| No. | Date | Venue | Opponents | Score | Competition | U.S. Virgin Islands scorers | Att. | Ref. |
|---|
| 1 | March 22, 1998 | (H) | British Virgin Islands | 1–0 | Friendly | Unknown | — | [1] |
| 2 | February 26, 1999 | Thomas Robinson Stadium, Nassau (N) | Turks and Caicos Islands | 2–2 | 1999 Caribbean Cup qualification | Unknown | — | [1] [3] |
| 3 | February 28, 1999 | Thomas Robinson Stadium, Nassau (N) | Bahamas | 0–0 | 1999 Caribbean Cup qualification | | — | [1] [3] |
| 4 | January 28, 2000 | (H) | Saint Lucia | 0–9 | Friendly | | — | [1] |
| 5 | January 30, 2000 | (H) | Saint Lucia | 0–2 | Friendly | | — | [1] |
| 6 | March 5, 2000 | Arnos Vale Stadium, Kingstown (A) | Saint Vincent and the Grenadines | 0–9 | 2002 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 4,000 | [1] [4] |
| 7 | March 19, 2000 | Paul E. Joseph Stadium, Frederiksted (H) | Saint Vincent and the Grenadines | 1–5 | 2002 FIFA World Cup qualification | Santos | 425 | [1] [4] |
| 8 | March 24, 2001 | (A) | British Virgin Islands | 0–2 | Friendly | | — | [1] |
| 9 | April 10, 2001 | Stade Sylvio Cator, Port-au-Prince (N) | Haiti | 1–12 | 2001 Caribbean Cup qualification | Unknown | — | [1] [5] |
| 10 | April 12, 2001 | Stade Sylvio Cator, Port-au-Prince (N) | Guadeloupe | 0–11 | 2001 Caribbean Cup qualification | | — | [1] [5] |
| 11 | April 14, 2001 | Stade Sylvio Cator, Port-au-Prince (N) | Saint Lucia | 1–14 | 2001 Caribbean Cup qualification | Unknown | — | [1] [5] |
| 12 | August 16, 2002 | Instituto Preparatorio de Menores, Santo Domingo (H) [A] | Dominican Republic | 1–6 | 2003 CONCACAF Gold Cup qualification | Sheppard | — | [1] [6] |
| 13 | August 18, 2002 | Instituto Preparatorio de Menores, Santo Domingo (A) | Dominican Republic | 1–5 | 2003 CONCACAF Gold Cup qualification | Sheppard | — | [1] [6] |
| 14 | January 30, 2004 | A. O. Shirley Recreation Ground, Road Town (A) | British Virgin Islands | 0–5 | Triangular Tournament | | — | [1] [7] |
| 15 | January 31, 2004 | A. O. Shirley Recreation Ground, Road Town (N) | Dominica | 0–5 | Triangular Tournament | | — | [1] [7] |
| 16 | February 18, 2004 | Lionel Roberts Park, Charlotte Amalie (H) | Saint Kitts and Nevis | 0–4 | 2006 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 225 | [1] [8] |
| 17 | March 31, 2004 | Warner Park, Basseterre (A) | Saint Kitts and Nevis | 0–7 | 2006 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 800 | [1] [8] |
| 18 | September 25, 2004 | A. O. Shirley Recreation Ground, Road Town (A) | British Virgin Islands | 1–2 | Friendly | Challenger | — | [1] |
| 19 | November 24, 2004 | Independence Park, Kingston (N) | Haiti | 0–11 | 2005 Caribbean Cup qualification | | 250 | [1] [9] |
| 20 | November 26, 2004 | Independence Park, Kingston (N) | Jamaica | 1–11 | 2005 Caribbean Cup qualification | Lauro | 4,200 | [1] [9] |
| 21 | November 28, 2004 | Independence Park, Kingston (N) | Saint Martin | 0–0 | 2005 Caribbean Cup qualification | | 200 | [1] [9] |
| 22 | September 27, 2006 | Lionel Roberts Park, Charlotte Amalie (N) | Bermuda | 0–6 | 2007 Caribbean Cup qualification | | 150 | [1] [10] |
| 23 | October 1, 2006 | Lionel Roberts Park, Charlotte Amalie (N) | Dominican Republic | 1–6 | 2007 Caribbean Cup qualification | Pierre | 250 | [1] [10] |
| 24 | March 14, 2008 | A. O. Shirley Recreation Ground, Road Town (A) | British Virgin Islands | 0–0 | Friendly | | — | [1] |
