Anming Hu | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chinese | 胡安明 [1] | ||||||
|
Anming Hu (born 1968) [2] is a Chinese-Canadian academic who worked as an associate professor in the Department of Mechanical,Aerospace and Biomedical Engineering at the University of Tennessee,Knoxville (UTK) from 2013 to February 2020 when he was charged with fraud,after which UT suspended him.
He was arrested on February 27,2020,and charged with fraud under a 2011 law the Donald Trump administration used to target professors and researchers working at American universities as part of the "China Initiative" on combating economic espionage. Hu was accused of not disclosing his association with a Chinese university;on September 9,2021,the trial resulted in acquittal,thus Hu was cleared of all charges. On February 1,2022,he returned to his lab at UTK. [3]
Hu was the first target of the China Initiative to stand trial. He was represented by Knoxville attorney Phil Lomonaco. [4] Hu was charged with three counts of wire fraud and three counts of making false statements after 21 months of FBI surveillance failed to turn up evidence of espionage. [5] The first trial of Hu's case ended in a mistrial due to a hung jury on June 16,2021. The trial generated controversy due to the FBI's conduct,which included knowingly building a case based on false evidence,obtaining Hu's university documents without warrant,spying on Hu and his family,and attempting to coerce Hu to spy on China for the United States. [6] [7] Following the mistrial,Hu was again prosecuted by the United States Department of Justice,which resulted in a second defeat for the Justice Department when Hu was acquitted. [8]
Hu was born and raised in a rural village near Jinan in Shandong. He earned his Bachelor of Science at Shandong University in 1990,and his Master of Science as well as a PhD in condensed matter physics at the Chinese Academy of Sciences in 1993 and 1997 respectively. He immigrated to Canada,where he attended the University of Waterloo and graduated with his second PhD in laser physics in 2008. Hu had three children with his wife and became a Canadian citizen in 2009. At the time of his arrest,he had applied for permanent residency in the United States. [9] [10]
In June 2021,FBI agent Kujtim Sadiku admitted in a testimony that he falsely accused Hu of being a spy,baselessly implicated him as a Chinese military agent to UTK,and used false information to put him on the Federal No Fly List. The agent also stated he attempted to have Hu spy for the United States. Hu refused,leading to FBI agents stalking and harassing him for more than two years. [5] According to Sadiku,he got a tip that Hu might be a spy but cannot remember where he got that information. He did a Google search of Hu in March 2018,which turned up a couple of press releases in Chinese with one including a photograph of Hu. Sadiku then proceeded to use Google translation to do further research. The app made an error in translating Hu's forename in the photo caption. The translation of two documents described Hu obtaining a 2012 "short term" award to teach at Beijing University for 20 hours annually through China's Long-Term Thousand Talents Program as a visiting scholar. Sadiku investigated him based on his involvement in the program,which he described as benefiting the Chinese military. He opened up an economic espionage case because the US government believes the program aims at acquiring information and technology from the US. When Sadiku confronted Hu,Hu said that those who agreed to spy for China were "cheaters," and that he was not involved in any espionage. Sadiku offered Hu to spy for the US using his part-time work at Beijing University as cover,but Hu refused,stating that he was too afraid. Hu then sent Sadiku an email informing him that he would not go to China. Despite no longer believing Hu was a spy,Sadiku ordered a surveillance team to spy on Hu and his eldest son,then a freshman at UT,for the next 21 months. A group of six or seven agents followed him to work,to school,to the grocery,and even went through his trash. They found no evidence of espionage,but the FBI persisted in building up a case against Hu,resulting in the fraud charges. Sadiku called it Operation Chelsea Dagger. [6] [7]
The charges against Anming Hu were based on the Wolf Amendment,a 2011 defense spending bill that prevents NASA funds from being used for collaboration with "China or Chinese-owned companies." Hu was charged with three counts of wire fraud and three counts of making false statements in connection with a NASA grant he received through the University of Tennessee. Hu denied being a member of Long-Term Thousand Talents Program but admitted he had ties to the Beijing University of Technology and that he was working on a NASA grant. Hu had been upfront with his ties to a university in Beijing and followed UT administrative advice when preparing documents for the grant. As far as he knew,nothing criminal was involved in his summer work in China,which the University of Tennessee permitted. Hu had repeatedly disclosed his involvement in the Beijing university to UT,and a UT grant administrator even assured him via email that the NASA China restriction did not apply to faculty. [11] He was told by UT that he only had to disclose income from lectures in China exceeding $10,000. He earned $3,000 from his lectures in China. [12] Despite the lack of espionage charges,one of the prosecutors stated during the trial that one of the reasons for prosecuting scientists and professors was "to teach these Chinese spies a lesson." [13]
