James Winchester | |
---|---|
Justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court | |
Assumed office January 4, 2000 | |
Appointed by | Frank Keating |
Preceded by | Alma Wilson |
Personal details | |
Born | Clinton,Oklahoma,U.S. | March 23,1952
Spouse | Susan Winchester |
Education | University of Oklahoma (BA) Oklahoma City University (JD) |
James R. Winchester (born March 23,1952) [1] is an American lawyer and judge who has served as on the Oklahoma Supreme Court for district 5 since 2000. He had two-year terms as chief justice of the Supreme Court beginning in 2007 and 2017.
Winchester was born in Clinton,Oklahoma,in 1952.
He received his Bachelor of Arts from the University of Oklahoma in 1974 and his Juris Doctor from the Oklahoma City University School of Law in 1977. [2]
Winchester practiced law in Weatherford,Oklahoma,and Hinton,Oklahoma,before being named associate district judge for Caddo County,Oklahoma,in January 1983. In December 1983,at age 30,Winchester became one of the youngest district judges in the state when he was appointed as district judge for the Sixth Judicial District of Oklahoma. During his tenure as a district judge,he tried more than 200 jury trials,ranging from fraud to first-degree murder death-penalty cases. [3]
Winchester was named Outstanding State Trial Court Judge by the Oklahoma Trial Lawyers Association in 1986 and was an executive board member of the Oklahoma Judicial Conference from 1992 to 1996. He was also president of the Oklahoma Judicial Conference in 1995. From August 1997 to January 2000,he was a United States administrative law judge with the U.S. Social Security Administration. [2] While in these positions,he established the second in-state program for Children Coping With Divorce to assist children during difficult times. [3]
The governor of Oklahoma,Frank Keating,appointed Winchester to the Oklahoma Supreme Court on January 4,2000,replacing the late justice,Alma Wilson,who had died during the previous year. He was named to District 5,which includes Carter,Cleveland,Garvin,Grady,Jefferson,Love,McClain and Stephens counties. [2] In 2007,the eight other justices of the Oklahoma Supreme Court elected him to serve a two-year term as chief justice of Oklahoma.
Winchester was last re-elected to the same position in November 2016 by a large margin. According to the Norman Transcript,the tally was:
Yes | 798,227 | 61.3% |
No | 503,437 | 38.7% [4] |
In November 2022,Oklahomans voted to retain him for another six years with more than 60% of the vote. [5]
Justice Winchester has angered some in the Oklahoma political establishment by his judgements on certain issues:
During Winchester's term as chief justice,the court issued a new rule that restricted public internet access to Supreme Court documents. The only exception was to allow access to dockets,and parties to the case were required to redact personal information before the document could be released. The justification was to balance the right of privacy of individuals against the right of public access. Winchester and four associate justices signed the order on March 11,2008. The new rule was to take effect June 10,2008. [6]
Justice Yvonne Kauger wrote a separate opinion that partly concurred and partly dissented from the majority. She said that she disagreed with "... the instantaneous restriction of public access to current public court documents on line". [6] In addition,she wrote:
The court made this decision with input only from the court clerks. Others directly affected by the decision - the bar,the bench,the Legislature,the public - were not consulted. . . . [A]s a result of this order,not only is the court taking a giant,30-year leap backwards to a time when the personal computer was nonexistent,the public is now paying for access to a system which is made inaccessible by the order. [6]
A post on the same blog from a reader named only as Don,said,"...Oklahoma Supreme Court has withdrawn its order restricting public access to court records." The post further explained that lawyers,free-speech advocates,law enforcement,court clerks,journalists and companies that perform background checks had all complained that the rules were too far-reaching. The office of the Chief Justice publicly announced that it was withdrawing the order to allow time for further study and consideration of the issue. [6]
John M. Wylie of the Oologah Lake Leader was named as the March 2008 editorial winner by the Oklahoma Press Association (OPA) for a highly critical piece he wrote,even citing two provisions of the Oklahoma Constitution that Winchester and his colleagues allegedly violated in attempting to impose the order. He stated that these justices should be impeached if they did not reverse course and vacate the order. OPA posted the rebuke online for wider distribution. [7]
In a 2015 case, Prescott v. Oklahoma Capitol Preservation Commission ,Winchester sided with a majority of the court,when the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) had sued to force the removal of a monument to the Ten Commandments from the Oklahoma Capitol building. The defense team,whose aim was to restore the monument to the capitol grounds,was led by E. Scott Pruitt,then the attorney general of the State of Oklahoma,assisted by two other attorneys from his office. [lower-alpha 1] The court majority ruled that the monument must be removed promptly because it violated Article 2,Section 5,of the Oklahoma Constitution,which says that (state) property cannot be used to promote a "church denomination or system of religion". Seven justices supported the plaintiff (ACLU) while two supported the state's position that there was no violation. [lower-alpha 2] Governor Mary Fallin claimed the court's ruling was erroneous and announced that she would not allow the removal while the state appealed the decision. [8] Despite Fallin's statement,the Ten Commandments was removed from the capitol building in early October 2016. [9]
After the verdict was announced,opposition groups that wanted the monument restored on the Capitol grounds announced their intention to recall the justices at the November 2016 general election. However,all nine justices won by wide margins,retaining their positions.
