Criticism of IKEA

Global furniture and homeware retailer IKEA has been criticized for various issues, including their raw material sourcing, the size of their stores, the impact of their stores on local communities, legal violations, and unfair or discriminatory business practices, among others.

Wood sourcing practices

Illegal timber in Ukraine

In 2020, the NGO Earthsight found IKEA and others to be selling furniture made from wood illegally felled during "silent periods" in the forests of the Ukrainian Carpathians. The wood in question was certified by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) despite its sourcing. ^[1]

Illegal timber in Russia

In 2021, the NGO Earthsight alleged the use of illegally logged wood from protected forests in Russia by IKEA and others, with the source forests being owned by millionaire politician Evgeny Bakurov. Bakurov's pine was certified by the FSC. IKEA denied wrongdoing and announced a temporary ban on sanitary felled wood from Russia, while also insisting that Bakurov's wood was "legally harvested". ^[2]

Illegal timber in Romania

In 2017, a team of French journalists learned IKEA was cutting down 200-year-old trees and converting them into particle board in their sub-supplier Kronospan's factory in Sebeș, Romania. Kronospan delivers particle board to Ecolor, which produces, among other things, the Brimnes shelf for IKEA. Mikhail Tarasov, IKEA's Global Forestry Manager, answered in an interview that the only thing they ask their suppliers for is using particle board in their furniture. ^[3] Questions regarding where IKEA sources their furniture and wood are considered classified. ^[3]

In 2022, The New Republic published a report about the misuse of logging permits in Romanian forests owned by INGKA Investments, the investment arm of IKEA owner INGKA Holding. INGKA had cleared far bigger areas of protected old-growth forest in Romania than permitted, contributing to local corruption and violence against environmental activists. Since 2015, INGKA Investments has become the largest private landowner in Romania, by buying up forest. It is estimated that around 10% of the wood used for IKEA furniture comes from Romania. ^[4]

Scandinavica

In 2014, documents were found at the Securitate archives in Bucharest, Romania, which indicated that IKEA's open purchase of Romanian lumber throughout the 1980s was part of a complex scheme (codenamed "Scandinavica") to fund the Securitate and allow the accumulation of foreign currency in the Socialist Republic of Romania: the Romanian lumber company Tehnoforestexport would regularly overcharge IKEA, transfer the overpayments into private Securitate bank accounts, wait for interest to accrue, and then reimburse IKEA the principal. IKEA denied complicity in Scandinavica but began an internal investigation. ^[5]

Timber from Belarus

7% of the wood that becomes IKEA furniture comes from Belarus, where the state owns all of the country's forests. IKEA has been accused of financing President of Belarus Alexander Lukashenko's repression against political opponents, with Anna Sundström, Secretary-General of the Olof Palme International Center, arguing that the money contributes to maintaining his oppressive regime. ^[6]

Child deaths

In July 2015, IKEA and the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, through the company's Safer Homes Together advertising campaign, issued a warning in the United States, the United Kingdom, and Ireland to customers to secure the Malm chests of drawers and wardrobes firmly to the wall using free kits distributed by the company, after the deaths of two young children in the U.S. in February and June 2014 when the furniture tipped over and fell on them. Since 1989, there were three other deaths from other similar appliance models tipping over, and 14 incidents of Malm chests tipping over, resulting in four injuries. The company sent out free kits on request for customers to anchor the furniture to the wall. ^[7] In June 2016, after a third toddler died in the U.S., IKEA recalled all Malm dressers as well as several similar models which posed a tipping danger if not secured to the wall with the supplied kit. ^{[8] [9]} On 12 July 2016, bowing to two weeks of rising pressure in China, IKEA announced that it was extending this recall to that country, which, along with Europe, was initially excluded from the recall. ^[10] Over 29 million dressers were recalled. ^{[11] [12]} IKEA settled wrongful death lawsuits for over $50 million in compensation to the families of the three children who were killed. ^{[13] [14]}

