Phantom Zone

Last updated
Phantom Zone
Phantom Zone.jpg
Superman trapped in the Phantom Zone as seen on the cover of Superman (vol. 5) #2 (August 2018). Art by Ivan Reis.
First appearance Adventure Comics #283 (April 1961)
Created by Robert Bernstein (writer)
George Papp (artist)
In-universe information
TypePrison
Dimension
Interdimensional realm
Publisher DC Comics

The Phantom Zone is a prison-like parallel dimension appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics. It is mainly associated with stories featuring Superman. It first appeared in Adventure Comics #283 (April 1961), and was created by Robert Bernstein and George Papp. [1] It was frequently used in the Superman comics before the continuity was rebooted in the 1980s, after Crisis on Infinite Earths , and has appeared occasionally since.

Contents

Fictional history

Pre-Crisis

The Phantom Zone was a "pocket universe" discovered by Jor-El that existed outside the space-time continuum; it was used on the planet Krypton as a humane method of imprisoning criminals. [2] Kryptonians had abolished the death penalty in the long distant past. In more recent history, criminals were punished by being sealed into capsules and rocketed into orbit in suspended animation with crystals attached to their foreheads to slowly erase their criminal tendencies; Klax-Ar was one criminal who received this punishment but escaped. Gra-Mo was the last to suffer the punishment, for it was then abolished in favor of the Zone.

The inmates of the Phantom Zone reside in a ghost-like state of existence from which they can observe, but cannot interact with, the regular universe. [3] Inmates do not age or require sustenance in the Phantom Zone; furthermore, they are telepathic and mutually insubstantial. As such, they were able to survive the destruction of Krypton and focus their attention on Earth, as most of the surviving Kryptonians now reside there. [4] Most have a particular grudge against Superman because his father created the method of their damnation, and was often the prosecutor at their trials. When they manage to escape, they usually engage in random destruction, particularly easy for them since, on Earth, each acquires the same powers as Superman. Nevertheless, Superman periodically released Phantom Zone prisoners whose original sentences had been completed, and most of these went to live in the bottle city of Kandor.

The sole inmate of the Phantom Zone who was not placed there as punishment for a crime is Mon-El, a Daxamite who fell victim to lead poisoning. Superboy was forced to cast him into the Phantom Zone to keep him alive, where he remained for nearly a thousand Earth years until the time of the Legion of Super-Heroes when Brainiac 5 created a medication that allowed him to leave safely.

Green Lantern Guy Gardner once experienced an extended and tortuous stay after an explosion of a Green Lantern power battery sent him there, until rescued by Superman and Green Lantern Hal Jordan, who had believed him to be dead all that time.

Phantom Girl can enter or leave the Phantom Zone as she pleases, and once did so to interrogate the prisoners about Jor-El. [5]

Superman develops communications equipment for the Phantom Zone, like the Zone-o-Phone, and refinements to the projector. In addition, the city of Kandor uses the Phantom Zone regularly, with parole hearings sometimes chaired by Superman. However, since the departure of Kandor, that is, outside of Mon-El, most of the inhabitants were confined to lifers and generally not inclined to making conversation with their jailer. As for Superman himself, as much as he appreciates how the Zone is necessary to contain its Kryptonian inmates, who otherwise would be extremely dangerous and destructive in a yellow-sun environment, and to shelter Mon-El, he apparently privately harbors concerns about the justness of its penal use. This is illustrated in the acclaimed story "For the Man Who Has Everything" by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons, where Clark is ensnared in a fantasy illusion created by an alien parasitical plant called a Black Mercy. As his subconscious resists the illusion of a peaceful life on Krypton, among the first signs of its degeneration is the sight of his cousin, Kara Zor-El, hospitalized after being attacked by an anti-Phantom Zone militant who left literature protesting that the Phantom Zone is a method of torture.

In the Steve Gerber miniseries The Phantom Zone #1-4 (January–April 1982), it is revealed that the Zone not only has a breach through which other inmates had escaped, but that they were never heard from again. [6] The imprisoned Superman and Quex-Ul use this method and travel through several dimensional "layers" seeking the exit into the physical universe. They finally encounter a Kryptonian wizard named Thul-Kar, who tells them that he believed Jor-El's prophecy of Krypton's doom and entered the Phantom Zone through magic. Using the same breach, he discovered the truth about the Phantom Zone: all its levels are manifestations of the consciousness of a sentient, malevolent entity called Aethyr, The Oversoul.

