Tsanars

Last updated

Tsanars [lower-alpha 1] were a Caucasian people who are mentioned in Arabic texts of the eight-to-tenth centuries AD. They originally lived near Darial Gorge north of Tbilisi but expanded to Kakheti. In the ninth and tenth centuries, Tsanars migrated to regions near Shakki around passes connecting Kakheti with Dagestan.

Contents

Nomenclature

Pliny the Elder in first century AD named Tsanars Sanaroi (Σαναροι). The Armenian name Tsanar(k') (Ծանար(ք)) is found in the seventh-century work Ashkharhatsuyts, according to which, the Alans called Tsanars Tselkan. The same name is found in the tenth-century Georgian chronicle Conversion of Kartli which mentions the Tselkans, Pkhovelians, Mtiulians and Tchartalians (inhabitants of Chartalis-Khevi River, a tributary of the Aragvi). In the tenth-century Arabic work Hudud al-'Alam , Tsanars are named Ṣanār (صنار). [1]

The name may be present in the ethnonymy and toponymy of the Central Caucasus. According to German scientist Julius Klaproth, the Ossetians called the Mokhevians Tsona, and the region spanning Darial Gorge to Kobi Sona-Sena. in 1970, Russian historian and caucasologist Nataliya Volkova  [ ru ] recorded the Ossetian name for Kazbek as Sæna (Сæна) in the village of Kobi. The Kabardian name for Svans, and sometimes the entire population south of the Cross Pass  [ ru ], is sonē (сонэ). It is possible these names are comparable to the ethnonym Tsanars. [2]

Contemporaneous documentation

Early mentions

Tsanars were known to Ptolemy. [3] [4] Pliny the Elder mentioned Tsanars (Σαναροι) in the first century as a people who occupied Darial Gorge and the territory to the south. The seventh-century work Ashkharhatsuyts mentions Tsanars as Tsanar(k') (Ծանար(ք)), the neighbours of Tushs and Dvals, and on whose land were the mountain passes of Alans and Tselkans. [5]

Arab invasions

In Muslim historiography, stories about unrest among the Tsanars have been preserved. [6] According to Arab authors like al-Ya'qubi, the warlike mountaineers Tsanars became especially active in the second half of the eighth and early ninth centuries. Their frequent rebellions worried the Arab administration of Arminiya. [7]

According to the story of eighth-century historian Al-Baladhuri, Yazid ibn Asid marched to the Bāb al-Lān (Gates of Alans) and defeated rebelling Tsanars, afterwards imposing kharaj ('land tax') on them. Historians Mikhail Artamonov and Aram Ter-Ghevondyan relate this battle and other events to the first period of the reign of Yazid ibn Asid in Arminiya (c. 752 – 754). This dating is dismissed by Arsen Shaginyan  [ ru ] who notes in the story of Al-Baladhuri, the battle happened "when al-Mansur became the caliph". [8]

According to the story of al-Ya'qubi, Amr ibn Ismail arrived at the request of the ruler of Arminiya and led a 20,000-strong army against Tsanars, killing 16,000 of them in one day and moving to Tbilisi. [6] He also mentions under the rule of al-'Abbas ibn Zufar al-Hilali, who was appointed by Harun al-Rashid, Tsanars again rebelled. [9] According to the story Kitabul Futuh by Ibn A'tham al-Kufi, al-Hasan ibn Qahtab led a 30,000-strong army against Tsanars, killing 10,000 of them. He then marched on and conquered the rebellious inhabitants of Javakhit (Javakheti-Javakhk). [6]

After the death of Ishaq ibn Isma'il, Abbasid commander Bugha al-Kabir conducted a military campaign against Ishaq's allies the Tsanars. [10] The Georgian Chronicles says Bugha's army was 120,000-strong. [11] Tsanars were effective against his troops, defeating him multiple times in short succession. Bugha fought Tsanars either sixteen or nineteen times in nine days, and his repeated losses were humiliating. [12] According to Tovma Artsruni, after the losses, Bugha invaded Caucasian Albania. [13]

Tovma Artsruni does not mention any outside help but according to Ya'qubi, Tsanars requested help against Bugha from Byzantines, Khazars and the Saqāliba (Slavs). [lower-alpha 2] Faced with this army, Bugha wrote to al-Mutawakkil, who sent Muhammad ibn Khalid al-Shaybani as governor over the north. This calmed Tsanars enough to seek peace. Joseph Laurent and Marius Canard note their main goal was to maintain the Kura River as a territorial divide. Later allies of Tsanars indicate they were involved in power struggles between groups of Arabs in the north. Al-Yaqubi confirms their good connections to other non-Georgian, both Christian and non-Christian, ethnic groups of the Caucasus and beyond. [12]

