Scholasticide

Last updated

Scholasticide, often used interchangeably with the terms educide and epistemicide, [1] [2] [3] refers to the intended mass destruction of education in a specific place. [4]

Contents

Educide has been used to describe the mass destruction in the Iraq War (2003–2011) and the Gaza Genocide (2023 – present). [5]

Terminology

The terms are used interchangeably, covering various forms of the deliberate mass destruction of educational infrastructure.[ citation needed ] The suffix -cide, Latin for "killing", makes a connection with genocide.

The term scholasticide, where "schola-" is Latin for school, was first used by Karma Nabulsi in January 2009 in relation to the destruction of Palestinian educational infrastructure during the December 2008 to January 2009 Israeli war against Gaza. [6] [7]

The term "educide" was first used in March 2011 by Hans-Christof von Sponeck, UN Humanitarian Coordinator for Iraq, in a speech concerning Iraq at the Ghent University Conference, with the prefix referring to "education". [4] [8]

The term epistemicide was coined by Boaventura de Sousa Santos in 2014 and describes the destruction of knowledge systems, where episteme means knowledge. [9]

Epistemicide can be used in light of a coloniser destroying the existing knowledge systems of the colonised, to replace them with knowledge systems controlled by the coloniser. [10]

Elements

Characteristics that are often mentioned as elements of educide include, but are not necessarily limited to;

Genocide

Educide has been linked to genocide. [4] The United Nations (UN) established what constitutes a genocide in Article II of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. Genocide is the intentional killing and destruction of an entire group, based on their ethnicity, nationality, race, or religion. [12]

Motives

Educide happens intentionally by an aggressor to a certain place and/or people. There are several reasons why an actor decides to commit educide. Motives for educide are for example colonisation. occupation, or annihilition of perceived threats.

When an actor wishes to impose power over a territory, this can go together with displacing or oppressing the native population and giving ruling power to the settlers or occupation forces. This process is often violent as the aggressor tries to suppress uprisings and resistance from the people living there. This suppression can happen via soft power, hard power, or both. Soft power is getting results not by coercion but by attraction, for example via payments, good affiliation, or education. [13] Education plays a crucial role, as it reproduces ideas such as norms, and values of a society; identities and nationalism; and it determines how history is taught. Consequently, it establishes an idea of who is good and who is bad. The coloniser/occupier can use education institutions to control these ideas. It does so by taking over the educational infrastructure. In this process, the original infrastructure is often overruled and/or destroyed. The absence of the original educational infrastructure leads to the colonised/occupied having to mirror and adapt to the infrastructure that is present, that of the coloniser, and is thus (partially) under its influence and control. This can happen via hard power by coercing change and destroying the existing educational infrastructure, which leads to educide.

If an actor perceives a certain group of people form a threat to the actor's stability, security, or power, it could try to weaken or destroy this group of people. In this process, the actor could perceive the educational infrastructure as a danger, since this is where knowledge is developed that serves this group of people. The actor can then decide to destroy the educational infrastructure. For an example, see the case study on Iraq below.

Impact

The destruction of the educational infrastructure of a place has long-term effects on its people. Possible impacts of educide are

  1. Inaccessibility to education;
  2. Educational delays and disadvantages (e.g. higher illiteracy rate);
  3. Underemployment: due to the absence of education, people will not reach their potential in the education they could have achieved, or are not able to receive their diploma. This leads to the possibility of people having work that does not reach their full capabilities and satisfaction in their job.; [14]
  4. Linguicide: if a certain language is no longer taught, there is a chance for the death of this language because people no longer know how to write or read it, nor develop their oral skills to the full potential;
  5. Brain drain: during educide, academics and students can be targeted and thus fled their country, leading to a brain drain as high educated people leave the country;
  6. Ethnic cleansing and/or genocide: removing the entire educational infrastructure can lead to a loss of collective memory and knowledge reproduction, and thus contribute to ethnic cleansing and/or genocide of a people and its identity;
  7. Colonisation: by removing the existing educational infrastructure and replacing it with a new one, a coloniser can control the reproduction and access to knowledge, which are instrumental in colonising a territory.

