2010 Fox Glacier FU-24 crash

Last updated

2010 Fox Glacier FU-24 crash
VH-JAV (16027849414) - Blurred details.jpg
A Fletcher FU-24 adapted for skydiving similar to the accident aircraft
Accident
Date4 September 2010 (2010-09-04)
SummaryExcessive pitch-up during take-off leading to a stall, cause undetermined
Site Fox Glacier Aerodrome, New Zealand
43°27′39″S170°00′53″E / 43.46083°S 170.01472°E / -43.46083; 170.01472
Aircraft
Aircraft type Fletcher FU-24
OperatorSkydive New Zealand
Registration ZK-EUF
Flight origin Fox Glacier Aerodrome, New Zealand
DestinationFox Glacier Aerodrome, New Zealand
Occupants9
Passengers4
Crew5
Fatalities9
Survivors0

On 4 September 2010, a modified Fletcher FU-24 aeroplane on a parachuting flight from Fox Glacier Aerodrome, New Zealand, crashed shortly after take-off, killing all nine people on board.

Contents

The subsequent investigation concluded that the most significant factor contributing to the accident was the weight and balance configuration on the accident flight, which resulted in the aircraft's centre of gravity being located beyond its rear limit, leading to loss of control immediately after lift-off. [1] After the report was released, additional inquiries identified problems with the way that the accident investigation had been conducted, leading to public criticism. Responding to the public pressure, the commission that investigated the accident reviewed the circumstances and findings of the original investigation, and released an amended report that acknowledged that the true cause of the crash could not be determined, in part due to mishandling of the original investigation. As a result, new policies were implemented to improve the quality, transparency, and expertise of air accident investigations in New Zealand.

Accident

The pilot had already completed nine parachuting operations that day, before stopping for lunch. [2] : 1  At 1:20pm (local time, UTC+12), after the aircraft was refuelled with about 160 litres of fuel, the pilot and passengers – four skydiving instructors and four tourists – boarded the aircraft. [2] : 1 

Eyewitnesses reported the aircraft's take-off roll appeared to be normal, but after lifting off the ground it continued pitching upwards until it was almost vertical. At around 350 feet, the aircraft rolled to the left so the nose was pointing down, and dived towards the ground. The aircraft was observed to be pulling out of the dive, but impacted with the ground at 1:25pm at an almost vertical angle and burst into flames, killing all nine on board. [2] : 1 

The pilot and three of the instructors were New Zealanders; the other instructor and one of the tourists were Australian; the other three tourists were an Irishman, an Englishman and a German woman. [3] [4] [5] It was the worst aircraft crash in New Zealand in 17 years. [6] [7]

Aircraft

The aircraft was a single-engine Fletcher FU-24, a type manufactured in New Zealand and usually used for aerial topdressing. The accident aircraft had been modified in 1998 by replacing the original piston engine with a Walter M601 turboprop engine. [2] : 2  After being purchased by Skydive New Zealand in early 2010, the aircraft was further modified to carry out parachuting operations and re-entered service in this configuration in July, two months before the accident. [2] : 2–3  [8]

Aftermath

A week after the crash, on 11 September the New Zealand Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) issued an emergency airworthiness directive (AD), applicable to all FU-24s engaged in parachuting operations. [9] The AD limits the number of people that can be carried in the rear of the aircraft; and requires accurate determination of passenger weights and of the CofG. [9] In February 2011, the company that manufactured the aircraft released statements critical of the practice of putting larger, more powerful engines in its aircraft, stating that the change could have been a factor in the Fox Glacier and other fatal accidents. [10]

Investigation

New Zealand's Transport Accident Investigation Commission (TAIC) investigated the accident. [2] In an interim report released in November 2010, the investigators found that the aircraft was five kilograms overweight, and that the seating arrangement of the passengers in the aircraft negatively affected its centre of gravity. [8] The TAIC investigators also noted that the passengers were not secured with restraints and that further examination was needed to determine whether that was an additional factor in the crash. [8] Because each passenger had not been individually weighed, an estimate of the total weight of the passengers, weight, and fuel was used in the commission's calculations. [2] : 3  The interim report did not contain any analysis, or conclusions, and noted that the findings, analysis, and conclusions of the final report may differ. [2] : vii 

