Commission on Presidential Debates

Commission on Presidential Debates

Predecessor	League of Women Voters (sponsor)
Formation	1987;37 years ago (1987)
Type	Non-profit, 501(c)(3) corporation [1]
Purpose	Organization of the United States presidential and vice-presidential election debates
Co-Chairs	Frank Fahrenkopf [2] Dorothy S. Ridings Kenneth Wollack
Executive Director	Janet H. Brown
Website	www.debates.org

The Commission on Presidential Debates (CPD) is a nonprofit corporation established in 1987 under the joint sponsorship of the Democratic and Republican political parties in the United States. ^{[1] [3]} The CPD sponsors and produces debates for U.S. presidential and vice-presidential candidates and undertakes research and educational activities relating to the debates. Between 1988 and 2020, the CPD organized all general election presidential debates.

In 2024, the campaigns of the major-party presumptive presidential candidates, Democratic incumbent Joe Biden and Republican former president Donald Trump, circumvented the CPD and committed to two debates outside the CPD's purview.

History

Debates before the CPD

The first televised presidential debates were held between Richard Nixon and John F. Kennedy during the 1960 campaign. No general election debates were held in 1964, and Richard Nixon refused to participate in any debate in 1968 and 1972. Beginning with the 1976 election, the League of Women Voters sponsored the televised Gerald Ford–Jimmy Carter debates, followed by the John B. Anderson–Ronald Reagan and Reagan–Carter debates for the 1980 election, and Reagan and Walter Mondale in 1984.

Formation

After studying the election process in 1985, the bipartisan National Commission on Elections recommended "[t]urning over the sponsorship of presidential debates to the two major parties". ^[3] The CPD was established in 1987 by the chairmen of the Democratic and Republican Parties to "take control of the presidential debates". ^[3] The commission was staffed by members from the two parties and chaired by the heads of the Democratic and Republican parties, Paul G. Kirk and Frank Fahrenkopf. ^[3] At a 1987 press conference announcing the commission's creation, Fahrenkopf said that the commission was not likely to include third-party candidates in debates, and Kirk said he personally believed they should be excluded from the debates. ^[3]

In 1988, the League of Women Voters withdrew its sponsorship of the presidential debates after the George H. W. Bush and Michael Dukakis campaigns secretly agreed to a "memorandum of understanding" that would decide which candidates could participate in the debates, which individuals would be panelists (and therefore able to ask questions), and the height of the lecterns. The league rejected the demands and released a statement saying that it was withdrawing support for the debates because "the demands of the two campaign organizations would perpetrate a fraud on the American voter." ^[4]

Debate format and venues

The CPD sponsored the debates in every presidential election from 1988 through 2020. Debates ran 90 minutes long, with no commercial interruptions. ^[5]

Of the 33 debates conducted under its sponsorship, 30 were held on college or university campuses. ^[5] Washington University in St. Louis hosted more presidential and vice-presidential debates than any other institution. ^[6]

2024 presidential election

In January 2022, the Republican National Committee (RNC) warned the CPD that it planned to amend the Rules of the Republican Party to prohibit Republican presidential nominees from attending CPD-sponsored debates. ^[7] The RNC unanimously passed the amendment to quit to CPD in April 2022. ^[8]

In November 2023, the CPD announced its plans for debate dates and sites for the 2024 presidential campaign, with three presidential debates (to be held on September 16, October 1, and October 9) and one vice presidential debate (to be held September 25). ^[9] However, the campaigns of both President Joe Biden and his challenger, former president Donald Trump, criticized the CPD's plans, ^[10] including over format and timing (i.e., concerns that the debates would be held too late in the campaign season). ^{[11] [12]}

In May 2024, the Biden and Trump campaigns struck a deal to circumvent the CPD and participate in two debates (on CNN on June 27 and ABC News on September 10), breaking a longstanding tradition of debates organized under the auspices of the CPD. ^[10] The CNN debate will be "open to any presidential candidate who consistently polls above 15 percent in approved public surveys and is on enough state ballots to win a majority of electoral college votes." ^[10] The future of the CPD was thrown into doubt. ^[13] On June 24, 2024, the CPD announced that it was "regrettably" releasing the sites it had selected for its 2024 debates from their contracts, adding that "CPD stands ready to sponsor 2024 debates should circumstances change." ^[5]

Leadership and funding

The commission is a nonprofit organization, led by a bipartisan board of directors. ^{[10] [14]} It has 501(c)(3) status. ^[15]

