The Void (philosophy)

The concept of "The Void" in philosophy encompasses the ideas of nothingness and emptiness, a notion that has been interpreted and debated across various schools of metaphysics. In ancient Greek philosophy, the Void was discussed by thinkers like Democritus, who saw it as a necessary space for atoms to move, thereby enabling the existence of matter. Contrasting this, Aristotle famously denied the existence of a true Void, arguing that nature inherently avoids a vacuum.

In Eastern philosophical traditions, the Void takes on significant spiritual and metaphysical meanings. In Buddhism, Śūnyatā refers to the emptiness inherent in all things, a fundamental concept in understanding the nature of reality. In Taoism, the Void is represented by Wuji , the undifferentiated state from which all existence emerges, embodying both the potential for creation and the absence of form.

Throughout the history of Western thought, the Void has also been explored in the context of existentialism and nihilism, where it often symbolizes the absence of intrinsic meaning in life and the human condition's confrontation with nothingness. Modern scientific discussions have further engaged with the concept of the Void, particularly in the study of quantum mechanics and cosmology, where it is linked to ideas such as the quantum vacuum and the structure of the universe.

In Western esotericism, aphairesis ("clearing aside"), or the via negativa , is a method used to approach the transcendent 'Ground of Being' by systematically negating all finite concepts and attributes associated with the divine. This process allows mystics to move beyond the limitations of human understanding and language, ultimately seeking a direct experience of the divine as the ineffable source of all existence, beyond any specific attributes or definitions. ^[1]

Historical background

The concept of the Void has its origins in ancient Greek philosophy, where it was central to discussions on the nature of the cosmos and space. Parmenides suggested it did not exist and used this to argue for the non-existence of change, motion, and differentiation, among other things. ^[2] In response to Parmenides, Democritus, one of the early proponents of atomism, posited that the universe was composed of atoms moving through the Void. According to Democritus, the Void was a necessary empty space that allowed for the movement and interaction of atoms, making it essential for the existence of matter itself. This view framed the Void as a real and foundational component of the universe, contrasting with the notion of it being mere nothingness. ^[3]

Aristotle, in contrast, rejected the existence of a true Void, arguing that nature abhors a vacuum (horror vacui). In Book IV of Physics , Aristotle contended that the Void (Greek : κενόν), understood as an absolute absence of matter, could not exist because it would contradict the natural laws governing movement and change. He believed that movement required a medium through which it could occur, and a completely empty space would prevent such movement. This Aristotelian view became highly influential, shaping medieval and Renaissance perspectives on the nature of space and matter. ^[4]

Stoic philosophers admitted the subsistence of four incorporeals among which they included void: "Outside of the world is diffused the infinite void, which is incorporeal. By incorporeal is meant that which, though capable of being occupied by body, is not so occupied. The world has no empty space within it, but forms one united whole. This is a necessary result of the sympathy and tension which binds together things in heaven and earth."^{[ This quote needs a citation ]} Chrysippus discusses the Void in his work On Void and in the first book of his Physical Sciences; so too Apollophanes in his Physics, Apollodorus, ^[5] and Posidonius in his Physical Discourse, book ii." ^[6]

During the medieval period, Christian theologians engaged with the concept of the Void from a metaphysical and theological perspective. Classical theologians like Thomas Aquinas integrated Aristotelian philosophy with Christian theology, arguing that God's omnipresence precluded the existence of a Void. For Aquinas, the idea of a Void was incompatible with the belief in a God who is present everywhere, thus reinforcing the rejection of any absolute emptiness in creation. ^[7]

Despite Aristotle's rejection, the concept of the Void reemerged during the Renaissance and early modern period, particularly in the context of scientific inquiry. The development of vacuum experiments by scientists like Evangelista Torricelli in the 17th century challenged Aristotelian physics by demonstrating the possibility of creating a vacuum, thereby reigniting philosophical discussions about the nature of the Void and its place in the physical world. These experiments laid the groundwork for later scientific advancements, including the study of space and the vacuum in modern physics. ^[8] There were questions as to whether the Void was truly nothing, or if it was in fact filled with something, with theories of aether being suggested in the 18th century to fill the Void. ^[9]

In The Void (2007), particle physicist Frank Close discusses the concept of 'empty space' from Aristotle through Newton, Mach, Einstein and beyond (including the idea of an 'aether' and current examinations of the Higgs field). ^[10]

In Eastern philosophy

The concept of the Void holds significant spiritual and metaphysical importance in Eastern philosophy, particularly in Buddhism and Taoism. While each tradition interprets the Void differently, both see it as central to understanding the nature of reality and existence.

