Disappearance of Bobby Dunbar

Last updated
Disappearance of Bobby Dunbar
Bobby Dunbar (1913).jpg
The child raised as Bobby Dunbar, now thought to be Bruce Anderson, standing in front of a car.
DateAugust 23, 1912;112 years ago (1912-08-23)
Location St. Landry Parish, Louisiana, United States
Type Disappearance
Outcome Cold case
Deaths1 (Dunbar, in absentia)
MissingRobert "Bobby" Clarence Dunbar, aged 4
AccusedWilliam Cantwell Walters ( exonerated ) [1] [2]
Charges Kidnapping (dismissed)
Verdict Guilty (overturned)
Sentence2 years in prison served (overturned)

Bobby Dunbar was an American boy whose disappearance at the age of four and apparent return were widely reported in newspapers across the United States in 1912 and 1913. After eight months of nationwide searching, investigators believed that they had found the child in Mississippi, in the hands of William Cantwell Walters of Barnesville, North Carolina. Dunbar's parents claimed the boy as their missing son. However, both Walters and a woman named Julia Anderson insisted that the boy with him was Anderson's son Bruce. Anderson could not afford a lawyer, and the court eventually ruled in favor of the Dunbars. The Dunbars retained custody of the child, who proceeded to live out the remainder of his life as Bobby.

Contents

In 2004, DNA profiling established in retrospect that the boy found with Walters and "returned" to the Dunbars as Bobby had not been a blood relative of the Dunbar family. This makes most believe that the boy was in fact Bruce Anderson and had been wrongly identified by Dunbar's parents. Julia Anderson had no means to contest the Dunbars' decision but always maintained the child was her son. However, this does not solve what happened to the true Bobby Dunbar, who is presumed dead in absentia.

Disappearance

Bobby Dunbar
Twoboyssidebyside-thedaybook-feb18-1914.jpg
Photos in a 1914 newspaper of a confirmed Bobby Dunbar before he was lost (left) and the boy who was found later (right).
Born
Robert Clarence Dunbar

May 23, 1908
DisappearedAugust 23, 1912 (aged 4)
St. Landry Parish, Louisiana
Status Missing for 112 years; presumed dead in absentia [lower-alpha 1]
Bruce Anderson
Julia Anderson and Bruce Anderson.jpg
Bruce Anderson (right) with his mother Julia Anderson (left), c.1912
Born
Charles Bruce Anderson

c.1908 [3]
DiedMarch 8, 1966 (aged 57–58)
Other names
  • Bobby Dunbar [4]
  • Robert Clarence Dunbar, Sr.
Known forBeing mistaken for Bobby Dunbar
SpouseMarjorie Geraldine Byars
Children4 [5]
ParentJulia Anderson (mother)

Robert Clarence "Bobby" Dunbar was the first son born to Lessie and Percy Dunbar of Opelousas, Louisiana. He was born on May 23, 1908. [6] In August 1912, the Dunbars took a fishing trip to nearby Swayze Lake in St. Landry Parish, Louisiana. On August 23, while on that trip, Bobby disappeared. [7] :3–6

After an eight-month search, authorities located William Cantwell Walters, who worked as an itinerant handyman, specializing in the tuning and repairing of pianos and organs. Walters had been traveling through Mississippi with a boy who appeared to match the description of Bobby Dunbar. Walters claimed that the boy was actually Charles Bruce Anderson, generally referred to as Bruce, the son of a woman who worked for his family. He said that the boy's mother was named Julia Anderson, and that she had willingly granted him custody. Anderson would later confirm this. Nonetheless, Walters was arrested and authorities sent for the Dunbars to come to Mississippi and attempt to identify the boy.

