Ramakatsa v Magashule

Last updated

Ramakatsa v Magashule
Constitutional court of South Africa.jpeg
Court Constitutional Court of South Africa
Full case nameRamakatsa and Others v Magashule and Others
Decided18 December 2012 (2012-12-18)
Docket nos.CCT 109/12
Citation(s) [2012] ZACC 31; 2013 (2) BCLR 202 (CC)
Case history
Appealed from High Court of South Africa, Free State DivisionRamakatsa and Others v Magashule and Others [2012] ZAFSHC 207
Court membership
Judges sitting Mogoeng CJ, Moseneke DCJ, Cameron J (leave to appeal only), Froneman J, Jafta J, Khampepe J, Nkabinde J, Skweyiya J, van der Westhuizen J (merits only), Yacoob J and Zondo J
Case opinions
Section 19(1)(b) of the Constitution obligates every political party to act lawfully and in accordance with its own constitution. (Unanimous.) Leave to appeal is granted. (9:1) The African National Congress's June 2012 provincial elective conference in the Free State was unlawful and invalid. (7:3)
Decision by
  • Yacoob J
    (Mogoeng, Moseneke, Cameron, Jafta, Khampepe, Nkabinde, Skweyiya and Zondo concurring on leave to appeal)
  • Moseneke DCJ and Jafta J
    (Khampepe, Nkabinde, Skweyiya, van der Westhuizen and Zondo concurring on the merits)
Dissent
  • Froneman J
    (Yacoob and Mogoeng concurring on the merits)
Keywords

Ramakatsa and Others v Magashule and Others is a 2012 decision of the Constitutional Court of South Africa on the internal governance of political parties and the section 19 right to participate in political party activities. The court reviewed and overturned an internal elective conference held by the African National Congress (ANC) in Parys, Free State in June 2012. This had the effect of invalidating the election of the Free State ANC's provincial leadership, including the election of Ace Magashule as ANC Provincial Chairperson.

Contents

Writing for a majority of the court, Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke and Justice Chris Jafta held that the Constitution obligates political parties to act lawfully, in accordance with their own constitutions, and otherwise in a manner that preserves their members' political rights. Thus, insofar as the ANC had disenfranchised its members by ignoring electoral irregularities in the internal conference, it had violated its members' constitutional rights as well as their contractual rights.

Background

Between 21 and 24 June 2012 in Parys, the Free State provincial branch of the African National Congress (ANC) held its provincial elective conference. It elected the Free State ANC's new Provincial Executive Committee (PEC), which would serve for the next four years and which included the provincial party's executive leaders, including the Provincial Chairperson. All five executive leaders were elected unopposed, and Ace Magashule, who was also the Premier of the Free State, secured his fourth consecutive term as Provincial Chairperson. [1] Their election was unopposed because their opponents, led by outgoing ANC Provincial Treasurer Mxolisi Dukwana, boycotted the elective conference, alleging that there had been election fraud. [2]

In particular, Dukwana and his supporters alleged that there had been irregularities in the selection of the delegates who attended the provincial elective conference and voted in the election. According to the ANC's constitution, these delegates were mandated by their local party branch at branch general meetings, through a designated procedure. Dukwana's supporters alleged that many of the delegates who attended the provincial conference had been selected according to improper procedures, in violation of the ANC constitution, in order to predetermine a victory for Magashule and his faction. [2] Thus, they claimed, the provincial conference was improperly constituted and the electoral outcomes were invalid. [1]

However, the National Executive Committee of the ANC endorsed the results of the provincial conference, with national ANC Secretary-General Gwede Mantashe validating an audit of the delegates. [1] Dukwana's supporters suggested that Mantashe and other national party leaders were complicit in the Magashule faction's fraud: the outcomes of the provincial conference had national political significance, especially because the PEC would be voting delegates to the ANC's 53rd National Conference, which was to be held in December 2012. Unlike Dukwana's faction, [3] Magashule's faction was supportive of incumbent ANC President Jacob Zuma, and, were Zuma to win a second term in the ANC presidency in December 2012, he would also become the party's presidential candidate in the 2014 general election. [2] Because of the ANC's electoral dominance, its national conference – and therefore also its provincial conferences – would have an indirect but significant effect on the outcome of the presidential election.