Buddhism: Śūnyatā

In Buddhism, the concept of the Void is most closely associated with Śūnyatā , often translated as "emptiness". This idea is central to Mahayana Buddhist philosophy and is most elaborately discussed in the works of Nagarjuna, a foundational figure in the Madhyamaka school. Śūnyatā refers to the absence of inherent existence in all phenomena; nothing possesses an independent, permanent self-nature. Instead, everything exists interdependently, arising and ceasing due to a web of causes and conditions. This understanding is meant to free practitioners from attachment and the delusion of a permanent self, leading to enlightenment. ^[11]

Nagarjuna's analysis in the Mūlamadhyamakakārikā (Fundamental Verses on the Middle Way) elaborates on Śūnyatā by deconstructing various concepts and phenomena to show that they lack intrinsic essence. This deconstruction is not nihilistic; rather, it opens the way to seeing reality as a dynamic interplay of conditions, without clinging to any fixed viewpoints. Śūnyatā, therefore, is both a philosophical insight and a meditative realization that leads to the understanding of the true nature of reality. ^[12]

Taoism: Wuji and Taiji

In Taoism, the concept of the Void is represented by Wuji (無極), which denotes a state of undifferentiated emptiness or non-being. Wuji is the source of all existence, preceding the dualistic manifestation of Taiji (太極), the Supreme Ultimate, which gives rise to the interplay of yin and yang. This cosmological framework is central to Taoist metaphysics, where Wuji symbolizes the limitless potential and the unmanifest state from which all things emerge and to which they ultimately return. ^[13]

The Tao Te Ching , attributed to Laozi, discusses the concept of the Tao (道) as the ultimate source and underlying principle of the universe, which can be understood as synonymous with Wuji. The Tao is described as something that cannot be named or defined, embodying the qualities of the Void—emptiness, potentiality, and the origin of all phenomena. This understanding of the Void as the root of existence reflects a non-dualistic view, where the apparent multiplicity of the world is ultimately grounded in an ineffable, empty source. ^[14]

Zhou Dunyi, a Song dynasty philosopher, synthesized Taoist and Confucian ideas in his Taijitu shuo (Explanation of the Diagram of the Supreme Ultimate), where he describes Wuji and Taiji as interconnected aspects of the same reality. Wuji represents the boundless void from which the dynamism of Taiji emerges, leading to the generation of the yin-yang duality and, consequently, the entire cosmos. ^[15]

In modern philosophy

The concept of the Void takes on new dimensions in modern philosophy, particularly in the realms of existentialism and nihilism. These philosophical movements, emerging primarily in the 19th and 20th centuries, grapple with the implications of the Void for human existence, meaning, and morality.

Nihilism and the rejection of meaning

Nihilism, particularly as articulated by Friedrich Nietzsche, presents a more radical confrontation with the Void, often characterized by the rejection of all moral, religious, and metaphysical beliefs. Nietzsche famously declared the "death of God" in The Gay Science (1882), a metaphor for the collapse of traditional values and the rise of the Void as a central concern in modernity. With the death of God, Nietzsche argues, humanity faces a profound Void—an absence of any external source of meaning or value. This leads to what Nietzsche calls "nihilism", where the previous foundations of meaning are exposed as baseless, leaving individuals in a state of existential crisis. ^[16]

However, Nietzsche does not view the Void purely negatively. Instead, he sees it as an opportunity for the Übermensch (lit. 'Overman') to create new values and meanings. In this way, the Void becomes a space of potential, where the destruction of old beliefs clears the way for the creation of new ones. Nietzsche's vision of the Void is thus both a challenge and an invitation to re-evaluate and re-create meaning in a world devoid of inherent purpose. ^[17]

Existentialism: The existential void

In existentialist thought, the Void often symbolizes the absence of inherent meaning in the universe and the individual's confrontation with this emptiness. Philosophers such as Albert Camus and Jean-Paul Sartre explore the Void as a fundamental aspect of the human condition, where individuals must create their own meaning in a world that offers none.

