Tiananmen Exiles

Last updated

Tiananmen Exiles: Voices of the Struggle for Democracy in China is a scholarly book by Rowena Xiaoqing He, published by Palgrave Macmillan in April 2014. The book has been named one of the Top five China Books by the Asia Society. [1] It is primarily an oral history of Yi Danxuan, Shen Tong, and Wang Dan, all exiled student leaders from the 1989 Tiananmen Movement in China. "Tracing the life trajectories of these exiles, from childhood during Mao's Cultural Revolution, adolescence growing up during the reform era, and betrayal and punishment in the aftermath of June 1989, to ongoing struggles in exile", the author explores, "how their idealism was fostered by the very powers that ultimately crushed it, and how such idealism evolved facing the conflicts that historical amnesia, political commitment, ethical action, and personal happiness presented to them in exile." [2] Dan Southerland notes in Christian Science Monitor that the book provides "fresh insights and an appreciation for the challenges that exiled Chinese student leaders faced after they escaped from China." [3] Paul Levine from American Diplomacy states that there was “a fourth major character: the author herself.” [4] Tiananmen Exiles is a part of the Palgrave Studies in Oral History and contains a foreword by Perry Link. The forward was published in the New York Review of Books the same week the book came out.

Contents

Author

Rowena Xiaoqing He was born in China and was raised as a part of the "Tiananmen Generation". [5] She received her M.A. and Ph.D degrees from the University of Toronto and conducted her postdoctoral research at Harvard's Fairbank Center for Chinese Studies. [6] She is a current member at the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton (2018-2019) working on her manuscript on history, memory, and Chinese student nationalism in the Post-Tiananmen era. [7] As of 2019, she is Associate Professor of History at the Chinese University of Hong Kong. She has previously taught at Harvard University, Wellesley College, and St. Michael's College. [8]

In her profile interview with the New York Times (in both English and Chinese editions), He details the challenges of "teaching Tiananmen to a generation." [7] In the Tiananmen courses she created, she engaged students to organize symposiums to share what they had learned with the general public, and invited faculty members to serve as chairs and discussants, among them, historian Merle Goldman and political scientist Roderick MacFarquhar, who gave closing remarks each year at the student-initiated symposium. [9] [10] For the 25th anniversary of the Movement, He and her students organized a full-day conference which included panels of academics, journalists, and exiled leaders. Based on a Boston Globe story one freshman student from China "told the packed auditorium" that “I took this class because I am the generation that’s being brainwashed...Everything I knew about June 4, 1989, was the fragments I heard from my dad.” [11]

The Harvard Magazine reports that "the course has not escaped its own controversy. A Chinese man told one student not to take the course because it represented a biased version of history, and each year, some students, usually those from mainland China, ask for their names and appearances to be withheld from the publicly accessible course website." [12] He's teaching has been covered by the Harvard Crimson, [13] Harvard Political Review, [14] the Harvard Magazine [15] the Wellesley News [16] and other international news outlet. She received the Harvard University Certificate of Teaching Excellence three consecutive times. [8] In addition to her scholarly work, He writes and speaks widely outside the academia. [17] [18] [19]

Synopsis

Rowena He starts with introducing the idea of oral history and addresses her method style, as she swaps between Chinese and English in her interviews, and has combined the methods of life history, narrative inquiry and arts-based inquiry. [20] She starts with an introduction to Wang Dan, Shen Tong, and Yi Danxuan. Wang Dan was a student leader who was arrested after the protests and served fourteen years in two different sentences, he would later be exiled to the United States and would receive his PhD. [21] Shen Tong co-chaired the Student Dialogue Delegation, escaped China six days after the crackdown, and would later publish the autobiography Almost a Revolution . Tong is also still politically active while in exile. [22] Yi Danxuan was the Vice-President of the Guangzhou Patriotic Student Federation, spent 2 years in prison, and was exiled from China but was allowed temporary entry during the Beijing Olympics. [22]

The book starts with a portion of He's autobiography which tells of her childhood and her connection to the Tiananmen protests. She then tells how her father became disenchanted with the Chinese Communist Party and shows how the school system pushed a pro-Party ideology. [23] She then describes how she exiled herself to Canada and there became excited because of the literature on Tiananmen in the library. [24]

Yi Danxuan was the exile that He was most excited to interview, mainly because of the lack works on him and his efforts outside of Beijing. [25] Yi asked He to “stop thinking about your research for a moment while I talk to you” as the exiles are people and not just subjects; He notes how this was an important moment for herself. [26] In the interview, He asked Yi about his current involvement in the community who were involved in the Tiananmen Protests. [27] She further inquired about his imprisonment, but Yi gave little information to He on this matter. [28] Finally, He inquired on how Yi was settling into the United States, and Yi stated that “I don’t enjoy settling down in North America. I won’t feel happy.” [29]

