Richard C. Hoagland

Last updated

Richard C. Hoagland
Born
Richard Charles Hoagland [1]

(1945-04-25) April 25, 1945 (age 79) [2]
Morristown, New Jersey, U.S.
Known forAdvocating his beliefs in advanced ancient civilizations colonizing the solar system; accusations of corruption of NASA and U.S. government
Notable workThe Monuments of Mars: A City on the Edge of Forever
AwardsInternational Angstrom Medal for Excellence in Science, 1993. [3] [note 1]
Ig Nobel Prize for Astronomy, 1997. [4]

Richard Charles Hoagland (born April 25, 1945) is an American author and a proponent of various conspiracy theories about NASA, lost alien civilizations on the Moon, and on Mars and other related topics. Hoagland has been documented to misappropriate others' professional achievements and is widely described as a conspiracy theorist and pseudoscientist. [5] [6] [7] [8]

Contents

Background

Hoagland has no education beyond the high school level. According to Hoagland's curriculum vitae, [2] he has no advanced training, schooling, or degrees in any scientific field. Hoagland asserts he was a Curator of Astronomy and Space Science at the Springfield Science Museum, 1964–1967, and assistant director at the Gengras Science Center [note 2] in West Hartford, Connecticut, 1967–1968, and a Science Advisor to CBS News during the Apollo program, 1968–1971. In July 1968, Hoagland filed a copyright registration for a planetarium presentation and show script called The Grand Tour. [9]

A popular planetarium lecturer at the Springfield Science Museum, Hoagland produced a program called "Mars: Infinity to 1965" to coincide with the Mariners 3 and 4 missions. [10] He designed a room with special equipment to display the relative positions of the Earth, Mars, and the Mariners during their trip and thereafter contracted with NASA to relay the pictures of the Martian surface, on a near-live-feed, to the general audience. [10] Hoagland co-hosted a radio program for WTIC (AM) in Hartford, Connecticut, The Night of the Encounter, along with Dick Bertel, covering the July 14, 1965 Mariner 4 flyby of the planet Mars. [11] Local newspapers had noted the radio broadcast to be history's first laser audio transmission. [10]

In 1976, Hoagland, an avid Star Trek fan, initiated a letter-writing campaign that successfully persuaded President Gerald Ford to name the first Space Shuttle the Enterprise , replacing the previously slated name for the prototype vehicle, Constitution. [12] [note 3]

Hoagland authored the book The Monuments of Mars: A City on the Edge of Forever (published in 1987) and co-authored the book Dark Mission: The Secret History of NASA, which was ranked 21st on November 18, 2007, on The New York Times Best Seller list for paperback nonfiction. [13] Richard Grossinger, the founder of North Atlantic Books, writes that Monuments became the most successful title published by North Atlantic, and that at its peak the book sold over 2000 copies per month. [14] Grossinger also reports that Hoagland wrote much of the book while in Los Angeles County jail. [14]

Hoagland ran the now-defunct The Enterprise Mission website, which he described as "an independent NASA watchdog and research group, the Enterprise Mission, attempting to figure out how much of what NASA has found in the solar system over the past 50 years has actually been silently filed out of sight as classified material, and therefore totally unknown to the American people." [15]

Hoagland appeared regularly as the "Science Advisor" for Coast to Coast AM , a late-night radio talk show, until being replaced by Robert Zimmerman in July 2015. [16]

While Hoagland makes frequent reference to his receipt of the "International Angstrom Medal for Excellence in Science" in August 1993, the organization that awarded the medal, The Angstrom Foundation Aktiebolag, founded by Lars-Jonas Ångström, was not authorized by Uppsala University or the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences to make use of the academy's Anders Jonas Ångström memorial medal. The academy has long authorized only Uppsala University to use its medal for the Ångström's Prize (Ångströms premium), awarded yearly by Uppsala professors to physics students. Mr. Ångström stated in May 2000 that although his award to Hoagland was a mistake, he acted with good faith and with good intentions. [3] [17] [18] [19]

Claims by Hoagland

Hoagland claims the source of a so-called NASA "coverup", with relation to the "Face on Mars" and other related structures, is the result of a report commissioned by NASA authored by the Brookings Institution, the so-called Brookings Report. Hoagland claimed that page 216 of the 1960 report, "Proposed Studies on the Implications of Peaceful Space Activities for Human Affairs", instructed NASA to deliberately withhold from the public any evidence it may find of extraterrestrial activity, specifically on the Moon, [Mars]], or Venus.

