Post-war plans for the Gaza Strip

Last updated

As the Gaza war continued throughout 2024 and 2025, various leaders of different regional and international powers put forth distinct plans for the post-war organization of the Gaza Strip. Ultimately, the United Nations Security Council voted to support the US-backed Gaza peace plan in November 2025.

Contents

Plans

Israeli leaders' plans

On 16 October 2023, the Israeli war cabinet defined four central goals for the war: toppling the Hamas regime and dismantling its capabilities, removing the terrorist threat from Gaza, returning the hostages, and maintaining the security of Israel's borders and its residents. [1]

About a month after the war began, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said that overall security responsibility for the Gaza Strip would rest with Israel after the war, for an indefinite period. [2] He said that the Strip would be "demilitarized and under a civilian government, but a reliable force would be required to enter and kill the murderers so that an entity like Hamas would not emerge", [3] and that after the elimination of Hamas there would be overall Israeli security control over the Gaza Strip, including full demilitarization. [4] On 11 November, Netanyahu expressed opposition to the possibility of the Palestinian Authority assuming civilian control over the Strip. [5] In response to a question about the possibility of returning Jewish settlement to the Strip, he said that he did not see this as a realistic goal. [6]

In February 2024, Netanyahu presented his proposal for the "Day After Hamas" to the Security Cabinet of Israel. It included management by local people and was not rejected or approved by a vote at the cabinet. [7] About six months after the start of the war, it was reported that Netanyahu was preventing a strategic discussion on the goals of the war in light of its progress, contrary to the agreement reached in the war cabinet. [8] In May 2024, it was reported that the IDF leadership was demanding that the prime minister make a decision on post-war issues. [9] On 15 May, Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant convened a press conference in which he called on Netanyahu to announce that Israel would not control Gaza, and expressed his opposition to an Israeli civilian and military government in Gaza. His remarks drew criticism from coalition and opposition figures, and were supported by the leader of the National Unity party, Benny Gantz. [10]

On 24 July, Netanyahu outlined his vision for the post-war Gaza Strip before the US Congress:

A demilitarized Gaza free of weapons and extremism. We do not want to settle in Gaza, but we will have to maintain security responsibility there. It should be run by Palestinians who do not want to destroy Israel. A new generation of Palestinians should learn no more to hate Jews but to live in peace with us. After our victory, with the help of partners in the region, the demilitarization of Gaza and the end of extremism in Gaza, we can bring about a future of peace and prosperity. [11]

On 2 April, Israel Katz announced the Israeli government's intention to "seize large areas" of Gaza as large air and ground operations resumed following the end of the March ceasefire. [12] On 17 April, Katz said that Israeli forces would remain in areas of Gaza, Lebanon and Syria indefinitely. [13] On 5 May, the Israeli cabinet approved plans to capture the entire Gaza Strip and occupy it for an unspecified period. [14] Far-right Minister of Finance Bezalel Smotrich said that Gaza would be "entirely destroyed" in Israel's new offensive and that the population would be expelled. [15]

On 8 August 2025, the Security Cabinet approved five principles for ending the war, including disarming Hamas, returning all hostages, demilitarizing the Gaza Strip, maintaining Israeli security control over it, and establishing an alternative civilian government not affiliated with Hamas or the Palestinian Authority. [16] Smotrich then withdrew confidence in Netanyahu's war leadership, criticizing his Gaza strategy as weak and calling for a decisive military victory over Hamas. [17]

Donald Trump's proposals

In February 2025, Donald Trump announced his intention to displace the Palestinian population of Gaza, reiterating his position that they should be resettled in neighboring Arab countries. [18] Ahead of a meeting with Netanyahu, Trump specified his intention to permanently displace Gaza's Palestinian inhabitants, which would be in violation of international law. He proposed a US takeover of Gaza during a press conference with Netanyahu. [19]

