South of the Border (2009 film)

Last updated

South of the Border
Poster of the movie South of the Border.jpg
Theatrical release poster
Directed by Oliver Stone
Written by Tariq Ali
Mark Weisbrot
Produced byFernando Sulichin
Jose Ibanez
Rob Wilson
Starring Hugo Chávez
Evo Morales
Cristina Kirchner
Néstor Kirchner
Rafael Correa
Raúl Castro
Fernando Lugo
Lula da Silva
Tariq Ali
Narrated byOliver Stone
CinematographyCarlos Marcovich
Albert Maysles
Lucas Fuica
Edited byAlexis Chavez
Elisa Bonora
Music byAdam Peters
Production
companies
Good Apple Productions
Ixtlan
Muse Productions
New Element Productions
Pentagrama Films
Distributed byCinema Libre
Release date
  • September 2009 (2009-09)
Running time
78 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish

South of the Border is a 2009 American documentary film directed by Oliver Stone. The documentary premiered at the 2009 Venice Film Festival. Writer for the project Tariq Ali calls the documentary "a political road movie". [1]

Contents

The film has Stone and his crew travel from the Caribbean down the spine of the Andes in an attempt to explain the "phenomenon" of Venezuelan president Hugo Chávez, and account for the continent's "pink tide" leftward tilt. A key feature is also Venezuela's recent Bolivarian revolution and Latin America's political progress in the 21st century. Stone stated that he hopes the film will help people better understand a leader who is wrongly ridiculed "as a strongman, as a buffoon, as a clown." [2]

In addition to Chávez, Stone sought to flesh out several other Latin American presidents whose policies and personalities generally get limited, or according to Stone, biased media attention in the United States and Europe, notably: Evo Morales of Bolivia; Cristina Kirchner and former president Néstor Kirchner of Argentina; Rafael Correa of Ecuador; Raúl Castro of Cuba; Fernando Lugo of Paraguay; and Lula da Silva of Brazil. [1]

Content

The documentary examines the free-market economic policies of the U.S. and the International Monetary Fund, and how they have largely failed to alleviate Latin America's chronic income inequality. The film suggests that financial calamities such as the Argentine peso collapse of 2001, combined with Latin suspicions of U.S. drug-eradication efforts and resentment over the selling off of natural resources through multinational companies, have contributed to the rise of socialist and social-democratic leaders across the region.

According to the Associated Press, "Stone said he didn't see it necessary to present the opposition's case in his film." [3]

Production

We were not writing a book, or having an academic debate. It was to have a sympathetic view of these governments.

—Tariq Ali, South of the Border writer [4]

Oliver Stone spoke of his move to balance the media reactions to other pink tide leaders in the region: "... the project started as something about the American media demonizing Latin leaders. It became more than that as we got more involved. The press in America, I think you're aware, has divided the Latin continent into the 'bad Left' and the 'good Left'." [1]

US economist Mark Weisbrot advised Stone on the documentary and was credited as one of the writers alongside Tariq Ali. [3] [5] [6] [7]

In May 2010, Stone began a Latin American tour to promote the film, with screenings planned in Ecuador, Brazil, Bolivia, Paraguay and Argentina. The documentary was also being released in some cities in the United States and Europe later in 2010. [2]

The Box Office Mojo site reports that as of August 2010 the film had grossed $198,600 domestically. [8]

The documentary was released in the U.K. at the end of July 2010 by Dogwoof film distributors. [9]

Reception

South of the Border received mixed reviews, and has as a score of 45 out of 100 on Metacritic, based on 19 film reviews collected. [10]

United States

The Hollywood Reporter wrote that the film is "a rebuttal of what [Stone] views as the fulminations and lies of right-wing media at home and abroad regarding the socialist democracies of South America". [11]

Time magazine described the film as a "slapdash effort", "amateur night as cinema, as lopsided and cheerleadery as its worldview". [12]

He raises no tough issues, some of which are summarized in Amnesty International's 2009 report on Venezuela: "Attacks on journalists were widespread. Human-rights defenders continued to suffer harassment. Prison conditions provoked hunger strikes in facilities across the country." [12]

Variety said, "The docu ( sic ) offers little genuine information and no investigative research, adopting a style even more polemical than Stone’s earlier focus on Fidel Castro and Yasser Arafat." [13] Reuters said Stone "deliver[ed] a strong endorsement of Chavez's socialist agenda, and question[ed] the tenets of what he calls U.S. 'predatory capitalism,'" [14]