As explained by Thul-Kar, Aethyr itself came into being uncounted millennia ago when two spiral galaxies collided at an almost primordial stage after the physical universe's creation. Countless worlds were simultaneously destroyed and the deaths of so many beings merged somehow to form a single, evil consciousness that called itself Aethyr The Oversoul. This supremely powerful entity enclosed itself into a dimension outside the physical universe within itself, forming the Phantom Zone.

The Zone itself is an interface between the Earth-One dimension (the physical universe) and Aethyr's mind, the outer layer (where zone criminals are housed) representing its ability for abstract thought; the Zone is basically Aethyr's capacity to imagine other possibilities of existence, and is the outermost template of its consciousness. Only by entering Aethyr's core realm can a zone prisoner escape back to the physical universe, but this process is dangerous since any being who tries risks being destroyed in numerous ways as well as by forever having their souls merged with Aethyr's essence while within Aethyr's core realm. [7] This is because as someone enters deeper into Aethyr's consciousness, then no longer exist as an abstract entity and its existence becomes subject to Aethyr's whims. When attacking Superman and Quex-Ul, Aethyr personified itself as an aggressive, purple-skinned dog's head that breathed flames capable of destroying and absorbing the souls of those that it wishes to conquer. While Quex-Ul is killed by Aethyr in this fashion, Superman manages to make his way out of the Phantom Zone by avoiding those flames and flying directly through Aethyr's skull and its mind, returning to Earth through a tear in the fabric of Aethyr's mind and the physical universe, but not without encountering the horrific remains of all of the souls entrapped within Aethyr over the millennia. [8]

Mister Mxyzptlk is later possessed by Aethyr. During the process while Mxyzptlk is imprisoned on his own home dimension, Thul-Kar communicates with Mxyzptlk and offers him an escape in exchange for the merger. This merger, however, empties the Phantom Zone of its criminal inhabitants. As the Phantom Zone villains head to Earth to conquer it, Thul-Kar and Nam-Ek are re-absorbed into Aethyr. Superman awakes and sees that the Phantom Zone villains are wreaking havoc on Earth, causing destruction to the Capitol Building in Washington, D.C., and demanding Superman come out and fight them. Superman battles the Phantom Zone villains in Washington D.C., While fighting Faora Hu-Ul, he witnesses her disappearing as she is absorbed into Aethyr. Mister Mxyzpltk reveals that his strong personality has taken over Aethyr and he absorbs all the rest of the Phantom Zone inhabitants back into himself, determined to torture them endlessly and wreak havoc as he sees fit. Mxyzpltk-Aethyr leaves, intending to next take over the Fifth Dimension, and Superman is left to put out the fires in Washington and then rid Metropolis of the Kryptonite remains of Argo City. [9]

Post-Crisis

Phantom Zone criminals pictured from left to right: Ursa, General Zod, and Non. Art by Gary Frank and Jonathan Sibal. Phantom Zone Criminals.png
Phantom Zone criminals pictured from left to right: Ursa, General Zod, and Non. Art by Gary Frank and Jonathan Sibal.

In the Post- Crisis DC Universe, the Phantom Zone first appears after Superman returns from space with a Kryptonian artifact called the Eradicator. This device, created by his Kryptonian ancestor Kem-L, attempts to recreate Krypton on Earth, building the Fortress of Solitude; the extradimensional space in which the Eradicator finds the Kryptonian materials necessary is called the Phantom Zone. [10] [11] A Phantom Zone Projector is part of Superman's current Fortress. It has been used to access the Bottle City of Kandor and to trap villains such as the White Martians.

The Phantom Zone has been independently discovered by various characters where it is called the "Buffer Zone" by the Bgztlians, the "Still Zone" by the White Martians, the "Stasis Zone" by Loophole, the "Ghost Zone" by Prometheus, and the "Honeycomb" by the Queen Bee I. In Post- Crisis /Post- Zero Hour continuity, it was Loophole's "Stasis Zone" technology that exiled Mon-El, known in the new continuity as Valor/M'Onel, into the Phantom Zone for 1,000 years.

