Squab pie

Last updated

Squab pie
Squab pie ready for lid.jpg
A squab pie in preparation, before the pastry lid is added
CourseMain
Place of origin United Kingdom
Region or state South West England
Serving temperatureHot
Main ingredients Lamb, Apples

Squab pie is a traditional dish from South West England, with early records showing it was associated with Cornwall, Devon and Gloucestershire. Although the name suggests it contains squab (young domestic pigeon), in fact it contains mutton and apples. The pie was eaten around the world in the 1900s, though outside South West England it generally did contain pigeon.

Contents

Origins

Although it is not known exactly where squab pie was first made, it is clear that it was somewhere in South West England. There are references to it originating in Gloucestershire, [1] Devon [2] and Cornwall. [3] Although it appears that squab pie did originally contain pigeons, [4] mutton and apples have been used as a substitute since at least 1737 [5] using a recipe that has remained in cookbooks for years afterwards. [6] [7] This misnaming has meant that the pie is considered to be a surprise. [8] Squab is described as tender with a mild berry flavour, [9] and so it is possible that the combination of mutton and apples created a similar flavour. There is also a theory that the name squab pie is short for "squabble pie", as it stems from a disagreement over whether to have a meat or apple pie. [4]

There are many variations to the squab pie in England, although it traditionally includes mutton, it has come to mean a pie with many ingredients [10] or a "scraps pie". [11] Squab pie in Devon can be served with clotted cream. [12] Alternatively, in America, it is cooked with squab, and is synonymous with pigeon pie. [13]

Recipe

Squab pie is a mutton pie with a shortcrust pastry lid. It should be made with at least one layer of onions, followed by alternating layers of sliced apples and mutton chops. The mixture should be covered with water, though less than in some pies, covered with pastry and baked in the oven for about two hours. [14]

Variations

Within the UK, the most common variation is to use lamb instead of mutton. [15] [16] Gloucester Squab pie did not require lamb and suggests any leftover meat could be used. [1] Other ingredients can be included, for example Agatha Christie produced a variant which included hard-boiled eggs [4] and another recipe took the concept of serving with clotted cream and adds cream to thicken. [12]

Outside of England, the concept of squab pie does exist, but in a more literal form actually containing squab. Known as Piccioni All'Inglese, one Italian chef explains that he is aware that the recipe does not match the traditional English version, but he "[does] not care a fig". [17] In America, squab pie still uses squab. It was included in a "Cooking for profit" book in San Francisco, to make a pie using 18 squabs in a gravy. [18]

Reaction

In 2009, less than 3% of British teenagers had tried the dish and it has been listed amongst the "at risk" British Classics. [4] A prominent critic of squab pie was Charles Dickens' journal All the Year Round :

Of all the west country pies, squab pie is, in our humble estimation, the most incongruous and the most detestable. The odious composition is made of fat clumsy mutton chops, embedded in layers of sliced apples, shredded onions, and — O tempora! O mores! — brown sugar! The result is nausea, unsociability, and, in course of time, hatred of the whole human race. The greasy sugary, oniony taste is associated, in our mind, with the detested name of Bideford.

—  Charles Dickens & Wilkie Collins, All the Year Round [19]

Using its many ingredients definition, squab pie was used by Gallynipper as an analogy for New York City. [20] This is a positive comparison, explaining that New York does "not smell bad... nor look uninviting" and that it is "a wonder and a success".

Poetry

Then in parts minutely nice
Soft and fragrant apples slice
With its dainty flesh, the sheep
Next must swell the luscious heap
Then the onions savory juice
Sprinkle not with hand profuse

A gentleman of Bodmin, 1846 [21]

Squab pie has been the subject of poetry. In "The Squab-Pie. A Devonshire Tale" published in 1827, John Taylor uses verse to tell of the captain of a ship in Plymouth who forgot to get meat for his trip. A boy on the ship goes into town to claim a large squab pie from the bakery for a penny, though it was not meant to be his. Set on a Sunday, the family who had commissioned the pie from the baker, in order to avoid cooking, try to find it, but to no avail. Taylor explains the moral is that if you believe it is a sin to cook on a Sunday, you should not be still having a big meal by getting a baker to cook for you. [22]

The ingredients are given in verse by a Cornishman from Bodmin, during William Sandys' 1846 tour around Cornwall. Sandys also includes a story of Christmas-time in Cornwall which includes the pie served with mashed potatoes and pilchards. [21] In "Verses Occasioned by Ben Tyrrell's Mutton Pies", published in 1772, Thomas Warton also confirmed that the squab pie was mutton based and came from Cornwall. [23] The Devon author, William Crossing, writing in 1911, discusses a short folk rhyme about squab pie: "Mutton, onions, apples and dough, Make a good pie as any I know." He does not say, however, from where he heard it. [24] In the song "Glorious Devon" written by Sir Edward German in 1905, several Devonshire dishes receive praise: "Squab pie, junket and cider brew, Richest cream of the cow, What 'ud Old England without 'em do?" [25]

