The Global Dilemma: Guns or Butter

Last updated
The Global Dilemma: Guns or Butter
Guns or Butter IBP PC box cover.jpg
Developer(s) Chris Crawford
Publisher(s) Mindscape
Platform(s) Macintosh, DOS
Release1990
Genre(s) Strategy, Wargame
Mode(s) Single-player

The Global Dilemma: Guns or Butter is a 1990 video game written by Chris Crawford and published by Mindscape. It was originally released on the Macintosh, and then for IBM PC compatibles. The game is a simulation of macroeconomics in which the player attempts to improve the economy of their country in an effort to outproduce the computer players. Over time this allows them to build up a military superiority and take over the opposing countries. If the computer beats the player, the game shows them facing an animated firing squad.

Contents

The Global Dilemma failed to achieve the play balance that Crawford desired, and he considered it among the worst games he released. It was commercially unsuccessful, earning Crawford no royalties past the advance. He used some of the same basic concepts as the basis of his next game, Balance of the Planet .

Gameplay

Global Dilemma takes place on a randomly drawn continent consisting of a number of provinces. The provinces are assigned to the players in contiguous groups to create countries, one for each human or computer player. Double-clicking on a province opens a data card showing its details, including the population and details of the geography. The game starts in 1520 and each turn lasts a year. The game is modal, advancing through three stages before the computer calculates the results of the turn and displays the outcomes. [1]

After examining the map, the player uses the Next Phase command to bring them to the economic summary screen. Here all of the basic commodities and products are listed, along with their recent production and any surplus or deficit. Some of these items are basic commodities like lumber or coal, whose production rate, or output, is governed by the number of people assigned to the task. Others, like food, use a combination of labor assignment and tools, so the output can be improved by building tools for the assigned workers. [1]

Double-clicking on any of the economic items opens another window that shows the inputs and outputs for that item. For instance, opening the lumber item shows the number of workers assigned to producing lumber, and that the lumber is used to make charcoal, farm tools and plows. Double clicking on the charcoal icon in this window takes you to the charcoal window, which shows its input being lumber and its output being used to make pig iron and gunpowder. Double-clicking pig iron shows you its inputs as iron ore and charcoal, and its output being farm tools and swords. Lines between the various items show the amount of goods flowing through the system, along with any surplus or (if the line is missing) deficit. If an item, like iron ore, is only being used to produce one output item, only that line will be displayed. [1]

After assigning labor, the player once again uses the Next Phase command to move to the combat commands screen on the main map. Each province now displays an icon indicating the number of troops available, and instructions to move them can be made by dragging the icons. Another use of Next Phase shows the combat outcomes on the map, or goes directly to the turn summary if there is no combat or it is completed. [1]

In advanced games, the diplomatic system is also available. In this system the players can propose alliances to protect each other or attack others. The system shows the relationships between the leaders on a scatterplot and expressions on the faces indicating their relationship with the player. This allows the player to estimate who would join an alliance at a glance. [1]

Development

Crawford had an enormous hit with Balance of Power in 1985, selling hundreds of thousands of copies and making about $10 million for its publisher, Mindscape. [2] During the development of Power he had cut a number of ideas to keep the game simple and allow it to fit within the 128 kB memory of the original Macintosh computers. He later concluded these ideas didn't really belong in that game anyway, especially the more detailed economics concepts, but they had always struck him as interesting. [3]

He followed this up in 1987 with Trust & Betrayal: The Legacy of Siboot , but it was not a commercial success, in spite of being one of Crawford's favorite games. [4] His publisher, Mindscape, asked him to do a sequel of Balance of Power as his next effort, and this was released in 1990 as Balance of Power: The 1990 Edition. Crawford was not terribly happy with the effort, considering it to be more a cleaned up version of the original than a true sequel. [5]

Some time around this point, Crawford, Sid Meier and Dan Bunten all began work on new empire building games. They later met to discuss their designs. [5] Meier stated his goal was to make the game fun, above anything else, and he was willing to abandon realism or depth to achieve that end. He went on to release Civilization in late 1991, which was a huge success and produced a series of sequels. Bunten was primarily interested in putting social aspects into the system, following in the footsteps of the lauded M.U.L.E. [lower-alpha 1] Bunten went on to release Global Conquest in 1992, a four-player game with cooperative elements that received highly favorable reviews. [6]

Crawford's game started out with the name Macro-Economic Conquest. As the name implies, his design focused on the economic aspects of production, and how they affected the running of an empire. The basic concept was to define the relationships between the raw materials and the worked goods needed to gather them; for instance, farming was improved by building farm tools, which could be built by assigning workers to create them using wood and iron. Iron, in turn, required charcoal and iron ore. [7]

Other inputs into the design were his dissatisfaction with fixed maps and a desire to improve the diplomacy system. The first led to the creation of a purely algorithmic system for generating random continents with provinces within them. The system generated more complex and convincingly real landforms than contemporary systems like Empire , which drew blob-like shapes. [8] Another algorithm was used to generate random names for the provinces. The second was inspired by work he had seen at Atari, Inc. by Susan Brennan that could change a face to represent different emotions. He used this concept in the game to modify the faces of the computer players when they met during diplomatic events. [9]

Reception

Crawford was not alone in considering Dilemma to be among his poorest games, [7] but the poor sales translated into almost no reviews.