| 25 | March 15, 2008 | A. O. Shirley Recreation Ground, Road Town (A) | British Virgin Islands | 1–1 | Friendly | Augustus | — | [1] |
| 26 | March 26, 2008 | Grenada National Stadium, St. George's (A) | Grenada | 0–10 | 2010 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 3,000 | [1] [11] |
| 27 | June 19, 2011 | Ronald Webster Park, The Valley (A) | Anguilla | 0–0 | Friendly | | 550 | [1] |
| 28 | July 3, 2011 | Lionel Roberts Park, Charlotte Amalie (H) | British Virgin Islands | 2–0 | 2014 FIFA World Cup qualification | Lesmond, Klopp | 350 | [1] [12] |
| 29 | July 10, 2011 | A. O. Shirley Recreation Ground, Road Town (A) | British Virgin Islands | 2–1 | 2014 FIFA World Cup qualification | Thomas, Klopp | 600 | [1] [12] |
| 30 | September 2, 2011 | Stade Sylvio Cator, Port-au-Prince (A) | Haiti | 0–6 | 2014 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 12,000 | [1] [12] |
| 31 | September 6, 2011 | Paul E. Joseph Stadium, Frederiksted (H) | Antigua and Barbuda | 1–8 | 2014 FIFA World Cup qualification | Browne | 250 | [1] [12] |
| 32 | October 7, 2011 | Paul E. Joseph Stadium, Frederiksted (H) | Haiti | 0–7 | 2014 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 406 | [1] [12] |
| 33 | October 11, 2011 | Sir Vivian Richards Stadium, Saint George (A) | Antigua and Barbuda | 0–10 | 2014 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 1,500 | [1] [12] |
| 34 | November 11, 2011 | Paul E. Joseph Stadium, Frederiksted (H) | Curaçao | 0–3 | 2014 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 210 | [1] [12] |
| 35 | November 15, 2011 | Ergilio Hato Stadium, Willemstad (A) | Curaçao | 1–6 | 2014 FIFA World Cup qualification | Cornelius | 2,000 | [1] [12] |
| 36 | May 30, 2014 | Blakes Estate Stadium, Saint John's (N) | Montserrat | 0–1 | 2014 Caribbean Cup qualification | | — | [1] [13] |
| 37 | June 1, 2014 | Blakes Estate Stadium, Saint John's (N) | Bonaire | 1–2 | 2014 Caribbean Cup qualification | Taylor | — | [1] [13] |
| 38 | March 8, 2015 | Antigua Recreation Ground, St. John's (A) | Antigua and Barbuda | 0–2 | Friendly | | — | [1] [14] |
| 39 | March 22, 2015 | Barbados National Stadium, Saint Michael (A) | Barbados | 1–0 | 2018 FIFA World Cup qualification | Browne | 2,300 | [1] [15] |
| 40 | March 26, 2015 | Addelita Cancryn Junior High School Ground, Charlotte Amalie (H) | Barbados | 0–4 | 2018 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 410 | [1] [15] |
| 41 | March 26, 2016 | Raoul Illidge Sports Complex, Philipsburg (A) | Sint Maarten | 2–1 | 2017 Caribbean Cup qualification | Herring, Wrensford | — | [1] [16] |
| 42 | March 29, 2016 | Addelita Cancryn Junior High School Ground, Charlotte Amalie (H) | Grenada | 1–2 | 2017 Caribbean Cup qualification | Wrensford | — | [1] [16] |
| 43 | June 4, 2016 | Addelita Cancryn Junior High School Ground, Charlotte Amalie (H) | Guyana | 0–7 | 2017 Caribbean Cup qualification | | — | [1] [16] |
| 44 | June 7, 2016 | Ergilio Hato Stadium, Willemstad (A) | Curaçao | 0–7 | 2017 Caribbean Cup qualification | | — | [1] [16] |
| 45 | September 9, 2018 | IMG Academy, Bradenton (H) [B] | Canada | 0–8 | 2019–20 CONCACAF Nations League qualifying | | 150 | [1] [17] |
| 46 | October 12, 2018 | IMG Academy, Bradenton (H) [B] | Curaçao | 0–5 | 2019–20 CONCACAF Nations League qualifying | | — | [1] [17] |