Bloomberg's journalist, Fabiola Moura described the film as "rosy in its picture", while being "a tonic dose of a perspective rarely seen in U.S. media coverage of the region", [15] and commented:

The movie doesn’t mention Chavez’s blacklisting of millions of people who signed a petition seeking a recall vote against him in 2004; the persecution of political rivals; the creation of a new "Capital District" to usurp power from the opposition-led Caracas city government; and the refusal to renew the broadcasting license of Radio Caracas Television, the country’s oldest station. [15]

NPR says the film tells only one side of the story and gives "kid glove treatment" to Chavez and his allies. [16]

The Chicago Sun-Times gave the film a favourable review. The reviewer stated, in regards to the film's criticism that "those criticisms ironically validate another theme of the documentary: the media's often biased coverage of Latin American politics." [17]

Foreign Policy magazine said Stone asked softball questions of the South American leaders and

More troubling is how South of the Border masquerades as journalism... The film leaves the viewer flush with platitudes about the leader's Bolivarian Revolution, but with a head full of unanswered questions about how it actually works..... But Stone seems content to take virtually everything he sees at face value.... In the end, the film tell us less about Latin America than it does about Oliver Stone, and his career-long quest to expose Washington's supposedly implacable hegemonic designs. [18]

Larry Rohter wrote in The New York Times accusing the film of "misinformation." [19] On June 28, 2010, Oliver Stone responded to Rohter by rejecting the reporter's criticisms, saying they were not founded in fact, and criticizing the Times for its editorial board’s endorsement of the military coup of April 11, 2002 against the elected government of Venezuela, which he argued was "embarrassing" to the newspaper. [20] Stone said that Rohter had written an article on April 12, 2002 which strongly endorsed the coup in Venezuela and other anti-Chavez articles previously. [21] Stone's rebuttal concludes with the statement: "It is not surprising that someone [Rohter] who supports the military overthrow of a democratically elected government would not like a documentary like this one, which celebrates the triumphs of electoral democracy in South America over the last decade." [20] [21] Mark Weisbrot added that "he [Rohter] failed to find any factual errors in the film – despite some rather desperate attempts." [22] Rohter replied and reiterated that a number of economical and historical facts were either omitted or changed by the filmmakers in Chavez's favor. He called the accusations levied against him by the film's creators a "smokescreen" and a "smear campaign". [23] The film's creators claimed similar treatment from Rohter.

Ronald Radosh criticized the film in the Wall Street Journal . [24]

Mark Weisbrot, who worked on the movie, wrote: "It's nice when you make a documentary about how the major media outlets misrepresent reality, and the media response to the film proves your point. In fact, the media's response to Oliver Stone's South of the Border, which I wrote with Tariq Ali, really completes a number of the film's arguments." [22]

Tariq Ali, who also worked on the movie added: “It’s hardly a secret that we support the other side. It’s an opinionated documentary”...“the aim of our film is very clear and basic.” In “South of the Border,” he added: “We were not writing a book, or having an academic debate. It was to have a sympathetic view of these governments.” [25]

United Kingdom

The documentary received mixed reviews from the mainstream press. Steve Rose wrote in The Guardian that it was "unashamedly partisan and unintentionally hilarious – both of which make it highly watchable." [26] Rose praises Stone for correcting the partisan view of the US media, but criticises Stone's interview approach, saying: "Full credit to the director for correcting the view perpetrated by the US media: that the continent's new leftist presidents, particularly Venezuela's Hugo Chávez and Bolivia's Evo Morales, are 'dictators' bent on America's destruction, rather than democratically elected leaders ..." And that "Stone goes on to shoot himself in the foot with a series of clumsy, sycophantic interviews. He thinks he's being Walter Cronkite but he's more Alan Partridge." [26] The film received a rating of one star out of five from The Independent reviewer who said "it becomes clear that Stone is ill-equipped to conduct a serious political analysis of the continent. He gets amazing access to national leaders and yet, face to face with them, he doesn't even look interested in what they have to say." [27]

Latin America

In Venezuela, the film grossed US$18,601 on 20 screens after 12 days. [28] The film was criticised by Leopoldo López, an opposition leader, for ignoring and not mentioning a number of very serious problems in Venezuela such as escalating crime, inflation, food scarcity, housing, and access to water and electricity which has worsened under Chavez's rule. He disagrees with Stone's argument that "most peoples' lives in this country have improved under Chavez". [29] Stone responded that presenting the second party opposition's case in the documentary was not his main goal. He also said that: "People forget that he cut the poverty rate by one half...People in Venezuela are getting an education, they are getting health care and welfare. [Chavez] actually delivered on what he said he would." [3]