Superman fashions the Phantom Zone technology into an arrow projectile which upon striking a victim will project them into the Phantom Zone. Roy Harper, the original Speedy, steals this arrow from Superman when the original Teen Titans are invited for a visit many years ago. Roy, however, never uses the arrow and passes it on to his replacement, Mia Dearden, who uses the arrow during the events of Infinite Crisis on Superboy-Prime. He is too strong for even the Phantom Zone arrow, and manages to break out.

At one point, the White Martians imprison Batman in the Phantom Zone and take his identity as Bruce Wayne.

Batman devises a measure made after Superman recovers from his first battle with Doomsday, that, when the Justice League or any other superhero groups encounter a Doomsday Level Threat, a group of heroes, authority, and military forces will contain it within a proximity after clearing all civilians within it. If Superman and the rest fall, the Doomsday Protocol will commence by sending it to the Phantom Zone. [12]

In Action Comics , General Zod, along with Ursa and Non, appear in search of the son of Zod and Ursa. [13]

Supergirl #16 shows a form of life native to the Phantom Zone. These Phantoms are enraged over the use of their universe to house criminals and seek revenge on the one responsible. [14]

During the "New Krypton" storyline, the Kryptonians in Kandor have started to take matters into their own hands and started rounding up some of Superman's enemies to throw them into the Phantom Zone. First, they attack the Science Police where they make off with the Parasite. The second target is Silver Banshee who the Kandorians chase across the skies. At Arkham Asylum, the Kryptonians knock out Nightwing and Robin where they make off with Toyman while another group knocks out Black Lightning to claim Toyman. Bizarro is even attacked by Thara's group while flying. While Superman, Supergirl, and Zora are disgusted at what some of the Kandorians did and demands the ones responsible to turn themselves over to the authorities, Alura would not cooperate and gives the orders to throw the villains that they rounded up into the Phantom Zone. [15] Those who were thrown into the Phantom Zone were later freed by Superman. [16]

In the miniseries 52 the Phantom Zone is ingested by Mister Mind while he is mutating into a giant insect form. Once full-grown, Mind regurgitates it in an attempt to destroy Booster Gold and Rip Hunter, but the attack is deflected by Supernova, who returns the Phantom Zone to its proper dimensional plane. Supernova is able to control the Zone as his supersuit's powers are based upon Phantom Zone projector technology stolen by Rip Hunter.

In Action Comics #874, the Phantom Zone vanished. [17] Action Comics #886 offers a possible explanation as to the Phantom Zone's disappearance, the theory being that the Phantom Zone was actually the mythical Nightwing, counterpart to the Flamebird, imprisoned in an altered state of being. Having chosen a new Avatar, Chris Kent, who was freed from the Zone, he too would have been freed from his shackles, thus causing the Phantom Zone to cease to exist. [18]

In Adventure Comics (vol. 2) #11, the Phantom Zone is recreated by Chameleon Boy and Superman. [19]

The New 52

In The New 52 , Jor-El suggests going into the Phantom Zone when Krypton was about to explode. Zod, however, appears with other Phantom Zone prisoners and attempts to escape the Phantom Zone. Krypto sacrifices himself by attacking Xa-Du, thus going into the Phantom Zone as well. [20]

It is revealed that Doctor Xa-Du was the first Kryptonian prisoner to be sent to the Phantom Zone due to his forbidden experiments in suspended animation, with Jor-El executing the sentence. The Phantom Zone is reverted to the Pre-Crisis version. [21]

DC Rebirth

During the Dark Days: Metal event of the DC Rebirth reboot, Superman has theorized that the Phantom Zone might be actually a permeable membrane between Earth-0 (DC Universe) and the Dark Multiverse. [22]

Known inmates

Inmates in Pre-Crisis

Throughout the Silver Age of Comic Books, the following inhabitants of the Phantom Zone have been depicted. Based on this list, at least 34 Kryptonians were projected into the Phantom Zone on Krypton over a period of less than 256 Kryptonian days. [23] The entry on the Kryptonian Calendar shows the details on the relationship between Kryptonian sun-cycles and Earth years.

