Brachyhyops

Last updated

Brachyhyops
Temporal range: Middle to Late Eocene
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Class: Mammalia
Order: Artiodactyla
Family:† Entelodontidae
Genus:† Brachyhyops
Colbert, 1937
Type species
†Brachyhyops wyomingensis
Colbert, 1937
Species
  • B. wyomingensisColbert 1937
  • B. trofimovi(Dashzeveg 1976)
  • B. neimonngoliensisWang & Qiu 2002
  • B. viensisRussell 1980
Synonyms
  • Eoentelodon trofimoviDashzeveg 1976
  • Dyscritochoerus lapointensis

Brachyhyops is an extinct genus of entelodont artiodactyl mammal that lived during the Eocene Epoch of western North America and southeastern Asia (including Mongolia, China, and Kazakhstan). [1] [2] [3] [4] The first fossil remains of Brachyhyops are recorded from the late Eocene deposits of Beaver Divide in central Wyoming and discovered by paleontology crews from the Carnegie Museum of Natural History during the early 20th century. The type species, Brachyhyops wyomingensis, is based on a single skull and was named by E.H. Colbert in 1937, but was not officially described until 1938. During the latter half of the 20th century, additional specimens from North America have been recorded from Saskatchewan and as far south as Texas, indicating that Brachyhyops had a broad distribution and was well-dispersed throughout western North America.

Contents

More recent discoveries from Eocene deposits in Mongolia lead to the recognition of a second species of Brachyhyops, B trofimovi. [5] It is notable that the oldest specimens of Brachyhyops are middle Eocene in age and have been recorded exclusively from southern Asia, whereas specimens from the late Eocene only occur in the northern part of the continent. [6] This implies that the genus Brachyhyops most likely originated in southern Asia, migrated north and eventually dispersed into western North America.

Discovery

In 1934, crew members of the Carnegie Museum paleontological expedition discovered the holotype of Brachyhyops wyomingensis (CM 12048) from the uppermost beds of the Eocene White River Formation, in a member known as the Big Sand Draw Sandstone Lentil, at Beaver Divide, Wyoming. [1] [2] [7] The specimen consists of a single, exceptionally well preserved, but severely distorted, isolated skull with no mandibles or post cranial material. Since its initial discovery, several other partial specimens of Brachyhyops have been recorded within North America and Asia. Currently, four species of Brachyhyops have been recognized; two from Asia and two within North America, and include Brachyhyops trofimovi from Mongolia, B. neimongoliensis from northern China, B. viensis from Saskatchewan, Canada; Wyoming, and New Mexico, USA, and lastly, B. wyomingensis from Wyoming, Utah, and Texas, USA.

Description

Holotype (CM 12048) of Brachyhyops wyomingensis was diagnosed by Edwin H. Colbert in 1938 [2] as a medium sized skull with a relatively short snout and a length that is comparable to the skull of a modern peccary. The portion of the skull behind the eye socket is greater compared to the portion of the skull in front of the eye socket due to the short size of the snout. The dentition is I3(?)-C1-P4-M3, indicating in the upper jaw the number of incisors, canines, premolars, and molars respectively. Colbert [2] compared B. wyomingensis to Helohyus, Chaeropotamus, Achaenodon, and Parahyus based on tooth shape. No mandibles were preserved with the holotype specimen and therefore dentition of the lower jaws could not be determined. The overall width of the skull is broad and having widely separated parietal crests. In addition, the zygomatic arches are deepened and expanded below and behind the eye socket, contributing to the wide skull shape, which is very similar to other entelodonts. The rear portion of eye socket is closed and situated directly above the last two molars. Articulation surfaces for the lower jaws; the glenoids, are broad, shallow, and situated around the occlusal line of the upper cheek teeth. Both paroccipital processes are short and parietals are weakly developed. The basicranium, or occiput, is considered basal.

Classification and Evolution

Brachyhyops is an artiodactyl which has a poorly resolved evolutionary status that continues to be subject of revision. Colbert [2] initially classified Brachyhyops strictly within the bunodontids based on its bunodont-like tooth shape. More recent studies revised the evolutionary relationship of Brachyhyops and it has now been recognized as a very basal entelodontid that might represent the origin of the clade Entelodontidae, [5] [8] which also includes members such as the Oligocene Archaeotherium and Miocene Daeodon .

