Whispering City

Last updated
Whispering City
Whispering City poster.jpg
Theatrical release poster
Directed by Fedor Ozep
Screenplay byRian James
Leonard Lee
Story byMichael Lennox and George Zuckerman
Produced byGeorge Marton
Paul L'Anglais (exec.)
Starring Paul Lukas
Mary Anderson
Helmut Dantine
CinematographyGuy Roe
William O. Steiner
Edited by Leonard Anderson
W.L. Bagier
Richard J. Jarvis
Music by Morris Davis
Production
company
Quebec Productions
Distributed by Eagle-Lion Films
Release date
  • November 20, 1947 (1947-11-20)(United States)
Running time
98 minutes
CountryCanada
LanguageEnglish
Budget750,000 (estimated) CAD [1]
$680,000

Whispering City (also known as Crime City) is a 1947 Canadian black-and-white film noir directed by Fedor Ozep and starring Paul Lukas, Mary Anderson, and Helmut Dantine. [2] It was filmed on location in Quebec City and Montmorency Falls, Quebec, Canada in both English and French.

Contents

A French language version entitled La Forteresse, with different actors but with the same director, was made simultaneously. [2]

Plot

Taking place in Quebec City, the film tells the story of a lawyer and a patron of the arts, Albert Frédéric, who, earlier in life, caused a murder and made it look like an accident for financial gain.

Later in life, a dying woman tells a reporter the tale of how she thinks the accident was actually murder. The young American reporter, Mary Roberts, begins investigating the case, unaware that the charming lawyer may be behind it all. Meanwhile, Michel Lacoste, a classical composer, who is supported by Frédéric, is having marriage troubles. Finally his wife kills herself and leaves the husband a note. Frédéric sneaks into the apartment, takes the note and convinces the man that he killed her in a drunken rage.

Michel, whose night was indeed blacked out by drink, can't remember anything. The lawyer then offers the composer a deal: kill reporter Mary Roberts in exchange for legal representation that will guarantee to get the younger man off the hook. The man, seeing no other choice, agrees reluctantly. The man and woman meet but he does not have the heart to kill her. The two begin to fall in love, gradually figure out that the lawyer is the real killer and set about a scheme to drive the lawyer into confessing to the crime.

Cast

Whispering City

La Forteresse

Production

Faced with the dilemma that the French market in Quebec was too small to support a self-sustaining film industry all by itself, while the language barrier between Quebec and the anglophone market in the rest of North America made it virtually impossible for a Quebec-produced film to pursue wider distribution, producer Paul L'Anglais tried to resolve the difficulty by producing Whispering City and La Forteresse as English and French versions of the same film. [3] He opted to make the experiment a Hollywood-style thriller, set in the urban Quebec City market instead of the rural communities more typical of Quebec cinema in its era. [3]

The film's $750,000 budget made it the most expensive film ever made in Canada as of that time, a title it retained until the early 1970s. [3]

Release

The film was seen by over 100,000 people in Quebec over six weeks and was shown in Paris for three weeks. [4]

Reception

Film critic Dennis Schwartz gave the film a mixed review, writing, "Watchable minor film noir, that is competently directed by Fyodor Otsep from a story by George Zuckerman and Michael Lennox. The acting by Paul Lukas and Helmut Dantine is far beyond what you would expect in such an inexpensive film. But the narrative has too many coincidental plot points to be believable, though the crisply told story is for the most part entertaining. The film is told in flashback by a tourist guide sleigh driver to two riders in Quebec City." [5]

La Forteresse was more positively received in the Quebec market than Whispering City was among English audiences. [3] Some critics who have viewed both films for comparison have asserted that La Forteresse is actually a better film, for various reasons including faster-paced editing and a greater expressiveness among the actors in the French cast; [3] however, writer André Loiselle concluded that "what ultimately explains the success of La Forteresse and the failure of Whispering City are cultural rather than stylistic or aesthetic reasons. The former, as a French-Canadian thriller enjoyed the best of both worlds, as it capitalised on both the insular character of Quebec's culture and its status as merely another subdivision of Hollywood's domestic market. Whispering City on the other hand, suffered from the worst of both worlds as it proved to be neither a particularly good Hollywood film nor a distinctly Canadian work." [3] Roly Young of The Globe and Mail reviewed both films together, rating Whispering City four stars but La Forteresse four-and-a-half, identifying the strength of Nicole Germain's performance as Marie in La Forteresse as the biggest distinction between the two. [6]

