On February 23,2023,Harris invited Jacqueline Breger,an informed constituent,to testify before Arizona's Joint Senate/House Election Hearing to Strengthen and Increase Confidence in Arizona's 2024 Elections. [2] Ms. Breger testified about counties having alleged backdoor portals in their computer systems,which weakened the integrity of the elections. She further elaborated on allegations of other corruption that resulted in the eventual expulsion of Liz Harris.
QAnon Affiliation
Harris,a real estate agent,[3][4] is a longtime promoter of QAnon conspiracies.[4][5] Harris repeatedly spread QAnon messaging beginning in 2018 and when QAnon message board operator Ron Watkins moved to Arizona in 2021 from Japan to run for Congress in the 2022 midterm election,Watkins listed property owned by Harris as his residential address on his voter registration.[6][7]
In May 2021,Harris claimed in a video on a QAnon affiliated podcast that her efforts were part of "good versus evil" and that efforts in Arizona would lead to revelations of nationwide election fraud.[8] At the time while QAnon community leaders General Micheal Flynn and Jason Sullivan were staging events using the domino brand,every day on her podcast Harris held up a sign with the QAnon brand quote,"May Arizona be the first domino to fall."[8]
In April 2023,after expulsion from the Arizona House for lying during an ethics committee investigation,Harris became an even bigger hero to some in the QAnon online community who touted her expulsion as proof she was right about her conspiracies.[9]Kari Lake,a prominent supporter of Harris,told Steve Bannon on the War Room,“All they’ve done is make her an icon now. She’s going to be an icon. If they think they’ve made her lose power,I think Liz Harris is going to gain power from this move.”[9]
Role Spreading Multiple Conspiracies Following the 2020 Election
In March 2021,Harris's canvassers Steven Steele and Earl Shafer found shredded ballots in a dumpster behind the Maricopa County Election and Tabulation Center and immediately following the incident,Harris,without proof,claimed the ballots had been burned as part of a cover-up conspiracy involving a fire at Supervisor Clint Hickman's farm.[10] As of 2023,Harris and Steele continue to claim that House Speaker Ben Toma,who sought Harris's expulsion from the Legislature,held a bonfire at Toma's home to destroy evidence of his involvement in an unsubtantiated bribery scandal.[10]
In March 2023,Harris invited a woman named Jacqueline Breger to a Joint Legislative Hearing to amplify and promote an outlandish conspiracy that Breger referenced an upcoming book by her boyfriend John Thaler.[11] Thaler,who has an arrest warrant for multiple domestic violence offenses against his ex-wife,made similar claims accusing his ex-wife of participating in a bribery and fraud scheme in multiple failed lawsuits against both his ex-wife and mother-in-law.[12][5][13] Before Harris held the hearing,two judges had already dismissed Thaler's claims ruling they were an "elaborate fiction."[13] A federal court had called it a "delusional and fantastical narrative."[11] Emails subsequently obtained by the Arizona Republic showed that Harris knew the details of the fabricated scandal before inviting Breger to testify and that Harris lied about her knowledge and involvement to State Senate staffers when they sought details of the presentation before the hearing.[11][14]
In September 2023,Harris reported on her social media podcast that legislators were seeking an indictment of Katie Hobbs that week on RICO charges and the rumor quickly escalated to many online viewers believing Hobbs had been indicted.[15]
Attempts to Overturn the 2020 Election
Harris has been a leading proponent of efforts in Arizona to overturn the 2020 election.[16] Harris testified at a public panel put together by a group of legislative associates of Harris,including Kelly Townsend,Sonny Borelli,and Mark Finchem after the then House Speaker Rusty Bowers refused to allow the group a formal session to amplify Harris's claims of widespread election fraud.[17] During that hearing held on November 30,2020,Harris testified she had been conducting a canvass and identified illegitimate voters,asking that legislators exercise their power and pull back the Biden electors.[18]
Harris created a website "Crime of the Century" as part of her efforts to spread and promote disinformation about the 2020 election.[19] As part of the effort,she repeatedly made false claims regarding the results of her canvassing efforts which were touted by the U.S. Department of Justice as a form of voter suppression.[19]