Taxonomy

Brachyhyops was named by Colbert (1937) [also said to be 1938]. The type species is B. wyomingensis. It was assigned to Artiodactyla by Colbert (1937); assigned to Suina by Effinger (1998), and was assigned to Entelodontidae by Carroll (1988). [9]

Merger with Eoentelodon

Eoentelodon was synonymized subjectively with Brachyhyops by Lucas and Emry (2004) as "Brachyhyops yunnanensis." However, in 2007, I. Vislobokova determined that Eoentelodon was not only distinct from Brachyhyops, but more closely related to Proentelodon , another primitive entelodont found in slightly older Middle Eocene strata of Mongolia, and placed Eoentelodon and Proentelodon in their own subfamily, Proentelodontinae. [10]

Fossil distribution

Fossils have been uncovered from Texas to Uintah County, Utah to Saskatchewan, Canada as well as Jiangsu, China.

Paleobiogeography

Asian distribution

The oldest fossil material that is assigned to Brachyhyops is early to upper Eocene in age, and recorded from six Asian localities, predominantly Mongolia, China, with the lone exception of a single location in Kazakhstan. Currently, two localities in southern Asia yield the oldest Brachyhyops material known. The first locality is situated in the northwestern Yunnan of southern China, and specimens of Brachyhyops sp. are recorded from the early middle, or late middle Eocene Xiangshan Formation. No Brachyhyops specimens from the lower to middle Eocene have been recorded from northern Asia; instead, the four remaining localities are all younger (late Eocene) in age and include the southeastern Mongolian taxa B. trofimovi from the Ergilin Dzo Formation at the Khoer Dzan locality and Brachyhyops? sp. from the Ergilin Dzo Formation at the Ergilin Dzo locality. [5] A single taxon, B. neimongolensis, is recorded from the upper Eocene Ulan Gochu Formation of northern China. [4] Lastly, material assigned to ‘Eoentelodon sp.’ (revised as Brachyhyops sp. by Tsubamoto et al. [5] ) is recorded from the lower Aksyir ‘svita’ in eastern Kazakhstan, which was later correlated to the late Eocene Ergilian Asian Land Mammal ‘age’ (ALMA) by Emry et al. [11] and Lucas et al. [12]

North American distribution

Brachyhyops is the oldest entelodont from North America and is recorded exclusively from late Eocene (late Duchesnean – early Chadronian) age deposits. [3] Their geographic range is restricted to western North America and spans from Saskatchewan, Canada to as far south as Big Bend, Texas, USA. A total of nine localities have yielded Brachyhyops material. The Cypress Hills Formation in Saskatchewan, Canada, suggests an early Chadronian age, approximately 37 Ma, and represents the type locality for Brachyhyops viensis as well as the northernmost area in which Brachyhyops specimens have been recorded. Apparently an undocumented Brachyhyops specimen has been recorded from the late Eocene White River Formation of Montana, however, the exact museum location where this specimen is housed remains unknown. [3] Three localities in Wyoming yielded Brachyhyops material and these include a partial skull roof and maxilla from the lower White River Formation (late Eocene) of the Flagstaff Rim, Wyoming. Based on size and tooth shape, these specimens have been assigned to B. viensis. [3] The next locality in Wyoming is the type locality for B. wyomingensis which was recorded from the Big Sand Draw Lentil of the White River Formation at Beaver Divide, and comprises a single skull without mandibles. The third locality yielded cranial fragments that are assigned to B. viensis and were recorded from the lower strata of the White River Formation at Canyon Creek, approximately 50 km east of Beaver Divide. [3] Additional Brachyhyops wyomingensis material was recorded from a single location in northeastern Utah, namely the Lapoint Member of the Duchesne River Formation, which has an age of approximately 39.74 ± 0.07 Ma based on radioisotopic dates from nearby volcanic ashes. [3] Two localities within New Mexico yielded Brachyhyops material and include a single molar (m1) from the lower jaw that was assigned to B. viensis and recorded within the Duchesnean interval of the Galisteo Formation in north central New Mexico, and is of late Duchesnean (38 Ma) age. [3] An additional specimen was recorded from the upper Baca Formation at Mariano Mesa in west central New Mexico and is also situated within the Duchesnean. This specimen comprises a single premolar and four molars (p3 – m4) from a single right lower jaw and are assigned to B. wyomingensis based on the shape and dimensions of the teeth. The final locality within North America is located in Trans-Pecos, Texas, USA, and contains well documented records of Brachyhyops wyomingensis from the late Duchesnean Porvenir local fauna which is situated above a volcanic ash that is radioisotopically dated to 37.8 ± 0.15 Ma. [3] The fact that there is no stratigraphic overlap between northern and southern Asian Brachyhyops specimens, suggests that Brachyhyops originated in southern Asia during the early and late middle Eocene and continuously dispersed into northern Asia. Long term exposure of the Beringian land bridge during the late Eocene promoted continuous intercontinental dispersal from Asia into North America, resulting in further dispersal and diversification of Brachyhyops across western North America during the late Eocene. [3]