Hoagland has also proposed a form of physics he calls "hyperdimensional physics", [20] [21] which he claims represents a more complete implementation of James Clerk Maxwell's original 20 quaternion equations, [22] instead of the original Maxwell's equations as amended by Oliver Heaviside commonly taught today. [23] The mainstream physics community rejects these ideas as unfounded. [24] [25] [26] [27] [28]

Hoagland claims the "Face on Mars" is part of a city built on Cydonia Planitia consisting of colossal pyramids and mounds arranged in a geometric pattern. [29] To Hoagland, this is evidence that an advanced civilization might once have existed on Mars. [29] In the years since its discovery, the "face" has been near-universally accepted as an optical illusion, [7] an example of the psychological phenomenon of pareidolia. [24] [30] [31] Similar optical illusions can be found in the geology of Earth; [32] examples include the Old Man of the Mountain, the Pedra da Gávea, and Stac Levenish. [33]

Although the Pioneer 10 plaque was designed entirely by Carl Sagan, Linda Salzman Sagan, and Frank Drake, [8] Hoagland has inaccurately claimed to have co-created the plaque with Eric Burgess, as in 1990 when asserting that "Carl for many years has been taking public credit for the Pioneer plaque which, of course, Eric Burgess and I conceived." [8] Later that year, Hoagland went so far as to claim he designed the plaque when he said, "Carl... was involved with Eric Burgess and me in the design of [the] message." [8] Burgess' account is at odds with Hoagland's design claims, stating that "The design itself was created by Carl Sagan and Frank Drake, with the artistic help of Sagan’s then-wife Linda Salzman Sagan", without mentioning Hoagland at all. [34] Sagan's correspondence regarding the matter also contradicts Hoagland's claims, specifically saying "he did not contribute one bit of data towards the message design." [35] Burgess recalls similarly, adding that all Hoagland did concerning the plaque "was support me and say it's a good idea." [8] Yet Hoagland's now-defunct website continued to credit him as "co-creator of the 'Pioneer Plaque.'" [36]

Responses by scientists

Many scientists have responded to Hoagland's claims and assertions. Professional astronomer Phil Plait described Hoagland as a pseudoscientist and his claims as ridiculous. [6] Plait has also criticized Hoagland for having no university degree. [17] Prof. Ralph Greenberg asserted that the logic of Hoagland's deductions from the geometry of Cydonia Mensae is flawed [7] and says that he is not a trained scientist in any sense. The claim that the crashing of the Galileo orbiter into Jupiter caused a "mysterious black spot" on the planet has since been disputed by both NASA and Plait. There is photographic evidence that a similar "black spot" was present in imagery of Jupiter taken in 1998. A second image referenced by Plait shows a dark ring that looks similar to the spot Hoagland cited. [37] In 1995, Malin Space Science Systems, NASA prime contractor for planetary imaging, published a paper critiquing claims that the "city" at Cydonia is artificial, the claimed mathematical relationships, and – very specifically – denying any claims about concealing questionable data from the public. [38]

In October 1997, Hoagland received the Ig Nobel Prize for Astronomy "for identifying artificial features on the moon and on Mars, including a human face on Mars and ten-mile-high buildings on the far side of the moon." The prize is given for outlandish or "trivial" contributions to science. [4]

Publications

Books

Contributions, introductions, forewords

Videos

Notes

  1. ↑ A private award presented to Hoagland by Lars-Jonas Ångström in Washington, D.C., August 1993; not to be confused with the long-established Ångström's Prize (Ångströms premium), awarded yearly by professors at Uppsala University to physics students.
  2. ↑ The Children's Museum, formerly The Science Center of Connecticut, is home to the Gengras Planetarium.
  3. ↑ In "Why 'Enterprise?'", The Enterprise Mission credits the 1976 Space Shuttle letter-writing campaign as being "organized by Richard C. Hoagland and a small group of associates, including White House consultant, Jerome Glenn." Glenn is the co-founder and Director of The Millennium Project, a think tank. His résumé Archived October 7, 2013, at the Wayback Machine posted on his organization's website mentions that he was "instrumental in naming the first Space Shuttle the Enterprise."