Albert Camus

Camus, in The Myth of Sisyphus (1942), elaborates on this existential dilemma by discussing the concept of the absurd—the conflict between humans' desire to find meaning and the universe's indifferent silence. For Camus, the Void is the backdrop against which the absurd plays out, as individuals grapple with the realization that life is inherently meaningless. However, rather than succumbing to despair, Camus advocates for a defiant embrace of the absurd, where one finds freedom and meaning through personal choice and action, even in the face of the Void. ^[18]

Jean-Paul Sartre

Sartre, in his seminal work Being and Nothingness (1943), describes human existence as being "condemned to be free", where the Void represents the nothingness at the core of existence that individuals must confront when they realize that life has no preordained purpose. ^[19] Jean-Paul Sartre's exploration of the Void is central to his existentialist philosophy. Sartre argues that consciousness itself is a form of nothingness, or néant , that introduces a fundamental gap between the self and the world. This gap creates a sense of the Void, as consciousness is constantly aware of what it is not—what it lacks or desires. Sartre describes this as a perpetual state of "lack" or "nothingness", where human beings are always confronted with their own freedom to choose, yet burdened by the responsibility that this freedom entails. ^[20]

For Sartre, the Void is not just an abstract concept but an experiential reality. It manifests in moments of existential anxiety, where individuals confront the absence of any inherent meaning or purpose in life. This confrontation with the Void reveals the radical freedom that defines human existence: we are not bound by any predetermined essence or external authority, but are free to define ourselves through our choices. However, this freedom is accompanied by a sense of vertigo or anguish, as it exposes the individual to the vast, empty space of potential that they must navigate without any guarantees. ^[21]

Sartre's famous statement that "existence precedes essence" ^[22] encapsulates this idea. It implies that there is no pre-existing blueprint for what it means to be human; instead, individuals must create their own essence through their actions. This creation, however, occurs against the backdrop of the Void—an absence of inherent meaning that forces individuals to take full responsibility for their choices and the meanings they create. ^[23]

Moreover, Sartre discusses the Void in the context of interpersonal relationships, particularly in his analysis of "the look" ( le regard ). When one person gazes at another, it objectifies the other, reducing them to an object within the world. This objectification creates a sense of the Void, as it strips away the subject's freedom and exposes the emptiness at the core of their being. Sartre uses this concept to illustrate how the Void operates not only on an individual level but also in social interactions, where the awareness of others' perceptions can lead to feelings of alienation and nothingness. ^[20]

In science and cosmology

The scientific understanding of the Void has evolved dramatically, particularly from the 17th century onward. Evangelista Torricelli's vacuum experiments in the 1640s demonstrated the possibility of an empty space devoid of matter, challenging the longstanding Aristotelian belief that nature abhors a vacuum (horror vacui). These experiments laid the groundwork for a new understanding of the Void as a physical reality rather than a mere conceptual possibility. ^[8]

The concept of the Void underwent further transformation with the rejection of the aether theory in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Aether was once believed to be a subtle, invisible medium that filled all of space and carried light waves. However, the Michelson-Morley experiment in 1887 failed to detect any evidence of aether, leading to the theory's eventual abandonment. This shift was further reinforced by Albert Einstein's theory of relativity, which revolutionized the understanding of space itself. According to relativity, space is not a passive backdrop but a dynamic field influenced by mass and energy, fundamentally altering the traditional notion of the Void. ^[24]

In the context of quantum mechanics, the Void is no longer seen as a simple vacuum but as a quantum vacuum—a field filled with fluctuating energy. As Lawrence Krauss describes it in A Universe from Nothing (2012), even "empty" space is not truly empty but contains a seething field of virtual particles that continuously pop in and out of existence. This quantum vacuum is a foundational aspect of modern physics, underlying the particles and forces that constitute the universe. ^[25]

In art and literature

The concept of the Void has had a profound influence on both art and literature, where it is often used to explore themes of emptiness, the unknown, and the boundaries of human experience. Through visual and literary expressions, the Void becomes a metaphor for existential questions, psychological states, and the nature of reality itself.

Literary themes

In literature, the Void often serves as a metaphor for existential despair, the search for meaning, or the confrontation with the unknown. Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot (1953) is a quintessential example, where the Void is both literal and metaphorical. The play's setting is a barren, empty landscape, and the characters are caught in an endless wait for something that never arrives. The Void here represents the absence of meaning, purpose, and resolution, reflecting the existentialist idea that life is fundamentally devoid of intrinsic meaning. ^[26]

Franz Kafka's works also engage deeply with the concept of the Void. In The Trial (1925), the protagonist, Josef K., finds himself entangled in a nightmarish legal system where the rules are arbitrary and the authority figures remain unseen. The Void in Kafka's work often symbolizes the oppressive and incomprehensible nature of modern life, where individuals struggle against forces that they cannot understand or control. ^[27]