| 47 | November 18, 2018 | Wildey Turf, Wildey (A) | Barbados | 0–3 | 2019–20 CONCACAF Nations League qualifying | | — | [1] [17] |
| 48 | March 22, 2019 | Raymond E. Guishard Technical Centre, The Valley (A) | Anguilla | 3–0 | 2019–20 CONCACAF Nations League qualifying | Mack, Pierre, Dennis | — | [1] [17] |
| 49 | September 5, 2019 | Bethlehem Soccer Stadium, Upper Bethlehem (H) | Cayman Islands | 0–2 | 2019–20 CONCACAF Nations League | | — | [1] [17] |
| 50 | September 8, 2019 | Raymond E. Guishard Technical Centre, The Valley (A) [C] | Saint Martin | 2–1 | 2019–20 CONCACAF Nations League | Dennis, Joseph | — | [1] [17] |
| 51 | October 12, 2019 | Wildey Turf, Wildey (A) | Barbados | 0–1 | 2019–20 CONCACAF Nations League | | — | [1] [17] |
| 52 | October 15, 2019 | Bethlehem Soccer Stadium, Upper Bethlehem (H) | Barbados | 0–4 | 2019–20 CONCACAF Nations League | | — | [1] [17] |
| 53 | November 16, 2019 | Truman Bodden Sports Complex, George Town (A) | Cayman Islands | 0–1 | 2019–20 CONCACAF Nations League | | — | [1] [17] |
| 54 | November 19, 2019 | Bethlehem Soccer Stadium, Upper Bethlehem (H) | Saint Martin | 1–2 | 2019–20 CONCACAF Nations League | McGuiness | — | [1] [17] |
| 55 | March 21, 2021 | DRV PNK Stadium, Fort Lauderdale (N) | Anguilla | 0–0 | Friendly | | — | [1] [18] |
| 56 | March 27, 2021 | Bethlehem Soccer Stadium, Upper Bethlehem (H) | Antigua and Barbuda | 0–3 | 2022 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 0 [D] | [1] [19] |
| 57 | March 30, 2021 | Kirani James Athletic Stadium, St. George's (A) | Grenada | 0–1 | 2022 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 0 [D] | [1] [20] |
| 58 | June 2, 2021 | Estadio Panamericano, San Cristóbal (A) [E] | Montserrat | 0–4 | 2022 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 0 [D] | [1] [21] |
| 59 | June 5, 2021 | Bethlehem Soccer Stadium, Upper Bethlehem (H) | El Salvador | 0–7 | 2022 FIFA World Cup qualification | | 150 | [1] [22] |
| 60 | June 3, 2022 | Stadion Rignaal Jean Francisca, Willemstad (N) | Sint Maarten | 1–1 | 2022–23 CONCACAF Nations League | Mack | | [1] [23] |
| 61 | June 6, 2022 | Bethlehem Soccer Stadium, Upper Bethlehem (H) | Turks and Caicos Islands | 3–2 | 2022–23 CONCACAF Nations League | Browne, Mills, Mack | | [1] [24] |
| 62 | June 11, 2022 | Bethlehem Soccer Stadium, Upper Bethlehem (H) | Bonaire | 0–2 | 2022–23 CONCACAF Nations League | | | [1] [25] |
| 63 | June 14, 2022 | Stadion Rignaal Jean Francisca, Willemstad (N) | Bonaire | 0–2 | 2022–23 CONCACAF Nations League | | | [1] [26] |
| 64 | March 25, 2023 | TCIFA National Academy, Providenciales (A) | Turks and Caicos Islands | 0–1 | 2022–23 CONCACAF Nations League | | | |
| 65 | March 28, 2023 | Bethlehem Soccer Stadium, Upper Bethlehem (H) | Sint Maarten | 1–2 | 2022–23 CONCACAF Nations League | Kendall | | |
| 66 | September 7, 2023 | Bethlehem Soccer Stadium, Upper Bethlehem (H) | Cayman Islands | 2–2 | 2023–24 CONCACAF Nations League | St. Louis | | |
| 67 | October 14, 2023 | Guillermo Prospero Trinidad Stadium, Oranjestad (A) | Aruba | 1–3 | 2023–24 CONCACAF Nations League | Henry | | |
| 68 | October 17, 2023 | Truman Bodden Sports Complex, George Town (A) | Cayman Islands | 1–2 | 2023–24 CONCACAF Nations League | Rak. Joseph | | |
| 69 | November 16, 2023 | Bethlehem Soccer Stadium, Upper Bethlehem (H) | Aruba | 1–4 | 2023–24 CONCACAF Nations League | Farrell | | |