Newspaper accounts differ with regard to the initial reaction between the boy and Lessie Dunbar. [7] :55–58 While one account indicated that the boy immediately shouted "Mother" upon seeing her and the two then embraced, another said only that the boy cried and quoted Lessie Dunbar as saying she was unsure whether he was her son. Other newspaper accounts quote both the Dunbars as initially stating doubts as to the boy's identity. There were similar contradictions in newspaper accounts of the boy's first sighting of the Dunbars' younger son, Alonzo, with one newspaper claiming that the boy recognized Alonzo instantly, called him by name and kissed him, with another saying the boy showed no sign of recognizing Alonzo. The next day, after bathing the boy, Lessie Dunbar said she positively identified his moles and scars and was then certain that he was her son. The boy returned to Opelousas with the Dunbars to a parade, with much fanfare celebrating the "homecoming."

Shortly thereafter, Julia Anderson of North Carolina arrived to support Walters' contention that the boy was, in fact, her son, Bruce. Anderson was unmarried and worked as a field hand for Walters' family. She said that she had allowed Walters to take her son only for what was supposed to be a two-day trip to visit one of Walters' relatives. She further asserted that she had not consented for Walters to take her son for more than a few days.

According to newspaper accounts, Anderson was presented with five different boys who were of the same approximate age as her son, including the boy who had been claimed by the Dunbars. When the boy in question was presented, he reportedly gave no indication that he recognized her. She asked whether he was the boy recovered, but was not given an answer and finally declared that she was unsure.

Upon seeing the boy again the next day, when she was allowed to undress him, she indicated a stronger certainty that the boy was indeed her son Bruce. However, word had already spread about her failure to positively identify him on the first attempt. This, combined with the fact that newspapers questioned her moral character in having had three children (the other two deceased by that point) out of wedlock, led to Anderson's claims being dismissed.

With no money to sustain a long court battle, Anderson returned home to North Carolina. She later returned to Louisiana for Walters' kidnapping trial to attest to his innocence and push for the court to determine that the boy was her son. At the trial, she became acquainted with the residents of the town of Poplarville, Mississippi, many of whom had also come to proclaim Walters' innocence. William Walters and the boy had spent quite a bit of time in Poplarville during their travels and the community there had come to know them well, with a number of them asserting that they had seen Walters with the boy prior to the disappearance of Bobby Dunbar. Despite their testimony, the court reached the determination that the boy was in fact Bobby Dunbar. Walters was extradited from Mississippi to Louisiana for trial. [8] Walters was convicted of kidnapping, while the boy remained in the custody of the Dunbar family and lived out the remainder of his life as Bobby Dunbar. Walters served two years in prison before his conviction was overturned on appeal; the state decided not to re-try him, and he was released. [9]

After the trial

After the trial, the people of Poplarville welcomed Anderson and she began a new life there, eventually marrying and having seven children. [7] :340–346 According to her descendants, she became a devout Christian, helped found a church and served as nurse and midwife to the small community. Although her children indicated that her life was a happy one after settling in Poplarville, they said that she nonetheless spoke often of her lost son and that their family always regarded him as having been kidnapped by the Dunbars. She died on February 1, 1940, and is buried in Fords Creek Cemetery in Poplarville. [10]

In 2008, one of Anderson's sons, Hollis, recounted the story for This American Life that in 1944 Bobby Dunbar/Bruce Anderson visited him at his place of business, where they talked. Hollis' sister Jules has recounted a similar experience wherein a man, who she believes to have been Dunbar, came to the service station where she worked and talked to her for an extended period. The Dunbar family also has a similar story, as told by Bobby Dunbar's son Gerald. The family was returning home from a trip and passed through Poplarville when Dunbar said, "Those are the people they came to pick me up from."

After Walters had served two years of his prison term for kidnapping, his attorney was successful in appealing the conviction and it was overturned by the Louisiana Supreme Court. [10] [11] [12] Walters was then granted the right to a new trial. Citing the excessive costs of the first trial, prosecutors in Opelousas declined to try him again and instead released him. [13] [14] After his release from custody, Walters resumed an itinerant lifestyle. Walters died on April 7, 1945, and was buried in Pueblo, Colorado, beside his wife. [7] :351 The grandchildren of Walters' brother reported that during their childhood, he typically visited their grandfather a few times per year and that during these visits, Walters always maintained his innocence regarding the kidnapping charge. The boy raised as Bobby Dunbar married, had four children of his own and died on March 8, 1966. He was buried in Bellevue Memorial Park in Opelousas, Louisiana. [7] :383 His widow died in 1994 and was interred next to her husband.