Shen Tong was one of the more difficult and controversial exiles that He interviewed. The main problem that He faced was that Shen has published his own autobiography, He's solution was to interview him on topics not covered in Almost a Revolution. [30] In doing this she predominantly concentrates on his life prior to 1989 and in exile. [30] When He asked Shen about his family and their reactions to his political activism Shen told He that his father was originally unsupportive but that changed with his exile as “the worst thing had already happened. He didn’t need to worry about me when I was abroad." [31]

Much like with Shen, He was faced the challenge of interviewing Wang Dan who is “a symbol of the crushed democracy movement”; as with Shen, He concentrated on his “formative years as the basis of his later life”. [32] [33] Wang and He highlight throughout dialogue the influence of the Cultural Revolution on those involved in the Tiananmen protest. [34]

The author ends her book with a group dialogue between the exiles. The major ideas focused on during the discussion are the ideas of ‘home’, a desire to return to China and a feeling of guilt for their families left in China. [35] [36] [37] The other major issue discussed is how big of a role June 4 should play in their lives and Wang succinctly stated that “June 4 should not be the only meaningful thing in our lives." [38] The author then ends by showing how the exiles have moved on with their lives after the protest. [39]

Reception

Tiananmen Exiles has received many positive reviews:

“Rowena He herself is an example of someone who has battled for years, sometimes in the face of angry criticism, to keep alive the memories of an idealism that emerged in full force in 1989. And she’s determined not to let us forget.” -Christian Science Monitor by Dan Southerland

"A compelling account of idealism and the price it exacts" - Kirkus

“Bold attempt to reclaim Chinese history from the state” -The Independent by Edward Wilson

"Rowena He...courageously battles state-imposed amnesia, forcing us to remember the human cost of China's 1989" - The Daily Telegraph by Julia Lovell

"Those who have chosen, or were forced by circumstances, not to live the official lie, including Rowena He, are condemned as traitors to China rather than as critics of the regime. For the three student leaders interviewed in her book, the events of 1989 and their subsequent exile created a permanent post-traumatic state. Much the same could be said of the nation they left behind, a nation that is waiting for the moment when the legacy of the tragedy suffered a quarter-century ago can be faced." - New Statesman by Isabel Hilton

“As long as the Communist Party continues to refuse to tolerate any conversation about June Fourth, it will only ensure that voices like Ms. He’s echo even louder in the silence." - The Wall Street Journal Real Time by Maura Cunningham

Noted journalist Ian Johnson writes in the New York Review of Books that He's book is “A moving and very personal account of life as a political emigrant" and "a convincing and powerful account of a central experience in contemporary Chinese life." [40]

Princeton Historian Yu Ying-shih comments that "Rowena Xiaoqing He has ingeniously reconstructed the entire movement in a historical perspective not only to unlock the past and explain the present but also to peer into the future of China's sustained struggle against totalitarian tyranny." [41]

Vera Schwartz comments that “Rowena He’s book is an essential corrective," to the "complex legacy of Tiananmen:"

Through her own writings and ongoing testimony about the events of 1989, she has refused to let the hope for democracy wither under the weight of platitudes and Party-imposed amnesia. The cost of this act of moral courage has been very high...The lonely few keep educating themselves about the vague ideals that they carried as youths into Tiananmen Square. They refuse to become deaf to history’s trauma, in the way that Primo Levi feared for the generation after the Holocaust. [42] The Journal of East Asian Libraries notes that "Tiananmen Exiles has organically tied the Cultural Revolution and Tiananmen movement together through the lives and agonies of three former student leaders, and through them, the lives and struggles of their generation."

Bjorn Alpermann states that He's book “is a valuable contribution to the literature on the Chinese democracy movement and provides fascinating insights into the world of Chinese political exiles,” however, “the 'infighting' among the exiled dissidents—apparently an important consideration to all three of the interviewees—is only alluded to,” as He seems to concentrate more on the “questions of identity and citizenship.” [43] James Seymour points what is supposedly a shortcoming, namely, the second chapter, He's personal story, as it “is somewhat less successful than the others because it has little to do with the Tiananmen experience.” [44]  He herself has detailed the literature of her narrative history approach under Against Amnesia: Narrative as a Quest and Who Am I as a Researcher in Chapter One. [45] Vera Schwarcz also notes in the Human Rights Quarterly, He's narrative approach is a methodology of oral history” “indebted to a new trend which encourages narrative and autobiographical engagement with the subject.” [46] Ian Johnson, too, in the New York Review of Books, explains that:

