| Year | Association | Category | Work | Result | Ref. |
|---|
| 1998 | Theatre World Awards | – | High Society | Won | [34] |
| 1998 | Drama Desk Awards | Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical | High Society | Nominated | [35] |
| 2009 | Austin Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Won | [36] |
| 2009 | Boston Society of Film Critics | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | 2nd place | [37] |
| 2009 | Chicago Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Nominated | [37] |
| 2009 | Dallas–Fort Worth Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | 2nd place | [38] |
| 2009 | Detroit Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Nominated | [39] |
| 2009 | Houston Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Won | [40] |
| 2009 | Los Angeles Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | 2nd place | [41] |
| 2009 | National Board of Review | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Won | [42] |
| 2009 | New York Film Critics Circle | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | 3rd place | [43] |
| 2009 | San Diego Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | 2nd place | [44] |
| 2009 | St. Louis Gateway Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Nominated | [45] |
| 2009 | Toronto Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Won | [46] |
| 2009 | Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association | Best Breakthrough Performance | Up in the Air | Nominated | [47] |
| Best Ensemble Cast | Up in the Air | Nominated [a] |
| Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Nominated |
| 2010 | Irish Film & Television Academy | Best International Actress | Up in the Air | Nominated | [48] |
| 2010 | National Society of Film Critics | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Nominated | [49] |
| 2010 | Online Film Critics Society | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Nominated | [50] |
| 2010 | Palm Springs International Film Festival | Rising Star Award | Up in the Air | Won | [51] |
| 2010 | Vancouver Film Critics Circle | Best Supporting Actress | Up in the Air | Nominated | [52] |
| 2010 | Detroit Film Critics Society | Best Ensemble | Scott Pilgrim vs. the World | Nominated [a] | [53] |
| 2014 | Detroit Film Critics Society | Best Ensemble | Into the Woods | Nominated [a] | [54] |
| 2024 | Palm Springs International Film Festival | Directors to Watch | Woman of the Hour | Won | [55] |
| 2024 | Astra Film Awards | Best First Feature | Woman of the Hour | Won | [56] |
| 2024 | San Diego Film Critics Society | Best First Feature (Director) | Woman of the Hour | Nominated | [57] |
| 2024 | St. Louis Film Critics Association | Best First Feature | Woman of the Hour | Nominated | [58] |
| 2024 | Toronto Film Critics Association | Best First Feature | Woman of the Hour | Won | [59] |
| 2024 | Las Vegas Film Critics Society | Breakout Filmmaker of the Year | Woman of the Hour | Nominated | [60] |
| 2024 | Online Film Critics Society | Best Debut Feature | Woman of the Hour | Nominated | [61] |