Best Loser System

Last updated

The Best Loser System (BLS) refers to the method used in Mauritius since the 1950s to guarantee ethnic representation across the entire electorate in the National Assembly without organising the representation wholly by ethnicity. [1]

Contents

The BLS was strongly advocated by Comité d'Action Musulman (CAM) leader Abdool Razack Mohamed after none of the 6 Muslim candidates, including himself, was elected at the 1948 general elections. Mohamed was supported by Labour Party's Seewoosagur Ramgoolam and IFB's Sookdeo Bissoondoyal during his lobby for the BLS. [2] [3]

Depite having been devised for ensuring ethnoreligious representation in Parliament, the Best Loser System has at three occasions allowed the existence of a parliamentary opposition, namely in 1982, 1995 and 2024 when none of the elected members were from the opposition.

Methodology

The island's Constitution provides for 8 additional seats (often called "Best Loser" or "Correctional" seats) to prevent under-representation of minority ethnic groups. [4] The methodology is applied by the Office of the Electoral Commission after the proclamation of detailed results of each General Election. [5] The Electoral Commission divides the electorate into four communities: Hindus, Muslims, Sino-Mauritians and the general population. The latter is made up of voters who do not belong to the first three, including Mauritian Creoles, Mulattos and Franco-Mauritians. [6] The main steps are described as follows: [7]

  1. Based on the ethnic composition of the island dating back to the 1972 census the representation of 4 ethnic communities is compared to the ethnic composition of the elected members. Thus for each community the 1972 community size figure is divided by the number of seats won in the actual election by candidates of that particular community.
  2. The most underrepresented ethnic community gets 1 of the first 4 additional seats. This is allocated to the best unsuccessful candidate of that community, irrespective of party affiliations.
  3. The same formula is applied 3 additional times, each time the (new) level of under-representation of the ethnic communities is re-calculated. If a community runs out of candidates, the seat is not given to another community, but is kept for later allocation.
  4. The Electoral Commissioner determines how many of the first 4 seats have not been given to the political party with the highest number of seats obtained in all 21 constituencies. A corresponding number of seats is then allocated to candidates of that party who belong to the most under-represented ethnic community.

2024 Best Losers

Only 4 Best Losers were nominated by the Electoral Commissioner after the November 2024 General Elections when Alliance du Changement coalition came to power: [8]

  1. Henriette-Manan Dianette (Alliance Liberation)
  2. Jacques Edouard (Alliance Liberation)
  3. Adrien Charles Duval (Alliance Lepep)
  4. Joe Lesjongard (Alliance Lepep)

2019 Best Losers

Following the November 2019 General Elections the Electoral Commissioner (Irfan Rahman) published the list of Best Losers which consisted of the following: [9]

  1. Richard Duval (Alliance Nationale PTr-PMSD)
  2. Eshan Juman (Alliance Nationale PTr-PMSD)
  3. Stephan Toussaint (Alliance Morisien MSM-ML)
  4. Stéphanie Anquetil (Alliance Nationale PTr-PMSD)
  5. Fazila Jeewa Daureeawoo (Alliance Morisien MSM-ML)
  6. Tania Diolle (Alliance Morisien MSM-ML)
  7. Anwar Husnoo (Alliance Morisien MSM-ML)
  8. Marie Arianne Navarre-Marie (MMM)

2014 Best Losers

There were 7 Best Losers who were nominated as a result of the December 2014 General Elections. These seats were allocated by the Electoral Commissioner (Irfan Rahman) to the following candidates who had not been elected: [10]

  1. Alain Wong (Alliance Lepep MSM-PMSD-ML)
  2. Thierry Henry (Alliance Lepep MSM-PMSD-ML)
  3. Raffick Sorefan (Alliance Parti Travailliste/Mouvement Militant Mauricien (Alliance PTr/MMM))
  4. Franco Quirin (Alliance Parti Travailliste/Mouvement Militant Mauricien (Alliance PTr/MMM))
  5. Guy Lepoigneur (Alliance Lepep MSM-PMSD-ML)
  6. Salim Abbas Mamode (Alliance Lepep MSM-PMSD-ML)
  7. Jean-Claude Barbier (Alliance Parti Travailliste/Mouvement Militant Mauricien (Alliance PTr/MMM))