Diet

The dentition of Brachyhyops is heterodont, which forms a complex set of different teeth including incisors, large canines, premolars, and molars, which are used to capture and process a wide variety of food items including both meat and vegetation. Despite their heterodont tooth condition, there has been a considerable amount of debate regarding the diet of Brachyhyops and various other entelodontids with similar dentition, such as Archaeotherium and Daeodon . Researchers have proposed different dietary hypotheses based on the heterodont dentition and shape of the teeth, interpreting entelodontids as rooting, pig-like omnivores, [13] [14] browsers [15] or even active predators, [16] based on wear grooves on their dentition. By studying well-preserved fossils, Joeckel [17] re-evaluated these interpretations and performed several modeled analyses regarding the wear patterns on the dentition and structure of the skull (in particular the growth series and muscle reconstruction of the skull) and concluded an omnivorous diet for Archeaotherium, and most likely Brachyhyops, in which scavenging and active hunting appears to have played a possible role.

Paleoecology

The habitat in which Brachyhyops occurred appears to be savannah-woodland or open grassland and lived alongside a diversity of other herbivores and carnivores in Eocene Asia and western North America. [18] [19]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Entelodontidae</span> An extinct family of pig-like omnivores from North America and Eurasia

Entelodontidae is an extinct family of pig-like artiodactyls which inhabited the Northern Hemisphere from the late Eocene to the Middle Miocene epochs, about 38-19 million years ago. Their large heads, low snouts, narrow gait, and proposed omnivorous diet inspires comparisons to suids and tayassuids (peccaries), and historically they have been considered closely related to these families purely on a morphological basis. However, studies which combine morphological and molecular (genetic) data on artiodactyls instead suggest that entelodonts are cetancodontamorphs, more closely related to hippos and cetaceans through their resemblance to Pakicetus, than to basal pigs like Kubanochoerus and other ungulates.

<i>Entelodon</i> Extinct genus of mammals

Entelodon, formerly called Elotherium, is an extinct genus of entelodont artiodactyl endemic to Eurasia. Fossils of species are found in Paleogene strata ranging in age from the Houldjinian until the Rupelian epoch of the early Oligocene.

<i>Cynodictis</i> Extinct genus of carnivores

Cynodictis is an extinct amphicyonid carnivoran which inhabited Eurasia from the Late Eocene subepoch to the Early Oligocene subepoch living from 37.2—28.4 million years ago, existing for approximately 8.8 million years.

<i>Archaeotherium</i> Extinct genus of mammals

Archaeotherium is an extinct genus of entelodont artiodactyl endemic to North America during the Eocene and Oligocene epochs (35—28 mya), existing for approximately 9.1 million years. Archaeotherium fossils are most common in the White River Formation of the Great Plains, but it has also been found in the John Day Basin of Oregon and the Trans-Pecos area of Texas.

<i>Daeodon</i> Extinct genus of mammals

Daeodon is an extinct genus of entelodont even-toed ungulates that inhabited North America about 23 to 20 million years ago during the latest Oligocene and earliest Miocene. The type species is Daeodon shoshonensis, described by a very questionable holotype by Cope. Some authors synonymize it with Dinohyus hollandi and several other species, but due to the lack of diagnostic material, this is questionable at best.

Eoentelodon is a small, primitive entelodont, assigned as such by Carroll (1998), from the Middle Eocene of China. It was a very small entelodont, about the size of a modern pig, and was slightly smaller than its North American counterpart, Brachyhyops.