Inmates in Post-Crisis

The following were imprisoned in the Phantom Zone:

Inmates in All-Star Superman

Inmates in The New 52/DC Rebirth

Other versions

Superman & Batman: Generations

In the Elseworlds tale Superman & Batman: Generations , Superman is sentenced to the Phantom Zone in 1989 when he is stripped of his powers in a confrontation with the Ultra-Humanite that ends with his foe's death, after the Ultra-Humanite's actions led to the death of Superman's wife Lois Lane and his son Joel being tricked into killing Superman's daughter Kara before Joel dies himself, as well as arranging various 'accidents' for Clark Kent's other remaining loved ones. The judges reason that even if Superman feels that he may have killed his foe deliberately after the deaths of his family and friends, putting him in a conventional prison without his powers would be dangerous and solitary confinement was too extreme given his past deeds, selecting the Zone based on the suggestion of the new Batman, Bruce Wayne Junior. Superman is released in 1999 by the now-rejuvenated Bruce Wayne as Bruce returns to the role of Batman - Bruce noting that he is ending the sentence a few months early but is certain that nobody would object to early release "for good behavior" - although Superman was briefly able to appear as a phantom in the real world in 1997 to distract a foe who was about to kill Knightwing (Superman's grandson, adopted by Batman's son after the deaths of Superman's children).

In other media

Television

Films

Live-action

Animation

Video games

Miscellaneous

The Phantom Zone appears in Kevin J. Anderson's novel The Last Days of Krypton. [85]

Parodies and homages

Similar dimensions

There had been similar Zones that were in comparison to the Phantom Zone:

Notes

  1. 1 2 30 Kryptonian sun-cycles is impossible given Superman's time on Earth, thus 30 Earth years must be assumed to be correct; extrapolating from Quex-Ul's release date in Superman #157 (November 1962), a sentence of 19 Kryptonian sun-cycles (26 Earth years) would make more sense.
  2. If 15 sun-cycles is correct, Az-Rel should have been released into Kandor long ago.
  3. Full name given as "Dru-Zod" in World of Krypton #3 (September 1979). DC Comics.
  4. Last name given as "Ze-Da" in Phantom Zone #1 (January 1982). DC Comics.
  5. Name given as "Gaz-Or" in Phantom Zone #1 (January 1982). DC Comics.
  6. The name "Ni-Van" was mentioned in World of Krypton #2 (August 1979). DC Comics.
  7. Revealed as Jor-El's cousin in Superboy Annual #1 (Summer 1964). DC Comics.
  8. 1 2 Kru-El is erroneously depicted wearing Dr. Xadu's outfit in at least five appearances.
  9. Last name given as "Va-Dim" in DC Comics Presents #97 (September 1986). DC Comics.
  10. DC Comics Presents #97 (September 1986) incorrectly states that Nam-Ek was projected into the Zone on Krypton for 15 sun-cycles.
  11. Phantom Zone #1 (Jan. 1982) incorrectly states that Roz-Em was projected into the Zone on Krypton.
  12. Last name given as "Kor-Onn" in Superman Family #188 (March 1978). DC Comics.
  13. Name given as "Va-Kox" in Phantom Zone #1 (January 1982); incorrectly called Varox in Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #101 (April 1967).
  14. Dr. Xadu is explicitly named in Superman #150 (January 1962) and Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #62 (July 1962), and is depicted in four additional stories. This contradiction is never addressed.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Krypton (comics)</span> Fictional planet, native world of Superman

Krypton is a fictional planet appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics, most commonly appearing or mentioned in stories starring the superhero Superman as the world from whence he came. The planet was created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster, and was named after the chemical element krypton. The planet was first mentioned in Action Comics #1 and made its first appearance in Superman #1 (1939).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kryptonian</span> Fictional race native to the planet Krypton

Kryptonians are a fictional extraterrestrial race within the DC Comics universe that originated on the planet Krypton. The term originated from the stories of DC Comics superhero, Superman. The stories also use "Kryptonian" as an adjective to refer to anything created by or associated with the planet itself or the cultures that existed on it.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fortress of Solitude</span> Location featured in Superman comics