Devil in Cornwall

Another legend surrounding squab pie, along with the other unusual pies of Cornwall, is that they were the reason that the Devil never came to Cornwall. In his book Popular Romances of the West of England; or, The drolls, traditions, and superstitions of old Cornwall, a collection of Cornish traditions, Robert Hunt explains that the Devil crossed the River Tamar to Torpoint. The chapter, entitled "The Devil's Coits, etc.", reasons that the Devil discovered the Cornish would put anything in a pie and decided to leave before they took a fancy to a "devilly" pie, returning to Devon. [26]

See also

Related Research Articles

Chowder Category of soups

Chowder is a type of soup or stew often prepared with milk or cream and thickened with broken crackers, crushed ship biscuit, or a roux. Variations of chowder can be seafood or vegetable. Crackers such as oyster crackers or saltines may accompany chowders as a side item, and cracker pieces may be dropped atop the dish. New England clam chowder is typically made with chopped clams and diced potatoes, in a mixed cream and milk base, often with a small amount of butter. Other common chowders include seafood chowder, which includes fish, clams, and many other types of shellfish; lamb or veal chowder made with barley; corn chowder, which uses corn instead of clams; a wide variety of fish chowders; and potato chowder, which is often made with cheese. Fish chowder, corn chowder, lamb chowder, and especially clam chowder are popular in the North American regions of New England and Atlantic Canada; and internationally in New Zealand.

English cuisine Culinary traditions of England

English cuisine encompasses the cooking styles, traditions and recipes associated with England. It has distinctive attributes of its own, but also shares much with wider British cuisine, partly through the importation of ingredients and ideas from the Americas, China, and India during the time of the British Empire and as a result of post-war immigration.

Pie Baked, filled pastry

A pie is a baked dish which is usually made of a pastry dough casing that contains a filling of various sweet or savoury ingredients. Sweet pies may be filled with fruit, nuts, brown sugar, sweetened vegetables, or with thicker fillings based on eggs and dairy. Savoury pies may be filled with meat, eggs and cheese (quiche) or a mixture of meat and vegetables.

Pasty Baked pie filled with meat or vegetables

A pasty is a British baked pastry, a traditional variety of which is particularly associated with Cornwall, United Kingdom. It is made by placing an uncooked filling, typically meat and vegetables, on one half of a flat shortcrust pastry circle, folding the pastry in half to wrap the filling in a semicircle and crimping the curved edge to form a seal before baking.

Shepherds pie Meat pie with a crust or topping of mashed potato

Shepherd's pie, cottage pie, or hachis Parmentier is a dish consisting of cooked minced meat topped with mashed potato. Its defining ingredients are red meat and onions in gravy or sauce, with a topping of mashed potato. Common variants include adding vegetables to the filling and topping the dish with cheese.

Lancashire hotpot English stew from Lancashire, England

Lancashire hotpot is a stew originating from Lancashire in the North West of England. It consists of lamb or mutton and onion, topped with sliced potatoes and baked in a heavy pot on a low heat.

Clotted cream Thick cream made by indirectly heating full-cream cows milk

Clotted cream is a thick cream made by indirectly heating full-cream cow's milk using steam or a water bath and then leaving it in shallow pans to cool slowly. During this time, the cream content rises to the surface and forms "clots" or "clouts", hence the name. It forms an essential part of a cream tea.

Stargazy pie Cornish dish made of baked fish

Stargazy pie is a Cornish dish made of baked pilchards (sardines), along with eggs and potatoes, covered with a pastry crust. Although there are a few variations using other types of fish, the unique feature of stargazy pie is fish heads protruding through the crust, so that they appear to be gazing to the stars.

Scottish cuisine Culinary traditions of Scotland

Scottish cuisine encompasses the cooking styles, traditions and recipes associated with Scotland. It has distinctive attributes and recipes of its own, but also shares much with British and wider European cuisine as a result of local, regional, and continental influences—both ancient and modern.

<i>The Compleat Housewife</i> Book by Eliza Smith

The Compleat Housewife, or, Accomplish'd Gentlewoman's Companion is a cookery book written by Eliza Smith and first published in London in 1727. It became extremely popular, running through 18 editions in fifty years.

There are many geographically indicated foods of the United Kingdom. In British cuisine, there is a custom of naming foodstuffs with reference to their place of origin. However, there are other reasons for this practice; Scotch egg, which was invented in London and Dover sole which indicates where they were landed, for example.

Hodge-podge or hotch potch is a soup or stew, usually based on diced mutton or other meat, with green and root vegetables. It is familiar in different versions in Britain and North America and is particularly associated with Scotland.

Cornish cuisine

Cornish cuisine encompasses the cooking styles, traditions and recipes associated with Cornwall and the Cornish people. It has been heavily influenced by the geography of the county as well as its social history.

Cuisine of Devon

The cuisine of Devon in England has influenced, and been influenced, by other British cuisine.

