Yamatai Kyushu Theory

Last updated
Topographic map of Kyushu area Japan Kyushu Map Chikei.gif
Topographic map of Kyushu area

The Yamatai Kyushu Theory is the theory that the Yamatai kingdom was located in Kyushu rather than in Honshu as the Yamatai Honshu Theory proposes. [1]

Contents

The theory proposes that the original capital of Japan was located in Kyushu, and when the Kofun period began, the Yamato Kingship moved the capital east to the Kinai region, before eventually moving it to Kyoto, and finally Tokyo, the current capital. [1]

Overview

The Yamato District, Fukuoka is located in the Yamato Province of Chikugo Province, in his "Foreign Affairs Record", Chikugo Province, Yamato District, Fukuoka. Since then, the mainstream of academic circles has been divided into two mainstream theories: the " Honshu theory (by Naitō Torajirō and others) and the " Kyushu theory (by Shiratori Kurakichi and others). The Kyūshū theory, however, has a different explanation. The Kyushu theory, however, is divided into two camps: one that claims that the Yamataikoku was "moved" (the "To-kyo" theory) and the other that it was not.

There are two theories about the subsequent Yamatai Kingdom; one is that it was conquered by the Kinai forces, and the other is that it moved eastward and conquered the Kinai. [a] In the past, it was the first time that the Japanese government had been involved in the war. [b] [c]

Basic rationale

The basic arguments for the Kyushu theory of the Yamatai Kingdom include the following.

Basis

Advocates

Advocates of the Kyushu theory of the Yamataikoku include Arai Hakuseki, Shiratori Kurakichi, Dairoku Harada, Taku Tanaka, [6] Takehiko Furuta, Kenzaburo Torigoe, [7] Toshiaki Wakai, [8] Biten Yasumoto, Toshio Hoga and others. In addition, it is said that research based on domestic materials such as "Kiki" tends not to be taken into consideration, despite the indications of Taro Sakamoto's "The Birth of the Nation" and Hidesaburo Hara, and Toshiaki Wakai said about this tendency before the war. He criticizes the repressed theory of Sokichi Tsuda as being caused by being touted even after the war. [8]

See also

Notes

  1. The former assumes the conquest of Kitakyushu during the Keiko, Seigyo, and Chuai dynasties, as seen in the Chronicles. The latter theory is based on the fact that the Jimmu's Eastern Expedition is a reflection of the Jimmu's Eastern Expedition, but some argue that the Book of Sui is unacceptable as it may differ considerably from the existing mythology. However, it is possible that the writings in the Book of Sui
  2. In the latter half of the Edo period, scholars of Japanese studies proposed the theory of "false arrogance" (the theory that Kyushu forces presumed to have presided over the Imperial Court. These include Hon'i Nobunaga's "Onokebisu Gaikoku", Tsurumine Boshin's "Sogoku Gaikoku Ko", and Kondo Yoshiki's "Seihan Gensetsu".)
  3. In modern times, there is the Kyushu dynasty theory  [ ja ] by Takehiko Furuta and others (the theory that the representative dynasty of the Japanese archipelago was consistently located in Kyushu and declined after the Battle of Baekgang. (This theory has received some attention in academic circles, including the publication of an article in Shigaku zasshi. This is a theory that has received much attention in academic circles.
  4. Miyake Yonekichi states that the 12,000 ri is the distance to Fuyakuni, where the distance is known, and Yamada Yoshio states that this is not the actual distance, which is partly unknown, but merely the sum of the 7,000 ri to Gwoja Korea and the 5,000 ri of the circumference of the Japanese land. This is not a combination of the real distances, which are partly unknown, but merely the sum of the 7,000 ri to Gouja Korea and the 5,000 ri of the Japanese land. The Takehiko Furuta, who advocates the Kyushu dynasty theory, advocates a reading that "the same route is marked twice, as distance and number of days, for the sake of accuracy".
  5. The Kinai theory does not seem to give any special interpretation to the official name, even if it considers Gounakukoku to be a force from Keno or the Tokai region, such as Kuwana or Kano. Naito Konan, who holds the Kinai theory, ascribes Gu-nu-kuni to Kumaso and "Gu-ko-chi-beigu" to Kikuchi-hiko, in view of the violent clashes between the imperial court and Kumaso in the reign of Emperor Keiko, which he considers to be close to the time of the Yamataikoku. This would mean that the direction is correct here, but he says there is no problem with the description of Gounakukoku because it belongs to a different system from the itinerary article. In Weilüe it is written "拘右智卑狗", but this can be regarded as a typographical error, since in ancient Japanese the vowel never appeared in the middle of a word. The Kibi, Izumo, and Higashi-Shikoku theories consider the Gugnu Kingdom to be a Kawachi power.
  6. There is an opinion that the Hokenoyama burial mound, which was built at the same time as the Chopsticks Tomb or even earlier, has a coffin and burial chamber and was built in the first half of the 4th century.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kofun period</span> Period of Japanese history from 300 to 538

The Kofun period is an era in the history of Japan from about 300 to 538 AD, following the Yayoi period. The Kofun and the subsequent Asuka periods are sometimes collectively called the Yamato period. This period is the earliest era of recorded history in Japan, but studies depend heavily on archaeology since the chronology of historical sources tends to be distorted. The word kofun is Japanese for the type of burial mound dating from this era.