The TAIC released its final report in May 2012. [11] The report concluded that "The most likely reason for the crash was the aeroplane being excessively out of balance [which] created a tendency for the nose to pitch up". [12] : 17  It also stated that the aircraft probably became airborne too early and at too low an airspeed to prevent an uncontrollable pitch up. [12] : 17  It also said that the extreme pitch angle made it improbable that the unrestrained sky divers could have prevented themselves from sliding back to the tail of the aircraft, increasing the weight balance issues. [12] : 18  It pointed out flaws in the management of the conversion of the aircraft for skydiving purposes, and documentation errors had not been noticed by the CAA, which approved the modifications. [10] The commission assigned the blame for the crash to the pilot, the company that operated the plane, the firm that modified the aircraft into a skydiving configuration, and the Civil Aviation Authority. [11]

In August 2012, a coroner's inquest into the deaths of the occupants of the aircraft was held in Greymouth, and was streamed live on the Ministry of Justice website. [13] A Fletcher test pilot and an engineer provided expert testimony at the inquest that raised doubts about the conclusions reached in the TAIC's final report. [12] : 5  The coroner's final report, released in May 2013, was critical of the way that the investigation had been conducted by the TAIC, and challenged the conclusions reached in the commission's final report. [14] The investigators had ordered the wreckage of the aircraft to be buried only three days after the accident, which prevented any further investigation into possible mechanical failures or inadvertent pilot errors that may have led to or contributed to the crash. [14] The coroner's report felt that it was unlikely that there was any load shift in the aircraft, and that although weight and balance issues may have contributed to the accident, it was likely that some other unknown factor caused the crash. [14]

After the publication of the coroner's report, investigators from the TV3 Third Degree series became interested in profiling the story. [12] : 5  Enlisting the help of a private forensic engineer and air accident investigator, the television investigators dug up the wreckage of the aircraft that had been buried shortly after the accident, and conducted flight tests in a similar aircraft. [12] : 5, 24  In a report televised on TV3 on March 26, 2014, the program cast serious doubts on the investigation that had been performed by the TAIC. [15] Among other flaws, the reporting was critical of the fact that the wreckage of the aircraft had been buried on the orders of the TAIC before key components, including the control stick and cables, could be examined by investigators. [16] The private forensic engineer said, “I would think on the evidence we have available, that a control system failure of some sort is likely". [16] After the reports, members of the New Zealand aviation industry and relatives of the victims raised concerns about the TAIC's findings. [12] : 6  In April, in response to the media reports, the TAIC announced that it would take a second look at its investigation into the crash. [17] It said that it would involve several consultants, including a metallurgist, in the review. [10]

In 2015, an independent review of the commission's investigation and report found that the conclusions reached by the TAIC were "probably wrong". [18] It said that because the wreckage of the aircraft had been buried shortly after the accident, the ability to find the true cause of the crash was limited. [18] It announced that additional funding had been sought for the Commission to enable the hiring of additional investigators, and that at least two investigators would be deployed when investigating future accidents. [19] : 1  It also announced changes in its investigative policy, including the removal of all evidence from an accident site and securing it during the duration of the investigation, the greater use of external experts, increased transparency, and increased training of investigators. [19] : 2  MP Phil Twyford said the report revealed "appalling incompetence" on the part of the TAIC, saying, "This is unbelievable mickey-mouse conduct by an agency that's charged with investigating some of our most serious transport accidents". [18] The head commissioner of the TAIC said that an apology to the families of the victims would not be necessary, although some of the families disagreed, saying "We were totally expecting an apology. When we heard her come out yesterday and say very little has changed and they won't be apologising at all, it just stinks of arrogance." [18] A New Zealand First spokesman said the incident was embarrassing for New Zealand and could affect its reputation as an adventure-tourism destination, and a Green Party spokesperson said, "The commission probably owes the family a serious apology and, if they are unwilling to issue that apology, I definitely think that the minister should be pulling them up." [18]

In October 2015, the TAIC revised the final report, concluding, "[TAIC] considered various adverse factors that might have been present singly or in combination, but could not determine the cause of the excessive pitch-up at take-off that preceded the steep climb and the subsequent stall." [20]

Memorial

Memorial at Te Kopikopiko o te Waka viewing point Te Kopikopiko o te Waka viewpoint - MC 05.jpg
Memorial at Te Kopikopiko o te Waka viewing point

A memorial to the nine people who died in the crash is located at the Te Kopikopiko o te Waka viewing point located 9 kilometres (5.6 mi) to the west of the Fox Glacier township.