In more contemporary literature, the Void is explored in works like Don DeLillo's White Noise (1985), where the pervasive sense of emptiness and alienation in modern society is a central theme. The characters in White Noise are constantly bombarded by the noise of consumer culture and media, creating a metaphorical Void that reflects the absence of authentic human connection and meaning in their lives. ^[28]

Artistic representations

In the visual arts, the Void is frequently represented as an absence, a space that invites contemplation or evokes a sense of the infinite. One of the most notable artists who explored the Void is Yves Klein, a French artist known for his monochrome works and his exploration of immateriality. Klein's Le Vide (The Void) exhibition in 1958 featured an empty gallery space, painted white, intended to focus the viewer's attention on the emptiness and the absence of material objects. This work challenges traditional notions of art by making the Void itself the subject of the experience. ^[29]

Alberto Giacometti, another prominent artist, frequently engaged with the concept of the Void in his sculptures. His elongated figures, such as Walking Man (1960), evoke a sense of isolation and alienation, with the surrounding space emphasizing the emptiness and solitude of the figures. Giacometti's work reflects existential themes, where the Void becomes a metaphor for the human condition and the pervasive sense of nothingness that can accompany it. ^[30]

Japanese artist Yayoi Kusama also explores the Void through her immersive installations, such as the Infinity Mirror Rooms. These rooms use mirrors and lights to create an illusion of infinite space, allowing viewers to experience the disorienting and transcendent qualities of the Void. Kusama's work often reflects her own struggles with mental illness, using the Void as both a personal and universal symbol of the unknown and the infinite. ^[31]

Film

The Void is a recurring motif in cinema, often used to symbolize existential dread, the unknown, or the metaphysical boundaries between life and death. Stanley Kubrick's 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) is one of the most iconic examples, where the vast emptiness of space represents both the awe-inspiring and terrifying aspects of the Void. The film's minimal dialogue and expansive visual sequences emphasize the isolation and mystery of space, which serves as a metaphor for the human condition and the search for meaning in an indifferent universe. ^[32]

Another film that delves into the concept of the Void is The Void (2016), ^[33] a Canadian horror film directed by Steven Kostanski and Jeremy Gillespie. The film blends Lovecraftian horror with surreal imagery, depicting a hospital that becomes a gateway to a nightmarish otherworld. The Void in this film is not just a physical space but also a symbolic representation of terror and the unknown, drawing on cosmic horror traditions to explore the fear of the incomprehensible. ^[34]

Scholarly perspectives and criticism

In analytical philosophy, the Void has often been a subject of scrutiny, particularly regarding the treatment of "nothingness" as a substantive concept. Bertrand Russell, a prominent figure in analytical philosophy, expressed skepticism about metaphysical discussions that involve the Void, arguing that such concepts often arise from linguistic and conceptual confusions. Russell posited that the idea of the Void or nothingness can be misleading, as it seems to ascribe existence to a non-existent entity, thereby generating paradoxes rather than resolving philosophical problems. ^[35]

This critique of the Void extends into contemporary discussions, particularly in the context of scientific theories. Lawrence Krauss's book A Universe from Nothing presents a scientific perspective on the Void, arguing that the quantum vacuum—an apparently empty space filled with fluctuating energy and virtual particles—requires a rethinking of what "nothing" truly means. While Krauss's approach attempts to bridge the gap between physics and metaphysics, it has drawn criticism from philosophers like David Albert, who argue that Krauss conflates scientific and philosophical concepts, leading to oversimplified conclusions about the nature of existence and the origins of the universe. ^[36]

In popular culture

Main article: The Void in popular culture

See also

• Marina Abramović  – Serbian performance artist
• Chaos  – Void state preceding creation
• Ginnungagap  – Primordial void mentioned in the Gylfaginning
• Kenoma  – Concept in Gnosticism
• Ma  – Japanese artistic concept
• Nuit  – Deity in Thelema
• Lee Ufan  – Korean artist
• Zhi  – Primordial state in Tibetan Buddhism