Later investigation

Years after Bobby Dunbar's death, one of his granddaughters, Margaret Dunbar Cutright, began her own investigation of the events, poring through newspaper accounts, interviewing the children of Julia Anderson and examining the notes and evidence presented by Walters' defense attorney for his kidnapping trial and appeal. [15] Although Cutright had initially hoped to prove that her grandfather was a Dunbar, her research ultimately led her to doubt her belief.

In 2004, after an Associated Press reporter approached the family about the story, Bob Dunbar Jr. consented to undergoing DNA tests. The results showed that Dunbar Jr. was not related by blood to his supposed cousin, the son of Alonzo Dunbar, who was the younger brother of Bobby Dunbar Sr. (the original Bobby Dunbar, who went missing in 1912). [15] Since the DNA testing was conclusive, the fate of the real Bobby Dunbar remains unknown.

2008 radio documentary

In March 2008, Public Radio International's This American Life featured The Ghost of Bobby Dunbar, a radio documentary about the investigation of the case by Margaret Dunbar Cutright. [15] She expressed her own opinion that the real Bobby Dunbar most likely fell into Swayze Lake during the fishing trip and was eaten by an alligator. She revealed that the results of her investigation had brought joy to Julia Anderson's family as vindication of her claims, as well as to William Walters' family as an exoneration of the kidnapping accusation against him. She also said that her findings had sown discord within her own family, as the majority of her grandfather's children and grandchildren considered themselves to be members of the Dunbar family, cherished their existing familial relationships, and were resentful of Cutright, both for having delved into the matter and for bringing it back into the public eye. [15]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Solomon Northup</span> Free-born African American kidnapped by slave-traders

Solomon Northup was an American abolitionist and the primary author of the memoir Twelve Years a Slave. A free-born African American from New York, he was the son of a freed slave and a free woman of color. A farmer and a professional violinist, Northup had been a landowner in Washington County, New York. In 1841, he was offered a traveling musician's job and went to Washington, D.C. ; there he was drugged and kidnapped into slavery. He was shipped to New Orleans, purchased by a planter, and held as a slave for 12 years in the Red River region of Louisiana, mostly in Avoyelles Parish. He remained a slave until he met Samuel Bass, a Canadian working on his plantation who helped get word to New York, where state law provided aid to free New York citizens who had been kidnapped and sold into slavery. His family and friends enlisted the aid of the Governor of New York, Washington Hunt, and Northup regained his freedom on January 3, 1853.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Opelousas, Louisiana</span> City in Louisiana, United States

Opelousas is a small city and the parish seat of St. Landry Parish, Louisiana, United States. Interstate 49 and U.S. Route 190 were constructed with a junction here. According to the 2020 census, Opelousas has a population of 15,786, a 6.53 percent decline since the 2010 census, which had recorded a population of 16,634. Opelousas is the principal city for the Opelousas-Eunice Micropolitan Statistical Area, which had an estimated population of 80,808 in 2020. Opelousas is also the fourth largest city in the Lafayette-Acadiana Combined Statistical Area, which has a population of 537,947.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard Hauptmann</span> German-American executed for kidnapping and murder (1899–1936)

Bruno Richard Hauptmann was a German-born carpenter who was convicted of the abduction and murder of Charles Augustus Lindbergh, Jr., the 20-month-old son of aviator Charles Lindbergh and his wife Anne Morrow Lindbergh. The Lindbergh kidnapping became known as "The Crime of the Century". Both Hauptmann and his wife, Anna Hauptmann, proclaimed his innocence to his death, when he was executed in 1936 by electric chair at the Trenton State Prison. Anna later sued the State of New Jersey, various former police officers, the Hearst newspapers that had published pre-trial articles insisting on Hauptmann's guilt, and former prosecutor David T. Wilentz.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Emmett Till</span> African American lynching victim (1941–1955)

