Disposition Matrix

Last updated

Predator drone launching a Hellfire missile of the kind used to kill persons named on the list Predator and Hellfire.jpg
Predator drone launching a Hellfire missile of the kind used to kill persons named on the list

The Disposition Matrix, informally known as a kill list, is a database of information for tracking, capturing, rendering, or killing suspected enemies of the United States. [1] Developed by the Obama administration beginning in 2010, it goes beyond existing kill lists and is intended to become a permanent fixture of U.S. policy. [1] The process determining the criteria for killing is not public and was heavily shaped by National Counterterrorism Director and former Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) Director John O. Brennan. [2]

Contents

Though White House, National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC), and CIA spokespeople have declined to comment on the database, officials have stated privately that kill lists will expand "for at least another decade", if not indefinitely. One official stated "it's a necessary part of what we do". [1] Paul R. Pillar, the former deputy director of the CIA's counterterrorism center, has stated, "We are looking at something that is potentially indefinite". [1]

The database's existence was revealed in a three-part series published by The Washington Post .

Purpose

We can't possibly kill everyone who wants to harm us ... It's a necessary part of what we do. . . . We're not going to wind up in 10 years in a world of everybody holding hands and saying, 'We love America.'

– Unnamed senior Obama administration official, The Washington Post , 23 October 2012. [1]

The creation of the Disposition Matrix database is part of an effort embraced by White House counterterrorism adviser John O. Brennan to codify the targeted killing policies developed by President Barack Obama. Under the George W. Bush administration, Brennan served as top aide to CIA director George Tenet, where he defended the administration's use of extraordinary rendition, enhanced interrogation, and torture by definition according to international standards. [3] Brennan's association with the CIA's interrogation program was controversial and forced him to withdraw his candidacy for directorship of the CIA or National Intelligence in 2008. [4]

According to The New York Times , Brennan was the "principal coordinator" of U.S. kill lists. Former Obama administration counter-terrorism official Daniel Benjamin has stated that Brennan "probably had more power and influence than anyone in a comparable position in the last 20 years". [5]

The database's creation also accompanied an expansion of the drone fleet, turning the CIA into a "paramilitary force" according to The Washington Post. It is associated with increased Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC) operations in Africa, and increased JSOC involvement in forming kill lists. [1] The database has unified originally separate but overlapping kill lists maintained by both JSOC and the CIA, and was originally proposed by former NCTC director Michael Leiter. [1]

Scope

John O. Brennan, former director of the Central Intelligence Agency and chief counter-terrorism advisor to U.S. President Barack Obama John Brennan.jpg
John O. Brennan, former director of the Central Intelligence Agency and chief counter-terrorism advisor to U.S. President Barack Obama

The Disposition Matrix database catalogues biographies, locations, associates, and affiliations of suspects. It also catalogues strategies for finding, capturing, or killing suspects, or subjecting them to extraordinary rendition. [1] As of 2012, the database continued to direct U.S. operations in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Somalia and Yemen, and was expected to facilitate expanded operations in Algeria, Egypt, Mali, Libya, Iran, and throughout east Africa. [1]

A clear example of the expansion of targeted killing as managed by the database is the U.S. military base in Djibouti City, Djibouti, near Somalia. [6] Called Camp Lemonnier and originally created by the French Foreign Legion, the camp has transformed into the largest overseas U.S. drone base outside of Afghanistan. About 3,200 U.S. soldiers, contractors and civilians are assigned to the camp, 300 of whom are special operations personnel. [6]

One terrorism suspect on the Disposition Matrix is Somali citizen Ahmed Abdulkadir Warsame, who is currently a prisoner of the United States being held in New York. [1]

Process

I tend to do what I think is right. But I find much more comfort, I guess, in the views and values of this president.