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aviation accidents and incidents</span> Accidental aviation occurences

An aviation accident is an event during aircraft operation that causes serious injury, death, or destruction. An aviation incident is any operating event that compromises safety but does not progress to an aviation accident. Preventing accidents and incidents is the main goal of aviation safety.

1947 BSAA Avro Lancastrian <i>Star Dust</i> accident Fatal aviation accident

On 2 August 1947, Star Dust, a British South American Airways (BSAA) Avro Lancastrian airliner on a flight from Buenos Aires, Argentina, to Santiago, Chile, crashed into Mount Tupungato in the Argentine Andes. An extensive search operation failed to locate the wreckage, despite covering the area of the crash site. The fate of the aircraft and its occupants remained unknown for over fifty years, giving rise to various conspiracy theories about its disappearance.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mount Erebus disaster</span> November 1979 aviation accident in Antarctica

The Mount Erebus disaster occurred on 28 November 1979 when Air New Zealand Flight 901 (TE901) flew into Mount Erebus on Ross Island, Antarctica, killing all 237 passengers and 20 crew on board. Air New Zealand had been operating scheduled Antarctic sightseeing flights since 1977. This flight left Auckland Airport in the morning and was supposed to spend a few hours flying over the Antarctic continent, before returning to Auckland in the evening via Christchurch.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Northwest Airlines Flight 4422</span> 1948 aviation accident

On March 12, 1948, Northwest Airlines Flight 4422 (NC95422) crashed into Mount Sanford, Alaska, with a crew of six and 24 passengers. The flight was a C-54 charter flying back to the United States from Shanghai. The aircraft refueled at Anchorage and took off at 8:12 P.M. to continue on to its destination, New York City. Instead of following the published airway, which detoured around Mount Sanford, the aircraft flew a direct line, crashing into the mountain. After the initial impact the wreckage slid down for about 3000 feet before coming to rest. There were no survivors. The passengers were American merchant mariners, crew members of the tanker SS Sunset, being ferried back home.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">United Air Lines Flight 23</span> 1933 aircraft bombing in Indiana, United States

United Air Lines Flight 23 was a regularly-scheduled flight operated by United Air Lines between Newark, New Jersey, and Oakland, California, with intermediate stops. On October 10, 1933, the Boeing 247 airliner serving the flight, registered as NC13304, exploded and crashed near Chesterton, Indiana, United States, en route from Cleveland to Chicago. It carried three crew and four passengers. All aboard died in the crash, which was caused by an on-board explosive device. Eyewitnesses on the ground reported hearing an explosion shortly after 9 pm and seeing the aircraft in flames at an altitude around 1,000 feet (300 m). A second explosion followed after the aircraft crashed. The crash scene was adjacent to a gravel road about 5 miles (8 km) outside of Chesterton, centered in a wooded area on the Jackson Township farm of James Smiley.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ansett New Zealand Flight 703</span> 1995 aviation accident

Ansett New Zealand Flight 703 was a scheduled flight from Auckland to Palmerston North. On 9 June 1995, the de Havilland Canada Dash 8-100 aircraft crashed into the Tararua Range on approach to Palmerston North. The flight attendant and three passengers died as a result of the crash; the two pilots and 15 passengers survived.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Air India Flight 101</span> 1966 aviation accident

Air India Flight 101 was a scheduled Air India passenger flight from Bombay to London, via Delhi, Beirut, and Geneva. On the morning of 24 January 1966 at 8:02 CET, on approach to Geneva, the Boeing 707-437 operating the flight accidentally crashed into Mont Blanc in France, killing all 117 people on board. Among the victims was Dr. Homi Jehangir Bhabha, the founder and chairman of the Atomic Energy Commission of India.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Airlines PNG Flight 4684</span> 2009 aviation accident

Airlines PNG Flight 4684 (CG4682/TOK4684) was a scheduled domestic passenger flight operated by Papua New Guinean airliner Airlines PNG, flying from Jacksons International Airport in Papua New Guinea's capital Port Moresby to Kokoda Airport in Oro Province, Papua New Guinea. On 11 August 2009, the aircraft operating the flight, a de Havilland Canada Twin Otter, crashed into a forest in Kokoda Valley, a popular trekking site in Papua New Guinea, while carrying 13 people in bad weather. A search and rescue operation was conducted by authorities and found the wreckage of the crashed plane on the next day, 12 August 2009. The aircraft was severely damaged, and searchers found no signs of life. Papua New Guinean Search and Rescue Agency then announced that everyone on board was killed instantly in the crash.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Little Baldon air crash</span> 1965 air crash in the United Kingdom

