GNU Bison

GNU Bison

Original author(s)	Robert Corbett
Developer(s)	The GNU Project
Initial release	June 1985;38 years ago (1985-06) [1]
Stable release	3.8.2 [2]   / 25 September 2021
Repository	git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/bison.git
Written in	C and m4
Operating system	Unix-like
Type	Parser generator
License	GPL
Website	www.gnu.org/software/bison/

GNU Bison, commonly known as Bison, is a parser generator that is part of the GNU Project. Bison reads a specification in Bison syntax (described as "machine-readable BNF" ^[3] ), warns about any parsing ambiguities, and generates a parser that reads sequences of tokens and decides whether the sequence conforms to the syntax specified by the grammar.

The generated parsers are portable: they do not require any specific compilers. Bison by default generates LALR(1) parsers but it can also generate canonical LR, IELR(1) and GLR parsers. ^[4]

In POSIX mode, Bison is compatible with Yacc, but also has several extensions over this earlier program, including

• Generation of counterexamples for conflicts
• Location tracking (e.g., file, line, column)
• Rich and internationalizable syntax error messages in the generated parsers
• Customizable syntax error generation,
• Reentrant parsers
• Push parsers, with autocompletion
• Support for named references
• Several types of reports (graphical, XML) on the generated parser
• Support for several programming languages (C, C++, D, or Java)

Flex, an automatic lexical analyser, is often used with Bison, to tokenise input data and provide Bison with tokens. ^[5]

Bison was originally written by Robert Corbett in 1985. ^[1] Later, in 1989, Robert Corbett released another parser generator named Berkeley Yacc. Bison was made Yacc-compatible by Richard Stallman. ^[6]

Bison is free software and is available under the GNU General Public License, with an exception (discussed below) allowing its generated code to be used without triggering the copyleft requirements of the licence.

Features

Counterexample generation

One delicate issue with LR parser generators is the resolution of conflicts (shift/reduce and reduce/reduce conflicts). With many LR parser generators, resolving conflicts requires the analysis of the parser automaton, which demands some expertise from the user.

To aid the user in understanding conflicts more intuitively, Bison can instead automatically generate counterexamples. For ambiguous grammars, Bison often can even produce counterexamples that show the grammar is ambiguous.

For instance, on a grammar suffering from the infamous dangling else problem, Bison reports

doc/if-then-else.y: <span style="color:purple;">warning</span>: shift/reduce conflict on token "else" [-<span style="color:purple;">Wcounterexamples</span>]   Example: <span style="color:orange;">"if" expr "then"</span> <span style="color:blue;">"if" expr "then" stmt</span> <span style="color:red;">•</span> <span style="color:blue;">"else" stmt</span>   Shift derivation     <span style="color:orange;">if_stmt</span>     <span style="color:orange;">↳ "if" expr "then"</span> <span style="color:green;">stmt</span>                         <span style="color:green;">↳</span> <span style="color:blue;">if_stmt</span>                            <span style="color:blue;">↳ "if" expr "then" stmt</span> <span style="color:red;">•</span> <span style="color:blue;">"else" stmt</span>   Example: <span style="color:orange;">"if" expr "then"</span> <span style="color:blue;">"if" expr "then" stmt</span> <span style="color:red;">•</span> <span style="color:orange;">"else" stmt</span>   Reduce derivation     <span style="color:orange;">if_stmt</span>     <span style="color:orange;">↳ "if" expr "then"</span> <span style="color:green;">stmt</span>                        <span style="color:orange;">"else" stmt</span>                         <span style="color:green;">↳</span> <span style="color:blue;">if_stmt</span>                            <span style="color:blue;">↳ "if" expr "then" stmt</span> <span style="color:red;">•</span>

Reentrancy

Reentrancy is a feature which has been added to Bison and does not exist in Yacc.

Normally, Bison generates a parser which is not reentrant. In order to achieve reentrancy the declaration %define api.pure must be used. More details on Bison reentrancy can be found in the Bison manual. ^[7]

Output languages

Bison can generate code for C, C++, D and Java. ^[8]

For using the Bison-generated parser from other languages a language binding tool such as SWIG can be used.