At the 2nd Canadian Film Awards in 1950, Quebec Productions, the studio of producer L'Anglais and his business partner René Germain, received a special citation "for sustained and creative effort in establishing a feature-length film industry in Canada", collectively based on the films Whispering City/La Forteresse, A Man and His Sin , Séraphin and The Village Priest (Le Curé du village). [7]

Whispering City was later screened at the 1984 Festival of Festivals as part of Front & Centre, a special retrospective program of artistically and culturally significant films from throughout the history of Canadian cinema. [8]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cinema of Canada</span>

Cinema in Canada dates back to the earliest known display of film in Saint-Laurent, Quebec, in 1896. The film industry in Canada has been dominated by the United States, which has utilized Canada as a shooting location and to bypass British film quota laws, throughout its history. Canadian filmmakers, English and French, have been active in the development of cinema in the United States.

<i>The Barbarian Invasions</i> 2003 film by Denys Arcand

The Barbarian Invasions is a 2003 Canadian-French sex comedy-drama film written and directed by Denys Arcand and starring Rémy Girard, Stéphane Rousseau and Marie-Josée Croze. The film is a sequel to Arcand's 1986 film The Decline of the American Empire, continuing the story of the character Rémy, a womanizing history professor now terminally ill with cancer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Denys Arcand</span> Canadian film director

Georges-Henri Denys Arcand is a Canadian filmmaker. During his four decades career, he became one of the most internationally-recognized director from Quebec, earning widespread acclaim and numerous accolades for his "intensely personal, challenging, and intellectual films."

Claude Jutra was a Canadian actor, film director, and screenwriter.

<i>Good Riddance</i> (film) 1980 Canadian film

Good Riddance is a 1980 French-language Canadian drama film. Directed by Francis Mankiewicz and written by Réjean Ducharme, the film concerns Manon, an unstable young girl who lives with her mother Michelle and her alcoholic and intellectually disabled uncle Ti-Guy.

<i>Seducing Doctor Lewis</i> 2003 Canadian film

Seducing Doctor Lewis is a 2003 Quebec comedy film and the first film directed by Jean-François Pouliot. The script was written by Ken Scott. It won the Audience Award at 2004 Sundance Film Festival. Starring in the movie are Raymond Bouchard, Benoît Brière, David Boutin and Lucie Laurier.

<i>The Decline of the American Empire</i> 1986 film by Denys Arcand

The Decline of the American Empire is a 1986 Canadian sex comedy-drama film directed by Denys Arcand and starring Rémy Girard, Pierre Curzi and Dorothée Berryman. The film follows a group of intellectual friends from the Université de Montréal history department as they engage in a long dialogue about their sexual affairs, touching on issues of adultery, homosexuality, group sex, BDSM and prostitution. A number of characters associate self-indulgence with societal decline.

<i>Léolo</i> 1992 film by Jean-Claude Lauzon

Léolo is a 1992 French Canadian coming-of-age fantasy comedy-drama film by director Jean-Claude Lauzon. The film tells the story of a young boy named Léo "Léolo" Lauzon, played by Maxime Collin, who engages in an active fantasy life while growing up with his Montreal family, and begins to have sexual fantasies about his neighbour Bianca, played by Giuditta del Vecchio. The film also stars Ginette Reno, Pierre Bourgault, Andrée Lachapelle, Denys Arcand, Julien Guiomar, and Germain Houde. Gilbert Sicotte narrates the film as the adult Léolo.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Helmut Dantine</span> Austrian actor

Helmut Dantine was an Austrian-American actor who often played Nazis in thriller films of the 1940s. His best-known performances are perhaps the German pilot in Mrs. Miniver and the desperate Bulgarian refugee in Casablanca, who tries gambling to obtain travel visa money for himself and his wife. As his acting career waned, he turned to producing.

Michel Arcand is a Canadian film editor from Val-d'Or, Quebec. He is a three-time Genie Award winner for Best Editing.

