Scientific plagiarism in India

Last updated

A lack of oversight and a lack of proper training for scientists have led to the rise of plagiarism and research misconduct in India. [1] India does not have a statutory body to deal with scientific misconduct in academia, like the Office of Research Integrity in the US, and hence cases of plagiarism are often dealt in ad-hoc fashion with different routes being followed in different cases. In most cases, a public and media outcry leads to an investigation either by institutional authorities or by independent enquiry committees. Plagiarists have in some cases been suspended, removed or demoted. [2] However, no fixed route has been prescribed to monitor such activities. This has led to calls for establishment of an independent ethics body. [3]

Contents

Society for Scientific Values

The Society for Scientific Values is an independent body of scientists with the goal of upholding ethics in the Indian Scientific community. In absence of a statutory body to investigate academic misconduct, the society has been acting as an independent watchdog over the years. The society has been active in recently over several past cases involving plagiarism. K. L. Chopra, ex-director of Indian Institute of Technology, Kharagpur is currently the president of the society while N. Raghuram of GGS Indraprastha University is the secretary. [4]

Plagiarism in IIMs

IIM Ahmedabad

On 17 August 1992, a student complained to the Director IIM stating that "While doing my summer project, I had to do some modelling and data analysis. I had carried my copies of Levin (Statistics for Management), and Baumol (Economic Theory and Operations Analysis) along from the organisation I was in, I borrowed copies of Wagner (Principles of Operations Research) and Quantitative Techniques for Managerial Decisions by U. K. Srivastava (a CMA Prof. at IIMA), G. V. Shenoy, and S. C. Sharma. As I was browsing through the books, I came across a most interesting thing. At several places, the Srivastava, Shenoy, Sharma book had simply lifted stuff from the other three books (Baumol, Levin, and Wagner) and no references anywhere in the book". Upon enquiry a Committee, based on a report by a student, found that the book Quantitative Techniques for Managerial Decisions by U. K. Srivastava, G. V. Shenoy, and S. C. Sharma had copied without acknowledgment of the source at least at 10 different places including 5 foreign books and some other Indian books, such as Baumol, Levin and Wagner (all books were published prior to the publication of the book). [5]

IIM Indore

On 3 March 2012, the director of IIM Indore, N. Ravichandran, has been asked by the centre to respond to an accusation of plagiarism against him and another senior faculty member of the institute, Omkar D. Palsule-Desai. They had submitted a paper—The management case on "Euthanasia: Should it be Lawful or Otherwise?". Ahmedabad-based researcher K.R. Narendrababu has complained that the paper was sourced heavily from a Supreme Court judgment without adequate attribution. [6] One month later, on 12 April, veteran industrialist Mr LN Jhunjhunwala, who is also the chairman of the Indian Institute of Management (IIM), Indore's board of governors resigned citing major differences with Dr N Ravichandran. Another board member and Bhopal-based retired IAS officer Dr MN Buch also resigned. [7] [8]

Other instances of plagiarism

Prof. B.S. Rajput controversy

The most high-profile and widely publicised controversy in India has been that of Prof. B. S. Rajput and colleagues in the field of Theoretical Physics.

Prof. B.S. Rajput was the vice-chancellor of Kumaon University, India in 2002 when various physicists in India started a website alleging that some of his papers claimed authorship of work, reported earlier by other researchers. [9] The principal allegation was that a paper published by S.C. Joshi and B.S. Rajput entitled "Axion-dilaton black holes with SL(2,Z) symmetry through APT-FGP model" in Europhysics Letters , Vol. 57, No. 5, was entirely copied from a six-year-old paper by Renata Kallosh of Stanford in Physical Review D , Vol 54, No. 8. [10] However, the campaign very soon included three other papers by Prof. Rajput and colleagues as plagiarised papers. One of these papers "BPS Spectra of Dyons in Four-Dimensional N = 2 Supersymmetric Theories" was later recalled by the journal Progress of Theoretical Physics . [11]

