Just Stop Oil M25 blockade case

Last updated

R v Hallam
Roger Hallam, 2020 (cropped).jpg
Roger Hallam in 2020
Court Southwark Crown Court
Full case name Rex v Hallam and others
Decided18 July 2024
Court membership
Judge sittingChristopher Hehir

R v Hallam was a 2024 British court case involving five activists from the climate protest group Just Stop Oil. The activists were convicted of conspiracy to cause public nuisance after they organised protests to block the M25 motorway in November 2022. Roger Hallam, co-founder of Just Stop Oil and Extinction Rebellion, was sentenced to five years' imprisonment, while his fellow activists Daniel Shaw, Louise Lancaster, Lucia Whittaker De Abreu and Cressida Gethin were sentenced to four years each. The activists have been collectively referred to as the "Whole Truth Five" in Just Stop Oil's social media posts. [1]

Contents

The severity of the sentences sparked widespread criticism from various quarters. They are thought to be the longest sentences ever given in the UK for peaceful protest. Among the critics are UN Human Rights Commissioner Volker Türk, the United Nations special rapporteur for environmental defenders Michel Forst, Amnesty International and former Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams.

Background

Just Stop Oil is a British environmental activist group focused on the issue of human-caused climate change. It was founded in February 2022 with the primary objective of convincing the UK government to stop licensing new oil and gas projects. [2] Just Stop Oil has often received criticism for using illegal and disruptive tactics in its protests, such as vandalism and traffic obstruction, although the group is committed to non-violence. [2] [3]

M25 protests

On 7 November 2022 dozens of Just Stop Oil activists climbed onto gantries over London's orbital motorway, the M25. [4] This resulted in police stopping the traffic, causing gridlock. The protests continued for four consecutive days, ending on 11 November, and involved 45 activists in total. [5] The disruption led to alleged economic losses of £765,000 and cost the Metropolitan Police more than £1.1 million. It caused over 50,000 hours of vehicle delay, affecting at least 700,000 vehicles. [5] [6]

Trial

The trial was held at Southwark Crown Court under Judge Christopher Hehir and lasted for two and a half weeks. [7] All the defendants represented themselves during the trial, although three instructed counsel to speak on their behalf during mitigation. [8]

The court heard that Roger Hallam, Daniel Shaw, Louise Lancaster, Lucia Whittaker De Abreu and Cressida Gethin had spoken on a Zoom call organised to recruit potential volunteers for the M25 protest. [9]

On the second day of defence evidence, eleven people were arrested for alleged contempt of court after protesting outside the court holding signs saying "jurors have the right to hear the whole truth". By the final day there were more than 80 protestors outside the courtroom. [7] The court dropped its proceedings against those arrested. [5]

Over the course of the trial, the defendants repeatedly caused disruption by refusing to leave the witness stand and speaking out of turn. [7] By the end of the trial, four of the five defendants had been remanded to custody after police were called to court seven times to make arrests. [9] As punishment, Judge Hehir reduced the time given to each defendant from one hour to twenty minutes. [10] Furthermore, he prohibited them from using climate crisis as a defence for their actions. [11]

On 11 July, the jury unanimously found the defendants guilty of conspiracy to cause public nuisance under the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 and the Criminal Law Act 1977. [5] Seven days later, Judge Hehir sentenced Hallam to five years' imprisonment, while co-defendants Shaw, Lancaster, Whittaker De Abreu and Gethin were sentenced to four years apiece. [10] [12] These are thought to be the longest sentences ever given in the UK for peaceful protest. [10] [13] The previous longest sentences were received by Just Stop Oil activists Morgan Trowland and Marcus Decker, who were jailed for three years and two years and seven months, respectively, for scaling the Queen Elizabeth II Bridge on the Dartford Crossing in October 2022. [5]

Reactions

UN Human Rights Commissioner Volker Türk described the sentences as "deeply troubling". [14] Michel Forst, the United Nations special rapporteur for environmental defenders, attended two days of the trial and was critical of the proceedings, stating that such severe sentences for non-violent protest are "not acceptable in a democracy". [15] Amnesty International UK's human rights adviser, Tom Southerden, described the sentences as "draconian" and urged the government to repeal the sections of the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 that legislate the offence of public nuisance used against the defendants. [15] [16]