<i>Pour la suite du monde</i> 1963 film

Pour la suite du monde is a 1963 Canadian documentary film produced by the National Film Board of Canada and directed by Michel Brault, Marcel Carrière and Pierre Perrault. It is the first of Perrault's Isle-aux-Coudres Trilogy: Le règne du jour followed in 1967, Les voitures d'eau in 1968.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nicole Germain</span> Canadian actress and journalist

Nicole Germain, C.M. was a Canadian actress in Quebec radio and film in the 1940s and 1950s and later as a journalist. In 1974, she was named a member of the Order of Canada.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1977 Toronto International Film Festival</span>

The 2nd Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) took place in Toronto, Ontario, Canada between September 9 and September 18, 1977. Retrospective of Quebec cinema was introduced and also Greek cinema was emphasized. J.A. Martin Photographer directed by Jean Beaudin was selected as the opening film.

Q-Bec My Love is a Canadian film, directed by Jean Pierre Lefebvre and released in 1970. A satirical allegory for Quebec nationalism, the film is depicted in disconnected vignettes which portray the professional, sexual and romantic relationships of Q-Bec with her boss Peter Ottawa, her husband Jean-Baptiste Bilingue and her lover Sam Washington.

The 2nd Canadian Film Awards were presented on April 19, 1950 to honour achievements in Canadian film. The ceremony was hosted by Prime Minister Louis St. Laurent.

Saint Martyrs of the Damned is a Canadian drama film, directed by Robin Aubert and released in 2005. The film stars François Chénier as Flavien Juste, a tabloid reporter who writes about strange paranormal phenomena; when he is sent to the small Quebec town of Saints-Martyrs-des-Damnés to investigate a series of strange disappearances, his photographer colleague Armand disappears as well, but he finds the townspeople actively impeding his efforts to locate his friend.

Two Women in Gold is a Canadian sex comedy film, directed by Claude Fournier and released in 1970.

The Village Priest is a Canadian drama film, directed by Paul Gury and released in 1949. The film stars Ovila Légaré as a smalltown Roman Catholic priest whose skills as a spiritual and moral leader of the community are tested when Leblanc, a criminal fugitive originally from the town, returns home to see his estranged daughter Juliette on the eve of her wedding to Lionel Théberge.

A Man and His Sin is a Canadian drama film, directed by Paul Gury and released in 1949. Adapted from Claude-Henri Grignon's 1933 novel Un homme et son péché, the film stars Hector Charland as Séraphin Poudrier, the wealthy but miserly mayor of the village of Sainte-Adèle, Quebec, Nicole Germain as Donalda Laloge, a village resident who was given in marriage to Séraphin as payment for a family debt even though she is actually in love with her boyfriend Alexis Labranche, and Ovila Légaré as the village priest Antoine Labelle.

Séraphin is a Canadian drama film, directed by Paul Gury and released in 1950. A sequel to the 1949 film A Man and His Sin , which was an adaptation of the novel by Claude-Henri Grignon, the film tells the story of Séraphin Poudrier's family and community getting their revenge on him for his miserliness and lack of compassion amid the context of Antoine Labelle's drive to increase the settlement and development of the region.

References

  1. Variety (22 August 2018). "Variety (September 1947)". New York, NY: Variety Publishing Company. Retrieved 22 August 2018 via Internet Archive.
  2. 1 2 Gerald Pratley, A Century of Canadian Cinema. Lynx Images, 2003. ISBN   1-894073-21-5. p. 239.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 André Loiselle, "La Forteresse/Whispering City" in Jerry White, ed. The Cinema of Canada. Wallflower Press, 2006. ISBN   9781904764601. pp. 33-40.
  4. Melnyk 2004, p. 81.
  5. Schwartz, Dennis. Ozus' World Movie Reviews. film review, May 1, 2005. Accessed: July 8, 2013.
  6. Roly Young, "Rambling With Roly: Whispering City/La Forteresse". The Globe and Mail , May 12, 1947.
  7. Herbert Whittaker, "Show Business". The Globe and Mail , April 15, 1950.
  8. Carole Corbeil, "The stars are coming out for Toronto's film festival". The Globe and Mail , September 6, 1984.

Works cited