IKEA France spying

In 2012, IKEA in France was accused by the independent newspaper Le Canard enchaîné and the investigative website Mediapart of spying on its employees and clients by illegally accessing National Police records. The head of risk management at IKEA feared his employees were anti-globalists or potential ecoterrorists. ^{[15] [16]}

The French branch of IKEA went on trial on 22 March 2021, for running an elaborate system to spy on staff members and job applicants by illegally using private detectives and police officers. ^[17]

On 15 June 2021, IKEA France was found guilty of spying and ordered to pay €1.1m in fines and damages for these illegal practices. Additionally, Jean-Louis Baillot, the former head of IKEA France was ordered to pay €50,000 and received a two-year suspended prison sentence. Jean-François Paris, IKEA's former head of risk management and alleged mastermind of the scheme, received a suspended 18 month prison sentence and was fined €10,000. ^[18]

Store size, construction, and openings

IKEA's goals of sustainability and environmental design in its merchandise have sometimes been at odds with the impact a new IKEA store can have on a community. In particular, the size of proposed IKEA stores and a perceived negative effect on other local businesses has often seen significant opposition from members of such communities. Some examples include:

• In 2004, there was controversy about an Irish law restricting the maximum size of a retail outlet to 6,000 square metres (65,000 sq ft). IKEA's plan to build a much larger store in Dublin caused the law to be put up for debate. The law was changed to remove the size limit for retail outlets selling durable goods in designated areas. ^[19] The Minister for the Environment was criticized for allegedly changing the law to suit one company and other agencies protested the law change as damaging to small businesses while the government defended its decision stating that the move was a positive one for Irish consumers. IKEA Dublin has since opened on 27 July 2009. ^[20]
• In September 2004, when IKEA offered a limited number of free $150 vouchers at the opening of a new store in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia, three people were crushed to death in a stampede that followed the store's opening. ^[21]
• IKEA has demolished historic buildings to make room for parking lots, including part of Marcel Breuer's landmark Pirelli Tire Building in New Haven, Connecticut, ^[22] and the Red Hook graving dock in Brooklyn, New York City. ^[23] The College Park, Maryland store was also built over a historic tavern, and inside the store is an interactive display detailing its history.
• In 2007, about ten ancient tombs were destroyed in the construction of an IKEA store in Nanjing, China. Archaeologists from the Nanjing Museum requested the building company to halt work to retrieve artifacts, but did not receive the necessary permission. ^[24]
• In June 2007, the designated nationalist Social Democratic and Labour Party in Northern Ireland complained about an artist's rendering of IKEA's Belfast store that included both the Union Flag and the Ulster Banner flag as two of the three flags in front of the store. After being labelled "an upmarket Orange hall" by the party, IKEA assured customers and co-workers that only the Swedish flag would be displayed outside the store. ^[25]
• In 2008, a police investigation for corruption in Spain uncovered the director of IKEA Expansion and an entrepreneur owner of the land discussing the location of a store in Alicante, during which it was alleged the director was meeting with organized crime. ^[26]

Involvement of IKEA founder with Nazi sympathizer

In 1994, Stockholm daily newspaper Expressen reported on IKEA founder Ingvar Kamprad's past involvement with Swedish pro-Nazi groups as one of the member's archives revealed his name. The archives showed Kamprad had attended a number of meetings and had befriended a leading extremist, Per Engdahl, starting in 1945 and extending well into the 1950s. The newspaper printed more details, including the text of a 1950 note from Kamprad to Engdahl in which Kamprad said he was proud to be involved with the groups. Kamprad denied he was ever a formal member of the Nazi groups and said he was drawn to Engdahl's vision of a non-communist, socialist Europe. He mentioned that his activities during that time "a part of my life which I bitterly regret." ^[27]