Other

Tariq Ali who collaborated with Stone to make the film remarked that: "These changes that are taking place are not coming about through armed struggle or guerrilla warfare or Che Guevara. All these changes have come about through democratic elections." [1]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hugo Chávez</span> President of Venezuela, 1999–2002 and 2002–2013

Hugo Rafael Chávez Frías was a Venezuelan politician and military officer who served as president of Venezuela from 1999 until his death in 2013, except for a brief period of forty-seven hours in 2002. Chávez was also leader of the Fifth Republic Movement political party from its foundation in 1997 until 2007, when it merged with several other parties to form the United Socialist Party of Venezuela (PSUV), which he led until 2012.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bolivarian Revolution</span> 21st-century political process in Venezuela

The Bolivarian Revolution is a political process in Venezuela that was led by Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez, the founder of the Fifth Republic Movement and later the United Socialist Party of Venezuela (PSUV), and his successor Nicolás Maduro. The Bolivarian Revolution is named after Simón Bolívar, an early 19th-century Venezuelan revolutionary leader, prominent in the Spanish American wars of independence in achieving the independence of most of northern South America from Spanish rule. According to Chávez and other supporters, the Bolivarian Revolution seeks to build an inter-American coalition to implement Bolivarianism, nationalism and a state-led economy.

Comandante is a political documentary film by American director Oliver Stone. In the film, Stone interviews Cuban leader Fidel Castro on a diverse range of topics. Stone and his film crew visited Castro in Cuba for three days in 2002, and the film was released in 2003, having its premiere at the Sundance Film Festival early that year. The film was partly produced by HBO and was planned for broadcast. Shortly before airtime, after Cuba executed three hijackers of a ferry to the United States and imprisoned more than 70 political dissidents, HBO pulled the program. To this day, it still has not been given a video release in the USA.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2002 Venezuelan coup attempt</span> Temporary ousting of President of Venezuela Hugo Chavez on 11 April 2002

A failed coup d'état on 11 April 2002 saw the president of Venezuela, Hugo Chávez, ousted from office for 47 hours before being restored to power. Chávez was aided in his return to power by popular support and mobilization against the coup by loyal ranks in the military. The coup was reported to have been planned for some time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Telesur</span> Public television network in Venezuela

Telesur is a Latin American terrestrial and satellite news television network headquartered in Caracas, Venezuela and sponsored by the governments of Venezuela, Cuba and Nicaragua.

<i>The Revolution Will Not Be Televised</i> (film) 2003 documentary about Venezuelan coup

The Revolution Will Not Be Televised, also known as Chávez: Inside the Coup, is a 2003 Irish documentary film. It focuses on events in Venezuela leading up to and during the April 2002 coup d'état attempt, which saw President Hugo Chávez removed from office for two days. With particular emphasis on the role played by Venezuela's private media, the film examines several key incidents: the protest march and subsequent violence that provided the impetus for Chávez's ousting; the opposition's formation of an interim government headed by business leader Pedro Carmona; and the Carmona administration's collapse, which paved the way for Chávez's return. The Revolution Will Not Be Televised was directed by Irish filmmakers Kim Bartley and Donnacha Ó Briain. Given direct access to Chávez, the filmmakers intended to make a fly-on-the-wall biography of the president. They spent seven months filming in Venezuela, following Chávez and his staff and interviewing ordinary citizens. As the coup unfolded on 11 April, Bartley and Ó Briain filmed on the streets of the capital, Caracas, capturing footage of protesters and the erupting violence. Later, they filmed many of the political upheavals inside Miraflores, the presidential palace.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United States–Venezuela relations</span> Bilateral relations

United States–Venezuela relations have traditionally been characterized by an important trade and investment relationship as well as cooperation in combating the production and transit of illegal drugs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aleida Guevara</span> Cuban doctor; daughter of Che Guevara

Aleida Guevara March is a Cuban physician who is the eldest daughter of four children born to Ernesto "Che" Guevara and his second wife, Aleida March.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mark Weisbrot</span> American economist and columnist

Mark Alan Weisbrot is an American economist and columnist. He is co-director with Dean Baker of the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR) in Washington, D.C. Weisbrot is President of Just Foreign Policy, a non-governmental organization dedicated to reforming United States foreign policy.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bank of the South</span> South American monetary fund and lending organization

The Bank of the South or BancoSur is a monetary fund and lending organization established on 26 September 2009 by Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay, Uruguay, Ecuador, Bolivia and Venezuela with promises of initial capital of US$20 billion. Argentina, Venezuela, and Brazil were to have each pledged $4 billion, and Uruguay, Ecuador, Paraguay and Bolivia were to have contributed smaller amounts. The intention of the bank was to lend money to nations in the Americas for the construction of social programs and infrastructure. Documents establishing the bank as an entity were signed in 2007, and the agreement between the countries was finalized in 2009, but as of 2016, the bank had not been capitalized.

