The Stone Breakers

Last updated

The Stone Breakers
French: Les Casseurs de pierres
Gustave Courbet - The Stonebreakers - WGA05457.jpg
Les Casseurs de pierres
Artist Gustave Courbet
Year1849 (1849)
Medium Oil-on-canvas
Movement Realism (arts)
SubjectWork
Dimensions1.5 m× 2.6 m(4.9 ft× 8.5 ft)
ConditionDestroyed in bombing
Location Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister, Dresden (until 1945)
Followed byLes Casseurs de pierresc. (1849)

The Stone Breakers (French : Les Casseurs de pierres), also known as Stonebreakers, was an 1849 oil painting on canvas by the French painter Gustave Courbet. Now destroyed, the image remains an often-cited example of the artistic movement Realism.

Contents

The painting was exhibited at the 1850 Paris Salon where it was criticized by for its depiction of a subject that was not considered proper for high art. Some critics disliked Courbet's application of very thick paint and the poor lighting in the image. Conversely, social theorist Pierre-Joseph Proudhon praised the work and saw it as a successful socialist painting. He called the composition "a masterpiece in its genre". By 1915, it was considered to be an "important work".

Courbet produced two versions of the painting. The version displayed at the 1850 Paris Salon was in the collection of the Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister in Dresden. At the time of its acquisition by the museum, the painting was referred to as "Courbet's monumental masterpiece". In February 1945, Dresden was bombed by the Allies of World War II. The Germans decided to relocate the painting but it was subsequently destroyed during a bombing raid while being relocated by truck to a safe storage. The second version, a reversed image, survived the war and is in the Oskar Reinhart Collection in Winterthur.

History

Gustave Courbet, Les Casseurs de pierres (1849) Oskar Reinhart Collection, Winterthur Les Casseurs de pierres by Courbet (Winterthour).png
Gustave Courbet, Les Casseurs de pierres (1849) Oskar Reinhart Collection, Winterthur
Firmin Gillot (after Gustave Courbet), The Stone Breaker (undated), National Gallery of Art Washington D.C. Gillot - The Stone Breaker (after 1849).jpg
Firmin Gillot (after Gustave Courbet), The Stone Breaker (undated), National Gallery of Art Washington D.C.

Gustave Courbet created works of art in the genre of realism and he described it as "my way of seeing". [1] In 1855 Courbet claimed that the title of realist "was thrust upon him". [2] Despite Courbet's statement he is given credit for coming up with the term realism. [3] To demonstrate his style of painting in the realism genre, Courbet once claimed that he could not paint an angel because he never saw one. [4] However in his work, The Stone Breakers, Courbet controlled the subject matter, giving the subject symbolic and intellectual components. [3]

He began work on The Stone Breakers painting in November 1849 after seeing two laborers breaking rocks along the road. Near the end of November 1849 Courbet sent a letter to his friends, French historian Francis Wey and his wife Marie Wey, describing how he found inspiration for the painting: [1]

I had taken our carriage to go to the Château of Saint-Denis to paint a landscape. Near Maisières I stopped to consider two men breaking stones on the road. One rarely encounters the most complete expression of poverty, so right there on the spot I got an idea for a painting. I made a date to meet them at my studio the following morning. And since then I have painted my picture.

Courbet went on to describe the clothing of the two peasants as representative of their low station. He also had sympathy for the two stone breakers and in letters he indicated that he was aware of the separation of classes. In describing the older worker he used the French word courbé (bent), which may have been a pun on his own last name Courbet. [1]

The Stone Breakers was first exhibited at the Paris Salon of 1850–1851. As a work of realism the subject matter addressed a scene of everyday life. The painting was meant to depict the hard labor that poor citizens experienced. [3] Courbet created two versions of the painting. [5]

The second version of the painting is a mirror image and it is in the Oskar Reinhart Collection in Winterthur. Courbet signed it in the lower right corner. The second version is smaller, measuring 56 cm × 85 cm (22 in × 33 in), and it is darker. [6]

In c. 1864 Courbet created a drawing of the younger person portrayed in The Stone Breakers. The drawing is titled, A young stone breaker. It is a black crayon drawing on white paper and it is 29.5 cm × 21.1 cm (11.6 in × 8.3 in). The work is in the Ashmolean Museum at the University of Oxford. [7] The National Gallery of Art in Washington D.C., also has a similar image of the young stone breaker. The image is attributed to Firmin Gillot and Courbet and it is from the René Huyghe collection. The dimensions of the work are 30.1 cm × 23.1 cm (11.9 in × 9.1 in). [8]