The case against Hu depended on him knowing the government's new and expansive interpretation of research funding rules and hiding his affiliations with Beijing University of Technology. [14] The indictment [15] against Hu stated:
NASA defined "China or any Chinese-owned company" to include Chinese universities ... Through his fraudulent representations and omissions to UTK about his affiliation with BJUT,HU knowingly and willfully caused UTK to falsely certify to NASA and to NASA contractors that UTK was in compliance with NASA's China Funding Restriction
The definition was not published in NASA's Grants and Cooperative Agreements Manual (GCAM) [16] but instead was circulated internally within NASA in the 2012 Grant Information Circular (GIC) 12-01A. [17] According to NASA,the Information Circular "is used for internal dissemination ...,is temporary in nature or episodic and ... should be used very carefully and their duration shall not exceed one year" (NASA NFS Section 1801.272 [18] ). As of 2016,NASA GIC 12-01A was no longer active. [19] The U.S. used the same NASA Circular in 2020 as the basis for criminal charges against Texas A&M University professor Zhengdong Cheng. [20]
Hu's trial for fraud ended on June 16,2021,in a mistrial when the jury could not reach a verdict. [5] [21] Afterward,Wendy Chandler,who was Juror 44 and one of the four female jurors in an all-white jury,stated that she kept looking for a big reveal but ultimately characterized the trial as "the most ridiculous case" and the charges against Hu as "a series of plausible errors,a lack of support from UT,and ruthless ambition on behalf of the FBI." [11] The day after the end of the trial,Democratic Representatives Ted Lieu,Mondaire Jones,and Pramila Jayapal voiced concerns about Hu's prosecution and called on Justice Department Inspector General Michael E. Horowitz to investigate allegations of FBI misconduct. [22]
On July 30,2021,the federal government announced that they would retry Anming Hu. [23]
On September 9,2021,Anming Hu was acquitted of fraud charges by a federal judge. [14] According to U.S. District Judge Thomas A. Varlan:"[E]ven viewing all the evidence in the light most favorable to the government,no rational jury could conclude that defendant acted with a scheme to defraud NASA." [8] Varlan cited testimony from NASA OIG special agent Lee Gibson: [24]
Agent Gibson of the NASA Office of Inspector General testified that the NASA grant money that defendant helped obtain went to UTK ... Further,Agent Gibson testified that he had no evidence that defendant “took any money to China or had anybody in China working on”the NASA grants. [25]
But according to NASA,"It is acceptable as long as you keep your NASA projects and your PRC related projects separate,i.e.,don't use any NASA funds for projects with the PRC". [26] Varlan further wrote,"In fact,Agent Gibson specifically testified that he was not sure whether BJUT was incorporated under the laws of the People’s Republic of China." [25] Although Gibson speculated that NASA considered BJUT to be a Chinese-owned company [27] NASA Senior Analyst Chris Murguia stated that 'a state-owned university [such as BJUT] would be considered “China”',whereas a private university is a "Chinese-owned company". [28]
It was revealed during the trial that the University of Tennessee aided the FBI in their investigation by handing over Hu's university documents without a warrant,concealing the investigation from him,misleading NASA,and firing him the moment he was arrested. Meetings were set up between Hu's bosses and the FBI but it is unclear who authorized these meetings. The FBI did not have any proof of wrongdoing by Hu when they entered UT and did not have the legal authority to take records from his personnel files. [29]
The university suspended Hu without pay and the federal government revoked his work authorization. According to the faculty handbook,the faculty senate president should be consulted when the administration is considering suspending a tenured faculty member,which did not happen. The then-president was only informed of the case. [30]
After being acquitted of wrongdoing,UT Provost and Senior Vice Chancellor John Zomchick said the university was willing to undo Hu's termination if he could verify U.S. authorization to work in the next year. According to Mary McAlpin,the president of the UT chapter of the American Association of University Professors,regaining his work visa would require sponsorship from UT. [30]
Subsequently,in October 2021 the university offered to reinstate Hu with some back pay,research funding,and university support to regain his work visa. [31] His reinstatement was finalized effective February 1,2022. [32]