<i>The Accomplisht Cook</i> 1660 English cookery book by Robert May

The Accomplisht Cook is an English cookery book published by the Restoration era professional cook Robert May in 1660, and the first to group recipes logically into sections.

Fish and Tin and Copper is a traditional folk song/ballad associated with Cornwall, and dealing with the legend of the devil visiting Cornwall and being frightened away, fearing that he'd be made into a Cornish pasty filling.

In English cuisine, battalia pie is a large game pie, or occasionally a fish pie, filled with many small "blessed" pieces, beatilles, of offal, in a gravy made from meat stock flavoured with spices and lemon. The dish was described in cookery books of the 17th and 18th centuries.

<i>The Queen-Like Closet</i>

The Queen-like Closet, Or, Rich Cabinet was a cookery book published in 1670 by the English writer on household management, Hannah Woolley. It ran through five English editions by 1684. At least two German editions were also printed.

Pie in American cuisine has roots in English cuisine and has evolved over centuries to adapt to American cultural tastes and ingredients. The creation of flaky pie crust shortened with lard is credited to American innovation.

References

  1. 1 2 Gleanings From Gloucestershire Housewives - Traditional Recipes. READ BOOKS. 2006. p. 20. ISBN   1-4067-9380-9.
  2. ↑ Gillington Byron, May (1932). Pot-luck: or, The British home cookery book; over a thousand recipes from old family. Hodder and Stoughton. p. 21.
  3. ↑ King, William (1708). The Art of Cookery: in imitation of Horace's Art of Poetry. With some Letters to Dr Lister and Others. London: Printed for Bernard Lintott. p.  75.
  4. 1 2 3 4 "Pigeon pie... without the pigeon". Western Morning News. 27 February 2009.
  5. ↑ The whole duty of a woman, or, An infallible guide to the fair sex. London: T Read. 1737. pp.  504. squab pie.
  6. ↑ Glasse, Hannah (1747). The art of cookery made plain and easy: which far exceeds any thing of the kind yet published. W. Strahan. pp.  144. squab pie.
  7. ↑ Rundell, Maria (1808). A new system of domestic cookery. J Murray. p. 132.
  8. ↑ "Pies are a part of American Heritage". Sarasota Herald-Tribune. 14 April 1978. Retrieved 21 January 2011.
  9. ↑ Canova, Jane (Spring 2005). "Monuments to the Birds: Dovecotes and Pigeon Eating in the Land of Fields". Gastronomica . 5 (2): 50–59. doi:10.1525/gfc.2005.5.2.50.
  10. ↑ Walker, John (1809). Principles of English Pronunciation. J. Johnson and T. Cadell and W. Davies. p. 500.
  11. ↑ Gould, Sabine. In The Roar of the Sea. p. 405.
  12. 1 2 Henry, Diana (26 September 2010). "Devonshire 'squab' pie recipe". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 20 January 2011.
  13. ↑ Webster, Noah (1830). American dictionary of the English language: exhibiting the origin, orthography, pronunciation, and definitions of words. Converse. pp.  783. squab pie.
  14. ↑ Bregion, Joseph (1845). The Practical Cook. Chapman and Hall. pp.  264–265.
  15. ↑ Hobson, Jeremy (2007). Curious Country Customs. David & Charles. p. 78. ISBN   978-0-7153-2658-9.
  16. ↑ "Lamb Pie". BBC. Retrieved 20 January 2011.
  17. ↑ Baca, Murtha (2003). Science in the kitchen and the art of eating well. Toronto Press. pp. 215–216. ISBN   0-8020-8657-8.
  18. ↑ Whitehead, Jessup (1893). Cooking for Profit. Forgotten Books. p. 142. ISBN   1-4400-7331-7.
  19. ↑ Dickens, Charles; Collins, Wilkie (June 1868). "Leaves from the mahogany tree: Concerning pies". All the Year Round. 19: 613.
  20. ↑ Gallynipper (1882). Gallynipper in Yankeeland. Carlisle, Massachusetts: Applewood books. p. 129. ISBN   1-4290-0446-0.
  21. 1 2 Sandys, William (1846). Specimens of Cornish provincial dialect. J R Smith. pp.  79.
  22. ↑ Taylor, John (1827). Poems on various subjects. London: Payne and Foss. pp.  190–193.
  23. ↑ Warton, Thomas (1772). The Oxford sausage, or Select poetical pieces, written by the most celebrated wits of the University of Oxford. Oxford: G. Robinson. pp. 22–23.
  24. ↑ Crossing, William (1911). "Squab Pie". Folk Rhymes of Devon. Exeter: James G. Commin. p. 119.
  25. ↑ "The gem of that fair galaxy". Exeter Express and Echo. Local World . Retrieved 23 December 2014.
  26. ↑ Hunt, Robert (1871). Popular romances of the west of England; or, The drolls, traditions, and superstitions of old Cornwall. JC Hotten. pp. 185–186.

Sources

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.