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Carl Sagan</span> American astrophysicist, cosmologist and author (1934–1996)

Carl Edward Sagan was an American astronomer, planetary scientist, and science communicator. His best known scientific contribution is his research on the possibility of extraterrestrial life, including experimental demonstration of the production of amino acids from basic chemicals by exposure to light. He assembled the first physical messages sent into space, the Pioneer plaque and the Voyager Golden Record, which were universal messages that could potentially be understood by any extraterrestrial intelligence that might find them. He argued in favor of the hypothesis, which has since been accepted, that the high surface temperatures of Venus are the result of the greenhouse effect.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">The Planetary Society</span> International non-governmental nonprofit organization

The Planetary Society is an American internationally-active non-governmental nonprofit organization. It is involved in research, public outreach, and political space advocacy for engineering projects related to astronomy, planetary science, and space exploration. It was founded in 1980 by Carl Sagan, Bruce Murray, and Louis Friedman, and has about 60,000 members from more than 100 countries around the world.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Spacelab</span> Temporary, reusable laboratory aboard the Space Shuttle

Spacelab was a reusable laboratory developed by European Space Agency (ESA) and used on certain spaceflights flown by the Space Shuttle. The laboratory comprised multiple components, including a pressurized module, an unpressurized carrier, and other related hardware housed in the Shuttle's cargo bay. The components were arranged in various configurations to meet the needs of each spaceflight.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Steve Squyres</span> Professor of Physical Sciences at Cornell University

Steven Weldon Squyres is an American geologist and planetary scientist. He was the James A. Weeks Professor of Physical Sciences at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York. His research area is in planetary sciences, with a focus on large solid bodies in the Solar System such as the terrestrial planets and the moons of the Jovian planets. Squyres was the principal investigator of the Mars Exploration Rover Mission (MER).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">STS-48</span> 1991 American crewed spaceflight to deploy the Upper Atmospheric Research Satellite

STS-48 was a Space Shuttle mission that launched on September 12, 1991, from Kennedy Space Center, Florida. The orbiter was Space ShuttleDiscovery. The primary payload was the Upper Atmosphere Research Satellite (UARS). The mission landed on September 18 at 12:38 a.m. EDT at Edwards Air Force Base on runway 22. The mission was completed in 81 revolutions of the Earth and traveled 3,530,369 km (2,193,670 mi). The 5 astronauts carried out a number of experiments and deployed several satellites. The total launch mass was 108,890 kg (240,060 lb) and the landing mass was 87,440 kg (192,770 lb).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">John M. Grunsfeld</span> American astronaut and astronomer (born 1958)

John Mace Grunsfeld is an American physicist and a former NASA astronaut. He is a veteran of five Space Shuttle flights and has served as NASA Chief Scientist. His academic background includes research in high energy astrophysics, cosmic ray physics and the emerging field of exoplanet studies with specific interest in future astronomical instrumentation. After retiring from NASA in 2009, he served as the deputy director of the Space Telescope Science Institute in Baltimore, Maryland. In January 2012, he returned to NASA and served as associate administrator of NASA's Science Mission Directorate (SMD). Grunsfeld announced his retirement from NASA in April 2016.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">SETI Institute</span> Not-for-profit research organization

The SETI Institute is a not-for-profit research organization incorporated in 1984 whose mission is to explore, understand, and explain the origin and nature of life in the universe, and to use this knowledge to inspire and guide present and future generations, sharing knowledge with the public, the press, and the government. SETI stands for the "search for extraterrestrial intelligence".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Phil Plait</span> American astronomer, writer, and skeptic (born 1964)