Her book is written in the tradition of contemporary academic narrative research, which invites her to tell her own story as a way of making clear her standpoint. We learn of her upbringing during the Cultural Revolution, the problems her family faced, and how her father’s idealism was crushed during the Mao period…All of this helps us understand the sense of entrapment that the Tiananmen generation felt growing up during the Mao era, and the resulting desire to break out and embrace the 1989 movement. [40]

Seymour's second criticism is that readers who have read “the [autobiographical] accounts of Shen Tong and Wang Dan will not find much that is new here,” however “we do learn a lot about Wang’s formative years,” and the controversial aspect of Shen's political career. [47] Regarding this, in He's chapter dedicated to Shen Tong, she refers specifically to the relationship between her profile of Shen Tong and the autobiography that Shen had published many years earlier (1990):

This chapter might be viewed as a continuation of the autobiography, shifting the focus from Sheng Tong’s socialization in China prior to 1989 to his experience in exile. Readers will find in this chapter Shen Tong’s firsthand reflections about his life in exile with respect to his prior experiences in China as well as new perspectives on each episode of his life that were derived from the interview and group discussions. Unlike other studies on the Tiananmen uprising that mainly focus on the causes and progression of the uprising, here I am concerned with the full lives and struggles of these exile students from their own personal perspectives. [48]

In what is a very positive review in The Spectator, Jonathan Mirsky states that there are “few factual errors do not detract from this book’s masterly narrative and analysis.” [49] This is in reference to He's statement that the “1989 Tiananmen movement was the most serious open conflict between the communist regime and the Chinese people since the establishment of the People’s Republic in 1949.” Mirsky deems this an error:

God knows it was ghastly enough, but the first years of the communist period, when Mao’s bloodthirstiness was encouraged by Deng Xiaoping and Zhou Enlai, witnessed the executions of at least two million souls; and during the Cultural Revolution of 1966–1976 many more millions died, including those killed by the army...He’s own parents suffered during those years, but like so many Chinese they scarcely mentioned the horrors of the past to their children; so that even though He is well-versed in her country’s history, that earlier period hasn’t touched her in the way Tiananmen has. [49]

The fundamental difference at work here is that the events listed above were political campaigns launched by the CCP against the Chinese people, not social movements when people took to the streets to openly confront the communist regime, and did not constitute "the most serious open conflicts" since 1949.

Mirsky further cites He's book as “profound” in keeping the Tiananmen movement's significance alive. [50]

Related Research Articles

1989 Tiananmen Square protests Chinese controversial pro-democracy movement in 1989

The Tiananmen Square protests or the Tiananmen Square Incident, commonly known as the June Fourth Incident in mainland China, were student-led demonstrations held in Tiananmen Square in Beijing during 1989. The popular national movement inspired by the Beijing protests is sometimes called the '89 Democracy Movement. The protests started on April 15 and were forcibly suppressed on June 4 when the government declared martial law and sent the military to occupy central parts of Beijing. In what became known as the Tiananmen Square Massacre, troops with assault rifles and tanks fired at the demonstrators and those trying to block the military's advance into Tiananmen Square. Estimates of the death toll vary from several hundred to several thousand, with thousands more wounded.

Chai Ling Chinese psychologist

Chai Ling is a Chinese psychologist who was one of the student leaders in the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989. She is the founder of All Girls Allowed, an organization dedicated to ending China's one-child policy, and the founder and President of Jenzabar, an enterprise resource planning software firm for educational institutions.

Wang Dan (dissident) Chinese protester

Wang Dan is a leader of the Chinese democracy movement and was one of the most visible student leaders in the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989. He holds a Ph.D. in history from Harvard University, and from August 2009 to February 2010, Wang taught cross-strait history at Taiwan's National Chengchi University, as a visiting scholar. He then taught at National Tsing Hua University until 2015.

Wang Ruowang was a Chinese author and dissident who was imprisoned various times for political reasons by both the Kuomintang and the Communist government of China for advocating reform and liberalization. His name at birth was "Shouhua", but he was most commonly known by his pen name, "Ruowang". He was a prolific essayist and literary critic.

Wang Youcai Tiananmen Square Student Leader

Wang Youcai, an active dissident of the Chinese Government, was one of the supporters of democracy in China and an important student leader in the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989. Then a graduate student at the Peking University, he was arrested in 1989 and sentenced to four years in 1991 for "conspiring to overthrow the Government of China".