References

1. Pseudo-Dionysius (1987), p. 138; Taylor (1992), p. 86; Morley (2020), p. 98.
2. DK fragment B 8.5–6, 8.22–24.
3. Koyré (1957); Sorabji (1983).
4. Aristotle (2017); Sorabji (1983).
5. Zeyl (2013), p. 44.
6. Diogenes Laërtius (1925), Book VII (140).
7. Aquinas (1947); Gilson (1936).
8. Koyré (1957); Dear (2001).
9. Newton (2018), Book 3.
10. Close (2007).
11. Nāgārjuna & Kalupahana (1991); Nāgārjuna (1995); Conze (1962).
12. Nāgārjuna (1995); Williams (2008).
13. Saso (1972); Robinet (1997).
14. Lao-Tzu (2010).
15. Zhang (2002); Wang (2005).
16. Nietzsche (1974); Deleuze (2006).
17. Nietzsche (1974); Heidegger (1991).
18. Camus (1991); Flynn (2006).
19. Sartre (1993); Flynn (2006).
20. Sartre (1993); Catalano (1985).
21. Sartre (1993); Solomon (2005).
22. Sartre (1993), p. ^{[ page needed ]}.
23. Flynn (2006).
24. Einstein (1920); Whittaker (1951).
25. Krauss (2012); Hawking & Mlodinow (2010).
26. Esslin (1961); Pilling (1994).
27. Brod (1960); Gray (2005).
28. Cowie (2000); Osteen (2000).
29. Klein (1982); Stich (1994).
30. Sylvester (1994); Butler (2011).
31. Applin (2012); Tate (2018).
32. Kubrick (1968); Abrams (2007).
33. Kostanski & Gillespie (2016).
34. Abrams (2017).
35. Russell (1925).
36. Krauss (2012); Albert (2012).

