graduates from the College of New Jersey, came to present-day Washington County to plant churches and spread Presbyterianism to what was then the American frontier beyond the Appalachian Mountains. John McMillan, the most prominent of the three founders because of his strong personality and longevity, came to the area in 1775 and built his log cabin college in 1780 near his church in Chartiers. Thaddeus Dod, known as a keen scholar, built his log cabin college in Lower Ten Mile in 1781. Joseph Smith taught classical studies in his college, called "The Study" at Buffalo.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">First Presbyterian Church (Washington, Pennsylvania)</span>

The First Presbyterian Church 1793, alternatively known as the First Presbyterian Church, is a Presbyterian church in Washington, Pennsylvania. It has been the de facto college church for Washington & Jefferson College since the early 19th century. It is under the Washington Presbytery.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">City of Washington–Washington & Jefferson College relations</span>

The relationship between the City of Washington, Pennsylvania, and Washington & Jefferson College spans over two centuries, dating to the founding of both the city and the college in the 1780s. The relationship between the town and college were strong enough that the citizens of Washington offered the college a $50,000 donation in 1869 in a successful attempt to lure the Washington & Jefferson College trustees to select Washington over nearby Canonsburg as the consolidated location of the college. The relationship was strained through the latter half of the 20th century, however, as the college pursued an expansion policy that clashed with the residential neighborhood. The college's frustrations grew after preservationists unsuccessfully attempted to pass laws prohibiting the college from demolishing certain buildings that were listed on the East Washington Historic District. Relations were so bad that residents and college officials engaged in a shouting match at a meeting. Local preservationists also unsuccessfully tried to block the demolition of Hays Hall, which had been condemned.

John Canon was an American Revolutionary soldier, miller, judge, and businessman, who founded three towns, including Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, which bears his name.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John McMillan's Log School</span> Log building in Pennsylvania, United States

John McMillan's Log School is a landmark log building in Canonsburg, Pennsylvania that was the site of John McMillan's frontier Latin school during the 1780s. It is a symbol of Canonsburg and Canonsburg's educational tradition. In 1930, The Pittsburgh Press said that the building was "viewed by the pioneers with even more reverence than Pittsburgh now view the towering Cathedral of Learning in Oakland." It is one of the oldest buildings in Western Pennsylvania. It is the "oldest educational building west of the Allegheny Mountains."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charles Clinton Beatty</span> American minister

Charles Clinton Beatty was a Presbyterian minister, seminary founder, and academic philanthropist.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Coleman, Helen Turnbull Waite (1956). Banners in the Wilderness: The Early Years of Washington and Jefferson College. University of Pittsburgh Press. pp.  155–156. OCLC   2191890.
  2. Coleman, Helen Turnbull Waite (1956). Banners in the Wilderness: The Early Years of Washington and Jefferson College. University of Pittsburgh Press. pp.  143–149. OCLC   2191890.
  3. Coleman, Helen Turnbull Waite (1956). Banners in the Wilderness: The Early Years of Washington and Jefferson College. University of Pittsburgh Press. pp.  149–155. OCLC   2191890.
  4. McClain, Emlin (1909). "Protection to Contracts and Property - Pennsylvania College Cases". A selection of cases on constitutional law (2 ed.). Boston: Little, Brown, and Company. p. 1013.
  5. Thompson, James (1870). Pennsylvania College Cases  . Supreme Court of Pennsylvania via Wikisource.
  6. Clifford, Nathan (1871). Pennsylvania College Cases  . United States Supreme Court via Wikisource.

Further reading

Walayat, Aaron J. (2021). "The Pennsylvania College Cases: 150 Years Later". The Pennsylvania Bar Association Quarterly. 92 (4): 198–211.