Trump insisted that neighboring countries would pay for Gaza's reconstruction and that "world people" would live there. He did not rule out deploying US troops if necessary. On 5 and 6 February, Trump aides and Trump himself walked back some of his comments, including his willingness to deploy US soldiers. On 10 February, Trump said that Palestinians who leave Gaza would have no right of return. In a meeting with King Abdullah II of Jordan, Trump said that the US would take rather than buy Gaza because "It's a war torn area. It's Gaza. There is nothing to buy." [20] Trump had proposed Jordan take in the displaced Palestinians from Gaza, which Jordanian foreign minister Ayman Safadi rejected, stating "They don't want to come to Jordan and we don't want them to come to Jordan." [21]

Trump's statements were met with condemnation from world leaders; however, in Israel, far-right national security minister Itamar Ben-Gvir praised Trump, saying that Palestinian "migration" was the only solution. [22] Netanyahu and Ben-Gvir characterized the planned displacement of Gazans as a "voluntary migration", but communications minister Shlomo Karhi said the transfer will be forced. [23]

Trump has rejected the Arab League plan saying that "The current proposal does not address the reality that Gaza is currently uninhabitable and residents cannot humanely live in a territory covered in debris and unexploded ordnance," and that the Trump administration will go ahead with seizing the territory "to bring peace and prosperity to the region". [24]

In May 2025, US special envoy Steve Witkoff proposed a ceasefire in Gaza. This proposal reportedly included a 60-day truce, freeing of 28 hostages, release of over 1000 Palestinian prisoners and supply of humanitarian aid. Israel accepted the proposal. Hamas requested amendments to the plan and reiterated calls for the complete withdrawal of the IDF from Gaza. [25]

In September 2025, Israeli and British media reported a proposal by former British prime minister Tony Blair for a Gaza International Transitional Authority to administer the Gaza Strip for a transitional period, before turning over administration to the Palestinian Authority. [26] [27]

Gaza Peace Summit in Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt, 13 October 2025 Sharm El Sheikh Summit for Peace, 13 October 2025 (Roman Ismayilov) 19.jpg
Gaza Peace Summit in Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt, 13 October 2025

On 29 September 2025, Trump and Netanyahu announced in a press conference that they had agreed on a peace plan. It includes the cessation of hostilities, the release of Israeli hostages, and the establishment of a governance alternative to Hamas. Trump stated that the implementation of the plan was contingent upon Hamas's approval. [28] [29] Multiple Arab countries announced their support for the plan. On 3 October, Hamas agreed to releasing hostages and handing over Gaza's administration to an technocratic government supported by Arab countries, also pledging to continue to negotiate on other parts of the plan. Hamas did not comment on the stipulation that it must disarm. [30]

On 8 October 2025, Trump announced that Israel and Hamas had agreed to the "first phase" of the plan, which included a pause in fighting, the release of "at least" some hostages and prisoners, and an Israeli troop withdrawal from parts of Gaza. The agreement, reached after negotiations in Egypt involving U.S., Qatari, Turkish, Egyptian, Israeli and Hamas officials, was described as the most significant breakthrough in months toward ending the two-year war. [31] [32] An international Gaza peace summit on the next phase of the peace plan took place on 13 October 2025 in Sharm el Shaikh, Egypt. [33]

Arab League proposal

Arab governments rejected Trump's transfer plan, instead backing an Egyptian proposal. The Arab League in March devised a $53-billion plan detailing the reconstruction of Gaza while keeping its population in place. [34] The proposal also included the requirement that Hamas disarm and fresh elections to a reformed Palestinian Authority be held. [24] Algerian President Abdelmadjid Tebboune boycotted the league meeting saying that it was "monopolized by a limited and narrow group of Arab countries". [24] Hamas reiterated that the group's arms were non-negotiable and rejected the plan. [24]

Russian proposal

On 13 November 2025, a Russian counter-proposal to the one drafted by the USA was announced to the UNSC. [35] The proposal is made of 10 points, in which support for full Palestinian statehood is declared, and supporting the annexation by the Palestinian Authority of Gaza as soon as possible. [36] The Russian plan also opposed a stabilization force in Gaza. Russia also insists that the American plan is in contradiction with previous Council resolutions. [37] The plan was also supported by China. [38]

