George V. Mann | |
---|---|
Born | September 15, 1917 |
Died | July 17, 2013 95) | (aged
Nationality | American |
Occupation(s) | Medical researcher, physician, academic, and author |
Academic background | |
Education | D.Sc., Biochemistry M.D. |
Alma mater | Cornell College Johns Hopkins University |
Academic work | |
Institutions | Harvard University,Vanderbilt University |
George V. Mann was an American medical researcher,physician,academic,and author known for his research on cholesterol's impact on cardiovascular health. He served as an assistant professor at Harvard University early in his career and as a professor and researcher of medicine and biochemistry at Vanderbilt University until his retirement. [1]
Mann's authored works encompass over 200 articles published in medical journals,including the New England Journal of Medicine and the American Journal of Epidemiology ,along with books for the general public that include The Care and Feeding of Athletes and Coronary Heart Disease:The Dietary Sense and Nonsense. [2]
Mann was born in 1917 in Fort Dodge,a town in north-central Iowa,and grew up on various farms in the region where his father worked as a sharecropper. He graduated in 1939 with a BS degree in chemistry from Cornell College in Mount Vernon,Iowa. Subsequently,he earned a Doctor of Science degree in biochemistry and an MD from Johns Hopkins School of Medicine in 1945. [1]
Mann started his medical career at the Osler Service of Johns Hopkins University between 1945 to 1946. He then completed his residency at Peter Bent Brigham Hospital in Boston from 1946 to 1947 and spent a year working with the Joslin Diabetes Service at New England Deaconess Hospital also in Boston. In 1949,he was appointed Assistant Professor of Nutrition at Harvard University and served as an Investigator for the American Heart Association. [3] In 1955,he was appointed Associate Director of the Framingham Heart Study,an ongoing cardiovascular study on 5209 residents of the town of Framingham,Massachusetts that began in 1948,was led for over 40 years by Thomas Dawber and continues as of 2025. In 1958,he became Professor of Medicine and Biochemistry at Vanderbilt University [4] where he held a Career Investigator appointment with the National Institutes of Health until his retirement from Vanderbilt in 1987. [5]
In response to the perceived epidemic of coronary heart disease,in 1957,Ancel Keys,a physiology professor at the University of Minnesota,proposed the "lipid hypothesis",also known as the "diet-heart hypothesis," suggesting a causal link between saturated fat intake and coronary heart disease risk. Keys' formulated the lipid hypothesis during his post-WWII travels in Italy,Sardinia,and Spain,where he observed that less wealthy individuals with lower saturated fat diets from meat and dairy experienced fewer heart attacks. For the next three decades,Mann became a leading critic of the lipid hypothesis who clashed with both Keys and Key's mentee and successor in his research group at the University of Minnesota,Henry Blackburn–as Mann and others in the lab-based biomedical research community could not find any direct evidence from their lab-based studies for the link between diet and heart disease. [6]
In 1957,Ancel Keys launched the Seven Countries Study,tracking 12,770 men across 16 locations in the US,Europe,and Japan to test the lipid hypothesis. [7] Critics argued that the selected countries reflected his preferred diets and excluded nations like France and Germany,where high milk and meat consumption coincided with low coronary heart disease rates. Within the same year,in response,Yerushalmy and Hilleboe analyzed data from 22 countries worldwide and found no significant link between dietary fat and coronary heart disease. [8]
The first in a series of disagreements over the origin of cardiovascular disease that would span both of the lengthy careers of Keys and Mann occurred from 1955 until 1956,when Mann—then an assistant professor of nutrition at the Harvard School of Public Health—published an article entitled "Lack of Effect of a High Fat Intake on Serum Lipid Levels." In the article,based on feeding two human subjects a high-saturated-fat diet and measuring their cholesterol levels,Mann found no link between increased fat intake and elevated blood cholesterol. [9] In 1956,Keys responded with a critique of Mann's small sample size,his misuse of statistics,and his interpretation,which Keys re-cast as more supportive of his lipid hypothesis. He concluded that Mann's paper was "an interesting case of statistical fallacy applied to inadequate evidence." [10]
In 1957,public support for the lipid hypothesis increased as Keys informed the personal physician of then-President Eisenhower that saturated fat in the president's diet might have contributed to his heart attacks. However,the growing number of epidemiological studies,including the Seven Countries study,remained observational and failed to establish a cause-and-effect relationship between high saturated fat intake and increased cardiovascular disease. [7]