The prosecution of Anming Hu was led by Assistant U.S. Attorney Casey Arrowood. [33] Arrowood was nominated in 2022 by President Biden for U.S. Attorney of the Eastern District of Tennessee. [34] Asian American civil rights groups called on supporters to oppose the nomination,which they called an "affront to the Asian American,immigrant,and scientific communities." [35] [36] Hu said that instead of being punished,Arrowood is being rewarded,encouraging future cases such as his to happen again. [36]
The OCA-Asian Pacific American Advocates denounced the government's decision to retry Anming Hu. OCA National president Linda Ng accused law enforcement of rampant anti-Asian sentiment and "systemic efforts to strip Asian Americans and Asian immigrants of their civil liberties." Nearly 100 members of Congress led by Representative Ted Lieu sent a letter to Attorney General Merrick Garland calling for an investigation into the "wrongful targeting of individuals of Asian descent." [23] US Congressperson Judy Chu accused the FBI of racial profiling in a Congressional Asian Pacific American Caucus (CAPAC) statement,pointing out that Hu's case is only the most glaring of many FBI cases that had been flawed from the start,"evident in the number of cases that have been dropped without any explanation." [29] [37]
Wen Ho Lee or Li Wenho is a Taiwanese-American nuclear scientist and a mechanical engineer who worked for the University of California at the Los Alamos National Laboratory in New Mexico. He created computerized simulations of nuclear explosions for the purposes of scientific inquiry,as well as for improving the safety and reliability of the U.S. nuclear arsenal.
The Ministry of State Security (MSS) is the principal civilian intelligence,security and secret police agency of the People's Republic of China,responsible for foreign intelligence,counterintelligence,and the political security of the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). One of the largest and most secretive intelligence organizations in the world,it is headquartered in Haidian,Beijing,with powerful semi-autonomous branches at the provincial,city,municipality and township levels throughout China.
Elizabeth Terrill Bentley was an American NKVD spymaster,who was recruited from within the Communist Party USA (CPUSA). She served the Soviet Union as the primary handler of multiple highly placed moles within both the United States Federal Government and the Office of Strategic Services from 1938 to 1945. She defected by contacting the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and debriefing about her espionage activities.
The Lawrence Franklin espionage scandal involved Lawrence Franklin,a former United States Department of Defense employee,passing classified documents regarding United States policy towards Iran to Israel. Franklin pleaded guilty to several espionage-related charges and was sentenced in January 2006 to nearly 13 years of prison,which was later reduced to ten months' house arrest. Franklin passed information to American Israel Public Affairs Committee policy director Steven Rosen and AIPAC senior Iran analyst Keith Weissman,who were fired by AIPAC. They were then indicted for illegally conspiring to gather and disclose classified national security information to Israel. However,prosecutors later dropped all charges against them without any plea bargain.
Richard William Miller was an American FBI agent who was the first FBI agent indicted for and convicted of espionage. In 1991,he was sentenced to 20 years in prison but was freed after serving fewer than three years.
Noshir Sheriarji Gowadia is a former design engineer and convicted spy for several countries. He was arrested in 2005 and later convicted on industrial espionage-related federal charges.
Brian Patrick Regan is a former master sergeant in the United States Air Force who was convicted of offering to sell secret information to foreign governments.
The American media referred to 1985 as the Year of the Spy because law enforcement arrested many foreign spies operating on American soil. However,the preceding year,1984,actually had more arrests for espionage in the United States.
Stewart David Nozette is an American planetary scientist,technologist,and consultant who worked for the United States Department of Energy,the United States Department of Defense,DARPA,the United States Naval Research Laboratory,and NASA. He is also a convicted felon for attempted espionage and fraud against the United States. The FBI arrested him on October 19,2009,charging him with attempted espionage after a sting operation which Nozette's lawyer claims amounted to entrapment. At trial,Nozette admitted attempting to sell U.S. classified information to someone he believed was an Israeli Mossad operative,but was in reality an undercover Federal Bureau of Investigation employee. He pleaded guilty to one charge of attempted espionage and was sentenced,under the terms of a plea bargain,to thirteen years in prison. After serving time at the Federal Correctional Institution,Terre Haute,Nozette was released on November 13,2020.