Emmett Louis Till was an African American teenager who was abducted and lynched in Mississippi in 1955 after being accused of offending a white woman, Carolyn Bryant, in her family's grocery store. The brutality of his murder and the acquittal of his killers drew attention to the long history of violent persecution of African Americans in the United States. Till posthumously became an icon of the civil rights movement.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kidnapping of Charley Ross</span> 1874 kidnapping in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Charles Brewster "Charley" Ross was the primary victim of the first American kidnapping for ransom to receive widespread media coverage. His fate remains unknown, and his case is one of the most famous disappearances in U.S. history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Machine Gun Kelly (gangster)</span> American gangster (1900–1954)

George Kelly Barnes, better known by his nickname "Machine Gun Kelly", was an American gangster from Memphis, Tennessee, active during the Prohibition era. His nickname came from his favorite weapon, a Thompson submachine gun. He is best known for the kidnapping of oil tycoon and businessman Charles F. Urschel in July 1933, from which he and his gang collected a $200,000 ransom. Urschel had collected and left considerable evidence that assisted the subsequent FBI investigation, which eventually led to Kelly's arrest in Memphis on September 26, 1933. His crimes also included bootlegging and armed robbery.

Mack Charles Parker was a Black American victim of lynching in the United States. He had been accused of raping a pregnant white woman in northern Pearl River County, Mississippi. Three days before he was to stand trial, Parker was kidnapped from his jail cell in the Pearl River County Courthouse by a mob, beaten and shot. His body was found in the Pearl River, 20 miles west of Poplarville, 10 days later. Following an investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the men who killed him were released. Despite confessions, no one was ever indicted for the killing. Historian Howard Smead called the killing the "last classic lynching in America."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Murder of Bobby Greenlease</span> American child kidnapping case in 1953

Robert Cosgrove Greenlease Jr. was a six-year-old from Kansas City, Missouri, United States, who was the victim of a kidnapping and homicide on September 28, 1953. His father, Robert Cosgrove Greenlease Sr., was a multi-millionaire auto dealer, and the demanded ransom payment was the largest in American history at the time.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Franklin Delano Floyd</span> American murderer (1943–2023)

Franklin Delano Floyd was an American murderer, rapist, and death row inmate. He was convicted of the 1989 murder of Cheryl Ann Commesso, as well as the kidnapping of 6-year-old Michael Anthony Hughes, who he claimed was his son, from his elementary school in Choctaw, Oklahoma. Floyd was also considered a person of interest in the 1990 hit-and-run death of his second wife and kidnapping victim Sharon Marshall, mother of Michael Anthony Hughes. It was later discovered that before becoming his wife, Sharon had been raised by Floyd from an early age as his daughter and was kidnapped by Floyd as a child.

This is a list of notable overturned convictions in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert Lee Willie</span> American murderer (1958–1984)

Robert Lee Willie was an American serial killer who killed at least three people in Louisiana from the late 1970s to 1980. He was sentenced to death for the rape and murder of 18-year-old Faith Hathaway and was executed in 1984.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wineville Chicken Coop murders</span> Series of abductions and murders of young boys

The Wineville Chicken Coop murders, also known as the Wineville Chicken murders, were a series of abductions and murders of young boys that occurred in the city of Los Angeles and in Riverside County, California, United States between 1926 and 1928. The murders were perpetrated by Gordon Stewart Northcott, a 19-year-old farmer who had moved to the U.S. from Canada two years earlier, as well as his mother, Sarah Louise Northcott, and his nephew, Sanford Clark.

Walter B Collins was a nine-year-old boy who went missing in 1928. The state of California concluded that Collins had been murdered by Gordon Stewart Northcott as part of the Wineville Chicken Coop murders.

Gilbert Louis Dupré Sr., was a self-educated lawyer and state representative from Opelousas, Louisiana, known for his initial political opposition to Governor Huey Pierce Long Jr. He held his state House seat from 1913 to 1932. A native of St. Landry Parish in South Louisiana, he maintained his legal office for many years in Opelousas.

