Astrit Haraqia

Astrit Haraqia (born 14 June 1972) is a politician in Kosovo. He was the minister of culture, youth, and sports in the Kosovo government from 2004 to 2008, serving as a member of the Democratic League of Kosovo (LDK).

Early life and career

Haraqia was born in Gjakova, in what was then the Socialist Autonomous Province of Kosovo in the Socialist Republic of Serbia, Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia. He holds a Bachelor of Laws degree. In 1996, he became the leader of the LDK's youth forum in Gjakova. ^[1]

Politician

Early years in local government (2002–04)

The LDK won a majority victory in Gjakova in the 2000 Kosovan local elections with twenty-six out of forty-one seats. In March 2002, Haraqia was named as the city's chief executive officer. ^[2] He appeared in the fourth position on the LDK's electoral list for the city in the 2002 Kosovan local elections; local elections in Kosovo are held under open list proportional representation, and he was presumably elected to the local assembly when the list won a plurality victory with seventeen seats. ^{[3] [4]} He ultimately continued to serve as chief executive officer until November 2004. ^[5]

In September 2004, Haraqia placed signs at Gjakova's entry and exit points declaring the city to be an "autonomous province." This was not a serious declaration of independence but rather a protest against the Kosovo Trust Agency for what he considered to be its slow pace of privatization in the city. ^[6]

Haraqia was elected as a member of the LDK's presidency in June 2004. ^[7]

Government minister (2004–08)

The LDK won the 2004 Kosovan parliamentary election and afterward formed a coalition government with the Alliance for the Future of Kosovo (AAK). Under the terms of the coalition agreement, AAK leader Ramush Haradinaj became prime minister. When the new ministry took office in December 2004, Haraqia became minister of culture, youth, and sports.

Kosovo's governing institutions were at this time overseen by the United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK). In July 2005, it was reported that UNMIK leader Søren Jessen-Petersen was dissatisfied with Haraqia's performance in office and was seeking his dismissal. ^[8]

In September 2005, Haraqia travelled to Belgrade for what were described as "very cordial and constructive" talks with Serbian minister of culture Dragan Kojadinović. Their discussions were primarily focused on the reconstruction of Serbian Orthodox churches following the 2004 unrest in Kosovo. Media reports noted that Haraqia was the first government minister in Kosovo to visit Belgrade since the end of the 1998–99 Kosovo War. ^[9]

Haraqia met with representatives of the American Jewish Committee in July 2006 about the protection of Kosovo's Jewish cultural heritage. ^[10]

In 2006, the Kosovo government held a public ceremony in Pristina to commemorate the fifth anniversary of the 11 September 2001 attacks in the United States of America. Haraqia described the event as demonstrating the solidarity of Kosovars with the American people; during the ceremony, he described the United States as the "promoter and protector of the world democracy." He added that Kosovo institutions were planning an obelisk to honour of the victims of the 2001 attack. ^[11]

In May 2007, Haraqia met with Albanian minister of culture Ylli Pango regarding plans to welcome American president George W. Bush to Tirana the following month. Kosovo officials placed high importance on Bush's visit due to ongoing debates around the status of Kosovo. ^[12]

Kosovo's auditor-general released a report in August 2007, charging Haraqia with abuse of funds in the oversight of his ministry. Haraqia rejected the charge. ^[13]

During the buildup to Kosovo's unilateral declaration of independence in 2008, various debates took place about the flag of the new entity. Haraqia was the first LDK official to publicly agree with United Nations envoy Martti Ahtisaari that the preferred flag of recently deceased Kosovo president Ibrahim Rugova would not be suitable for this purpose, as it included the Albanian double-headed eagle and hence could not represent all of Kosovo's ethnic communities. Haraqia said that he "[did] not know any greater admirer of President Rugova" than himself but added that the party would need to show flexibility on this point. ^[14]

The Democratic Party of Kosovo (PDK) defeated the LDK in the 2007 Kosovan parliamentary election, and PDK leader Hashim Thaçi became prime minister in January 2008. Although Thaçi's coalition government included the LDK, Haraqia was not reappointed to cabinet, and his term ended when the new ministry took office. Haraqia was not a candidate in the 2007 parliamentary election; he instead ran for mayor of Gjakova in the concurrent 2007 local elections and was defeated in the second round of voting.

Since January 2008

Haraqia has faced several legal challenges since standing down as a government minister.