On publication of the site, Prof. Rajput threatened to take legal action against the website, maintaining that the paper was written by Mr. Joshi, one of his students, without prior approval from him. [12] However, the site was endorsed by over 40 Indian physicists. In addition, seven physicists including Nobel Laureate, S. Chu, R. Laughlin and D. Osheroff wrote to the president of India, APJ Abdul Kalam requesting an investigation in this matter. [13] The situation became murkier when Prof Kavita Pandey, head of the Physics department at Kumaon University claimed that she was suspended by the university as she brought this issue to the public. [14]

In midst of all this blame game, the president of India asked the Governor of Uttaranchal who was also the chancellor of the Kumaon University to institute an enquiry to investigate the case. [15] The committee led by a retired judge of Allahabad high court Justice S.R. Singh consisted of Prof K.B. Powar, former chief of the Association of Indian Universities, New Delhi, Prof Indira Nath, former secretary of the Society of Scientific Values and AIIMS faculty member and physicist Prof R. Rajaraman of JNU. The committee presented its report in February 2003 upholding the plagiarism charges. [16] Prof. Rajput maintained that he has personally done no harm and it was his student's fault. However, he resigned from Vice-chancellorship immediately after the report. [17]

Sangiliyandi Gurunathan controversy

Sangiliyandi Gurunathan, a professor from Kalasalingam University in India, has been found to be involved in plagiarism. [18] [19] [20] [21] [22]

Gopal Kundu controversy

A controversy erupted in National Centre for Cell Science (NCCS), Pune in 2006 when an anonymous mail alleged that the authors (H. Rangaswami and Colleagues from the group of Dr. Gopal Kundu) may have misrepresented data (especially through Western blots) in a paper published in Journal of Biological Chemistry . The allegation was that they had rehashed the same set of data which they had published earlier. [23] [24] An internal committee of the NCCS advised the authors to take back their paper, however an independent committee led by G. Padmanabhan, a former director of Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, concluded that there was no manipulation in the data. [25] This led to some heated debate between Indian Scientists with several viewpoints being presented. [26] [27] On 23 February 2007, the Journal of Biological Chemistry withdrew the paper amid allegations of data manipulation. The authors still maintain that the two papers used different set of data though similar experiments. [28] In November 2010, after an internal investigation by its ethics committee, the Indian Academy of Sciences banned Gopal Kundu from participating in their activities for three years. [29]

Prof. P. Chiranjeevi controversy

Chemistry professor of Sri Venkateswara University (SVU) is accused of plagiarising more than 70 research papers published between 2004 and 2007. University Executive Council has banned him from undertaking examination work and research guidance. He has been debarred from securing further promotions and appointments to administrative positions. [30]

Dr. Ram B. Singh controversy

A private practitioner based in Moradabad, Uttar Pradesh, India is suspected of research fraud. [31]

Prof. K. Kumar controversy

In yet another high-profile case involving a Director of an Indian technical institute, a web campaign, similar to the campaign started by physicists in India, reported plagiarism in papers published by Prof. Kalyan Kumar and colleagues at North Eastern Regional Institute of Science and Technology, NERIST, India. Three papers have been reported to have similarity to works reported earlier. Two of these, "Improved PID controller using fuzzy precompensated algorithm for PMBLDC motor drive" ( AMSE Advances in Modelling and Analysis C , Volume 61, number 1-2, January 2006, Page (s) 1–15) and "Optimum PI controller for Permanent Magnet Brushless DC Motor" ( Electrical Review , Volume 12, No 6, June 2005, Pages 16 –23) have been shown to be very similar to earlier papers by Bhim Singh, AHN Reddy and SS Murthy of Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi. The papers of Singh, Reddy and Murthy, viz "Hybrid fuzzy logic proportional plus conventional integral-derivative controller for permanent magnet brushless DC motor" ( IEEE International Conference on Industrial Technology 2000, Volume 2, 19–22 January 2000, pp. 185–191) and "Gain Scheduling Control of Permanent Magnet Brushless dc Motor" ( Journal of Institution of Engineers  : India EL, Vol 84, September 2003 ) predate the papers of Kumar and Singh by five years.