License and distribution of generated code

Because Bison generates source code that in turn gets added to the source code of other software projects, it raises some simple but interesting copyright questions.

A GPL-compatible license is not required

The code generated by Bison includes significant amounts of code from the Bison project itself. The Bison package is distributed under the terms of the GNU General Public License (GPL) but an exception has been added so that the GPL does not apply to output. ^{[9] [10]}

Earlier releases of Bison stipulated that parts of its output were also licensed under the GPL, due to the inclusion of the yyparse() function from the original source code in the output.

Distribution of packages using Bison

Free software projects that use Bison may have a choice of whether to distribute the source code which their project feeds into Bison, or the resulting C code made output by Bison. Both are sufficient for a recipient to be able to compile the project source code. However, distributing only the input carries the minor inconvenience that the recipients must have a compatible copy of Bison installed so that they can generate the necessary C code when compiling the project. And distributing only the C code in output, creates the problem of making it very difficult for the recipients to modify the parser since this code was written neither by a human nor for humans - its purpose is to be fed directly into a C compiler.

These problems can be avoided by distributing both the input files and the generated code. Most people will compile using the generated code, no different from any other software package, but anyone who wants to modify the parser component can modify the input files first and re-generate the generated files before compiling. Projects distributing both usually do not have the generated files in their revision control systems. The files are only generated when making a release.

Some licenses, such as the GPL, require that the source code be in "the preferred form of the work for making modifications to it". GPL'd projects using Bison must thus distribute the files which are the input for Bison. Of course, they can also include the generated files.

Use

Because Bison was written as a replacement for Yacc, and is largely compatible, the code from a lot of projects using Bison could equally be fed into Yacc. This makes it difficult to determine if a project "uses" Bison-specific source code or not. In many cases, the "use" of Bison could be trivially replaced by the equivalent use of Yacc or one of its other derivatives.

Bison has features not found in Yacc, so some projects can be truly said to "use" Bison, since Yacc would not suffice.

The following list is of projects which are known to "use" Bison in the looser sense, that they use free software development tools and distribute code which is intended to be fed into Bison or a Bison-compatible package.

• Bash shell uses a yacc grammar for parsing the command input.
• Bison's own grammar parser is generated by Bison. ^[11]
• CMake uses several Bison grammars. ^[12]
• GCC started out using Bison, but switched to a hand-written recursive-descent parser for C++ in 2004 (version 3.4), ^[13] and for C and Objective-C in 2006 (version 4.1) ^[14]
• The Go programming language (GC) used Bison, but switched to a hand-written scanner and parser in version 1.5. ^[15]
• LilyPond requires Bison to generate its parser. ^[16]
• MySQL ^[17]
• GNU Octave uses a Bison-generated parser. ^[18]
• Perl 5 uses a Bison-generated parser starting in 5.10. ^[19]
• The PHP programming language (Zend Parser).
• PostgreSQL ^[20]
• Ruby MRI, the reference implementation of the Ruby programming language, relies on a Bison grammar. ^[21]
• syslog-ng uses several Bison grammars assembled together. ^[22]

A complete reentrant parser example

The following example shows how to use Bison and flex to write a simple calculator program (only addition and multiplication) and a program for creating an abstract syntax tree. The next two files provide definition and implementation of the syntax tree functions.

/* * Expression.h * Definition of the structure used to build the syntax tree. */#ifndef __EXPRESSION_H__#define __EXPRESSION_H__/** * @brief The operation type */typedefenumtagEOperationType{eVALUE,eMULTIPLY,eADD}EOperationType;/** * @brief The expression structure */typedefstructtagSExpression{EOperationTypetype;/* /< type of operation */intvalue;/* /< valid only when type is eVALUE */structtagSExpression*left;/* /<  left side of the tree */structtagSExpression*right;/* /< right side of the tree */}SExpression;/** * @brief It creates an identifier * @param value The number value * @return The expression or NULL in case of no memory */SExpression*createNumber(intvalue);/** * @brief It creates an operation * @param type The operation type * @param left The left operand * @param right The right operand * @return The expression or NULL in case of no memory */SExpression*createOperation(EOperationTypetype,SExpression*left,SExpression*right);/** * @brief Deletes a expression * @param b The expression */voiddeleteExpression(SExpression*b);#endif /* __EXPRESSION_H__ */