In April 2008, Haraqia and his assistant Bajrush Morina were charged by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) with intimidating a witness; it was alleged that Haraqia and Morina tried to dissuade the witness from testifying against Ramush Haradinaj. ^[15] Haraqia was convicted of the offence on 17 December 2008. After completing a five-month sentence, he was released pending his appeal. ^{[16] [17]} On 23 July 2009, the ICTY's Appeals Chamber overturned his conviction. ^[18]

Haraqia led the LDK's list for the Gjakova municipal assembly in the 2009 Kosovan local elections and was elected when the list won five seats. ^{[19] [20]}

In October 2010, Bujar Bukoshi and Ukë Rugova established the Ibrahim Rugova List as a faction within the LDK. Haraqia sided with them, becoming one of the faction's most prominent members. ^[21] The Rugova List soon began functioning as a distinct party, contesting the 2010 Kosovan parliamentary election on the electoral list of the AAK. The PDK won the 2010 election and afterward formed a new coalition ministry that included the Rugova List, even as the LDK moved into opposition. Bukoshi was appointed as one of Kosovo's five deputy prime ministers, and Haraqia was named as a deputy minister of finance. ^[22]

Both Bukoshi and Haraqia resigned from office amid corruption charges in July 2012. Haraqia was accused of misuse of a public position during his time as minister of culture; the specific charges related to his ministry's decision to provide three hundred thousand Euros for two film projects that were never completed. ^[23] He was convicted in November 2016 and given a ten-month suspended sentence. ^[24] Following an appeal, his sentence was increased to one year. ^[25] A further appeal saw the charges dismissed on technical grounds, when the case was not tried by its legal deadline. ^[26]

Behgjet Pacolli, who also served as a deputy prime minister after the 2010 election, alleged that Haraqia requested payment of 3.6 million Euros to solve the ownership of Pristina's Grand Hotel during his tenure as a deputy finance minister. ^[27]

In May 2016, Ukë Rugova, Haraqia, and nineteen others were indicted on charges of organized crime involving trafficking immigrants and the sale of counterfeit visas to Italy. ^[28] Haraqia presented a different interpretation of these events in a subsequent interview, saying that he began issuing visas for the benefit of specific people, mainly from Gjakova, with the support of Ibrahim Rugova in 1995. He added that most of the people in question later returned to Kosovo. He specifically rejected charges of forgery, saying that the visas had been signed by an ambassador. ^[29]

The case against Ukë Rugova, Haraqia, and the others accused was initially overseen by the European Union Rule of Law Mission in Kosovo (EULEX). In January 2018, EULEX announced that it was giving up on the case. Analyst Ehat Miftaraj of the Kosovo Law Institute said that EULEX's changing mandate made it impossible for the organization to oversee cases of such complexity; he added that EULEX's inability to deal with the case was one of its greatest failings. ^[30] The matter was ultimately transferred to the Republic of Kosovo's courts; in November 2023, Ukë Rugova, Haraqia, and the others pleaded not guilty. ^[31]

Haraqia was a personal friend of Ibrahim Rugova. In a January 2017 interview, he recalled Rugova's dying words of advice to him: "Our greatest luck is that we managed to have the USA as friends. Therefore, even when you will not like any of their decisions, you must respect them. Without America, we wouldn't be anywhere even today." ^[32]

Electoral record

Local (Gjakova)

2007 Kosovan local elections: Mayor of Gjakova

Candidate		Party	First round		Second round
			Votes	%	Votes	%
	Pal Lekaj	Alliance for the Future of Kosovo	12,409	37.98	19,185	56.39
	Astrit Haraqia	Democratic League of Kosovo	7,789	23.84	14,836	43.61
	Teuta Sahatqija	ORA	3,723	11.39
	Besnik Bardhi	New Kosovo Alliance	3,481	10.65
	Besim Mehmeti	Democratic League of Dardania	2,465	7.54
	Agim Jaka	Democratic Party of Kosovo	1,012	3.10
	Mentor Rruka	Alternative for Gjakova	809	2.48
	Aqif Shehu (incumbent)	Aqif Shehu	571	1.75
	Marjan Oroshi	Democratic Christian Party for Integration	414	1.27
Total			32,673	100.00	34,021	100.00
Source: [33] [34] [35]

