Symphony No. 3 (Mendelssohn)

Last updated
Symphony No. 3 in A minor
by Felix Mendelssohn
Felix Mendelssohn Bartholdy - Bleistiftzeichnung von Eduard Bendemann 1833.jpg
Drawing of the composer by Eduard Bendemann, 1833
Key A minor
Catalogue Op. 56
Composed1829 (1829)–42
Performed3 March 1842 (1842-03-03)

The Symphony No. 3 in A minor, Op. 56, known as the Scottish, is a symphony by Felix Mendelssohn, composed between 1829 and 1842.




Mendelssohn was initially inspired to compose this symphony during his first visit to Britain in 1829. [1] [2] [3] After a series of successful performances in London, Mendelssohn embarked on a walking tour of Scotland with his friend Karl Klingemann. [4] On 30 July, Mendelssohn visited the ruins of Holyrood Chapel at Holyrood Palace in Edinburgh, where, as he related to his family in a letter, he received his initial inspiration for the piece:

In the deep twilight we went today to the palace were Queen Mary lived and loved...The chapel below is now roofless. Grass and ivy thrive there and at the broken altar where Mary was crowned Queen of Scotland. Everything is ruined, decayed, and the clear heavens pour in. I think I have found there the beginning of my "Scottish" Symphony. [5]

Alongside this description, Mendelssohn enclosed in his letter a scrap of paper with the opening bars of what would become the symphony's opening theme. [6] A few days later Mendelssohn and his companion visited the western coast of Scotland and the island of Staffa, which in turn inspired the composer to start the Hebrides. [7] After completing the first version of the Hebrides, Mendelssohn continued to work on his initial sketches of what would become Symphony No. 3 while touring Italy. [3] However, he struggled to make progress, and after 1831 set the piece aside. [3]

It is not known exactly when Mendelssohn resumed work on the symphony (sketches suggest he may have returned to the first movement in the late 1830s) but he was certainly working in earnest on the piece by 1841 and completed the symphony in Berlin on 20 January 1842. [8] Although it was the fifth and final of Mendelssohn's symphonies to be completed, it was the third to be published, and has subsequently been known as Symphony No. 3. [3] Intriguingly, despite describing the work as his 'Scottish Symphony' to his family in 1829, by the time the work was published in 1842 Mendelssohn never publicly called attention to the symphony's Scottish inspiration, and it is debatable whether he intended the finished work to be considered 'Scottish'. [9] Ever since the Scottish provenance became known following the composer's death, however, audiences have found it hard not to hear the piece as evoking the wild Romantic landscapes of the north - even if such picturesque associations have caused audiences to overlook the many other musical qualities of this symphony.


The premiere took place on 3 March 1842 in the Leipzig Gewandhaus.


The work is scored for an orchestra consisting of two flutes, two oboes, two clarinets in B flat and A, two bassoons, two horns in C and A, two horns in E, F and D, two trumpets in D, timpani, and strings.


External audio
Performed by the Berlin Philharmonic under Herbert von Karajan
Nuvola apps arts.svg I. Andante con moto
Nuvola apps arts.svg II. Vivace non troppo
Nuvola apps arts.svg III. Adagio
Nuvola apps arts.svg IV. Allegro vivacissimo

Mendelssohn's symphony is in four interconnected movements:

  1. Andante con moto — Allegro un poco agitato (in A minor and in sonata form with introduction)
    Orchesterwerke Romantik Themen.pdf
  2. Vivace non troppo (in F major and in sonata form)
    Orchesterwerke Romantik Themen.pdf
  3. Adagio (in A major and in abridged sonata form)
    Orchesterwerke Romantik Themen.pdf
  4. Allegro vivacissimo — Allegro maestoso assai (in A minor → A major and in sonata form)
    Orchesterwerke Romantik Themen.pdf

Unusually, Mendelssohn marked the movements to be performed without breaks, and underlined the connection between the symphony's parts by making them grow from the continual thematic transformation of the original idea he had notated in 1829, presented in the slow introduction to the first movement. [10] Despite this overriding concern for musical unity the emotional scope of the work is wide, consisting of a dark and stormy first movement, a joyous and fairly brief second movement, a slow movement maintaining an apparent struggle between love and fate, and a finale that takes its components from Scottish folk dance.