Ethnicity and localization

Historians debate the ethnicity of Tsanars. [15] [16] [17] Historians Vladimir Minorsky, Anatoly Novoseltsev and others connect them with the Vainakhs (Chechens and Ingush). [lower-alpha 3] Georgian historians Sargis Kakabadze, Mariam Lortkipanidze and others connect them with the Svans [18] [19] or with Georgians in general. [20] [21] [22] [23] Historian Givi Tsulaya  [ ru ] disagrees the ethnicity of Tsanars is debatable, saying this point of view is "too categorical to be accepted unconditionally". [24] According to Tsulaya, the Tsanars were an ethnic group of Eastern Georgia. [15] According to al-Masudi, the Tsanars "claim to be descended from the Arabs, namely from Nizār b. Maʿadd b. Muḍar, and a branch (fakhdh) of ʿUqayl, settled there since olden times".[ citation needed ] Vladimir Minorsky dismisses this claim, stating the Tsanars "certainly had nothing to do with Arab tribes". [12] Commenting to Hudud al-'Alam , Vasily Bartold suggested a genetic connection of Tsanars with North Dagestanis. [25] Russian historian and caucasologist Nataliya Volkova  [ ru ] dismisses versions precisely attributing Tsanars to Vainakhs, Dagestanis or Georgians due to the lack of direct evidence of the linguistic affiliation. Based on the ethnic situation in this region in the ancient and early medieval periods, it could be assumed the Tsanars were an Ibero-Caucasian speaking group. [26] The Tsanars later gradually merged with the Georgians. [15] [17]

Historians also debate the territory of the Tsanars, who were mostly localized in Kakheti (Georgia) and Shakki (Caucasian Albania). Al-Masudi places them between Tbilisi and Bāb al-Lān (modern day Darial Gorge [27] ) Apparently referring to al-Masudi, the anonymous author of Hudud al-'Alam places Tsanars between Tbilisi and Shaki; the length of their country is measured as 20 farsakhs. [lower-alpha 4] [25] According to the Darband-nāmeh, they lived in Jurzān, a term that usually refers to Kartli (Georgia). [28] Historian Cyril Toumanoff notes the word Ṣanāriya "was used by Arabs to designate Kaxetia in general ... In Georgian sources, on the other hand, the Canars are encountered only in the narrow sense of the term". [29] Vladimir Minorsky said Tsanars originally inhabited Darial Gorge but later expanded eastwards into Kakheti. [30] In the ninth and tenth centuries, the centres of Tsanars moved eastwards to the region near Shakki and the passes connecting Kakheti with Dagestan [3]

Notes

  1. Also spelled Ts'anars, Canars; Ancient Greek: Σαναροι, romanized: Sanaroi; Alanic: Tselkan; Armenian: Ծանար(ք), romanized: Tsanar(k'); Arabic: صنار, romanized: Ṣanār; Georgian :წანარი, romanized:ts'anari
  2. Historian Josef Markwart considers this the earliest mention of a Slavic State in history. [14]
  3. Novoseltsev 1990, p. 107 (see the citation 94 on p. 156), referring to Minorsky 1963, p. 211; Novoseltsev, Pashuto & Cherepnin 1972, p. 40.
  4. Farsakh—measure of length, varying depending on the area from 6 to 8 km (3.7 to 5.0 mi). [25]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kingdom of the Iberians</span> Medieval Georgian state

The Kingdom of the Iberians was a medieval Georgian monarchy under the Bagrationi dynasty which emerged circa 888 AD, succeeding the Principality of Iberia, in historical region of Tao-Klarjeti, or upper Iberia in north-eastern Turkey as well parts of modern southwestern Georgia, that stretched from the Iberian gates in the south and to the Lesser Caucasus in the north.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ashot I of Iberia</span> Kouropalatēs

Ashot I the Great was a presiding prince of Iberia, first of the Bagratid family to have attained to this office c. 813. From his base in Tao-Klarjeti, he fought to enlarge the Bagratid territories and sought the Byzantine protectorate against the Arab Muslim encroachment until being murdered c. 826. Ashot is also known as Ashot I Kouropalates for the Byzantine title of kouropalates that he bore. A patron of Christian culture and a friend of the church, he has been canonized by the Georgian Orthodox Church.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tsanareti</span> Historic district in the early medieval Caucasus

Tsanareti was a historic district (Khevi) in the early medieval Caucasus, lying chiefly in what is now the northeastern corner in Georgia’s region of Mtskheta-Mtianeti.