<i>Paraentelodon</i> Extinct genus of entelodonts

Paraentelodon is an extinct entelodont from the Late Oligocene and Oligocene-Miocene boundary of Asia. The fossils of the type species P. intermedium were found in Georgia, Kazakhstan and China. An indeterminate species represents in Bugti Hills which is the late Oligocene of Pakistan.

<i>Asiavorator</i> Extinct genus of carnivores

Asiavorator is an extinct genus of civet-like carnivoran belonging in the family Stenoplesictidae. It was endemic to Asia and lived during the Eocene and Oligocene epochs.

<i>Agriochoerus</i> Extinct genus of mammals

Agriochoerus is an extinct genus of scansorial herbivore of the tylopod family Agriochoeridae, endemic to North America. Agriochoerus and other agriochoerids possessed claws, which is rare within Artiodactyla, as well as likely being scansorial. Agriochoerus was first described in 1869.

The Washakie Formation is a geologic formation in northern Colorado and southern Wyoming. It preserves many mammal, bird, reptile and other fossils dating back to the Lutetian stage of the Eocene within the Paleogene period. The sediments fall in the Bridgerian and Uintan stages of the NALMA classification.

Proentelodon is an extinct genus of entelodont artiodactyl from the Middle Eocene of Mongolia. P. minutus is the oldest representative of the family Entelodontidae, P. minutus gen. et sp. nov, is described from the Middle Eocene Khaichin Ula II Fauna in Mongolia. The placement of the genus in the entelodonts has been questioned by other authors, but its placement as related to the group has been supported by some cladistic analyses.

<i>Ronzotherium</i> Extinct genus of mammals

Ronzotherium is an extinct genus of perissodactyl mammal from the family Rhinocerotidae. The name derives from the hill of 'Ronzon', the French locality near Le Puy-en-Velay at which it was first discovered, and the Greek suffix 'therium' meaning 'beast'. At present 5 species have been identified from several localities in Europe and Asia, spanning the Late Eocene to Upper Oligocene.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Homacodontidae</span> Extinct family of mammals

Homacodontidae is an extinct family of basal artiodactyl mammals from the early Eocene to late Oligocene of North America, Europe, and Asia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Helohyidae</span> Family of extinct artiodactyl mammals

Helohyidae were a group of artiodactyl mammals. They were most prominent in the mid-to-upper Eocene.

<i>Achaenodon</i> Extinct mammal

Achaenodon is an extinct artiodactyl mammal, possibly belonging to the family Helohyidae. It lived in the mid-late Eocene and its fossil remains have been found in North America.

<i>Xenocranium</i> Genus of prehistoric burrowing mammals

Xenocranium is an extinct monotypic genus of placental mammal from extinct paraphyletic subfamily Epoicotheriinae within extinct paraphyletic family Epoicotheriidae in extinct order Palaeanodonta, that lived in North America during the late Eocene.

<i>Bachitherium</i> Extinct genus of mammals

Bachitherium is an extinct genus of Paleogene ruminants that lived in Europe from the late Eocene to the late Oligocene. The genus was erected in 1882 by Henri Filhol for Bachitherium curtum, the type species, and B. insigne; five more species have since been named although one, B. sardus, is currently pending reassessment. The genus name derives from "Bach", the French locality where its first fossils were found, and the Greek θήρ/therium meaning "beast". Bachitherium has historically been assigned to various families within the ruminant infrorder Tragulina, but was reclassified to its own monotypic family Bachitheriidae by Christine Janis in 1987.

Alagtsavbaatar is an extinct species of carnivorous cat-like carnivoran belonging to the superfamily Aeluroidea. It was endemic to Asia, with all known specimens being found in Mongolia, and lived during the late Eocene epoch. It is a monotypic genus, with the type and only known species being A. indigenus, and is named after the Alag Tsav locality where its remains were first discovered.

The Ergilin Dzo Formation, is a geologic formation in southeastern Mongolia. It preserves fossils of a wide variety of animals, which date back to the late Eocene epoch. The type fauna of the Ergilian Asian land mammal age is defined by the mammalian fossils of this formation.

Ergilictis is an extinct genus of mammal that lived during the late Eocene and early Oligocene epochs. It was endemic to Asia, and its fossils have been found in the Ergilin Dzo and Hsanda Gol formations of Mongolia. It belongs to the family Didymoconidae, which has uncertain taxonomic affinities.