Chuck Moss reviewed the game for Computer Gaming World , and stated that "to be totally fair, it is an uneven product, one whose military and diplomatic components do not measure up to its groundbreaking economic model. In a classroom, G/B would probably get an A+ for effort, but an overall B+ in result." [10]

In 1991, PC Format named The Global Dilemma one of the 50 best computer games ever. The editors wrote, "If it's global political simulations you're after, nobody does it better than Chris Crawford. This and his earlier offering, Balance of Power, are unparalleled works of sheer genius." [11]

Notes

  1. ↑ Crawford considers M.U.L.E. the best game design of all time. [5]

Related Research Articles

In software engineering, porting is the process of adapting software for the purpose of achieving some form of execution in a computing environment that is different from the one that a given program was originally designed for. The term is also used when software/hardware is changed to make them usable in different environments.

<i>M.U.L.E.</i> 1983 video game

M.U.L.E. is a 1983 multiplayer video game written for the Atari 8-bit family of home computers by Ozark Softscape. Designer Danielle Bunten Berry took advantage of the four joystick ports of the Atari 400 and 800 to allow four-player simultaneous play. M.U.L.E. was one of the first five games published in 1983 by new company Electronic Arts, alongside Axis Assassin, Archon: The Light and the Dark, Worms?, and Hard Hat Mack. Primarily a turn-based strategy game, it incorporates real-time elements where players compete directly as well as aspects that simulate economics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Danielle Bunten Berry</span> American game designer and programmer

Danielle Bunten Berry, formerly known as Dan Bunten, was an American game designer and programmer, known for the 1983 game M.U.L.E., one of the first influential multiplayer video games, and 1984's The Seven Cities of Gold.

<i>Balance of Power</i> (video game) 1985 video game

Balance of Power is a strategy video game of geopolitics during the Cold War, created by Chris Crawford and published in 1985 on the Macintosh by Mindscape, followed by ports to a variety of platforms over the next two years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chris Crawford (game designer)</span> Computer game designer

Christopher Crawford is an American video game designer and writer. Hired by Alan Kay to work at Atari, Inc., he wrote the computer wargame Eastern Front (1941) for the Atari 8-bit family which was sold through the Atari Program Exchange and later Atari's official product line. After leaving Atari, he wrote a string of games beginning with Balance of Power for Macintosh. Writing about the process of developing games, he became known among other creators in the nascent home computer game industry for his passionate advocacy of game design as an art form. He self-published The Journal of Computer Game Design and founded the Computer Game Developers Conference.

<i>Trust & Betrayal: The Legacy of Siboot</i> 1987 video game

Trust & Betrayal: The Legacy of Siboot, often abbreviated simply to Siboot, was a game designed and programmed by Chris Crawford for the Macintosh and published by Mindscape in 1987.

Racter is an artificial intelligence program that generates English language prose at random. It was published by Mindscape for IBM PC compatibles in 1984, then later for the Apple II, Macintosh, and Amiga. An expanded version of the software, not the one released through Mindscape, was used to generate the text for the published book The Policeman's Beard Is Half Constructed.

<i>The Settlers</i> (1993 video game) 1993 city-building and real-time strategy video game

The Settlers is a city-building video game with real-time strategy elements, developed and published by Blue Byte Software. Released in Germany for Amiga in June 1993, and in the United Kingdom in November, it is the first game in The Settlers series. In 1994, Blue Byte and Massive Development ported the game to DOS. Blue Byte published the DOS version in Europe under its original title in May, but in North America, it was published in December by SSI as Serf City: Life is Feudal. In 2018, the game was re-released for Microsoft Windows as The Settlers: History Edition.

<i>The Seven Cities of Gold</i> (video game) 1984 video game

The Seven Cities of Gold is a strategy video game created by Danielle Bunten Berry and Ozark Softscape and published by Electronic Arts in 1984. The player takes the role of a late 15th-century explorer for the Spanish Empire, setting sail to the New World in order to explore the map and interact with the natives in order to win gold and please the Spanish court. The name derives from the "seven cities" of Quivira and Cíbola that were said to be located somewhere in the Southwest United States. It is considered to be one of the earliest open world video games.