Ethics Allegation for Dishonest Non Disclosure
The surviving family filed a wrongful death lawsuit alleging Harris knew there was black mold in a home that as a real estate agent Harris knew existed when she sold the home to the family which allegedly resulted in the death of a 41 year old mother of two young children.[20]
Post 2020 Controversial Canvass Effort
Harris led a controversial canvassing effort with then House Rep. Kelly Townsend following the 2020 election with multiple inaccuracies that were debunked within minutes following the 2020 election.[21][9] Months after Harris's canvass effort that began in November 2020 was underway,the U.S. Department of Justice issued a formal cease and desist letter alleging the audit effort may amount to voter intimidation.[22][23] Harris did not stop continuing with her canvass effort and months later issued her canvass report of findings which AP reported as "nonsensical."[22][24][25]
2020 and 2022 Campaigns for State Legislature
In 2020,Harris unsuccessfully ran for a seat in the Arizona legislature.[4]
In 2022,Harris campaigned for election to the state House from Arizona's 13th Legislative District,[26] a district covering portions of the Phoenix suburbs,[27] specifically south Chandler,west Gilbert,and Sun Lakes[28] in the East Valley.[29]
In the November 2022 election,Harris (along with Democratic Representative Jennifer Pawlik) was elected to the state House from the two-seat 13th District.[30] Harris defeated fellow Republican Julie Willoughby by 275 votes after an automatic recount,in which Harris had a net gain of five votes,concluded in December 2022.[27][31]
2020 and 2022 Election Denialism
Harris espouses election denialism.[4][26] After Donald Trump lost Arizona in the 2020 presidential election,Harris promoted unsupported claims that the election was "stolen" from Trump. She led a door-to-door canvassing campaign in a bid to find supposed "election fraud" and released a report (possibly debunked by election experts) claiming fraud.[26][32] The Arizona Attorney General's office,then led by Republican attorney general Mark Brnovich,assigned 60 staffers to investigate the 2020 election;after spending 10,000 hours investigating,no evidence of fraud was found.[5] Harris's door-to-door canvassing effort drew scrutiny from the U.S. Justice Department Civil Rights Division on concerns of potential voter intimidation.[32] Harris claimed in a May 2021 video that her efforts were part of "good versus evil" and that efforts in Arizona would lead to revelations of nationwide election fraud.[8]
In September 2022,Harris spoke at a national conspiracist conference hosted by Mike Lindell,a businessman who had urged Trump to declare martial law to remain in power;Lindell asserted that the summit would be "one of the most important events in history."[26] At the event,Harris promoted claims of election fraud,and claimed that her allies were being persecuted.[26]
On April 24,2023,Harris held an election fraud seminar in Chandler,Arizona with indicted Colorado Mesa County Recorder Tina Peters,who had reportedly been an ally of Harris for years pushing unfounded conspiracies.[33]
Arizona Legislative career
After her election,Harris baselessly claimed that the 2022 Arizona elections,in which Republicans lost top statewide races,was marred by fraud. She threatened to refuse to cast any vote in the House until the election was redone.[29][34][26]
Upon taking office in January 2023,she introduced legislation that would ban both mail-in voting and in-person early voting,and make it easier to challenge election results in court.[35]
Although a first-term representative,Harris's vote was important to the Republicans' one-vote majority in the House.[36] (Republicans hold 31 seats,and Democrats 29 seats.)[35] In February 2023,Harris was the sole Republican to vote against a major Republican budget package,defeating the measure.[37]
2023 hearing
In February 2023,Harris invited Jacqueline Breger,a Scottsdale insurance agent,to testify before a joint hearing of Republican-controlled House and Senate elections committees.[12] In her 41-minute presentation,[13] Breger claimed that Governor Katie Hobbs,several members of the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors,a dozen Maricopa County Superior Court judges,and the mayor of Mesa had all taken bribes from the Sinaloa Cartel through a housing deed scam as part of a vast money laundering,racketeering,and election fraud scheme.[5] Breger also claimed that the LDS Church was implicated in the supposed conspiracy.[12][13] Breger offered no evidence to support her baseless claims.[12][13][5] In her testimony,Breger relied on an upcoming book by her boyfriend John Thaler,who made similar claims in multiple failed lawsuits against his ex-wife and mother-in-law.[12][5][13] Before the hearing,two judges had dismissed Thaler's claims as an elaborate fiction;[13] a federal court had called it a "delusional and fantastical narrative."[5] Emails subsequently obtained by the Arizona Republic showed that Harris knew about the details of the fake scandal before inviting Breger to testify,and that Harris did not disclose her knowledge to state Senate staffers who sought details of the presentation.[13]