Prior action

In August 2012, six ordinary branch members of the Free State ANC, led by Mpho Ramakatsa, applied to the High Court of South Africa to challenge the propriety of the provincial conference. Represented by Dali Mpofu, they sought an order nullifying the outcomes of the leadership elections held at the conference. [4] They named 26 respondents, including the 25 members of the PEC elected at the conference – Provincial Chairperson Magashule, Deputy Provincial Chairperson Thabo Manyoni, Provincial Secretary William Bulwane, Deputy Provincial Secretary Mamiki Qabathe, Provincial Treasurer Msebenzi Zwane, and 20 additional members – and the national ANC itself.

The application was heard in the High Court's Free State Division on 11 October 2012. Judge M. H. Rampai dismissed their application on 26 October, handing down judgment on 13 November. He did not consider the merits of the application but dismissed it on the grounds that there were several fatal procedural defects in the case. [5]

The applicants sought to bypass the regular process of appeals, lodging an urgent application to appeal directly to the apex court, the Constitutional Court of South Africa. The urgent application for direct leave to appeal was heard in the Constitutional Court on 20 November 2012, and, after that application was granted, the merits of the appeal were heard on 29 November 2012. [6] The court handed down separate orders after each hearing but conjoined its reasons in a single judgment, handed down on 18 December 2012.

Judgments

Leave to appeal

Majority opinion

On 21 November 2012, after hearing the urgent application for leave to appeal, the court handed down an order granting leave to appeal and scheduling a hearing on the merits for 29 November 2012; the respondents were invited to file further papers opposing the merits of the appellants' case, if so inclined. This order had the support of a nine-to-one majority, comprising Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng, Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke, and Justices Edwin Cameron, Chris Jafta, Sisi Khampepe, Bess Nkabinde, Thembile Skweyiya, Zak Yacoob, and Raymond Zondo. Their reasons were set out in an opinion written by Justice Yacoob.

Minority opinion

The sole dissenting opinion was written by Justice Johan Froneman. He held that, although the matter invoked political rights protected by the Constitution, and although the appeal had reasonable prospects of success, it was not in the interests of justice for the Constitutional Court to hear the merits urgently and as a court of first instance: the applicants' argument might justify urgent hearing in the High Court or in the intermediate Supreme Court of Appeal, but it raised "no issue that needs urgent constitutional clarification in the national or public interest". Although "the practical reality" might be that ANC provincial conferences affect the outcome of general elections, that is not a reality recognised by the Constitution, according to which the President of South Africa is elected by the National Assembly.

Merits

Majority opinion

After hearing the merits of the appeal, a majority of the Constitutional Court upheld the appeal on 18 December 2012. The majority comprised Deputy Chief Justice Moseneke and Justice Jafta, who together wrote the majority's opinion on the merits, as well as Justices Khampepe, Nkabinde, Skweyiya, Zondo, and Johann van der Westhuizen. Van der Westhuizen, who had not heard the original application for leave to appeal, joined the coram in place of Justice Cameron, who did not hear the merits.

In their opinion, Moseneke and Jafta held that, factually, the ANC provincial conference had not been properly constituted in terms of the ANC Constitution; as the applicants claimed, the delegates had not been properly audited and accredited. On these grounds, aggrieved party members had a common law claim of contractual infringement against the ANC, since the party's constitution was a contract between the party and its members. More significantly, the majority held that the breach was not just contractual but also constitutional. It reached this conclusion by exploring the relationship between political parties and the political rights protected by section 19 of the Constitution, which the court sought to give a historical and purposive application.

In particular, section 19(1)(b) of the Constitution protects every citizen's right "to participate in the activities of... a political party". As private organisations, individual political parties may choose how to regulate their members' exercise of the section 19(1)(b) participation right; the ANC did so through its constitution and subsidiary rules. However, the court held that section 19(1)(b) binds each political party to adopt internal rules that are consistent with the Constitution – and that therefore protect the party's members participation rights – and, importantly for the current case, binds each political party "to act lawfully and in accordance with its own constitution". The irregularities in the Free State conference therefore violated the applicants' right to participate in the activities of their political party, the ANC. The court nullified the provincial conference, and its electoral outcomes, on these grounds, declaring them unlawful and invalid.

Minority opinion

Froneman's was again the dissenting opinion: although he would not have granted the applicants' leave to appeal, he held that the appeal should in any case fail on the merits. He agreed with the majority that it was a clear consequence of section 19 that "the right to participate in the activities of a political party imposes a duty on every political party to act lawfully and in accordance with its own constitution". However, the "factual basis" for the court's review was the assertion that the ANC had failed to investigate the alleged procedural irregularities, thereby violating its own constitution. This factual basis, according to Froneman, was "unfounded". The respondents, notably ANC Secretary-General Mantashe, had filed affidavits disputing that assertion, and Plascon-Evans obliged the court to accept those opposing affidavits as factually correct. Chief Justice Mogoeng and Justice Yacoob concurred in Froneman's judgment on the merits and would also have dismissed the appeal, though they had disagreed with Froneman about the preliminary grant of leave to appeal.