Price discrimination

In 2007, Canadian newscast CityNews reported that IKEA had been charging up to twice as much in their Canadian stores as for the same items sold in their American stores, despite the Canadian dollar having temporarily reached parity with the U.S. dollar. ^[28]

Within the days after the launch of the South Korean edition of the official IKEA website, complaints arose from a group of consumers on IKEA's pricing policy in the country: the prices of certain products were higher than other countries. ^[29] On 24 November 2014, Jang Duck-jin, head of the Fair Trade Commission's consumer policy bureau, told the media that the commission was planning to commission a consumer group to compare IKEA's product prices by country, ^[30] and on 19 March 2015, the Consumers Union of Korea published a report comparing the prices of 49 IKEA products in South Korea and other countries, which concluded that exchange rate adjusted prices in Korea were second highest out of 28 developed economies compared, and fourth highest once adjusted for purchasing power. ^[31]

Biased branding and advertising accusations

• Former Norwegian prime minister Kjell Magne Bondevik has criticized IKEA for not depicting women assembling furniture in its instruction booklets. ^[32] IKEA denied this claim in a statement. ^[33]
• In 2008, Klaus Kjøller, a researcher from the University of Copenhagen, accused IKEA of cultural imperialism, arguing that for years, IKEA has named their cheap rugs after Danish places, while the more expensive and luxurious furniture was named after Swedish places. ^[34]
• In October 2012, IKEA was criticized in Sweden for airbrushing women out of pictures in catalogues used in Saudi Arabia. ^[35]
• In October 2017, a Chinese IKEA commercial, showing a mother scolding her daughter for not "bringing home a boyfriend", was criticized by netizens for "sexist" and discrimination against singles and single women in China. IKEA apologized for "giving the wrong perception". ^[36]

Horse meat meatballs

Main article: 2013 horse meat scandal

In February 2013, IKEA announced it had pulled 17,000 portions of Swedish meatballs containing beef and pork from stores in Europe after testing in the Czech Republic found traces of horse meat in the product. The company removed the Swedish meatballs from store shelves on 25 February 2013, but only made the announcement public after Swedish newspaper Svenska Dagbladet uncovered what happened. ^[37] In a March 2013 media report, an IKEA representative stated that the corporation had made Familjen Dafgård, its main meatball supplier, cease business with 8 of its 15 suppliers, and would reduce the number of purchasing countries. The offending meat was traced to a Polish abattoir. ^[38]