Prominent figures, including TV presenter and environmentalist Chris Packham, TV chef Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall, entrepreneur Dale Vince, Green Party peer Jenny Jones, Green Party MP Siân Berry and Labour Party MP Clive Lewis spoke out against the sentencing. [15] [17] Over 1200 artists, athletes and academics signed a letter to the Attorney General, calling for an urgent meeting to discuss "the jailing of truth tellers and their silencing in court". Among the signatories were former Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams, musicians Chris Martin and Annie Lennox, and author Philip Pullman. A spokesman for the Attorney General's office stated that "the Attorney General has no power to intervene in these cases". [18]

In contrast, Andrew Tettenborn, a professor of law at Swansea University, spoke out in favour of the sentencing in an article in The Spectator. [19]

The UK government refused to comment on the sentencing, with a spokesman for the prime minister stating that "it is not for politicians to intervene" in matters of judgement and sentencing. [13] [15]

Appeal

On 13 August 2024 lawyers acting on behalf of the five activists announced they intended to appeal the ruling, arguing that the sentences were excessive. [20]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tommy Robinson</span> British far-right activist (born 1982)

Stephen Christopher Yaxley-Lennon, better known as Tommy Robinson, is a British anti-Islam campaigner and one of the UK's most prominent far-right activists. Since 28 October 2024, he has been serving an 18-month prison sentence for contempt of court.

The United Arab Emirates Five are five activists who were arrested in April 2011 on charges of breaking United Arab Emirates law of defamation by insulting heads of state, namely UAE president Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan, vice president Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, and Abu Dhabi crown prince Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, through running an website that expressed anti-government views.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bahrain Thirteen</span> Bahraini opposition

The Bahrain Thirteen are thirteen Bahraini opposition leaders, rights activists, bloggers and Shia clerics arrested between 17 March and 9 April 2011 in connection with their role in the national uprising. In June 2011, they were tried by a special military court, the National Safety Court, and convicted of "setting up terror groups to topple the royal regime and change the constitution"; they received sentences ranging from two years to life in prison. A military appeal court upheld the sentences in September. The trial was "one of the most prominent" before the National Safety Court. A retrial in a civilian court was held in April 2012 but the accused were not released from prison. The sentences were upheld again on 4 September 2012. On 7 January 2013, the defendants lost their last chance of appeal when the Court of Cassation, Bahrain's top court upheld the sentences.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Extinction Rebellion</span> Environmental pressure group

Extinction Rebellion is a UK-founded global environmental movement, with the stated aim of using nonviolent civil disobedience to compel government action to avoid tipping points in the climate system, biodiversity loss, and the risk of social and ecological collapse. Extinction Rebellion was established in Stroud in May 2018 by Gail Bradbrook, Simon Bramwell, Roger Hallam, Stuart Basden, along with six other co-founders from the campaign group Rising Up!

The Stansted 15 are a group of non-violent human rights activists who took action to stop a deportation flight leaving from Stansted Airport, UK on 28 March 2017. The plane, a Titan Airways Boeing 767 was chartered by the UK Home Office to deport 60 migrants to Ghana, Nigeria and Sierra Leone.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Roger Hallam (activist)</span> British environmental activist and co-founder of Extinction Rebellion

Julian Roger Hallam is an environmental activist who co-founded Extinction Rebellion, Just Stop Oil, Insulate Britain, the cooperative federation organisation Radical Routes, and the political party Burning Pink. In April 2024, Hallam was given a suspended two year sentence for attempting to block Heathrow Airport with drones. In July 2024, Hallam was convicted of conspiracy to cause a public nuisance for organising protests to block the M25 motorway two years prior, for which he was sentenced to five years' imprisonment.