The Fortress of Solitude is a fictional fortress appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics, commonly in association with Superman. It is the place where Superman first learned about his true identity, heritage, and purpose on Earth. The fortress functions as a place of solace/occasional headquarters for Superman and is typically depicted as being in frozen tundra, away from civilization. Its predecessor, Superman's "Secret Citadel", first appeared in Superman #17, where it was said to be built into a mountain on the outskirts of Metropolis. By issue #58 it is referred to as the Fortress of Solitude, seems at a glance to be a freestanding castle, and is said to be located in a "polar waste". When the Fortress reappears in 1958 and for the first time takes center stage in a story, it is again an underground complex in a mountainous cliffside.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">General Zod</span> DC Comics character

General Zod is a supervillain appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics, commonly as an adversary of the superhero Superman. The character, who first appeared in Adventure Comics #283, was created by Robert Bernstein and initially designed by George Papp. As a Kryptonian, he exhibits the same powers and abilities as Superman and is consequently viewed as one of his greatest enemies alongside Lex Luthor, Darkseid, and Brainiac. He is also well known for his catchphrase, "Kneel before Zod!".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ursa (DC Comics)</span> Fictional character of the DC Universe

Ursa is a supervillain appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics. She first appeared in the 1978 film Superman: The Movie portrayed by actress Sarah Douglas. The character made her comic book debut in Action Comics #845. An adversary of the superhero Superman and accomplice of General Zod, she is typically depicted as having been imprisoned in the Phantom Zone along with Zod and Non.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dev-Em</span> Fictional character who appears in DC Comics

Dev-Em is a fictional character who appears in DC Comics. He first appeared in Adventure Comics #287, created by Jerry Siegel and George Papp. Various versions of the Dev-Em character have appeared over the years in Legion of Super-Heroes related comic books.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Zor-El</span> Fictional character in the DC Comics Universe

Zor-El is a fictional character appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics. A Kryptonian, he is the brother of Jor-El, husband of Alura, father of Supergirl, and paternal uncle of Superman.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jax-Ur</span> Comics character

Jax-Ur is a supervillain appearing in comic books published by DC Comics, usually as an adversary of Superman. Created by writer Otto Binder and artist George Papp, the character first appeared in Adventure Comics #289. He has been described as "the worst troublemaker in the Phantom Zone" and was the first criminal banished there.

The Superman dynasty, an extension of the House of El, is a lineage of DC Comics superheroes. The term is used for the descendants of Kal-El, the original Superman, who continue to uphold his legacy of heroism well into the 853rd century, as depicted in the DC One Million crossover. Repeated references to members of the Superman dynasty, as Superman's "descendants" and at least one reference to them as the "blood of his blood" would seem to indicate that they are, in fact, the biological descendants of Superman in some fashion.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Faora</span> Comics character

Faora is a supervillain appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics, commonly in association with Superman. The character was created by Cary Bates and Curt Swan, and first appeared in Action Comics #471. Most commonly, Faora is an ally and sometimes the wife and/or lover of Superman's Kryptonian nemesis General Zod.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Non (comics)</span> Comics character

Non is a supervillain appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics. He first appeared in the 1978 film Superman, portrayed by Jack O'Halloran, and first appeared in comics in Action Comics #845. An accomplice of General Zod and an adversary of the superhero Superman, he is typically depicted as having been imprisoned in the Phantom Zone along with Zod and Ursa, among whom he is portrayed as the strong and silent muscle.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chris Kent (character)</span> Fictional superhero in DC Comics

Christopher Kent (Lor-Zod) is a superhero appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics. The character first appeared in Action Comics #844 and was created by Richard Donner, Geoff Johns, and Adam Kubert.

Black Zero is a name shared by two supervillains, two terrorist organizations, one special forces group, and a computer virus that have all appeared in various comic book series published by DC Comics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quex-Ul</span> Comics character

Quex-Ul is a supervillain appearing in American comic books published by DC Comics. He is depicted as an enemy of Superman, although they are also sometimes allies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alura (DC Comics)</span> Fictional character in the DC Comics Universe

Alura In-Ze is a character appearing in media published by DC Comics, usually those involving Superman. Alura is the Kryptonian daughter of In-Zee, wife of Zor-El, mother of Supergirl, and paternal aunt of Superman. Created by writer Otto Binder and artist Al Plastino, the character first appeared in Action Comics #252.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thara Ak-Var</span> Comics character

Thara Ak-Var is a fictional character appearing in comic books published by DC Comics, created by Geoff Johns and James Robinson. The character first appeared during the Superman: New Krypton storyline in Superman #681. She is the latest character to take on the role of Flamebird. Along with the new Nightwing, Thara is the feature character in Action Comics beginning with issue #875. Thara Ak-Var's name is a reference to Ak-Var, who was the second pre-Crisis Flamebird, and his wife, Thara.