Aftermath

After the judgment was handed down, the ANC National Executive Committee abided by the Constitutional Court's decision and disbanded the Free State PEC as elected at the June 2012 conference. [7] [8] The elected members were therefore barred from voting at the 52nd National Conference later that week, though Zuma nonetheless won re-election to the ANC presidency. The Free State ANC was led by an interim task team until May 2013, when the provincial elective conference was re-run with fresh elections. The same five executive leaders, including Magashule as Provincial Chairperson, were elected to the same positions they had won illegitimately in June 2012. [9]

The ruling removed Ace Magashule from office as ANC Provincial Chairperson Ace Magashule.png
The ruling removed Ace Magashule from office as ANC Provincial Chairperson

The Ramakatsa conference was used to challenge several other elections in the Free State ANC. The next provincial elective conference, held in December 2017 in the run-up to the ANC's 53rd National Conference, resembled the June 2012 conference in various respects: Magashule was re-elected unopposed after his opponent, this time Thabo Manyoni, boycotted the conference, alleging irregularities. [10] The December 2017 election was also nullified, this time by the Bloemfontein High Court, after the court found that there had indeed been electoral irregularities inconsistent with the ANC constitution. [11] [12] [13] The December 2017 conference was re-run in June 2018 and elected Sam Mashinini as Provincial Chairperson, but it too was declared invalid. [14] [15]

In 2021, Magashule himself relied on Ramakatsa in his legal challenge to the ANC's internal step-aside rule and its use to suspend him from the party. In that matter, he was represented by Dali Mpofu, counsel for the Ramakatsa applicants. [16] [17]

Significance

Ramakatsa v Magashule was the first time that the Constitutional Court permitted an individual to base a cause of action against another non-state actor solely and directly on the contents of a constitutional right (in contrast to Khumalo v Holomisa , where the constitutional right had been used to develop existing common law). [18] It was therefore the strongest instance yet of a horizontal application of the Bill of Rights to private relationships. [18]

More specifically, it provided an influential conception of the role of political parties in participatory democracy; in New Nation Movement v President , the court grappled with Ramakatsa's application or lack thereof to the constitutional status of independent candidates. [19] Insofar as it expanded jurisprudence on the interpretation of section 19 of the Constitution, Pierre de Vos viewed Ramakatsa as a "slight correction" to the court's earlier judgments in United Democratic Movement v President and New National Party v Government, which had been criticised for espousing a "narrow and formalistic view" of democracy and political rights. [20]

De Vos also argued that Ramakatsa, and particularly the obiter finding that party constitutions must be consistent with the national Constitution, affirmed a strong link between internal party democracy and political freedoms and could be interpreted to place a positive duty on Parliament to pass a "party law" to regulate minimum standards of internal party democracy. [20]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Constitutional Court of South Africa</span> Supreme court of South Africa

The Constitutional Court of South Africa is a supreme constitutional court established by the Constitution of South Africa, and is the apex court in the South African judicial system, with general jurisdiction.

Baaitse Elizabeth "Bess" Nkabinde-Mmono is a South African retired judge who served in the Constitutional Court of South Africa from January 2006 to December 2017. During that time, she was acting Deputy Chief Justice of South Africa from 23 May 2016 to 7 June 2017. She joined the bench in November 1999 as a judge of the Bophuthatswana Provincial Division.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ace Magashule</span> South African politician and activist

Elias Sekgobelo "Ace" Magashule is a South African politician and former anti-apartheid activist who served as the Secretary General of the African National Congress (ANC), South Africa's governing party, between December 2017 and his suspension on 3 May 2021. He served as the Premier of the Free State, one of South Africa's nine provinces, from 2009 until 2018, and is known to be influential in the ANC of his home province.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sisi Ntombela</span> 6th Premier of the Free State

Sefora Hixsonia "Sisi" Ntombela is a South African politician who was the 6th Premier of the Free State and a Member of the Free State Provincial Legislature for the African National Congress. She previously served as the Free State MEC for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs and Human Settlements and as MEC for Social Development. Ntombela was also the Deputy President of the African National Congress Women's League and the treasurer of the Free State ANC.