<i>Tabloid</i> (film) 2010 American film

Tabloid is a 2010 American documentary film directed by Errol Morris. It tells the story of Joyce McKinney, who was accused of kidnapping and raping Kirk Anderson, an American Mormon missionary in England, in 1977. The incident, known as the Mormon sex in chains case, became a major tabloid story in the United Kingdom and triggered a circulation battle between two popular tabloid newspapers, the Daily Express and the Daily Mirror.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Killing of Yoshihiro Hattori</span> 1992 shooting in Louisiana, US

Yoshihiro Hattori was a Japanese student on an exchange program to the United States who was shot to death in Baton Rouge, Louisiana. The shooting happened when Hattori, on his way to a Halloween party, went to the wrong house by mistake. Property owner Rodney Peairs fatally shot Hattori, erroneously thinking that he was trespassing with criminal intent. The killing and Peairs' trials received worldwide attention, initiating discussion about race relations and attitudes toward Asians in the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Julia A. J. Foote</span> American deacon

Julia A. J. Foote was ordained as the first woman deacon in the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church and the second to be ordained as an elder. She was a leader in the Wesleyan-Holiness movement, preaching the doctrine of entire sanctification throughout pulpits of the African Methodist Episcopal Zion connexion.

Swayze Lake is situated in St. Landry Parish, Louisiana, United States. The lake is best known for the disappearance of Bobby Dunbar; the boy was last seen there attending a family fishing trip on August 23, 1912.

James Jerold Koedatich is an American serial killer who kidnapped and murdered two young women within a two-weeks span in Morris County, New Jersey, in late 1982. Following his arrest, he was tried, convicted, and sentenced to death, but was resentenced to life in prison in 1990. Prior to the murders, Koedatich murdered his roommate in Florida, for which he served eleven years in prison, and while in prison he killed his cellmate, but that was ruled to be self-defense.

John Peter Malveaux is an American serial killer and rapist who committed between four and five murders around Opelousas, Louisiana from January to October 1997. Following his arrest and confession to the crimes, Malveaux pleaded guilty on all counts and was given four life terms without parole.

References

  1. "The Bobby Dunbar kidnapping case leaves unanswered questions".
  2. "Man convicted in 1912 kidnapping cleared by DNA evidence". 5 May 2004.
  3. "A Tale of Two Children, and DNA solves mystery of one". 11 January 2008.
  4. "Bobby Dunbar mystery solved? DNA test puts 100-year-old mystery to rest".
  5. "Robert Clarence Dunbar - The Charley Project".
  6. "Purcy Dunbar (sheet 11A, family 223, NARA microfilm T624)". Index and image, U.S. Census, Opelousas Ward 2, St. Landry Parish, Louisiana . FamilySearch. 1910. Retrieved 2012-09-17.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 Tal McThenia; Margaret Dunbar Cutright (2012). A Case for Solomon: Bobby Dunbar and the Kidnapping That Haunted a Nation. Free Press. ISBN   978-1-439158593. OCLC   709673184.
  8. Ex parte Walters, 64So.2 (Miss.1913).
  9. "The Strange Case of Bobby Dunbar". Country Roads Magazine.
  10. 1 2 "The Bobby Dunbar kidnapping case leaves unanswered questions". The Daily World. 2018-08-17.
  11. "Man convicted in 1912 kidnapping cleared by DNA evidence". 5 May 2004.
  12. State v. Walters, 66So.364 (La.June 29, 1914).
  13. Allen G. Breed, Associated Press (2004-05-05). "DNA clears man of 1914 kidnapping conviction". USA Today.
  14. Allen G. Breed, Associated Press (2004-02-01). "Family continues search for Bobby Dunbar". Oakland Tribune. Archived from the original on 2009-03-18.
  15. 1 2 3 4 "The Ghost of Bobby Dunbar". This American Life, Episode 352. March 14, 2008.

Notes

  1. Dunbar was never found and his body has never been located, but today he would be at an age where it is almost guaranteed he would be dead.