The Little Baldon air crash occurred on 6 July 1965 when a Handley Page Hastings C1A transport aircraft operated by No. 36 Squadron Royal Air Force, registration TG577, crashed into a field in Little Baldon, near Chiselhampton, Oxfordshire, shortly after taking off from RAF Abingdon. The flight was captained by Flt Lt John Akin. All 41 people aboard, including six crew, perished in the crash, making it the third worst air crash in the United Kingdom at the time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">AIRES Flight 8250</span> 2010 aviation accident

AIRES Flight 8250 was a domestic scheduled passenger flight that on 16 August 2010 crashed on landing at night in poor weather on the Colombian island of San Andrés, killing two of the 131 people on board. The aircraft, an AIRES-operated Boeing 737-700, was arriving from the Colombian capital Bogotá when it heavily touched down short of the runway, breaking up in three sections.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Meopham air disaster</span> 1930 crash caused by tailplane failure

The Meopham Air Disaster occurred on 21 July 1930 when a Junkers F.13ge flying from Le Touquet to Croydon with two crew and four passengers crashed near Meopham, Kent, with the loss of all on board. The report of the inquiry into the accident was made public, the first time in the United Kingdom that an accident report had been published.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1949 Queensland Airlines Lockheed Lodestar crash</span> Air disaster in Queensland, Australia

On 10 March 1949 a Lockheed Lodestar aircraft became airborne at Coolangatta, Queensland, Australia for a flight to Brisbane. Before reaching a height of 300 feet (90 m) it suddenly pitched nose-up, stalled and crashed onto its belly beyond the end of the airstrip.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2012 Carterton hot air balloon crash</span> Disaster in New Zealand in January 2012

On 7 January 2012, a scenic hot air balloon flight from Carterton, New Zealand, collided with a high-voltage power line while attempting to land, causing it to catch fire, disintegrate and crash just north of the town, killing all eleven people on board.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fox Glacier Aerodrome</span> Airport in Fox Glacier, New Zealand

Fox Glacier Aerodrome is a small landing strip serving tourist sightseeing and skydiving flights over the Fox Glacier and Southern Alps areas of New Zealand.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1943 Saint-Donat RCAF Liberator III crash</span>

The 1943 Saint-Donat Liberator III Crash was an aerial accident that killed 24 people‍—‌the worst accident in Canadian military aviation history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2015 Fox Glacier helicopter crash</span> Aviation accident

On 21 November 2015, a Eurocopter AS350 Astar helicopter, operated by Alpine Adventures on a sightseeing flight, crashed on Fox Glacier in the South Island of New Zealand. All seven people on board died.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tropical Airways Flight 1301</span> Domestic short-haul passenger flight crash

Tropical Airways Flight 1301 (TBG1301/M71301) was a domestic short-haul passenger flight, flying from Cap-Haïtien International Airport in Cap-Haïtien, Haiti to the commune of Port-de-Paix which crashed onto a sugarcane field less than 10 minutes after take off on the evening of 24 August 2003. The aircraft was a 19-seater Let L-410 Turbolet carrying 19 passengers and 2 crew. Witnesses stated that the aircraft caught fire during take-off and exploded when it hit the ground. All on board were killed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">K2 Aviation de Havilland Beaver (DHC-2) crash</span>

On 4 August 2018, a de Havilland Canada DHC-2 Beaver aircraft operated by K2 Aviation crashed in poor weather near Denali, Alaska, United States. All five people on board survived the crash, but died before rescuers were able to arrive at the scene. The five people consisted of the pilot and four Polish tourists.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2019 English Channel Piper PA-46 crash</span> Aircraft accident that killed Argentinian footballer Emiliano Sala

On 21 January 2019, a Piper PA-46 Malibu light aircraft transporting Argentine football player Emiliano Sala crashed in the English Channel off Alderney in the Channel Islands. It had been travelling from Nantes, France, to Cardiff, Wales. Sala was due to begin his career at Cardiff City.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Skydive Umeå Gippsland GA8 Airvan crash</span> 2019 aviation accident in Umeå, Sweden

On 14 July 2019, a Gippsland GA8 Airvan crashed on a river islet in Sweden, killing all nine people on board. Structural failure of a wing is suspected as the cause of the accident. Consequently, the Gippsland GA8 Airvan was grounded by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) in Australia, the Civil Aviation Authority (CAANZ) in New Zealand and the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) in the European Union. The grounding order was issued on 20 July and was due to run until 3 August, but was lifted early as CASA found there was no evidence for an unsafe condition, and the EASA said the wrecked aircraft had been exposed to aerodynamic loads beyond the limits specified in the type-certification basis.