<i>New Nation Movement NPC v President of the Republic of South Africa</i> South African legal case

New Nation Movement NPC and Others v President of the Republic of South Africa and Others, [2020] ZACC 11, is a decision of the Constitutional Court of South Africa, handed down on 11 June 2020, which declared that the Constitution requires that citizens be allowed to stand for election to the National Assembly and provincial legislatures as independents without having to join or form a political party. The declaration was suspended for 24 months to allow Parliament to modify the electoral laws to comply. The majority judgment was written by Justice Madlanga and a concurring opinion was written by Justice Jafta; these opinions were supported by eight of the nine judges hearing the case. Justice Froneman filed a dissenting opinion.

Kwekwe William Bulwane is a South African politician who has been a member of the Free State Provincial Legislature since May 2019. He had previously served as an MPL in April 2018. Bulwane had previously served in the Free State Executive Council as the Member of the Executive Council for Agriculture and Rural Development from May 2019 to October 2021 and as the MEC for Police, Roads and Transport from October 2021 until his demotion from the Executive Council in March 2023.

Sibongile Jeremia Besani is a South African politician from the Free State. Since July 2019, he has worked for the African National Congress (ANC) as head of the party presidency. He has been a member of the ANC National Executive Committee since December 2017.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gadija Brown</span> South African politician

Gadija Brown is a South African politician and banker who is a member of the Free State Provincial Legislature for the African National Congress (ANC) and the provincial Member of the Executive Council (MEC) for Finance.

Malambule Samuel Mashinini is a South African politician and trade union leader who has been a member of the Free State Provincial Legislature since 2014. A member of the African National Congress, he was elected to the Free State Provincial Legislature in May 2014. He was then appointed as Member of the Executive Council (MEC) for the Department of Public Works and Infrastructure. A year later, he became the MEC for Economic and Small Business Development, Tourism and Environmental Affairs. Mashinini was appointed MEC for Police, Roads & Transport in October 2016. He was dismissed in October 2021.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Step-aside rule</span> Policy of the African National Congress

The step-aside rule is an internal policy of the African National Congress (ANC), the ruling party of South Africa, which requires members charged with corruption or other serious crimes voluntarily to "step aside" from participation in party and government activities, or face suspension. Since its adoption in 2017 at the ANC's 54th National Conference, it has led to the suspension of several ANC members, most prominently ANC Secretary-General Ace Magashule. In 2022, it was applied to prohibit affected members from standing in internal leadership elections.

The Provincial Executive Committees (PECs) of the African National Congress (ANC) are the chief executive organs of the party's nine provincial branches. Comprising the so-called “Top Five” provincial officials and up to 30 additional elected members, each is structured similarly to the party's National Executive Committee (NEC) and is elected every four years at party provincial conferences.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mxolisi Dukwana</span> South African politician

Mxolisi Abraham Dukwana is a South African politician who has been the seventh Premier of the Free State since February 2023. He has also served as Provincial Chairperson of the Free State branch of his political party, the African National Congress (ANC), since January 2023. Prior to his election as Premier, he served in the Free State Executive Council as Member of the Executive Council (MEC) for Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs since October 2021.

Thabo Manyoni is a South African politician who was the Mayor of Mangaung Metropolitan Municipality from 2011 to 2016. He represented his party, the African National Congress (ANC), in the Free State Executive Council from 2009 to 2011 and in the National Assembly from 2016 to 2017. He was Deputy Provincial Chairperson of the ANC's Free State branch from 2008 to 2017. He was also Chairperson of the South African Local Government Association from 2011 to 2016 and in 2019 he was appointed to a five-year term as Chairperson of South Africa's Municipal Demarcation Board.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Motshidisi Koloi</span> South African politician and educator

Motshidisi Agnes Koloi, also spelled Motshidise, is a South African politician and educator who served as the Member of the Executive Council (MEC) for Social Development in the Free State provincial government between March and October 2023. Before that, she was MEC for Public Works and Human Settlements from May 2019 until March 2023. She served in the Free State Provincial Legislature as an ANC representative from May 2019 until October 2023. Prior to her election to the Provincial Legislature, Koloi had served as the executive mayor of the Moqhaka Local Municipality.

Motlagomang Grazy Qabathe, commonly known as Mamiki Qabathe, is a South African politician who served in the Executive Council of the Free State as Member of the Executive Council (MEC) for Social Development from May 2019 until October 2023. Before that, she was Speaker of the Free State Provincial Legislature from 2015 to 2019. She is a member of the African National Congress (ANC).