Shen Tong One of the student leaders in the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989

Shen Tong is an American impact investor, activist, and writer. He founded business accelerators FoodFutureCo in 2015 and Food-X in 2014, the latter of which is recognized by Fast Company as one of "The World's Top 10 Most Innovative Companies of 2015 in Food". He was a Chinese dissident who was exiled as one of the student leaders in the democracy movement at Tiananmen Square in 1989. Shen was one of the People of the Year in Newsweek 1989, and he became a media, software, social entrepreneur, and investor in the late 1990s. He serves on the board of Food Tank.

Xiong Yan (dissident) Chinese dissident / US Army chaplain

Xiong Yan is a China-born naturalized American. He was a dissident involved in Tiananmen Square protests of 1989. Xiong Yan studied at Beijing University Law School from 1986–1989. He came to the United States of America as a political refugee in 1992, and later became a chaplain in U.S. Army, serving in Iraq. Xiong Yan is the author of three books, and has earned six degrees.

<i>Almost a Revolution</i> book by Shen Tong

Almost a Revolution is an autobiography by Shen Tong (沈彤), one of the student leaders in the Tiananmen Square Protests of 1989 in Beijing, China, written with former Washington Post writer Marianne Yen.

Feng Congde Chinese dissident

Feng Congde is a Chinese dissident and Republic of China Restoration activist. He came into prominence during the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 as a student leader from Peking University, which placed him onto the Chinese government's 21 Most Wanted list. He spent 10 months hiding in various locations in China, until he was smuggled out to Hong Kong on a shipping vessel.

Wang Juntao

Wang Juntao is a Chinese dissident and democracy activist accused by the Chinese government for being one of the “black hands” behind the Tiananmen Student Movement. He was listed first on the government's “six important criminals” list, and was sentenced to a thirteen-year prison term in 1991 for his alleged work of “conspiring to subvert the government and of counterrevolutionary propaganda and agitation”. Wang was released from prison for medical reasons in 1994 and has been living in exile in the United States.

Su Xiaokang Chinese writer

Su Xiaokang is an influential intellectual, writer, journalist, political activist and in 1989 was named one of China's seven most-wanted dissident intellectuals. His most notable work River Elegy paved the way to the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989, and his participation in the protest also forced him into the exile in the aftermath of the Tiananmen Square Massacre. Su currently resides in Delaware.

A Tiananmen Journal: Republic on the Square by Feng Congde (封从德) was first published in May 2009 in Hong Kong. This book records the Tiananmen protest of 1989 from April 15, 1989, to June 4, 1989, in detail. Author Feng Congde is one of the student leader in the protest and his day-by- day diary entries, record every activity during the protest including the start of student protests in Peking University, the activities of major student leaders, important events, and unexposed stories about student organizations and their complex decision making.

Merle Goldman is an American historian of modern China. She is Professor Emerita of History, Boston University, especially known for a series of studies on the role of intellectuals under the rule of Mao Zedong and on the possibilities for democracy and political rights in present-day China.

During the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 in Beijing, China, students demanded a dialogue between Chinese government officials and student representatives. In total, three sessions of dialogue took place between the students and government representatives.

Many women participated in the Tiananmen Square Protests of 1989 for democratic reform in China. Lee Feigon states "women [during the Tiananmen Square Protests] were relegated for the most part to traditional support roles." Chai Ling and Wang Chaohua, however, were female student leaders taking part in leadership activities during the pro-democracy movement. Ranging from student leaders to intellectuals, many women contributed their opinions and leadership skills to the movement. Although women had substantial roles, they had different standpoints regarding the hunger strike movement on May 13.

The People’s Republic of Amnesia: Tiananmen Revisited is a nonfiction book by journalist Louisa Lim and published by Oxford University Press in 2014. It explores the lives of people who were affected by the Tiananmen Square protests of 1989 and the June 4 Tiananmen Square massacre in China. Lim uses personal accounts to tell the story of the 1989 student protests and their aftermath.

<i>Scarlet Memorial: Tales of Cannibalism in Modern China</i> book by Zheng Yi

Scarlet Memorial: Tales of Cannibalism in Modern China is a book of reportage literature by the Chinese novelist Zheng Yi. Zheng and a group of writers under the joint pseudonym "T. P. Sym" translated and abridged it from the Chinese work 红色 纪念碑 Hongse jinianbei. Zheng uses local government documents, eye-witness accounts and confessions to describe the factional violence and even cannibalism that occurred in the Guangxi Massacre during the Cultural Revolution (1966–1976).