References

  1. ↑ Final Report, Aviation inquiry 10-009, Walter Fletcher FU24, ZK-EUF loss of control on take-off and impact with terrain, Fox Glacier aerodrome, South Westland, 4 September 2010 (PDF) (Report). Transport Accident Investigation Commission. Archived (PDF) from the original on 24 January 2019. Retrieved 24 August 2019.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 "Interim Factual Report 10-009 – Walter Fletcher FU24, ZK-EUF, loss of control on take-off, Fox Glacier, South Westland, 4 September 2010". Transport Accident Investigation Commission. 11 November 2010. Archived from the original on 17 July 2011. Retrieved 11 November 2010.
  3. ↑ "Investigation begins into NZ plane crash". Sydney Morning Herald . 5 September 2010. Retrieved 5 September 2010.
  4. ↑ Sinclair, Joe (5 September 2010). "Briton killed in New Zealand plane crash named". The Independent . London. Archived from the original on 6 September 2010. Retrieved 5 September 2010.
  5. ↑ "Nine dead as plane crashes in fireball – stuff.co.nz". 5 September 2010. Retrieved 11 November 2010.
  6. ↑ "Victims of New Zealand skydive plane crash named". BBC News . 5 September 2010. Archived from the original on 4 September 2010. Retrieved 5 September 2010.
  7. ↑ "Nine killed in New Zealand's worst plane crash". The Indian Express . Retrieved 5 September 2010.
  8. 1 2 3 Johnston, Kirsty; Glass, Amy (11 November 2010). "Fox Glacier crash report: plane off balance". Stuff . Retrieved 14 August 2021.
  9. 1 2 New Zealand CAA Airworthiness Directive Number DCA/FU24/179 "Parachuting Operations – Limitation and C of G Determination" Archived 5 October 2010 at the Wayback Machine . Retrieved 13 September 2010
  10. 1 2 3 Neal, Tracy (26 May 2014). "Concerns addressed over fatal flight". Nelson Mail. Retrieved 15 August 2021.
  11. 1 2 Newport, Peter (29 October 2015). "No Apology for families of sky dive crash victims". Radio New Zealand . Retrieved 14 August 2021.
  12. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 McGregor, Andrew (May 2014). "Fox Glacier Air Accident 2010: A technical critique of the investigation report written by the New Zealand Transport Accident Investigation Commission (TAIC) with guidance for reopening its investigation" (PDF). Prosolve Ltd.
  13. ↑ "Fox Glacier plane crash inquest opens". New Zealand Herald . 12 August 2012. Retrieved 14 August 2021.
  14. 1 2 3 Moran, Dylan; Satherley, Dan (5 May 2013). "Fox Glacier crash report brings 'closure'". Newshub . Retrieved 14 August 2021.
  15. ↑ Morrah, Michael (26 March 2014). "Investigation casts doubt over Fox Glacier crash findings". Newshub . Retrieved 14 August 2021.
  16. 1 2 "Questions over probe into plane crash at New Zealand's Fox Glacier". News Corp Australia . 26 March 2014. Retrieved 15 August 2021.
  17. ↑ "Fox Glacier plane crash to be reviewed". SBS World News . AAP. 17 April 2014. Retrieved 15 August 2021.
  18. 1 2 3 4 5 Lagford, Amelia (30 October 2015). "'Appalling incompetence' in Fox Glacier inquiry". Radio New Zealand . Retrieved 14 August 2021.
  19. 1 2 "Process Review into the conduct of the investigation into the Fox Glacier accident in September 2010". Transport Accident Investigation Commission. October 2015. Archived from the original on 22 January 2016. Retrieved 15 August 2021.
  20. ↑ "Fox Glacier plane crash victim's son backs critical report findings". Stuff . 29 October 2015. Retrieved 13 August 2021.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.