In yet another controversy, the same group of authors have claimed to publish a paper entitled, "Sensorless control of permanent magnet brushless dc motors" in Electrical Review (Volume 14, No 1, January 2007, Pages 10–14), which has been reported to have high similarity to a thirteen-year-old paper entitled "Sensorless control of permanent magnet AC motors" by K. Rajshekara and A. Kawamura from EPS Anderson and Yokohama University, published in Proceedings of the 20th International Conference on Industrial Electronics, Control and Instrumentation, 1994. IECON'94, Bologna, Italy, Volume 3, September 1994, Page(s): 1589 – 1594. [32] [33]

K. Muthukumar controversy

Another controversy occurred in 2007, this time surrounding authors from Anna University and Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research (IGCAR) publishing an article in the Journal of Materials Science . [34] [35] The article written by K. Muthukumar, T. Mathews, S. Selladurai and R. Bokalawela was reported to be a reproduction of an article published earlier in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) by David Andersson and others at the Royal Institute of Technology, Sweden. In a correction published online, the journal reported that the article 'does not just plagiarise the results presented in the PNAS paper but actually copies most of it word for word'. The journal had started an investigation and is also working with officials at the two institutions. The three authors other than the first author have distanced themselves from the paper and the first author has accepted his mistake.

Prof Balakrishnan and Prof Ashok Pandey controversy

Ashok Pandey is a scientist of the National Institute for Interdisciplinary Science and Technology of India's Council of Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR). He is the editor of several well known international journals in Biotechnology. He appears in the list of most cited authors and received the Thomson Scientific Citation Laureate Award 2006. His paper cited as K. Balakrishnan and A. Pandey (1996) Influence of amino acids on the synthesis of cyclosporin A by Tolypocladium inflatum. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 45: 800–803 which was published as an original article in July 1996, was an extensively plagiarised version of J. Lee and S.N. Agathos (1989) Effect of amino acids on the production of cyclosporin A by Tolypocladium inflatum. Biotechnol Lett 11:77–82. This was pointed out by Agathos in his letter to the Editor of the journal. [36] The Editor-in-Chief of the journal, Alexander Steinbüchel, confronted Ashok Pandey with the evidence and decided that "manuscripts from K. Balakrishnan and A. Pandey will no longer be considered for publication in this journal, and the Editors-in-Chief of other journals covering aspects of microbiology and /or biotechnology will be informed about this matter". [36]

Prof M.R. Adhikari and L.K. Pramanik controversy

A retired academic at Calcutta University, Mahimaranjan Adhikari and his PhD student L.K. Pramanik, have been found to be indulging in Plagiarism, courtesy the American Mathematical Society. AMS has cautioned universities worldwide regarding this incidence. The papers reported to be plagiarised are 'The connectivity of squares of box graphs', 'On edge-connectivity of inserted graphs' and 'Factors of inserted graphs'. The reviews may be found in MathSciNet. The original work was carried out by T Zamfirescu's in the 1970s. An investigation by Calcutta university found these to be true and the university is planning action against the concerned. [37] Prof. M.R. Adhikari for his part has shifted the entire blame on the research scholar Lakshmikanto Pramanik who had "used his name without consent". A reply to the editor of the South East Asian Bulletin of Mathematics (MR2400443) confirms this.

Scientific misconduct and plagiarism by IITs

By the end of the year 2010, three Indian Institutes of Technology, the most prestigious and elite institutes of the nation, have also become controversial due to alleged scientific misconduct and unethical practices. [38] IIT Kharagpur physics professor R.N.P. Choudhary has lost his position as head of department after a junior faculty member Dr. A.K. Thakur accused him of not sharing research credit with him. [38] IIT Delhi was also in news for retraction notice by the Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms in its January 2010 issue, blaming Dr. Anup K Ghosh – a faculty of IIT Delhi, along with others, for being allegedly involved in plagiarism. [39] Nearly a year later, this time Prof. Ashok Kumar of Bioscience and Bioengineering school of IIT Kanpur has been accused with plagiarism charges by the journal Biotechnology Advances and subsequently retracted two of his articles. [40] [41]