Mann,in his role as Associate Director of the Framingham Heart Program from 1955 until 1959,analyzed the links between diets and cardiovascular disease,and by 1960 had concluded that saturated fat was not an overt cause of heart disease based on their survey group,although these results remained obscure until years after the study was completed. Mann concluded that "epidemiology is apt not to be a decisive method for resolution of these problems. At best,the method may supply a few clues and enough encouragement to gifted people who will find the answer in the laboratory." [11] Decades later in 1992,William P. Castelli who led the Framingham project from 1979 to 1995 observed that the more saturated fat the survey group ate,the lower their serum cholesterol became. [12] [13]
Despite these criticisms of his lipid hypothesis,Keys was undeterred and responded by writing several books for the public that espoused low-fat diets. In recognition of these popular books,Time magazine featured Keys,referred to as "Mr. Cholesterol," as the cover subject for their January 13,1961,issue. By 1961,the American Heart Association concluded that it accepted the lipid hypothesis and suggested that the public replace saturated fats with polyunsaturated vegetable oils as protection against heart disease. [14]
During the late 1950s,Mann expanded his research from lab-based cholesterol analyses in animals to field-based,epidemiological studies involving a statistically significant number of human subjects from Indigenous groups with high-saturated fat diets. These groups included populations in the US and Central America, [15] the Pygmies of central Africa,the Eskimos of northern Alaska,and the Maasai of east Africa. Despite consuming high-cholesterol diets that included whale blubber,beef,wild game,cow's blood,and very high-fat cow's milk,all these diverse and widely-separated groups exhibited low blood cholesterol levels. Mann interpreted this as evidence against the lipid-heart hypothesis,instead proposing the exercise-heart hypothesis,which suggested that their high physical fitness protected all of these groups from heart disease. [16] [17] [18]
Keys countered Mann's conclusions on the low cholesterol levels of the Masai with three alternative explanations:previous studies had identified other nomadic Kenyan tribes who subsisted on large amounts of very high-fat camel's milk and,unlike the Masai,exhibited high cholesterol levels;the low rate of heart disease in the Masai reflected their state of being "chronically underfed and frequently half-starved";and Mann's proposal that sour milk in the Masai's diet acted to keep blood cholesterol levels low was,in fact,an affirmation of Keys' lipid hypothesis linking diet and cholesterol levels. [19]
Following the conclusion of his work with the Masai in the late 1960s,Mann's research focused on developing the exercise-heart hypothesis as a major control on cholesterol levels and coronary heart disease. Using groups of volunteer human subjects,including local firemen in the Nashville area,he developed programs for exercise over weeks to months that monitored the effects of exercise on their cholesterol levels and cardiovascular health. He showed that as little as thirty minutes of vigorous exercise per week could be beneficial,leading to further trials, [20] and by 1977,he concluded that exercise was more essential than diet in heart disease prevention. [6] Based on these studies,he published an exercise guide in 1970 entitled Over 30:An Exercise Program for Adults,which provided calisthenics-based routines designed to promote fitness,flexibility,and overall health maintenance. Laurence M. Hursh commented,"It is by far the best guide I have ever seen. If you are over 30,have a medical checkup and get Dr. Mann's book". [21] During this period,he was an invited technical observer to the 1976 summer Olympics in Montreal,Canada,and in 1980 published a book:The Care and Feeding of Athletes. [22]
By 1977,Mann established his role as the chief critic of the lipid hypothesis through two events:first,the publication of his review article in the New England Journal of Medicine,titled "Diet-Heart:End of an Era," [6] which summarized three decades of research and controversy over the hypothesis;and second,his profile in People Magazine,titled "Dr. George Mann Says Low Cholesterol Diets are Useless,the ‘Heart Mafia’Disagrees." [23] In his review article,he recounted observations from decades of lab-based and epidemiological studies. Based on this review of the data,he concluded that the diet-heart or lipid hypothesis remained an unproven hypothesis that was not supported by scientific observations. The journal published a full-length rebuttal by the panel of the American Health Association advisory group that was charged with developing dietary guidelines that espoused the lipid hypothesis. [24]
Olszewski in 2014 highlighted the discussions surrounding the lipid hypothesis,which explored the role of epidemiology in clinical medicine. [24] Advocates of epidemiology embraced it as a powerful tool for answering complex questions,while critics like Mann viewed epidemiology as an imperfect science that could not definitively explain human biology. The debate became irrelevant as US policymakers had already adopted the lipid hypothesis starting in the early 1960s. During his retirement years,Mann persisted in his criticism of the lipid hypothesis with a book for the public that summarized all of his observations on diet and health entitled:Coronary Heart Disease:The Dietary Sense and Nonsense. Julian Tudor Hart commended the book’s critique of the diet-heart hypothesis,calling it an essential resource on coronary health. [25]