Extinction Rebellion (XR), a 2018 UK-founded environmental movement, has since spread to the rest of Europe, the United States, and other countries, forming an international "non-violent civil disobedience" movement through mass protest. XR carries out demonstrations to highlight governments' inaction on climate change. Since 2018, Extinction Rebellion has taken a variety of actions in Europe, the US, and elsewhere in the world, to urge political and economic forces to take action amid the climate crisis. Although, their non-violent disobedience protests are an effort to generate attention around environmental issues, XR activists have become known for civil disobedience and disruptive tactics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Animal Rising</span> Activist group

Animal Rising is a British animal activist movement with the stated aim of compelling social change towards animal rights and a plant-based food system. They justify their actions with the impact of animal agriculture on climate change, species extinction and ecosystem breakdown.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022</span> Act of the United Kingdom Parliament

The Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 is an act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom that was introduced by the Home Office and the Ministry of Justice. It gives more power to the police, criminal justice, and sentencing legislation, and it encompasses restrictions on "unacceptable" protests, crimes against children, and sentencing limits. It was passed by the Houses of Parliament on 26 April 2022 and received Royal Assent on 28 April 2022.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Impossible Rebellion</span> 2021 climate change protests

Impossible Rebellion was a series of nonviolent climate change protests in the United Kingdom organised by Extinction Rebellion (XR), from 23 August 2021 to 4 September 2021. The protests particularly targeted the City of London to raise awareness of the role of the financial sector in climate change. Protesters during the Impossible Rebellion demanded that the UK government cease new investments in the fossil fuel industry. XR also demand that the government declare a climate emergency, reach net zero carbon emissions by 2025 and create a citizens' assembly on climate change.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Insulate Britain protests</span> 2021 climate change protests in Britain

A series of protests by the group Insulate Britain involving traffic obstruction began on 13 September 2021. The group blockaded the M25 and other motorways in the United Kingdom, and roads in London and the Port of Dover.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Just Stop Oil</span> British climate activism group

Just Stop Oil is a British environmental activist group primarily focused on the issue of human-caused climate change. The group aims to convince the British government to commit to ending new fossil fuel licensing and production using civil resistance, nonviolent direct action, traffic obstruction, and vandalism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Violet CoCo</span> Australian climate activist

Deanna Maree "Violet" Coco, usually known as Violet CoCo, is an Australian climate activist who was briefly jailed on remand for blocking the Sydney Harbour Bridge in 2022. She successfully appealed her 15-month jail sentence, with the convictions remaining, in March 2023, after the judge found that her conviction was based on false information from the police about an ambulance being blocked by her protest. She was instead put on a 12 month conditional release order.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Last Generation (climate movement)</span> German environmental organization

The Last Generation is a group of climate change activists using forms of direct action which is mostly active in Germany, Italy and Poland. It describes itself as an "alliance" and was formed in 2021 from participants in the Hungerstreik der letzten Generation. The term was chosen because they considered themselves to be the last generation before tipping points in the earth's climate system would be reached. The Austria section of Last Generation announced in August 2024 that it would end its activities under that name.

The Climate Emergency Fund (CEF) is a Los Angeles-based nonprofit organization that supports climate change activist groups involved in civil disobedience. It was founded in 2019 by filmmaker Rory Kennedy, a member of the prominent Kennedy family, and Getty family heiress Aileen Getty.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard Hermer, Baron Hermer</span> British barrister life peer (born 1968)

Richard Simon Hermer, Baron Hermer, is a British barrister and life peer who has served as Attorney General for England and Wales and Advocate General for Northern Ireland since July 2024.

Phoebe Plummer is a British climate activist. First inspired by a United Nations report published by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, they joined Just Stop Oil in August 2022 and were arrested three times in their first week. An October 2022 protest in which they and Anna Holland threw tomato soup at a Vincent van Gogh painting at London's National Gallery caused worldwide outrage and £10,000 worth of damage to the frame but empowered activists to carry out similar actions. Plummer was sentenced the month after for blocking the M25 motorway. The following November, Holland and other activists caused tailbacks on multiple roads in West London with a slow march protest, for which they faced the first jury trial under section 7 of the Public Order Act 2023.

Just Stop Oil <i>Sunflowers</i> protest 2022 protest

On 14 October 2022, Phoebe Plummer and Anna Holland threw two tins of Heinz Cream of Tomato Soup at a Sunflowers painting by Vincent van Gogh at the National Gallery in London, glued themselves to the wall, and asked the crowd whether they were more concerned by the protest or the effects of climate change on the planet. They had been inspired to do so by the decrease in media coverage of the organisation's activism and selected that painting due to its vulnerability. Their act earned the pair worldwide censure and queerphobic abuse and caused £10,000 worth of damage to the picture's frame but inspired several subsequent activists to throw other foodstuffs at other paintings. The pair were convicted of criminal damage in July 2024 by Christopher Hehir, who sentenced Plummer to 24 months in prison and Holland to 20 months in September 2024 to criticism from George Monbiot and Nadya Tolokonnikova.