Philip Cary Plait, also known as The Bad Astronomer, is an American astronomer, skeptic, and popular science blogger. Plait has worked as part of the Hubble Space Telescope team, images and spectra of astronomical objects, as well as engaging in public outreach advocacy for NASA missions. He has written three books, Bad Astronomy, Death from the Skies, and Under Alien Skies. He has also appeared in several science documentaries, including How the Universe Works on the Discovery Channel. From August 2008 through 2009, he served as president of the James Randi Educational Foundation. Additionally, he wrote and hosted episodes of Crash Course Astronomy, which aired its last episode in 2016.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brookings Report</span> 1961 report significant for consideration of public reaction to extraterrestrial life

Proposed Studies on the Implications of Peaceful Space Activities for Human Affairs, often referred to as "the Brookings Report", was a 1960 report commissioned by NASA and created by the Brookings Institution in collaboration with NASA's Committee on Long-Range Studies. It was submitted to the House Committee on Science and Astronautics of the United States House of Representatives in the 87th United States Congress on April 18, 1961.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Alan Stern</span> American engineer and planetary scientist (born 1957)

Sol Alan Stern is an American engineer, planetary scientist and space tourist. He is the principal investigator of the New Horizons mission to Pluto and the Chief Scientist at Moon Express.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cydonia (Mars)</span> Area of Mars

Cydonia is a region on the planet Mars that has attracted both scientific and popular interest. The name originally referred to the albedo feature that was visible from earthbound telescopes. The area borders the plains of Acidalia Planitia and the highlands of Arabia Terra. The region includes the named features Cydonia Mensae, an area of flat-topped mesa-like features; Cydonia Colles, a region of small hills or knobs; and Cydonia Labyrinthus, a complex of intersecting valleys. As with other albedo features on Mars, the name Cydonia was drawn from classical antiquity, in this case from Kydonia, a historic polis on the island of Crete. Cydonia contains the "Face on Mars", located about halfway between the craters Arandas and Bamberg.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brian O'Leary</span> American astronaut (1940–2011)

Brian Todd O'Leary was an American scientist, author, and NASA astronaut candidate. He was part of NASA Astronaut Group 6, a group of scientist-astronauts chosen with the intention of training for the Apollo Applications Program.

Space (<i>The X-Files</i>) 9th episode of the 1st season of The X-Files

"Space" is the ninth episode of the first season of the American science fiction television series The X-Files, premiering on the Fox network on November 12, 1993. It was written by series creator Chris Carter, directed by William Graham, and featured guest appearances by Ed Lauter and Susanna Thompson. The episode is a "Monster-of-the-Week" story, unconnected to the series' wider mythology. "Space" earned a Nielsen household rating of 6.5, being watched by 6.1 million households in its initial broadcast, and received negative reviews from critics.

Michael C. Malin is an American astronomer, space scientist, and CEO of Malin Space Science Systems. His cameras have been important scientific instruments in the exploration of Mars.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edward C. Stone</span> American scientist (1936–2024)

Edward Carroll Stone was an American space scientist, professor of physics at the California Institute of Technology, and director of the NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">NASA</span> American space and aeronautics agency

The National Aeronautics and Space Administration is an independent agency of the U.S. federal government responsible for the civil space program, aeronautics research, and space research. Established in 1958, it succeeded the National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics (NACA) to give the U.S. space development effort a distinct civilian orientation, emphasizing peaceful applications in space science. It has since led most of America's space exploration programs, including Project Mercury, Project Gemini, the 1968–1972 Apollo Moon landing missions, the Skylab space station, and the Space Shuttle. Currently, NASA supports the International Space Station (ISS) along with the Commercial Crew Program, and oversees the development of the Orion spacecraft and the Space Launch System for the lunar Artemis program.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Discovery and exploration of the Solar System</span>

Discovery and exploration of the Solar System is observation, visitation, and increase in knowledge and understanding of Earth's "cosmic neighborhood". This includes the Sun, Earth and the Moon, the major planets Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, and Neptune, their satellites, as well as smaller bodies including comets, asteroids, and dust.