Dr. Sanjeeb Kumar Sahoo controversy

Dr. S.K. Sahoo is a scientist in the field of nanotechnology (cancer drug delivery) at the Institute of Life Sciences (an autonomous institute of the Department of Biotechnology, Govt. of India) located in Bhubaneswar, India. [42] There have been serious concerns related to the accuracy of the data presented in many articles published by him. [43] According to a notice published in the June 2013 issue of the journal Acta Biomaterialia, five research articles published by Dr. S.K. Sahoo have been retracted following highly unethical practices such as serial self plagiarism, data manipulation and falsification of results. [44]

Other

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scientific misconduct</span> Violation of codes of scholarly conduct and ethical behavior in scientific research

Scientific misconduct is the violation of the standard codes of scholarly conduct and ethical behavior in the publication of professional scientific research. It is violation of scientific integrity: violation of the scientific method and of research ethics in science, including in the design, conduct, and reporting of research.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">C. N. R. Rao</span> Indian chemist (born 1934)

Chintamani Nagesa Ramachandra Rao,, is an Indian chemist who has worked mainly in solid-state and structural chemistry. He has honorary doctorates from 86 universities from around the world and has authored around 1,800 research publications and 56 books. He is described as a scientist who had won all possible awards in his field except the Nobel Prize.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Brian Wansink</span> American consumer behavior researcher

Brian Wansink is an American former professor and researcher who worked in consumer behavior and marketing research. He was the executive director of the USDA's Center for Nutrition Policy and Promotion (CNPP) from 2007 to 2009 and held the John S. Dyson Endowed Chair in the Applied Economics and Management Department at Cornell University, where he directed the Cornell Food and Brand Lab.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sambalpur University</span> Public Research University in Odisha, India

Sambalpur University is a public research university located in Burla town, of district Sambalpur, India, in the state of Odisha. Popularly known as Jyoti Vihar, it offers courses at the undergraduate, post-graduate and doctoral (Ph.D.) levels. The governor of Odisha is the chancellor of the university. The campus is located 15 km away from Sambalpur.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sunil Mukhi</span> Indian physicist

Sunil Mukhi is an Indian theoretical physicist working in the areas of string theory, quantum field theory and particle physics. Currently he is adjunct professor at the International Centre for Theoretical Sciences of the Tata Institute of Fundamental Research and honorary professor emeritus at the Indian Institute of Science Education and Research, Pune.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Science and technology in Pakistan</span> Overview of Pakistani science and technology