In the years between Mann’s retirement in 1987 and death in 2013,criticism of the lipid hypothesis passed to journalists starting with Gary Taubes who published an article in the journal Science [26] and an article in the New York Times [27] that compiled the arguments by Mann and others on why saturated fats were not detrimental to cardiac health. Journalist and nutritionist Nina Teicholz continued this discussion in her 2014 book that questioned the emphasis on avoiding saturated fat and referred to the work of Mann and other researchers on this topic. [28] Detailed accounts of the career of Mann,his impact of his diet research,and his multi-decadal debates with Keys and other advocates of the lipid hypothesis were published in academic journals by Olszewski, [24] Elliot,and Teicholz. [12]
Mann was married to Jean Ebersbach Mann from 1946 until her death in 1994. She was a nursing graduate from Johns Hopkins School of Nursing in 1943 and became the Director of Nursing at Nashville General Hospital during the 1970s and early 1980's. He is survived by five children and four grandchildren. [1]
In nutrition,biology,and chemistry,fat usually means any ester of fatty acids,or a mixture of such compounds,most commonly those that occur in living beings or in food.
High-density lipoprotein(HDL) is one of the five major groups of lipoproteins. Lipoproteins are complex particles composed of multiple proteins which transport all fat molecules (lipids) around the body within the water outside cells. They are typically composed of 80–100 proteins per particle. HDL particles enlarge while circulating in the blood,aggregating more fat molecules and transporting up to hundreds of fat molecules per particle.
Atherosclerosis is a pattern of the disease arteriosclerosis,characterized by development of abnormalities called lesions in walls of arteries. This is a chronic inflammatory disease involving many different cell types and driven by elevated levels of cholesterol in the blood. These lesions may lead to narrowing of the arterial walls due to buildup of atheromatous plaques. At the onset there are usually no symptoms,but if they develop,symptoms generally begin around middle age. In severe cases,it can result in coronary artery disease,stroke,peripheral artery disease,or kidney disorders,depending on which body part(s) the affected arteries are located in the body.
Ancel Benjamin Keys was an American physiologist who studied the influence of diet on health. In particular,he hypothesized that replacing dietary saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat reduced cardiovascular diseases. Modern dietary recommendations by health organizations,systematic reviews,and national health agencies corroborate this.
A saturated fat is a type of fat in which the fatty acid chains have all single bonds between the carbon atoms. A fat known as a glyceride is made of two kinds of smaller molecules:a short glycerol backbone and fatty acids that each contain a long linear or branched chain of carbon (C) atoms. Along the chain,some carbon atoms are linked by single bonds (-C-C-) and others are linked by double bonds (-C=C-). A double bond along the carbon chain can react with a pair of hydrogen atoms to change into a single -C-C- bond,with each H atom now bonded to one of the two C atoms. Glyceride fats without any carbon chain double bonds are called saturated because they are "saturated with" hydrogen atoms,having no double bonds available to react with more hydrogen.
The French paradox is an apparently paradoxical epidemiological observation that French people have a relatively low incidence of coronary heart disease (CHD),while having a diet relatively rich in saturated fats,in apparent contradiction to the widely held belief that the high consumption of such fats is a risk factor for CHD. The paradox is that if the thesis linking saturated fats to CHD is valid,the French ought to have a higher rate of CHD than comparable countries where the per capita consumption of such fats is lower.
The Mediterranean diet is a concept first invented in 1975 by the American biologist Ancel Keys and chemist Margaret Keys. The diet took inspiration from the eating habits and traditional food typical of Crete,much of the rest of Greece,and southern Italy,and formulated in the early 1960s. It is distinct from Mediterranean cuisine,which covers the actual cuisines of the Mediterranean countries,and from the Atlantic diet of northwestern Spain and Portugal. While inspired by a specific time and place,the "Mediterranean diet" was later refined based on the results of multiple scientific studies.
Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is any disease involving the heart or blood vessels. CVDs constitute a class of diseases that includes:coronary artery diseases,heart failure,hypertensive heart disease,rheumatic heart disease,cardiomyopathy,arrhythmia,congenital heart disease,valvular heart disease,carditis,aortic aneurysms,peripheral artery disease,thromboembolic disease,and venous thrombosis.