The United States has often accused the People's Republic of China of attempting to unlawfully acquire U.S. military technology and classified information as well as trade secrets of U.S. companies in order to support China's long-term military and commercial development. Chinese government agencies and affiliated personnel have been accused of using a number of methods to obtain U.S. technology,including espionage,exploitation of commercial entities,and a network of scientific,academic and business contacts. Prominent espionage cases include Larry Wu-tai Chin,Katrina Leung,Gwo-Bao Min,Chi Mak,Peter Lee,and Shujun Wang. The Ministry of State Security (MSS) maintains a bureau dedicated to espionage against the United States,the United States Bureau.
The University of Tennessee,Knoxville is a public land-grant research university in Knoxville,Tennessee,United States. Founded in 1794,two years before Tennessee became the 16th state,it is the flagship campus of the University of Tennessee system,with ten undergraduate colleges and eleven graduate colleges. It hosts more than 30,000 students from all 50 states and more than 100 foreign countries. It is classified among "R1:Doctoral Universities –Very high research activity".
The Sarah Palin email hack occurred on September 16,2008,during the 2008 United States presidential election campaign when vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin's personal Yahoo! email account was subjected to unauthorized access. The hacker,David Kernell,obtained access to Palin's account by looking up biographical details,such as her high school and birthdate,and using Yahoo!'s account recovery for forgotten passwords. Kernell then posted several pages of Palin's email on 4chan's /b/ board. Kernell,who at the time of the offense was a 20-year-old college student,was the son of longtime Democratic state representative Mike Kernell of Memphis.
Glenn Duffie Shriver is an American convicted of conspiracy to commit espionage for China. At the behest of Chinese intelligence,Shriver unsuccessfully applied for jobs with the US State Department and CIA,meeting with handlers from China more than 20 times. He was first approached while living in China by operatives of the Shanghai State Security Bureau,a subsidiary of China's Ministry of State Security (MSS),who hoped to develop a mole which would provide them information regarding American foreign policy. He was caught and arrested by the FBI soon after applying to a job with the CIA's National Clandestine Service. In a 2010 plea bargain,he pled guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit unlawful conveyance of national defense information,and served four years in prison at the Federal Correctional Institution in Elkton,Ohio. He was released in 2013,and was later depicted in the short film Game of Pawns,commissioned by the FBI.
Samuel Scott Alden was an American special assistant to Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Director J. Edgar Hoover,FBI special agent,director of the Tennessee Alcoholic Beverage Commission,lawyer,college professor,and a college sports coach. He was also a direct descendant of John Alden,a pilgrim who came to the United States on the Mayflower. Alden studied at the University of Tennessee where he played for coach Robert Neyland on their 1927 football team,but did not graduate from there. He instead enrolled in and graduated from Peabody College,then chose to pursue a law degree from Vanderbilt University Law School.
Feng "Franklin" Tao is a Chinese-born American chemical engineer who was a tenured associate professor at the University of Kansas. His research areas of specialization are heterogeneous catalysis,energy chemistry,nanoscience and surface science.
Sirous Asgari is an Iranian materials scientist and academic known for his research in lithium ion batteries,phase transformation and diffusion in solid materials. He is currently a full professor in the Department of Materials Science and Engineering at Sharif University of Technology,Iran.
Alexander Yuk Ching Ma is an American former CIA clandestine officer accused of acting as a double agent on behalf of the People's Republic of China,gaining employment with the FBI in order to act as a mole. He was arrested in August 2020,charged under the Espionage Act with conspiring along with his brother,also a former CIA officer,to pass classified information to officials of the Chinese Ministry of State Security. He pled guilty and was sentenced to 10 years in prison.
The China Initiative was a program by the United States Department of Justice to prosecute perceived Chinese spies in American research and industry,in order to combat economic espionage. Launched in November 2018,the program targeted hundreds of prominent Chinese-American academics and scientists,of which an estimated 250 lost their jobs,and many more had their careers negatively impacted. The persecution also contributed to at least one suicide.
Casey Thomas Arrowood is an American lawyer serving as an assistant United States attorney since 2016. He was nominated to serve as the United States attorney for the Eastern District of Tennessee.
According to guidance published by NASA and circulated to grant applicants, "Chinese universities and other similar institutions are considered to be incorporated under the laws of the PRC and, therefore, the funding restrictions apply to grants and cooperative agreements that include bilateral participation, collaboration, or coordination with Chinese universities."
This article needs additional or more specific categories .(August 2021) |