2010 Best Losers

Following the 2010 General Elections the Labour-MSM-PMSD coalition came to power and the Electoral Commission nominated 7 Best Losers who had not been elected: [11]

  1. Stéphanie Anquetil (PTr-MSM-PMSD)
  2. Francisco François (OPR)
  3. Josique Radegonde (MMM)
  4. Raffick Sorefan (MMM)
  5. Michael Sik Yuen (PTr-PMSD-MSM)
  6. Reza Issack (PTr-PMSD-MSM)
  7. Aurore Perraud (PTr-PMSD-MSM)

Soon after his 2010 nomination as a Best Loser, as well as Minister of Commerce, Cooperatives and Consumer Protection, it was revealed by the Electoral Commission that Michael Sik Yuen had identified himself as belonging to Population Générale instead of Sino-Mauricien during the nomination phase of these elections. He later justified his decision by claiming that the Best Loser System is too divisive and that it hinders the unification of the Mauritian nation. In 2014 a new party Rassemblement Citoyen pour la Patrie advertised that all its candidates would identify as to Population Générale in order to make the Best loser system less divisive. However, if adopted on a large scale, such practice would distort the allocation of seats, further undermining the representation of minorities. [12] [13]

2005 Best Losers

8 Best Losers were nominated to the National Assembly by the Electoral Commissioner following the 2005 General Elections as the Labour-PMSD coalition headed the new government: [14]

  1. James Burty David (PTr-PMSD)
  2. Christian Léopold (MR)
  3. Nicholas Von-Mally (MR)
  4. Etienne Sinatambou (PTr-PMSD)
  5. Cader SayedHossen (PTr-PMSD)
  6. Jean-François Chaumière (PTr-PMSD)
  7. Dany Perrier (MSM-MMM)
  8. Showkutally Soodhun (MSM-MMM)

2000 Best Losers

8 Best Losers were nominated by the Electoral Commission after the victory of the MSM-MMM coalition. 2 of these nominees (Yerrigadoo and Ramdass) were Hindus but from minority Telugu and Tamil communities: [15]

  1. Nicholas Von Mally (Mouvement Rodriguais)
  2. James Burty David (PTrPMSD)
  3. Ahmad Jeewa (MMM)
  4. Christian Léopold (MR)
  5. Anwar Omar (MSM-MMM)
  6. Motee Ramdass (MSM-MMM)
  7. Ravi Yerrigadoo (MSM-MMM)
  8. Xavier-Luc Duval (PTr-PMSD)

1995 Best Losers

Only 4 Best Losers were nominated after the 1995 General Elections when the Labour-MMM coalition came to power: [16]

  1. Gaëtan Duval (Parti Gaëtan Duval)
  2. Nicholas VonMally (Mouvement Rodriguais)
  3. Imam Mustapha Beeharry (Mouvement Islamiste)
  4. Alex Nancy (Mouvement Rodriguais)

1991 Best Losers

There were 4 Best Losers who were nominated after the 1991 General Elections as the MSM-MMM coalition came to power: [17]

  1. Razack Peeroo (PTr-PMSD)
  2. Gaëtan Duval (PTr-PMSD)
  3. Siddick Chady (PTr-PMSD)
  4. Clarel Malherbe (PTr-PMSD)

1987 Best Losers

There were 8 Best Losers who were nominated after the 1987 General Elections: [18]

  1. Sahid Maudarbocus (MMM)
  2. Swalay Kasenally (MMM)
  3. Germain Comarmond (MSM-PTr)
  4. Karl Offmann (MSM-PTr)
  5. Showkutally Soodhun (MSM-PTr)
  6. Alain Laridon (MSM-PTr)
  7. Régis Finette (MSM and PMSD)
  8. Zeel Peerun (MMM)

1983 Best Losers

There were 8 Best Losers who were nominated after the 1983 General Elections: [19]