Science and technology is a growing field in Pakistan and has played an important role in the country's development since its founding. Pakistan has a large pool of scientists, engineers, doctors, and technicians assuming an active role in science and technology. The real growth in science in Pakistan occurred after the establishment of the Higher education Commission in 2002 which supported science in a big way and also became the major sponsor of the Pakistan Academy of Sciences under the leadership of Prof. Atta-ur-Rahman. The emphasis was placed on quality rather than numbers during this period. The quality measures introduced by Prof. Atta-ur-Rahman as Founding Chairman HEC included:1) All Ph.D. thesis were evaluated by eminent foreign scientists,2) All PhD theses and research papers were checked for plagiarism 3) Some 11,000 students were sent abroad to leading universities for PhD level training and absorbed on their return, 4) Appointments at faculty positions were linked to international stature of the applicants as judged from their international publications, patents and citations, and (5) Quality Enhancement Cells were established in all universities for the first time in the history of the country. (6) The minimum criteria for establishment of a new university were approved by the Cabinet and universities that did not meet these criteria were closed down. (7) The Model University Ordinance was approved setting the governance parameters for new universities. (8) A list of fake higher education institutions was prepared and made public. (9) Quality Assurance Agency (QAA) was set up within the Higher Education Commission that established Quality Enhancement Cells (QECs) as its operational units in public and private-sector universities across the country. (10) The funding of universities was linked to excellence in teaching and research under a formula based funding mechanism that considered enrolment, subjects and quality of teaching and research. The first IT policy and implementation strategy was approved under the leadership of Prof. Atta-ur-Rahman, then Federal Minister of Science & technology, in August 2000 which laid the foundations of the development of this sector On the request of Prof. Atta-ur-Rahman, Intel initiated a nationwide programme to train school teachers in Information and Communication technologies in March 2002 which has led to the training of 220,000 school teachers in 70 districts and cities across Pakistan. A 15-year tax holiday was approved on the recommendation of Prof. Atta-ur-Rahman which has resulted in growth of IT business from $30 million in 2001 to over $3 billion. The Pakistan Austria University of Applied Engineering (Fachhochschule) has been established in Haripur Hazara under a Steering Committee Chaired by Prof. Atta-ur-Rahman in which students will get degrees from several Austrian universities. Pakistan's growth in scientific output can be seen from the fact that in 1990 Pakistan published 926 scholarly documents while in 2018 the number rose to 20548, a twenty times increase.In contrast India published 21443 scholarly documents in 1990 and the number rose to 171356 in 2018, an eight times increase. In 2018, 336 people per million were researchers in the R&D in Pakistan compared to 256 people per million being researchers in India. The reforms begun by Prof. Atta-ur-Rahman FRS in 2003-2008 have continued over the subsequent decade and according to the Web of Science report, there was a 300% growth in research publications in 2019 over the decade, with 2019 marking the first year in which Pakistan was ranked above the world average in research. In 2019, Pakistan produced 300% more publications indexed in the Web of Science Core Collection than in 2010. In the decade of 2010-2019, more than half of Pakistan’s research was published in journals with Impact Factor. The global influence of Pakistan’s research is increasing as scientists in the country are publishing more in top quartile journals. The Category Normalized Citation Impact of Pakistan’s publications has risen from 0.67 to 1.03. output. As of 2020, Pakistan has 85% teledensity with 183 million cellular, 98 million 3G/4G and 101 million broadband subscribers, due to the foundations laid by Prof. Atta-ur-Rahman of the IT and telecom industry during 2000-2008. In an analysis of scientific research productivity of Pakistan, in comparison to Brazil, Russia, India and China, Thomson Reuters has applauded the developments that have taken place as a result of the reforms introduced by Prof. Atta-ur-Rahman FRS, since Pakistan has emerged as the country with the highest increase in the percentage of highly cited papers in comparison to the "BRIC" countries

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Prem Chand Pandey</span> Indian scientist

Prem Chand Pandey is an Indian space scientist, planetary scientist, and academic in the fields of satellite oceanography, remote sensing, atmospheric science, the Antarctic and climate change, and also he is the founding director of the National Centre for Polar and Ocean Research (NCPOR).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">M. R. S. Rao</span> Indian scientist (1948–2023)

Manchanahalli Rangaswamy Satyanarayana Rao was an Indian scientist. He was awarded the fourth-highest civilian award, the Padma Shri, for Science and Engineering in 2010. From 2003 to 2013 he was president of Jawaharlal Nehru Centre for Advanced Scientific Research (JNCASR) in Bangalore, India.

Scientific Reports is a peer-reviewed open-access scientific mega journal published by Nature Portfolio, covering all areas of the natural sciences. The journal was established in 2011. The journal states that their aim is to assess solely the scientific validity of a submitted paper, rather than its perceived importance, significance, or impact.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">B. S. Sahay</span>

Prof. B. S. Sahay is the Founder Director, Indian Institute of Management Jammu. He was the Founder Director of Indian Institute of Management (IIM) Raipur, Management Development Institute (MDI), Gurgaon and Institute of Management Technology (IMT), Ghaziabad. Sahay completed his BTech from BIT Sindri and received his MTech and PhD from Indian Institute of Technology Delhi.