Hypercholesterolemia,also called high cholesterol,is the presence of high levels of cholesterol in the blood. It is a form of hyperlipidemia,hyperlipoproteinemia,and dyslipidemia.
Stanol esters is a heterogeneous group of chemical compounds known to reduce the level of low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol in blood when ingested,though to a much lesser degree than prescription drugs such as statins. The starting material is phytosterols from plants. These are first hydrogenated to give a plant stanol which is then esterified with a mixture of fatty acids also derived from plants. Plant stanol esters are found naturally occurring in small quantities in fruits,vegetables,nuts,seeds,cereals,legumes,and vegetable oils.
Phytosterols are phytosteroids,similar to cholesterol,that serve as structural components of biological membranes of plants. They encompass plant sterols and stanols. More than 250 sterols and related compounds have been identified. Free phytosterols extracted from oils are insoluble in water,relatively insoluble in oil,and soluble in alcohols.
The lipid hypothesis is a medical theory postulating a link between blood cholesterol levels and the occurrence of cardiovascular disease. A summary from 1976 described it as:"measures used to lower the plasma lipids in patients with hyperlipidemia will lead to reductions in new events of coronary heart disease". It states,more concisely,that "decreasing blood cholesterol [...] significantly reduces coronary heart disease".
The Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension or the DASH diet is a diet to control hypertension promoted by the U.S.-based National Heart,Lung,and Blood Institute,part of the National Institutes of Health (NIH),an agency of the United States Department of Health and Human Services. The DASH diet is rich in fruits,vegetables,whole grains,and low-fat dairy foods. It includes meat,fish,poultry,nuts,and beans,and is limited in sugar-sweetened foods and beverages,red meat,and added fats. In addition to its effect on blood pressure,it is designed to be a well-balanced approach to eating for the general public. DASH is recommended by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) as a healthy eating plan. The DASH diet is one of three healthy diets recommended in the 2015–20 U.S. Dietary Guidelines,which also include the Mediterranean diet and a vegetarian diet. The American Heart Association (AHA) considers the DASH diet "specific and well-documented across age,sex and ethnically diverse groups."
Mary Gertrude Enig was a nutritionist and researcher known for her unconventional positions on the role saturated fats play in diet and health. She disputed the medical consensus that diets high in saturated fats contribute to development of heart disease,while she advocated for a low-carbohydrate high-fat diet,rich in animal fats and coconut oil.
The chronic endothelial injury hypothesis is one of two major mechanisms postulated to explain the underlying cause of atherosclerosis and coronary heart disease (CHD),the other being the lipid hypothesis. Although an ongoing debate involving connection between dietary lipids and CHD sometimes portrays the two hypotheses as being opposed,they are in no way mutually exclusive. Moreover,since the discovery of the role of LDL cholesterol (LDL-C) in the pathogenesis of atherosclerosis,the two hypotheses have become tightly linked by a number of molecular and cellular processes.
David Mark Hegsted was an American nutritionist who studied the connections between food consumption and heart disease. His work included studies that showed that consumption of saturated fats led to increases in cholesterol,leading to the development of dietary guidelines intended to help Americans achieve better health through improved food choices.
Ronald M. Krauss is an American professor of pediatrics,medical researcher and low-carbohydrate diet advocate. He studies genetic,dietary,and hormonal effects on plasma lipoproteins and coronary disease risk.
The Seven Countries Study is an epidemiological longitudinal study directed by Ancel Keys at what is today the University of Minnesota Laboratory of Physiological Hygiene &Exercise Science (LPHES). Begun in 1956 with a yearly grant of US$200,000 from the U.S. Public Health Service,the study was first published in 1978 and then followed up on its subjects every five years thereafter.
Trans fat,also called trans-unsaturated fatty acids,or trans fatty acids,is a type of unsaturated fat that occurs in foods. Small amounts of trans fats occur naturally,but large amounts are found in some processed foods. Since consumption of trans fats is unhealthy,artificial trans fats are highly regulated or banned in many nations. However,they are still widely consumed in developing nations,resulting in hundreds of thousands of deaths each year. The World Health Organization (WHO) had set a goal to make the world free from industrially produced trans fat by the end of 2023. The goal was not met,and the WHO announced another goal "for accelerated action till 2025 to complete this effort" along with associated support on 1 February 2024.
William Peter Castelli is an American physician,epidemiologist and former director of the Framingham Heart Study.