Vusimusi William Tshabalala is a South African politician who has represented the African National Congress (ANC) in the Free State Provincial Legislature since 2019. He was also the Majority Chief Whip in the legislature until October 2021, when he was replaced after the ANC suspended him while he faced internal disciplinary charges. He is also known for his controversial tenure in the Free State's Maluti-a-Phofung Local Municipality, where he was Mayor between 2013 and 2018.

Nokwanje Selina "Mathabo" Leeto is a South African politician who has been the Member of the Executive Council (MEC) for Health in the Executive Council of the Free State and a Member of the Free State Provincial Legislature since 2023. Leeto had previously served in the provincial legislature between 2014 and 2019 and during that time, she was the MEC for Sports, Arts, Culture and Recreation. Leeto is the Provincial Treasurer of the African National Congress, as of 2023.

Modise Casalis "Casca" Mokitlane is a former politician and diplomat from South Africa who served in the Free State Provincial Legislature from 1999 until 2014. He is a former Deputy Provincial Chairperson of the African National Congress (ANC) and is known for his short-lived defection to the opposition Congress of the People (COPE) between 2009 and 2014.

Sello Leon Dithebe is a South African politician who represented the African National Congress (ANC) in the National Assembly from 2000 to 2004 and from 2005 to 2009. He is a former Provincial Secretary of the ANC's Free State branch and in 2023 was appointed as spokesman to the Premier of the Free State, Mxolisi Dukwana.

Petrus Zanemvula "Pat" Matosa is a South African politician from the Free State. He represented the African National Congress (ANC) in the National Assembly from 1997 to 1999 and before that in the Free State Provincial Legislature from 1994 to 1997. His career as a public representative was cut short when he was convicted of the attempted murder of a traffic cop, though his conviction was later overturned.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Merten, Marianne (24 June 2012). "Free State ANC meets amidst tension". IOL. Archived from the original on 17 December 2021. Retrieved 17 December 2021.
  2. 1 2 3 "Ace set to win Free State for JZ". The Mail & Guardian. 21 June 2012. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  3. "Faction aims to unseat Magashule". The Mail & Guardian. 26 April 2012. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  4. "Magashule abusing courts to keep leadership 'merits' quiet: Mpofu". Sunday Times. 11 October 2012. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  5. "Free State ANC members lose court bid". News24. 26 October 2012. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  6. "ConCourt reserves judgment in ANC Free State case". The Mail & Guardian. 29 November 2012. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  7. "Free State ANC PEC barred from voting at Mangaung". The Mail & Guardian. 15 December 2012. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  8. "ANC to disband Free State provincial executive after court ruling". Business Day. 15 December 2012. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  9. "Free State ANC re-elects controversial Ace Magashule". The Mail & Guardian. 11 May 2013. Retrieved 9 January 2023.
  10. "Ace Magashule scores another term as Free State ANC leader". The Mail & Guardian. 12 December 2017. Retrieved 9 January 2023.
  11. "Free State ANC conference declared unlawful, 14 branches sanctioned". The Mail & Guardian. 15 December 2017. Retrieved 9 January 2023.
  12. Merten, Marianne (2 April 2019). "Ace Magashule & the ANC election lists: Nineteen years of strife and manipulation". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  13. Mokoena and Others v Magashule and Others (2555/2016) [2017] ZAFSHC 224 (14 December 2017).
  14. Ngqakamba, Sesona (31 March 2021). "SCA rules 2018 ANC Free State election 'unlawful and unconstitutional'". News24. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  15. Ramakatsa and Others v African National Congress and Another (724/2019) [2021] ZASCA 31 (31 March 2021).
  16. Vos, Pierre de (18 May 2021). "Ace would appear to have a losing hand in his court battle with the ANC". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  17. Ngalwa, Sibusiso (28 June 2021). "Ace Magashule's court case against the ANC is more a political than legal battle". Daily Maverick. Retrieved 26 February 2024.
  18. 1 2 Dafel, Michael (2015). "The directly enforceable constitution: Political parties and the horizontal application of the Bill of Rights". South African Journal on Human Rights. 31 (1): 56–85.
  19. Zongwe, Dunia (1 May 2021). "New Nation Movement NPC and Others v President of the Republic of South Africa and Others 2020 (6) SA 257 (CC)". SAIPAR Case Review. 4 (1). ISSN   2522-686X.
  20. 1 2 de Vos, Pierre (2015). "It's My Party (And I'll Do What I Want To)?: Internal Party Democracy and Section 19 of The South African Constitution". South African Journal on Human Rights. 31 (1): 30–55. doi:10.1080/19962126.2015.11865234. ISSN   0258-7203.