Comparison of OLAP servers

Last updated

The following tables compare general and technical information for a number of online analytical processing (OLAP) servers. Please see the individual products articles for further information.

Contents

General information

OLAP serverCompanyWebsiteLatest stable version Software license License pricing
Apache Doris Apache Software Foundation [1] 1.2.3 Apache 2.0 free
Apache Druid Apache Software Foundation [2] 29.0.0 [3] Apache 2.0 free
Apache Kylin Apache Software Foundation [4] 3.1.0 Apache 2.0 free
Apache Pinot Apache Software Foundation [5] 1.1.0 Apache 2.0 free
Atoti ActiveViam [6] 6.0.5 Proprietary community
ClickHouse Clickhouse Inc [7] 22.08 Apache 2.0 free
Essbase Oracle [8] 21.5 Proprietary
IBM Cognos TM1 IBM [9] 10.2.2 FP7 Proprietary -
icCube icCube [10] 8.4.6 Proprietary community /
Jedox OLAP Server Jedox [11] 2019.3 Proprietary
Kyvos Kyvos Insights [12] 2022.3 Proprietary -
Microsoft Analysis Services Microsoft [13] 2016 Proprietary
Mondrian OLAP server Pentaho [14] 3.7 EPL free
Oracle Database OLAP Option Oracle [15] 11g R2 Proprietary
SAP NetWeaver BW SAP [16] 7.30 Proprietary -
SAS OLAP Server SAS Institute [17] 9.4 Proprietary -
StarRocks Linux Foundation [18] 3.1 Apache 2.0 free

Data storage modes

OLAP server MOLAP ROLAP HOLAP Offline
Apache DorisYesYesYesYes
Apache Druid YesYesYesYes
Apache Kylin YesNoNoYes
Apache Pinot YesYesYesYes
ClickHouse YesYesYesYes
Essbase YesNoNo
IBM Cognos BI YesYesYes
IBM Cognos TM1 YesNoNo Cognos Insight Distributed mode
icCube YesNoNoYes
Jedox OLAP Server YesNoNoNo
Kyvos YesYesYesYes
Microsoft Analysis Services YesYesYesLocal cubes,
PowerPivot for Excel,
Power BI Desktop
MicroStrategy Intelligence Server YesYesYes MicroStrategy Office,
Dynamic Dashboards
Mondrian OLAP server NoYesNo
Oracle Database OLAP Option YesNoNo
SAP NetWeaver BW YesYesNo
SAS OLAP Server YesYesYes
StarRocksYesYesYesYes

APIs and query languages

APIs and query languages OLAP servers support.

OLAP server XML for Analysis OLE DB for OLAP MDX Stored procedures Custom functions SQL LINQ [19] Visualization JSON REST API
Apache DorisNoNoNoNoYes [20] YesNoSuperset, Redash, Metabase, Tableau, Qlik, Pivot, PowerBIYesYes
Apache Druid NoNoNoNoYesDruid SQLNoSuperset, Pivot, RedashYesYes
Apache Kylin YesNoYesNoYesYesSuperset, Zeppelin, Tableau, Qlik, Redash, Microsoft ExcelYesYes
Apache Pinot NoNoNoNoYesYesNoSuperset, Pivot, RedashYesYes
ClickHouse NoNoNoNoYes [21] YesNoSuperset, Zeppelin, Tableau, Qlik, Redash, DataLens [22] YesYes
Essbase YesYesYesYesYesNoYesSmartView (Excel-AddIn), Oracle Analytics Cloud, Narrative Reporting, Tableau, IBM Cognos ?Yes
IBM Cognos TM1 YesYesYesYesYesNoYesTM1 Web/TM1 Contributor, IBM Cognos Insight, IBM Performance Modeler, IBM Cognos Cafe for Excel, Cognos BI, TM1 Perspectives for ExcelYesYes
icCube YesYesYes Java, [23] R [24] YesIn the reportingYesicCube reporting and all XMLA compliant visualization tools like Excel, etcYesYes
Jedox OLAP Server YesYesYesCube Rules, SVS TriggersYesNoYesMicrosoft Excel, Qlik, Tableau, Jedox Web, Power BINoYes
Kyvos YesYesYesNoYesYesNoKyvos Insights, Microsoft Excel, Qlik, Tableau, Power BI, MicroStrategy, IBM Cognos, Business Objects, XLCubed, Looker, Altryx, and moreYesYes
Microsoft Analysis Services YesYesYes .NET [25] Yes [26] Yes [27] YesMicrosoft Excel, SharePoint, Microsoft Power BI, and 70+ other visualization toolsNoNo
MicroStrategy Intelligence Server YesNoYesYesYesYesYesDossier, Dashboard, ReportsYesYes
Mondrian OLAP server YesYes [28] YesYesYes [29] NoYesYes [30]  ? ?
Oracle Database OLAP Option NoYes [31] Yes [31] Java, PL/SQL, OLAP DML YesYes [32] No ? ? ?
SAP NetWeaver BW YesYesYesNoYesNoYes ? ? ?
SAS OLAP Server YesYesYesNoNoNoYesWeb Report Studio ? ?
StarRocksNoNoNoNoYes [33] YesNoSuperset, Redash, Metabase, Tableau, Qlik, Pivot, PowerBIYesYes