/* * Expression.c * Implementation of functions used to build the syntax tree. */#include"Expression.h"#include<stdlib.h>/** * @brief Allocates space for expression * @return The expression or NULL if not enough memory */staticSExpression*allocateExpression(){SExpression*b=(SExpression*)malloc(sizeof(SExpression));if(b==NULL)returnNULL;b->type=eVALUE;b->value=0;b->left=NULL;b->right=NULL;returnb;}SExpression*createNumber(intvalue){SExpression*b=allocateExpression();if(b==NULL)returnNULL;b->type=eVALUE;b->value=value;returnb;}SExpression*createOperation(EOperationTypetype,SExpression*left,SExpression*right){SExpression*b=allocateExpression();if(b==NULL)returnNULL;b->type=type;b->left=left;b->right=right;returnb;}voiddeleteExpression(SExpression*b){if(b==NULL)return;deleteExpression(b->left);deleteExpression(b->right);free(b);}

The tokens needed by the Bison parser will be generated using flex.

%{/* * Lexer.l file * To generate the lexical analyzer run: "flex Lexer.l" */#include"Expression.h"#include"Parser.h"#include<stdio.h>%}%optionoutfile="Lexer.c"header-file="Lexer.h"%optionwarnnodefault%optionreentrantnoyywrapnever-interactivenounistd%optionbison-bridge%%[\r\n\t]*{continue;/* Skip blanks. */}[0-9]+{sscanf(yytext,"%d",&yylval->value);returnTOKEN_NUMBER;}"*"{returnTOKEN_STAR;}"+"{returnTOKEN_PLUS;}"("{returnTOKEN_LPAREN;}")"{returnTOKEN_RPAREN;}.{continue;/* Ignore unexpected characters. */}%%intyyerror(SExpression**expression,yyscan_tscanner,constchar*msg){fprintf(stderr,"Error: %s\n",msg);return0;}

The names of the tokens are typically neutral: "TOKEN_PLUS" and "TOKEN_STAR", not "TOKEN_ADD" and "TOKEN_MULTIPLY". For instance if we were to support the unary "+" (as in "+1"), it would be wrong to name this "+" "TOKEN_ADD". In a language such as C, "int *ptr" denotes the definition of a pointer, not a product: it would be wrong to name this "*" "TOKEN_MULTIPLY".

Since the tokens are provided by flex we must provide the means to communicate between the parser and the lexer. ^[23] The data type used for communication, YYSTYPE, is set using Bison %union declaration.

Since in this sample we use the reentrant version of both flex and yacc we are forced to provide parameters for the yylex function, when called from yyparse. ^[23] This is done through Bison %lex-param and %parse-param declarations. ^[24]

%{/* * Parser.y file * To generate the parser run: "bison Parser.y" */#include"Expression.h"#include"Parser.h"#include"Lexer.h"// reference the implementation provided in Lexer.lintyyerror(SExpression**expression,yyscan_tscanner,constchar*msg);%}%coderequires{typedefvoid*yyscan_t;}%output"Parser.c"%defines"Parser.h"%defineapi.pure%lex-param{yyscan_tscanner}%parse-param{SExpression**expression}%parse-param{yyscan_tscanner}%union{intvalue;SExpression*expression;}%tokenTOKEN_LPAREN"("%tokenTOKEN_RPAREN")"%tokenTOKEN_PLUS"+"%tokenTOKEN_STAR"*"%token<value>TOKEN_NUMBER"number"%type<expression>expr/* Precedence (increasing) and associativity:   a+b+c is (a+b)+c: left associativity   a+b*c is a+(b*c): the precedence of "*" is higher than that of "+". */%left"+"%left"*"%%input:expr{*expression=$1;};expr:expr[L]"+"expr[R]{$$=createOperation(eADD,$L,$R);}|expr[L]"*"expr[R]{$$=createOperation(eMULTIPLY,$L,$R);}|"("expr[E]")"{$$=$E;}|"number"{$$=createNumber($1);};%%

The code needed to obtain the syntax tree using the parser generated by Bison and the scanner generated by flex is the following.