Himiko, also known as the Shingi Waō, was a shamaness-queen of Yamatai-koku in Wakoku (倭国). Early Chinese dynastic histories chronicle tributary relations between Queen Himiko and the Cao Wei Kingdom (220–265) and record that the Yayoi period people chose her as ruler following decades of warfare among the kings of Wa. Early Japanese histories do not mention Himiko, but historians associate her with legendary figures such as Empress Consort Jingū, who is said to have served as regent from 201 to 269.

Yamatai or Yamatai-koku(邪馬台国)(c. 1st century –c. 3rd century) is the Sino-Japanese name of an ancient country in Wa (Japan) during the late Yayoi period (c. 1,000 BCE –c. 300 CE). The Chinese text Records of the Three Kingdoms first recorded the name as (邪馬臺) or (邪馬壹) followed by the character 國 for "country", describing the place as the domain of Priest-Queen Himiko (卑弥呼). Generations of Japanese historians, linguists, and archeologists have debated where Yamatai was located and whether it was related to the later Yamato (大和国).

<i>Kofun</i> Megalithic tombs in Northeast Asia

Kofun are megalithic tombs or tumuli in Northeast Asia. Kofun were mainly constructed in the Japanese archipelago between the middle of the 3rd century to the early 7th century AD.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fukiishi</span>

Fukiishi were a means of covering burial chambers and burial mounds during the kofun period of Japan. Stones collected from riverbeds were affixed to the slopes of raised kofun and other burial chambers. They are considered to have descended from forms used in Yayoi-period tumuli. They are common in the early and mid-Kofun periods, but most late Kofun-period tumuli do not have them.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Magoshi-Nagahizuka Kofun</span>

The Magoshi-Nagahizuka Kofun (馬越長火塚古墳) is a large Kofun period burial mound located in the Ishimakihonmachi neighborhood of the city of Toyohashi, Aichi in the Tōkai region of Japan. The site was designated a National Historic Site of Japan in 2016.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jimmu's Eastern Expedition</span> Legendary war

Jimmu's Eastern Expedition refers to a series of legends in which Emperor Jimmu became the first emperor of Japan, after defeating Nagasunehiko, who had ruled the Nara Basin and its surrounding area, after leaving Hyuga Province. According to the traditional dating system adopted in late 19th century, this expedition took place in 663 BC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yamato Kingship</span> Historical Japanese state

The Yamato Kingship was a tribal alliance centered on the Yamato region from the 4th century to the 7th century, and ruled over the alliance of noble families in the central and western parts of the Japanese archipelago. The age is from the 3rd to the 7th century, later than the Yamatai Kingdom. After the Taika Reform, the ōkimi as an emperor, at that time, was in power, and the Yamato period ended. The time period is archaeologically known as the Kofun period. Regarding its establishment, due to the relationship between Yamatai and Yamato's succession to the king's power, there are very different views on it.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hashihaka Kofun</span> Megalithic tomb in Japan

The Hashihaka kofun is a megalithic tomb (kofun) located in Sakurai, Nara Prefecture, Japan. The Hashihaka kofun is considered to be the first large keyhole-shaped kofun constructed in Japan and is associated with the emergence of the Yamato Kingship.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yamatai Honshu Theory</span> Historical theory of the location of the Yamatai Kingdom

The Yamatai Honshu Theory is the theory that the Yamatai kingdom was located in Honshu, specifically Kinai, where the capital was located in the Kofun period rather than in Kyushu as the Yamatai Kyushu Theory proposes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Makimuku ruins</span> Ruins in Japan

The Makimuku ruins are ruins in Nara Prefecture Sakurai near Mount Miwa. Recovered artifacts are of the Yayoi Period and Kofun Period.

<i>Wajinden</i> Section in the Book of Wei in the Records of the Three Kingdoms

The Wajinden are passages in the 30th fascicle of the Chinese history chronicle Records of the Three Kingdoms that talk about the Wa people, who would later be known as the Japanese people. It describes the mores, geography, and other aspects of the Wa, the people and inhabitants of the Japanese archipelago at the time. The Records of the Three Kingdoms was written by Chen Shou of the Western Jin dynasty at the end of the 3rd century.

Takehiko Furuta ) was a Japanese, history of ideas scholar, ancient history fabricator, conspiracy theorist. Former professor at Showa Pharmaceutical University. He specializes in Shinran and other medieval Japanese philosophical history and conspiracy theory. He has proposed the highly controversial Kyushu dynasty theory, to little academic acclaim.