OLAP distinctive features

A list of OLAP features that are not supported by all vendors. All vendors support features such as parent-child, multilevel hierarchy, drilldown.

Data processing, management and performance related features:

OLAP serverReal TimeWrite-backPartitioningUsage Based OptimizationsLoad Balancing and Clustering
Apache DorisYesYesYesYesYes
Apache Druid Yes ?YesYesYes
Apache Kylin Yes [34] NoYesYesYes
Apache Pinot YesYesYesYesYes
ClickHouse YesYesYesYesYes
Essbase YesYesYesYesYes
IBM Cognos BI YesNoYesYes ?
IBM Cognos TM1 YesYesYes ? ?
icCube Yes [35] NoYes [36]  ? ?
Jedox OLAP Server YesYesYes ? ?
Kyvos YesYesYesYesYes
Microsoft Analysis Services YesYesYesYesYes
MicroStrategy Intelligence Server  ?Yes [37] YesYesYes
Mondrian OLAP server YesPlannedYes ? ?
Oracle Database OLAP Option  ?YesYesNo ?
SAP NetWeaver BW  ?YesYes ? ?
SAS OLAP Server  ?YesYes ? ?
StarRocksYesYesYesYesYes

Data modeling features:

OLAP serverSemi-additive measuresMany-to-ManyMulti-Cube ModelPerspectivesKPIMultilingualNamed SetsMulti-attribute HierarchiesActions
Apache DorisYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesNo
Apache Druid YesYesYes ?NoYes ?YesYes
Apache Kylin NoNoYesNoYesYesNoYesYes
Apache Pinot YesYes ? ?NoYes ?YesYes
ClickHouse YesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesNo
Essbase Yes ? ? ?YesYesYesYes ?
IBM Cognos BI YesYes ? ? ? ?YesYes ?
IBM Cognos TM1 YesYesYes ? ? ? ? ? ?
icCube Yes [38] YesYesYesYesYesYesYes ?
Jedox OLAP Server YesYesYesYesYesYesYesYes ?
Kyvos YesYesYesNoYesYesYesYesNo
Microsoft Analysis Services YesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYes
MicroStrategy Intelligence Server YesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYes
Mondrian OLAP server Yes [39]  ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
Oracle Database OLAP Option Yes ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
SAP NetWeaver BW Yes ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
SAS OLAP Server Yes ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?
StarRocksYesYesYesYesYesYesYesYesNo

System limits

OLAP server# cubes# measures# dimensions# dimensions in cube# hierarchies in dimension# levels in hierarchy# dimension members
Apache DorisUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestricted
Apache Druid Unrestricted [lower-alpha 1] UnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestricted
Apache Kylin UnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestricted
Apache Pinot UnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestricted
ClickHouse UnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestricted
Essbase [40] UnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestricted255255 ?20,000,000 (ASO), 1,000,000 (BSO)
IBM Cognos TM1 Unrestricted [lower-alpha 1] UnrestrictedUnrestricted [lower-alpha 1] 256Unrestricted [lower-alpha 1] UnrestrictedUnrestricted
icCube 2,147,483,6472,147,483,6472,147,483,6472,147,483,6472,147,483,6472,147,483,6472,147,483,647
Jedox OLAP Server (32 bits) (32 bits)250
Kyvos UnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestricted
Microsoft Analysis Services [41] 2,147,483,6472,147,483,6472,147,483,6472,147,483,647 (max. number of dimensions in a database)2,147,483,6472,147,483,6472,147,483,647 (xOLAP)

Unrestricted (In-memory)