International law

Educide is not discussed as a specific crime, such as genocide, in international law. Nevertheless, other elements in international humanitarian law (IHL) try to prevent the crimes committed during educide. IHL established for example the protection of schools and the protection of innocent civilians. [15] [16]

Cases

Iraq

The first case in which the term educide was used, was for Iraq. The claimed educide in Iraq happened through multiple episodes. Before the 1990s, Iraq's educational infrastructure was good and improving. During the 1990s, the UN imposed sanctions decreased the education's quality and accessibility, as it reduced income via trade which would end up going to the educational system. The situation worsened further during the Iraq War (2003–2011) and the war in Iraq against terrorist groups such as Daesh (2013–2017). [17] [18]

Iran

Iraq War

During the Iraq War, the US aimed for a regime change in Iraq to fight the perceived threat of terror and weapons of mass destruction as part of the "war on terror" campaign, which is described by critics as an illegitimate invasion motivated by imperialism (see also: Rationale for the Iraq War; Legitimacy of the 2003 invasion of Iraq; Opposition to the Iraq War, Protests against the Iraq War; and Legality of the Iraq War). Changing the regime, by changing the political and economic status quo, was partially done via educide. The US dismantled the educational system, replaced it with a system dependent on British and American universities, and promoted "Western values," which were criticised for being Islamophobic. [19] However, this led primarily to the Iraqi educational infrastructure being destroyed systematically and with the intention to do so. [20] Between 2003 and 2007, school attendance dropped by almost 70%, at least 280 academics were killed, and 30% of the total number of professors, doctors, and engineers left Iraq. [20] Iraq's educational infrastructure faced many problems due to a lack of materials, a fear of bombings and kidnappings that prevented people from going to their educational institutions, and many professors fleeing the country. [20] Additionally, around 2007, many could not perform their professions due to missing certificates, while governmental officials sometimes missed the actual education they claimed to have. [14] The absence of education had a lot of impact on the Iraqi population, as more than 40% of the Iraqi people are aged 15 years or younger. [21]

Daesh

Between 2013 and 2017 the educational infrastructure suffered again. Due to the war against Daesh (also known as "IS", "ISIS", or "ISIL"), the Iraqi government reduced assistance to 5.2 million children. As of 2023, 770,000 children are displaced. [22] Between 2013 and 2017, in places under Daesh control, the curriculum was changed. Classes such as history or literature were replaced for religious teachings. The change of curriculum resulted in parents taking their children out of school to prevent indoctrination. Girls were disadvantaged in their access to education, with an adapted curriculum based on gender and having access to education only up to the age of 15. Girls dropped out due to marrying young, as this could prevent them from being forcefully married to a Daesh fighter. Moreover, from 2013 to 2017, educational institutions were attacked. Refworld reports that more than 100 attacks happened in which 300 people (students and staff) were injured. Additionally, there were targeted murders, kidnappings, and threats which harmed 60 students and more than 100 staff. Finally, the buildings of educational institutions were used for military purposes, such as Mosul University. [23]

The educide in Iraq, although throughout different circumstances, was intending to change the status quo by replacing the existing educational infrastructure with a new one. In both cases, it led to significantly destruction of education and access to education.

Gaza, Palestine

The terms "educide," "scholasticide," and "epistemicide" have been used to describe Israeli repression of Palestinian educational infrastructure. [24] After the 2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel on October 7 (for more background information, see Blockade of the Gaza Strip and Gaza-Israel Conflict), Israel attacked Gaza. This attack has been ongoing ever since and developed into a war on Gaza as well as a possible case of genocide on Gaza. [25] [26] [27] The war on Gaza has destroyed the entire infrastructure and thus forms a case of educide.

