Robert Dowdall

Last updated March 09, 2023

Sir Robert Dowdall (died 1482) was an Irish judge who held the office of Chief Justice of the Irish Common Pleas for more than forty years. He is mainly remembered today for the murderous assault on him by Sir James Keating, the Prior of Kilmainham, in 1462.^[1]

Career

He was the son of Luke Dowdall of County Louth. The Dowdalls were a Derbyshire family who originated at Dovedale, and came to Ireland in the thirteenth century, where they were mainly based at Newtown and Termonfeckin.^[2] Later members of the family included George Dowdall, Archbishop of Armagh, James Dowdall, the Catholic martyr, and his cousin, also James Dowdall, Lord Chief Justice of Ireland.^[1]

Dovedale, Derbyshire Dovedale.JPG — Dovedale, Derbyshire

He was appointed King's Serjeant in 1435 and Chief Justice of the Court of Common Pleas (Ireland) in 1438; he held the latter office until his death in 1482. He was Deputy Treasurer of Ireland in 1461 and was knighted the same year. In 1446, he took a lease of lands in County Louth from Robert FitzRery, the future Attorney General for Ireland, who was later a colleague of Dowdall on the Court of Common Pleas.^[3]

Marriage

He married (almost certainly his second marriage) Anne Wogan, daughter and co-heiress with her sister Katherine of John Wogan of Rathcoffey, County Kildare, in 1454.^[4] She was the widow of Oliver Eustace of the influential Castlemartin family. She owned substantial dower lands, including Clongowes Wood, but lost Rathcoffey Castle itself, following a bitter inheritance dispute with her cousin Richard Wogan, former Lord Chancellor of Ireland. She also laid claim to the ancestral Wogan lands in Pembrokeshire although her right to inherit these lands was disputed by her sister Katherine and her husband, the Welshman Owen Dunn, or Owain Dwnn.^[4] Although Robert and Anne appealed to the King and Council for redress, Owain and Katherine remained in possession of Picton Castle, the Wogan's stronghold in Wales.^[4]

Robert resided mainly at Clontarf near Dublin.^[1]

Rathcoffey Castle

He was a companion of the Brotherhood of Saint George, a short-lived military order founded by King Edward IV in 1474 for the defence of the Pale.^[5]

Attempted murder of Dowdall by Sir James Keating

Dowdall is chiefly remembered for the murderous assault on him in 1462 by Sir James Keating, Prior of the Knights Hospitallers. At Pentecost 1462, Dowdall, who was making a pilgrimage to a holy well 'one of the shrines of the Pale', was attacked 'near Clonliff' (North of Dublin city) by Keating, armed with a sword, and was put in fear of his life.^[6] There seems no reason to doubt that the Prior meant to kill him. Dowdall prosecuted Keating before the Irish Parliament, which found the Prior guilty of assault. He was fined £100, and ordered to pay Dowdall 100 marks as compensation, but was able through the use of a technicality to evade making either payment.^[7]

The motive for the attack is unknown: Elrington Ball, comparing it to the murder of James Cornwalsh, Chief Baron of the Irish Exchequer, twenty years earlier, argued that crimes of violence were endemic in medieval Ireland.^[1] However, equally savage crimes took place in contemporary England, such as the murder in 1455 of the respected lawyer Nicholas Radford by followers of Thomas Courtenay, 6th Earl of Devon, undoubtedly with the Earl's connivance.^[8]

Such incidents demonstrate a general breakdown of law and order in both kingdoms in the mid-fifteenth century, which greatly weakened the authority of the English Crown. Keating, despite his clerical office, was clearly a violent and turbulent individual, who dealt with an attempt to remove him as Prior by throwing his intended successor, Marmaduke Langley, into prison, where he died. He was disgraced many years later for his part in the attempt to put the pretender Lambert Simnel on the throne of England, and died in wretched poverty in about 1491.^[9]

This was not the only serious crime of which Robert was the victim: in 1455 he and his wife Anne petitioned Parliament for the restoration of their cattle, sheep and goods which had been unlawfully seized.