– John O. Brennan in August 2012. The Washington Post , 24 October 2012. [2]

The database eliminates the prior system of dual (but not judicial) scrutiny by both The Pentagon and the National Security Council, instead using a "streamlined" system in which suspects were designated by multiple agencies and ultimately presented to Brennan. [1] The head of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, responsible for carrying out orders to kill suspects on the list, no longer contributes to the decision of whether or not to kill them. [1]

Instead, the National Counterterrorism Center plays a greater role in determining targets, which they generate at the request of the White House. The criteria and decisions determining who may be targeted for killing are developed in large part by John Brennan, who "wields enormous power in shaping decisions on 'kill' lists and the allocation of armed drones". [2] Targets are reviewed every three months with input from the CIA and JSOC, before being passed on to top officials in the NCTC, CIA, JSOC, the National Security Council, Pentagon, and U.S. State Department. [1] Ultimately, the authority to kill a suspect outside Pakistan must be approved by the President. [1]

The review process also allows the killing of individuals whose identities are unknown, but who are thought to be engaged in certain activities, for instance packing a vehicle with explosives. [1]

As reported previously, United States citizens may be listed as targets for killing in the database. [7] Suspects are not formally charged of any crime nor offered a trial in their defense. [8] Obama administration lawyers have asserted that U.S. citizens alleged to be members of Al Qaeda and said to pose an "imminent threat of violent attack" against the United States may be killed without judicial process. [9] The legal arguments of U.S. officials for this policy were leaked to NBC News in February 2013, in the form of briefing papers summarizing legal memos from October 2011. [9]

Endorsement

U.S. officials have described the Disposition Matrix as legally and morally sound, and The Washington Post has written that "internal doubts about the effectiveness of the drone campaign are almost nonexistent". [1] U.S. President Barack Obama has called the decision to kill U.S. citizen and terrorism suspect Anwar al-Awlaki "an easy one", [7] and shares counterterrorism views with Brennan, the principal architect of the criteria used when making suspects targets in the database. Referring to President Obama's view of drone strikes, Brennan has stated, "I don't think we've had a disagreement". [2]

U.S. officials speaking to The Washington Post seemed "confident that they have devised an approach that is so bureaucratically, legally and morally sound that future administrations will follow suit". [1] Brennan, a principal architect of the "Disposition Matrix", stated in April 2012 that "in order to ensure that our counterterrorism operations involving the use of lethal force are legal, ethical, and wise, President Obama has demanded that we hold ourselves to the highest possible standards and processes". [10]

The Obama administration's drone program received approval from Republican Party presidential candidate Mitt Romney during the 2012 U.S. presidential elections. [1] [3]

Robert M. Chesney has written for the Lawfare blog that "it certainly is a good thing to create an information management tool that makes certain that officials across agencies and departments can have real-time, comprehensive understanding of the options available (practically, legally, diplomatically, etc.) in the event specific persons turn up in specific places". [11] He has also argued that The Washington Post article describing the program falsely implies that it has been associated with a change in U.S. counter-terrorism policy. [11]

According to research by the RAND Corporation, "drone strikes are associated with decreases in both the frequency and the lethality of militant attacks overall and in IED and suicide attacks specifically". [12]

The number of US drone strikes significantly increased under the Trump administration. [13] [14]

Criticism

Anyone who thought U.S. targeted killing outside of armed conflict was a narrow, emergency-based exception to the requirement of due process before a death sentence is being proven conclusively wrong.

– The American Civil Liberties Union, 23 October 2012. [15]

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has condemned the database, writing in a press release that "anyone who thought U.S. targeted killing outside of armed conflict was a narrow, emergency-based exception to the requirement of due process before a death sentence is being proven conclusively wrong". [15] It has also filed freedom of information requests regarding the database and filed a lawsuit challenging its constitutionality. [15]

Glenn Greenwald has written that "the central role played by the NCTC in determining who should be killed [is] rather odious ... the NCTC operates a gigantic data-mining operation, in which all sorts of information about innocent Americans is systematically monitored, stored, and analyzed". [16] Greenwald concludes that the Disposition Matrix has established "simultaneously a surveillance state and a secretive, unaccountable judicial body that analyzes who you are and then decrees what should be done with you, how you should be "disposed" of, beyond the reach of any minimal accountability or transparency". [16] Former counter-terrorism specialist and military intelligence officer Philip Giraldi has criticized the disposition matrix's "everyday" killing of targets with what he calls "little or no evidence", leaving the White House "completely unaccountable". [17] [18] Giraldi later commented that Brennan "feels the [drone] program has run its course as a CIA operation". [19]