References

  1. 1 2 Colbert, E.H. (1937). Notice of a new genus and species of Artiodactyl from the Upper Eocene of Wyoming. American journal of Science, Series 5, 33: 473-474
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 Colbert, E.H. (1938). Brachyhyops, a new bunodont artiodactyls from Beaver Divide, Wyoming: Annals of the Carnegie Museum. Vol. 27. 87-108
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Lucas, S.G., Emry, R.J. (2004). The entelodont Brachyhyops (Mammalia, Artiodactyla) from the upper Eocene of Flagstaff Rim, Wyoming. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin, no. 26, p. 97-100
  4. 1 2 Wang, B.-Y., Qiu, Z.-X. (2002). A new species of Entelodontidae (Artiodactyla, Mammalia) from the late Eocene of Nei Mongol, China. Vertebrata PalAsiatica, vol. 40, p. 194-202 (in Chinese with English summary)
  5. 1 2 3 4 Tsubamoto, T., Saneyoshi, M., Watabe, M., Tsogbataar, K., Mainbayar, B. (2011). The Entelodontid Artiodactyl Fauna from the Eocene Ergilin Dzo Formation of Mongolia with Comments on Brachyhyops and the Khoer Dzan Locality. Paleontological Research, 15(4):258-268
  6. ↑ Tsubamoto, T., Takai., M., Egi, N. (2004). Quantitative analyses of biogeography and faunal evolution of middle to late Eocene mammals in East Asia. Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology, vol. 24, p. 657-667
  7. ↑ Prothero, D.R., Sanchez, F. (2004). Magnetic stratigraphy of the middle to upper Eocene at Beaver Divide, Fremont County, Central Wyoming. In Lucas, S.S., Zeigler, K.E., Kondrashov, P.E. (eds.) Paleogene Mammals. New Mexico Museum of Natural History and Science Bulletin No. 26, 151-154
  8. ↑ Foss, S.E. (2007). Family Entelodontidae. In, Prothero, D. R. and Foss, S. E. eds.,The Evolution of Artiodactyls, p. 120–129. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
  9. ↑ J. A. Effinger. 1998. Entelodontidae. In C. M. Janis, K. M. Scott, and L. L. Jacobs (eds.), Evolution of Tertiary Mammals of North America 1:375-380
  10. ↑ I. A. Vislobokova.The oldest representative of Entelodontoidea (Artiodactyla, Suiformes) from the Middle Eocene of Khaichin Ula II, Mongolia, and some evolutionary features of this superfamily Paleontological Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, Profsoyuznaya ul. 123, Moscow, 117997, Russia
  11. ↑ Emry, R.J., Lucas, S.G., Tyutkova, L., Wang, B. (1998). The Ergilian-Shandgolian (Eocene-Oligocene) transition in the Zaysan basin, Kazakhstan. Bulletin of Carnegie Museum of Natural History, no. 34, p. 298-312
  12. ↑ Lucas, S.G., Emry, R.J., Bayshashov, B.U., Tyutkova, L.A. (2009). Cenozoic mammalian biostratigraphy and biochronology in the Zaysan basin, Kazakhstan. Museum of Northern Arizona Bulletin, no. 65, p. 621-633
  13. ↑ Scott, W.B. (1940). The mammalian fauna of the White River Oligocene, Part IV: Artiodactyla. Transacrions of the American Philosophical Society, New Series 28:363-746
  14. ↑ Romer, A.S. (1966). Vertebrate Paleontology. University of Chicago Press; Chicago
  15. ↑ Russell, L.S.(1980). Tertiary mammals of Saskatchewan part V; The Oligocene Entelodonts. Life Science s Contributions of the Royal Ontario Museum 122
  16. ↑ Peterson, O.A. (1909). A revision of Entelodontidae. Memoirs of the Carnegie Museum, 9:41-158
  17. ↑ Joeckel, R.M. (1990). A functional interpretation of the masticatory system and paleoecology of Entelodonts. Paleobiology, vol. 16:4, p.459-482
  18. ↑ Scott, W.B. (1945). The Mammalia of the Duchesne River Oligocene. Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, New Series, 34(3): 209-253
  19. ↑ Rasmussen, T.D., Hamblin, A.H., Tabrum, A.R. (1999). The Mammals of the Eocene Duchesne River Formation. In Gillette, D.D. (ed.) Vertebrate Paleontology in Utah. Miscellaneous Publication 99-1, Utah Geological Survey. Pp. 421-427
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.