<i>Superman: War of the Supermen</i>

Superman: War of the Supermen is an American comic book limited series from DC Comics that serves as the culmination to the Superman line-wide event New Krypton. The series began on Free Comic Book Day 2010, with a zero-issue released free of charge before the main limited series began the following week.

"H'El on Earth" is a Superman crossover story arc published by DC Comics. Written primarily by Scott Lobdell, it details the appearance of H'El, a mysterious Kryptonian. The plot of "H'El on Earth" follows H'El's plan to restore Krypton and the Superman family's attempts to stop him.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kandor (comics)</span> Bottled city of the fictional planet Krypton in the DC Universe

Kandor is a fictional city spared from the doomed world of Krypton in DC Comics' Superman titles. Before Krypton exploded, the futuristic city was captured by the supervillain Brainiac, miniaturized by his shrinking ray and placed inside a glass bell jar. Defeating Brainiac and taking possession of the jar, Superman brings the city to his Arctic hideout, the Fortress of Solitude, and spends many years attempting to restore it to normal size.

"The Phantom Zone" is a four-issue 1982 Superman comic book miniseries published by DC Comics.

References

  1. "GCD :: Issue :: Adventure Comics #283". Comics.org. Retrieved 2010-12-25.
  2. Fleisher, Michael L. (2007). The Original Encyclopedia of Comic Book Heroes, Volume Three: Superman. DC Comics. pp. 267–270. ISBN   978-1-4012-1389-3.
  3. Greenberger, Robert; Pasko, Martin (2010). The Essential Superman Encyclopedia. Del Rey. pp. 309–312. ISBN   978-0-345-50108-0.
  4. Wells, John (2015). American Comic Book Chronicles: 1960-64. TwoMorrows Publishing. p. 54. ISBN   978-1605490458.
  5. 1 2 Adventure Comics #323 (August 1964). DC Comics.
  6. Cowsill, Alan; Irvine, Alex; Manning, Matthew K.; McAvennie, Michael; Wallace, Daniel (2019). DC Comics Year By Year: A Visual Chronicle. DK Publishing. p. 186. ISBN   978-1-4654-8578-6.
  7. 1 2 Phantom Zone #3 (March 1982). DC Comics.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 Phantom Zone #4 (April 1982). DC Comics.
  9. DC Comics Presents #97. DC Comics.
  10. Jurgens, Dan  ( w ),Jurgens, Dan ( p ), Kubert, Andy  ( i )."Be It Ever So Deadly" The Adventures of Superman ,no. 460(November 1989).New York:DC Comics.
  11. Jurgens, Dan  ( w ),Jurgens, Dan ( p ), Perez, George  ( i )."Home" The Adventures of Superman ,no. 461(December 1989).New York:DC Comics.
  12. Action Comics #825. DC Comics.
  13. Action Comics #845. DC Comics.
  14. Supergirl #16. DC Comics.
  15. 1 2 Superman #682. DC Comics.
  16. Superman #684. DC Comics.
  17. Action Comics #874. DC Comics.
  18. Action Comics #886. DC Comics.
  19. Adventure Comics (vol. 2) #11. DC Comics.
  20. Action Comics (vol. 2) #5. DC Comics.
  21. Action Comics (vol. 2) #13. DC Comics.
  22. Dark Days #3. DC Comics.
  23. World Of Krypton #2 (August 1979) and #3 (September 1979). DC Comics.
  24. Action Comics #336 (April 1966). DC Comics.
  25. Superman Family #183 (September-October 1977). DC Comics.
  26. Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #93 (July 1969). DC Comics.
  27. 1 2 3 4 Phantom Zone #1 (January 1982). DC Comics.
  28. Superman #204 (February 1968). DC Comics.
  29. Superboy #121 (June 1965). DC Comics.
  30. Superboy #162 (January 1970). DC Comics.
  31. 1 2 Adventure Comics #283 (April 1961). DC Comics.