Minneapolis anti-war protest: 'Stop Killer Drones', 5 May 2013 Stop Killer Drones (15836463196).jpg
Minneapolis anti-war protest: 'Stop Killer Drones', 5 May 2013

In April 2016, peace worker and tribal elder Malik Jalal, who appears to have been targeted by repeated drone strikes, was invited to the United Kingdom (UK) by Ken Macdonald in order to explain to the UK's Houses of Parliament that his life and those of his friends and relatives are at risk due to his reported presence on the list. [20] [21]

Criticizing strikes organized under the aegis of the database, the World Socialist Web Site has written that "the great majority of those killed in Pakistan are targeted for resisting the US occupation of neighboring Afghanistan, while in Yemen they are killed for opposing the US-backed regime there". [3] Regarding the effect of the database in the United States, the site has written that "the Obama administration has arrogated to itself the most extreme power that can be asserted by any dictatorship—that of ordering citizens put to death without presenting charges against them, much less proving them in a court of law". [3] They later criticized the relative silence in the media and the political establishment following the revelation. [22]

In 2016, New York Daily News journalist Gersh Kuntzman has criticized the U.S. government's drone assassination program, and has even implied that the Obama administration may be guilty of war crimes. [23]

Describing the criteria for killing established by the database and drone program, Voice of Russia has written that "in essence, this means that based on intelligence evidence, the administration assumes the right to judge and execute anyone without bothering about such minor things as proper court hearings, or the right of the accused person for proper legal defense". [24] It has accused the Obama administration of violating U.S. principles of due process, stating, "the fact that such operations clearly violate the principles propagated by the U.S. itself, like the right of everyone for legal defense, does not seem to bother the administration". [24]

U.N. Special Rapporteur Ben Emmerson said the U.S. may have committed war crimes in its campaign of drone strikes. Ben Emmerson QC, UN Special Rapporteur on Counterterrorism and Human Rights (11105307123).jpg
U.N. Special Rapporteur Ben Emmerson said the U.S. may have committed war crimes in its campaign of drone strikes.

Speaking at Harvard Law School on 25 October 2012, United Nations Special Rapporteur on human rights and counter terrorism, Ben Emmerson, stated that he would launch "an investigation unit within the special procedures of the Human Rights Council to inquire into individual drone attacks".[ citation needed ] Emmerson and Christof Heyns, UN Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions, have described some U.S. drone attacks as war crimes. [25] Emmerson said that U.S. drone strikes may have violated international humanitarian law. [26] [27]

John Hudson, writing in The Atlantic Wire, has raised the concern that from a semantic perspective, the term "Disposition Matrix" sanitizes and perhaps obscures the more descriptive phrase "kill list". [28]

The United States Senate is split over how to handle the issue, with Democrats urging the creation of a special court to review the matrix. Senate Armed Services Committee chair John McCain called for control of all armed drones to be transferred from the CIA to the U.S. Department of Defense, [29] while Dianne Feinstein has expressed doubt that the Pentagon would take the same level of care to avoid collateral damage. [30]

An American journalist and Syrian Civil War war correspondent Bilal Abdul Kareem reported drone assassination attempts by the U.S. military, which killed random civilians that were present nearby, including two attacks on vehicles he was traveling in, including one where the car he was sitting in was blown up by a missile shot from a drone. [31] [32] [33] In 2017, he filed a lawsuit against the United States government in the District of Columbia, claiming they had attempted to assassinate him, and requesting his removal from the Disposition Matrix. [34] [35]

See also

Related Research Articles

Qaed Salim Sinan al-Harethi, also known as Abu Ali al-Harithi was an al-Qaeda operative and a citizen of Yemen who is suspected of having been involved in the October 2000 USS Cole bombing, and the October Limburg attack.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Special Activities Center</span> Covert and paramilitary unit of the American Central Intelligence Agency

The Special Activities Center (SAC) is a division of the United States Central Intelligence Agency responsible for covert and paramilitary operations. The unit was named Special Activities Division (SAD) prior to 2015. Within SAC there are two separate groups: SAC/SOG for tactical paramilitary operations and SAC/PAG for covert political action.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Joint Special Operations Command</span> Joint component command of the U.S. Special Operations Command