MicroStrategy Intelligence Server Unrestricted [lower-alpha 1] Unrestricted [lower-alpha 1] Unrestricted [lower-alpha 1]  ?Unrestricted [lower-alpha 1] Unrestricted [lower-alpha 1] Unrestricted [lower-alpha 1]
SAS OLAP Server [42] Unrestricted [lower-alpha 1] 1024128 ?128194,294,967,296
StarRocksUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestrictedUnrestricted
  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Please update as 'unrestricted', is just not possible

Security

OLAP serverAuthenticationNetwork encryptionOn-the-Fly [lower-alpha 1] Data access
Cell securityDimension securityVisual totals
Apache DorisBuilt-in, LDAP, Kerberos SSL YesYesYesYes
Apache Druid Druid Database authentication SSL YesNoYesNo
Apache Kylin LDAP, SAML, Kerboros, Microsoft Active DirectorySSLYesNoNo ?
Apache Pinot HTTP basic authentication SSL  ?NoNoNo
ClickHouse Built-in, LDAP, Microsoft Active Directory, Kerberos SSL YesYesYesYes
Essbase Essbase authentication, LDAP authentication, Microsoft Active Directory SSL YesYesYesNo
IBM Cognos TM1 Builtin, LDAP, Microsoft Active Directory, NTLM, IBM Cognos BI authentication SSL YesYesYesYes
icCube HTTP Basic/Form Authentication, Windows SSO (NTLM, Kerberos), Plugin Based for Embedded Usage SSL YesYesYesYes
Jedox OLAP Server Jedox authentication, LDAP, Microsoft Active Directory SSL YesYesYes ?
Kyvos Built-in, LDAP, Microsoft Active Directory, SAML, Windows SSO (NTLM, Kerberos) SSL YesYesYesYes
Microsoft Analysis Services NTLM, Kerberos SSL and SSPI YesYesYesYes
MicroStrategy Intelligence Server Host authentication, database authentication, LDAP,
Microsoft Active Directory, NTLM, SiteMinder, Tivoli, SAP, Kerberos
SSL, AES [43]  ?YesYesYes
Oracle Database OLAP Option Oracle Database authentication SSL  ?YesYesNo
SAS OLAP Server [44] Host authentication, SAS token authentication, LDAP, Microsoft Active Directory Yes [45]  ?YesYesYes
  1. On-the-Fly : The ability to define authentication dynamically via programmatic interfaces. New users do not require restarting the server or redefining the security.

Operating systems

The OLAP servers can run on the following operating systems:

OLAP serverWindowsLinuxUNIXz/OSAIX
Apache DorisNoYesYesNoNo
Apache Druid NoYesYes
Apache Kylin NoYesYesNoNo
Apache Pinot YesYesYesYesYes
ClickHouse NoYesYesNoNo
Essbase YesYesYesNoYes
IBM Cognos TM1 YesYesYesNoYes
icCube YesYesYesYesYes
Jedox OLAP Server YesYesYesNo
Kyvos NoYesYesNoNo
Microsoft Analysis Services YesNoNoNo
MicroStrategy Intelligence Server YesYesYesNoYes
Mondrian OLAP server YesYesYesYes
Oracle Database OLAP Option YesYesYesYes
SAP NetWeaver BW YesYesYesYes
SAS OLAP Server YesYesYesYes
StarRocksNoYesYesNoNo

Note (1):The server availability depends on Java Virtual Machine not on the operating system

Support information

OLAP serverIssue Tracking SystemRoadmapSource code
Apache Doris Apache Doris– Github Issues Apache Doris Roadmap Open
Apache Druid Druid – Github Issues Open
Apache Kylin Jira Apache Kylin Roadmap Open
Apache Pinot Apache Pinot – Github Issues Open
ClickHouse ClickHouse – Github Issues ClickHouse Roadmap Open
Essbase myOracle Support Closed
IBM Cognos TM1 IBM Service Request Closed
icCube [hthttps://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/iccube Stackoverflow]Closed
Jedox OLAP Server Mantis Available upon requestOpen
Kyvos ZendeskAvailable upon requestClosed
Microsoft Analysis Services Connect -Closed
MicroStrategy Intelligence Server MicroStrategy Resource Center -Closed
Mondrian OLAP server Jira Open
Oracle Database OLAP Option myOracle Support Closed
SAP NetWeaver BW OSS Closed
SAS OLAP Server Support Closed
StarRocks StarRocks– Github Issues StarRocks Roadmap Open

See also

Related Research Articles

Online analytical processing, or OLAP, is an approach to answer multi-dimensional analytical (MDA) queries swiftly in computing. OLAP is part of the broader category of business intelligence, which also encompasses relational databases, report writing and data mining. Typical applications of OLAP include business reporting for sales, marketing, management reporting, business process management (BPM), budgeting and forecasting, financial reporting and similar areas, with new applications emerging, such as agriculture.