Later life

In 1474, he was a party to the charter establishing the Dublin Smith's Guild, which ranked third in precedence among the Guilds of the City of Dublin. It can scarcely have gratified him to know that his old enemy Prior Keating was another of the Guild's founders.^[10] Two years later he was party to a similar charter setting up the Glovers and Skinners Guild.^[11]

In 1478, Dowdall made a gift of 100 marks, to be invested in land or merchandise or loaned out at interest, to Saint Anne's Guild, the leading medieval religious guild in Dublin. The income derived from the investments was to be used to support two priests in Saint Audoen's Church to sing and pray for Dowdall's soul, and after his death to pray for him on each anniversary of his death. He died four years later.^[1]

Descendants

His only known wife was Anne Wogan, daughter and co-heiress of John Wogan of Rathcoffey, and widow of Oliver Eustace of Castlemartin. Robert had at least one son, Thomas Dowdall, Master of the Rolls in Ireland, who was already a grown man when his father married Anne. Through Thomas, he was the ancestor of Archbishop George Dowdall and George's nephew James Dowdall, Lord Chief Justice of Ireland.^[1] He was also an ancestor of the Dowdall baronets.^[12]

Related Research Articles

Rowland FitzEustace, 1st Baron Portlester was an Irish peer, statesman and judge. He was one of the dominant political figures in late fifteenth-century Ireland, rivalled in influence probably only by his son-in-law Garret FitzGerald, the "Great" Earl of Kildare.

Sir James Donnellan was an Irish lawyer and politician, who became Chief Justice of the Irish Common Pleas in 1660. He was unusual among the Irish judges of the time in being of Gaelic descent; and more remarkable in that his service as a judge under Oliver Cromwell did not disqualify him from service after the Restoration of Charles II.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chief Justice of the Common Pleas for Ireland</span>

The chief justice of the Common Pleas for Ireland was the presiding judge of the Court of Common Pleas in Ireland, which was known in its early years as the Court of Common Bench, or simply as "the Bench", or "the Dublin bench". It was one of the senior courts of common law in Ireland, and was a mirror of the Court of Common Pleas in England. The Court of Common Pleas was one of the "four courts" which sat in the building in Dublin which is still known as the Four Courts, apart from a period in the fourteenth century when it relocated to Carlow, which was thought to be both more central and more secure for the rulers of Norman Ireland.

Sir Maurice Eustace was an Irish landowner, politician, barrister and judge of the seventeenth century who spent the last years of his career as Lord Chancellor of Ireland. This was an office for which he felt himself to be entirely unfit, and in which he was universally agreed to be a failure.

Nicholas St Lawrence, 4th Baron Howth was a leading Irish soldier and statesman of the early Tudor period, who held the office of Lord Chancellor of Ireland.

Richard Wogan was an Irish judge and cleric who held the office of Lord Chancellor of Ireland, and also served as a soldier.

Sir Thomas Luttrell was a wealthy Anglo-Irish landowner of the sixteenth-century Irish Pale. He was also a distinguished lawyer and judge who held the offices of King's Serjeant, Solicitor General for Ireland and Chief Justice of the Irish Common Pleas.

The Rochfort family came to Ireland in the thirteenth century and acquired substantial lands in counties Kildare, Meath and Westmeath. Several members of the family were prominent as lawyers and politicians. They gained the title Earl of Belvedere, and gave their name to the village of Rochfortbridge. The main Rochfort line ended with the death of the 2nd Earl of Belvedere in 1814.

Sir Thomas Cusack (also spelt Cusacke or Cusake) (1490–1571) was an Anglo-Irish judge and statesman of the sixteenth century, who held the offices of Master of the Rolls in Ireland, Lord Chancellor of Ireland, and Chancellor of the Exchequer of Ireland, and sat in the Irish House of Commons. He was one of the most trusted and dependable Crown servants of his time, although he led a somewhat turbulent private life.

Sir James Dowdall was an Irish judge of the Elizabethan era who briefly held office as Lord Chief Justice of Ireland. He should not be confused with James Dowdall, the Catholic martyr, who was his cousin.

Sir John de Shriggeley, whose family name is also spelt Shirggeley and Shryggeley was an Irish statesman and judge who held several important judicial offices, including Chief Justice of the Irish Common Pleas. Although he committed two murders, he was a valued servant of the English Crown.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Thomas Dowdall (judge)</span> Irish judge

Thomas Dowdall, also spelt Dowdale, Douedall, or Dowedall, was an Irish barrister and judge who held the office of Master of the Rolls in Ireland.

The Brotherhood of Saint George was a short-lived military guild, which was founded in Dublin in 1474 for the defence of the English-held territory of the Pale. For a short time it was the only standing army maintained by the English Crown in Ireland. It was suppressed by King Henry VII in 1494, due to his suspicions about the Brotherhood's loyalty to his dynasty. It was not an order of knighthood, although some of its individual members were knights.