The lively second movement is melodically and rhythmically in the style of Scottish folk music, using the notes of the pentatonic scale and the characteristic Scotch snap rhythm, although no direct quotations have ever been identified. A novel feature lies in the coda of the finale, where Mendelssohn introduces a new majestic theme in A major to close the work in a contrasting manner to the rest of the A minor finale. Akin to a victory hymn and intended by Mendelssohn to allude to a male-voice choir, this ending returns to the balladic tone of the first movement's introduction, transforming the material of the original inspiration for the piece Mendelssohn had twelve years before. [11] Contemporary musicians such as Robert Schumann found the effect highly poetic, though some later twentieth-century critics have shown aversion to the 'happy ending'. [12] The conductor Otto Klemperer, for instance, disliked this coda and wrote his own ending in a vein similar to the general character of the movement. [13] Recordings of him conducting both endings are available. [14] [15] However, removing the maestoso coda destroys the intricate cyclic structure Mendelssohn has created across the symphony's four movements and nowadays critics are more inclined to recognize the composer's original and lasting contribution to the nineteenth-century symphony. [16]


Related Research Articles

Sonata form is a musical structure consisting of three main sections: an exposition, a development, and a recapitulation. It has been used widely since the middle of the 18th century.

Piano Quintet (Schumann)

The Piano Quintet in E-flat major, Op. 44, by Robert Schumann was composed in 1842 and received its first public performance the following year. Noted for its "extroverted, exuberant" character, Schumann's piano quintet is considered one of his finest compositions and a major work of nineteenth-century chamber music. Composed for piano and string quartet, the work revolutionized the instrumentation and musical character of the piano quintet and established it as a quintessentially Romantic genre.

The Piano Quintet in F minor, Op. 34, by Johannes Brahms was completed during the summer of 1864 and published in 1865. It was dedicated to Her Royal Highness Princess Anna of Hesse. Like most piano quintets composed after Robert Schumann's Piano Quintet (1842), it is written for piano and string quartet.

String Quartet No. 14 (Beethoven)

The String Quartet No. 14 in C minor, Op. 131, was completed by Ludwig van Beethoven in 1826. It is the last-composed of a trio of string quartets, written in the order Opp. 132, 130, 131.

Cyclic form is a technique of musical construction, involving multiple sections or movements, in which a theme, melody, or thematic material occurs in more than one movement as a unifying device. Sometimes a theme may occur at the beginning and end ; other times a theme occurs in a different guise in every part.

Nikolai Medtner Russian composer and pianist

Nikolai Karlovich Medtner was a Russian composer and pianist. After a period of comparative obscurity in the twenty-five years immediately after his death, he is now becoming recognized as one of the most significant Russian composers for the piano.

String Quartet No. 12 (Beethoven)

The String Quartet No. 12 in E major, Op. 127, by Ludwig van Beethoven, was completed in 1825. It is the first of Beethoven's late quartets.

Symphony No. 9 (Schubert)

The Symphony No. 9 in C major, D 944, known as the Great(first published by Breitkopf & Härtel in 1849 as "Symphonie / C Dur / für großes Orchester",listed as Symphony No. 8 in the Neue Schubert-Ausgabe), is the final symphony completed by Franz Schubert. Originally called The Great C major to distinguish it from his Symphony No. 6, the Little C major, the subtitle is now usually taken as a reference to the symphony's majesty. Unusually long for a symphony of its time, a typical performance of The Great lasts an hour when all repeats indicated in the score are taken. The symphony was not professionally performed until a decade after Schubert's death.

Symphony No. 5 (Mendelssohn)

The Symphony No. 5 in D major/D minor, Op. 107, known as the Reformation, was composed by Felix Mendelssohn in 1830 in honor of the 300th anniversary of the Presentation of the Augsburg Confession. The Confession is a key document of Lutheranism and its Presentation to Emperor Charles V in June 1530 was a momentous event of the Protestant Reformation. This symphony was written for a full orchestra and was Mendelssohn's second extended symphony. It was not published until 1868, 21 years after the composer's death – hence its numbering as '5'. Although the symphony is not very frequently performed, it is better known today than when it was originally published. Mendelssohn's sister, Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel, chose the name Reformation Symphony.

The Symphony No. 3 in C minor, Op. 78, was completed by Camille Saint-Saëns in 1886 at what was probably the artistic peak of his career. It is also popularly known as the Organ Symphony, even though it is not a true symphony for organ, but simply an orchestral symphony where two sections out of four use the pipe organ. The composer inscribed it as: Symphonie No. 3 "avec orgue".

Piano Sonata No. 13 (Beethoven)

Piano Sonata No. 13 in E-flat major, Op. 27 No. 1, "Quasi una fantasia", is a sonata composed by Ludwig van Beethoven in 1800–1801.

The Piano Sonata No. 3 in F minor, Op. 5 of Johannes Brahms was written in 1853 and published the following year. The sonata is unusually large, consisting of five movements, as opposed to the traditional three or four. When he wrote this piano sonata, the genre was seen by many to be past its heyday. Brahms, enamored of Beethoven and the classical style, composed Piano Sonata No. 3 with a masterful combination of free Romantic spirit and strict classical architecture. As a further testament to Brahms' affinity for Beethoven, the Piano Sonata is infused with the instantly recognizable motive from Beethoven's Symphony No. 5 during the first, third, and fourth movements. Composed in Düsseldorf, it marks the end of his cycle of three sonatas, and was presented to Robert Schumann in November of that year; it was the last work that Brahms submitted to Schumann for commentary. Brahms was barely 20 years old at its composition. The piece is dedicated to Countess Ida von Hohenthal of Leipzig.