  32. 1 2 Superboy #100 (October 1962). DC Comics.
  33. 1 2 Action Comics #434 (April 1974) and #435 (May 1974). DC Comics.
  34. 1 2 Action Comics #471-473 (May–July 1977). DC Comics.
  35. Superman #166 (January 1964). DC Comics.
  36. 1 2 3 Superman #223 (January 1970). DC Comics.
  37. Superboy #104 (April 1963). DC Comics.
  38. 1 2 3 Adventure Comics #400 (December 1970). DC Comics.
  39. Adventure Comics #289 (October 1961). DC Comics.
  40. Action Comics #309 (February 1964). DC Comics.
  41. Action Comics #297 (February 1963). DC Comics.
  42. 1 2 Extrapolating from Quex-Ul's release date in Superman #157 (November 1962), a sentence of 20 Kryptonian sun-cycles (27.4 Earth years) would make sense.
  43. Superboy #89 (June 1961). DC Comics.
  44. Adventure Comics #305 (February 1963). DC Comics.
  45. World's Finest Comics #256 (April–May 1979). DC Comics.
  46. Adventure Comics #457-458 (May–June to July-August 1978). DC Comics.
  47. 1 2 3 4 Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #59 (August 1965). DC Comics.
  48. 1 2 Action Comics #548 (October 1983). DC Comics.
  49. 1 2 Action Comics #549 (November 1983). DC Comics.
  50. If 15 sun-cycles is correct, Nadira should have been released into Kandor long ago.
  51. Superman #282 (December 1974). DC Comics.
  52. Superman #311 (May 1977) through #315 (September 1977). DC Comics.
  53. Action Comics #505 (March 1980). DC Comics.
  54. Action Comics #506 (April 1980). DC Comics.
  55. Action Comics #323 (March 1965). DC Comics.
  56. Superman #157 (Nov. 1962). DC Comics.
  57. Superman #154 (July 1962). DC Comics.
  58. Kryptonian Calendar
  59. Superman #164 (October 1963). DC Comics.
  60. Adventure Comics #304 (January 1963). DC Comics.
  61. Superman Family #183 (May–June 1977). DC Comics.
  62. Superman Family #188 (March 1978). DC Comics.
  63. Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen #97 (October 1966). DC Comics.
  64. Action Comics #307 (December 1963). DC Comics.
  65. Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #98 (January 1970). DC Comics.
  66. Action Comics #284 (January 1962). DC Comics.
  67. Given Superman's time on Earth, Vorb-Un cannot have been sentenced on Krypton, thus he must have been sentenced in Argo City.
  68. Action Comics #310 (March 1964). DC Comics.
  69. Superman #219 (August 1969). DC Comics.
  70. A period of 30 sun-cycles is given in multiple stories, with only Action Comics #284 (January 1962) incorrectly stating 40 sun-cycles.
  71. Since Superboy is nearly 16 years old in this story, Zan-Em would have been sent to the Zone somewhere between 13.8 and 14.8 Earth years prior, thus he must be referring to Earth decades.
  72. Adventure Comics #458 (July-August 1978). DC Comics.
  73. DC Comics Presents #84 (August 1985). DC Comics.
  74. Action Comics #279 (August 1961). DC Comics.
  75. Superman's Girl Friend, Lois Lane #73 (April 1967). DC Comics.
  76. Superman #414 (December 1985). DC Comics.
  77. Action Comics #877. DC Comics.
  78. 1 2 Adventure Comics (vol. 2) #8. DC Comics.
  79. Action Comics #851. DC Comics.
  80. Action Comics #875. DC Comics.
  81. Supergirl: Rebirth #1. DC Comics.
  82. Superman Vol. 5 #2. DC Comics.
  83. Action Comics Vol. 2 #5. DC Comics.
  84. "Legion of Super Heroes: "Phantoms" Review". Superman Homepage. Retrieved September 30, 2024.
  85. DC Comics; HarperCollins and Harper, New York, New York, 2007. ISBN   978-0-06-134075-8
  86. "Meet Lord Buckethead, the U.K. election's intergalactic spacelord".