The following tables compare general and technical information for a number of relational database management systems. Please see the individual products' articles for further information. Unless otherwise specified in footnotes, comparisons are based on the stable versions without any add-ons, extensions or external programs.

Essbase is a multidimensional database management system (MDBMS) that provides a platform upon which to build analytic applications. Essbase began as a product from Arbor Software, which merged with Hyperion Software in 1998. Oracle Corporation acquired Hyperion Solutions Corporation in 2007. Until late 2005 IBM also marketed an OEM version of Essbase as DB2 OLAP Server.

A user-defined function (UDF) is a function provided by the user of a program or environment, in a context where the usual assumption is that functions are built into the program or environment. UDFs are usually written for the requirement of its creator.

In computer programming contexts, a data cube is a multi-dimensional ("n-D") array of values. Typically, the term data cube is applied in contexts where these arrays are massively larger than the hosting computer's main memory; examples include multi-terabyte/petabyte data warehouses and time series of image data.

A pivot table is a table of values which are aggregations of groups of individual values from a more extensive table within one or more discrete categories. The aggregations or summaries of the groups of the individual terms might include sums, averages, counts, or other statistics. A pivot table is the outcome of the statistical processing of tabularized raw data and can be used for decision-making.

Multidimensional Expressions (MDX) is a query language for online analytical processing (OLAP) using a database management system. Much like SQL, it is a query language for OLAP cubes. It is also a calculation language, with syntax similar to spreadsheet formulae.

Microsoft SQL Server Analysis Services (SSAS) is an online analytical processing (OLAP) and data mining tool in Microsoft SQL Server. SSAS is used as a tool by organizations to analyze and make sense of information possibly spread out across multiple databases, or in disparate tables or files. Microsoft has included a number of services in SQL Server related to business intelligence and data warehousing. These services include Integration Services, Reporting Services and Analysis Services. Analysis Services includes a group of OLAP and data mining capabilities and comes in two flavors multidimensional and tabular, where the difference between the two is how the data is presented. In a tabular model, the information is arranged in two-dimensional tables which can thus be more readable for a human. A multidimensional model can contain information with many degrees of freedom, and must be unfolded to increase readability by a human.

Business intelligence software is a type of application software designed to retrieve, analyze, transform and report data for business intelligence. The applications generally read data that has been previously stored, often - though not necessarily - in a data warehouse or data mart.

In computing, a materialized view is a database object that contains the results of a query. For example, it may be a local copy of data located remotely, or may be a subset of the rows and/or columns of a table or join result, or may be a summary using an aggregate function.

The Oracle Database OLAP Option implements On-line Analytical Processing (OLAP) within an Oracle database environment. Oracle Corporation markets the Oracle Database OLAP Option as an extra-cost option to supplement the "Enterprise Edition" of its database.

Microsoft SQL Server is a proprietary relational database management system developed by Microsoft. As a database server, it is a software product with the primary function of storing and retrieving data as requested by other software applications—which may run either on the same computer or on another computer across a network. Microsoft markets at least a dozen different editions of Microsoft SQL Server, aimed at different audiences and for workloads ranging from small single-machine applications to large Internet-facing applications with many concurrent users.

Pentaho is business intelligence (BI) software that provides data integration, OLAP services, reporting, information dashboards, data mining and extract, transform, load (ETL) capabilities. Its headquarters are in Orlando, Florida. Pentaho was acquired by Hitachi Data Systems in 2015 and in 2017 became part of Hitachi Vantara.

CubePort is a commercial software application that converts from Oracle Essbase to the analogous Microsoft product Microsoft Analysis Services, which is built into Microsoft SQL Server. This application achieves this through various analogy mapping techniques, and is a standard client-server application that runs on a Windows computer but may connect to non-Windows servers. CubePort converts the various OLAP structures and syntaxes in the source through an extraction process, interprets, and recreates in the target. The objective is to simulate exactly the behavior of the original source system to the target system.