The Joint Special Operations Command (JSOC) is a joint component command of the United States Special Operations Command (USSOCOM) and is charged with studying special operations requirements and techniques to ensure interoperability and equipment standardization, to plan and conduct special operations exercises and training, to develop joint special operations tactics, and to execute special operations missions worldwide. It was established in 1980 on recommendation of Colonel Charlie Beckwith, in the aftermath of the failure of Operation Eagle Claw. It is headquartered at Pope Field.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">National Counterterrorism Center</span> U.S. government organization responsible for national and international counterterrorism efforts

The National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC) is a United States government organization responsible for national and international counterterrorism efforts. It is based in Liberty Crossing in McLean, Virginia. NCTC advises the United States on terrorism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Saleh Ali Saleh Nabhan</span> Member of al-Qaeda

Saleh Ali Saleh Nabhan also known as Abu Yusuf, was an operative of al-Qaeda in Somalia. He was listed on the FBI's third major "wanted" list, the FBI Seeking Information – War on Terrorism list, for his association with multiple attacks in Kenya in 2002, as well as his possible involvement in the 1998 United States embassy bombings, in which over 250 people lost their lives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anwar al-Awlaki</span> American-Yemeni imam and suspected Islamist extremist (1971–2011)

Anwar Nasser Abdulla al-Awlaki was an American-Yemeni lecturer and alleged jihadist who was killed in 2011 in Yemen by a U.S. government drone strike ordered by President Barack Obama. Al-Awlaki became the first U.S. citizen to be targeted and killed by a drone strike from the U.S. government. U.S. government officials have claimed that al-Awlaki was a key organizer for the Islamist militant group al-Qaeda.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John Brennan (CIA officer)</span> Director of the Central Intelligence Agency from 2013 to 2017

John Owen Brennan is a former American intelligence officer who served as the Director of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) from March 2013 to January 2017. He served as chief counterterrorism advisor to U.S. President Barack Obama, with the title Deputy National Security Advisor for Homeland Security and Counterterrorism, and Assistant to the President. Previously, he advised Obama on foreign policy and intelligence issues during the 2008 election campaign and presidential transition.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Counterterrorism Mission Center</span> Central Intelligence Agency unit founded 1986

The U.S. Central Intelligence Agency's Mission Center forCounterterrorism is a division of the CIA's Directorate of Operations, established in 1986. It was renamed during an agency restructuring in 2015 and is distinct from the National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC), which is a separate entity. The most recent publicly known Assistant Director for Counterterrorism Mission Center was Chris Wood who led the organization from 2015 to 2017.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">International counter-terrorism activities of the CIA</span>

After the Central Intelligence Agency lost its role as the coordinator of the entire United States Intelligence Community (IC), special coordinating structures were created by each president to fit his administrative style and the perceived level of threat from terrorists during his term.

The Analysis Corporation (TAC) was the Intelligence Solutions business of Global Defense Technology & Systems, Inc. (GTEC), now Sotera Defense Solutions, a defense contracting company. Based in McLean, Virginia, it is a wholly owned subsidiary of Global Strategies Group Inc., the operating company of GTEC. From its inception in 1990 to its dissolution in 2012, TAC worked on projects in the counterterrorism and national security realm by supporting national watchlisting activities as well as other counterterrorism requirements.

Between 2004 and 2018, the United States government attacked thousands of targets in northwest Pakistan using unmanned aerial vehicles (drones) operated by the United States Air Force under the operational control of the Central Intelligence Agency's Special Activities Division. Most of these attacks were on targets in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas along the Afghan border in northwest Pakistan. These strikes began during the administration of United States President George W. Bush, and increased substantially under his successor Barack Obama. Some in the media referred to the attacks as a "drone war". The George W. Bush administration officially denied the extent of its policy; in May 2013, the Obama administration acknowledged for the first time that four US citizens had been killed in the strikes. In December 2013, the National Assembly of Pakistan unanimously approved a resolution against US drone strikes in Pakistan, calling them a violation of "the charter of the United Nations, international laws and humanitarian norms."