<i>Journal of Cosmology</i> Self-published online journal of pseudoscience and fringe science

The Journal of Cosmology is a website that describes itself as a "scientific journal". It has been criticized for lacking oversight and proper peer-review, and promoting fringe theories. It was established in 2009 by neuroscientist Rhawn Joseph; as of 2023, Rudolph Schild is the editor-in-chief.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">G. Scott Hubbard</span> Aeronautics and astronautics researcher (born 1948)

G. Scott Hubbard is a physicist who has been engaged in space-related research as well as program, project and executive management for more than 45 years including 20 years with NASA, culminating as director of NASA's Ames Research Center. As of 2012, Hubbard chairs SpaceX Safety Advisory Panel, he previously served as the NASA representative on the Columbia Accident Investigation Board, was NASA's first Mars program director and restructured the Mars program in the wake of mission failures.

References

  1. ↑ "Mars Pathfinder Conspiracy". Coast to Coast AM . June 17, 1997. Retrieved November 16, 2012. Art Bell confirms that Hoagland's middle name is Charles.
  2. 1 2 Richard C. Hoagland on Facebook
  3. 1 2 "rich-ang.jpg". The Enterprise Mission. Archived from the original on February 2, 2003. Retrieved April 18, 2013.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link) Image of an Anders Jonas Ångström memorial medal of the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences and Lars-Jonas Ångström with Richard C. Hoagland in Washington, D.C.
  4. 1 2 "The 1997 Ig Nobel Prize Winners". Improbable Research. Archived from the original on November 14, 2021. Retrieved November 14, 2021.
  5. ↑ Oberg, James (January 21, 2008). "The dark side of space disaster theories". The Space Review . Retrieved November 16, 2012.
  6. 1 2 Plait, Phil (2008). "Richard Hoagland's Nonsense". Bad Astronomy (Blog). badastronomy.com. Retrieved November 16, 2012.
  7. 1 2 3 Greenberg, Ralph. "The D&M Pyramid On Mars And Richard Hoagland'S Theories About Cydonia". Math.washington.edu. Archived from the original on July 19, 2014. Retrieved July 30, 2014.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 Posner, Gary P. (November–December 2000). "The Face Behind the 'Face' on Mars: A Skeptical Look at Richard C. Hoagland". Skeptical Inquirer . 24 (6). Amherst, New York: Committee for Skeptical Inquiry: 20–26. Archived from the original on November 6, 2023.
  9. ↑ Library of Congress. Copyright Office (July–December 1968). Dramas and Works Prepared for Oral Delivery. Catalog of Copyright Entries: Third Series. Volume 22, Parts 3–4, Number 2. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office. p. 108. Retrieved November 9, 2012.
  10. 1 2 3 Sanderson, Richard (August 10, 2000). "Springfield's Link to the Red Planet". Springfield Journal. Vol. 26, no. 3. Archived from the original on October 27, 2002. Retrieved November 16, 2012.
  11. ↑ "The Night of the Encounter". Goldenage-WTIC.org. Retrieved November 17, 2012. Page includes a half-hour of excerpts from the 1965 WTIC radio program in the MP3 format.
  12. ↑ Deming, Joan; Slovinac, Patricia; et al. (July 2008). "NASA-wide Survey and Evaluation of Historic Facilities in the Context of the U.S. Space Shuttle Program: Roll-Up Report" (PDF). Washington, D.C.: Prepared by Archaeological Consultants, Inc. for NASA. p. 36. Archived from the original (PDF) on September 23, 2021. Retrieved November 17, 2012. Report cites Heppenheimer, Tom A. (2002). Development of the Space Shuttle, 1972–1981. History of the Space Shuttle. Vol. 2. Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Press. pp. 100–101. ISBN   978-1-58834-009-2.
  13. ↑ "November 18, 2007: Paperback Nonfiction". The New York Times. Retrieved November 22, 2012. Rankings reflect sales, for the week ended Nov. 3 ...