As a result of the war on Gaza, most educational institutions are destroyed, including 80% of all schools in Gaza. [28] Critics have claimed that Israel has systematically and intentionally destroyed all the universities in Gaza. [29] [30] Some of the educational buildings have been changed into military bases by Israel. [31] In addition to the material infrastructure, Israel has targeted those connected to the educational infrastructure, such as students and academics. In April 2024, 5479 students, 261 teachers, and 95 university professors were killed and 7819 students and 756 teachers injured. The numbers have been increasing ever since. [32] [28] According to the Ministry of Education and Higher Education in Gaza, 625000 students cannot access education. [33] For further information, Scholars Against the War on Palestine, has listed the acts that are part of the scholasticide, and which have happened in Gaza. [34]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">UNRWA</span> UN agency supporting Palestinian refugees

The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East is a UN agency that supports the relief and human development of Palestinian refugees. UNRWA's mandate encompasses Palestinians who fled or were expelled during the Nakba, the 1948 Palestine War, and subsequent conflicts, as well as their descendants, including legally adopted children. As of 2019, more than 5.6 million Palestinians are registered with UNRWA as refugees.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Israeli–Palestinian conflict</span> Ongoing military and political conflict in the Levant

The Israeli–Palestinian conflict is an ongoing military and political conflict about land and self-determination within the territory of the former Mandatory Palestine. Key aspects of the conflict include the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, the status of Jerusalem, Israeli settlements, borders, security, water rights, the permit regime, Palestinian freedom of movement, and the Palestinian right of return.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gaza City</span> Ancient Levantine metropolis and modern city in Palestine

Gaza, also called Gaza City, is a city in the Gaza Strip, Palestine. As of 2022, it was the largest city in the State of Palestine, with 590,481 inhabitants in 2017. The city is spread across an area of 45 square kilometres (17 sq mi). Gaza is one of the principal coastal cities in the country, home to Palestine's only port. Located some 76.6 kilometres (47.6 mi) southwest of the country's proclaimed capital East Jerusalem, the city is located on the coast of the Mediterranean Sea. Prior to the 2023 Israel–Hamas war, it was the most populous city in the State of Palestine, when massive displacement happened during the war.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Palestine</span> Country in West Asia

Palestine, officially the State of Palestine, is a country in the southern Levant region of West Asia recognized by 146 out of 193 UN member states. It encompasses the Israeli-occupied West Bank, including East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip, collectively known as the occupied Palestinian territories, within the broader geographic and historical Palestine region. Palestine shares most of its borders with Israel, and it borders Jordan to the east and Egypt to the southwest. It has a total land area of 6,020 square kilometres (2,320 sq mi) while its population exceeds five million people. Its proclaimed capital is Jerusalem, while Ramallah serves as its administrative center. Gaza City was its largest city prior to evacuations in 2023.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Al-Quds Open University</span> University in Palestine

Al-Quds Open University is an independent, distance education public university in Palestine. It was created by a decree issued by the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) in 1991.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Omer Bartov</span> Israeli-American historian (born 1954)

Omer Bartov is an Israeli-American historian. He is the Samuel Pisar Professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies at Brown University, where he has taught since 2000. Bartov is a historian of the Holocaust and is considered one of the world's leading authorities on genocide. The Forward calls him "one of the foremost scholars of Jewish life in Galicia."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jabalia refugee camp</span> Refugee camp in the Gaza Strip, Palestine

Jabalia Camp is a Palestinian refugee camp established in 1948 by the United Nations to house those displaced by the 1948 Palestinian expulsion. Located 3 kilometers (1.9 mi) north of Jabalia in the Gaza Strip, it is the largest refugee camp in Palestinian territory, with more than 100,000 inhabitants. Due to Israeli attacks during the Israel–Hamas war, the refugee camp was described as "destroyed".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pakistan–Palestine relations</span> Diplomatic relations between Pakistan and the State of Palestine

Pakistan–Palestine relations refer to the bilateral relations between Islamic Republic of Pakistan and State of Palestine. The Palestinian Authority established an embassy in Islamabad on 31 January 2017. Pakistan remains a staunch supporter of the proposal for the continuation of the native Palestinian state, and in line with its pro-Palestinian approach, does not recognize the State of Israel. However, the former President of Pakistan, Pervez Musharraf, stated that Pakistan will recognize Israel if the latter withdraws its forces from some of the occupied territories and allows the remaining Palestinian land to continue to exist, within the Green Line that served as the international border between the occupation force, Israel, and the Palestine from the First Arab–Israeli War of 1948 to the Third Arab–Israeli War of 1967. Pakistan frequently provides various forms of humanitarian aid to the Palestinian Authority.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Port of Gaza</span> Port in Gaza, Palestine