While some Republicans in the legislature (such as Wendy Rogers and Rachel Jones) praised Breger,[5] other Arizona Republican legislators,even some of whom had for years entertained unsubstantiated claims of election fraud,disavowed the allegations,[32][38] which had become increasingly bizarre over time.[5] After the hearing,House Speaker Ben Toma and Senate President Warren Petersen criticized Harris's actions as "irresponsible" and "disgraceful."[32]
Five days after the hearing,[13] Harris distanced herself from Breger's and Thaler's claims,conceding that the presentation "was not sufficient to substantiate these extraordinary claims," but later resumed amplifying the claims on her social media.[13][12] Democratic Representative Stephanie Stahl Hamilton filed a complaint against Harris with the House Ethics Committee,saying that Harris had made Arizona a "national joke";Harris asserted that she was constitutionally obligated to allow the testimony.[12]
Expulsion from Arizona House seat
On April 12,2023,Harris was expelled from the legislature by a 46–13 vote for damaging "the integrity of the House," for lying to colleagues during a public hearing of the Ethics Committee.[39][40][12][41][42] After Harris was expelled,one of her canvassers Steve Steele sought her vacant position [43]
Steele,along with Harris and fellow canvasser Earl Shafer who found shredded ballots in a dumpster behind the election center claimed along with Harris,without proof,that the ballots had been burned as part of a cover-up conspiracy involving a fire at Supervisor Clint Hickman's farm. Harris and Steele continue to claim that House leader Toma,who sought Harris's expulsion. had a bonfire at his home burning evidence of his involvement in the conspiracy as part of an alleged cover-up.[43]
Although Harris claimed she did not know prior to the hearing in April 2023 that Breger was going to publicly impugn the character of fellow legislators,former AG's office attorney Jennifer Wright claimed Harris had lunch with her months earlier in January 2023 and at that time Harris discussed the alleged fraudulent deed scheme which Wright alleges she told Harris to go to law enforcement.[44][45] Wright met and worked with Harris and Recorder Stephen Richer following the 2018 election looking into claims of election irregularities.[46]
Related Research Articles
QAnon is a far-right American political conspiracy theory and political movement that originated in 2017. QAnon centers on fabricated claims made by an anonymous individual or individuals known as "Q". Those claims have been relayed and developed by online communities and influencers. Their core belief is that a cabal of Satanic,cannibalistic child molesters is operating a global child sex trafficking ring that conspired against president Donald Trump. QAnon has direct roots in Pizzagate,an Internet conspiracy theory that appeared one year earlier,but also incorporates elements of many other theories. QAnon has been described as a cult.
Bradley Allen Klippert is an American politician,minister,law enforcement officer,and military officer who formerly served as a member of the Washington House of Representatives from the 8th Legislative District.
Scott Gordon Perry is an American politician and retired U.S. Army National Guard brigadier general who is the U.S. representative for Pennsylvania's 10th congressional district. His district,numbered the 4th district from 2013 to 2019,includes Harrisburg,York,and most of the inner suburbs. Perry serves on the House Transportation,Infrastructure,and Foreign Affairs committees.
Karen Fann is a former Republican member of the Arizona Senate,representing Arizona Legislative District 1. Fann became President of the Arizona Senate in 2019,and served until 2023.
Kelly Townsend is an American author,childbirth educator and birth doula who was a Republican politician. She was a member of the Arizona Senate representing District 16 from 2021 to 2023,and previously was a member of the Arizona House of Representatives from 2013 to 2021,acting as Majority Whip from 2017 to 2018.