Symphony No. 1 (Mendelssohn)

Symphony No. 1 in C minor, Op. 11, is a work by Felix Mendelssohn, completed on 31 March 1824, when the composer was only 15 years old. The autographed score was published in 1831.

Symphony No. 10 (Schubert)

Schubert's Symphony No. 10 in D major, D 936A, is an unfinished work that survives in a piano sketch. Written during the last weeks of the composer's short life, it was only properly identified in the 1970s. It has been orchestrated by Brian Newbould in a completion that has subsequently been performed, published and recorded.

Piano Trio No. 2 (Mendelssohn)

The Piano Trio No. 2 in C minor, Op. 66, was written by Felix Mendelssohn in 1845 and published in February 1846. The work is scored for a standard piano trio consisting of violin, cello and piano. Mendelssohn dedicated the work to his close friend and violinist, Louis Spohr, who played through the piece with the composer at least once.

The Symphony in C major, WWV 29, is the only completed symphony of Richard Wagner.

Organ Sonatas, Op. 65 (Mendelssohn)

Felix Mendelssohn's six Organ Sonatas, Opus 65, were published in 1845. Mendelssohn's biographer Eric Werner has written of them: "Next to Bach's works, Mendelssohn's Organ Sonatas belong to the required repertory of all organists."

Piano Sonata in B minor (Strauss)

The Piano Sonata in B minor, Op.5, was written by Richard Strauss in 1881–82 when he was 17 years old. The Sonata is in the Romantic style of his teenage years. The first recording of the piece was the last recording made by the Canadian pianist Glenn Gould.

Symphony No. 1 in G minor, "Sérieuse", is an orchestral work by Swedish composer Franz Berwald. It was premiered on December 2, 1842 in a concert at the Royal Opera, Stockholm given by the Swedish Royal Court Orchestra conducted by the composer's cousin Johan Fredrik Berwald. This first performance was not a success, leading to this symphony being the only one of Berwald's mature symphonies to be performed during his lifetime;.

Concert Fantasia for violin with orchestra, Op. 20 is the only violin concertante work by Danish composer Otto Malling published in 1885. A performance takes ca.13,5-16 min.


  1. Bromberger, Eric. "Symphony No. 3 "Scottish"". Los Angeles Philharmonic Association. Archived from the original on 17 October 2013. Retrieved 20 January 2013.
  2. Palmer, John. "Symphony No. 3 in A minor ("Scottish"), Op. 56". Rovi Corporation . Retrieved 20 January 2013.
  3. 1 2 3 4 Rodda, Richard E. "Symphony No. 3 in A minor, Opus 56, "Scottish"". John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts . Retrieved 20 January 2013.
  4. See "The Journey North" in Mendelssohn in Scotland website, accessed 9 January 2015.
  5. R. Larry Todd, 'Mendelssohn', in D. Kern Holoman (ed.), The Nineteenth-Century Symphony (New York: Schirmer, 1997), pp. 78–107
  6. The original sketch has been recorded by Riccardo Chailly and the Gewandhausorchester on 'Mendelssohn Discoveries' (Decca CD 478 1525, 2009)
  7. See website, accessed 9 January 2015
  8. Douglass Seaton, 'A Draft for the Exposition of the First Movement of Mendelssohn's "Scotch" Symphony', Journal of the American Musicological Society, 30 (1977), 129–35
  9. Thomas Schmidt-Beste, 'Just how "Scottish" is the "Scottish" Symphony?', in Cooper and Prandi, The Mendelssohns: Their Music in History (Oxford University Press, 2002), pp. 147-65.
  10. Rey M. Longyear, 'Cyclic Form and Tonal Relationships in Mendelssohn's "Scottish" Symphony', In Theory Only, 4 (1979), 38–48.
  11. Peter Mercer-Taylor, 'Mendelssohn's "Scottish" Symphony and the Music of German Memory', 19th-Century Music, 19 (1995), 68-82.
  12. Robert Schumann, 'Sinfonien für Orchester', Neue Zeitschrift für Musik, 18 (1843)
  13. Walton, Chris (1 January 2004). "Act of Faith: Klemperer and the 'Scottish' Symphony". The Musical Times. 145 (1886): 35–50. doi:10.2307/4149093. JSTOR   4149093.
  14. shostakk (7 August 2012). "Mendelssohn: Symphony no. 3 "Scottish" - Klemperer & Philharmonia Orchestra" via YouTube.
  15. "Mendelssohn: Symphony No. 3 "Scottish" ( BRSO & Otto Klemperer )".
  16. Benedict Taylor, Mendelssohn, Time and Memory: The Romantic Conception of Cyclic Form (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011), pp. 263-75.