References

1. ASTRIT HARAQIA MINISTËR Archived 2007-03-28 at the Wayback Machine , Government of Kosovo, accessed 9 March 2024.
2. ASTRIT HARAQIA MINISTËR Archived 2007-03-28 at the Wayback Machine , Government of Kosovo, accessed 9 March 2024.
3. ZGJEDHJET PËR KUVENDE KOMUNALE 2002 – Fletëvotimet dhe listat e kandidatëve (Gjakovë), Central Election Commission, Republic of Kosovo, accessed 18 January 2022.
4. Zgjedhjet për Kuvende Komunale 2002 – Rezultatet dhe Statistikat (Rezultatet e subjekteve sipas komunave), Central Election Commission, Republic of Kosovo, accessed 4 February 2022.
5. ASTRIT HARAQIA MINISTËR Archived 2007-03-28 at the Wayback Machine , Government of Kosovo, accessed 9 March 2024.
6. "Kosovo's Djakovica declares autonomy in protest at sluggish privatization," British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 22 September 2004 (Source: KosovaLive web site, Pristina, in English 21 Sep 04).
7. "Rugova re-elected chairman of main Kosovo party," British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 22 June 2004 (Source: Kosovo Information Centre web site, Pristina, in Albanian 19 Jun 04).
8. "UNMIK chief demands dismissal of three Kosovo government officials - paper," British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 27 July 2005 (Source: Koha Ditore, Pristina, in Albanian 25 Jul 05 p 2).
9. "Ambiente cordial en reunión de ministros cultura serbio y kosovar," Agencia EFE - Servicio General, 23 September 2005.
10. "Kosovo culture minister vows to protect Jewish cultural heritage," British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 21 July 2006 (KosovaLive website, Pristina, in English 20 Jul 06).
11. "Kosovo commemorates anniversary of 9/11 terrorist attacks against US," British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 11 September 2006 (Source: KosovaLive website, Pristina, in English 11 Sep 06).
12. "Kosovo minister to discus modalities for welcoming bush with Albanian officials," British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 27 May 2007 (Source: Express, Pristina, in Albanian 25 May 07).
13. "Kosovo culture minister rejects auditor's findings on abuse of funds", British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 21 August 2007.
14. "Kosovo minister: Ahtisaari package rules out using Rugova's flag for new state," British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 24 May 2007 (Source: Express, Pristina, in Albanian 21 May 07 pp 6,7).
15. "Kosovo ex minister to appear before ICTY to face witness intimidation charges," British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 30 April 2008 (Source: KosovaLive website, Pristina, in English 29 Apr 08).
16. "Ex-Kosovo Minister Jailed by The Hague", Balkan Insight, 17 December 2008, accessed 9 March 2024.
17. "Astrit Haraqija Granted Provisional Release Pending Appeal", International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, 8 April 2009, accessed 9 March 2024.
18. "Appeals Chamber Reverses Haraqija’s, Confirms Morina’s Conviction for Contempt", International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, 23 July 2009, accessed 9 March 2024.
19. Zgjedhjet për Kuvende Komunale 2009 – Rezultatet dhe Statistikat (Rezultatet e subjekteve sipas komunave), Central Election Commission, Republic of Kosovo, p. 3.
20. Zgjedhjet për Kuvende Komunale 2009 – Rezultatet dhe Statistikat (Rezultatet e të gjithë kandidatëve sipas komunave), Central Election Commission, Republic of Kosovo, p. 16.
21. "Late Kosovo President Rugova's son establishes faction within LDK," British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 29 October 2010 (Source: RTK TV, Pristina, in Albanian 1730 gmt 28 Oct 10).
22. "'Harrohet' Astrit Haraqija", Telegrafi, 12 March 2012, accessed 9 March 2024.
23. Petrit Çollaku, "Shakeup at Top of Kosovo Politics", Balkan Insight, 13 July 2012.
24. "Ish-ministri i Kulturës, Astrit Haraqija nuk paraqitet në Gjykatë", Telegrafi, 22 November 2016, accessed 9 March 2024.
25. "Haraqija: Gjykata më dënoi pa prova", Telegrafi, 13 December 2016, accessed 9 March 2024.
26. "Parashkruhet aktakuza për Astrit Haraqinë", Telegrafi, 8 April 2017, accessed 9 March 2024.
27. "Kosovo daily lists government's 60 'failures', 'scandals'," British Broadcasting Corporation Monitoring European, 14 January 2014 (Source: Koha Ditore, Pristina, in Albanian 10 Jan 14 pp 1,3).
28. "Aktakuzë kundër Ukë Rugovës, Astrit Haraqisë dhe 19 tjerëve për krim të organizuar", Telegrafi, 17 May 2016, accessed 9 March 2024.
29. "Haraqija nën hetime, synonin postin e kryeministrit!", Telegrafi, May 2016, accessed 9 March 2024.
30. "Pse EULEX-i hoqi dorë nga rasti i Ukë Rugovës?", Telegrafi, 30 January 2018, accessed 9 March 2024.
31. "Court hearing on visas, Ukë Rugova, Astrit Haraqija and others plead not guilty", Kosova Press, 17 November 2023, accessed 9 March 2024.
32. "Astrit Haraqija tregon çka e porositi presidenti Rugova në orët e vdekjes", Telegrafi, January 2017, accessed 9 March 2024.
33. ZGJEDHJET PËR KRYETARË TË KOMUNAVE 2007 – Fletëvotimet (Raundi i parë) – Pejë, Central Election Commission, Republic of Kosovo, accessed 16 September 2023.
34. ZGJEDHJET PËR KRYETARË TË KOMUNAVE 2007 – Rezultatet dhe Statistikat (Raundi i parê) – Rezultatet e kandidatëve për Kryetar Komune, Central Election Commission, Republic of Kosovo, p. 2, accessed 14 January 2022.
35. ZGJEDHJET PËR KRYETARË TË KOMUNAVE 2007 – Rezultatet dhe Statistikat (Raundi i dytë) – Rezultatet e kandidatëve për Kryetar Komune, Central Election Commission, Republic of Kosovo, p. 2, accessed 14 January 2022.