Gopal Chandra Kundu is an Indian cell and cancer biologist and a Senior Scientist (Scientist-G) at National Centre for Cell Science. He is known for his contributions towards the understanding the mechanism of cancer progression in breast, melanoma and other cancers and development of novel therapeutic targets and target-based therapy in cancers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dinakar Mashnu Salunke</span>

Dinakar Masanu Salunke is an immunologist and structural biologist Presently, he is the Director of International Centre for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology (ICGEB) New Delhi. Earlier he was the Executive Director of newly established Regional Centre for Biotechnology (RCB), an institution jointly set up by Department of Biotechnology (India) and UNESCO at Faridabad. He is the recipient of Shanti Swarup Bhatnagar Prize for Science and Technology in the category of biological sciences and Fellow of all major science academies in India.

Palle Rama Rao FREng is an Indian scientist noted for his contribution to the field of Physical and Mechanical Metallurgy. He has collaborated and conducted research activities for over dozen universities and associations all over India and abroad. He has been honoured with the titles of Padma Vibhushan in 2011 by president of India for his contributions to scientific community. He is acting as the chairman, Governing Council, International Advanced Research Centre for Powder Metallurgy & New Materials (ARCI), Hyderabad.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Khadg Singh Valdiya</span> Indian geologist and academic (1937–2020)

Khadg Singh Valdiya was an Indian geologist and a former vice chancellor of Kumaon University, internationally recognized for his path-breaking work in the fields of geodynamics and Environmental Science. A 2007 recipient of Padma Shri, he was honoured again by the Government of India in 2015 with Padma Bhushan, the third highest Indian civilian award.

Vijay Kumar is an Indian molecular biologist, virologist and an honorary scientist at the International Centre for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology. Known for his research in hepatology, Kumar is an elected fellow of National Academy of Sciences, India, National Academy of Medical Sciences, and National Academy of Agricultural Sciences as well as a J. C. Bose National Fellow of the Department of Biotechnology. The Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, the apex agency of the Government of India for scientific research, awarded him the Shanti Swarup Bhatnagar Prize for Science and Technology, one of the highest Indian science awards for his contributions to Medical Sciences in 1997.

Arun Mallojirao Jayannavar was an Indian condensed matter physicist and a senior professor at the Institute of Physics, Bhubaneswar. Known for his research on many interdisciplinary areas of condensed matter physics, Jayannavar was an elected fellow of all the three major Indian science academies viz. Indian Academy of Sciences, National Academy of Sciences, India and Indian National Science Academy. The Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, the apex agency of the government of India for scientific research, awarded Jayannavar the Shanti Swarup Bhatnagar Prize for Science and Technology, one of the highest Indian science awards, for his contributions to physical sciences in 1998.

Joyoti Basu is an Indian biochemist, cell biologist and a senior professor at the Bose Institute. Known for her studies on the membrane structure of red blood cells, Basu is an elected fellow of all three major Indian science academies, namely the National Academy of Sciences, India, the Indian Academy of Sciences and the Indian National Science Academy, as well as the Indian Society for Chemical Biology. The Department of Biotechnology of the Government of India awarded her the National Bioscience Award for Career Development, one of the highest Indian science awards, for her contributions to biosciences in 2002.

Kumaravel Somasundaram is an Indian cancer biologist and a professor at the Department of Microbiology and Cell Biology of the Indian Institute of Science. Known for his studies on the therapeutics of Glioblastoma, Somasunderam is an elected fellow of all the three major Indian science academies namely, the National Academy of Sciences, India, the Indian Academy of Sciences and the Indian National Science Academy. The Department of Biotechnology of the Government of India awarded him the National Bioscience Award for Career Development, one of the highest Indian science awards, for his contributions to biosciences in 2006.

Sunil Kumar Manna is an Indian immunologist and the head of the immunology lab of the Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics. He is known for his studies on cell signaling and apoptosis. The Department of Biotechnology of the Government of India awarded him the National Bioscience Award for Career Development, one of the highest Indian science awards, for his contributions to biosciences, in 2009.