Before World War II the one version of the painting was housed at the Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister in Dresden. [9] [10] The painting was acquired by the museum c. 1882 and it was referred to as "Courbet's monumental masterpiece." [11] During World War II, from 13 to 15 February 1945, the Allies continuously bombed the city of Dresden, Germany. German troops hastily loaded artworks from Dresden's galleries and museums onto trucks. The Stone Breakers was destroyed, along with 153 other paintings, when a transport vehicle moving the pictures to the Königstein Fortress, near Dresden, was bombed by Allied forces. [12]

Description and analysis

The Stone Breakers painting is in the realism genre, and depicted two peasants (a young man and an old man) breaking rocks. [1] It considered one of the major works that led the art-world to realism. [5] In the composition old and young are on the same level in the image. It is an example of the realism of poverty and the tragedy of work-life. [13] The men are shown as two road laborers in unclean clothing. They wear wooden clogs which the press of the day satirized. Caricatures of the size of the wooden clogs on one of the subjects were exaggerated. [14]

The men in tattered clothing represented the oppressed workers who toiled breaking rocks. The painting might have caused viewers to feel uneasy because the men had tools and rocks which may be considered weapons. [15] The men had long-handled hammers. [16] Courbet may have also encouraged the uneasiness by not showing the faces of the two men. [15] The men's faces are likely not shown because they serve as representatives of the common workers. The figures in the painting perform repetitive menial labor and they demonstrate the injustice of peasant life. [5]

Courbet described the painting by saying: [1]

On one side is an old man of seventy, bent over his work, his sledgehammer raised, his skin parched by the sun, his head shaded by a straw hat; his trousers of coarse material, are completely patched; and in his cracked sabots you can see his bare heels sticking out of socks that were once blue. On the other side is a young man with swarthy skin, his head covered with dust; his disgusting shirt all in tatters reveals his arms and parts of his back; a leather suspender holds up what is left of his trousers, and his mud caked leather boots show gaping holes at every side.

In the November 1849 letter to Francis and Marie Wey, Courbet described the painting as being the same size as his other painting ( A Burial at Ornans ) which was also displayed at the Paris Salon along with The Stone Breakers. The size of A Burial at Ornans was 1.5 m × 2.6 m (4.9 ft × 8.5 ft). [5]

Jules Breton's idealized version of peasants, The Gleaners 1854 Jules Adolphe Aime Louis Breton, The Gleaners, 1854. National Gallery of Ireland.jpg
Jules Breton's idealized version of peasants, The Gleaners 1854

Other artists like Jules Breton portrayed the plight of the rural poor. Courbet's peasants in The Stone Breakers are not idealized like those in works such as Breton's 1854 painting, The Gleaners . Early in Breton's career he took inspiration from the realism that Courbet was painting. As Breton's career progressed he began to create idealized images of peasants and poor people. [17]

The Stone Breakers was controversial at the Paris Salon. The depiction of realistic subjects who were toiling in misery was considered inappropriate. The lowborn workers displayed on the large canvas were considered a portrayal of ugliness. With the painting Courbet achieved notoriety and the composition was considered to be a political statement supporting socialist ideals. It was said that the painting "scandalized" those who attended the Paris Salon. [3]

Reception

Before the Paris Salon French poet Max Buchon viewed the painting and described the two men as "the dawn and twilight of modern galley-slave existence". After the 1850 Paris Salon, French diplomat Louis de Geofroy described the sentiment in the painting by saying, "art that is made for everyone should be what everyone sees." L'Illustration published a review of The Stone Breakers and they described it as, "a subject with very little appeal". They described the composition as not treating the subjects with importance and not having appropriate lighting. Fabien Pillet reviewed the work for Le Moniteur Universel and he stated that Courbet should be counted among the painters "who reveal a marked predilection for the least civilized of rustic customs and habits". [1] Some art critics made remarks about the careless thick paint applied by palette knife and others thought the paint thickness conveyed ruggedness. Many critics conveyed the idea that the subject of the painting was not proper for high art. [5] At the Paris Salon the painting was met with hostility and the subject was considered unfit for painting. The workers were also criticized as "brutish, worn and dirty". Writer Jules Champfleury declared, "starting today, critics can get ready to fight for or against realism in art. [4]