Elise Marie Stefanik is an American politician serving as the U.S. representative for New York's 21st congressional district. As chair of the House Republican Conference since 2021,she is the fourth-ranking House Republican. Stefanik's district covers most of the North Country and the Adirondack Mountains,some of the outer suburbs of Utica and the Capital District in New York. In addition to being the first woman to occupy her House seat,Stefanik was 30 when first elected to the House in 2014,making her the youngest woman elected to Congress at the time.
Anthony Kern is an American politician and a Republican member of the Arizona Senate,representing District 27 since 2023. He previously represented District 20 in the State House of Representatives from January 5,2015,to January 11,2021.
Mark William Finchem is an American far-right politician who served as a member of the Arizona House of Representatives representing District 11 from 2015 to 2023. He is the Arizona coordinator for the Coalition of Western States,an organization that opposes the activities of the Bureau of Land Management and supported the occupation of the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge in 2016.
Venden "Vince" Leach is an American politician from Arizona. A Republican,he was a member of the Arizona State Senate from 2019 to 2023,representing District 11. From 2015 to 2019,he was a member of the Arizona House of Representatives representing District 11.
James Carl Marchant Jr. is an American politician in Nevada. A member of the Republican Party,he represented the 37th district in the Nevada Assembly,covering parts of the northwestern Las Vegas Valley,from 2016 to 2018. A staunch supporter of former President Donald Trump,Marchant was the Republican nominee for Nevada's 4th congressional district in 2020 and for Secretary of State of Nevada in 2022.
Peggy Suzanne Judd is an American politician from Arizona. A member of the Republican Party,she was a member of the Arizona House of Representatives from January 2011 to January 2013. She was elected to the Cochise County Board of Supervisors in November 2016.
Robert J. Sutherland is a former American politician previously serving as a member of the Washington House of Representatives for the 39th district.
Marjorie Taylor Greene,sometimes referred to by her initials MTG,is an American far-right politician,businesswoman,and conspiracy theorist who has been the U.S. representative for Georgia's 14th congressional district since 2021. A member of the Republican Party,she was elected to Congress in 2020 following the retirement of Republican incumbent Tom Graves and was reelected in 2022.
Members of the United States Republican Party have reacted differently to Republican president Donald Trump's false claims about the 2020 United States presidential election,with many publicly supporting them,many remaining silent,and a few publicly denouncing them. Trump falsely claimed to have won the election,and made many false and unsubstantiated claims of election fraud. By December 11,2020,126 out of 196 Republican members of the House backed a lawsuit filed in the United States Supreme Court supported by nineteen Republican state attorneys general seeking to subvert the election and overturn the election results. The Trump campaign hired the Berkeley Research Group to investigate whether there had been voter fraud. The researchers found nothing,and the consultancy reported this to Trump and his chief of staff Mark Meadows on a conference call in the final days of the year,before the attack on the Capitol.
Wendy Rogers is an American far-right Republican politician. First elected in 2020,Rogers is the Arizona State Senator representing Legislative District 7.
Robert Steven Chase is an American politician and businessman. A Republican,he was a member of the Washington House of Representatives from the 4th district. Elected in 2020,he assumed office on January 11,2021.
The 2022 Arizona Secretary of State election was held on Tuesday,November 8,to elect the next Secretary of State of Arizona. Incumbent Secretary of State Katie Hobbs declined to run for a second term,to instead run for governor. Primary elections were held on August 2,2022. Democrat and former Maricopa County recorder Adrian Fontes defeated Republican representative Mark Finchem by 4.8%.
Jovan Hutton Pulitzer is an American entrepreneur and onetime treasure hunter from Dallas,Texas,who invented the widely-criticized CueCat barcode scanner and "kinematic artifact detection" technology to find folds and bamboo fibers in election ballots. His marketing involved the defunct online show Net Talk Live! and selling crystals.
Justine Wadsack is an American politician. Wadsack was elected in 2022 to serve in the Arizona State Senate representing District 17 as a member of the Republican Party. Wadsack defeated incumbent State Senator Vince Leach in the Republican primary.
Alexander Kolodin,or Alex Kolodin is an American lawyer,politician and Republican member of the Arizona House of Representatives elected to represent District 3 in 2022.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