Kununokuni (狗奴国)(Kunu no kuni/kunukoku、Kuna no Kuni/Kunakoku、Konanokuni / Konakoku) was a Japanese country that was in conflict with Yamatai, which is mentioned in the "Wajinden" in the "Book of Wei" in the Chinese history book "Records of the Three Kingdoms" of the Three Kingdoms period.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hokenoyama Kofun</span> Ancient Japanese tomb

Hokenoyama Kofun is a scallop shaped Kofun containing several burial chambers at the site of the Makimuku ruins in Nara Prefecture, Japan. It is dated to around 250 AD.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Zenpokoenfun</span> Style of Ancient Japanese tomb resembling a keyhole

Zenpokoenfun is an architectural model of Japanese ancient tombs (Kofun), which consists of a square front part and a circular back part. The part connecting the two is called the middle part, which looks like a keyhole when viewed from above. Therefore, they are also called keyhole-shaped mounds in English, and in Korean, they are called long drum tombs due to their resemblance to Janggu, and it is also a form of the Kofun that appeared earlier in the Kofun period along with the enpun. Generally, large Kofun are front and rear circular tombs, widely distributed in Honshu, Shikoku, and Kyushu with Gokishichidō as the center. Among them, the largest front and rear circular tomb in Japan are the Mozu Tombs with a total length of 525 meters. In addition to Japan, there are also the front and rear circular tombs in South Korea, as well as the front and rear circular tombs in Chosan County Ancient Tomb Group and Chasong County Ancient Tomb Group located in North Korea. In addition, Korean archaeologist Jiang Renqiu believes that the Songhe Dong No. 1 Tomb located in Goseong County, South Gyeongsang Ancient Tomb Group, is the Zenpokoenfun.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tōjin Kofun Cluster</span> Japanese burial mound

Tōjin Kofun Cluster (唐仁古墳群) is a group of Kofun period burial mounds located in the Shinkawanishi neighborhood of the town of Higashikushira, Kagoshima Prefecture, Japan. The site been protected as a National Historic Site since 1934. It is the largest group of burial mounds in Kagoshima Prefecture, and includes the largest kofun in the prefecture, the Tōjin Ōtsuka Kofun (唐仁大塚古墳)

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kurozuka Kofun</span> Kofun period keyhole-shaped burial mound in Japan

Kurozuka Kofun (黒塚古墳) is a Kofun period keyhole-shaped burial mound, located in the Yanagimoto-cho neighborhood of the city of Tenri, Nara in the Kansai region of Japan. The tumulus was designated a National Historic Site of Japan in 2001. It is noted for the 33 triangular-rimmed bronze mirrors with divine beasts that were excavated in almost the same arrangement as when they were originally buried.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mesuriyama Kofun</span> Kofun period keyhole-shaped burial mound in Japan

Mesuriyama Kofun (メスリ山古墳) is an early Kofun period burial mound, located in the Takada neighborhood of the city of Sakurai, Nara in the Kansai region of Japan. The tumulus was designated a National Historic Site of Japan in 1980.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sakurai Chausuyama Kofun</span> Kofun period keyhole-shaped burial mound in Japan

Sakurai Chausuyama Kofun (桜井茶臼山古墳) is a Kofun period burial mound, located in the Tobiyama neighborhood of the city of Sakurai, Nara in the Kansai region of Japan. The tumulus was designated a National Historic Site of Japan in 1980. It is thought to have been built in the latter half of the 3rd century, the next generation after Hashihaka Kofun.

References

  1. 1 2 "Yamatai | ancient kingdom, Japan | Britannica". www.britannica.com. Retrieved 2022-06-16.
  2. Hokenoyama kofun no kenkyū[Studies of the Hokenoyama Tumulus]. Nara-ken Kashihara-shi: Nara Kenritsu Kashihara Kōkogaku Kenkyūjo. 2008. pp. 289–291. ISBN   978-4-902777-61-1. OCLC   608290238.
  3. "ホケノ山古墳と箸墓古墳". 橿原考古学研究所附属博物館 (in Japanese). Retrieved 2019-10-28.
  4. Hokenoyama kofun no kenkyū[Studies of the Hokenoyama Tumulus]. Nara-ken Kashihara-shi: Nara Kenritsu Kashihara Kōkogaku Kenkyūjo. 2008. pp. 191–192. ISBN   978-4-902777-61-1. OCLC   608290238.
  5. "『ホケノ山古墳の年代について』". 邪馬台国の会 (in Japanese). Retrieved 2019-10-28.
  6. "田中卓『海に書かれた邪馬台国―ついに明かされた女王国の秘密 (1975年)』". 神社と古事記 (in Japanese). 31 December 1975. Retrieved 2022-02-01.
  7. "Great Yamatai Country" and others
  8. 1 2 若井敏明 (2010). 邪馬台国の滅亡 : 大和王権の征服戦争. Yoshikawa Kōbunkan. ISBN   978-4-642-05694-6. OCLC   587064942.