French social theorist Pierre-Joseph Proudhon called The Stone Breakers "a masterpiece in its genre". He saw the painting as "a visual condemnation of capitalism and potential for greed". Courbet stated that the subject had to do with his interest in "real and existing things". [3] He went on to say that it was a successful case study of a "socialist painting". [1] By 1915 the painting was considered to be an "important work" and one critic called it an example of the gripping "Truth of life". [18] Art historian Sheila D. Muller has compared the composition's impact with that of Passing Mother's Grave because of the "monumental treatment of the commonplace". [19] In 2009, art historian Kathryn Calley Galitz said, "The Stone Breakers ... challenged convention by rendering scenes from daily life on the large scale previously reserved for history painting and in an emphatically realistic style." [12]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Édouard Manet</span> French painter (1832–1883)

Édouard Manet was a French modernist painter. He was one of the first 19th-century artists to paint modern life, as well as a pivotal figure in the transition from Realism to Impressionism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Impressionism</span> 19th-century art movement

Impressionism was a 19th-century art movement characterized by relatively small, thin, yet visible brush strokes, open composition, emphasis on accurate depiction of light in its changing qualities, ordinary subject matter, unusual visual angles, and inclusion of movement as a crucial element of human perception and experience. Impressionism originated with a group of Paris-based artists whose independent exhibitions brought them to prominence during the 1870s and 1880s.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jean-François Millet</span> French painter (1814–1875)

Jean-François Millet was a French artist and one of the founders of the Barbizon school in rural France. Millet is noted for his paintings of peasant farmers and can be categorized as part of the Realism art movement. Toward the end of his career, he became increasingly interested in painting pure landscapes. He is known best for his oil paintings but is also noted for his pastels, Conté crayon drawings, and etchings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Salon des Refusés</span> Art exhibition in Paris, first held in 1863

The Salon des Refusés, French for "exhibition of rejects", is generally known as an exhibition of works rejected by the jury of the official Paris Salon, but the term is most famously used to refer to the Salon des Refusés of 1863.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gustave Courbet</span> French realist painter (1819–1877)

Jean Désiré Gustave Courbet was a French painter who led the Realism movement in 19th-century French painting. Committed to painting only what he could see, he rejected academic convention and the Romanticism of the previous generation of visual artists. His independence set an example that was important to later artists, such as the Impressionists and the Cubists. Courbet occupies an important place in 19th-century French painting as an innovator and as an artist willing to make bold social statements through his work.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Exposition Universelle (1855)</span> Worlds Fair held in Paris, France, from 15 May to 15 November 1855

The Exposition Universelle of 1855, better known in English as the 1855 Paris Exposition, was a world's fair held on the Champs-Élysées in Paris, France, from 15 May to 15 November 1855. Its full official title was the Exposition Universelle des produits de l'Agriculture, de l'Industrie et des Beaux-Arts de Paris 1855. It was the first of ten major expositions held in the city between 1855 and 1937. Nowadays, the exposition's sole physical remnant is the Théâtre du Rond-Point des Champs-Élysées, designed by architect Gabriel Davioud, which originally housed the Panorama National.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Barbizon School</span> 19th century artistic movement

The Barbizon school of painters were part of an art movement toward Realism in art, which arose in the context of the dominant Romantic Movement of the time. The Barbizon school was active roughly from 1830 through 1870. It takes its name from the village of Barbizon, France, on the edge of the Forest of Fontainebleau, where many of the artists gathered. Most of their works were landscape painting, but several of them also painted landscapes with farmworkers, and genre scenes of village life. Some of the most prominent features of this school are its tonal qualities, color, loose brushwork, and softness of form.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oswald Achenbach</span> German painter

Oswald Achenbach was a German painter associated with the Düsseldorf school of painting. Though little known today, during his lifetime he was counted among the most important landscape painters of Europe. Through his teaching activities, he influenced the Kunstakademie Düsseldorf. His brother, Andreas Achenbach, who was twelve years older, was also among the most important German landscape painters of the 19th century. The two brothers were humorously called "the A and O of Landscapes".

<i>LOrigine du monde</i> Oil-on-canvas painted by Gustave Courbet

L'Origine du monde is a picture painted in oil on canvas by the French painter Gustave Courbet in 1866. It is a close-up view of the vulva and abdomen of a naked woman, lying on a bed with legs spread.