<i>The War on Democracy</i> 2007 film

The War on Democracy is a 2007 documentary film directed by Christopher Martin and John Pilger, who also wrote the narration. Focusing on the political situations in nations of Latin America, the film criticizes both the United States' intervention in foreign countries' domestic politics and its "War on Terrorism". The film was first released in the United Kingdom on 15 June 2007.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Republic of Venezuela</span> Republic from 1953 to 1999

The Republic of Venezuela was a democratic republic first established in 1958, and replaced in 1999 by the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela. Venezuela saw ten years of military dictatorship from 1948 to 1958. After the 1948 Venezuelan coup d'état brought an end to a three-year experiment in democracy, a triumvirate of military personnel controlled the government until 1952, when it held presidential elections. These were free enough to produce results unacceptable to the government, leading them to be falsified and to one of the three leaders, Marcos Pérez Jiménez, assuming the Presidency. His government was brought to an end by the 1958 Venezuelan coup d'état, which saw the advent of democracy with a transitional government under Admiral Wolfgang Larrazábal in place until the December 1958 elections. Prior to the elections, three of the main political parties, Acción Democrática, COPEI and Unión Republicana Democrática, with the notable exclusion of the Communist Party of Venezuela, signed up to the Puntofijo Pact power-sharing agreement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oliver Stone</span> American filmmaker (born 1946)

William Oliver Stone is an American film director, producer, and screenwriter. Stone is known as a controversial but acclaimed director, tackling subjects ranging from the Vietnam war, and American politics to musical biopics and crime dramas. He has received numerous accolades including four Academy Awards, a BAFTA Award, a Primetime Emmy Award, and five Golden Globe Awards.

Venezuelanalysis is a pro-Bolivarian Revolution website that describes itself as "an independent website produced by individuals who are dedicated to disseminating news and analysis about the current political situation in Venezuela." Its stated objective is "to counter the corporate media propaganda against the Bolivarian Revolution by giving a voice to leftist and grassroots movements in Venezuela".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2010 Colombia–Venezuela diplomatic crisis</span>

The 2010 Colombia–Venezuela diplomatic crisis was a diplomatic stand-off between Colombia and Venezuela over allegations in July by Colombian President Álvaro Uribe that the Venezuelan government was actively permitting the FARC and ELN guerrillas to seek safe haven in its territory. The Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC), founded in 1964, is the largest of Colombia's left-wing guerilla groups, and the National Liberation Army (ELN), also founded in 1964, is another left-wing guerilla group inspired by the Cuban revolution and Marxist ideology. Uribe presented evidence to the Organization of American States (OAS) and in response, Venezuela broke off diplomatic relations with Colombia amid speculation of a possible war. Both countries eventually reconciled, with the help of the Union of South American nations (UNASUR) and agreed to re-establish diplomatic relations by mid-August.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bolivarian propaganda</span> Pro-Venezuela/Hugo Chávez nationalist propaganda

Bolivarian propaganda is a form of nationalist propaganda, especially in Venezuela and associated with chavismo, Venezuela's socialism. This type of propaganda has been associated with Hugo Chávez's Bolivarian Revolution, which used emotional arguments to gain attention, exploit the fears of the population, create external enemies for scapegoat purposes, and produce nationalism within the population, causing feelings of betrayal for support of the opposition.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gregory Wilpert</span>

Gregory Wilpert is a German activist and founder of Venezuelanalysis.com, a website supportive of Hugo Chávez's Bolivarian Revolution in Venezuela. He has been described as "perhaps the most prominent Chavista". He is currently an editor at the Institute for New Economic Thinking.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tariq Ali</span> British political activist, writer, and historian (born 1943)

Tariq Ali is a Pakistani-British political activist, writer, journalist, historian, filmmaker, and public intellectual. He is a member of the editorial committee of the New Left Review and Sin Permiso, and contributes to The Guardian, CounterPunch, and the London Review of Books. He studied Philosophy, Politics, and Economics at Exeter College, Oxford.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Llaguno Overpass events</span>