Game balance is a branch of game design with the intention of improving gameplay and user experience by balancing difficulty and fairness. Game balance consists of adjusting rewards, challenges, and/or elements of a game to create the intended player experience.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Game client</span>

A game client is a network client that connects an individual user to the main game server, used mainly in multiplayer video games. It collects data such as score, player status, position and movement from a single player and send it to the game server, which allows the server to collect each individual's data and show every player in game, whether it is an arena game on a smaller scale or a massive game with thousands of players on the same map. Even though the game server displays each player's information for every player in a game, players still have their own unique perspective from the information collected by the game client, so that every player's perspective of the game is different, even though the world for every player is the same. The game client also allows the information sharing among users. An example would be item exchange in many MMORPG games where a player exchange an item he/she doesn't want for an item he/she wants, the game clients interconnect with each other and allows the sharing of information, in this exchanging items. Since many games requires a centralized space for players to gather and a way for users to exchange their information, many game clients are a hybrid of client-server and peer-to-peer application structures.

A government simulation or political simulation is a game that attempts to simulate the government and politics of all or part of a nation. These games may include geopolitical situations, the creation of domestic political policies, or the simulation of political campaigns. They differ from the genre of classical wargames due to their discouragement or abstraction of military or action elements.

<i>Chris Crawford on Game Design</i>

Chris Crawford on Game Design (ISBN 0-13-146099-4) is a book about computer and video game design by Chris Crawford. Although referred to as the second edition of The Art of Computer Game Design, it is in fact a completely new book. It was published by Peachpit under the New Riders imprint in 2003. It includes Crawford's response to recent game developments, such as The Sims, and dedicates a chapter to each of his first 14 published games: Tanktics, Legionnaire, Wizard, Energy Czar, Scram, Eastern Front (1941), Gossip, Excalibur, Balance of Power, Patton Versus Rommel, Siboot, The Global Dilemma: Guns & Butter, Balance of the Planet and Patton Strikes Back.

<i>Patton Versus Rommel</i> 1986 video game

Patton vs. Rommel is a computer wargame designed and programmed by Chris Crawford for the Macintosh and published by Electronic Arts in 1986. Versions for MS-DOS compatible operating systems and Commodore 64 were developed by Sculptured Software and published in 1987.

<i>Legionnaire</i> (video game) Real-time tactics strategy computer game from 1982 for Atari computers

Legionnaire is a computer wargame for the Atari 8-bit series created by Chris Crawford in 1982, and released through Avalon Hill. Recreating Julius Caesar's campaigns in a semi-historical setting, the player takes command of the Roman legions in real-time battles against the barbarians.

Algorithmic game theory (AGT) is an area in the intersection of game theory and computer science, with the objective of understanding and design of algorithms in strategic environments.

Dynamic game difficulty balancing (DGDB), also known as dynamic difficulty adjustment (DDA) or dynamic game balancing (DGB), is the process of automatically changing parameters, scenarios, and behaviors in a video game in real-time, based on the player's ability, in order to avoid making the player bored or frustrated. The goal of dynamic difficulty balancing is to keep the user interested from the beginning to the end, providing a good level of challenge.

<i>Global Conquest</i> 1992 video game

Global Conquest is a video game published by Microplay Software in 1992 for IBM PC compatibles. It is a version of Empire with numerous gameplay upgrades and a multi-player mode supported via modems.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Material balance planning</span> Method of economic planning

Material balances are a method of economic planning where material supplies are accounted for in natural units and used to balance the supply of available inputs with targeted outputs. Material balancing involves taking a survey of the available inputs and raw materials in an economy and then using a balance sheet to balance the inputs with output targets specified by industry to achieve a balance between supply and demand. This balance is used to formulate a plan for resource allocation and investment in a national economy.

<i>Balance of the Planet</i> 1990 video game

Balance of the Planet is a simulation video game developed by Chris Crawford. He self-published it in 1990 for Macintosh. It was ported to MS-DOS and PC-98.

References

Citations

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Crawford 1990.
  2. ↑ Crawford 2003, p. 297.
  3. ↑ Crawford 2003, pp. 292–293.
  4. ↑ Rouse III 2010, pp. 267–268.
  5. 1 2 3 Rouse III 2010, p. 269.
  6. ↑ "CGW Salutes The Games of the Year". Computer Gaming World. November 1992. p. 110. Retrieved 4 July 2014.
  7. 1 2 Rouse III 2010, p. 270.
  8. ↑ Crawford 2003, pp. 343–348.
  9. ↑ Crawford 2003, p. 356.
  10. ↑ Moss, Chuck (December 1990). "Economic Imperative: Mindscape's The Global Dilemma: Guns or Butter". Computer Gaming World. Vol. 1, no. 77. pp. 52–54.
  11. ↑ Staff (October 1991). "The 50 best games EVER!". PC Format (1): 109–111.

Bibliography

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.