As of 2024, the co-chairs of the Commission were Frank Fahrenkopf (a former chairman of the Republican National Committee) and Antonia Hernández. ^[2] Fahrenkopf has been co-chair since the CPD was established. ^{[14] [16]} The other co-chair was originally Paul G. Kirk, Jr., who served as chairman of the Democratic National Committee. ^[14] Kirk stepped down from the CPD in 2009, and was replaced as co-chair by Michael D. McCurry. ^[14] McCurry stepped down as co-chair in January 2017, and was replaced by Dorothy S. Ridings, a past executive of the Council on Foundations and League of Women Voters. ^[17] Kirk and Ridings hold the title Co-Chair Emeriti. ^[2] Kenneth Wollack, former president of the National Democratic Institute, was appointed as a third co-chair in 2019. ^{[18] [19]} Hernandez, formerly a CPD vice-chair, was selected as co-chair in 2022. ^[20]

As of 2024, the Commission's board consists of eight members: ^[2] Roy Blunt (former Republican senator from Missouri), ^[21] Charles Gibson (a longtime television journalist, formerly of ABC News), ^{[22] [23]} John Griffen (managing director of Allen & Co.); ^[23] the Reverend John I. Jenkins (the president of the University of Notre Dame), ^[23] Monica C. Lozano (the president and CEO of the College Futures Foundation), ^[24] Richard D. Parsons (a cable executive), ^[23] Rajiv J. Shah (the president of the Rockefeller Foundation and former administrator of USAID), ^[24] and Olympia Snowe (former Republican senator from Maine). ^[23]

Past board members include John C. Danforth (former Republican senator from Missouri), ^[25] Yvonne Hao (an investor and businesswoman), ^{[23] [26]} Jane Harman (a former Democratic congresswoman who later became director of the Woodrow Wilson Center) ^{[23] [15]} and Newton N. Minow (a former member of the Federal Communications Commission during the John F. Kennedy administration). ^{[2] [23]} Other past board members include Shirley M. Tilghman, Richard Moe, Kay Orr, Leon E. Panetta, Mitch Daniels, and Caroline B. Kennedy. ^[27]

Janet H. Brown has served as the CPD's executive director ^[2] since the commission was established in 1987. ^[19]

The commission's debates are sponsored by private contributions from foundations and corporations ^[28] as well as fees from hosting institutions. ^[29]

Complaints from third parties

Christopher Hitchens speaking at a September 2000 third-party protest at the commission's headquarters

Third parties have often criticized exclusion of their candidates from debates, due to the CPD's rule (established in 2000) that candidates must garner at least 15% support across five national polls to be invited to the national debates. ^{[30] [31]} The last candidate from outside the two major parties to participate in a CPD-sponsored debate was Ross Perot, who polled sufficiently high in his 1992 presidential campaign to debate George H. W. Bush and Bill Clinton in all three debates; Perot's running mate, James Stockdale, also participated in the vice presidential debate. ^[32] When Perot ran again in 1996, the CPD declined to invite him to the debates, finding that the Reform Party candidate had no "realistic chance to win" the election. ^[32]

Multiple lawsuits have been filed by third-party candidates challenging the CPD's policy of requiring a candidate to have 15% support in national polls to be included in presidential debates; all have been rejected by the courts. ^{[33] [34] [35]}

In October 2004, Libertarian candidate Michael Badnarik and Green Party candidate David Cobb were arrested while protesting against CPD for excluding third-party candidates from the nationally televised debates in St. Louis, Missouri. ^[36] In October 2012, Green Party presidential nominee Jill Stein and vice-presidential nominee Cheri Honkala were arrested for disorderly conduct while trying to take part in the second presidential debate at Hofstra University in Hempstead, New York. ^{[37] [38] [39]}

