Year Author(s)/Editor(s) Title Publisher Result Ref. 1990s 1992 Randy Stradley (ed.) Dark Horse Presents Dark Horse Comics Winner [ 1] Stephen R. Bissette and others (eds.) Taboo #5 Spiderbaby Grafix /Tundra Publishing Nominee [ 1] Dave Elliott and Gary Leach (eds.) A1 #5 Atomeka Press Nominee [ 1] Diane Noomin (ed.) Twisted Sisters Penguin Books Nominee [ 1] Art Spiegelman and Françoise Mouly (eds.) Raw vol. 2, #3 Raw Books /Penguin Books Nominee [ 1] 1993 Stephen R. Bissette (ed.) Taboo Spiderbaby Grafix /Tundra Publishing Winner [ 2] Dennis Eichhorn (ed.) Real Stuff Fantagraphics Nominee [ 2] David Mazzucchelli and Richmond Lewis (eds.) Rubber Blanket Rubber Blanket Press Nominee [ 2] Chris Oliveros (ed.) Drawn & Quarterly Drawn & Quarterly Nominee [ 2] Byron Preiss (ed.)The Ray Bradbury Chronicles Bantam Books Nominee [ 2] Jerry Prosser and Rich Shupe (eds.)The Residents: Freak Show Dark Horse Comics Nominee [ 2] 1994 Randy Stradley (ed.) Dark Horse Presents Dark Horse Comics Winner [ 3] Karen Berger (ed.)Vertigo Comics Jam DC Comics /Vertigo Comics Nominee [ 3] Dennis Eichhorn (ed.) Real Stuff Fantagraphics Nominee [ 3] Jerry Prosser (ed.) Andrew Vachss' Hard Looks Dark Horse Comics Nominee [ 3] Howard Zimmerman (ed.)Ray Bradury Comics Topps Comics Nominee [ 3] 1995 Andy Helfer (ed.) Big Book of Urban Legends Paradox Press Winner [ 4] Diane Noomin (ed.) Twisted Sisters Kitchen Sink Press Nominee [ 4] Chris Oliveros (ed.) Drawn & Quarterly Drawn & Quarterly Nominee [ 4] Randy Stradley and Bob Schreck (eds.) Dark Horse Presents Dark Horse Comics Nominee [ 4] 1996 Bronwyn Taggart (ed.) Big Book of Conspiracies Paradox Press Winner [ 5] Monte Beauchamp (ed.) BLAB! #8 Kitchen Sink Press Nominee [ 5] Joe R. Lansdale and Richard Klaw (eds.)Weird Business Mojo Press Nominee [ 5] Chris Oliveros (ed.) Drawn & Quarterly Drawn & Quarterly Nominee [ 5] Kim Thompson (ed.) Zero Zero Fantagraphics Nominee [ 5] 1997 Mark Chiarello and Scott Peterson (eds.) Batman Black and White DC Comics Winner [ 6] Tony Bedard (ed.), by Peter Gutierrez and various artistsShi: Kaidan Crusade Comics Nominee [ 6] Jim Higgins (ed.), by Carl Sifakis and various artists Big Book of Hoaxes Paradox Press Nominee [ 6] Joe Pruett (ed.) Negative Burn Caliber Comics Nominee [ 6] Randy Stradley (ed.)A Decade of Dark Horse Comics Dark Horse Comics Nominee [ 6] 1998 Scott Allie (ed.) Hellboy Christmas Special Dark Horse Comics Winner [ 7] Monte Beauchamp (ed.) BLAB! #9 Fantagraphics Nominee [ 7] Karen Hirsch (ed.)Mind Riot Simon & Schuster /Aladdin Paperbacks Nominee [ 7] Jim Ottaviani (ed.)Two-Fisted Science G.T. Labs Nominee [ 7] Shelly Roeberg (ed.)Vertigo Comics: Winters Edge DC Comics /Vertigo Comics Nominee [ 7] Kim Thompson (ed.) Zero Zero Fantagraphics Nominee [ 7] 1999 Diana Schutz (ed.), by Matt Wagner Grendel: Black, White and Red & Red, White and Black Dark Horse Comics Winner [ 8] Andy Helfe Kirchner , Steve Vance , and Anina Bennett Big Book of Bad Paradox Press /DC Comics Nominee [ 8] Joe Pruett (ed.) Negative Burn #50 Caliber Comics Nominee [ 8] Bob Schreck (ed.)Oni Double Feature Oni Press Nominee [ 8] Jeff Smith , Mark Crilley , Linda Medley , Stan Sakai , Jill Thompson , and Charles Vess Trilogy Tour II Book Cartoon Books Nominee [ 8] 2000s 2000 Scott Dunbier (ed.), by Alan Moore , Rick Veitch , Kevin Nowlan , Melinda Gebbie , and Jim Baikie Tomorrow Stories America's Best Comics Winner [ 