| Year | Production | Author(s) | Producers | Ref. |
|---|
| 2010 |
| The Scottsboro Boys | David Thompson, John Kander, Fred Ebb | Vineyard Theatre | [21] |
| Click, Clack, Moo | Billy Aronson, Kevin Del Aguila, Brad Alexander, Doreen Cronin | Theatreworks USA |
| Everyday Rapture | Dick Scanlan, Sherie Rene Scott | Second Stage Theatre |
| The Toxic Avenger | Joe DiPietro and David Bryan | Jean Cheever and Tom Polum |
| Yank! A WWII Love Story | Joseph Zellnik and David Zellnik | York Theatre Company, Maren Berthelsen, Pamela Koslow, Stuart Wilk, Matt Schicker, Hugh Hayes, Jim Kierstead, Sondra Healy, Shidan Majidi |
| 2011 |
| Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson | Michael Friedman and Alex Timbers | The Public Theater, Center Theatre Group and Les Freres Corbusier | [22] |
| In Transit | Kristen Anderson-Lopez, James-Allen Ford, Russ Kaplan, and Sara Wordsworth | Primary Stages, the Baruch/Viertel/Routh/Frankel Group, Jane Bergere, Jodi Glucksman, Ken Greiner, Chip Meyrelles, Christina Papagjika, and Janet Rosen |
| The Burnt Part Boys | Chris Miller, Nathan Tysen, and Mariana Elder | Playwrights Horizons and Vineyard Theatre |
| The Kid | Andy Monroe, Jack Lechner and Michael Zam | The New Group |
| We the People: America Rocks! | Joe Iconis, Brad Alexander, Kevin Del Aguila, Eli Bolin, Sam Forman, Tommy Newman, Ryan Scott Oliver, Adam Overett, Mark Weiner, and Erik Weiner and Jordan Allen-Dutton | Theatreworks USA |
| 2012 |
| Once | Enda Walsh, Glen Hansard, and Markéta Irglová | New York Theatre Workshop | [23] |
| Queen of the Mist | Michael John LaChiusa | Transport Group |
| SILENCE! The Musical | Jon Kaplan, Al Kaplan, and Hunter Bell | Victoria Lang, Rich Affannato, Donna Trinkoff in association with Scott Kirschenbaum, Theater Mogul, Kitefliers Studio, Terry Schnuck, and John Arthur Pinckard |
| The Blue Flower | Jim Bauer and Ruth Bauer | Second Stage Theatre |
| The Shaggs: Philosophy of the World | Joy Gregory, Gunnar Madsen, and John Langs | Playwrights Horizons and New York Theatre Workshop |
| 2013 |
| Dogfight | Benj Pasek, Justin Paul, and Peter Duchan | Second Stage Theatre | [24] |
| Giant | Michael John LaChiusa and Sybille Pearson | The Public Theater in association with Dallas Theater Center |
| Murder Ballad | Julia Jordan and Juliana Nash | Manhattan Theatre Club |
| The Other Josh Cohen | David Rossmer and Steve Rosen | Amas Musical Theatre in association with Scandobean Productions, LLC |
| Skippyjon Jones | Kevin Del Aguila and Eli Bolin | Theatreworks USA |
| 2014 |
| Fun Home | Jeanine Tesori and Lisa Kron | The Public Theater | [25] |
| Here Lies Love | David Byrne and Fatboy Slim, additional music by Tom Gandy and J Pardo | The Public Theater |
| Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 | Dave Malloy | Howard & Janet Kagan, Paula Marie Black, John Logan, Lisa Matlin, Daveed Frazier, Tom Smedes, Vertical Ent./Roman Gambourg/Lev Gelfer |
| What's It All About? Bacharach Reimagined | Burt Bacharach and Hal David, conceived by Kyle Riabko and David Lane Seltzer | New York Theatre Workshop |
| 2015 |
| Hamilton | Lin-Manuel Miranda | The Public Theater | [26] |