The Port of Gaza is a small port near the Rimal district of Gaza City, Gaza. It is the home port of Palestinian fishing-boats and the base of the Palestinian Naval Police, a branch of the Palestinian National Security Forces. Under the Oslo II Accord, the activities of the Palestinian Naval Police are restricted to 6 nautical miles from the coast. Since 2007, the Port of Gaza has been under an Israeli-imposed naval blockade as part of a blockade of the Gaza Strip, and activities at the port have been restricted to small-scale fishing.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Effects of war</span> Effect of war

The effects of war are widely spread and can be long-term or short-term. Soldiers experience war differently than civilians. Although both suffer in times of war, women and children suffer atrocities in particular. In the past decade, up to two million of those killed in armed conflicts were children. The widespread trauma caused by these atrocities and suffering of the civilian population is another legacy of these conflicts, the following creates extensive emotional and psychological stress. Present-day internal wars generally take a larger toll on civilians than state wars. This is due to the increasing trend where combatants have made targeting civilians a strategic objective.

Al-Zaytun is the southwestern and largest quarter of the Old City of Gaza. Prior to the demolition of the Old City's walls, it was one of the three walled quarters of Gaza's Old City, the other two being al-Tuffah in the northeast and al-Daraj in the northwest. Omar Mukhtar Street, Gaza City's main thoroughfare, separates al-Zaytun from al-Daraj.

Events in the year 2023 in Palestine.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Palestinian genocide accusation</span> Allegations pertaining to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict

The State of Israel has been accused of carrying out a genocide against Palestinians at various times during the longstanding Israeli–Palestinian conflict. Debate on whether Israel's treatment of Palestinians since the Nakba meets the definition of genocide, and whether such actions are continuous or limited to specific periods or events, is ongoing. This treatment has also been characterised as "slow-motion genocide", as well as a corollary or expression of settler colonialism and indigenous land theft.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ghassan Abu-Sittah</span> British-Palestinian plastic and reconstructive surgeon

Ghassan Soleiman Abu-Sittah is a British-Palestinian plastic and reconstructive surgeon who specialises in craniofacial surgery, aesthetic surgery, cleft lip and palate surgery, and trauma-related injuries. Since April 2024 he has served as Rector of the University of Glasgow.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Attacks on schools during the Israeli invasion of Gaza</span> 2023 airstrikes on educational facilities in the Gaza Strip

Since the outbreak of the Israel–Hamas war on 7 October 2023, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) has conducted numerous airstrikes on more than 200 educational facilities, including universities, in the Gaza Strip. The IDF states such airstrikes are the result of the placement of military infrastructure and rocket launching from civilian areas, including schools. By late March 2024, the United Nations recorded more than 200 Israeli attacks on schools in Gaza, with at least 53 schools totally destroyed. By July 2024, all 19 Gaza universities had suffered severe damage with 80% of university buildings destroyed, 103 academics killed, and 90,000 students enrolled in higher education no longer able to pursue their studies. In June 2024, UNOCHA stated 76 percent of Gaza's schools required "full reconstruction or major rehabilitation", and in August 2024, UNICEF stated 564, or 85 percent, of all schools in Gaza had been hit by Israeli attacks.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gaza genocide</span> Characterisation of Israeli mass killings in Gaza

According to a United Nations agency and a growing number of experts and rights organisations, including Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch, Israel has committed genocidal acts against the Palestinian people during its ongoing invasion and bombing of the Gaza Strip as part of the Israel–Hamas war. Various observers, including the UN Special Committee to investigate Israeli practices and the United Nations Special Rapporteur, have cited statements by senior Israeli officials that may indicate an "intent to destroy" Gaza's population in whole or in part, a necessary condition for the legal threshold of genocide to be met.

Israa University was a university in the Gaza Strip created in 2014. Its main building was occupied for 70 days and physically destroyed by explosives on 17 January 2024 by Israeli armed forces, during the Israel–Hamas war.