Christopher Joseph Hehir is a British judge. Called to the bar in 1990, he later sat as a judge at Southwark Crown Court and a London Nightingale Court. In July 2024, he convicted Roger Hallam to five years in prison and four other protesters to four years each for their parts in the Just Stop Oil M25 blockade case, prompting criticism from over 1,200 artists, athletes, and academics. He then sentenced Phoebe Plummer and Anna Holland to 24 and 20 months over their parts in the Just Stop Oil Sunflowers protest in spite of an open letter imploring him otherwise, prompting various writers to compare their crimes to those committed by those he had previously given suspended sentences to.

Anna Holland is a British climate activist. Born in northwest England, they joined Just Stop Oil in May 2022 and met Phoebe Plummer at a Trafalgar Square roadblock that October. Later that month, the pair threw soup at a painting of Sunflowers by Vincent van Gogh, prompting worldwide outrage and earning the pair queerphobic abuse. The reaction from their family prompted Holland to retreat from frontline activism. In September 2024, Christopher Hehir sentenced Holland to 20 months in prison for their part in the act, prompting criticism.

References

  1. "Five 'fanatic' Just Stop Oil protesters jailed for plot to block M25". Sky News. 18 July 2024.
  2. 1 2 "Just Stop Oil website".
  3. Gayle, Damien (1 April 2022). "Inside Just Stop Oil, the youth climate group blocking UK refineries". The Guardian. Archived from the original on 17 October 2022. Retrieved 18 August 2024.
  4. "Just Stop Oil: Dozens of activists arrested over M25 protest". BBC News. 7 November 2022.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 Stedman, Harry (18 July 2024). "Five Just Stop Oil protesters jailed for conspiracy to block M25". The Independent. Retrieved 18 August 2024.
  6. Pilgrim, Tom (13 August 2024). "Just Stop Oil activists in bid to appeal jail terms for conspiracy to block M25". Evening Standard.
  7. 1 2 3 Gayle, Damien (11 July 2024). "Just Stop Oil activists found guilty of conspiring to block M25 traffic". The Guardian.
  8. Siddique, Haroon (19 July 2024). "Just Stop Oil jail terms raise questions over harsh treatment of protesters". The Guardian.
  9. 1 2 Gayle, Damien (12 July 2024). "Contempt, gagging and UN intervention: Inside the UK's wildest climate trial". The Guardian.
  10. 1 2 3 Gayle, Damien (18 July 2024). "Five Just Stop Oil activists receive record sentences for planning to block M25". The Guardian.
  11. Spray, Stuart (18 July 2024). "Just Stop Oil Protestors Receive Harshest Jail Terms Yet in Case that 'May Violate Human Rights Law'". Byline Times .
  12. "Rex v Hallam & ors - sentencing remarks" (PDF).
  13. 1 2 Hymas, Charles; Penna, Dominic (19 July 2024). "Starmer refuses to intervene over lengthy Just Stop Oil prison sentences". The Telegraph.
  14. Speare-Cole, Rebecca (23 July 2024). "Hundreds of celebrities condemn 'injustice' of Just Stop Oil sentences". The Independent.
  15. 1 2 3 4 Gayle, Damien; Horton, Helena; Quinn, Ben (19 July 2024). "'Not acceptable in a democracy': UN expert condemns lengthy Just Stop Oil sentences". The Guardian.
  16. "UK: Lengthy jail sentences for environmental protesters is 'draconian'". Amnesty International. 18 July 2024.
  17. Gayle, Damien; Horton, Helena (19 July 2024). "Celebrities add voice to outcry over severity of Just Stop Oil sentences". The Guardian. Retrieved 19 July 2024.
  18. Bell, Bethan (23 July 2024). "Just Stop Oil sentences condemned by celebrities". BBC News.
  19. Tettenborn, Andrew (19 July 2024). "Just Stop Oil fanatics deserve their lengthy jail terms". The Spectator. Retrieved 24 July 2024.
  20. Bancroft, Holly (13 August 2024). "Just Stop Oil protesters appeal record-breaking sentences for M25 disruption". The Independent.