Sqoop is a command-line interface application for transferring data between relational databases and Hadoop.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arcplan</span> Business intelligence software company

Arcplan is a software for business intelligence (BI), budgeting, planning & forecasting (BP&F), business analytics and collaborative Business Intelligence. It is the enhancement of the enterprise software inSight® and dynaSight of the former German provider arcplan Information Services GmbH.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Apache Kylin</span> Open-source distributed analytics engine

Apache Kylin is an open source distributed analytics engine designed to provide a SQL interface and multi-dimensional analysis (OLAP) on Hadoop and Alluxio supporting extremely large datasets.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">ClickHouse</span> Open-source database management system

ClickHouse is an open-source column-oriented DBMS for online analytical processing (OLAP) that allows users to generate analytical reports using SQL queries in real-time. ClickHouse Inc. is headquartered in the San Francisco Bay Area with the subsidiary, ClickHouse B.V., based in Amsterdam, Netherlands.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Apache Pinot</span> Open-source distributed data store

Apache Pinot is a column-oriented, open-source, distributed data store written in Java. Pinot is designed to execute OLAP queries with low latency. It is suited in contexts where fast analytics, such as aggregations, are needed on immutable data, possibly, with real-time data ingestion. The name Pinot comes from the Pinot grape vines that are pressed into liquid that is used to produce a variety of different wines. The founders of the database chose the name as a metaphor for analyzing vast quantities of data from a variety of different file formats or streaming data sources.

References

  1. "Apache Doris". Github. Retrieved 6 April 2023.
  2. druid. "Druid | Interactive Analytics at Scale". druid.io. Retrieved 2017-09-01.
  3. "Latest Release".
  4. Kylin, Apache. "Apache Kylin | Home". kylin.apache.org. Retrieved 2018-11-08.
  5. Pinot, Apache. "Apache Pinot | Home". pinot.apache.org. Retrieved 2021-07-14.
  6. "Atoti".
  7. "ClickHouse".
  8. "Oracle Essbase".
  9. "Cognos Business Intelligence and Financial Performance Management". 9 November 2020.
  10. "icCube OLAP Server".
  11. "Jedox".
  12. "Kyvos".
  13. "Microsoft SQL Server 2008 Analysis Services". Microsoft .
  14. "Pentaho Analysis Services: Mondrian Project".
  15. "Oracle OLAP Documentation".
  16. "Components & Tools".
  17. "SAS OLAP Server".
  18. "StarRocks | A High-Performance Analytical Database". www.starrocks.io. Retrieved 2023-10-24.
  19. "SSAS Entity Framework Provider".
  20. "Apache Doris UDF" . Retrieved 6 April 2023.
  21. "ClickHouse SQL Reference". Yandex.
  22. "ClickHouse Visual Interfaces". Yandex.
  23. "icCube Java integration documentation". icCube.
  24. "icCube R language integration documentation". icCube.
  25. "SQL Server 2008 Books Online (October 2009)Defining Stored Procedures". MSDN. 9 December 2022.
  26. "SQL Server 2008 Books Online (October 2009)Using Stored Procedures". MSDN. 28 February 2023.
  27. "How to perform a SQL Server distributed query with OLAP Server". MSDN. 7 March 2023.
  28. "Pentaho and Simba Technologies Partner to Bring World's Most Popular Open Source OLAP Project to Microsoft Excel Users".
  29. "How to Define a Mondrian Schema". Pentaho.
  30. "Pentaho Business Analytics Visualization".
  31. 1 2 "Oracle and Simba Technologies Introduce MDX Provider for Oracle OLAP".
  32. "Querying Oracle OLAP Cubes: Fast Answers to Tough Questions Using Simple SQL".
  33. "StarRocks UDF" . Retrieved 6 April 2023.
  34. "Real-time OLAP".
  35. "icCube Real Time walkthrough".
  36. "icCube Partitioning".
  37. "Common Extensions of the MicroStrategy Platform". Archived from the original on 2010-11-28. Retrieved 2010-11-10.
  38. "icCube Aggregatin types".
  39. "Support for Non-Additive and Semi-Additive Measures".
  40. "Essbase Server Limits". Oracle. Archived from the original on 2015-06-26. Retrieved 2015-06-25.
  41. "SQL Server 2008 Books Online (October 2009)Maximum Capacity Specifications (Analysis Services - Multidimensional Data)". Microsoft. 9 December 2022.
  42. "SAS OLAP Cube Size Specifications".
  43. "MicroStrategy Intelligence Server Features". Archived from the original on 2012-07-10. Retrieved 2010-11-10.
  44. "SAS OLAP Security Totals and Permission Conditions".
  45. "How to Change Over-the-Wire Encryption Settings for SAS Servers".