Writers Against the War on Gaza is a coalition of writers, academics, artists, journalists, and culture workers seeking to protest the Israel–Hamas war and mobilize for Palestinian liberation via cultural organizing. Their tactics are based on Vietnam War-era culture worker mobilization, and, in particular, the organization American Writers Against the Vietnam War.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Destruction of cultural heritage during the Israeli invasion of the Gaza Strip</span>

The destruction of cultural heritage during the ongoing Israeli invasion of the Gaza Strip has included the damage and destruction by Israel of hundreds of culturally or historically significant buildings, libraries, museums and other repositories of knowledge in Gaza, alongside the destruction of intangible cultural heritage. By late January 2024, more than half of the buildings in Gaza had been damaged or destroyed and 1.7 million people displaced.

Attacks on protected zones and civilians in Gaza during the Israel–Hamas war have led to the killing of over 30,000 Palestinians and the displacement of over 2 million people, as well as the collapse of the education system and the destruction of most homes and hospitals in Gaza. Israel has faced accusations of war crimes from South Africa, the UN Human Rights Council, and Amnesty International, among others, due to the number of civilian casualties and the percentage of civilian infrastructure destroyed, including Palestinian refugee camps, schools, mosques, churches, and more. Analysis of satellite data shows that 80% of buildings in northern Gaza have been damaged or ruined. As of January 2024, researchers from Oregon State University and the City University of New York estimated that 50 to 62 percent of all buildings in the Gaza Strip were damaged or destroyed.