Others

In March 2025, the United States and Israel said they have contacted officials from Egypt, Jordan, Sudan, Syria, Morocco, Puntland, and Somaliland to discuss the resettlement of Gaza residents in their territories. [39] [40] [41] Egypt, [42] Jordan, [21] and Sudan, [43] rejected the proposal while Somalia and Somaliland denied that they had been contacted. [44] In May 2025, reports emerged that the Trump administration was working on a plan to permanently relocate 1 million Gazans to Libya, in exchange offering the release of around $30 billion in funds frozen by the US since the toppling of the regime of Muammar Gaddafi. [45] [46] In August 2025, reports suggested that Netanyahu was in talks with South Sudan to discuss the resettlement of Gaza residents. [47] [48] [49] Reports stated that the South Sudanese cabinet actually agreed to the deal, but it fell short in parliament and other parts of the South Sudanese government. [48] South Sudan rejected the reports and its ministry of foreign affairs released a statement denying holding talks with Israel about the relocation of Palestinians, calling the reports "baseless". [50] [49]

References

  1. Cohen, Gili (15 October 2023). "mitut shlaton chamas vepitron lesogyat hachatofim: mismach metrot hamlachama bechshef" מיטוט שלטון חמאס ופתרון לסוגיית החטופים: מסמך מטרות המלחמה נחשף [The collapse of the Hamas regime and a solution to the issue of the hostages: the document of the war objectives in the light]. Israeli Public Broadcasting Corporation (in Hebrew). Retrieved 10 August 2025.
  2. Hutzler, Alexandra (2023-11-07). "Netanyahu to ABC's Muir: 'No cease-fire' without release of hostages". ABC News . Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  3. "nitnihu le "pox niyoz": sinavar adain be'eza, venagia elav" נתניהו ל"פוקס ניוז": סינוואר עדיין בעזה, ונגיע אליו [Netanyahu to Fox News: Sinwar is still in Gaza, and we will get to him]. Ynet (in Hebrew). 2023-11-10. Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  4. "nitnihu leroshi harshuyot be'utaf: "tza"le yahzik birtzu'a gam achari hamlachama"" נתניהו לראשי הרשויות בעוטף: "צה"ל יחזיק ברצועה גם אחרי המלחמה" [Netanyahu to heads of authorities in the enclave: "The IDF will hold the Strip even after the war"]. Walla News (in Hebrew). 2023-11-10. Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  5. "nitnihu: yisral tishlut be'eza kel zman shetzrich, nimshich vele ne'atzur ad lanitzchon" נתניהו: ישראל תשלוט בעזה כל זמן שצריך, נמשיך ולא נעצור עד לניצחון [Netanyahu: Israel will control Gaza as long as necessary, we will continue and will not stop until victory]. Walla News (in Hebrew). 2023-11-08. Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  6. IsraeliPM (2023-11-11). shidur chi: rosh hamimshala nitnihu, sher habitchon glant vehisher gentz mekaymim mesivet ituna'imשידור חי: ראש הממשלה נתניהו, שר הביטחון גלנט והשר גנץ מקיימים מסיבת עיתונאים [Live broadcast: Prime Minister Netanyahu, Defense Minister Gallant and Minister Gantz hold a press conference] (in Hebrew). Retrieved 2025-08-10 via YouTube.
  7. "nitnihu hatzig lefani hakbint hamedini-bitchoni et hatza'ato le "yum shachari chamas"" ננתניהו הציג לפני הקבינט המדיני-ביטחוני את הצעתו ל"יום שאחרי חמאס" [Netanyahu presented his proposal for "the day after Hamas" to the political-security cabinet]. N12. 2024-02-23. Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  8. "banigud lesikum bakbint: nitnihu muna diyon astrategi al yaadi hamlachama" בניגוד לסיכום בקבינט: נתניהו מונע דיון אסטרטגי על יעדי המלחמה [Contrary to the Cabinet agreement: Netanyahu prevents a strategic discussion on the war's goals]. Channel 13 (in Hebrew). Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  9. Yehoshua, Yossi (2024-05-11). "bikoret betza"le betzel hamivtza bejabalia: "hozrim le'utam mekomot shuv veshuv"" ביקורת בצה"ל בצל המבצע בג'באליה: "חוזרים לאותם מקומות שוב ושוב" [IDF criticism in the shadow of the operation in Jabalia: "Returning to the same places again and again"]. Ynet (in Hebrew). Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  10. Cechnover, Yael (2024-05-15). "glant bebikoret harifa al nitnihu: yesh migma mesuknet lemimshel tzvai veezrachi yisrali be'eza" גלנט בביקורת חריפה על נתניהו: יש מגמה מסוכנת לממשל צבאי ואזרחי ישראלי בעזה [Gallant sharply criticizes Netanyahu: There is a dangerous trend towards Israeli military and civilian government in Gaza]. Ynet (in Hebrew). Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  11. "nitnihu bekungars al hayom shachari: "piroz birtzo'at aza – shiyuvil lesagsug veshlum"" נתניהו בקונגרס על היום שאחרי: "פירוז ברצועת עזה – שיוביל לשגשוג ושלום" [Netanyahu in Congress about the day after: "A demilitarization in the Gaza Strip – which will lead to prosperity and peace"]. Walla News (in Hebrew). 2024-07-24. Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  12. McKernan, Bethan (2 April 2025). "Israel announces intention to seize large areas of Gaza Strip in major escalation". The Guardian . Archived from the original on 4 May 2025. Retrieved 2 April 2025.
  13. Scharf, Isaac; Shurafa, Wafaa; Magdy, Samy (16 April 2025). "Israeli defense minister says troops will remain in Gaza, Lebanon and Syria indefinitely". Associated Press . Archived from the original on 15 May 2025. Retrieved 17 April 2025.
  14. Goldenberg, Tia; Mednick, Sam (5 May 2025). "Israel plans to capture all of Gaza under new plan, officials say". Associated Press . Archived from the original on 13 May 2025. Retrieved 5 May 2025.
  15. "Israeli official says Gaza will be "entirely destroyed," Palestinians "will start to leave in great numbers"". CBS News . 6 May 2025. Archived from the original on 8 May 2025. Retrieved 7 May 2025.
  16. Eichner, Itamar (2025-08-08). "Cabinet backs full Gaza takeover despite IDF chief's objections". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  17. Eichner, Itamar (2025-08-09). "Smotrich says 'lost faith' in Netanyahu's Gaza war position". Ynetnews. Retrieved 2025-08-10.
  18. "Trump Indicates Intent to Escalate Ethnic Cleansing in Gaza". Human Rights Watch . 5 February 2025. Archived from the original on 13 May 2025. Retrieved 16 March 2025.
  19. Shear, Michael D.; Baker, Peter; Kershner, Isabel (4 February 2025). "Trump Proposes U.S. Takeover of Gaza and Says Palestinians Should Move". The New York Times . Archived from the original on 16 May 2025.
  20. Singh, Kanishka (19 February 2025). "Timeline: Trump's remarks on plan to take over Gaza, displace Palestinians". Reuters .
  21. 1 2 Irish, John (14 February 2025). "Arab proposal for Gaza in works, but Jordan can't take more Palestinians, minister says". Reuters . Retrieved 19 March 2025.
  22. Wen, Philip; Chao-Fong, Léonie; Cooney, Christy; Sedghi, Amy; Belam, Martin; Lamb, Kate (5 February 2025). "Trump's declaration US will 'take over' Gaza Strip sparks global condemnation – live". The Guardian . Archived from the original on 5 March 2025.
  23. "In apparent first, Israeli minister indicates removal of Gazans will be forced, rather than voluntary". Times of Israel . 18 February 2025. Retrieved 23 February 2025.
  24. 1 2 3 4 Waldenberg, Samantha; Lilieholm, Lucas; Salem, Mostafa (4 March 2025). "US rejects alternative Gaza reconstruction plan proposed by Arab leaders". CNN . Archived from the original on 7 May 2025. Retrieved 19 March 2025.