Sir Thomas Plunket (c.1440–1519) was a wealthy Irish landowner, lawyer and judge in fifteenth-century and early sixteenth-century Ireland. He held office as Chief Baron of the Irish Exchequer and Chief Justice of the Irish Common Pleas. After the change of the English royal dynasty in 1485, his loyalty to the new Tudor dynasty was deeply suspect, and he was involved in two attempts to put a pretender on the English throne. On each occasion he was disgraced, fined and removed from office; yet he had sufficient political influence to ensure his return to favour and high office.

Adam Cusack (c.1630–1681) was an Irish landowner, barrister and judge of the seventeenth century.

Rathcoffey Castle is a 15th century castle in Rathcoffey, County Kildare, Ireland. It is a National Monument.

Sir James Keating was an Irish cleric and statesman of the fifteenth century. He was Prior of the Irish house of the Knights Hospitallers, which was based at Kilmainham, Dublin, and a member of the Privy Council of Ireland.

Robert Fitzrery was an Irish Law Officer, landowner and judge of the fifteenth century. He was a gifted lawyer, and the evidence also suggests that he was a shrewd and acquisitive man of business.

Hugh Canoun, or Hugh Canon was an English-born judge in early fourteenth-century Ireland. He was a justice of the Court of Common Pleas (Ireland) and served as Deputy Justiciar of Ireland. As a judge he was praised for his good and faithful service to the English Crown, and as a lawyer he was known as "a man very knowledgeable about all the King's business". On the other hand, his loyalty to the Crown during the Bruce Invasion of Ireland in 1315-18 was said to be extremely doubtful, although he was saved from disgrace by his influential connections. He was murdered by Andrew de Bermingham of Athenry during the last months of the Bruce Invasion, in the course of a private feud.

Walter de Wogan was a Welsh-born Irish administrator, soldier and judge of the early fourteenth century.

References

1 2 3 4 5 6 Ball F. Elrington The Judges in Ireland 1221-1921 John Murray London 1926 pp.100, 177-8
↑ Otway-Ruthven, A.J. A History of Medieval Ireland Barnes and Noble 1993 p. 116
↑ National Library of Ireland D. 18,590
1 2 3 Patent Roll 37 Henry VI
↑ Sir James Ware "Antiquities and History of Ireland" A. Crook Dublin 1705 p.15
↑ Thomas D'Arcy McGee A Popular History of Ireland from the Earliest Times to Catholic Emancipation Montreal 1862 3 Volumes (p. 295, Volume I)
↑ McGee History of Ireland
↑ Ross, Charles Edward IV Methuen London 1974 p. 390
↑ Brenan, M.J. Ecclesiastical History of Ireland Dublin John Coyne 1840 Vol. 2, p. 66
↑ Patent Roll 13 Edward IV
↑ Patent Roll 16 Edward IV
↑ Bernard Burke, Arthur Charles Fox-Davies, 'Dowdall Formerly of Mountttown' in A genealogical and heraldic history of the landed gentry of Ireland (Dalcassian Publishing Company, 1 Jan 1912), p.191 (Retrieved 2 November 2022).

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[Ball-1] 1 2 3 4 5 6 Ball F. Elrington The Judges in Ireland 1221-1921 John Murray London 1926 pp.100, 177-8

[2] Otway-Ruthven, A.J. A History of Medieval Ireland Barnes and Noble 1993 p. 116

[3] National Library of Ireland D. 18,590

[Roll-4] 1 2 3 Patent Roll 37 Henry VI

[5] Sir James Ware "Antiquities and History of Ireland" A. Crook Dublin 1705 p.15

[6] Thomas D'Arcy McGee A Popular History of Ireland from the Earliest Times to Catholic Emancipation Montreal 1862 3 Volumes (p. 295, Volume I)

[7] McGee History of Ireland

[8] Ross, Charles Edward IV Methuen London 1974 p. 390

[Brenan-9] Brenan, M.J. Ecclesiastical History of Ireland Dublin John Coyne 1840 Vol. 2, p. 66

[10] Patent Roll 13 Edward IV

[11] Patent Roll 16 Edward IV

[12] Bernard Burke, Arthur Charles Fox-Davies, 'Dowdall Formerly of Mountttown' in A genealogical and heraldic history of the landed gentry of Ireland (Dalcassian Publishing Company, 1 Jan 1912), p.191 (Retrieved 2 November 2022).

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]