The Camp Chapman attack was a suicide attack by Humam Khalil Abu-Mulal al-Balawi against the Central Intelligence Agency facility inside Forward Operating Base Chapman on December 30, 2009. One of the main tasks of the CIA personnel stationed at the base was to provide intelligence supporting drone attacks in Pakistan. Seven American CIA officers and contractors, an officer of Jordan's intelligence service, and an Afghan working for the CIA were killed when al-Balawi detonated a bomb sewn into a vest he was wearing. Six other American CIA officers were wounded. The bombing was the most lethal attack against the CIA in more than 25 years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Targeted killing</span> Extrajudicial assassination by governments

Targeted killing is a form of assassination carried out by governments outside a judicial procedure or a battlefield.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Killing of Abdulrahman al-Awlaki</span> Death of American teenager in 2011

Abdulrahman Anwar al-Awlaki was a 16-year-old United States citizen who was killed by a U.S. drone strike in Yemen. He was the son of Anwar al-Awlaki.

The United States is widely considered to have one of the most extensive and sophisticated intelligence network of any nation in the world, with organizations including the Central Intelligence Agency and the National Security Agency, amongst others. It has conducted numerous espionage operations against foreign countries, including both allies and rivals. Its operations have included the use of industrial espionage, cyber espionage. and mass surveillance.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Drone strikes in Yemen</span> United States drone strikes in Yemen

United States drone strikes in Yemen started after the September 11 attacks in the United States, when the US military attacked the Islamist militant presence in Yemen, in particular Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula using drone warfare.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Civilian casualties from the United States drone strikes</span> Overview of civilian casualties from U.S. drone strikes

Since the September 11 attacks, the United States has carried out drone strikes in Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Michael D'Andrea</span> Central Intelligence Agency officer

Michael D'Andrea is a retired Central Intelligence Agency officer who played an instrumental role in American counterterrorism efforts during the War on Terror. He served nine years as director of Counterterrorism Center (CTC), and held a major role in the manhunt for Osama bin Laden. His 42-year career has been described as among the most consequential in the recent history of the CIA, and he has been called the most lethal leader in the U.S. government for his tenure. He is widely credited with revolutionizing the CIA's terrorist-hunting efforts, and vastly expanding the program of targeted killings by drone strike used heavily against Al-Qaeda. "If he was a combatant commander, he would have been sitting in the gallery for the State of the Union, he would have had all the accolades, and then some, that David Petraeus ever had," said one former senior CIA official. "He ran that war."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Killing of Ayman al-Zawahiri</span> 2022 U.S. drone strike on the leader of al-Qaeda