References

  1. "The War on Education—in Gaza and at Home", In These Times , 2024-02-15, retrieved 2024-06-25
  2. Glück 2024: "The term "scholasticide" was coined by Karma Nabulsi during the 2008–2009 assault on Gaza to describe Israeli attacks on educational institutions, placing them within a historical context of "the systematic destruction of Palestinian education by Israel" since 1948 (Ahmad & Vulliamy 2009). The term has recently been expanded upon by a group called, Scholars Against the War on Palestine, to understand how scholasticide has "intensified on an unprecedented scale" during the present war to include the destruction of archives, libraries, museums and cultural heritage (Scholars Against the War on Palestine 2024)."
  3. Alousi 2022, p. 331: "The word educide was first used by Pluto Press in Nov 2009, which questioned whether the systematic killing of Iraqi academics and the intellectual élite could constitute a case of educide (Baker, et al., 2009). The word can be traced back to the former UN Humanitarian Coordinator for Iraq, Hans-Christoph Von Sponeck speech in March 2011 at the Ghent university conference. The speech examined the cataclysm of Iraqi academia and the country's disastrous education situation. Von Sponeck touched on educide; as a wrongdoing utilising the words education and genocide while focusing on the assassination of the élite academics within the Iraqi educated society."
  4. 1 2 3 4 Alousi 2022
  5. "UN experts deeply concerned over 'scholasticide' in Gaza". OHCHR. 2024-04-18. Retrieved 2024-06-25.
  6. "About – Scholars Against the War on Palestine". 2023-12-01. Retrieved 2024-04-24.
  7. Vulliamy, Ed (2009-01-10). "Attacks on school in Gaza". the Guardian. Retrieved 2024-06-25. This week, following the bombing of schools in Gaza, [Karma Nabulsi] says: "The systematic destruction of Palestinian education by Israel has countered that tradition since the occupation of 1967," citing "the calculated, wholesale looting of the Palestinian Research Centre in Beirut during the 1982 war and the destruction of all those manuscripts and archived history." "Now in Gaza," she says, "we see the policy more clearly than ever – this 'scholasticide'. The Israelis know nothing about who we really are, while we study and study them. But deep down they know how important education is to the Palestinian tradition and the Palestinian revolution. They cannot abide it and have to destroy it."
  8. Adriaensens, Dirk (2011-07-04). "Further Destruction Of Iraq's Higher Education: Blazing Fires, Forged Degrees And Silencer Guns By Dirk Adriaensens". Countercurrents. Retrieved 2024-06-25.
  9. Siddiqui, Rameen (2023-04-13). "Epistemicide: Intellectual Genocide and Eurocentric Modernity". Modern Diplomacy. Retrieved 2024-04-24., and the original at Epistemologies of the South: Justice against Epistemicide
  10. "The Epistemicide of the Palestinians: Israel Destroys Pillars of Knowledge". Institute for Palestine Studies. Retrieved 2024-04-24.
  11. Talebi, Tessa (2024-04-18). "The Hidden War on Higher Education: Unmasking the 'Educide' in Gaza". Project on Middle East Political Science. Retrieved 2024-04-24.
  12. "United Nations Office on Genocide Prevention and the Responsibility to Protect". www.un.org. Retrieved 2024-04-24.
  13. Köse, Talha; Özcan, Mesut; Karakoç, Ekrem (2016). "A Comparative Analysis of Soft Power in the MENA Region: The Impact of Ethnic, Sectarian, and Religious Identity on Soft Power in Iraq and Egypt". Foreign Policy Analysis. 12 (3): 354–373. ISSN   1743-8586. JSTOR   26168109.
  14. 1 2 Al Jazeera English (2007-12-09). Inside Iraq – Iraq's Education System – 07 Dec 07 – Pt 4 . Retrieved 2024-06-08 via YouTube.
  15. "The Protection of Schools under International Humanitarian Law – Militair Rechtelijk Tijdschrift". puc.overheid.nl. Retrieved 2024-05-19.
  16. "Students, teachers and schools should always be protected in armed conflict". International Committee of the Red Cross. 2023-09-11. Retrieved 2024-05-19.
  17. Alousi 2022.
  18. "Education Under Attack 2018 – Iraq". Refworld. Retrieved 2024-06-08.
  19. Kabel, Ahmed (2014-10-01). "The Islamophobic-Neoliberal-Educational Complex". Islamophobia Studies Journal. 2 (2): 68–72. doi:10.13169/islastudj.2.2.0058. ISSN   2325-8381.
  20. 1 2 3 Al Jazeera English (2007-12-09). Inside Iraq – Iraq's Education System – 07 Dec 07 – Pt 1 . Retrieved 2024-06-08 via YouTube.
  21. Al Jazeera English (2011-04-14). Iraqi children struggle to remain in school . Retrieved 2024-06-08 via YouTube.
  22. "The Education Crisis in Iraq: A Call for Urgent Reforms". Education International. 2024-03-25. Retrieved 2024-06-08.
  23. "Education Under Attack 2018 – Iraq". Refworld. Retrieved 2024-06-08.
  24. "The War on Education—in Gaza and at Home". In These Times. 2024-02-15. Retrieved 2024-06-11.
  25. "War on Gaza 2023: an unprecedented and devastating impact - United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia". www.unescwa.org. Retrieved 2024-06-11.
  26. "Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide in the Gaza Strip (Sou". www.icj-cij.org. Retrieved 2024-06-11.
  27. "Gaza war: UN rights expert accuses Israel of acts of genocide". 2024-03-26. Retrieved 2024-06-11.
  28. 1 2 "UN experts deeply concerned over 'scholasticide' in Gaza". OHCHR. 18 April 2024. Archived from the original on 16 June 2024. Retrieved 18 June 2024.
  29. Azzouz, Ammar (2024-03-03). "Erased city". City. 28 (1–2): 2. Bibcode:2024City...28....1A. doi: 10.1080/13604813.2024.2323388 . ISSN   1360-4813.
  30. "Academics have a duty to help stop the 'educide' in Gaza". University World News. Retrieved 2024-06-11.
  31. "Gaza: Israel continues its crime of ethnic cleansing by destroying last neighbourhoods, UN shelter centres in Jabalia camp [EN/AR] - occupied Palestinian territory | ReliefWeb". reliefweb.int. 2024-05-31. Retrieved 2024-06-15.
  32. Middle East Centre. "The Palestinian University and Scholasticide". London School of Economics and Political Science. Retrieved 2024-06-15.
  33. Solaimane, Mohamed (2024-06-14). "First field school in Gaza includes 1,200 displaced students". The New Arab. Retrieved 2024-06-15.
  34. "Toolkit - Scholars Against the War on Palestine". 2024-02-02. Retrieved 2024-06-15.

Bibliography

Further reading