The Dvals were a ethnographic group of Georgians. Their lands lying on both sides of the central Greater Caucasus mountains, somewhere between the Darial and Mamison gorges. This historic territory mostly covers the north of Kartli, parts of the Racha and Khevi regions in Georgia and south of Ossetia in Russia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Emirate of Tbilisi</span> Muslim outpost in the Caucasus

The Emirate of Tbilisi was a Muslim emirate in Transcaucasia. The Emirs of Tbilisi ruled over the parts of today's eastern Georgia from their base in the city of Tbilisi, from 736 to 1080. Established by the Arabs during their rule of Georgian lands, the emirate was an important outpost of the Muslim rule in the Caucasus until recaptured by the Georgians under King David IV in 1122.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sarir</span> Christian Dagestan state, 5th-12th century

Sarir or Serir was a medieval Christian state lasting from the 6th or 7th century to the 12th century in the mountainous regions of modern-day Dagestan in southern Russia. Its name is derived from the Arabic word for "throne" and refers to a golden throne that was viewed as a symbol of royal authority.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arab–Khazar wars</span> Series of wars between the Arabs and Khazars over control of the Caucasus

The Arab–Khazar wars were a series of conflicts fought between the Khazar Khaganate and successive Arab caliphates in the Caucasus region from c. 642 to 799 CE. Smaller native principalities were also involved in the conflict as vassals of the two empires. Historians usually distinguish two major periods of conflict, the First Arab–Khazar War and Second Arab–Khazar War ; the wars also involved sporadic raids and isolated clashes from the mid-seventh century to the end of the eighth century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sajid dynasty</span> 889–929 Iranian Muslim dynasty of Azerbaijan and Armenia

The Sajid dynasty, was an Iranian Muslim dynasty that ruled from 889/890 until 929. The Sajids ruled Azerbaijan and parts of Armenia first from Maragha and Barda and then from Ardabil. The Sajids originated from the Central Asian province of Ushrusana and were of Iranian (Sogdian) descent. Muhammad ibn Abi'l-Saj Diwdad the son of Diwdad, the first Sajid ruler of Azerbaijan, was appointed as its ruler in 889 or 890. Muhammad's father Abu'l-Saj Devdad had fought under the Ushrusanan prince Afshin Khaydar during the latter's final campaign against the rebel Babak Khorramdin in Azerbaijan, and later served the caliphs. Toward the end of the 9th century, as the central authority of the Abbasid Caliphate weakened, Muhammad was able to form a virtually independent state. Much of the Sajids' energies were spent in attempting to take control of neighboring Armenia. The dynasty ended with the death of Abu'l-Musafir al-Fath in 929.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arminiya</span> Province of the Arab Caliphates

Arminiya, also known as the Ostikanate of Arminiya or the Emirate of Armenia, was a political and geographic designation given by the Muslim Arabs to the lands of Greater Armenia, Caucasian Iberia, and Caucasian Albania, following their conquest of these regions in the 7th century. Though the caliphs initially permitted an Armenian prince to represent the province of Arminiya in exchange for tribute and the Armenians' loyalty during times of war, Caliph Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan introduced direct Arab rule of the region, headed by an ostikan with his capital in Dvin. According to the historian Stephen H. Rapp in the third edition of the Encyclopaedia of Islam:

Early Arabs followed Sāsānian, Parthian Arsacid, and ultimately Achaemenid practice by organising most of southern Caucasia into a large regional zone called Armīniya.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shirvanshahs</span> State in Shirvan (861–1538)

The Shirvanshahs were the rulers of Shirvan from 861 to 1538. The first ruling line were the Yazidids, an originally Arab and later Persianized dynasty, who became known as the Kasranids. The second ruling line were the Darbandi, distant relatives of the Yazidids/Kasranids.

Adarnase IV was a member of the Georgian Bagratid dynasty of Tao-Klarjeti and prince of Iberia, responsible for the restoration of the Iberian kingship, which had been in abeyance since it had been abolished by Sasanian Empire in the 6th century, in 888.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Durdzuks</span> Name in the Georgian Chronicles for Vainakh peoples

The Durdzuks, also known as Dzurdzuks, was a medieval exonym of the 9th-18th centuries used mainly in Georgian, Arabic, but also Armenian sources in reference to the Vainakh peoples.

Muhammad ibn Khalid ibn Yazid al-Shaybani was an Arab general and governor for the Abbasid Caliphate, active in the Caliphate's Caucasian provinces in the 9th century.

Lashkar Haytham ibn Khalid was the first Shirvanshah, or independent ruler of Shirvan, renouncing the suzerainty of the Abbasid Caliphate in 861 after Anarchy at Samarra and beginning the rule of Mazyadid or Yazidid dynasty.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Arab rule in Georgia</span> Medieval Arab-Muslim conquests in Georgia

Arab rule in Georgia, natively known as Araboba refers to the period in the History of Georgia when all or part of the country was under political domination of Muslim Arab rulers, from the first Arab incursions in the mid-7th century until the final defeat of the Emirate of Tbilisi at the hands of King David IV in 1122. Compared with other regions which endured Muslim conquests, Georgia's culture, and even political structure was not much affected by the Arab presence, as the people kept their faith, the nobles their fiefdoms, and the foreign rulers mostly insisted on the payment of tribute, which they could not always enforce. Still, repeated invasions and military campaigns by the Arabs devastated Georgia on many occasions, and the Caliphs retained suzerainty over large parts of the country and exerted influence over the internal power dynamics during most of the period.