On 31 July 2022, Ayman al-Zawahiri, the leader of the Salafi jihadist group al-Qaeda, was killed by a United States drone strike in Kabul, Afghanistan.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 Miller, Greg (23 October 2012). "Plan for hunting terrorists signals U.S. intends to keep adding names to kill lists". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 26 October 2012.
  2. 1 2 3 4 DeYoung, Karen (24 October 2012). "A CIA veteran transforms U.S. counterterrorism policy". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 4 November 2012.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Van Auken, Bill (25 October 2012). "Obama institutionalizes state assassinations". World Socialist Web Site. Archived from the original on 27 October 2012.
  4. ↑ Warrick, Joby (25 November 2008). "Brennan Withdraws From Consideration for Administration Post". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 11 February 2015.
  5. ↑ Worth, Robert; Mazzetti, Mark; Shane, Scott (5 February 2013). "Drone Strikes' Dangers to Get Rare Moment in Public Eye". The New York Times. Retrieved 5 February 2013.
  6. 1 2 Whitlock, Craig (25 October 2012). "Remote U.S. base at core of secret operations". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on 15 December 2012.
  7. 1 2 Shane, Scott; Becker, Jo (29 May 2012). "Secret 'Kill List' Proves a Test of Obama's Principles and Will". The New York Times. Archived from the original on 21 October 2012.
  8. ↑ Van Auken, Bill (26 October 2012). "Institutionalized state assassinations and the November 6 election". World Socialist Web Site. Archived from the original on 29 October 2012.
  9. 1 2 Savage, Charlie; Shane, Scott (5 February 2013). "Memo Cites Legal Basis for Killing U.S. Citizens in Al Qaeda". The New York Times. Retrieved 5 February 2013.
  10. ↑ Brennan, John O. (30 April 2012). "The Efficacy and Ethics of U.S. Counterterrorism Strategy". The Wilson Center. Archived from the original on 25 October 2012.
  11. 1 2 Chesney, Robert (24 October 2012). "Kill Lists, the Disposition Matrix, and the Permanent War: Thoughts on the Post Article". lawfareblog.com. Archived from the original on 27 October 2012.
  12. ↑ Johnston, Patrick B.; Sarbahi, Anoop (25 February 2012). "The Impact of U.S. Drone Strikes on Terrorism in Pakistan" (PDF). RAND Corporation.
  13. ↑ "Under Donald Trump, drone strikes far exceed Obama's numbers - Chicago Sun-Times". 8 May 2019.
  14. ↑ "Trump revokes Obama rule on reporting drone strike deaths - BBC News". BBC News. 7 March 2019.
  15. 1 2 3 Higgins, Sean (24 October 2012). "ACLU slams White House for "disposition matrix" i.e., terrorist hit list". The Washington Examiner. Archived from the original on 29 October 2013.
  16. 1 2 Greenwald, Glenn (24 October 2012). "Obama moves to make the War on Terror permanent". The Guardian. London. Archived from the original on 27 October 2012.
  17. ↑ Giraldi, Philip (8 November 2012). "Kill Lists Will Continue". Antiwar.com . Archived from the original on 10 November 2012.
  18. ↑ The Protocols for Death, by Philip Giraldi, Antiwar.com, 6 December 2012
  19. ↑ Hirsch, Michael (7 February 2013). "John Brennan's Love-Hate Relationship With Drones". National Journal. Archived from the original on 11 February 2013. Retrieved 16 February 2013.
  20. ↑ "Malik Jalal - FAQs - 38 Degrees". 18 April 2016. Retrieved 12 February 2018.
  21. ↑ "Meet Malik Jalal, Who is on the Drone Kill List". Common Dreams. Retrieved 12 February 2018.
  22. ↑ Kishore, Joseph (31 October 2012). "American democracy and the "disposition matrix"". World Socialist Web Site. Archived from the original on 3 November 2012.
  23. ↑ Kuntzman, Gersh (14 April 2016). "President Obama should apologize when he visits atomic bomb site in Hiroshima – and while he's at it, he should swear off drone strikes". nydailynews.com. Retrieved 15 May 2019.
  24. 1 2 Volkhonsky, Boris (26 October 2012). "Barack Obama widens the practice of extrajudicial killings". Voice of Russia. Archived from the original on 30 October 2012. Retrieved 27 October 2012.
  25. ↑ Drone strikes threaten 50 years of international law, says UN rapporteur, Owen Bowcott, The Guardian , 21 June 2012
  26. ↑ Drone strikes by US may violate international law, says UN . The Guardian. 18 October 2013.
  27. ↑ UN report calls for independent investigations of drone attacks. The Guardian. 18 October 2013.
  28. ↑ Hudson, John (24 October 2012). "How the White House 'Kill List' Became the White House 'Disposition Matrix'". The Atlantic Wire. Archived from the original on 27 October 2012.
  29. ↑ Helfrich, Jesse (13 February 2013). "No court for drone oversight, says GOP" . Retrieved 12 February 2018.
  30. ↑ Mali, Meghashyam (24 March 2013). "White House move to let Pentagon take over CIA armed drones sparks concern" . Retrieved 12 February 2018.
  31. ↑ Hubbard, Ben (10 March 2017). "Reporting From Syria, an American With a Point of View and a Message". The New York Times. Retrieved 12 June 2019.
  32. ↑ Stafford Smith, Clive (19 December 2016). "Reporting from the ground in times of war". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 12 June 2019.
  33. ↑ Ward, Clarissa (14 March 2016). "#UndercoverInSyria: Clarissa Ward reports from behind rebel lines". CNN. Archived from the original on 15 March 2016. Retrieved 12 June 2019.
  34. ↑ "How an American Citizen Ended Up on the US Kill List | Rolling Stone - YouTube". YouTube . 19 July 2018.
  35. ↑ Khan, Zain (9 July 2018). "Bilal Abdul Kareem : Who Escaped 5 US Drone Strike and Is on a US Kill List". The Siasat Daily . Retrieved 2 November 2018.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.