  25. "Hamas makes hostage pledge but demands changes to US Gaza ceasefire plan". BBC. 1 June 2025. Retrieved 2 June 2025.
  26. "Washington backing plan for Tony Blair to head transitional Gaza authority". The Guardian. 25 September 2025.
  27. "Revelaed: Tony Blair's US-backed proposal for ending the Gaza war and replacing Hamas". The Times of Israel. 25 September 2025.
  28. Chowdhury, Maureen; Sangal, Aditi; Hammond, Elise (2025-09-29). "Trump to meet Netanyahu as federal government shutdown looms - live updates". CNN. Retrieved 2025-09-29.
  29. "Live Updates: Trump, Netanyahu meet over Gaza hostage deal". The Jerusalem Post. 2025-09-29. Retrieved 2025-09-29.
  30. Stack, Liam (3 October 2025). "Hamas Says It Agrees to Release All Hostages in Gaza". The New York Times .
  31. "'First phase' of ceasefire deal to end war in Gaza agreed by Israel and Hamas". The Guardian . 8 October 2025. Retrieved 8 October 2025.
  32. "Live Updates: Israel and Hamas Reach Deal on Hostage and Prisoner Exchange". The New York Times . October 8, 2025.
  33. "World leaders arrive in Egypt as Gaza peace summit set to begin". Al Arabiya. 13 October 2025.
  34. "What is Egypt's plan for the reconstruction of Gaza?". Al Jazeera . 4 March 2025.
  35. Magid, Jacob (2025-11-14). "US proposal at UN for Gaza stabilization force faces pushback from Russia, China and Arabs". The Times of Israel. ToI Staff. Reuters, AP. ISSN   0040-7909 . Retrieved 2025-11-15.
  36. Lederer, Edith M.; Amiri, Farnoush (2025-11-14). "US presses for approval of UN resolution on Gaza as Russia offers rival proposal". ABC News. Associated Press. Retrieved 2025-11-15.
  37. "Russia Counters U.S. Gaza Plan at U.N., Throwing Security Council Vote Into Doubt". La Voce di New York. 2025-11-15. Retrieved 2025-11-15.
  38. "At U.N. Security Council, Russia Counters Trump Gaza Plan With Its Own". The New York Times. 2025-11-14. Retrieved 2025-11-15.
  39. "US, Israel look to Africa for Gaza relocation plan". The Jerusalem Post. 14 March 2025.
  40. "Reports: Morocco, 2 disputed Somalia regions considered as destinations for Gazans". The Times of Israel. 7 February 2025. Retrieved 22 March 2025.
  41. "US, Israel see Syria as possible home for relocated Gazans, says report". The Times of Israel. 17 March 2025.
  42. Shawkat, Ahmed (5 March 2025). "U.S., Israel reject Gaza reconstruction plan backed by Arab nations". CBS . Retrieved 19 March 2025.
  43. "AP Exclusive: US and Israel look to Africa for moving Palestinians uprooted from Gaza". Associated Press . 14 March 2025. Retrieved 16 March 2025.
  44. Rajan, Gnaneshwar; Abdelaziz, Khalid; Sheikh, Abdi; Al Mughrabi, Nidal (17 March 2025). "Somalia and Somaliland say no talks on resettling Palestinians from Gaza". Daily Dispatch. Retrieved 19 March 2025.
  45. "Trump administration working on plan to move 1 million Palestinians to Libya". NBC News . 16 May 2025. Retrieved 16 May 2025.
  46. "Million Palestinians could be relocated to Libya under US plans, report claims". The Independent . 17 May 2025. Retrieved 17 May 2025.
  47. "Netanyahu 'in talks' to relocate Palestinians from Gaza to South Sudan". The Independent . 2025-08-13. Retrieved 2025-08-18.
  48. 1 2 Tipen, Konan; Farmer, Ben; Bodkin, Henry (2025-08-13). "South Sudan 'approves' Israeli plan to send Gazans to country". The Daily Telegraph . ISSN   0307-1235 . Retrieved 2025-08-18.
  49. 1 2 "Israel said in talks with South Sudan about taking in Gazans; African country denies". The Times of Israel . Associated Press. 2025-08-13. ISSN   0040-7909 . Retrieved 2025-08-18.
  50. "South Sudan says no talks with Israel to resettle Palestinians from Gaza". Reuters. 13 August 2025. Retrieved 3 September 2025.