<i>The Painters Studio</i> Painting by Gustave Courbet

The Painter's Studio is an 1855 oil-on-canvas painting by Gustave Courbet. It is located in the Musée d'Orsay in Paris, France.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Realism (arts)</span> Artistic style of representing subjects realistically

Realism in the arts is generally the attempt to represent subject matter truthfully, without artificiality and avoiding speculative and supernatural elements. The term is often used interchangeably with naturalism, although these terms are not synonymous. Naturalism, as an idea relating to visual representation in Western art, seeks to depict objects with the least possible amount of distortion and is tied to the development of linear perspective and illusionism in Renaissance Europe. Realism, while predicated upon naturalistic representation and a departure from the idealization of earlier academic art, often refers to a specific art historical movement that originated in France in the aftermath of the French Revolution of 1848. With artists like Gustave Courbet capitalizing on the mundane, ugly or sordid, realism was motivated by the renewed interest in the common man and the rise of leftist politics. The realist painters rejected Romanticism, which had come to dominate French literature and art, with roots in the late 18th century.

<i>A Burial at Ornans</i> Painting by Gustave Courbet, 1850–1851

A Burial at Ornans is a painting of 1849–50 by Gustave Courbet. It is widely regarded as a major turning point in 19th-century French art. The painting records a funeral in Courbet's birthplace, the small town of Ornans. It treats an ordinary, provincial funeral with frank realism, and on the grand scale traditionally reserved for the heroic or religious scenes of history painting. Its exhibition at the 1850–51 Paris Salon created an "explosive reaction" and brought Courbet instant fame. It is currently displayed at the Musée d'Orsay in Paris, France

Bottle, Glass, Fork is an oil on canvas painting by Pablo Picasso (1881–1973). It was painted in the spring of 1912, at the height of the development of Analytic Cubism. Bottle, Glass, Fork is one of the best representations of the point in Picasso's career when his Cubist painting reached almost full abstraction. The analytic phase of Cubism was an original art movement developed by Picasso and his contemporary Georges Braque (1882–1963) and lasted from 1908-1912. Like Bottle, Glass, Fork, the paintings of this movement are characterized by the limited use of color, and a complex, elegant composition of small, fragmented, tightly interwoven planes within an all-over composition of broader planes. While the figures in Bottle, Glass, Fork can be difficult to discern, the objects do emerge after careful study of the painting. The painting is displayed in the Cleveland Museum of Art.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Realism (art movement)</span> 19th-century artistic movement

Realism was an artistic movement that emerged in France in the 1840s, around the 1848 Revolution. Realists rejected Romanticism, which had dominated French literature and art since the early 19th century. Realism revolted against the exotic subject matter and the exaggerated emotionalism and drama of the Romantic movement. Instead, it sought to portray real and typical contemporary people and situations with truth and accuracy. It did not avoid unpleasant or sordid aspects of life. The movement aimed to focus on unidealized subjects and events that were previously rejected in art work. Realist works depicted people of all social classes in situations that arise in ordinary life, and often reflected the changes brought by the Industrial and Commercial Revolutions. Realism was primarily concerned with how things appeared to the eye, rather than containing ideal representations of the world. The popularity of such "realistic" works grew with the introduction of photography—a new visual source that created a desire for people to produce representations which look objectively real.

<i>Happy Brothers</i> Painting by Uroš Predić

Happy Brothers, Their Poor Mother! is an 1887 oil painting by the Serbian artist Uroš Predić. It shows four intoxicated youths walking through their village whilst the mother of one shouts her disapproval from the distance. The painting is said to have been inspired by a frequent sight in Predić's home village of Orlovat—that of drunken youths returning from the pub at dawn. Predić painted the composition hoping it would persuade the villagers to change their ways. He was disappointed that it not only failed to decrease the incidence of drunkenness in Orlovat, but was well received by the villagers themselves, who were happy merely to have been depicted.

<i>The Bathers</i> (Courbet) 1853 painting by Gustave Courbet

The Bathers is an oil-on-canvas painting by the French artist Gustave Courbet, first exhibited at the Paris Salon of 1853, where it caused a major scandal. It was unanimously attacked by art critics for the large nude woman at its centre and the sketchy landscape background, both against official artistic canons. It was bought for 3000 francs by Courbet's future friend Alfred Bruyas, an art collector – this acquisition allowed the artist to become financially and artistically independent. It is signed and dated in the bottom right hand corner on a small rock. It has been in the musée Fabre in Montpellier since 1868.

<i>After Dinner at Ornans</i>

After Dinner at Ornans is an oil-on-canvas painting by the French Realist artist Gustave Courbet, painted in winter 1848–1849 in Ornans. It is now in the Palais des Beaux-Arts de Lille. Its dimensions are 195 by 257 cm.

<i>The Winnower</i> (Millet) 19th-century painting by Jean-François Millet

The Winnower is the title of three oil on canvas paintings by French artist Jean-François Millet, created between 1847 and 1848. The first, now held at the National Gallery, in London, was painted in 1847-1848, and presented at the Salon of 1848. Subsequently, Millet created two other versions, one kept at the Louvre Museum, in Paris, much smaller than the original, and the other at the Musée d'Orsay, also in Paris.