References

  1. ↑ In India, plagiarism is on the rise, GlobalPost.
  2. ↑ YP GUPTA (4 October 2023). "INTELLECTUAL FRAUD:Punishment For Plagiarised Research Must Be Severe". The Statesman.
  3. ↑ TV Padma (27 February 2007). "India 'needs independent ethics body' says watchdog". SciDev.net.
  4. ↑ "Society For Scientific Values – Homepage". Scientificvalues.org. Retrieved 1 September 2010.
  5. ↑ Indian Institute Of Management vs Ukakant Shrivastva on 16 March, 2001 Archived 17 October 2013(Date mismatch) at the Wayback Machine
  6. ↑ "Plagiarism finger at IIM head". The Telegraph. Calcutta, India. 4 March 2012. Archived from the original on 16 October 2013.
  7. ↑ http://www.pagalguy.com/news/why-chairman-member-iim-indores-board-a-8796288/ [ dead link ]
  8. ↑ "IIM-Indore Chairman resigns; alleges irregularities". The Times of India . Archived from the original on 16 October 2013.
  9. ↑ "Physics Plagiarism Alert". 27 October 2009. Archived from the original on 27 October 2009. Retrieved 21 July 2012.
  10. ↑ R. Ramchandra (8 November 2002). "The physics of plagiarism". The Frontline . Archived from the original on 14 October 2007.
  11. ↑ Manu P. Singh and B. S. Rajput*. "843–858". Progress of Theoretical Physics . Retrieved 1 September 2010.
  12. ↑ N. Gopal Raj (27 September 2002). "Plagiarism scandal brewing". The Hindu . Archived from the original on 10 November 2002.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
  13. ↑ "Archived copy" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 7 March 2007. Retrieved 3 November 2007.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
  14. ↑ SMA Kazmi (5 October 2002). "Kumaon prof says she blew plagiarism whistle on V-C, so he suspended her". The Indian Express .
  15. ↑ "Probe into plagiarism charge". The Frontline . 8 November 2002.
  16. ↑ P. Bagla (4 February 2003). "Probe panel upholds plagiarism charges against Kumaon V-C". The Indian Express .
  17. ↑ "Kumaon University V-C resigns". The Hindu . 7 February 2003. Archived from the original on 7 March 2003.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
  18. ↑ Pranav N Desai (15 October 2011). "Check plagiarism in science". The New Indian Express. Archived from the original on 20 August 2016.
  19. ↑ ivanoransky (7 August 2011). "India's Kalasalingam University swiftly fires professor, kicks out six students after data manipulation scandal". Retraction Watch.
  20. ↑ Elayappan Banumathi (2011). "Retraction Note : PEDF inhibits VEGF- and EPO- induced angiogenesis in retinal endothelial cells through interruption of PI3K/Akt phosphorylation". Angiogenesis. 14 (3): 407–408. doi: 10.1007/s10456-011-9224-2 . PMID   21769485.
  21. ↑ Sheikpranbabu Sardarpasha (2011). "Retraction notice to "Pigment epithelium-derived factor inhibits vascular endothelial growth factor-and interleukin-1beta-induced vascular permeability and angiogenesis in retinal endothelial cells" Vascular Pharmacology 52 (2010) 84–94". Vascular Pharmacology. 55 (5–6): 189. doi:10.1016/j.vph.2011.08.217. PMID   21893214.
  22. ↑ Kalishwaralal Kalimuthu (2011). "Retraction Note: Gold nanoparticles inhibit vascular endothelial growth factor-induced angiogenesis and vascular permeability via Src dependent pathway in retinal endothelial cells". Angiogenesis. 14 (3): 409–410. doi: 10.1007/s10456-011-9225-1 . PMID   21773740.
  23. ↑ "Now, Pune scientists face allegations of plagiarism". Yahoo India. 10 March 2007.
  24. ↑ "Kundu-JBC Case". Society for Scientific Values.