  1. Paul Bérenger (MMM)
  2. Joceline Minerve (MMM)
  3. France Canabady (MMM)
  4. Ghislaine Henry (PMSD)
  5. Kamil Ramoly (PMSD)
  6. Sylvio Michel (MSM-PTr)
  7. Ismaël Nawoor (MSM-PTr)
  8. Georgy Candahoo (MSM-PTr)

1982 Best Losers

There were 4 Best Losers were eventually nominated to the Legislative Assembly by the Electoral Commission although victorious party MMM had seriously considered the abolition of the Best Loser system: [20]

  1. Gaëtan Duval (PMSD)
  2. Nicol François (PMSD)
  3. Marie-France Roussety (PTr-PMSD)
  4. Michael Glover (PTr-PMSD)

1976 Best Losers

Following the 1976 General Elections the Best Losers included the following candidates who had not been elected:

  1. Yousuf Mohamed [21]
  2. Harold Walter (Mauritius) [22]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anerood Jugnauth</span> Mauritian statesman (1930–2021)

Sir Anerood Jugnauth, GCSK, PV, was a Mauritian statesman, politician and barrister who served both as President and Prime Minister of Mauritius. He was Member of Parliament for Piton & Riviere Du Rempart. A central figure of Mauritian politics in the 1980s and 1990s, he was Leader of the Opposition from 1976 to 1982. He served four consecutive terms as prime minister from 1982 to 1995 and again from 2000 to 2003. He was then elected as President from 2003 to 2012. Following his party's victory in the 2014 general elections, he served his sixth and final term as prime minister, becoming the nation's longest serving prime minister with more than 18 years of tenure, overtaking Seewoosagur Ramgoolam, who held the office for 14 years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Paul Bérenger</span> Deputy Prime Minister of Mauritius 2024

Paul Raymond Bérenger is a Mauritian politician who was Prime Minister of Mauritius from 2003 to 2005. He has been Leader of the Opposition on several occasions – from 1983 to 1987, 1997 to 2000, 2005 to 2006, 2007 to 2013, October 2013 to 15 September 2014, and again from December 2014 to December 2016 when he was replaced by Xavier-Luc Duval. Following his party's defeat in the 2014 general elections, he became Leader of the Opposition for the sixth time, making him the longest ever to serve in this constitutional position. He was also deputy prime minister from 1995 to 1997 and again from 2000 to 2003, and he was a cabinet minister in the government of Anerood Jugnauth in 1982 and 1991. Bérenger, a Christian of Franco-Mauritian descent, has been the only non-Hindu prime minister of Mauritius, or, more particularly, the only prime minister who has not belonged to the Jugnauth or Ramgoolam families.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mauritian Militant Movement</span> Political party in Mauritius

The Mauritian Militant Movement is a left-wing socialist political party in Mauritius. The party was founded by a group of students in the late 1960s. The MMM advocates a fairer society, without discrimination on the basis of social class, race, community, caste, religion, gender or sexual orientation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Elections in Mauritius</span>

Since 1967, Mauritius has experienced 13 free and fair democratic general elections to choose a government.

The Labour Party is a centre-left social democratic political party in Mauritius. It is one of four main Mauritian political parties, along with the Mauritian Militant Movement (MMM), the Militant Socialist Movement (MSM) and the Parti Mauricien Social Démocrate (PMSD). The party is led by Navin Ramgoolam. It tends to be more popular amongst Indo-Mauritians, especially in more rural areas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Navin Ramgoolam</span> Prime Minister of Mauritius (1995–2000; 2005–2014; since 2024)

Navinchandra Ramgoolam is a Mauritian politician and doctor serving as prime minister of Mauritius for the third time following the 2024 general election, after the landslide victory of his coalition Alliance du Changement. He is a prominent figure in the political history of Mauritius, having served multiple terms as the Prime Minister of the country. He is also the leader of the Labour Party.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Parti Mauricien Social Démocrate</span> Political party in Mauritius