Works cited

• Abrams, Jerold J., ed. (2007). The Philosophy of Stanley Kubrick. University Press of Kentucky. ISBN   978-0-8131-7256-9.
• Abrams, Simon (April 7, 2017). "The Void". RogerEbert.com (film review). Retrieved 2024-08-19.
• Albert, David (March 23, 2012). "The Origin of Everything". The New York Times. Retrieved 2024-08-18.
• Applin, Jo (2012). Yayoi Kusama: Infinity Mirror Rooms. Tate Publishing.
• Aquinas, Thomas (1947) [1911]. Summa Theologica . Translated by the Fathers of the English Dominican Province. New York: Benziger Brothers. 3 vols.
• Aristotle (2017). Physics. Dover Publications. ISBN   978-0-486-81351-6.
• Brod, Max (1960). Franz Kafka: A Biography. Schocken Books.
• Butler, Cornelia H. (2011). Alberto Giacometti: A Retrospective. The Museum of Modern Art.
• Camus, Albert (1991) [1942]. The Myth of Sisyphus. Translated by Justin O'Brien. Vintage Books.
• Catalano, Joseph S. (1985). A Commentary on Jean-Paul Sartre's Being and Nothingness. University of Chicago Press. ISBN   978-0-226-09699-5.
• Close, Frank (2007). The Void. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-160771-4.
• Conze, Edward (1962). Buddhist Thought in India. Allen & Unwin.
• Cowie, Peter (2000). Don DeLillo: The Pursuit of Meaning. Methuen.
• Dear, Peter (2001). Revolutionizing the Sciences: European Knowledge and Its Ambitions, 1500-1700. Princeton University Press. ISBN   978-0-691-08860-0.
• Deleuze, Gilles (2006). Nietzsche and Philosophy. Columbia University Press.^{[ ISBN missing ]}
• Diogenes Laërtius (1925). Lives of the Eminent Philosophers. Translated by Robert Drew Hicks. Harvard University Press. ISBN   978-0-674-99203-0.
• Einstein, Albert (1920). Relativity: The Special and General Theory. Henry Holt.
• Esslin, Martin (1961). The Theatre of the Absurd. Anchor Books.
• Flynn, Thomas (2006). Existentialism: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press.^{[ ISBN missing ]}
• Gilson, Étienne (1936). The Spirit of Mediaeval Philosophy. Sheed & Ward.
• Gray, Richard T. (2005). A Franz Kafka Encyclopedia. Greenwood Press.
• Hawking, Stephen; Mlodinow, Leonard (2010). The Grand Design . Bantam Books. ISBN   978-0-553-84088-9.
• Heidegger, Martin (1991). Nietzsche: Volumes One and Two. HarperCollins.
• Klein, Yves (1982). Overcoming the Problematics of Art: The Writings of Yves Klein. Spring Publications.
• Kostanski, Steven; Gillespie, Jeremy (2016). The Void. Screen Media Films.
• Koyré, Alexandre (1957). From the Closed World to the Infinite Universe. Johns Hopkins University Press. Institute of the History of Medicine.
• Kubrick, Stanley (1968). 2001: A Space Odyssey (film). Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer.
• Krauss, Lawrence (2012). A Universe from Nothing: Why There is Something Rather than Nothing. UK: Simon & Schuster. ISBN   978-1-4711-1269-0.
• Lao-Tzu (2010). Te-Tao Ching: A New Translation Based on the Recently Discovered Ma-wang Tui Texts. Translated by Robert G. Henricks. Random House. ISBN   978-0-307-77534-4.
• Morley, Simon (2020). The Simple Truth: The Monochrome in Modern Art. Reaktion Books. ISBN   978-1-78914-268-6.
• Nāgārjuna; Kalupahana, David J. (1991). Mūlamadhyamakakārikā of Nāgārjuna: The Philosophy of the Middle Way. Motilal Banarsidass. ISBN   978-81-208-0774-7.
• Nāgārjuna (1995). The Fundamental Wisdom of the Middle Way: Nāgārjuna's Mūlamadhyamakakārikā. Translated by Jay L. Garfield. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-976632-1.
• Nietzsche, Friedrich (1974) [1882]. The Gay Science. Translated by Walter Kaufmann. Vintage Books.
• Newton, Isaac (2018) [1704]. Opticks . Outlook Verlag. ISBN   978-3-7340-4795-4.
• Osteen, Mark (2000). American Magic and Dread: Don DeLillo's Dialogue with Culture. University of Pennsylvania Press.
• Pilling, John (1994). Beckett Before Godot. Cambridge University Press.
• Pseudo-Dionysius (1987). "The Mystical Theology". In Rorem, Paul (ed.). Pseudo-Dionysius: The Complete Works. Translated by Colm Luibhéid. Paulist Press. ISBN   978-0-8091-2838-9.
• Robinet, Isabelle (1997). Taoism: Growth of a Religion. Stanford University Press. ISBN   978-0-8047-6494-0.
• Russell, Bertrand (1925). The ABC of Relativity. George Allen & Unwin.
• Sartre, Jean-Paul (1993) [1943]. Being and Nothingness. Washington Square Press.
• Saso, Michael (1972). Taoism and the Rite of Cosmic Renewal. Washington State University Press. ISBN   978-0-87422-011-7.
• Stich, Sidra (1994). Yves Klein. Hatje Cantz.
• Solomon, Robert C. (2005). Existentialism. Oxford University Press. ISBN   978-0-19-517463-2.
• Sorabji, Richard (1983). Time, Creation, and the Continuum. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. ISBN   978-0-8014-1593-7.
• Sylvester, David (1994). Looking at Giacometti. Pimlico.
• Tate (2018). Yayoi Kusama: Infinity Mirror Rooms. Tate.
• Taylor, M. C. (1992). Disfiguring: Art, Architecture, Religion. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. ISBN   978-0-226-79133-3.
• Wang, Robin R. (2005). "Zhou Dunyi's Diagram of the Supreme Ultimate Explained: A Construction of the Confucian Metaphysics". Journal of the History of Ideas. 66 (3): 307–323. doi:10.1353/jhi.2005.0047.
• Whittaker, Edmund (1951) [1910]. A History of the Theories of Aether and Electricity. Thomas Nelson.
• Williams, Paul (2008). Mahayana Buddhism: The Doctrinal Foundations. Routledge. ISBN   978-1-134-25057-8.
• Zeyl, Donald J., ed. (2013) [1997]. Encyclopedia of Classical Philosophy. Routledge.^{[ ISBN missing ]}
• Zhang, Dainian (2002). Key Concepts in Chinese Philosophy. Translated by Edmund Ryden. Yale University Press. ISBN   978-0-300-19978-9.

Further reading

• Albert, David (1992). Quantum Mechanics and Experience. Harvard University Press.
• Carabine, Deirdre (2015). The Unknown God: Negative Theology in the Platonic Tradition: Plato to Eriugena. Belgium: Wipf & Stock Publishers. ISBN   978-1-62032-862-0.
• Frankl, Viktor (1946). Man's Search for Meaning. Beacon Press.
• Jung, Carl G. (1957). "Psychology and the Tibetan Book of the Dead". In Evans-Wentz, W. Y. (ed.). The Tibetan Book of the Dead: Or, The After-Death Experiences on the Bardo Plane, According to Lama Kazi Dawa-Samdup's English Rendering. Oxford University Press. pp. xlvi–lxxvi.
• McGinn, Bernard (1991). The Foundations of Mysticism: Origins to the Fifth Century. Crossroad.