9] Monte Beauchamp (ed.) BLAB! Fantagraphics Nominee [ 9] Brian Clopper (ed.)Brainbomb Behemoth Books Nominee [ 9] Etgar Keret , Mira Friedmann , Batia Kolton , Rutu Modan , Yirmi Pinkus , and Itzik Rennert Jet Lag Actus Tragicus Nominee [ 9] Jean-Christophe Menu (ed.) Comix 2000 L'Association Nominee [ 9] Jim Ottaviani (ed.)Dignifying Science G.T. Labs Nominee [ 9] 2001 Chris Oliveros (ed.) Drawn & Quarterly , vol. 3 Drawn & Quarterly Winner [ 10] Jon B. Cooke and John Morrow (eds.)Streetwise TwoMorrows Publishing Nominee [ 10] Patrizia Crivelli and others (eds.)Strapazin: Bubbles 'n' Boxes and Beyond Swiss Institute of New York/Swiss Federal Office of Culture Nominee [ 10] Tom Devlin and others (eds.)Expo 2000 Small Press Expo Nominee [ 10] Art Spiegelman and Françoise Mouly (eds.) Little Lit HarperCollins Nominee [ 10] 2002 Joey Cavalieri (ed.) Bizarro Comics DC Comics Winner [ 11] Gary Groth and Anne Elizabeth Moore (eds.)Comics Journal Winter Special 2002 Fantagraphics Nominee [ 11] Chris Oliveros (ed.) Drawn & Quarterly , vol. 4 Drawn & Quarterly Nominee [ 11] Jamie S. Rich (ed.)Oni Press Summer Color Special 2001 Oni Comics Nominee [ 11] Art Spiegelman and Françoise Mouly (eds.) Little Lit : Strange Stories for Strange Kids HarperCollins Nominee [ 11] 2003 SPX 2002 CBLDF Winner [ 12] Ben Catmull and Dylan Williams (eds.)Orchid Sparkplug Comics Nominee [ 12] Tim Ervin-Gore (ed.) Super Manga Blast Dark Horse Comics Nominee [ 12] Ng Suat Tong (ed.)Rosetta: A Comics Anthology Alternative Comics Nominee [ 12] 2004 Karen Berger and Shelly Bond (eds.), by Neil Gaiman , Dave McKean , P. Craig Russell , Miguelanxo Prado , Barron Storey , Frank Quitely , Glenn Fabry , Milo Manara , and Bill Sienkiewicz The Sandman: Endless Nights Vertigo Comics /DC Comics Winner [ 13] Scott Allie (ed.) The Dark Horse Book of Hauntings Dark Horse Comics Nominee [ 13] Chris Oliveros (ed.) Drawn & Quarterly , vol. 5 Drawn & Quarterly Nominee [ 13] Chris Pitzer (ed.)Project: Telstar AdHouse Books Nominee [ 13] Diana Schutz (ed.)AutobioGraphix Dark Horse Comics Nominee [ 13] Art Spiegelman and Françoise Mouly (eds.) Little Lit : It Was a Dark and Silly Night HarperCollins Nominee [ 13] 2005 Diana Schutz and David Land (eds.) Michael Chabon Presents The Amazing Adventures of the Escapist Dark Horse Comics Winner [ 14] Scott Allie (ed.) The Dark Horse Book of Witchcraft Dark Horse Books Nominee [ 14] Spencer Lamm (ed.) The Matrix Comics , vol. 2 Burlyman Entertainment Nominee [ 14] Jim McLauchlin (ed.), by Troy Hickman and othersCommon Grounds Top Cow Productions /Image Comics Nominee [ 14] Chris Ware (ed.)McSweeney's Quarterly #13 McSweeney's Nominee [ 14] 2006 Mark Chiarello (ed.)Solo DC Comics Winner [ 15] Scott Allie (ed.) The Dark Horse Book of the Dead Dark Horse Books Nominee [ 15] Nat Gertler (ed.)24 Hour Comics Day Highlights 2005 About Comics Nominee [ 15] Gary Groth and Eric Reynolds (eds.) Mome Fantagraphics Nominee [ 15] Kazu Kibuishi (ed.) Flight , vol. 2 Image Comics Nominee [ 15] 2007 Shelly Bond (ed.), by Troy Hickman and others Fables: 1001 Nights of Snowfall Vertigo Comics /DC Comics Winner [ 16] Frédéric Boilet (ed.)Japan as Viewed by 17 Creators Fanfare/Ponent Mon Nominee [ 16] Sammy Harkham (ed.) Kramers Ergot #6 Buenaventura Press Nominee [ 16] Glenn Head (ed.)Hotwire Comix and Capers Fantagraphics Nominee [ 16] Chris Pitzer (ed.)Project: Romantic AdHouse Books Nominee [ 16] 