References

1. Harvey, Fiona (23 June 2020). "Timber from unsustainable logging allegedly being sold in EU as ethical". The Guardian (published 2021-07-16). Retrieved 2022-07-22.
2. Jane Dalton (16 July 2021). "Ikea sold children's furniture 'made of illegally-logged Russian wood'". www.independent.co.uk (published 2020-06-23). Retrieved 2022-07-22.
3. "Prime Video: Wood Industry: A Business Against Nature". www.primevideo.com. Retrieved 30 April 2020.
4. Sammon, Alexander (16 February 2022). "Ikea's Race for the Last of Europe's Old-Growth Forest". The New Republic (published 2022-02-06). Retrieved 2022-07-22.
5. Ikea funds went to Romanian secret police in communist era, by Matei Rosca, in The Guardian ; published 4 July 2014; retrieved 6 July 2014
6. "Ikea hämtar virke från Lukasjenkos diktatur". Dagens Nyheter (in Swedish). 28 December 2020. Retrieved 28 December 2020.
7. Khomami, Nadia (23 July 2015). "Ikea issues warning after deaths of US children". The Guardian– via MSN.
8. Costello, Tom; Stelloh, Tim (28 June 2016). "Dangerous Dressers". NBC News.
9. "IKEA Recalls MALM and Other Models of Chests and Dressers Due to Serious Tip-Over Hazard. Consumers Urged to Anchor Chests and Dressers or Return for Refund". Ikea. 28 June 2016. Archived from the original on 13 May 2019. Retrieved 20 December 2021.
10. Feng, Emily (12 July 2016). "Ikea Extends Recall to China After Criticism". New York Times.
11. "Ikea Recalls 29 Million Dressers and Chests After 6 Children Killed". ABC News .
12. "Ikea recalls 29 million dressers after 6 kids killed". Fox News . 28 June 2016.
13. "Ikea will pay $50 million to families whose kids were crushed by dressers". NBC News .
14. "Ikea to Pay Parents of Kids Crushed by Falling Dressers $50 Million". Gizmodo. 22 December 2016. Retrieved 30 April 2020.
15. "Ikea 'stole secret French police reports' – claim – The Local". Thelocal.fr. 29 February 2012. Archived from the original on 2 July 2012. Retrieved 28 January 2013.
16. "Espionnage : quand Ikea faisait son marché dans les fichiers de police" (in French). Rue89. 28 February 2012. Retrieved 28 January 2013.
17. Wright, Lara; Lamberti, Ornella. CTV News. Ikea France goes on trial for spying on staff. Retrieved on 22 March 2021
18. Butler, Sarah (15 June 2021). "Ikea fined €1.1m by French court for spying on staff". The Guardian. Archived from the original on 16 June 2021. Retrieved 16 June 2021.
19. "RTÉ report on the loosening of shop planning laws". Rte.ie. 5 January 2005. Retrieved 10 June 2009.
20. "IKEA Ireland" . Retrieved 15 April 2008.
21. "World | Middle East | Three die in Saudi shop stampede". BBC News. 1 September 2004. Retrieved 10 June 2009.
22. Hawthorne, Christopher (February 2003). "Disposable Architecture". Metropolis. Archived from the original on 13 March 2014. Retrieved 13 March 2014.
23. "Suit aims to make an IKEA lot history". New York Daily News . 22 November 2006. Archived from the original on 12 July 2007. Retrieved 8 June 2007.
24. "Workers destroy ancient Chinese tombs: media". Reuters. 3 July 2007. Retrieved 17 November 2017.
25. "No Union flag at new Ikea store". BBC News. 12 June 2007. Retrieved 9 August 2007.
26. "Ortiz al enlace de Ikea: 'Te gustó, ¿eh?...¡Tener un amigo mafioso!" (in Spanish). El Mundo (Spanish Newspaper). 27 June 2014. Retrieved 27 June 2014.
27. "Ikea Founder Tells of Past". The New York Times. Associated Press. 9 November 1994. Retrieved 26 May 2020.
28. "CityNews: "Ikea confronted over Canadian–U.S. price differences"". 5 November 2007. Archived from the original on 1 December 2008. Retrieved 19 June 2008.
29. "IKEA pricing under fire". koreatimes. 16 November 2014. Retrieved 25 July 2018.
30. "IKEA under probe for overcharging consumers here". koreatimes. 24 November 2014. Retrieved 25 July 2018.
31. "IKEA accused of pricing higher in Korea". koreatimes. 19 March 2015. Retrieved 25 July 2018.
32. "Norwegian Prime Minister Slams Ikea". 10 March 2005. Archived from the original on 11 April 2013.
33. "IKEA to Review Equality in Manuals". Los Angeles Times. 11 March 2005. Retrieved 13 June 2013.
34. O'Mahony, Paul (20 February 2008). "Ikea guilty of 'cultural imperialism': Danes". The Local . Archived from the original on 28 February 2008. Retrieved 8 March 2008.
35. "IKEA airbrushes out women from its Saudi catalog". USA TODAY. Retrieved 16 July 2021.
36. "Ikea apologises for 'sexist' China advert". BBC. 26 October 2017.
37. "Horsemeat found in Ikea meatballs in Czech Republic". BBC. 25 February 2013. Retrieved 6 June 2013.
38. "IKEA meatballs return after horsemeat scare". Chicago Tribune. Reuters. 21 March 2013. Archived from the original on March 26, 2013. Retrieved 6 June 2013.