| The Fortress of Solitude | Itamar Moses and Michael Friedman | The Public Theater in association with Dallas Theater Center |
| The Lightning Thief | Rob Rokicki and Joe Tracz | Theatreworks USA |
| Nevermore – The Imaginary Life and Mysterious Death of Edgar Allan Poe | Jonathan Christenson | Radio Mouse Entertainment, Martin Hummel, Caiola Productions, Terry Schnuck, Susan Jaffe Tane, Hernreich-Horvath Productions, Catalyst Theatre in association with Fireboat Productions, Mary Cossette, and Meredith Lynsey Schade |
| Pretty Filthy | Michael Friedman and Bess Wohl, conceived by Steve Cosson | The Civilians in association with Jon B. Platt |
| 2016 |
| Futurity | César Alvarez and The Lisps | Soho Rep, Ars Nova and Carole Shorenstein Hays | [27] |
| Iowa | Jenny Schwartz and Todd Almond | Playwrights Horizons |
| Southern Comfort | Dan Collins and Julianne Wick Davis, Kate Davis, Robert DuSold and Thomas Caruso | The Public Theater |
| Tappin’ Thru Life | Maurice Hines | Leonard Soloway, Bud Martin, Riki Kane Larimer, Jeff Wolk, Phyllis and Buddy Aerenson, and Darren P. DeVerna/Jeremiah J. Harris and the Shubert Organization |
| The Wildness: Sky-Pony's Rock Fairy Tale | Kyle Jarrow and Lauren Worsham | Ars Nova in collaboration with The Play Company |
| 2017 |
| The Band's Visit | David Yazbek and Itamar Moses and Eran Kolirin | Atlantic Theater Company | [28] |
| Dear Evan Hansen | Steven Levenson and Benj Pasek and Justin Paul | Second Stage Theatre in association with Stacey Mindich Productions |
| Hadestown | Anaïs Mitchell | New York Theatre Workshop |
| Ride the Cyclone | Brooke Maxwell and Jacob Richmond | MCC Theater |
| The Total Bent | Stew and Heidi Rodewald | The Public Theater |
| 2018 |
| KPOP | Woodshed Collective, Jason Kim, Helen Park and Max Vernon | Ars Nova in association with Ma-Yi Theater Company and Woodshed Collective | [29] |
| Bella: An American Tall Tale | Kirsten Childs | Playwrights Horizons |
| Desperate Measures | Peter Kellogg and David Friedman | York Theatre Company in association with Cecilia Lin and Hu Guo |
| Hundred Days | The Bengsons and Sarah Gancher | New York Theatre Workshop |
| Jerry Springer: The Opera | Stewart Lee and Richard Thomas | The New Group |
| 2019 |
| Rags Parkland Sings The Songs Of The Future | Andrew R. Butler | Ars Nova | [30] |
| Be More Chill | Joe Iconis and Joe Tracz | Gerald Goehring, Michael F. Mitri, Jennifer Ashley Tepper, Marc David Levine, Marlene and Gary Cohen, 42nd.club, The Baruch Frankel Viertel Group, Alisa and Charlie Thorne, Jenny Niederhoffer, Chris Blasting/Simpson & Longthorne, Brad Blume/Gemini Theatrical, Jonathan Demar/Kim Vasquez, Ben Holtzman and Sammy Lopez, Koenigsberg/Federman/Adler, Ashlee Latimer and Jenna Ushkowitz, Jenn Maley and Cori Stolbun, Robert and Joan Rechnitz, Fred and Randi Sternfeld, YesBroadway Productions, in association with Two River Theater |
| Girl from the North Country | Conor McPherson and Bob Dylan | The Public Theater |
| Midnight at The Never Get | Mark Sonnenblick and Sam Bolen | York Theatre Company by arrangement with Visceral Entertainment and Mark Cortale Productions, Nathaniel Granor, Jeff G. Peters, Daryl Roth, Megan Savage |
| Miss You Like Hell | Quiara Alegría Hudes and Erin McKeown | The Public Theater |