<i>The Sower</i> (Millet) 19th-century painting by Jean-François Millet

The Sower is an oil painting by the French artist Jean-François Millet from 1850. It is one of several versions of the theme that he painted. The work has been in the collection of the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston since 1917.

<i>Passing Mothers Grave</i> 1856 painting by Jozef Israëls

Passing Mother's Grave, also known as Passing the Churchyard, is an oil painting on canvas made in 1856 by Jozef Israëls, a Dutch realist artist and a representative of the Hague School of painters. The subject of the painting is a widowed fisherman walking past his deceased wife's grave with his two children.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Boime, Albert (2008). Art in an Age of Civil Struggle, 1848–1871. Chicago, Illinois: University of Chicago Press. pp. 153–158. ISBN   978-0-226-06342-3. Archived from the original on 23 June 2023. Retrieved 9 June 2023.
  2. Berkovitch, Ellen (14 July 2000). "Invitational Shoe Resists Classification". The Santa Fe New Mexican. Archived from the original on 28 June 2023. Retrieved 28 June 2023.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 Cole, Bruce; Gealt, Adelheid M. (1989). Art of the Western World From Ancient Greece to Post Modernism. New York: Simon & Schuster. pp. 238–239. ISBN   978-0-671-74728-2 . Retrieved 28 June 2023.
  4. 1 2 Warehime, Marja (1998). Brassai Images of Culture and the Surrealist Observer. Baton Rouge, LA: Louisiana State University Press. p. 71. ISBN   978-0-8071-2276-1. Archived from the original on 28 June 2023. Retrieved 28 June 2023.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 Gunderson, Jessica (2008). Realism. Mankato, Minnesota: Creative Education. pp. 27–28. ISBN   978-1-58341-612-9. Archived from the original on 28 June 2023. Retrieved 9 June 2023.
  6. "Gustave Courbet, The Stonebreakers c. 1849". Roemerholz. Oskar Reinhart Collection 'Am Römerholz'. Archived from the original on 10 June 2023. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
  7. "A young stone breaker". Ashmolean Museum. University of Oxford. Archived from the original on 10 June 2023. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
  8. "The Stone Breaker, after 1849". National Gallery of Art. Washington, D.C. Archived from the original on 11 June 2023. Retrieved 11 June 2023.
  9. "Stone Breakers". 19th Century Art. Taylor & Francis Group. Archived from the original on 27 June 2023. Retrieved 28 June 2023.
  10. Strieter, Terry W. (1999). Nineteenth-century European Art: A Topical Dictionary. Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press. p. 49. ISBN   978-0-313-29898-1. Archived from the original on 28 June 2023. Retrieved 9 June 2023.
  11. The Splendor of Dresden: Five Centuries of Art Collecting. New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art. 1978. p. 262. ISBN   978-0-87099-177-6. Archived from the original on 28 June 2023. Retrieved 9 June 2023.
  12. 1 2 Collins, Michael (2022). Lost Masterpieces. London: DK Publishing. p. 160. ISBN   978-0-7440-7793-3.
  13. "Art in the Journals". The Standard Union. 20 May 1893. Archived from the original on 28 June 2023. Retrieved 28 June 2023.
  14. Hagen, Rose-Marie; Hagen, Rainer (2003). What Great Paintings Say. Cologne, Germany: Taschen. p. 407. ISBN   978-3-8228-2100-8. Archived from the original on 28 June 2023. Retrieved 9 June 2023.
  15. 1 2 Facos, Michelle (2011). An Introduction to Nineteenth-Century Art. Melton, United Kingdom: Taylor & Francis. p. 258. ISBN   978-1-136-84071-5. Archived from the original on 28 June 2023. Retrieved 23 June 2023.
  16. Rosenheim, Jeff L.; Conrath-Scholl, Gabriele; Heckert, Virginia A.; Sante, Lucy (2022). Bernd and Hilla Becher. New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art. p. 76. ISBN   978-1-58839-755-3. Archived from the original on 28 June 2023. Retrieved 28 June 2023.
  17. "Week in Art Circles". The Cincinnati Enquirer. 19 September 1915. Archived from the original on 28 June 2023. Retrieved 28 June 2023.
  18. Muller, Sheila D. (1997). Dutch Art: An Encyclopedia. New York: Garland Publishing. p. 195. ISBN   978-1-135-49574-9. Archived from the original on 3 March 2023. Retrieved 10 January 2023.