1874 Victorian colonial election

1874 Victorian colonial election

←  1871 25 March to 22 April 1874 1877  →
All 78 seats in the Victorian Legislative Assembly
First party Second party   Leader James Francis James Grant Party Constitutionalist Liberal Leader's seat Richmond Avoca Seats won 31 37 Percentage 27.47 24.8
Premier before election James Francis Constitutionalist Elected Premier James Francis Constitutionalist

The 1874 Victorian colonial election was held from 25 March to 22 April 1874 to elect the 8th Parliament of Victoria. All 78 seats in 49 electorates in the Legislative Assembly were up for election, though eleven seats were uncontested. ^[1]

There were 24 single-member, 21 two-member and 4 three-member electorates. ^[1]

The Premier James Francis fought the 1874 general election on a proposition for constitutional reform to settle disputes between the Legislative Assembly and the Legislative Council by joint sittings. ^[2] After the inconclusive election results became known, the editorial in The Argus commented: "In no one case does it appear that the proposed scheme of constitutional reform exercised any material effect upon the decision of the constituencies". ^[3] Although Francis continued as Premier after the election, the results precluded any prospect of passing the constitutional reform he had advocated. ^{[2] [4]}

Results

With no formal party structure, elected members were mainly classified as 'Ministerial', 'Opposition' or 'Doubtful', with unelected candidates given no classification. ^[1] 'Ministerial' members were considered to be supporters of the government of the previous parliament, 'Opposition' members were those "opposed to the Government either on general grounds or on the special reform proposition". Those members whose views were unknown were classified as 'Doubtful'. ^[5]

Legislative Assembly (FPTP) ^[1]

Party / Grouping			Votes	%	Swing	Seats	Change
	Ministerial		34,672	27.47		31
	Opposition		31,307	24.8		37
	Doubtful		7,012	5.55		8
	Liberal		4,792	3.8		2
	Constitutional		2,526	2.0		0
	Unclassified		45,922	36.38		0
Totals			126,231			78

Aftermath

After early attempts at passing a reform bill failed, Francis resigned in late July 1874 due to a serious bout of pleurisy. ^{[2] [6]} He was succeeded as Premier by the Attorney-General George Kerferd, who accepted that constitutional reform in the existing parliament would not be possible. ^{[7] [8]} Kerferd made only one change to the ministry, with James Service replacing Edward Langton as treasurer. The Local Government Act was passed in December 1874, but very little else was achieved due to continual political obstruction. ^{[7] [9]}

In late July 1875 the government's budget was carried in the parliament by a just single vote. In response Kerferd requested a dissolution, which was refused by the Acting-Governor, Sir William Stawell, prompting the resignation of Kerferd and his ministry. ^{[7] [10] [11]} The liberal politician, Graham Berry, then met with the acting-governor and undertook to form a ministry. ^[12] As Premier, Berry also took on the role of treasurer. He submitted a protectionist budget to the Legislative Assembly in September 1875, a significant part of which was a land tax. ^[13] However Berry lacked a majority in parliament after a moderate liberal faction led by James McCulloch had refused to join his ministry. ^{[13] [14]}

Berry's revenue-raising land tax proposal provoked a political backlash. ^[13] In October McCulloch's faction joined with Kerferd's supporters to carry a resolution for more general direct taxation measures. Berry responded to the defeat in parliament by requesting that the acting-governor grant a dissolution, but Stawell again refused the request. ^[14] Berry resigned and McCulloch, who had been Premier on three previous occasions, returned to office. ^[15] McCulloch then brought in a budget with generalised taxation features, without singling out the landholding class. ^[13] Berry's subsequent attempts to block supply were to no avail, and McCulloch's ministry remained in office until the May 1877 elections. By means of political agitation and mass meetings, Berry consolidated his leadership of a radical opposition by polarising the parliament and branding McCulloch a reactionary. His land tax proposal became the central plank of his liberal protectionist movement to contest the election in 1877. ^[13]

See also

• Members of the Victorian Legislative Assembly, 1874–1877

References

1. "The Eighth Parliament Elected 25 March to 22 April 1874". Psephos: Adam Carr's Electoral Archive.
2. Geoffrey Bartlett (1972), James Goodall Francis (1819–1884), Australian Dictionary of Biography website, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University; accessed 18 December 2023.
3. Editorial, The Argus (Melbourne), 23 April 1874, page 4.
4. Editorial, The Herald (Melbourne), 23 April 1874, page 2.
5. The General Election, The Argus (Melbourne), 23 April 1874, pages 5 and 6.
6. The Late M. J. G. Francis, The Age (Melbourne), 26 January 1884, page 9.
7. Margot Beever (1974), George Briscoe Kerferd (1831–1889), Australian Dictionary of Biography website, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University; accessed 18 December 2023.
8. The Political Situation, Ballarat Courier, 31 July 1874, page 2.
9. Bills Assented To, The Argus (Melbourne), 26 December 1874, page 9.
10. The Victorian Budget, Evening Journal (Adelaide), 31 July 1875, page 2.
11. The Crisis, Ovens and Murray Advertiser (Beechworth), 5 August 1875, page 4.
12. Telegraphic Despatches, Ovens and Murray Advertiser (Beechworth), 5 August 1875, page 2.
13. Geoffrey Bartlett (1969), Sir Graham Berry (1822–1904), Australian Dictionary of Biography website, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University; accessed 10 December 2023.
14. Sir William Stawell as Acting-Governor, Colac Herald, 19 May 1876, page 3; originally published as 'Our Melbourne Correspondent...', The Times (London), 22 March 1876, page 11.
15. Geoffrey Bartlett (1974), Sir James McCulloch (1819–1893), Australian Dictionary of Biography website, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University; accessed 10 December 2023.