The Llaguno Overpass, also known as the Llaguno Bridge, is a bridge in central Caracas, Venezuela, near the Miraflores Palace, made infamous by the events of 11 April 2002, when a shootout took place between the Caracas Metropolitan Police and the pro-government Bolivarian Circles, also known as El Silencio Massacre, causing 19 deaths and 127 injured people. The events preceded the 2002 Venezuelan coup attempt. The military high command refused Hugo Chávez's order to implement the Plan Ávila as a response to protests against him, a military contingency plan by the army to maintain public order last used in 1989 during The Caracazo, and demanded him to resign. President Chávez was subsequently arrested by the military. Chávez's request for asylum in Cuba was denied, and he was ordered to be tried in a Venezuelan court.

Mi amigo Hugo is a Venezuelan television documentary about Venezuelan president Hugo Chávez, produced by the Venezuelan government propaganda network Telesur and directed by Chavez's friend Oliver Stone.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Oliver Stone heads 'South of the Border' to chat up Chavez and others by Reed Johnson, Los Angeles Times , September 1, 2009. (Archived by WebCite at https://www.webcitation.org/5n4FtQ9zB?url=http://articles.latimes.com/2009/sep/01/entertainment/et-stone-doc1
  2. 1 2 Stone: Film an intro to Chavez and his movement, by Ian James, Associated Press, 29-05-2010
  3. 1 2 3 "Chavez gets red-carpet treatment in Venice". today.com. September 8, 2009. Retrieved December 1, 2023.
  4. Rohter, Larry (June 25, 2010). "Oliver Stone's Latin America". The New York Times. The New York Times . Retrieved September 22, 2015.
  5. Archived January 21, 2012, at the Wayback Machine [ dead link ]
  6. "Oliver Stone - Page 2". Interview Magazine. November 25, 2008. Retrieved December 29, 2010.
  7. "Cast & Credits " South of the Border - a film by Oliver Stone". Southoftheborderdoc.com. Retrieved December 29, 2010.
  8. "South of the Border (2010)". Box Office Mojo. August 12, 2010. Retrieved December 29, 2010.
  9. "Home - South of the Border". Southoftheborder.dogwoof.com. Retrieved December 29, 2010.
  10. "South of the Border". Metacritic . Retrieved December 2, 2010.
  11. Bennett, Ray (September 6, 2009). "South of the Border — Film Review". Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved December 1, 2023.
  12. 1 2 Richard Corliss, Time , 8 September 2009, South of the Border: Chávez and Stone's Love Story
  13. Weissberg, Jay (September 6, 2009). "South of the Border Movie Review". Variety.
  14. "Stone says Chavez film may struggle to get U.S. play". Reuters. September 8, 2009.
  15. 1 2 Fabiola Moura, 29 September 2009, Bloomberg , Chavez Rides Kid’s Bike as Oliver Stone Humanizes ’Dictators’
  16. Robert Smith, 25 September 200, NPR, Oliver Stone Profiles Power 'South Of The Border'
  17. Chicago Sun-Times , 9 July 2010, Oliver Stone goes latin: The director questions the 'official' story in 'South of the Border'
  18. Elizabeth Dickinson, Foreign Policy , 24 June 2010, | accessdate = 2010-12-02
  19. Rohter, Larry (June 26, 2010). "Oliver Stone's Latin America". The New York Times.
  20. 1 2 truthdig - truthdigg drilling beneath the headlines, Truthdig , Jun 28, 2010, South of the Border: Oliver Stone Responds to New York Times Attack
  21. 1 2 pulse, 28 June 2010, Stone, Ali, and Weisbrot respond to attack from the New York Times’ Larry Rohter (Stone, Ali and Weisbrot's letter to the New York Times)
  22. 1 2 Mark Weisbrot, guardian.co.uk, 16 July 2010, South of the Border: reviewing the reviewers
  23. Larry Rohter, History News Network, 26 July 2010, Oliver Stone Still Doesn't Get It
  24. WSJ, 26 June 2010, To Chavez, With Love
  25. Larry Rohter, New York Times, 26 July 2010,
  26. 1 2 Steve Rose, The Guardian , 29 July 2010, South of the Border
  27. Anthony Quinn, The Independent , 30 July 2010,
  28. Oliver Stone doc sinks in South America., by Anna Marie de La Fuente, Variety, 10-06-2010
  29. Leopoldo López, The Huffington Post , 15 July 2010, Why Oliver Stone is wrong about Venezuela

Further reading