This case directly led to State Question 790,"Religion and the State" on the November 2016 ballot. The proposition was to repeal Article 2,Section 5 of the Oklahoma Constitution. [10] The question was soundly defeated in the election. [lower-alpha 3]
In 2018,the former Oklahoma attorney general,Michael Hunter,sued Johnson &Johnson Co. (J &J),a major pharmaceutical manufacturer,for its role in contributing to over 2,100 deaths from opioid-related overdoses between 2011 and 2015. Hunter requested $17.2 billion in damages. The initial trial apparently found J&J guilty,but reduced the damage award to $465 million. By 2022,the state had appealed the case to OSC,requesting an award of $9.3 billion,which it had intended to use in fighting the opioid crisis. [11] ]
In 2022,Justice Winchester wrote the majority opinion that overruled a $465 million ruling against Johnson &Johnson Co.,saying that the lower court making the ruling had misinterpreted Oklahoma's public nuisance law. According to the OSC opinion,"The court has allowed public nuisance claims to address discrete,localized problems,not policy problems,”he wrote. “J&J had no control of its products through the multiple levels of distribution,including after it sold the opioids to distributors and wholesalers,which were then disbursed to pharmacies,hospitals,and physicians’offices,and then prescribed by doctors to patients. The OSC ruling also said J&J had no control over how patients used the drugs,once the drugs had been given to them.” [11]
Winchester currently[ when? ] lives in Chickasha,Oklahoma,with his wife,the former state representative Susan Winchester,and their son. [3]
The Oregon Supreme Court (OSC) is the highest state court in the U.S. state of Oregon. The only court that may reverse or modify a decision of the Oregon Supreme Court is the Supreme Court of the United States. The OSC holds court at the Oregon Supreme Court Building in Salem, Oregon, near the capitol building on State Street. The building was finished in 1914 and also houses the state's law library, while the courtroom is also used by the Oregon Court of Appeals.
Van Orden v. Perry, 545 U.S. 677 (2005), is a United States Supreme Court case involving whether a display of the Ten Commandments on a monument given to the government at the Texas State Capitol in Austin violated the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment.
Mary Fallin is an American politician who served as the 27th governor of Oklahoma from 2011 to 2019. A member of the Republican Party, she was elected in 2010 and reelected in 2014. She is the first and so far only woman to be elected governor of Oklahoma. She was the first woman to represent Oklahoma in Congress since Alice Mary Robertson left office in 1923.
The Supreme Court of Oklahoma is a court of appeal for non-criminal cases, one of the two highest judicial bodies in the U.S. state of Oklahoma, and leads the judiciary of Oklahoma, the judicial branch of the government of Oklahoma.
Steven W. Taylor is a former Chief Justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court. He is a former mayor of McAlester, Oklahoma. As a state district court judge, Taylor was the presiding judge in the state trial of the Oklahoma City bombing.
Glassroth v. Moore, 335 F.3d 1282, and its companion case Maddox and Howard v. Moore, 229 F. Supp. 2d 1290, is a decision from the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit that held a 2+1⁄2 ton granite monument of the Ten Commandments placed in the rotunda of the Heflin-Torbert Judicial Building in Montgomery, Alabama by then-Alabama Supreme Court Chief Justice Roy Moore was a violation of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment.
Yvonne Kauger is an associate justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court, and was appointed to the Court's District 4 seat by Governor George Nigh in 1984, and served as chief justice from 1997 to 1998. She was born in New Cordell, Oklahoma, and grew up in Colony, Oklahoma, and is an honorary member of the Cheyenne and Arapaho Tribes of Oklahoma. Kauger founded the Gallery of the Plains Indian in Colony, Oklahoma and is also the co-founder of the Red Earth organization. Kauger also serves as Symposium Coordinator of the Sovereignty Symposium. Kauger was inducted into the Oklahoma Women's Hall of Fame in 2001.