The Mauritian Social Democratic Party, also known as the Mauritian Conservative Party, is a political party in Mauritius. Conservative and Francophilic, the PMSD is the fourth biggest political party in the National Assembly and currently forms part of the opposition.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Militant Socialist Movement</span> Political party in Mauritius

The Militant Socialist Movement is a centre-left political party in Mauritius. It was the single largest political party in the National Assembly of Mauritius, having won 42 of the 69 seats in the 2019 general elections; however, following the 2024 election, it only possesses one seat. It also holds the largest number of seats in all city/town councils through the country with 60 councillors out of 120. The party tends to be more popular amongst Indo-Mauritians.

Dev Virahsawmy was a Mauritian politician, playwright, poet and advocate of the Mauritian Creole language. Though he wrote easily in both French and English, Virahsawmy was most renowned for his efforts to popularise the use of Creole.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2010 Mauritian general election</span>

General elections were held in Mauritius on 5 May 2010. The coalition comprising Mauritius Labour Party under Navin Ramgoolam, the Militant Socialist Movement under Pravind Jugnauth and the Mauritian Social Democrat Party under Xavier Luc Duval won a majority with 41 seats in the parliament. The Mauritian Militant Movement-led coalition under Paul Berenger finished second with 18 seats. The Mauritian Solidarity Front won one seat and the Rodrigues Movement won the two remaining seats. The elections were the ninth to be held since independence from the United Kingdom in 1968.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Xavier-Luc Duval</span> Mauritian politician

Charles Gaëtan Xavier-Luc Duval is a Mauritian politician and was also Deputy Prime Minister of Mauritius in the cabinet of Sir Anerood Jugnauth from December 2014 to December 2016. He was also Minister of Tourism & External Communications and serves as 1st Member of Parliament elected from Constituency No 18 Belle Rose & Quatres Bornes. He is the leader of the Mauritian Social Democrat Party (PMSD). His party has 4 MPs at parliament and he succeeded Arvin Boolell as Leader of Opposition on 4 March 2021.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alliance de L'Avenir</span> Political coalition in Mauritius

The L'Alliance de L'avenir was a political alliance in Mauritius which was formed in 2010 for the next parliamentary elections which were held on 5 May 2010. It is an alliance of the Labour Party, Mouvement Socialiste Militant and Parti Mauricien Social Démocrate. It was formed by the prime minister Dr. Navin Ramgoolam and is led by three other people, namely Rashid Beebeejaun, Xavier-Luc Duval and Pravind Jugnauth.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1983 Mauritian general election</span>

General elections were held in Mauritius on 21 August 1983. The result was a victory for an alliance of the Militant Socialist Movement, the Labour Party and the Parti Mauricien Social Démocrate, which between them won 46 seats. The Militant Socialist Movement (MSM) won 32 seats, whilst the Labour Party secured nine seats and PMSD five. This alliance allowed Jugnauth to continue as Prime Minister while bringing Seewoosagur Ramgoolam and Gaetan Duval back into the government after their severe defeat in the 1982 elections. Shortly after, Ramgoolam was appointed as Governor General, Duval became Deputy Prime Minister and Satcam Boolell became Minister of Foreign Affairs. Voter turnout was 85%.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2014 Mauritian general election</span>

General elections were held in Mauritius on 10 December 2014 and resulted in a landslide victory for the Alliance Lepep coalition, which secured 47 of the elected seats under the leadership of Sir Anerood Jugnauth. The Labour Party–Mauritian Militant Movement (PTR–MMM) alliance led by Navin Ramgoolam got 13 seats.

Harisun Boodhoo more commonly known as Harish Boodhoo, is a Mauritian political figure who served as Deputy Prime Minister of Mauritius from 11 June 1982 to 21 August 1983. He was elected Member of Parliament (MP) in 1976, 1982 and 1983 in Rivière des Anguilles and Souillac.

Jayarama Valayden, most commonly known as Rama Valayden is a Mauritian lawyer, social worker and politician.

Michael James Kevin Glover, most commonly known as Michael Glover is a Mauritian politician, and former Physical Education instructor.