2008 Gabriel Bá , Becky Cloonan , Fábio Moon , Vasilis Lolos , and Rafael Grampá 5 self-published Winner [ 17] Ivan Brandon (ed.)24Seven , vol. 2 Image Comics Nominee [ 17] Gary Groth and Eric Reynolds (eds.) Mome Fantagraphics Nominee [ 17] Anne Elizabeth Moore and Chris Ware (eds.)The Best American Comics 2007 Houghton Mifflin Nominee [ 17] Jason Rodriguez (ed.) Postcards: True Stories That Never Happened Villard Nominee [ 17] 2009 Rantz Hoseley (ed.)Comic Book Tattoo: Narrative Art Inspired by the Lyrics and Music of Tori Amos Image Comics Winner [ 18] Scott Allie and Sierra Hahn (eds.) MySpace Dark Horse Presents Dark Horse Comics Nominee [ 19] Lynda Barry (ed.)The Best American Comics 2008 Houghton Mifflin Nominee [ 19] Ivan Brunetti (ed.)An Anthology of Graphic Fiction, Cartoons, and True Stories , vol. 2 Yale University Press Nominee [ 19] Sammy Harkham (ed.) Kramers Ergot #7 Buenaventura Press Nominee [ 19] 2010s 2010 Mark Andrew Smith , D. J. Kirkbride , and Joe Keatinge (eds.) Popgun , vol. 3 Image Comics Winner [ 20] Paul Briggs (ed.)What Is Torch Tiger? Torch Tiger Nominee [ 21] Brendan Burford (ed.)Syncopated: An Anthology of Nonfiction Picto-Essays Villard Nominee [ 21] Kazu Kibuishi (ed.) Flight , vol. 6 Villard Nominee [ 21] Andrei Molotiu (ed.)Abstract Comics Fantagraphics Nominee [ 21] Bob Weill (ed.)Bob Dylan Revisited W. W. Norton & Company Nominee [ 21] 2011 Paul Morrissey and David Petersen (eds.) Mouse Guard: Legends of the Guard Archaia Entertainment Winner [ 22] Joy Ang and Nick Thornborrow (eds.)The Anthology Project Lucidity Press Nominee [ 23] Matt Dembicki (ed.) Trickster: Native American Tales Fulcrum Books Nominee [ 23] Nicolas Finet (ed.)Korea as Viewed by 12 Creators Fanfare/Ponent Mon Nominee [ 23] Sonny Liew and Lim Cheng Tju (eds.)Liquid City , vol. 2 Image Comics Nominee [ 23] 2012 Mike Richardson (ed.) Dark Horse Presents Dark Horse Comics Winner [ 22] Michel Choquette (ed.) The Someday Funnies Abrams ComicArts Nominee [ 24] Rob Davis and Woodrow Phoenix (eds.)Nelson Blank Slate Books Nominee [ 24] Chris Duffy (ed.)Nursery Rhyme Comics First Second Books Nominee [ 24] Harvey Pekar and Paul Buhle (eds.)Yiddishkeit: Jewish Vernacular and the New Land Abrams ComicArts Nominee [ 24] 2013 Mike Richardson (ed.) Dark Horse Presents Dark Horse Comics Winner [ 22] Justin Hall (ed.) No Straight Lines: Four Decades of Queer Comics Fantagraphics Nominee [ 25] Jeff Ranjo , Jed Diffenderfer , (eds.)Where Is Dead Zero? Dead Zero Publishing Nominee [ 25] Matt Smith (ed.) 2000 AD Rebellion Developments Nominee [ 25] Alex Spiro and Sam Arthur (eds.)Nobrow #7: Brave New World Nobrow Press Nominee [ 25] 2014 Mike Richardson (ed.) Dark Horse Presents Dark Horse Comics Winner [ 22] [ 26] Sam Arthur and Alex Spiro (eds.)Nobrow #8: Hysteria Nobrow Press Nominee [ 26] Gabe Fowler (ed.)Smoke Signal Desert Island Nominee [ 26] Matthew Levine and Cameron Chittock (eds.), by Ben Acker , Ben Blacker , et al.Thrilling Adventure Hour Archaia Entertainment /Boom! Studios Nominee [ 26] Michael Woods (ed.)Outlaw Territory Image Comics Nominee [ 26] 2015 Josh O'Neill , Andrew Carl , and Chris Stevens (eds.)Little Nemo: Dream Another Dream Locust Moon Winner [ 22] [ 27] Monte Beauchamp (ed.)Masterful Marks: Cartoonists Who Changed the World Simon & Schuster Nominee [ 27] Jonathan Clode and John Stuart Clark (eds.)To End All Wars: The Graphic Anthology of The First World