Tom Colbert is a former Associate Justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court. He was appointed to the Court's District 6 seat in 2004, by Governor Brad Henry, becoming the first African-American to serve on the court. On January 4, 2013, he was sworn in as Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and served In that post until January 2015. After completing his two-year term as Chief Justice, he resumed his previous position on the court as Associate Justice representing the 6th Judicial District. On January 19, 2021, Colbert’s retirement was announced by the Oklahoma Supreme Court, effective February 1 of the same year.
Roy Stewart Moore is an American politician, lawyer, and jurist who served as chief justice of the Supreme Court of Alabama from 2001 to 2003 and again from 2013 to 2017, each time being removed from office for judicial misconduct by the Alabama Court of the Judiciary. He was the Republican Party nominee in the 2017 U.S. Senate special election in Alabama to fill the seat vacated by Jeff Sessions, but was accused by several women of sexually assaulting them while they were underage and lost to Democratic candidate Doug Jones. Moore ran for the same Senate seat again in 2020 and lost the Republican primary.
The Oklahoma Court System is the judicial system for the U.S. State of Oklahoma. Based in Oklahoma City, the court system is a unified state court system that functions under the Chief Justice of Oklahoma who is its administrator-in-chief.
Rudolph Hargrave served as a justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court from 1978 until his retirement on December 31, 2010. Before being elevated to the highest court, he was a superior court and district judge for Seminole County from 1969 to 1978.
Ralph B. Hodges was born and raised in Anadarko, Oklahoma. He earned his J. D. degree from the University of Oklahoma. After serving as Bryan County Attorney and as District Judge, Hodges was appointed to the Oklahoma Supreme Court by Governor Henry Bellmon on April 19, 1965, as Associate Justice, where he would serve until his retirement from the Court in 2004. During that time he also served as Chief Justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court from 1977 to 1978 and 1993–1994.
Michael J. Hunter is an American politician from the state of Oklahoma. Hunter served as the Secretary of State of Oklahoma from 1999 to 2002, having been appointed by Governor of Oklahoma Frank Keating. On November 1, 2016, he was appointed to the same post by Governor Mary Fallin. He also served as Special Counsel to the Governor. On February 20, 2017, Hunter was appointed Attorney General of Oklahoma to replace Scott Pruitt who resigned to become the Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency. On November 8, 2018, Hunter won election as Attorney General.
James Michael Ritze is an American politician from the state of Oklahoma United States. A Republican, Ritze served as a member of the Oklahoma House of Representatives, representing the 80th district, which includes parts of Tulsa and Wagoner counties.
Prescott v. Oklahoma Capitol Preservation Commission, 2015 OK 54, 373 P.3d 1032, was a landmark case by the Oklahoma Supreme Court in which the Court found the placement of a Ten Commandments Monument at the Oklahoma State Capitol was unconstitutional.
Oklahoma Ballot State Question 790 was a ballot question in Oklahoma during the 2016 Elections that would have removed the Blaine Amendment from the Oklahoma State Constitution. Question 790 was defeated.
The Ten Commandments Monument, authorized by the Oklahoma legislature and approved by the governor in 2009, was installed on the grounds of the Oklahoma State Capitol, in Oklahoma City, in 2012. The mere concept engendered years of political controversy, court suits based on freedom of religion issues, destruction in 2014 by a man who drove his car into it, replacement in the same location, and even attempts to remove Supreme Court justices who ruled in 2014 that the monument must be removed to another site. After Governor Mary Fallin, key legislators, and the justices agreed on a substitute site, the monument was removed from the capitol grounds in 2015.
Patrick Robert Wyrick is a United States district judge of the United States District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma and a former Associate Justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court.
Baphomet is a bronze statue commissioned by the Satanic Temple depicting Baphomet, a winged, goat-headed, humanoid symbol of the occult. First unveiled in Detroit in 2015, the statue stands 8.5 feet (2.6 m) tall, weighing over 3,000 lb (1,400 kg), and features a prominent pentagram as well as two smiling youths gazing up at the seated central figure. Petitions to display Baphomet on public grounds have resulted in arguments concerning religious equality. Production of the statue, and its initial notoriety, is featured in the documentary Hail Satan?.
Thad H. Balkman is an American politician, lawyer and judge.