Ravi Yerrigadoo is a Mauritian politician.

Adrien Charles Duval is a Mauritian politician and barrister who is the Speaker of the National Assembly.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alliance Lepep</span> Political coalition in Mauritius

Alliance Lepep is a coalition of parties in the island state of Mauritius.

References

  1. ↑ Reena Jane Dobson, Reena Jane Dobson. "'The Most Cosmopolitan Island under the Sun'? Negotiating Ethnicity and Nationhood in Everyday Mauritius" (PDF). Centre for Cultural Research University of Western Sydney. Retrieved 2009-12-15.
  2. ↑ Bissoondoyal, Surendra. "To abolish or not to abolish? 10-Feb-2012". Mauritius Times. Retrieved 10 August 2024.
  3. ↑ Figaro, El. "Réforme électorale: «grat lédo maler» ?". L'Express. Retrieved 10 August 2024.
  4. ↑ Mahadew, Amar. "The Best Loser System in Mauritius: An Essential Electoral Tool for Representing Political Minorities" (PDF). ISBN 978-3-8452-5460-9 (ePDF). Community Law Centre, University of the Western Cape Constitution-Building in Africa. Retrieved 2015-10-09.
  5. ↑ Elklit, Jørgen. "Mauritius: Electoral system for Parliament in Mauritius". EISA African Democracy Encyclopaedia Project. Retrieved 2005-06-15.
  6. ↑ Fessha, Yonatan; Ho Tu Ham, Nora (2015). "Is it time to let go? The Best Loser System in Mauritius" (PDF). Afrika Focus. 28 (1): 66–67. Retrieved 6 November 2024.
  7. ↑ Mathur, Raj. "Party cooperation and the electoral system in Mauritius" (PDF). Australian National University. Retrieved 2021-06-18.
  8. ↑ "Les quatre Best Losers connus". Defimedia. 12 November 2024. Retrieved 2024-11-12.
  9. ↑ "Best Loser: les huit nouveaux députés correctionnels connus". L'Express. 9 November 2019. Retrieved 2019-11-09.
  10. ↑ "Best Losers : 51 députés pour l'alliance Lepep et 16 pour le PTr-MMM". L'Express. 12 December 2014. Retrieved 2014-12-12.
  11. ↑ "Système électoral: quatre à huit Best Losers nommés depuis 1982". L'Express. Retrieved 2019-10-30.
  12. ↑ "More Michael Sik Yuens Will Result in a Post Electoral Disaster". Le Mauricien. Retrieved 2014-01-15.
  13. ↑ "Mes premiers pas comme ministre". 5Plus. Retrieved 2010-05-25.
  14. ↑ "Système électoral: quatre à huit Best Losers nommés depuis 1982". L'Express. Retrieved 2019-10-30.
  15. ↑ "Système électoral: quatre à huit Best Losers nommés depuis 1982". L'Express. Retrieved 2019-10-30.
  16. ↑ "Système électoral: quatre à huit Best Losers nommés depuis 1982". L'Express. Retrieved 2019-10-30.
  17. ↑ "Système électoral: quatre à huit Best Losers nommés depuis 1982". L'Express. Retrieved 2019-10-30.
  18. ↑ "Système électoral: quatre à huit Best Losers nommés depuis 1982". L'Express. Retrieved 2019-10-30.
  19. ↑ "Système électoral: quatre à huit Best Losers nommés depuis 1982". L'Express. Retrieved 2019-10-30.
  20. ↑ "Système électoral: quatre à huit Best Losers nommés depuis 1982". L'Express. Retrieved 2019-10-30.
  21. ↑ "Décès de Mᵉ Yousuf Mohamed Parcours politique: la grève de 1979, un intense moment de son existence". L'Express. Retrieved 2022-04-05.
  22. ↑ Selvon, Sydney; Riviere, Lindsay (1991). Historical Dictionary of Mauritius. Metuchen N.J.: Scarecrow Press. p. 203. ISBN   978-0-8108-2480-5 . Retrieved 2022-12-11.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.