War Soaring Penguin Nominee [ 27] Rachel Deering (ed.)In the Dark: A Horror Anthology Tiny Behemoth Press/IDW Publishing Nominee [ 27] Anne Ishii , Chip Kidd , and Graham Kolbeins (eds.) Massive: Gay Erotic Manga and the Men Who Make It Fantagraphics Nominee [ 27] 2016 Tom Devlin (ed.)Drawn & Quarterly, Twenty-Five Years of Contemporary, Cartooning Comics, and Graphic Novels Drawn & Quarterly Winner [ 22] [ 28] Dan Berry (ed.)24 x 7 Fanfare Nominee [ 28] [ 29] Matt Bors (ed.)Eat More Comics: The Best of the Nib The Nib Nominee [ 28] [ 29] David Petersen (ed.) Mouse Guard : Legends of the Guard , vol. 3 Boom! Studios /Archaia Entertainment Nominee [ 28] [ 29] Shannon Watters (ed.)Peanuts: A Tribute to Charles M. Schulz Boom! Studios /KaBOOM! Nominee [ 28] [ 29] 2017 Sarah Gaydos and Jamie S. Rich (eds.) Love Is Love IDW Publishing /DC Comics Winner [ 22] [ 30] Santiago Garcia (ed.)Spanish Fever: Stories by the New Spanish Cartoonists Fantagraphics Nominee Brandon Graham and Emma Ríos (eds.) Island Magazine Image Comics Nominee Sammy Harkham (ed.) Kramers Ergot #9 Fantagraphics Nominee David Schilter and Sanita Muižniece (eds.)Baltic Comics Anthology š! #26: dADa kuš! Nominee 2018 Taneka Stotts (ed.)Elements: Fire, A Comic Anthology by Creators of Color Beyond Press Winner [ 22] Max B. Perlson , Trina Robbins , et al.A Bunch of Jews (and Other Stuff): A Minyen Yidn Bedside Press Nominee [ 31] [ 32] Sean Phillips (ed.)The Spirit Anthology Lakes International Comic Art Festival Nominee [ 31] [ 32] Eric Reynolds (ed.)Now #1 Fantagraphics Nominee [ 31] [ 32] Jamie Rhodes , et al.A Castle in England Nobrow Press Nominee [ 31] [ 32] 2019 Marco Lopez , Desiree Rodriguez , Hazel Newlevant , Derek Ruiz , and Neil Schwartz (eds.)Puerto Rico Strong Lion Forge Comics Winner [ 33] Shelly Bond (ed.)Femme Magnifique: 50 Magnificent Women Who Changed the World Black Crown/IDW Publishing Nominee [ 34] Alex de Campi (ed.)Twisted Romance Image Comics Nominee [ 34] Will Dennis (ed.), curated by J. H. Williams III and Wendy Wright-Williams Where We Live: A Benefit for the Survivors in Las Vegas Image Comics Nominee [ 34] 2020s 2020 Diane Noomin (ed.)Drawing Power: Women’s Stories of Sexual Violence, Harassment and Survival Abrams ComicArts Winner [ 35] [ 36] [ 37] Matt Bors (ed.)The Nib #2–4 The Nib Nominee [ 35] [ 38] Sammy Harkham (ed.) Kramers Ergot #10 Fantagraphics Nominee [ 35] [ 38] David Rault ABC of Typography SelfMadeHero Nominee [ 35] [ 38] David Schilter , Sanita Muižniece , et al. (eds.)Baltic Comics Anthology š! #34-37 kuš! Nominee [ 35] [ 38] 2021 MK Czerwiec (ed.)Menopause: A Comic Treatment Graphic Medicine/Pennsylvania State University Press Winner [ 39] Shelly Bond (ed.)Hey, Amateur! Go From Novice to Nailing It in 9 Panels IDW Publishing /Black Crown Nominee [ 40] Sammy Harkham (ed.)Los Angeles Times NTWRK Nominee [ 40] Wren McDonald (ed.)Ex Mag , vols. 1-2Peow Studio Nominee [ 40] Sarah Mirk (ed.)Guantanamo Voices: True Accounts from the World’s Most Infamous Prison Abrams ComicArts Nominee [ 40] Eric Reynolds (ed.)Now Fantagraphics Nominee [ 40] 2023 Matt Bors (ed) The Nib Magazine Nib Winner [ 41] Alex Antone and Jon Moisan (eds)Creepshow Image Skybound Nominee Josh Bernstein (ed) The Illustrated Al: The Songs of “Weird Al” Yankovic Z2 Bex Ollerton (ed) Sensory: Life on the Spectrum Andrews McMeel Rantz Hoseley (ed) Tori Amos: Little Earthquakes, The Graphic Album Z2