  25. ↑ G.S. mudur (6 March 2007). "Indicted there, acquitted here". The Telegraph. Calcutta, India. Archived from the original on 3 February 2013.
  26. ↑ S.P. Modak (10 June 2007). "Investigating Misconduct in Science" (PDF). Current Science . 92 (11).
  27. ↑ G. Padmanabhan (10 June 2007). "The NCCS Case" (PDF). Current Science . 92 (11).
  28. ↑ Hema Rangaswami (12 September 2007). "'Coping with misconduct in Indian science': a response". The Hindu . Chennai, India. Archived from the original on 15 January 2010.
  29. ↑ Hema Rangaswami (14 November 2010). "Rehashing catches up – Once-acquitted biologist barred for 3 years". The Telegraph. Kolkata, India. Archived from the original on 3 February 2013.
  30. ↑ "Alleged scientific fraud by SVU professor". The Hindu . Chennai, India. 23 February 2008. Archived from the original on 28 February 2008.
  31. ↑ White C (30 July 2005). "Suspected research fraud: difficulties of getting at the truth". The BMJ . 331 (7511): 281–8. doi:10.1136/bmj.331.7511.281. PMC   1181273 . PMID   16052022.
  32. ↑ "Plagiarism Alert". Archived from the original on 27 October 2009.
  33. ↑ "AAPSU demands ouster of NERIST Director". webindia123.
  34. ↑ "Anna University in plagiarism scandal" (PDF). Archived from the original on 7 April 2012. Retrieved 1 September 2010.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
  35. ↑ "Article: Anna University in plagiarism scandal". Hindustan Times . 20 October 2007. Archived from the original on 29 March 2015. Retrieved 31 May 2010.
  36. 1 2 Appl Microbiol Biotechnol (1997) 48:432–433
  37. ↑ "CU maths prof branded plagiarist". The Times of India. 2 January 2008.
  38. 1 2
  39. ↑ Chawla Shashi (2010). "Retraction notice to "Functional polymers synthesized by grafting of glycidyl methacrylate onto swift heavy ions irradiated BOPP films using chemical initiator" [Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 2009; 267(14) 2416–2422]". Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms. 268: 227. doi: 10.1016/j.nimb.2009.12.013 .
  40. ↑ Mishra Ruchi (2010). "Retraction notice to "Microbial production of dihydroxyacetone" [Biotech Adv. 26 (2008) 293–303]". Biotechnology Advances. 28 (6): 938. doi: 10.1016/j.biotechadv.2010.08.002 . PMID   20891033.
  41. ↑ Gupta Radha (2010). "Retraction notice to "Molecular imprinting in sol–gel matrix" [Biotech Adv. 26 (2008) 533–547]". Biotechnology Advances. 28 (6): 939. doi:10.1016/j.biotechadv.2010.08.003. PMID   20891034.
  42. ↑ Institute of Life Sciences. Ils.res.in.
  43. ↑ Dr. Sanjeeb Kumar Sahoo. Sk-sahoo.blogspot.cz (8 May 2013).
  44. ↑ Parhi Priyambada, Mohanty Chandana, Kumar Sahoo Sanjeeb (2013). "Retraction notice to "Enhanced cellular uptake and in vivo pharmacokinetics of rapamycin loaded cubic phase nanoparticles for cancer therapy" [Acta BioMaterialia 7 (2011) 3656–3669]". Acta Biomaterialia. 9 (6): 7078. doi: 10.1016/j.actbio.2013.04.006 . PMID   23802321.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  45. ↑ Vaidyanathan Ramanathan, Kalishwaralal Kalimuthu, Gopalram Shubaash, Gurunathan Sangiliyandi (2010). "Retraction notice to "Nanosilver – The burgeoning therapeutic molecule and its green synthesis" [Biotech Adv. 27 (2009) 924–937]". Biotechnology Advances. 28 (6): 940. doi: 10.1016/j.biotechadv.2010.08.010 . PMID   20891035.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  46. ↑ Jayaraman, K. S. (24 February 2012). "Indian science adviser caught up in plagiarism row". Nature . doi:10.1038/nature.2012.10102. S2CID   178887072.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.