Ishaq b. Isma'il b. Shuab al-Tiflisi , also known as Sahak in Georgian sources, was the emir of Tbilisi between 833 and 853. He was married to a daughter of king of Sarir and followed his uncle Ali on the throne.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Zagem</span>

Zagem or Bazari was a town in the southeast Caucasus, in the eastern Georgian kingdom of Kakheti. It flourished from the 15th to the 17th century as a vibrant commercial and artisanal centre. In the 1550s, it became a dependency of the Karabakh–Ganja province of Safavid Iran. The fortunes of the town were reversed by Safavid military actions in the area in 1615. By the 1720s, the town had been reduced to an insignificant hamlet. The settlement was located in what is now the Zaqatala District of Azerbaijan, but no evidence of the town remains at the site. The toponym Zagem is found exclusively in non-Georgian sources; Georgians knew it as Bazari, meaning "bazaar".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kingdom of Kakheti-Hereti</span> Medieval Georgian kingdom

The Kingdom of Kakheti-Hereti was an early Medieval monarchy in eastern Georgia, centered at the province of Kakheti, with its capital first at Telavi. It emerged in c. 1014 AD, under the leadership of energetic ruler of principality of Kakheti, Kvirike III the Great that finally defeated the ruler of Hereti and crowned himself as a king of the unified realms of Kakheti and Hereti. From this time on, until 1104, the kingdom was an independent and separated state from the united Kingdom of Georgia. The kingdom included territories from riv. Ksani to Alijanchay river and from Didoeti to southwards along the river of Mtkvari.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dzheyrakh</span> Rural locality in Ingushetia, Russia

Dzheyrakh - is a village and administrative center of Dzheyrakhsky District, in the Republic of Ingushetia, Russia.

Sultan-Murza or Saltan-Murza was an Ingush feudal lord who controlled the Darial Gorge and the village located in it, Lars. In 1589, he swore allegiance to the Russian Tsar Feodor I as part of the Georgian embassy, therefore becoming subordinated to the Tsardom of Russia.

References

  1. Volkova 1973, pp. 125–126.
  2. Volkova 1973, pp. 126–127.
  3. 1 2 Minorsky 1953, p. 506 (note 3).
  4. Rapp 2003, p.  399.
  5. Volkova 1973, p. 125.
  6. 1 2 3 Shaginyan 2008a, p. 82.
  7. Shaginyan 2008a, p. 87 (citation 27).
  8. Shaginyan 2008a, p. 78.
  9. Shaginyan 2008a, p. 85.
  10. Minorsky 1958, p. 19.
  11. Shaginyan 2008b, p. 112.
  12. 1 2 3 Vacca 2017, pp. 85–86.
  13. Minorsky 1953, p. 512.
  14. Minorsky 1958, p. 110 (note 2).
  15. 1 2 3 Novoseltsev 1990, p. 107.
  16. Vacca 2017, p. 85.
  17. 1 2 Tuallagov 2018, p. 26.
  18. Novoseltsev 1990, p. 107 (see the citation 94 on p. 156).
  19. "batsav | prof. topchishvili on the batsbi". www.batsav.com. Retrieved 2024-02-16.
  20. SHIOLASHVILI, PKHALADZE, AKHALADZE, BURDULI, KISTAURI. ETUDES FROM TRUSSO'S PAST (in English and Georgian). pp.  http://sciencejournals.ge/index.php/HAE/article/download/378/335/.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  21. ITONISHVILI. "დვალეთის ისტორიის საკითხები მრუდე სარკეში" (PDF).
  22. Chikobava, Akaki. "საქართველოს ისტორიის ნარკვევები. ტომი II. საქართველოს IV-X საუკუნეებში. თბილისი. 1973".{{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  23. Japaridze, Anania (2022). ალბანეთის საკათალიკოსო და საქართველოს ეკლესიის: იურისდიქცია კახეთსა და ჰერეთში [Catholicos Church of Albania and Church of Georgia: Jurisdiction in Kakheti and Hereti](PDF) (in Georgian). pp. 8–9.
  24. Tsulaya 1986, p. 26 (citation 130).
  25. 1 2 3 Volkova 1973, p. 126.
  26. Volkova 1973, p. 127.
  27. Dunlop 1960.
  28. Vacca 2017, pp. 86–87.
  29. Rapp 2003, p.  398.
  30. Minorsky 1958, p. 162 (note 1).

Sources