  14. 1 2 Grossinger, Richard 2010. The North Atlantic Books List 2: Categories. Archived January 22, 2020, at the Wayback Machine March 11, 2010.
  15. ↑ Hoagland, Richard C.; Bara, Mike (2007). Dark Mission: The Secret History of NASA. Port Townsend: Feral House. p. I. ISBN   978-1-932595-26-0.; Ibid., 2009, p. 57.
  16. ↑ "Richard C. Hoagland". Coast to Coast AM. Retrieved April 11, 2013.
  17. 1 2 Robert Roy Britt Space.com (March 18, 2004). "Scientist attacks alien claims on Mars". CNN. Retrieved July 30, 2014.
  18. ↑ "Richard C. Hoagland: Biographical Information". The Enterprise Mission. Archived from the original on April 14, 2013. Retrieved April 19, 2013.
  19. ↑ Plait, Phil (2008). "Richard Hoagland's Credentials". Bad Astronomy (Blog). badastronomy.com. Retrieved April 19, 2013.
  20. ↑ "The Enterprise Mission – Physics Lab". The Enterprise Mission. Archived from the original on April 3, 2013. Retrieved April 11, 2013. An online repository of "hyperdimensional physics"-related papers.
  21. ↑ Hoagland, Richard C.; Wilcock, David (May 15, 2004). "Hoagland & Wilcock on Coast to Coast". Coast to Coast AM (Interview). Interviewed by Art Bell. Archived from the original on December 3, 2007. Retrieved December 6, 2007. Transcript courtesy of The Enterprise Mission.
  22. ↑ Bearden, T. E. "Maxwell's Quaternion Equations". Rex Research. Retrieved April 11, 2013.
  23. ↑ See Maxwell's equations § Conventional formulation in SI units (especially details on Heaviside–Lorentz units)
  24. 1 2 Charles M. Wynn, Arthur W. Wiggins, Quantum Leaps in the Wrong Direction: Where Real Science Ends... and Pseudoscience begins (Joseph Henry Press, 2001). ISBN   0-309-17135-0
  25. ↑ "hyperdimensional physics | Exposing PseudoAstronomy". Pseudoastro.wordpress.com. Retrieved July 30, 2014.
  26. ↑ expat (March 19, 2014). "The Emoluments of Mars: Proposal for an experiment to test "hyperdimensional physics"". Dorkmission.blogspot.com. Retrieved July 30, 2014.
  27. ↑ Further proof of the misguided nature of Hoagland's "hyperdimensional physics" is the definitive failure of the WISE mission to find the large trans-Neptunian solar system bodies that Hoagland claimed existed through his theories. URL: http://www.scientificamerican.com/podcast/episode/no-planet-x/
  28. ↑ Chu-Carroll, Mark (October 31, 2010). "Free Energy by Switching Cameras (Classic Repost)". Good Math, Bad Math (Blog). Scientopia.org. Retrieved April 10, 2020.
  29. 1 2 "Exposing PseudoAstronomy Podcast – Shownotes Episode 59". Podcast.sjrdesign.net. Retrieved July 30, 2014.
  30. ↑ Britt, Robert Roy (March 18, 2004). "Scientist attacks alien claims on Mars". CNN. Space.com. Retrieved October 12, 2007.
  31. ↑ Normand Baillargeon, A Short Course in Intellectual Self Defense: Find Your Inner Chomsky, p. 177 (Seven Stories Press, 2007). ISBN   978-1-58322-765-7
  32. ↑ Dunning, Brian. "Skeptoid #97: The Face on Mars Revealed – New high resolution imagery has proven that this hill on Mars doesn't look quite so much like a carved face after all". Skeptoid .
  33. ↑ "Badlands Guardian Geological Feature". Google Maps. Retrieved April 26, 2007.
  34. ↑ "The Pioneer Plaque: Our Calling Card to the Cosmos". The Star Splitter, January 13, 2015
  35. ↑ "Sagan's Reply". Carl Sagan, September 6, 1990. Archived from the original on November 6, 2023.
  36. ↑ "Enterprise Mission". Richard C. Hoagland, July 6, 2018
  37. ↑ "PIA01496: Jovian Dark Spot". NASA. Retrieved June 28, 2006.
  38. ↑ Malin, Michael C. (1995). "Observations of the 'Face on Mars' and similar features by the Mars Global Surveyor Orbiter Camera". Malin Space Science Systems . Retrieved April 18, 2013.
Hoagland biography sites
Debunking websites
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.