/* * main.c file */#include"Expression.h"#include"Parser.h"#include"Lexer.h"#include<stdio.h>intyyparse(SExpression**expression,yyscan_tscanner);SExpression*getAST(constchar*expr){SExpression*expression;yyscan_tscanner;YY_BUFFER_STATEstate;if(yylex_init(&scanner)){/* could not initialize */returnNULL;}state=yy_scan_string(expr,scanner);if(yyparse(&expression,scanner)){/* error parsing */returnNULL;}yy_delete_buffer(state,scanner);yylex_destroy(scanner);returnexpression;}intevaluate(SExpression*e){switch(e->type){caseeVALUE:returne->value;caseeMULTIPLY:returnevaluate(e->left)*evaluate(e->right);caseeADD:returnevaluate(e->left)+evaluate(e->right);default:/* should not be here */return0;}}intmain(void){chartest[]=" 4 + 2*10 + 3*( 5 + 1 )";SExpression*e=getAST(test);intresult=evaluate(e);printf("Result of '%s' is %d\n",test,result);deleteExpression(e);return0;}

A simple makefile to build the project is the following.

# MakefileFILES=Lexer.cParser.cExpression.cmain.c CC=g++ CFLAGS=-g-ansi  test:$(FILES)$(CC)$(CFLAGS)$(FILES)-otestLexer.c:Lexer.lflexLexer.l  Parser.c:Parser.yLexer.cbisonParser.y  clean:rm-f*.o*~Lexer.cLexer.hParser.cParser.htest

See also

• Free and open-source software portal

• Berkeley Yacc (byacc) – another free software Yacc replacement sharing the same author as GNU Bison
• ANTLR ANother Tool for Language Recognition, another open-source parser generator

References

1. Corbett, Robert Paul (June 1985). Static Semantics and Compiler Error Recovery (Ph.D.). University of California, Berkeley. DTIC ADA611756.
2. Akim Demaille (25 September 2021). "Bison 3.8.2".
3. "Language and Grammar (Bison 3.8.1)". www.gnu.org. Retrieved 2021-12-26.
4. Bison Manual: Introduction.
5. Levine, John (August 2009). flex & bison. O'Reilly Media. ISBN   978-0-596-15597-1.
6. "AUTHORS". bison.git. GNU Savannah . Retrieved 2017-08-26.
7. Bison Manual: A Pure (Reentrant) Parser
8. Bison Manual: Bison Declaration Summary
9. Bison Manual: Conditions for Using Bison
10. A source code file, parse-gram.c, which includes the exception
11. "parse-gram.y". bison.git. GNU Savannah . Retrieved 2020-07-29.
12. "LexerParser in CMake". github.com.
13. GCC 3.4 Release Series Changes, New Features, and Fixes
14. GCC 4.1 Release Series Changes, New Features, and Fixes
15. Golang grammar definition
16. "Parser.yy - GNU LilyPond Git Repository". git.savannah.gnu.org.
17. "4. Parsing SQL - flex & bison [Book]".
18. "GNU Octave: Libinterp/Parse-tree/Oct-parse.cc Source File".
19. "What is new for perl 5.10.0?". perl.org.
20. "The Parser Stage". postgresql.org. 30 September 2021.
21. "Ruby MRI Parser". github.com.
22. "syslog-ng's XML Parser". github.com. 14 October 2021.
23. Flex Manual: C Scanners with Bison Parsers Archived 2010-12-17 at the Wayback Machine
24. Bison Manual: Calling Conventions for Pure Parsers

Further reading

• Levine, John (August 2009). flex & bison. O'Reilly Media. ISBN   978-0-596-15597-1.

External links

• Website in the GNU Project
  • Manual
• Bison project at GNU Savannah
• Entry in the Free Software Directory
• Internals of C parsers generated by GNU Bison
• How to download and install Bison (GNU Parser Generator) on Linux
• Win32 binaries by GnuWin32 (version 2.4.1)