References

1. "The Commission on Presidential Debates: An Overview". debates.org. Commission on Presidential Debates. n.d. Retrieved October 11, 2016.
2. "CPD: Commission Leadership". Debates.org. Retrieved May 15, 2024.
3. Gailey, Phil (February 19, 1987). "Democrats and Republicans Form Panel to Hold Presidential Debates". The New York Times . Retrieved October 7, 2008.
4. "League of Women Voters of the United States: League Refuses to "Help Perpetuate a Fraud"" (Press release). League of Women Voters. October 3, 1988. Retrieved October 4, 2012.
5. "Statement on CPD's 2024 General Election Debates". The Commission on Presidential Debates. June 24, 2024. Retrieved June 24, 2024.
6. "History of debates at Washington University in St. Louis". Newsroom. Washington University in St. Louis. June 26, 2008. Retrieved October 4, 2012.
7. Manchester, Julia (January 13, 2022). "RNC moves to require presidential candidates to skip traditional commission debates". The Hill . Retrieved January 13, 2022.
8. McDaniel, Eric (April 14, 2022). "Republicans say they're quitting the 'biased' Commission on Presidential Debates". NPR .
9. Commission on Presidential Debates Announces Sites and Dates for 2024 General Election Debates and 2024 Nonpartisan Candidate Selection Criteria, Commission on Presidential Debates (November 20, 2023).
10. Michael Scherer & Josh Dawsey (May 15, 2024). "Biden and Trump agree to CNN debate in June, ABC faceoff in September". Washington Post.
11. Steven Shepard, Sam Stein, Jonathan Lemire and Alex Isenstadt, Biden and Trump agree to debates. And then debate about more debates., Politico (May 15, 2024).
12. Shelton, Shania (May 15, 2024). "What to know about the history of presidential debates". CNN . Retrieved May 28, 2024.
13. Jonathan J. Cooper, The Commission on Presidential Debates faces an uncertain future after Biden and Trump bypassed it, Associated Press (May 16, 2024).
14. Robert Farley, Trump's Misguided Debate Bias Claim, FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center (October 13, 2016).
15. Ken Thomas, Debate Over Debates Draws Attention to Nonpartisan Commission, Wall Street Journal (October 8, 2020).
16. Commission on Presidential Debates Releases 2004 Candidate Selection Criteria, Commission on Presidential Debates (September 24, 2003).
17. Richard Winger, For First Time, Commission on Presidential Debates Has a Co-Chair Who is Not a Former Leader of the Democratic or Republican Parties, Ballot Access News (March 28, 2017).
18. "Commission on Presidential Debates Elects Kenneth Wollack as Co-Chair". Debates.org. October 1, 2019. Retrieved September 18, 2020.
19. Matt Pearce, Who's behind the presidential debates?, Los Angeles Times (2020).
20. Commission on Presidential Debates Elects Antonia Hernández as Co-Chair, Commission on Presidential Debates (April 25, 2022).
21. Commission on Presidential Debates Elects former Senator Roy Blunt to Board of Directors, Commission on Presidential Debates (January 16, 2024).
22. Tilghman, Princeton alumni elected to Commission on Presidential Debates, Princeton University (April 24, 2014).
23. Michael Tomasky, There's No Debating That Donald’s Destroying Democracy, Daily Beast (September 30, 2020).
24. Commission on Presidential Debates Elects Monica C. Lozano and Dr. Rajiv J. Shah to Board of Directors, Commission on Presidential Debates (June 6, 2022).
25. Joe Concha, Ex-GOP senator on debate commission blasts Trump’s bias accusations, warns of 'incalculable damage', The Hill (October 21, 2020).
26. Commission on Presidential Debates Elects Yvonne Hao to Board of Directors, Commission on Presidential Debates (October 2, 2019).
27. Former Board Members, Commission on Presidential Debates (accessed May 15, 2024).
28. "CPD: National Debate Sponsors". Debates.org. Retrieved May 15, 2024.
29. Fitzgerald, Rick (April 3, 2019). "U-M will make bid to host 2020 presidential debate". The University Record. The University of Michigan. Retrieved October 11, 2019.
30. Raskin, Jamie (2003). Overruling Democracy: The Supreme Court Versus the American People. Routledge. p. 126. ISBN   978-0-415-93439-8 . Retrieved October 4, 2012.
31. McDuffee, Allen (October 3, 2012). "Presidential debate sponsors drop over exclusion of Gary Johnson". The Washington Post . Retrieved October 13, 2012.
32. Dan Balz, Perot Is Rejected By Debates Panel: 3rd-Party Bid Lacks 'Realistic Chance to Win', Washington Post (September 17, 1996).
33. Johnson v. Comm'n on Presidential Debates , 869 F. 3d 976 (D.C. Cir. 2017).
34. Crist v. Comm'n on Presidential Debates , 262 F. 3d 193 (2nd Cir. 2001).
35. Ryan, Tim (June 12, 2020). "Court Rejects Push to Have Debates Welcome 3rd-Party Candidates". Courthouse News Service. Retrieved August 10, 2020.
36. "Opponents fail to stop US debate". BBC News . October 13, 2004. Retrieved September 26, 2016.
37. Zelman, Joanna (October 16, 2012). "Jill Stein Arrested Before Hofstra Debate". HuffPost . Retrieved October 16, 2012.
38. "Green Party's Stein Talks Arrest, Presidential Debates". WNYC. October 18, 2012. Archived from the original on April 16, 2013.
39. Amy Goodman (October 18, 2012). "Green party candidate Jill Stein's arrest highlights presidential debate stitch-up". The Guardian . London.

External links

• Official website