The 1989 Tiananmen Square protests, commonly known in mainland China as the June Fourth Incident, were student-led demonstrations in Beijing in 1989. More broadly, it refers to the popular national movement inspired by the Beijing protests during that period, sometimes called the '89 Democracy Movement. The protests were forcibly suppressed after Chinese Premier Li Peng declared martial law. In what became known in the West as the Tiananmen Square Massacre, troops with assault rifles and tanks fired at the demonstrators trying to block the military's advance towards Tiananmen Square. The number of civilian deaths was internally estimated by the Chinese government to be near or above 10,000.

Rowena He or He Xiaoqing is a history scholar on the 1989 Tiananmen Square protests and is Associate Professor at the Department of History in the Chinese University of Hong Kong.

References

  1. "Top Five China Books of 2014". ChinaFile. 2014-12-23. Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  2. He, Rowena. Tiananmen Exiles. p. 14.
  3. "What I didn't know about Tiananmen Square". Christian Science Monitor. 2014-08-15. ISSN   0882-7729 . Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  4. Paul Levin (September 2015). "The Republic of Amnesia". American Diplomacy. Archived from the original on 2018-04-07.
  5. Tiananmen Exiles. Palgrave Macmillan. 2014. Archived from the original on 2018-04-06.
  6. "Rowena Xiaoqing He". Institute for Advanced Study. Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  7. 1 2 Siling, Luo (2016-06-21). "Teaching Tiananmen to a New Generation". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  8. 1 2 "Rowena He". Saint Michael’s College. 2018. Archived from the original on 2018-03-30.
  9. "民主中国". minzhuzhongguo.org. Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  10. "青春的记忆有力量—— 读"哈佛大学学生天安门运动研讨会特辑"". www.tiananmenmother.org. Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  11. Contributor, Dan Adams-. "Students gather at Harvard to remember Tiananmen Square - The Boston Globe". BostonGlobe.com. Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  12. "History and Memory". Harvard Magazine. 2014-06-03. Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  13. "Scholar Perry Link Visits Seminar on China | News | The Harvard Crimson". www.thecrimson.com. Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  14. "Tiananmen in History and Memory | Harvard Political Review" . Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  15. "Tiananmen Plus Twenty-five". Harvard Magazine. 2014-06-03. Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  16. "The Wellesley News" . Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  17. He, Rowena Xiaoqing (2011-12-29). "Reading Havel in Beijing". Wall Street Journal. ISSN   0099-9660 . Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  18. "Washington Post: Breaking News, World, US, DC News & Analysis".
  19. "Tiananmen: A war of memory against forgetting".
  20. Rowena Xiaoqing He (2014). Tiananmen Exiles: Voices of the Struggle for Democracy in China. Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 31–33.
  21. He, Tiananmen Exiles,14-15.
  22. 1 2 He, Tiananmen Exiles, 15.
  23. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 48.
  24. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 54-55.
  25. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 15-16.
  26. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 62.
  27. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 64.
  28. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 77.
  29. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 82.
  30. 1 2 He, Tiananmen Exiles, 91-92.
  31. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 110.
  32. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 113.
  33. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 116.
  34. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 118.
  35. He, Tiananmen Exiles ,148.
  36. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 148-149.
  37. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 77.
  38. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 162.
  39. He, Tiananmen Exiles, 164-165.
  40. 1 2 Johnson, Ian (2014-06-05). "The Ghosts of Tiananmen Square". ISSN   0028-7504 . Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  41. "Tiananmen Exiles: Voices of the Struggle for Democracy in China (Palgrave Studies in Oral History) | Human Rights in China 中国人权 | HRIC". www.hrichina.org. Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  42. Schwarcz (2016). : 516.Cite journal requires |journal= (help); Missing or empty |title= (help)
  43. Björn Alpermann, "Tiananmen Exiles: Voices of the Struggle for Democracy in China," The China Journal, no. 74 (2015): 201.
  44. Seymour, James (2017). "Tiananmen Exiles: Voices of the Struggle for Democracy in China. By Rowena Xiaoqing He". The Oral History Review. 44 (1): 221. doi:10.1093/ohr/ohw107.
  45. He, Rowena. Tiananmen Exiles. pp. 31–35.
  46. Schwarcz, Vera (2016). "Tiananmen Exiles: Voices of the Struggle for Democracy in China by Rowena Xiaoqing He (review)". Human Rights Quarterly. 38 (2): 516–519. doi:10.1353/hrq.2016.0024.
  47. Seymour. "Tiananmen Exiles": 222.Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  48. He, Rowena. Tiananmen Exiles. pp. 91–92.
  49. 1 2 "Talking to the ghosts of Tiananmen Square". The Spectator. 2014-05-31. Retrieved 2019-03-22.
  50. Mirsky, “Talking to the ghosts of Tiananmen Square.”